Isolation of Paracoccus denitrificans cytochrome cd1: comparative kinetics with other nitrite reductases

The dissimilatory nitrite reductase of the cytochrome cd₁ type was purified from Paracoccus denitrificans (ATCC 13543) by a novel procedure that avoided conventional ion-exchange techniques. The characterization of this enzyme was extended to include amino acid composition, extinction coefficients, and kinetic properties not previously reported. Cytochromes cd₁ from Alicaligenes faecalis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa were also isolated and assayed with electron donor proteins. The enzymes from all three sources were shown to obey the same integrated rate law. Cross-reactivities were measured in which a reduced donor protein from one strain was assayed with cytochrome cd₁ from another strain using nitrite as ultimate acceptor. Donors included c-type cytochromes and azurins. In general, the enzymes showed specificity for a donor from the same strain; interspecies cross-reactions were typically slower on the order of 10-fold than corresponding native rates. Notable exceptions were Paracoccus cytochrome cd₁, which alone reacted with eukaryotic horse cytochrome c at appreciable rates, and the Pseudomonas cd₁-Alcaligenesc554 reaction, which was 4-fold faster than the native Alcaligenes cd₁-Alcaligenesc554 reaction. For all three enzymes, competitive kinetics were measured in which the alternative substrates, nitrite and oxygen, competed for enzyme in the same assay. It was found that the competitive kinetics were dominated by nonenzymatic reactions involving an enzyme product, nitric oxide.     

Electron transport chains and bioenergetics of respiratory nitrogen metabolism in Wolinella succinogenes and other Epsilonproteobacteria

Recent phylogenetic analyses have established that the Epsilonproteobacteria form a globally ubiquitous group of ecologically significant organisms that comprises a diverse range of free-living bacteria as well as host-associated organisms like Wolinella succinogenes and pathogenic Campylobacter and Helicobacter species. Many Epsilonproteobacteria reduce nitrate and nitrite and perform either respiratory nitrate ammonification or denitrification. The inventory of epsilonproteobacterial genomes from 21 different species was analysed with respect to key enzymes involved in respiratory nitrogen metabolism. Most ammonifying Epsilonproteobacteria employ two enzymic electron transport systems named Nap (periplasmic nitrate reductase) and Nrf (periplasmic cytochrome c nitrite reductase). The current knowledge on the architecture and function of the corresponding proton motive force-generating respiratory chains using low-potential electron donors are reviewed in this article and the role of membrane-bound quinone/quinol-reactive proteins (NapH and NrfH) that are representative of widespread bacterial electron transport modules is highlighted. Notably, all Epsilonproteobacteria lack a napC gene in their nap gene clusters. Possible roles of the Nap and Nrf systems in anabolism and nitrosative stress defence are also discussed. Free-living denitrifying Epsilonproteobacteria lack the Nrf system but encode cytochrome cd₁ nitrite reductase, at least one nitric oxide reductase and a characteristic cytochrome c nitrous oxide reductase system (cNosZ). Interestingly, cNosZ is also found in some ammonifying Epsilonproteobacteria and enables nitrous oxide respiration in W. succinogenes.     

Nitrosylation of c heme in cd1-nitrite reductase is enhanced during catalysis

The reduction of nitrite into nitric oxide (NO) in denitrifying bacteria is catalyzed by nitrite reductase. In several species, this enzyme is a heme-containing protein with one c heme and one d₁ heme per monomer (cd₁NiR), encoded by the nirS gene.     

Selection and organisation of denitrifying electron-transfer pathways in Paracoccus denitrificans

