Cell-cycle duration and sister-chromatid exchange frequency in cultured human lymphocytes

Whole heparinized blood samples from normal human donors were grown in culture media containing 10 μg/ml of bromodeoxyuridine. Lymphocytes were harvested after 58, 70, 72 and 80 h and scored for sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) under a fluorescence microscope. SCEs which occured during the first and second cell cycles were counted in second or third generation cells selected on the basis of their chromosome fluorescence patterns. The results of a preliminary study showed the mean SCE frequency per cell at 72 h to be 9.0 for second generation cells and 7.8 in third generation cells (P < 0.01). A second study, using culture medium with heat-inactivated fetal-calf serum, gave similar results (9.4 vs. 7.8, P 0.001) at 70 h. Therefore, the difference in SCE frequency between second and third generation cells at 70 or 72 h cannot be attributed to heat-labile substances of serum origin. An additional finding in the second study was that SCE frequencies in third division cells at 70 and80 h were the samee as those of second division cells at 58 h but significantly less (P < 0.001) than the frequency in second division cells at 70 h. These data were interpreted as arising from at least two different lymphocyte populations; one group of cells that is either slower growing or slower in phytohemagglutinin stimulation, with a higher SCE frequency which does not reach second division until 70 or 80 h, and a more rapidly dividing (or more quickly stimulated by phytohemagglutinin) population with a lower SCE frequency which reaches second division at 58 h and third division by 70–80 h. Whether or not this hypothesis is correct, the data show that SCE frequency varies significantly with cell-cycle duration. Since some carcinogens have been shown to alter cell kinetics (Craig-Holmes and Shaw, Mutation Res. 46 (1977) 375), changes in SCE frequency which are caused by a change in cell kinetics must be considered a factor in determining the mutagenicity of an agent by its ability to increase SCE frequency.     

Effects of caffeine-induced defective DNA replication on SCE and chromosome aberrations produced by alkylating agents

The effect of caffeine (CAF) pretreatment (during the first cell cycle) on the frequency of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) and chromosome aberrations induced by bifunctional(MC)- and monofunctional(M-MC)-mitomycin C, 4-nitroquinoline N-oxide (4NQO) and ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS) were examined by using a BrdU—Hoechst staining technique. When CAF was added to the cultures during the first cell cycle in the presence of BrdU and then the cultures treated with MC, M-MC, 4NQO or EMS during the second cell cycle, the effect of the CAF was synergistic, i.e., the SCE level achieved was much higher than that expected from a simple additive effect of the agents and CAF. These results do not support the concept that the process of SCE is a manifestation of CAF-sensitive post-replication repair of DNA damage (single-strand exchanges), but, instead, point to exchanges between the double-strands of the DNA duplex present in each chromatid. CAF at certain concentrations is known to significantly slow down the rate of DNA-chain growth, but not appreciably induce strand breaks. Inasmuch as CAF alone induced only a small increase in SCE rates, possible mechanisms which may induce SCE are not only related to the slowing down of the rate of DNA-chain growth, but may also involve breaks in the template strand permitting double-strand exchanges to occur. The mechanisms responsible for chemically induced SCE are also discussed.     

Spontaneous level of sister chromosome exchanges and their distribution in human cells]

Blood of practically healthy donors of both sexes (27 females and 23 males) was cultured under the standard conditions during 96 hours. Bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR) was added at the final concentration of 10 mkg/ml 28 hours before harvesting. The slides were stained with acridine orange and Giemsa for differential staining of chromatids. In each culture sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) were analysed in 50 cells, and the part of cells undergoing the first, second and third mitoses at the time of harvesting, was calculated. According to the mean number of SCE per cell, the distribution of individuals was consistent with the normal law, the mean being 6.525 and standard deviation--0.956. A significant heterogeneity in the speed of cell cycle of cultures was observed. The coefficient of variation for the part of cells undergoing the first mitosis was 50%, for the cells in the second mitosis--15%, and for the cells in the third mitosis--154%. Correlation analysis showed a positive dependence of the mean level of SCF upon the age of a donor and upon the part of cells in the second mitosis in this individual. No reliable correlation of the SCE level with the donor's sex was observed. The distribution of cells, obtained from the culture of one individual, was best approximated by beta-distribution, and the distribution of cells obtained from the cultures of different individuals--by gamma-distribution. In both there was obtained a satisfactory approximation by Pearson's distribution of the 1 type, and significant deviations were found from the normal, Poison's and the negative binomial distribution. The conditions were found of similarity of empirical distribution of SCE in cells to the normal one. For that, it is not the value of SCE for a separate cell that should be used as a unit of measurement, but the mean from the values of frequencies for 5-10 cells. Hence, it was shown that for the evaluation of the mean frequency of SCE with the precision of 1 exchange in separate individuals it is necessary to analyse 40 cells, and to observe the 15% increase of spontaneous SCE level under the action of deleterious factors--8 individuals are enough to analyse.     

