Electrooptical studies on proton-binding and -release of bacteriorhodopsin

Electric field induced pH changes of purple membrane suspensions were investigated in the pH range from 4.1 to 7.6 by measuring the absorbance change of pH indicators. In connection with the photocycle and proton pump ability, three different states of bacteriorhodopsin were used: (1) the native purple bacteriorhodopsin (magnesium and calcium ions are bound, the M intermediate exists in the photocycle and protons are pumped), (2) the cation-depleted blue bacteriorhodopsin (no M intermediate), and (3) the regenerated purple bacteriorhodopsin which is produced either by raising the pH or by adding magnesium ions (the M intermediate exists). In the native purple bacteriorhodopsin there are, at least, two types of proton binding sites: one releases protons and the other takes up protons in the presence of the electric field. On the other hand, blue bacteriorhodopsin and the regenerated purple bacteriorhodopsin (pH increase) show neither proton release nor proton uptake. When magnesium ions are added to the suspensions; the field-induced pH change is observed again. Thus, the stability of proton binding depends strongly on the state of bacteriorhodopsin and differences in proton binding are likely to be related to differences in proton pump activity. Furthermore, it is suggested that the appearance of the M intermediate and proton pumping are not necessarily related.     

Kinetics and stoichiometry of light-induced proton release and uptake from purple membrane fragments, Halobacterium halobium cell envelopes, and phospholipid vesicles containing oriented purple membrane

We have used flash spectroscopy and pH indicator dyes to measure the kinetics and stoichiometry of light-induced proton release and uptake by purple membrane in aqueous suspension, in cell envelope vesicles and in lipid vesicles. The preferential orientation of bacteriorhodopsin in opposite directions in the envelope and lipid vesicles allows us to show that uptake of protons occurs on the cytoplasmic side of the purple membrane and release on the exterior side.

In suspensions of isolated purple membrane, approximately one proton per cycling bacteriorhodopsin molecule appears transiently in the aqueous phase with a half-rise time of 0.8 ms and a half-decay time of 5.4 ms at 21 °C.

In cell envelope preparations which consist of vesicles with a preferential orientation of purple membrane, as in whole cells, and which pump protons out, the acidification of the medium has a half-rise time of less than 1.0 ms, which partially relaxes in approx. 10 ms and fully relaxes after many seconds.

Phospholipid vesicles, which contain bacteriorhodopsin preferentially oriented in the opposite direction and pump protons in, show an alkalinization of the medium with a time constant of approximately 10 ms, preceded by a much smaller and faster acidification. The alkalinization relaxes over many seconds.

The initial fast acidification in the lipid vesicles and the fast relaxation in the envelope vesicles are accounted for by the misoriented fractions of bacteriorhodopsin. The time constants of the main effects, acidification in the envelopes and alkalinization in the lipid vesicles correlate with the time constants for the release and uptake of protons in the isolated purple membrane, and therefore show that these must occur on the outer and inner surface respectively. The slow relaxation processes in the time range of several seconds must be attributed to the passive back diffusion of protons through the vesicle membrane.     

Effect of iodination of the purple membrane on the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin in the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium is coupled to a photocycle that results in the release and uptake of protons. The role of tyrosyl residues in the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin has been investigated by the technique of chemical modifications of these residues by iodination and nitration. The studies indicate that modification of a tyrosyl residue accelerates M₄₁₂ formation, whereas modification of another type of tyrosine residue(s) accessible from the cytoplasmic surface of the purple membrane inhibits M₄₁₂ decay. The results support the hypothesis that a reversible deprotonation of tyrosine residues prior to and after M₄₁₂ formation in the photocycle are steps in the light-driven pathway of H⁺ translocation by bacteriorhodopsin.     

Influence of membrane lipids on the photochemistry of bacteriorhodopsin in the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium

Purple membrane fragments from Halobacterium halobium were reconstituted with the native lipids replaced by dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine and by egg lecithin. In parallel studies the temperature dependence of bacteriorhodopsin phototransient lifetime and absorption dichroism and of in situ lipid microviscosity were determined; the former two by, respectively, conventional and polarization flash photometry, and the latter by observation of emission depolarization of an embedded fluorescent dye, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene. Discontinuities in lipid microviscosity profiles in native and egg lecithin purple membrane were reflected in both the photochemical cycle frequency and bacteriorhodopsin chromophore rotational mobility. The influence exerted by membrane-lipid viscosity appears to be a secondary effect, and points to the bacteriorhodopsin chromophoric group being situated in the protein interior.     

