Limiting dilution analysis of alloreactive cytotoxic precursor cells in aging mice

The quantitative minimal estimate of the frequency of alloantigen specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor cells (CTL-p) was determined in young and old C57BL/6 mice by limiting dilution analysis. Supernatant from phorbol myristate acetate-induced EL-4 cells was used as a source of IL 2 in these assays, which therefore were independent of the presence of the Lyt-2-, IL 2-producing cells known to be deficient in aging mice. These studies showed that 24-mo-old mice had approximately 10-fold fewer CTL-p than their young counterparts. Comparison of the limiting dilution assay (LDA) with IL 2-supplemented primary MLC shows that estimates of the frequency of CTL-p do not consistently agree with cytotoxic activity detected in the higher cell density primary MLC, and that the LDA is most likely a better estimate of the effect of age on the development of CTL.     

Limiting dilution analysis of the stem cells for T cell lineage

Stem cell activities of bone marrow, spleen, thymus, and fetal liver cells for T cell lineage were studied comparatively by transferring the cells from these organs through i.v. or intrathymus (i.t.) route into right leg- and tail-shielded (L-T-shielded) and 900 R-irradiated recipient mice, which were able to survive without supplying hemopoietic stem cells. Cells from B10.Thy-1.1 (H-2b, Thy-1.1) mice were serially diluted and were transferred into L-T-shielded and irradiated C57BL/6 (H-2b, Thy-1.2) mice, and 21 days later the thymus cells of recipient mice were assayed for Thy-1.1+ cells by flow cytofluorometry. The percentage of recipient mice possessing donor-type T cells was plotted against the number of cells transferred, and the stem cell activity in each cell source was expressed as the 50% positive value, the number of donor cells required for generating donor-type T cells in the thymuses of 50% of recipient mice. In i.v. transfer experiments, the activity of bone marrow cells was similar to that of fetal liver cells, and about 100 times and nearly 1000 times higher than those of spleen cells and thymus cells, respectively. In i.t. transfer experiments, the number of cells required for generating donor-type T cells was much lower than that in i.v. transfer experiments, although the ratio in 50% positive values between i.v. and i.t. transfers differed among cell sources. In i.t. transfers, the 50% positive value of bone marrow cells was five times, 400 times, and 500 times higher than that of fetal liver cells, spleen cells, and thymus cells, respectively. Our previous finding that stem cells are enriched in the spleens of mice which were whole body-irradiated and marrow-reconstituted 7 days earlier was confirmed also by the present limiting dilution assay carried out in i.v. as well as i.t. transfers.     

Hyperthermia and the generation and activity of murine influenza-immune cytotoxic T cells in vitro.

The rate of generation of murine secondary influenza virus-immune cytotoxic T cells in vitro is enhanced under limiting dilution conditions at hyperthermal temperatures (39 versus 37 degrees C). Increased mean values of cytotoxic activity were observed in the presence as well as absence of exogenous helper factors. Elevated cytotoxic activity at 39 degrees C was observed after day 3 to day 5 of culture. The number of autoreactive cytotoxic cells observed was not greater at 39 degrees C than at 37 degrees C. Elevated temperature did not influence target cell lysis or release of isotopes from killed target cells. The results are discussed with a view to the role of fever in augmenting the cellular immune response responsible for the host defense against primary viral infection.     

Virus specificity of human influenza virus-immune cytotoxic T cells.

The virus specificity of human in vitro cytotoxic T cell responses to influenza virus was studied with the use of peripheral blood mononuclear leukocytes from normal adult volunteers. Previous natural exposure of these donors to a variety of type A influenza viruses was documented by HI antibody titers. Cells sensitized in vitro with A/HK or A/PR8 were cytotoxic for autologous target cells infected with A/HK, A/PR8, or A/JAP 305 type A influenza viruses, but not for B/HK-infected or uninfected cells. B/HK-sensitized effector cells lysed target cells infected with B/HK but not targets infected with type A viruses. A/HK- and A/PR8-immune effector populations were shown to recognize cross-reactive antigens on A/HK- and A/PR8-infected target cells by cold target competition. Influenza-immune effector cells were cytotoxic for virus-infected autologous targets but much less so for virus-infected allogeneic targets. This self-restriction suggested that the cytotoxicity was largely T cell-mediated and was confirmed by cell separation analysis. Thus, the human secondary cytotoxic T cell response in vitro to influenza viruses is predominantly directed against cross-reactive determinants on cells infected with serologically distinct type A influenza viruses.     

