Laser blepharoplasty with transconjunctival orbicularis muscle/septum tightening and periocular skin resurfacing: a safe and advantageous technique

Carbon dioxide (CO2) laser blepharoplasty with orbicularis oculi muscle tightening and periorbital skin resurfacing is a safe procedure that produces excellent aesthetic results and diminishes the occurrence of complications associated with skin and muscle resection in the lower lid, particularly permanent scleral show and ectropion. The authors present a review of 196 cases of carbon dioxide laser blepharoplasty and periocular laser skin resurfacing performed at their center from April of 1994 to September of 1998. Of these cases, 113 patients underwent four-lid blepharoplasty, 59 underwent upper lid blepharoplasty only, and 24 underwent lower lid blepharoplasty only. Prophylactic lateral canthopexy was performed in 24 patients. Concomitant procedures (brow lift/rhytidectomy/rhinoplasty) were performed in 92 patients. The carbon dioxide laser blepharoplasty procedure resulted in no injuries to the globe, cornea, or eyelashes. Combined with laser tightening of the orbicularis oculi muscle and septum and periocular skin resurfacing, the transconjunctival approach to lower blepharoplasty preserves lower lid skin and muscle. Elimination of the traditional scalpel skin/muscle flap procedure results in a dramatically lower complication rate, particularly with regard to permanent ectropion and scleral show. Laser shrinkage of the orbicularis muscle and septum through the transconjunctival incision enables the correction of muscle aging changes such as orbicularis hypertrophy and malar festoons. The addition of periocular resurfacing enables the correction of skin aging changes of the eyelid that are not addressed by traditional scalpel blepharoplasty. In addition, lateral canthopexy constitutes an important adjunct to the laser blepharoplasty procedure for the correction of lower lid canthal laxity.     

Repositioning the orbicularis oculi muscle in the composite rhytidectomy.

While blepharoplasties are routinely done with face lift procedures, the improvement is accomplished by removing excess orbital fat with eyelid skin and muscle along the incisional line. The orbicularis oculi muscle remains intact as its inferior border, which has become ptotic and redundant with aging, and actually remains in the same position following a conventional lower lid blepharoplasty and rhytidectomy. However, by elevating the orbicularis oculi with the cheek fat and platysma in a composite face lift flap, and by excising the redundant inferior border of the orbicularis muscle, a total rejuvenation of the malar area is accomplished. The descent of the orbicularis oculi muscle is in an inferolateral vector, whereas the vector of facial aging is inferomedial. Thus, repositioning the orbicularis oculi is in a superomedial vector and is obligatory in a composite rhytidectomy.     

Achieving aesthetic balance in the brow,eyelids, and midface

An approach to the brow, eyelids, and midface emphasizing release and advancement of the orbicularis oculi muscle, conservative removal of orbital fat, preservation of the nerve supply to the orbicularis oculi muscle, and avoidance of canthal division was evaluated in 100 consecutive patients. The technique describes the selected release of three key retaining ligaments to the forehead, brow, and upper eyelid; mobilization of the lateral retinaculum and division of the lower lid retaining ligament; and division of the midface malar retaining ligament (zygomatic-cutaneous ligament). Preservation of motor branches to the lower lid orbicularis is stressed. Of significance to this series of patients is the inclusion of 50 patients with morphologically prone lower eyelids defined as atonic lower lids, exorbitism, and/or negative vector orbits. Three sites had failure of brow fixation, two patients had midface asymmetry requiring revision, and three patients failed to have complete correction of their preoperative lower lid retraction. There was zero incidence of scleral show or lower lid retraction that was not present preoperatively. No patients required division of the lateral commissure with canthoplasty, taping or suture suspension, massage, or steroid injections. Only two patients required division of the deep head of the lateral canthus, and these patients were noted to have had lateral canthal malposition preoperatively.     

Transblepharoplasty endoscopic subperiosteal midface lift

The use of endoscopy in the transblepharoplasty midface lift is essential for preventing the complications of facial nerve injury and bleeding. Complete observation allows precise dissection and release of all structures in the composite flap. This technique fully preserves the zygo-orbicular nerve plexus and prevents denervation of the orbicularis oculi and zygomaticus muscles. Blind dissection has a significant probability of denervation of the entire zygo-orbital muscle complex, and avulsion of the zygomaticofacial vessels, with associated postoperative bleeding complications. The modification involving suturing of the "vest" of the combined lateral orbital periosteal and superficial layers of the deep temporal fascia over the elevated "pants" of the orbicularis periosteal flap provides very secure fixation for suspension of the lower eyelid and midface. The use of slowly absorbable polydioxanone sutures for this technique prevents the problems caused by permanent sutures beneath the very thin skin of the lateral canthal area. Careful trimming of the prominent roll of the orbicularis muscle that often develops with suspension eliminates the uneven contour and yields a smooth lower lid appearance. The details and modifications described should decrease the complications and morbidity that can occur with this procedure and provide for a more precise and reliable procedure for rejuvenation of the lower eyelid and midface.     