Comparison of sister chromatid exchanges from three successive cell cycles in Wallabia bicolor chromosomes

An autoradiographic analysis of tritiated thymidine labeled chromosomes of Wallabia bicolor at the second and third metaphases after label incorporations has shown that sister chromatid exchanges (SCE's) from the first and second cell cycles are less than as frequent as SCE's from the third cell cycle after label. Exchange levels per cell cycle estimated at the seconf division are under-estimated due to coincident exchanges. In both methaphases exchanges were largely distributed at random along Wallabia chromosomes with frequencies proportional to chromosome length. The ratio of twin: single SCE's in spontaneoulsy occuring tetraploid cells indicated the first cycle exchanges were marginally more frequent than second cycle exchanges.These data are compatible with exchange probabilities being equal and independent over divisions, but a component of exchanges reducing as tritium content in chromosomes decreases cannot be excluded. This findings that SCE's are primarily independent of tritium cannot be attributed to a saturation of sites for exchange and it is therefore probable that sister exchanges are, in part at least, spontaneous events in Wallabia chromosomes.     

SCE evaluations in human lymphocytes after G0 exposure to mitomycin C Lack of expression of MMC-induced SCEs in cells that have undergone greater than two in vitro divisions

We conducted a series of experiments designed to determine whether DNA damage induced in G₀ lymphocytes by mitomycin C (MMC) would be expressed as sister-chromatid exchanges during the second and third post-treatment cell cycles. Lymphocytes from normal donors were exposed to MMC for 2 h prior to culture in the presence of phytohemagglutinin. MMC-treated and control cells were subsequently exposed to bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) for the entire culture period (i.e. 48 h or 72 h) or for the terminal 24 h of 72-h cultures. We observed a 3–4-fold increase in SCEs in MII metaphases from lymphocytes treated with MMC and cultured in the presence of BrdUrd for the entire culture period. In contrast, in replicate cultures of MMC-treated lymphocytes that were exposed to BrdUrd for the terminal 24 h only, the SCE frequency in uniformly harlequinized metaphases was not significantly different from that observed in control cultures. We interpret these data as providing evidence that MMC-induced lesions (or alterations) in the DNA of G₀ lymphocytes are probably expressed as SCEs during the first period of mitogeninduced DNA synthesis, and that these lesions do not persist and give rise to SCEs in subsequent cell divisions.     

Effect of 5-bromodeoxyuridine concentration on sister chromatid exchange frequency in consecutive replication cycles

A yield of single and twin sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) in Chinese hamster cells incubated at different concentrations of 5'-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) has been studied. The ratio of SCEs formed in the second and in the first cycle has been discovered to be dependent on the dose of BrdUrd; it is 1.5:1 for the high concentration of BrdUrd and 1:1 for the lowest one. The authors arrived at a conclusion that the observed level of SCEs--0.1 per chromosome per cycle for the lowest concentration is spontaneous.     

Evolution of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) in rat bone marrow cells as a function of time after 2 Gy of whole-body neutron irradiation

We scored sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) in bone marrow cells in 3-month-old rats as a function of time after 2 Gy of whole-body neutron irradiation. This dose reduced the mean survival time to 445 days after irradiation, and induced more than one tumor per animal; by 200 days post irradiation, all animals bore tumors at autopsy, but bone marrow was not a significant target for tumor induction. In controls, the mean SCE/cell remained constant from 3 to 24 months of age (2.38 SCE/cell, S.D. = 0.21). Irradiation induced 2 distinct increases in SCE: the first occurred during the days following exposure, and the second, from days 150 to 240. Thereafter, SCE values formed a plateau at 3.37 SCE/cell (S.D. = 0.39) until day 650. Between the two increases (i.e. from days 15 to 150), SCE dropped to control values. Analysis of SCE distribution per cell shows that the entire dividing cell population altered homogeneously during the increase in SCE. These results suggest that in our irradiated rats, the second increase in SCE coincides with tumor growth, whereas the first increase might be due to DNA damage that was rapidly repaired.     