Limiting dilution analysis of Epstein-Barr virus-induced immunoglobulin production

The major goal of this work is to establish a culture system for the growth of human B lymphocytes at the single-cell level so that the immunoglobulin secreted by the clonal progeny of that cell can be analyzed. A method which involves culturing small numbers (1–1000) of lymphocytes, which have been infected with Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) prior to plating, in round-bottom microtiter plates is described. A feeder layer of irradiated (2500 R) umbilical cord blood lymphocytes to which phytohemagglutinin has been added was found to be optimal. Culture supernatants collected from 3 to 6 weeks postinfection are assayed for the production of IgG and IgM by radioimmunoassay in order to determine the overall cloning efficiency of the system. We have shown that up to 33% of surface Ig-positive cells produce detectable clones in this system. Umbilical cord blood cells are superior to T-cell and macrophage cell lines as feeder layers. Furthermore, culture supernatants from phytohemagglutinin-stimulated umbilical cord lymphocytes do not adequately replace these cells. We also observed that while most IgM-secreting clones continued to produce immunoglobulin during the 7-week time period analyzed, the majority of IgG-secreting clones had a relatively short half-life in vitro. This culture system allows us to examine a significant proportion of the human B-cell population and carry out studies on the frequency of specific antibody- and isotype-producing clones.     

Differential distribution of antigen-specific helper T cells and cytotoxic T cells after antigenic stimulation in vivo. A functional study using limiting dilution analysis

We have developed modified limiting dilution analysis (LDA) techniques that distinguish in vivo Ag-stimulated murine helper T lymphocytes (HTL) and CTL from unstimulated precursor T cells, even those with the same Ag specificity. We refer to these cells that are detectable in the modified LDA as "Ag-conditioned" T cells (cHTL and cCTL). We have used the modified LDA techniques in conjunction with conventional LDA techniques (which enumerate all Ag-specific T cells) to evaluate the in vivo distribution of Ag-conditioned cHTL and cCTL following in vivo sensitization to alloantigens via sponge matrix or skin allografts. In general, we observed the following regarding the distribution of cHTL and cCTL: 1) Ag-conditioned HTL and CTL were detectable only after in vivo sensitization with alloantigen: 2) not all Ag-reactive T cells became conditioned T cells after in vivo Ag deposition; 3) the percentage of Ag-reactive T cells that converted to conditioned T cells after Ag deposition varied among different lymphoid compartments; 4) a high percentage of cHTL, but a low percentage of cCTL, accumulated in regional lymph nodes and spleen; 5) cHTL accumulated in peripheral blood, whereas cCTL did not; 6) Ag-conditioned cHTL were detectable in various lymphoid tissues for greater than 60 days following Ag deposition, whereas cCTL were detectable for only 14 to 20 days; and 7) unlike the other lymphoid sites, the site of Ag deposition accumulated a high percentage of both Ag-stimulated cHTL and cCTL. Furthermore, cHTL and cCTL appeared to reside in phenotypically distinct T cell subsets in that in vivo treatment with anti-L3T4 mAb abrogated the accumulation of HTL, but not CTL, at the site of Ag deposition. These data demonstrate differential compartmentalization of Ag-conditioned cHTL and cCTL subsequent to in vivo Ag deposition. The implications of these findings regarding the monitoring of in vivo immune responses are discussed.     

Limiting dilution analysis of CD45Rhi and CD45Rlo T cells: further evidence that CD45Rlo cells are memory cells

Murine CD4+ T cells can be separated into two distinct populations on the basis of their levels of expression of the CD45RB antigen (CD45Rhi and CD45Rlo). Murine CD45Rlo cells arise from CD45Rhi cells after antigenic exposure and provide antigen-specific help to B cells in a secondary immune response. In the present study, the ability of CD45Rhi and CD45Rlo cells to proliferate in response to either soluble antigen or allogeneic cells was examined by limiting dilution analysis. CD45Rhi cells were the major responding cells in unprimed animals; priming caused a large increase in the frequencies of responding CD45Rlo cells and this increase was evident 11 months later. These results further support the notion that CD4+ CD45Rlo cells are long-term memory cells.     