(1) Under anaerobic conditions the respiratory chain in cells of Paracoccus denitrificans, from late exponential cultures grown anaerobically with nitrate as electron acceptor and succinate as carbon source, has been shown to reduce added nitrate via nitrite and nitrous oxide to nitrogen without any accumulation of these intermediates. (2) Addition of nitrous oxide to cells reducing nitrate strongly inhibited the latter reaction. The inhibition was reversed by preventing electron flow to nitrous oxide with either antimycin or acetylene. Electron flow to nitrous oxide thus resembles electron flow to oxygen in its inhibitory effect on nitrate reduction. In contrast, addition of nitrite to an anaerobic suspension of cells reducing nitrate resulted in a stimulation of nitrate reductase activity. Usually, addition of nitrite also partially overcame the inhibitory effect of nitrous oxide on nitrate reduction. The reason why added nitrous oxide, but not nitrite, inhibits nitrate reduction is suggested to be related to the higher reductase activity of the cells for nitrous oxide compared with nitrite. Explanations for the unexpected stimulation of nitrate reduction by nitrite in the presence or absence of added nitrous oxide are considered. (3) Nitrous oxide reductase was shown to be a periplasmic protein that competed with nitrite reductase for electrons from reduced cytochrome c. Added nitrous oxide strongly inhibited the reduction of added nitrite. (4) Nitrite reductase activity of cells was strongly inhibited by oxygen in the presence of physiological reductants, but nitrite reduction did occur in the presence of oxygen when isoascorbate plus N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine was the reductant. It is concluded that competition for available electrons by two oxidases, cytochrome aa₃ and cytochrome o, severely restricted electron flow to the nitrite reductase (cytochrome cd). For this reason it is unlikely that the oxidase activity of this cytochrome is ever functional in cells. (5) The mechanism by which electron flow to oxygen or nitrous oxide inhibits nitrate reduction in cells has been investigated. It is argued that relatively small changes in the extent of reduction of ubiquinone, or of another component of the respiratory chain with similar redox potential, critically determine the capacity for reducing nitrate. The argument is based on: (i) the response of an anthroyloxystearic acid fluorescent probe that is sensitive to changes in the oxidation state of ubiquinone; (ii) consideration of the total rates of electron flow through ubiquinone both in the presence of oxygen and in the presence of nitrate under anaerobic conditions; (iii) use of relative extents of oxidation of b-type cytochromes as an indicator of ubiquinone redox state, especially the finding that b-type cytochrome of the antimycin-sensitive part of the respiratory chain is more oxidised in the presence of added nitrous oxide, which inhibits nitrate reduction, than in the presence of added nitrite which does not inhibit. Arguments against b- or c-type cytochromes themselves controlling nitrate reduction are given. (6) In principle, control on nitrate reduction could be exerted either upon electron flow or upon the movement of nitrate to the active site of its reductase. The observations that inverted membrane vesicles and detergent-treated cells reduced nitrate and oxygen simultaneously at a range of total rates of electron flow are taken to support the latter mechanism. The failure of an additional reductant, durohydroquinone, to activate nitrate reduction under aerobic conditions in the presence of succinate is also evidence that it is not an inadequate supply of electrons that prevents the functioning of nitrate reductase under aerobic conditions. (7) In inverted membrane vesicles the division of electron flow between nitrate and oxygen is determined by a competition mechanism, in contrast to cells. This change in behaviour upon converting cells to vesicles cannot be attributed to loss of cytochrome c, and therefore of oxidase activity, from the vesicles because a similar change in behaviour was seen with vesicles prepared from cells of a cytochrome c-deficient mutant.     

Cytochrome cd1 Nitrite Reductase NirS Is Involved in Anaerobic Magnetite Biomineralization in Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense and Requires NirN for Proper d1 Heme Assembly

The alphaproteobacterium Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense synthesizes magnetosomes, which are membrane-enveloped crystals of magnetite. Here we show that nitrite reduction is involved in redox control during anaerobic biomineralization of the mixed-valence iron oxide magnetite. The cytochrome cd₁-type nitrite reductase NirS shares conspicuous sequence similarity with NirN, which is also encoded within a larger nir cluster. Deletion of any one of these two nir genes resulted in impaired growth and smaller, fewer, and aberrantly shaped magnetite crystals during nitrate reduction. However, whereas nitrite reduction was completely abolished in the ΔnirS mutant, attenuated but significant nitrite reduction occurred in the ΔnirN mutant, indicating that only NirS is a nitrite reductase in M. gryphiswaldense. However, the ΔnirN mutant produced a different form of periplasmic d₁ heme that was not noncovalently bound to NirS, indicating that NirN is required for full reductase activity by maintaining a proper form of d₁ heme for holo-cytochrome cd₁ assembly. In conclusion, we assign for the first time a physiological function to NirN and demonstrate that effective nitrite reduction is required for biomineralization of wild-type crystals, probably by contributing to oxidation of ferrous iron under oxygen-limited conditions.     