Lid margin reconstruction with an orbicularis oculi musculocutaneous advancement flap and a conchal cartilage graft

A simple method to reconstruct the midlateral lid margin defect is described using an orbicularis oculi musculocutaneous advancement flap and a free conchal cartilage graft. This method is easy to perform not only in the lower eyelid, but also in the upper one, provides a natural gray line and a stable lid margin without postoperative eversion, and substitutes for the Leone and van Gemert procedure.     

The use of conchal cartilage graft in involutional entropion

A simple and stable technique for repairing involutional entropion is described. Through a transconjunctival incision between the lower border of tarsus and the lower lid retractor, the eyelid is divided between the tarsus and the orbicularis oculi muscle into external and internal layers. The internal layer is moved upward until the eyelashes turn outward, and then through-and-through sutures are placed to fix it in this corrected state. The resultant defect between the lower end of the tarsus and the retractor is filled with a conchal cartilage graft. The raw surface of the cartilage is epithelialized from the surrounding mucosa within 1 to 2 weeks without shrinkage. This technique is more stable than any other technique that we have performed.     

The resection of orbicularis oculi muscle from the upper eyelid in experimental surgery on the monkey

The purpose of this study was to determine the maximum amount of orbicularis oculi muscle that may safely be resected from the upper eyelid without causing functional abnormalities. Measured amounts of that muscle were surgically excised from both upper eyelids in six cynomolgus monkeys. All the eyelids were photographed and videotaped at progressively increased intervals to permit the evaluation of wound healing, scarring, and function. Our preliminary results revealed that the excision of preseptal and partial supraorbital orbicularis oculi muscle, preseptal and complete supraorbital muscle, or pretarsal muscle only did not result in lagophthalmos. Complete resection of pretarsal, preseptal, and supraorbital orbicularis oculi did result in lagophthalmos but caused no corneal injury. The orbicularis oculi muscle in the cynomolgus monkey is similar to that in humans, but it is not yet clear whether our findings in the monkey are applicable in humans. A determination of the maximum amount of orbicularis oculi muscle that can safely be excised in humans would enable plastic surgeons to better understand and develop techniques for eyelid reconstruction and blepharoplasty.     

Surgical anatomy of the midcheek and malar mounds

The anatomy of the midcheek has not been satisfactorily described to adequately explain midcheek aging and malar mounds, nor has it suggested a logical approach to their correction or provided sufficient detail for safe surgery in this area. This cadaver study, which was complemented by many operative dissections, located a missing link: a glide plane space overlying the body of the zygoma. The space functions to allow mobility of the orbicularis oculi, where it overlies the zygoma and the origins of the elevator muscles to the upper lip. The space is a cleft between the sub-orbicularis oculi fat and the preperiosteal fat and is lined by a fine membrane. The anatomic boundaries are clearly defined by retaining ligaments, which correlate with the triangularity of the space. Several anatomic features provide the functional characteristics of the prezygomatic space, including the (1) absence of direct attachments between the orbicularis in the roof to the floor, (2) more rigid inferior boundary formed by the zygomatic ligaments, and (3) more mobile upper ligamentous boundary formed by the orbicularis retaining ligament (separating from the preseptal space of the lower lid). These components determine the characteristic aging changes that occur in this region and explain much about malar mounds. An appreciation of this anatomy has several surgical implications. The prezygomatic space is a junction area that can be approached from the temple, lower lid, and cheek. The zygomatic branches of the facial nerve to the orbicularis do not cross the space; rather, they course in the walls and in the sub-orbicularis fat within the roof of the space.     

A critical analysis of the current surgical concepts for lower blepharoplasty

This article discusses the new trends in lower blepharoplasty. Many different techniques have been described for the treatment of lower lid deformities, some favoring the transconjunctival approach that avoids touching the orbicularis oculi muscle, others recommending the muscle cutaneous flap. In some cases, maintenance of the fat is indicated, whereas in others its removal is recommended. To clarify such divergences, the author performed 100 blepharoplasties. The transconjunctival approach was performed with or without skin removal and with or without canthopexy, and the muscle cutaneous flap method was performed with or without fat removal and with or without canthopexy. The patients were followed up and observed for 6 months. The preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative periods were analyzed. The patient, the surgeon, and a third person evaluated the results. Preoperative and postoperative photographs illustrate this article.     