Influence of low doses of BrdU and estimation of spontaneous SCE in CHO chromosomes: three-way differential staining and an immunoperoxidase method

The influence of low doses of 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) on the occurrence of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) during the first cell cycle, when unsubstituted DNA templates replicate in the presence of the halogenated nucleoside (SCE1) has been assessed in third mitosis (M3) Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells showing three-way differential (TWD) staining. In addition, lower concentrations of BrdU, not detectable by Giemsa staining, have been tested by a high resolution immunoperoxidase method (anti-BrdU monoclonal antibody) and SCEs were scored in second mitosis (M2) cells. Our findings was a dose-response curve for SCE1 that allows an estimated mean spontaneous yield of 1.32/cell per cell cycle by extrapolation to zero concentration of BrdU. On the other hand, when the total SCE frequency corresponding to the first and second rounds of replication (SCE1+SCE2) found in M3 chromosomes was compared with the yield of SCEs scored in M2 cells grown in BrdU at doses lower than 1 M no further reduction was achieved. This seems to indicate that SCEs can occur spontaneously in this cell line, though the estimated frequency is higher than that reported in vivo.by S. Wolff     

Factors influencing the frequency of mitomycin C-induced sister-chromatid exchanges in 5-bromodeoxyuridine-substituted human lymphocytes in culture.

Newly developed techniques for the detection of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) require the substitution of 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) for thymidine in DNA. We investigated the possibility of interactions between BrdU and one mutagen--carcinogen, mitomycin C (MMC) for the induction of both chromosomal aberrations and SCE in human peripheral lymphocytes in culture. No effect on aberration yield was found. Neither comparisons between the yields of SCE by BrdU substitution and differential staining and those detected by tritiated thymidine incorporation and autoradiography nor between the yields of SCE for different levels of BrdU incorporation provided any evidence of synergism. It was found, however, that MMC persists in cultures and continues to increase SCE frequencies for about 30 h. It was also observed that some MMC-induced DNA lesions persist long enough so that some of those present prior to S phase of the first cell cycle cause additional SCE in the third cycle.     

Effects of caffeine-pretreatment on SCE and chromosome aberrations induced by monofunctional- and bifunctional-mitomycin C in bloom syndrome lymphocytes

Bloom syndrome (BS) lymphocytes, which are characterized by a high incidence (75.4 per cell) of SCE, were treated with caffeine (CAF) during the first cell cycle and with monofunctional-(M-MC) and bifunctional-(MC)mitomycin C during the second cycle. The effect on the SCE level was synergistic. The CAF-pretreated cells in combination with M-MC and MC post-treatments, had significantly higher (SCE values 152.5 and 167.9 SCE per cell, resp.) than those treated with M-MC or MC alone during the second cycle (101.1 and 116.4 SCE per cell, resp.). M-MC and MC in the presence of BrdU (without CAF) for 2 cell cycles increased SCE to 157.6 and 169.4 per cell (about twice the control level). M-MC + CAF and MC + CAF treatments for 2 cell cycles did not produce a synergistic effect on the SCE frequency in BS cells; the SCE level was not significantly greater than that with M-MC or MC alone. Normal cells treated with MC and CAF for 2 cycles had a maximum SCE frequency of 156 per cell. This suggests that cells with SCE frequencies above this level may not be able to survive, i.e., this is the “saturation” level of SCE. However, CAF alone had almost no effect on SCE in either BS or normal cells and did not produce multiple chromosome aberrations. The lack of CAF effect on BS cells suggests that the lesions in DNA strands of BS cells which lead to SCE are double-strand lesions. In normal cells CAF is known to significantly slow down DNA-chain growth; the reduced rate of DNA-chain growth in BS is an inherent defect of the cells. Therefore, though CAF enhanced SCE and chromosome aberrations (shattered chromosomes) in combination with alkylating agents, CAF alone did not significantly increase the SCE rate in either BS cells or in normal cells. Thus, processes which may induce SCE are not only related to retarded rate of DNA-chain growth, but also to breaks in the template strand permitting double-strand exchanges to occur.     