Limiting dilution analysis of TNF producing cells in C3H/HeJ mice

A limiting dilution assay (LDA) that measures the frequency of TNF producing cells is described. LDA determination is based on the inhibition of growth of a highly TNF sensitive subline from the WEHI-164 fibrosarcoma by using a micro assay sensitive to single picogram amounts of recombinant murine TNF. Using such LDA, it was determined that the reported deficiency in LPS-induced TNF production in C3H/HeJ mice is a function of reduced frequency of TNF producing cells rather than a complete lack of responsiveness. In bulk culture, LPS-triggered TNF was produced by Thy-1.2 negative spleen cells with activity recovered in both G10 Sephadex adherent and nonadherent subpopulations. LPS stimulation of spleen cells from C3H/HeJ mice resulted in TNF mRNA expression as shown in both Northern blots and in situ hybridization. The frequency of TNF mRNA bearing cells in control of C3H/HeSnJ mice by in situ hybridization correlated with that found for TNF producing cells in LDA. In C3H/HeJ spleen, significantly higher numbers of TNF mRNA positive cells were found than were shown to produce TNF in LDA.     

Limiting dilution analysis of alloantigen-reactive T lymphocytes. IV. High frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursor cells in MLC blasts separated by velocity sedimentation

A sensitive limiting dilution microculture system was used to obtain minimal estimates of the frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursor cells (CTL-P) directed against DBA/2 alloantigens, after priming of spleen cells in unidirectional mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC, C57BL/6 anti-DBA/2). The mean CTL-P frequency in day 4 to 5 MLC populations was found to be approximately 50- to 100-fold greater than the frequency in normal spleen, and up to 25% of the cells present in such MLC could be identified operationally as CTL-P. Even higher frequencies (up to 50%) of CTL-P were obtained in a population of large-sized cells separated from day 4 MLC by velocity sedimentation. Furthermore, since a strikingly quantitative correlation was observed between CTL activity and CTL-P frequency in such separated MLC populations, it is likely that mature CTL in MLC are not end cells, but can further proliferate and thus behave operationally as CTL-P.     

Time course analysis of regulation of cytotoxic T cells

The frequency of cytotoxic T-cell precursors (T(K] was determined in spleen cells (SC) of naive mice and after subcutaneous (sc) or intravenous (iv) priming with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-haptenized syngeneic thymocytes by limiting dilution (LD) analysis in cultures containing exogenous interleukin 2 (IL-2). The frequency of TNP-specific T(K) (T(K)TNP) was found to be 1/4500 +/- 1097 in SC of naive mice. After treatment, the frequency of T(K)TNP increased up to threefold. An evaluation of regulatory elements (helper and suppressor T cells) (TH, TS) was possible by comparing SC from naive and primed animals after prolonged in vitro culture periods in the absence of exogenous IL-2. The experiments indicated that after 7 days of culture, activation of T(K) was limited by the supply of help. After 2-3 weeks of culture, sufficient help was available, especially in SC populations of primed mice, i.e., priming resulted in activation of the helper compartment with gradual differences depending on the route of priming (sc priming was more efficient than iv priming). But, after prolonged culture periods, cytotoxic activity was counterregulated by TS in naive and primed animals. While sc priming was a minor influence on the suppressor compartment, iv priming led to activation and numerical increase of TS. Finally, the activation status of effector and regulatory cells was tested at various times after antigenic stimulation. Four to five weeks after in vivo priming the system was found to move back into a status similar to that of naive mice, except that a small population of "nonsuppressible" T(K) appeared.     

Limiting dilution analysis of alloantigen-reactive T lymphocytes. III. Effect of priming on precursor frequencies.

The effect of specific priming with alloantigens on the frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) has been investigated. Alloimmune lymphoid cells were obtained from the spleen of C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice primed with DBA/2 (H-2d) tumor cells or from 14-day unidirectional mixed leukocyte cultures (C57BL/6 anti-DBA/2). CTL-P frequencies directed against H-2d alloantigens were estimated by limiting dilution analysis in a sensitive micro MLC system. Under these conditions, an apparent increase of 3 to 4-fold in CTL-P frequency was observed in alloimmune (as compared with normal) C57BL/6 spleen cells. Evidence was obtained suggesting that this increase was specific for the priming alloantigens. A much greater increase in CTL-P frequency (25 to 100-fold) was observed after alloimmunization of C57BL/6 spleen cells in unidirectional MLC. Under the latter conditions, 5 to 20% of the surviving splenic MLC cells could be identified operationally as CTL-P. A similar enrichment in CTL-P frequency was obtained when lymph node, peripheral blood, or thymus cells were cultured for 14 days in MLC. These studies provide direct evidence that the pool of specific CTL-P can be expanded after alloimmunization. Furthermore, the very high frequencies observed after in vitro priming indicate that this system should be particularly useful for future studies of the progeny of individual CTL-P.     