MACROSCOPIC OBSERVATIONS OF THE FACIAL MUSCLES IN THE BAIKAL SEAL (PHOCA SIBIRICA)

This study was performed to determine if, as expected, the enlarged eye of the Baikal seal ( Phoca sibirica ) has an influence on the form and function of the skull and facial muscles. Macroscopic observation of these muscles demonstrated that the M. orbicularis oculi expands around the palpebral fissure and that some facial muscles attach and insert in the M. orbicularis oculi , possibly supporting M. orbicularis oculi function. We suggest that these muscles move the eye and palpebral area and constitute a morphological and synergistic facial muscle complex system. Further, the development of the M. rectus lateralis around the sclera of the eye indicates that this muscle is also involved in eye movement.     

Intraoperative injection of botulinum toxin A into orbicularis oculi muscle for the treatment of crow's feet

The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the degree of efficacy of eliminating crow's feet by means of direct injection of botulinum toxin A into orbicularis oculi muscles under direct surgical vision during either blepharoplasty or face lift operations. Eighteen patients were injected with Botox A-14 in each orbicularis oculi muscle. Dilution was obtained by adding 4 ml of preservative-free saline to 100 IU of Botox A. Doses ranged from 15 to 50 IU in each muscle, varying according to the severity of wrinkles and intensity of muscle contraction. In 10 patients (56 percent), the Botox was injected throughout the outer surface of both orbicularis oculi dissected during a face-lift operation. In eight other patients (44 percent), the toxin was injected into the inner surface of both orbicularis oculi exposed during classic blepharoplasty procedures. Most authors have demonstrated that the effect produced by transcutaneous Botox lasts between 4 and 6 months; the paralysis obtained by direct muscular injection was effective for 9 months in 14 patients (78 percent) and 10 months in the other 4 patients (22 percent). Results were documented by means of preinjection and postinjection photographs, videotapes, and electromyographs. Neither local nor general adverse effects were noted. The improvement obtained in crow's feet was satisfactory to the patient and to us. The use of Botox intraoperatively permitted at the same time not only the treatment of crow's feet by paralysis of orbicularis oculi muscles but also the correction of senile changes in the lids and face by means of either blepharoplasty or face-lift operations.     

Severe ectropion: repair with a modified Tripier flap

Classical techniques, such as wedge resection, are well suited for mild cases of lower lid ectropion, but they often fail to cure severe cases. The reason these techniques often fail is because they address only the laxity and elongation of the ectropic lid, not the root cause. In nearly every case of severe ectropion, the root cause is importance of the pretarsal orbicularis muscle; i.e., there is inadequate muscle support for the pretarsal lower eyelid. A bipedicled musculocutaneous flap, transferred from the upper lid, was used to treat nine cases of severe lower eyelid ectropion. Eight patients had a good/excellent result. Four patients had electromyographic studies in the late postoperative period, without a single instance of even mild denervation. In cases of severe ectropion, this flap is an effective replacement for the missing skin and impotent muscle. It uses the often discarded blepharoplasty tissue, which has a perfect color and texture match. A single anatomic unit is rebuilt, transferring a strong new muscle strap with ideal supporting vectors and leaving scars in natural creases. This "blepharoplasty flap" may prove useful in other types of eyelid reconstruction.     

Selective myectomy for postparetic facial synkinesis

Synkinetic movements are secondary to facial palsy because they appear like a late sequela to spontaneously healing facial nerve injury. They are produced by an involuntary contraction of a muscle group simultaneous with contraction of other homologous muscle groups. The disorderly regeneration of severed axons is responsible for these movements. According to the Lippschitz theory, the regenerating nerve fibers sprout into the wrong peripheral branches. Between 1975 and 1986, 71 patients with facial paralysis were evaluated. Spontaneous recovery from the facial paralysis occurred in 28 of these patients; 14 (50 percent) developed synkinetic movements, and surgical treatment was sought by only 6 patients. In all patients, the lesion of the facial nerve was in the trunk, proximal to the principal ramification. The most frequent clinical finding was simultaneous activation between the orbicularis oculi and the elevators of the corner of the mouth (12 patients) or the elevators of the upper lip (2 patients). In 8 patients, in whom the slight synkinesis was not noticed by the patients, surgical correction was not necessary, but in the other 6 patients with severe aesthetic disturbances, surgical treatment for "disconnection" of the wrong impulses was realized. I obtained this "disconnection" through resection of the involved perioral muscle groups instead of paralysis of the orbicularis oculi. Follow-up of the 6 patients operated with the surgical treatment proposed herein for between 4 and 8 years has shown good aesthetic results without functional or aesthetic sequelae.     