Glycocardiolipin modulates the surface interaction of the proton pumped by bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane preparations

Glycocardiolipin is an archaeal analogue of mitochondrial cardiolipin, having an extraordinary affinity for bacteriorhodopsin, the photoactivated proton pump in the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. Here purple membranes have been isolated by osmotic shock from either cells or envelopes of Hbt. salinarum. We show that purple membranes isolated from envelopes have a lower content of glycocardiolipin than standard purple membranes isolated from cells. The properties of bacteriorhodopsin in the two different purple membrane preparations are compared; although some differences in the absorption spectrum and the kinetic of the dark adaptation process are present, the reduction of native membrane glycocardiolipin content does not significantly affect the photocycle (M-intermediate rise and decay) as well as proton pumping of bacteriorhodopsin. However, interaction of the pumped proton with the membrane surface and its equilibration with the aqueous bulk phase are altered.     

The effect of antibiotics on the photocycle and protoncycle of purple membrane suspensions

The interrelation was studied between the phototransient absorbing maximally at 412 nm (M₄₁₂) and light-induced proton release under steady-state conditions in aqueous suspensions of ‘purple membrane’ derived from Halobacterium halobium. The decay of M₄₁₂ was slowed down by the simultaneous application of the ionophoric antibiotics valinomycin and beauvericin. The former had only slight activity alone and the latter was effective only in conjunction with valinomycin. The steady-state concentration of M₄₁₂ which was formed on illumination was a direct function of the concentration of valinomycin. Maximum stabilization of M₄₁₂ was obtained when the valinomycin was approximately equimolar with the bacteriorhodopsin. Addition of salts to the medium increased the number of protons released per molecule of M₄₁₂ without affecting the level of M₄₁₂ which was produced by continuous illumination. The effectiveness of the salts in this respect depended on the nature of the cation. Ca²⁺ and their antagonists La³⁺ and ruthenium red were found to have especially high affinity for the system. The extent of light-induced acidification could not be enhanced by increasing the pH of the medium from 6.5 to 7.8. The possible mechanism of action of the ionophores and of the cations on the photocycle and on the proton cycle is discussed.     

The preparation of lipid-depleted bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin, the protein of the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium, was freed to the extent of 90–95% from the natural membrane lipids without loss of function. The residual lipid corresponded to less than 1 mol/mol of bacteriorhodopsin. Delipidation was achieved by treatment of the purple membrane with a mixture of the detergent dimethyldodecylamine oxide and sodium chloride. The detergent was removed by dialysis or by sucrose density gradient centrifugation. Analysis of the lipids removed and those still bound to bacteriorhodopsin was facilitated by the use of purple membrane preparations labelled with ³⁵S, ³²P, or ¹⁴C. The composition of the residual lipids associated with bacteriorhodopsin was similar to that of the total lipid in the purple membrane.     

Proteolysis and flash photolysis of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane fragments

Pronase treatment of aqueous suspensions of purple membrane fragments from H. halobium leads to the cleavage of bacteriorhodopsin. The protein fragments remaining in the membrane after treatment with relatively small concentrations of enzyme (2% w/w) in normal daylight range in molecular weight from 20,000-21,000 daltons, indicating that cleavage occurs mainly near the extremities of the protein chain. At higher enzyme concentrations the relative amounts of protein fragments having smaller molecular weight increase. Generally, the relative loss of retinal chromophore is larger than that of protein and thus the retinal binding site seems to be located near one of the chain ends that is cleaved off by enzyme.Irradiation with white light during the time of proteolysis (at both low and high enzyme concentrations) results in extensive cleavage, so that under certain conditions no high molecular weight components can be detected in SDS-polyacrylamide gels. It, therefore, appears that parts of the bacteriorhodopsin chain become more exposed to enzyme digestion when the purple membrane is illuminated.Enzyme treated aqueous purple membrane fragment suspensions still show photocycle activity. The main consequence of proteolysis is a pronounced appearance of biphasicity in the decay of M₄₁₂ and the regeneration of bR₅₇₀. Simultaneously the yield of O₆₆₀ is reduced. As with untreated purple membrane, the correlation between the rates of decay of M₄₁₂ and regeneration of bR₅₇₀ is greatest when the yield of O₆₆₀ is lowest.     