Defects in cytochrome cd 1-dependent nitrite respiration of transposon Tn5-induced mutants from Pseudomonas stutzeri

Mutants with defective respiratory nitrite utilization (Nir^- phenotype) were obtained by transposon Tn5 insertion into genomic DNA of the ZoBell strain of Pseudomonas stutzeri. Three representative mutants were characterized with respect to their activities of nitrite and nitric oxide reduction, cytochrome cd ₁ content, and pattern of soluble c-type cytochromes. Mutant strain MK201 over-produced cytochrome c ₅₅₂ about fourfold by comparison with the wild type, but possessed an in vitro functional cytochrome cd ₁. Mutant strain MK202 lacked cytochrome cd ₁ and, simultaneously, had low amounts of cytochrome c ₅₅₂ and the split -peak c-type cytochrome. Strain MK203 synthesized nitrite reductase defective in the heme d ₁ prosthetic group. Irrespective of these biochemically distinct Nir^- phenotypes, all mutants preserved the nitric oxidereducing capability of the wild type. The mutant characteristics demonstrate that cytochrome cd ₁ is essential for nitrite respiration of P. stutzeri and establish the presence of a nitric oxide-reducing system distinct from cytochrome cd ₁. They also indicate the functional or regulatory interdependence of c-type cytochromes.     

A cytochrome cd 1-type nitrite reductase mediates the first step of denitrification in Alcaligenes eutrophus

Respiratory nitrite reductase (NIR) has been purified from the soluble extract of denitrifying cells of Alcaligenes eutrophus strain H16 to apparent electrophoretic homogeneity. The enzyme was induced under anoxic conditions in the presence of nitrite. Purified NIR showed typical features of a cytochrome cd ₁-type nitrite reductase. It appeared to be a dimer of 60 kDa subunits, its activity was only weakly inhibited by the copper chelator diethyldithiocarbamate, and spectral analysis revealed absorption maxima which were characteristic for the presence of heme c and heme d ₁. The isoelectric point of 8.6 was considerably higher than the pI determined for cd ₁ nitrite reductases from pseudomonads. Eighteen amino acids at the N-terminus of the A. eutrophus NIR, obtained by protein sequencing, showed no significant homology to the N-terminal region of nitrite reductases from Pseudomonas stutzeri and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.     

Copper-containing nitrite reductase from Pseudomonas aureofaciens is functional in a mutationally cytochrome cd 1-free background (NirS−) of Pseudomonas stutzeri

The structural gene, nirK, for the respiratory Cu-containing nitrite reductase from denitrifying Pseudomonas aureofaciens was isolated and sequenced. It encodes a polypeptide of 363 amino acids including a signal peptide of 24 amino acids for protein export. The sequence showed 63.8% positional identity with the amino acid sequence of Achromobacter cycloclastes nitrite reductase. Ligands for the blue, type I Cu-binding site and for a putative type-II site were identified. The nirK gene was transferred to the mutant MK202 of P. stutzeri which lacks cytochrome cd ₁ nitrite reductase due to a transposon Tn5 insertion in its structural gene, nirS. The heterologous enzyme was active in vitro and in vivo in this background and restored the mutationally interrupted denitrification pathway. Transfer of nirK to Escherichia coli resulted in an active nitrite reductase in vitro. Expression of the nirS gene from P. stutzeri in P. aureofaciens and E. coli led to nonfunctional gene products. Nitrite reductase activity of cell extract from either bacterium could be reconstituted by addition of heme d ₁, indicating that both heterologous hosts synthesized a cytochrome cd ₁ without the d ₁-group.Abbreviations Cu-NIR Cu-containing nitrite reductase - DDC diethyldithiocarbamate - EPR electron paramagnetic resonance - IPTG isopropyl--D-galactoside - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - LB medium Luria-Bertani medium     

Enzymatic activity mastered by altering metal coordination spheres

Metalloenzymes control enzymatic activity by changing the characteristics of the metal centers where catalysis takes place. The conversion between inactive and active states can be tuned by altering the coordination number of the metal site, and in some cases by an associated conformational change. These processes will be illustrated using heme proteins (cytochrome c nitrite reductase, cytochrome c peroxidase and cytochrome cd ₁ nitrite reductase), non-heme proteins (superoxide reductase and [NiFe]-hydrogenase), and copper proteins (nitrite and nitrous oxide reductases) as examples. These examples catalyze electron transfer reactions that include atom transfer, abstraction and insertion.     