New treatment for crow's feet wrinkles by vertical myectomy of the lateral orbicularis oculi

Crow's feet wrinkles are common complaints in patients looking for facial rejuvenation. This article describes a new technique for a lasting treatment by vertical myectomy of the lateral orbicularis oculi muscle. The author presents 20 cases surgically treated in the past 16 months. The results are very promising.     

Orbital response indicates nasal pungency: analysis of biomechanical strain on the skin

Stimulation of the human nasal passage with pungent vapor elicits motor responses in a zone around the eye. This investigation addressed whether quantification of such responses, particularly activity of the orbicularis oculi muscle, could yield a sensitive index of nasal pungency. We placed an array of small, high-contrast targets just beneath the lower eyelid and videotaped their movement to capture deformation of the skin atop the orbicularis oculi during 3 s stimulation with pungent concentrations of ethyl acetate. Eleven subjects participated. Analysis of the movements served to determine mechanical strain, which yielded a single index that we termed 'maximum strain'. This increased with concentration of the vapor and with time during and just after stimulation. Comparison with psychophysical data showed that the strain became evident at concentrations just detectable as pungent. Maximum strain measured on the skin shows promise as an objective index of pungency.     

Transblepharoplasty lower eyelid and midface rejuvenation: part I. Avoiding complications by utilizing lessons learned from the treatment of complications

Transblepharoplasty midface elevation has become a common aesthetic procedure in recent years. As new techniques have been utilized, complications have arisen. Management of these referred complications has resulted in the development of a technique that elevates the midface and restores the normal position and shape to the lower eyelid with minimal postoperative problems. Four principles must be followed to achieve satisfactory results. The orbicularis oculi/orbital septum bond must not be altered in midface surgery. The lateral canthus must be reattached to its normal anatomic location at the lateral orbital rim if there is lateral canthal tendon laxity. The orbital fat should be addressed via a transconjunctival approach, when necessary, to prevent middle lamella inflammation and orbital septum retraction. A suture at the inferior lateral orbital rim simulating the orbitomalar ligament, as well as orbicularis oculi muscle sutures, elevates the midface. Utilizing these steps, the midface and lower eyelid can be satisfactorily repositioned with minimal complications. This surgical approach can be utilized in all appropriate candidates but is especially useful in reoperative cosmetic surgery patients and the older patient population.     

The muscle-suspension lower blepharoplasty.

The muscle-suspension (or muscle sling) lower blepharoplasty is a technique that can be used to some extent for all lower lids in which tightening and smoothing is desired. It seems to provide an extra degree of support by counteracting the natural tendency of gravity to produce scleral show or ectropion when the lid skin is tightened. It consists of anchoring a sling of orbicularis muscle to the periosteum of the lateral orbital rim, with an upward and lateral pull--while the skin is pulled in a more medial or upward direction.     

Composite rhytidectomy.

Signs of aging in the face reflect the change in position of deep anatomic elements, which are the platysma muscle, cheek fat, and the orbicularis oculi muscle. These changes occur from progressive ptosis of these elements, which continue to keep their intimate relationship with each other throughout the aging process. Conventional face lift procedures disrupt this normal relationship by separating the skin from these elements. All SMAS techniques reposition only the platysma muscle without repositioning the cheek fat and orbicularis muscle. This composite rhytidectomy allows elevation of a composite musculocutaneous flap containing all three elements for repositioning while maintaining their intimate relationship with each other and with the skin. One-hundred and sixty-seven composite rhytidectomies have been done with impressive results and minimal complications.     

The utilization of EMG biofeedback for the treatment of periorbital facial muscle tension

A case is presented of EMG feedback for reduction of tension in the orbicularis oculi muscle of both eyes. Feedback was provided for reduced firing of the upper and lower segments of the muscle. Within 25 sessions for the left eye and 20 sessions for the right, muscle output was markedly reduced from baseline and the patient reported no longer experiencing discomforting sensations of tightness. Follow-up of the patient 3 months posttreatment revealed that the initial problem of muscle tension no longer existed.The author is indebted to Charles H. Fitzpatrick, D.O., for his consultative services, to Augusta Alba, M.D., for her valuable critique and suggestions, and to John Mirone for his statistical services.