Reaction of the purple membrane with a carbodimide

Purple membrane was reacted with 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide at pH 4.5 and 8.0. At pH 4.5, the reaction yields cross-linked bacteriorhodopsin. The cross-linking is inhibited by pretreatment of the membrane with papain, or by the presence of carbohydrazide or glycine ethyl ester in the reaction mixture. The product of the pH 8.0 reaction is not cross-linked, but it displays altered properties. Two measures of photochemical activity (light-induced change in proton binding (Δh?) and decay of photointermediate M) show changes indicative of slowed proton uptake. The Δh? is increased by ethyl dimethylaminopropylcarbodiimide. This increase is unaffected by pretreatment of the membrane with papain, and it is not reversed by NH₂OH. However, the reaction is inhibited by millimolar concentrations of CaCl₂. The altered Δh? is not apparent in detergent-solubilized membranes. Ethyl dimethylaminopropyl-carbodiimide does not appear to cause a large alteration in the membrane surface charge, as measured by Ca²⁺ binding.We conclude that (1) at acid pH, ethyl dimethylaminopropylcarbodiimide can be used for cross-linking or for attachment of specific probes to the C-terminal region of bacteriorhodopsin, and hence to the cytoplasmic side of the purple membrane, and (2) at alkaline pH, ethyl dimethylaminopropylcarbodiimide reacts at a different type of site and appears to inhibit the proton pump.     

Glycocardiolipin modulates the surface interaction of the proton pumped by bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane preparations

Glycocardiolipin is an archaeal analogue of mitochondrial cardiolipin, having an extraordinary affinity for bacteriorhodopsin, the photoactivated proton pump in the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. Here purple membranes have been isolated by osmotic shock from either cells or envelopes of Hbt. salinarum. We show that purple membranes isolated from envelopes have a lower content of glycocardiolipin than standard purple membranes isolated from cells. The properties of bacteriorhodopsin in the two different purple membrane preparations are compared; although some differences in the absorption spectrum and the kinetic of the dark adaptation process are present, the reduction of native membrane glycocardiolipin content does not significantly affect the photocycle (M-intermediate rise and decay) as well as proton pumping of bacteriorhodopsin. However, interaction of the pumped proton with the membrane surface and its equilibration with the aqueous bulk phase are altered.     

Light-induced currents from oriented purple membrane: II. Proton and cation contributions to the photocurrent

The sign of B2, the micro-second component of the photocurrent from oriented purple membrane, is that of positive charge moving away from the purple membrane in the direction of proton release. B2 could be due to internal dipole or proton movement, proton release, or metal cation release. We found that the waveform of B2 is virtually insensitive to changes in the salt concentration as long as it is >40 mM KCl, >5 mM CaCl₂, or >0.5 mM LaCl₃. However, below these limits, B2's apparent rate of decay increases as the salt concentration decreases without any change in the initial amplitude. This salt dependence suggests that B2 is due to a positive charge, either a metal cation or a proton, moving from the membrane into the solution. That the positive charge is not a metal cation is suggested by the waveform of B2 remaining unchanged upon replacing the cations both in solution and in the binding sites of the purple membrane. Direct evidence that the positive charge movement is due to protons was obtained by examining the correlation of B2 with the proton dependent processes of bacteriorhodopsin in buffers and dyes. Based on these observations, we suggest that most, if not all, of the intrinsic B2 component of the photocurrent at moderate salt concentration is due to proton release.

The photocurrents from purple membranes whose surface potential has been reduced by delipidation or chemical modification of carboxyl groups with methyl esters were found to be only modestly changed. This suggests that the salt effect is not through its modulation of the surface potential. Rather, we propose that in low salt B2 represents the sum of a proton release from the surface of the purple membrane and a second current component, due to cations moving back towards the membrane, which is only important in low salt. The cation counter current is induced by proton release which creates a transient uncompensated negative charge on the membrane.