Sister chromatid exchanges in human leukocyte chromosomes: Spontaneous and induced frequencies in early- and late-proliferating cells in vitro

Summary Human leukocyte cultures were pulse-treated with the trifunctional alkylating mutagen trenimon in a final concentration of 10^-7 M for 15–20 h after culture start, i.e., in the G₁ phase of the cell cycle. At 24 h after culture start bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR) was added to the trenimon-treated cultures and to several untreated cultures running in parallel. The series treated with BUdR only and the series treated with BUdR+trenimon were each used to prepare two cultures at different culture times. Mitoses were collected during consecutive intervals of 12 h from 30 h up to 102 h after culture initiation by colcemid. For all preparation times (42 h, 54 h, 66 h, 78 h, 90 h, and 102 h) the frequencies of first, second, and third and further mitoses were determined in the BUdR- and in the BUdR+trenimon-treated series. In the trenimon-treated series a clear cell cycle delay was detected as compared with the normal distribution of different types of mitoses found in series treated with BUdR only. Spontaneous and trenimon-induced sister chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies were determined in second mitoses occurring at 66 h, 78 h, 90 h, and 102 h after culture start. For all these preparation times about six SCE per metaphase were consistently found in BUdR-treated, and about 19 SCE per metaphase in BUdR+trenimon-treated series, indicating a homogeneous sensitivity of early- and late-proliferating cells with respect to the induction of SCE.This paper is dedicated to Prof. B. Erich Wolf on the occasion of his 70th birthday     

Sister chromatid exchange in the centromere and centromeric area

Central and peripheral sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) were evaluated separately in human phytohemagglutinin (PHA)-stimulated lymphocytes after culture for 72 h in 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) containing medium. At the same time, the length of chromosome No. 1 was measured in 10 metaphases per case and the mean value taken as a representative parameter for the contraction of chromosomes. The statistical analysis of regression revealed a close relationship between the percentage of SCE observed in the centromere and the contraction state of chromosomes (P less than or equal to 0.01). A statistically significant increase of central exchanges was seen in more condensed chromosomes, due to the difficulty in differentiating clearly between centric and pericentric exchanges. Consequently, if exchanges in the centromere are omitted from evaluation, this would lead to spuriously low SCE rates in more contracted chromosomes. In order to exclude the variable factor of chromosome contraction in SCE studies, we highly recommend inclusion of counts of central exchanges. Results obtained on chromosomes with twisted chromatids, a situation which tends to stimulate SCE, should be omitted.     

Analysis of sister chromatid exchanges in the 1st, 2d and 3d mitoses using 5-bromodeoxyuridine and 5-bromodeoxycytidine

The cultures of Chinese hamster cells were treated with different concentrations (2.5, 5.0, 10.0, 20.0, 80.0 and 160.0 microgram/ml) 5-BrdU and 5-BrdC during 12 hours. The cultures were fixed at the 24-th hour. The linear increase of sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) was discovered with the increase of BrdU concentration. No change of SCE frequency was observed at different BrdC concentrations. The reasons for these differences in a concentration effect are discussed.     

Modeling of induction and elimination of sister chromatid exchanges in time

Induction and elimination of sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) have been simulated during several cell cycles. Two models of SCE elimination are suggested. The first model postulates that the mutagen-induced lesions are not repaired, a lesion being only inherited by one daughter cell after DNA synthesis. According to the second model, lesions are completely repaired at the first S-phase. No SCE induction takes place during next cell cycles. SCE frequency ranges for both models are described by an equation, including the probability distribution function. The best correspondence in experimental and theoretical results was obtained using the model claiming repair of lesions during one cell cycle.     

Analysis of baseline and BrdU-dependent SCEs at different BrdU concentrations

In the present paper we have used a rationale based on the development of theoretical equations that define sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequencies as a function of two variables, namely the baseline (BrdU-independent) and the BrdU-dependent SCE frequencies. The experimental design includes the estimation of SCE frequencies in second division chromosomes when both cycles occurred in the presence of BrdU and when BrdU incubation took place only during the first cycle in a wide range of BrdU concentrations. The final SCE yields in second division chromosomes could be separated into three different components: (1) The BrdU-independent, ‘spontaneous’ or baseline SCEs, whose low but biologically significant frequency was calculated to be about 0.06 SCEs per pg of DNA; this figure could be similar for most of the cell types; (2) the BrdU-dependent SCEs whose frequency increases with BrdU dose, probably as a result of BrdU substitution for thymidine; (3) the BrdU-dependent SCEs as a consequence of other cellular factors such as disturbance of nucleotide pool sizes. At high BrdU concentrations (300 μM upward) the three components appear to have a significant value in the final SCE yield, whereas at lower BrdU doses the third component seems to be negligible.     