Mutagenesis of nitrite reductase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa: tyrosine-10 in the c heme domain is not involved in catalysis

In Pseudomonas aeruginosa, conversion of nitrite to NO in dissimilatory denitrification is catalyzed by the enzyme nitrite reductase (NiR), a homodimer containing a covalently bound c heme and a d₁ heme per subunit. We report the purification and characterization of the first single mutant of P. aeruginosa cd₁ NiR in which Tyr¹⁰ has been replaced by Phe; this amino acid was chosen as a possibly important residue in the catalytic mechanism of this enzyme based on the proposal (Fülöp, V., Moir, J.W.B., Ferguson, S.J. and Hajdu, J. (1995) Cell 81, 369–377) that the topologically homologous Tyr²⁵ plays a crucial role in controlling the activity of the cd₁ NiR from Thiosphaera pantotropha. Our results show that in P. aeruginosa NiR substitution of Tyr¹⁰ with Phe has no effect on the activity, optical spectroscopy and electron transfer kinetics of the enzyme, indicating that distal coordination of the Fe³⁺ of the d₁ heme is provided by different side-chains in different species.     

Interaction of Pseudomonas cytochrome cd1 with the cytoplasmic membrane.

Labelling with ferritin-conjugated antibody shows that Pseudomonas cytochrome cd1 is associated with the inner surface of the cytoplasmic membrane. Cytochrome cd1 is however, enriched to the soluble fraction obtained after destruction of Pseudomonas spheroplasts. Comparison of the respiratory nitrite reductase activities, due to this cytochrome, between different cellular fractions and the purified enzyme shows that while the kinetic pattern and the temperature dependence of the activity remain almost the same the molecular activity is enhanced when the enzyme is released from cells. A new assay of respiratory nitrite reductase was developed in this study. The method is based on determination of the stoichiometrical proton consumption accompanying nitrite reduction.     

Periplasmic location of nitrous oxide reductase and its apoform in denitrifying Pseudomonas stutzeri

Immunogold labelling techniques on ultrathin sections of low temperature embedded cells yielded evidence for the periplasmic location of the respiratory enzymes N₂O reductase and nitrite reductase (cytochrome cd ₁) in Pseudomonas stutzeri strain ZoBell. Cell fractionation by spheroplast preparation and two-dimensional electrophoresis showed the absence of a membrane association of these enzymes. Immunocytochemical localization of N₂O reductase in a mutant strain deficient in the chromophore of N₂O reductase showed the gold label at the cell periphery, indicating that the copper chromophore processing takes place after export of this protein's apoform.     

Intramolecular Electron Transfer in Pseudomonas aeruginosa cd1 Nitrite Reductase: Thermodynamics and Kinetics

The cd₁ nitrite reductases, which catalyze the reduction of nitrite to nitric oxide, are homodimers of 60 kDa subunits, each containing one heme-c and one heme-d₁. Heme-c is the electron entry site, whereas heme-d₁ constitutes the catalytic center. The 3D structure of Pseudomonas aeruginosa nitrite reductase has been determined in both fully oxidized and reduced states. Intramolecular electron transfer (ET), between c and d₁ hemes is an essential step in the catalytic cycle. In earlier studies of the Pseudomonas stutzeri enzyme, we observed that a marked negative cooperativity is controlling this internal ET step. In this study we have investigated the internal ET in the wild-type and His369Ala mutant of P. aeruginosa nitrite reductases and have observed similar cooperativity to that of the Pseudomonas stutzeri enzyme. Heme-c was initially reduced, in an essentially diffusion-controlled bimolecular process, followed by unimolecular electron equilibration between the c and d₁ hemes (k_ET = 4.3 s⁻¹ and K = 1.4 at 298K, pH 7.0). In the case of the mutant, the latter ET rate was faster by almost one order of magnitude. Moreover, the internal ET rate dropped (by ∼30-fold) as the level of reduction increased in both the WT and the His mutant. Equilibrium standard enthalpy and entropy changes and activation parameters of this ET process were determined. We concluded that negative cooperativity is a common feature among the cd₁ nitrite reductases, and we discuss this control based on the available 3D structure of the wild-type and the H369A mutant, in the reduced and oxidized states.     