     

pH-dependence of interaction between melittin and bacteriorhodopsin

Melittin differentially slowed down the fast (M412f) and the slow (M412s) decay components of the photocyde intermediate M of trimeric bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane while it accelerated the M412s of Triton X-100-solubilized bacteriorhodopsin monomers. Raising the bulk pH could enhance the effect of melittin on the M412s of bacteriorhodopsin in these two states. From pH 5.5 to 8.8, melittin slightly influenced the yield of intermediate M in purple membrane, whereas the yield of M412s decreased and subsequently reversed with the addition of melittin. Moreover, the monomeric bacteriorhodopsin bleached more readily in the presence of melittin and the higher pH made the bleaching effect of melittin more intensive as well. These results re-certify our former suggestions that there was electrostatic interaction between melittin and bacteriorhodopsin, and indicate that the biphasic M decay may not result from the well-known linear kinetic scheme (M→N →BR). At last the mechanisms underlying the interact     

Interaction between gramicidin-A and bacteriorhodopsin in reconstituted purple membrane

The addition of gramicidin-A to reconstituted purple membrane, significantly inhibits light-induced proton movement. Kinetic analyses indicate that the treatment decreases the initial proton pumping rate (R_o), alters the interdependence (m) between the pumping process and its associated H⁺ leak path (k_L-k_D), but has no detectable effect on the proton permeability associated with phospholipid bilayers in the dark (k_D). These results suggest that gramicidin-A, under the experimental conditions, interacts directly with bacteriorhodopsin in the membrane. This suggestion is supported by the findings that both the resonance Raman and circular dichroism spectra of bacteriorhodopsin are affected by the antibiotic.     

Direction of proton translocation in proteoliposomes formed from purple membrane and acidic lipids depends on the pH during reconstitution

The reconstitution of proton pumping activity in proteoliposomes formed by brief sonication of purple membrane and lipid dispersions was studied as a function of pH. Proteoliposomes reconstituted using cardiolipin showed light-dependent proton extrusion when formed at a pH below 2.75 and proton uptake when formed above pH 2.75. Several other acidic lipids including halobacterial lipids behaved similarly. The experiments suggest that the degree of dissociation of the lipid phosphate groups determines the preferential orientation of bacteriorhodopsin in reconstituted proteoliposomes.     

Mechanism of generation and regulation of photopotential by bacteriorhodopsin in bimolecular lipid membrane. The quenching effect of blue light

Photoelectric properties of bacteriorhodopsin incorporated into a bimolecular lipid membrane were investigated with special regard to the mechanism of photoelectric field generation. It was shown that besides its proton pump and electric generator functions bacteriorhodopsin works as a possible molecular regulator of the light-induced membrane potential. When a bimolecular lipid membrane containing bacteriorhodopsin is continuously illuminated in its main visible absorption band, and afterwards by superimposed blue light matching the absorption band of the long-living photobleached bacteriorhodopsin (M₄₁₂) as well, the latter either enhances or decreases the steady-state photoresponse, depending upon the intensity of the green light. Thus, the additional blue-light illumination tends to cause the resultant photoelectric membrane potential to become stabilized. Two alternative schemes are tentatively proposed for the photochemical cycle of bacteriorhodopsin whereby blue light can control photovoltage generation. A kinetic model of the proton pump and the regulation of the photoelectric membrane potential is presented. This model fits all the experimental findings, even quantitatively. From the model some kinetic and physical parameters of this light-driven pump could be determined.     

Crystal structures of acid blue and alkaline purple forms of bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin, a light-driven proton pump found in the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum, exhibits purple at neutral pH but its color is sensitive to pH. Here, structures are reported for an acid blue form and an alkaline purple form of wild-type bacteriorhodopsin. When the P622 crystal prepared at pH 5.2 was acidified with sulfuric acid, its color turned to blue with a pKa of 3.5 and a Hill coefficient of 2. Diffraction data at pH 2-5 indicated that the purple-to-blue transition accompanies a large structural change in the proton release channel; i.e. the extracellular half of helix C moves towards helix G, narrowing the proton release channel and expelling a water molecule from a micro-cavity in the vicinity of the retinal Schiff base. In this respect, the acid-induced structural change resembles the structural change observed upon formation of the M intermediate. But, the acid blue form contains a sulfate ion in a site(s) near Arg82 that is created by re-orientations of the carboxyl groups of Glu194 and Glu204, residues comprising the proton release complex. This result suggests that proton uptake by the proton release complex evokes the anion binding, which in turn induces protonation of Asp85, a key residue regulating the absorption spectrum of the chromophore. Interestingly, a pronounced structural change in the proton release complex was also observed at high pH; i.e. re-orientation of Glu194 towards Tyr83 was found to take place at around pH 10. This alkaline transition is suggested to be accompanied by proton release from the proton release complex and responsible for rapid formation of the M intermediate at high pH.     