Cyclophosphamide-Induced IN VIVO Sister Chromatid Exchanges (Sce) in MUS MUSCULUS. III. Quantitative Genetic Analysis

In vivo cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were evaluated in females from five genetic strains of mice (C57BL/6J, C3H/S, 129/ReJ, BALB/c and DBA/2) and their F₁ hybrids. Baseline (noninduced) SCE values differ significantly among strains, 129/ReJ having the lowest and DBA/2 having the highest mean SCE per cell values. In general, the baseline SCE of a given F₁ is within the range of its corresponding parental strains or near the lower parental value. Furthermore, there is a genotype-dependent increase in mean SCEs per cell with CP dose. Strain differences in SCE induction are noted particularly at the two higher CP doses (4.50 and 45.0 mg/kg). In general, F₁ hybrids involving a strain with high induced SCEs and a strain with low induced SCEs exhibit mean SCE values that are closer to the value of the lower strain. F₁ s involving two strains with high SCEs or two strains with low SCEs yield SCEs not different from parental strains. The method of diallel cross analysis showed the order of dominance of these strains in SCE induction to be 129/ReJ BALB/c C3H/S DBA/2 C57BL/6J. These results support the involvement of predominantly nonadditive genetic factors as major gene(s) in SCE induction. In addition, involvement of random and independent events in SCE induction is suggested by the distribution of SCEs which follows a Poisson distribution.     

Thiophosphamide induction of sister chromatid exchanges at various phases in the cell cycle of a Chinese hamster cell culture]

Influence of three concentrations of thiophosphamide (thioTEPA) on the formation of sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) has been studied at different phases during 2 cell cycles in cultured Chinese hamster cells. It is shown that the frequency of SCE does not differ from the control level under the effect of the mutagen on cells in the G2 phase of the first cell cycle from the moment of harvesting. Thiophosphamide induces the same number of SCE at S, G1 stages of the first cell cycle and G2 of the second one till the moment of harvesting. The number of SCE correlates in a direct proportion with a concentration of thiophosphamide. A scheme of forming SCE is proposed.     

Caffeine induces sister-chromatid exchanges during the whole S-phase of the cell cycle

The capacity of caffeine to induce sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in different cell cycle stages and the proliferation kinetics were studied. Continuous treatment with this xanthine during the whole second cycle significantly increased the baseline SCE frequency. Pulse-treatment experiments showed that the induction of SCEs by caffeine, which was dose-dependent, was restricted to the S-phase of the cell cycle without effect on G1 or G2 cells. Moreover, unlike other SCE-inducing agents, such as DNA-synthesis inhibitors and DNA-damaging agents, caffeine produced similar SCE increases in cells treated at different times throughout the S-phase. In the light of Painter's model for SCE formation and the known effects of caffeine on the DNA replication pattern, the most likely mechanism of SCE induction by caffeine is an increase in the number of DNA-replication sites.     

Analysis of sister chromatid exchanges in lymphocytes cultured from 71 healthy men

Sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) were analyzed in peripheral blood lymphocytes from a select group of 71 healthy men, 56 nonsmokers and 15 cigarette smokers. In addition to estimating baseline SCE, data were examined to seek relationships of SCE frequencies to age and smoking. The baseline value of 7.53 SCE per cell from the 56 nonsmokers was within the range (5.60 to 9.10 SCE/cell) reported for other human populations. No relationship was found between the mean SCE frequency per cell and age. However, a significant increase in the SCE mean value was observed in smokers as compared to nonsmokers. The results of this study are compared with those of other reports on SCE effects of age and smoking.Abbreviations BUdR 5-bromo,2-deoxyuridine - SCE sister chromatid exchange     

Sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) induced by p-dichlorobenzene in cultured human lymphocytes

We have investigated the ability of p-dichlorobenzene (p-DCB) to induce sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) in cultured human lymphocytes. From our results we can conclude that p-DCB was able to induce a cytotoxic effect, measured as a decrease in third and second metaphases, together with an increase of SCEs.