Studies on T helper cells and the specificity of their soluble products for induction of cytotoxic T cells directed against trinitrophenyl-modified self

The role of T helper cells (Th) and their soluble products in the generation of a cytotoxic T-cell (CTL) response of thymocytes to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified syngeneic cells was investigated. The Th have a Thy 1⁺ Lyt 1⁺2^? surface phenotype, and produce at least two soluble helper factors. Production of factors requires stimulation of primed Th by specific antigen (self-TNP), and depends on a Thy 1⁺ Lyt 1⁺2^? cell. Factors present in supernatants after 5 hr of stimulation act preferentially on antiallogeneic precursor CTL (pCTL); factors present at 24 hr act preferentially on self-TNP-specific pCTL with a variable activity for alloantigen-specific pCTL. These results are interpreted as suggesting a possible role for helper factors having selective action in generation of CTL responses.     

Loss of specificity in cytolytic T lymphocyte clones obtained by limit dilution culture of Ly-2+ T cells

Nonspecific cytotoxicity developed reproducibly and with high frequency in limit dilution cultures consisting of low numbers of murine cells stimulated with concanavalin A in the presence of growth factors and irradiated filler cells. The individual clones in cultures showing nonspecific killing were all derived from single, Thy-1+, Ly-2+ cells. At early times of culture (day 5 or 6), clones appeared to be specific in their lytic activity, as expected of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL). On continued culture (day 8 or 9), most of the originally specific CTL clones became nonspecific, killing a range of murine target cells, both syngeneic and allogeneic. The lack of specificity was observed at all effector cell doses. The effector cells responsible for the nonspecific cytolysis were Thy-1+ and Ly-2+, as were most cells in the cultures. The effector cells had the normal DNA content for a dividing T cell population, and most cells in the cultures had a normal chromosome complement. In mixed cultures in which the responder cells and the irradiated filler cells were from different mouse strains, the nonspecific killers displayed the Thy-1 and H-2 allotypes of the responder, and not of the filler cells. The development of a broad cytotoxic potential appears to be a normal and rapid event when Ly-2+ T cell-derived CTL-clones are grown under these conditions; this is a caveat for the use of limit dilution cultures to determine the T cell specificity repertoire. The relationship between these nonspecific CTL, activated lymphocyte killers, and natural killer cells is discussed.     

Limiting dilution analysis of T helper cell heterogeneity: a single class of T cell makes both IL 2 and IL 3

We have previously described a limiting dilution assay (LDA) for estimating the frequency, in the spleens of unprimed mice, of alloantigen-responsive cells that, together with their immediate clonal progeny, can produce interleukin 2 (IL 2) in short-term culture. In this paper, we provide further evidence that the limiting cell in these cultures is, in fact, the immediate precursor of the IL 2-producing cell rather than merely a participant in a multicellular cascade that ultimately leads to production of this lymphokine. We also demonstrate the usefulness of the LDA method for estimating the frequency of the limiting cell for production of IL 3. By analyzing the supernatants of these short-term microcultures for both IL 2 and IL 3, we show that essentially all wells that produce IL 3 also produce IL 2. Furthermore, the amount of IL 2 produced in any individual well correlates strongly with the IL 3 production in the same well. Our data suggest that both these lymphokines are produced by a single class of T cell, and further that the regulatory events that control IL 2 generation in allostimulated helper cells act to control IL 3 levels in parallel.     

Persistence of donor-specific IL-2-secreting cells and cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors in human kidney transplant recipients evidenced by limiting dilution analysis

The low reactivity to donor alloantigens reported in PBL from kidney transplant recipients might be related to clonal deletion and/or suppression of donor-specific alloreactive cells. To discriminate between these two hypotheses, we quantified the number of IL-2 secreting cells (IL-2-SC) and of cytotoxic precursors (CTLp) in the T cells from tolerant recipients when stimulated with either donor specific or nonrelated third-party LCL. To eliminate the irrelevant reactivity, we used as responding cells high-density T cells that had been depleted of such reactivity by 4 days preculture with autologous lymphoblastoid cell line in the presence of bromodeoxyuridine. Thus, frequencies of IL-2-SC and CTLp specifically directed at alloantigens could be measured. In 11 recipients, there was no strong decrease in the frequency of donor-reactive T cells when compared to the frequency of those directed at a third-party lymphoblastoid cell line, either for IL-2-SC (tested in 11 patients) or for CTLp (tested in 6 patients). In three cases of seven, a suppression was observed only when T cells were stimulated by donor cells. These data suggest that donor-reactive cells are still present in PBL of kidney-transplant recipients tested from 6 mo to 4 y posttransplantation. Moreover, suppression of donor-specific cells can be demonstrated in peripheral T cells of some recipients, which may account in part for the absence of rejection.     