Production of functional bacteriorhodopsin by an Escherichia coli cell‐free protein synthesis system supplemented with steroid detergent and lipid

Cell‐free expression has become a highly promising tool for the efficient production of membrane proteins. In this study, we used a dialysis‐based Escherichia coli cell‐free system for the production of a membrane protein actively integrated into liposomes. The membrane protein was the light‐driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin, consisting of seven transmembrane α‐helices. The cell‐free expression system in the dialysis mode was supplemented with a combination of a detergent and a natural lipid, phosphatidylcholine from egg yolk, in only the reaction mixture. By examining a variety of detergents, we found that the combination of a steroid detergent (digitonin, cholate, or CHAPS) and egg phosphatidylcholine yielded a large amount (0.3–0.7 mg/mL reaction mixture) of the fully functional bacteriorhodopsin. We also analyzed the process of functional expression in our system. The synthesized polypeptide was well protected from aggregation by the detergent‐lipid mixed micelles and/or lipid disks, and was integrated into liposomes upon detergent removal by dialysis. This approach might be useful for the high yield production of functional membrane proteins.     

Structural determinants of purple membrane assembly

The purple membrane is a two-dimensional crystalline lattice formed by bacteriorhodopsin and lipid molecules in the cytoplasmic membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. High-resolution structural studies, in conjunction with detailed knowledge of the lipid composition, make the purple membrane one of the best models for elucidating the forces that are responsible for the assembly and stability of integral membrane protein complexes. In this review, recent mutational efforts to identify the structural features of bacteriorhodopsin that determine its assembly in the purple membrane are discussed in the context of structural, calorimetric and reconstitution studies. Quantitative evidence is presented that interactions between transmembrane helices of neighboring bacteriorhodopsin molecules contribute to purple membrane assembly. However, other specific interactions, particularly between bacteriorhodopsin and lipid molecules, may provide the major driving force for assembly. Elucidating the molecular basis of protein-protein and protein-lipid interactions in the purple membrane may provide insights into the formation of integral membrane protein complexes in other systems.     

Coreconstitution of bacterial ATP synthase with monomeric bacteriorhodopsin into liposomes. A comparison between the efficiency of monomeric bacteriorhodopsin and purple membrane patches in coreconstitution experiments

The conditions for coreconstitution of a bacterial ATP synthase and bacteriorhodopsin into lecithin liposomes and for light driven ATP synthesis have been optimized. A rate of maximally 280 nmol ATP min-1 mg ATP synthase-1 was achieved with monomerized bacteriorhodopsin compared with a rate of up to 45 nmol ATP min-1 mg-1 found for proteoliposomes containing bacteriorhodopsin in the form of purple membrane patches. The different rates are explained by the finding that monomeric bacteriorhodopsin is more homogeneously distributed among the liposomes than the purple membrane patches. The final activities depended on both the purification method for the two proteins and the coreconstitution procedure. Furthermore, the ratio (lipid to bacteriorhodopsin to ATP synthase) could be optimized. Light-driven ATP synthesis depends also on the type of detergent used. The best result was obtained by deoxycholate. Also the relationship between proton translocation (by bacteriorhodopsin) and ATP synthesis activity was measured. A constant H+/ATP ratio was found at higher light intensities. This ratio increased strongly at lower light intensities.     

Light activates rotations of bacteriorhodopsin in the purple membrane

To investigate how a photoactivated chromophore drives the proton pump mechanism of bacteriorhodopsin, we have observed how the chromophore rotates during the photocyle. To do this, we examined the dichroism induced in aqueous suspensions of purple membrane fragments by flashes of linearly polarized light. We find that the flash stimulates both the photocycling chromophores and their noncycling neighbors to undergo large (greater than 10 degrees - 20 degrees) rotations within the membrane during the photocycle, and that these two chromophore populations undergo distinctly different sequences of rotations. All these rotations could be eliminated by glutaraldehyde fixation as well as by embedding unfixed fragments in polyacrylamide or agarose gels. Thus, in these immbolizing preparations the chromophore can photocycle without rotating inside a bacteriorhodopsin monomer by more than our detection limit of 2 degrees - 5 degrees. The large rotations we observed in aqueous suspensions of purple membranes were probably due to rotations of entire protein monomers. The process by which a photocycling monomer causes its noncycling neighbors to rotate may help explain the highly cooperative behavior bacteriorhodopsin exhibits when it is aggregated into crystalline arrays of trimers.