Discrimination of ascorbate-dependent nonenzymatic and enzymatic,membrane-bound reduction of nitric oxide in denitrifying Pseudomonas perfectomarinus

The marine nitrite-respiring (denitrifying) bacterium, Pseudomonas perfectomarinus, catalyzes by a membrane-bound enzyme the reduction of nitric oxide to nitrous oxide with ascorbate-reduced phenazine methosulfate as electron donor. The entire nitric oxide-reducing capability of a cell-free system was membrane bound and this process was studied with respect to pH and substrate dependency. The enzymatic process was perturbed by an identical nonenzymatic reduction by iron(II) ascorbate in neutral to alkaline aqueous solution. 2 mol nitric oxide and 1 mol ascorbate were consumed per mol nitrous oxide formed. Enzymatic and nonenzymatic processes were discriminated by their differential behavior towards pH and metal-chelating agents. The pH optimum for the enzymatic and nonenzymatic reaction was 5.2 and greater than 7.0, respectively. EDTA (10 mM) inhibited the nonenzymatic reduction completely without interfering with the membrane-bound activity. The nonenzymatic system mimics the reaction of nitric oxide reductase and could serve as a model to study the formation of the N-N bond in denitrification. Enzymatic generation of nitric oxide by cytochrome cd and subsequent nonenzymatic reduction to nitrous oxide simulate an overall quasi-enzymatic nitrous oxide formation by cytochrome cd. The nonenzymatic reduction of nitric oxide might have occurred in previous work due to the ubiquitous use of ascorbate in studies on nitrite respiration and the likelihood of adventitious iron in biological samples.     

Crystal Structure of Dihydro-Heme d1 Dehydrogenase NirN from Pseudomonas aeruginosa Reveals Amino Acid Residues Essential for Catalysis

Many bacteria can switch from oxygen to nitrogen oxides, such as nitrate or nitrite, as terminal electron acceptors in their respiratory chain. This process is called “denitrification” and enables biofilm formation of the opportunistic human pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa, making it more resilient to antibiotics and highly adaptable to different habitats. The reduction of nitrite to nitric oxide is a crucial step during denitrification. It is catalyzed by the homodimeric cytochrome cd₁ nitrite reductase (NirS), which utilizes the unique isobacteriochlorin heme d₁ as its reaction center. Although the reaction mechanism of nitrite reduction is well understood, far less is known about the biosynthesis of heme d₁. The last step of its biosynthesis introduces a double bond in a propionate group of the tetrapyrrole to form an acrylate group. This conversion is catalyzed by the dehydrogenase NirN via a unique reaction mechanism. To get a more detailed insight into this reaction, the crystal structures of NirN with and without bound substrate have been determined. Similar to the homodimeric NirS, the monomeric NirN consists of an eight-bladed heme d₁-binding β-propeller and a cytochrome c domain, but their relative orientation differs with respect to NirS. His147 coordinates heme d₁ at the proximal side, whereas His323, which belongs to a flexible loop, binds at the distal position. Tyr461 and His417 are located next to the hydrogen atoms removed during dehydrogenation, suggesting an important role in catalysis. Activity assays with NirN variants revealed the essentiality of His147, His323 and Tyr461, but not of His417.     

Mechanism of nitrite reduction to nitrous oxide in a photodenitrifier,Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroide forma sp. denitrificans

The mechanism of anaerobic reduction of NO₂^? to N₂O in a photodenitrifier, Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides forma sp. denitrificans, was investigated. With ascorbate-reduced phenazine methosulfate (PMS) as the electron donor, the nitrite reductase of this photodenitrifier reduced NO₂^? to NO and a trace amount of N₂O. With dithionite-reduced benzyl viologen as the electron donor, the major product of NO₂^? reduction was NH₂OH, and a trace amount of N₂O was also produced. The nitrate reductase itself had no NO reductase activity with ascorbate-reduced PMS. It was concluded that the essential product of NO₂^? reduction by the purified nitrite reductase is NO. Chromatophore membranes stoichiometrically produced N₂O from NO₂^? with any electron donor, such as dithionite-redduced benzyl viologen, ascorbate-reduced PMS or NADH/FMN. The membranes also contrained activity of NO reduction of N₂O with either ascorbate-reduced PMS or duroquinol. The NO reductase activity with duroquinol was inhibited by antimycin A. Stoichiometric production of N₂O from N₂^? also was observed in the reconstituted NO₂^? reduction system which contained the cytochrome bc₁ complex, cytochrome c₂, the nitrite reductase and duroquinol as the electron donor. The preparation of the cytochrome bc₁ complex itself contianed NO reductase activity. From these results the mechanism of NO₂^? reduction to N₂O in this photodenitrifier was determined as the nitrite reductase reducing NO₂^? to NO with electrons from the cytochrome bc₁ complex, and NO subsequently being reduced, without release, to N₂O with electrons from the cytochrome bc₁ complex by the NO reductase, which is closely associated with the complex.     