Progenitors of oligodendrocytes: Limiting dilution analysis in fetal rat brain culture

In this paper, we describe the use of a combination of cell culture techniques and limiting dilution analysis to determine the number of oligodendrocyte progenitor cells and the oligodendrocyte clone size in primary dispersed cultures of 20- to 21-day-old fetal rat brain. Single-cell suspensions (1,2,3 × 10⁶ cells/ml) were plated in either microwell or 100 mm dishes. After 22 days in culture the number of differentiated oligodendrocytes was ascertained by determining the amount of myelin basic protein by radioimmunoassay. The total amount of myelin basic protein was the same in the two types of dish, indicating that proliferation and differentiation were unaffected when oligodendrocytes were grown in microwells. The fraction (F₀) of microwells containing no oligodendrocytes was determined at each cell dilution. F₀ decreased exponentially with increasing total cell concentration. The linearity of the plot of ln F₀ versus cell number indicates that the number of oligodendrocyte progenitor cells is limiting. From the equation describing the Poisson distribution of progenitor cells in microwells we calculated that, at the time of plating, primary cultures of fetal rat brain contain one oligodendrocyte progenitor cell per 1.3 × 10⁵ brain cells, or a total population of 300–500 progenitor cells per brain. The mean oligodendrocyte clone size was determined to be approximately 825 at 22 days and close to 2000 by 35 days in culture. Therefore, each progenitor cell must undergo approximately 11 divisions, on the average, during postnatal development.     

Fine specificity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes directed againstH-2L d

The fine specificity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) directed againstH-2L ^d was analyzed by studying the lytic activity of BALB/cH- 2^dm2 (H-2L ^d loss mutant) anti-BALB/c-H-2 ^d CTL, generated in secondary mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) against a panel of target cells of differentH-2 haplotypes. Target cells of allH-2 haplotypes tested, except that of the MLC responder, were lysed by anti-L^d CTL, although to a widely varying extent. The genes coding for antigens detected by anti-L ^d CTL were mapped to distinct regions in theH-2 ^d ,H- 2^dm1,H-2 ^q ,H-2 ^k , andH-2 ^b haplotypes. The sequence of lysis intensity against the variousH-2 haplotypes and theH-2 regions involved were as follows:L ^d ,D ^q L ^q ,D ^dm1 L^dm1,K ^k ,D ^b L ^b ,r, p, f, s, C3H.OH (K ^d D ^k L ^k ), strong lysis occurring againstL ^d and weak lysis againstH-2 ^s and C3H.OH.By monolayer adsorption and cold target inhibition experiments, it was shown that anti-L ^d CTL contained a CTL subset directed against a private L^d specificity, hitherto undetected by anti-L ^d antibodies. This subset of CTL was separate from the CTL subsets reacting againstH-2 ^q and against the mutant haplotypeH- 2^dm1. The reactions against the latter two haplotypes were also mediated by separate CTL subsets. It is concluded that the L^d molecule, to a varying extent, shares target antigens for CTL with K- and/or D-end H-2 molecules of all haplotypes tested. These antigens are detected by multiple subsets of anti-L ^d CTL. One CTL subset is directed against a target structure unique forL ^d (L^d private specificity).     

In vitro immunization to KLH. II. Limiting dilution analysis of antigen-reactive cells in primary and secondary culture

Limiting dilution analysis was used to estimate the frequency of human peripheral blood T lymphocytes that proliferate in response to in vitro immunization with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH). Antigen-reactive cells (ARC) were estimated 9 days after primary immunization with KLH. The ARC frequency of lymphocytes from 12 subjects ranged from 1:23,800 to 1:52,631. Lymphocytes from five of these subjects were also primed for 12 days with KLH, rechallenged in secondary culture with fresh adherent cells and KLH, and assayed 4 days later. The ARC frequency increased to 1:1,123 to 1:7,247, indicating that T cell clones responsive to KLH had expanded during primary culture. In addition, we observed that the proliferative response of lymphocytes from 5 of the 12 subjects were inhibited at high cell concentrations. Depletion of OKT8+ T cells before culturing with KLH however did not alter the inhibitory effect of high concentrations of T cells.