Stoichiometry of nitrite reduction catalyzed by Pseudomonas aeruginosa nitrite-reductase

The stoichiometry of the reduction of nitrite catalyzed by Pseudomonas aeruginosa nitrite-reductase (cytochrome cd₁) has been shown to yield nitrous oxide as the final product. Gas chromatography experiments demonstrated that nitric oxide is also formed as a free intermediate. A sequential formation of NO and N₂O is discussed as proposed to the parallel formation of the two products.     

The participation of cytochromes in the process of nitrate respiration in Klebsiella (Aerobacter) aerogenes

1. The participation of cytochromes in the membrane-bound, nitrate and oxygen respiratory systems of Klebsiella (Aerobacter) aerogenes has been investigated. The membrane preparations contained the NADH, succinate, lactate and formate oxidase systems, and in addition a high respiratory nitrate reductase activity.2. Difference spectra indicated the presence of cytochromes b, a₁, d, and o. Cytochromes of the c-type could not be detected in these membranes. Both cytochrome b content and respiratory nitrate reductase activity were the highest in bacteria grown anaerobically in the presence of nitrate.3. Cytochrome b was the only cytochrome which, after being reduced by NADH, could be partially reoxidized anaerobically in the presence of nitrate. Furthermore, nitrate caused a lower aerobic steady state reduction only of cytochrome b.4. NADH oxidase and NADH-linked respiratory nitrate reductase activities were both inhibited by antimycin A, 2-n-heptyl-4-hydroxyquinoline-N-oxide and KCN. NADH oxidase activity was selectively inhibited by CO, while azide was found to inhibit only the respiratory nitrate reductase. In the presence of azide, nitrate did not affect the level of reduction of cytochrome b.5. The evidence presented suggests that cytochrome b is a carrier in the electron transport systems to both nitrate and oxygen; from cytochrome b branching occurs, with one branch linked to the respiratory nitrate reductase and one branch linked to oxidase systems, containing the cytochromes a₁, d and o.     

Evolution of bacterial denitrification and denitrifier diversity

Little is known about the role of nitrate in evolution of bacterial energy-generating mechanisms. Denitrifying bacteria are commonly regarded to have evolved from nitrate-respiring bacteria. Some researchers regard denitrification to be the precursor of aerobic respiration; others feel the opposite is true. Currently recognized denitrifying bacteria such as Hyphomicrobium, Paracoccus, Pseudomonas and Thiobacillus form a very diverse group. However, inadequate testing procedures and uncertain taxonomic identification of many isolates may have overstated the number of genera with species capable of denitrification. Nitrate reductases are structurally similar among denitrifying bacteria, but distinct from the enzymes in other nitrate-reducing organisms. Denitryfying bacteria have one of two types of nitrite reductase, either a copper-containing enzyme or an enzyme containing a cytochrome cd moiety. Both types are distinct from other nitrate reductases. Organisms capable of dissimilatory nitrate reduction are widely distributed among eubacterial groups defined by 16S ribosomal RNA phylogeny. Indeed, nitrate reduction is an almost universal property of actinomycetes and enteric organisms. However, denitrification is restricted to genera within the purple photosynthetic group. Denitrification within the genus Pseudomonas is distributed in accordance with DNA and RNA homology complexes. Denitrifiers seem to have evolved from a common ancestor within the purple photosynthetic bacterial group, but not from a nitrate-reducing organism such as those found today. Although denitrification seems to have arisen at the same time as aerobic respiration, the evolutionary relationship between the two cannot be determined at this time.