The feasibility of producing inbred rather than F1 hybrid cultivars in Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera): an assessment of recombinant inbred lines

Results are presented for the performance of improved inbred lines of Brussels sprouts grown in replicated and fully guarded plots. Some lines were identified which out-performed the reference F₁ hybrid, Gower, for the yield of marketable sprouts and for sprout quality. No lines were found which were superior for both of these traits. These results support earlier contentions that inbred line performance in Brussels sprouts could be improved to levels comparable with those of commercial F₁ hybrids. The genetic gains required to achieve commercial parity with hybrids for all agronomically important traits continue to be large. Therefore, the use of inbred lines as commercial cultivars can only be viewed as a long term objective. Previous studies have identified additive x additive epistasis and the segregation of many loci as important factors limiting the genetic gains to be expected from a single cycle of crossing and inbreeding. In addition to these factors the current study identifies areas of difficulty encountered when attempting to screen and select large numbers of inbred lines, produced either by single seed descent or by anther culture, in a single season. Evidence is presented which suggests that imperfect visual selection and/or genotype × seasonal interactions may substantially reduce the efficiency of selections based upon a single trial of very many unreplicated lines.     

A comparison of inbred lines derived by doubled haploidy and single seed descent in spring barley (Hordeum vulgare)

Samples of F_x inbred lines, derived by doubled haploidy (DH) and single seed descent (SSD) from five spring barley crosses were compared for agronomic characters. It was shown that, over this range of diverse crosses, inbreds derived by either technique could surpass the better parent or even the heterotic F₁. The means of the DH and SSD were, however, different for a number of characters, as well as differing from the mid-parent value. It was concluded that these differences stemmed from the presence of interacting genes showing linkage disequilibrium, although there was no unambiguous test to distinguish this from differential survival during the production of inbreds. This view was further supported by the finding that the DH sample, which tends to preserve existing linkages, produced a higher proportion of lines exceeding the better scoring parent when compared with the SSD population.     

Comparison of bread wheat lines selected by doubled haploid, single-seed descent and pedigree selection methods

 Yield performance of each group of ten spring bread wheat lines selected by doubled haploid (DH), single-seed descent (SSD) and pedigree selection (PS) methods from three F₁ crosses was compared with the aim of evaluating the DH method in breeding programs. Populations of 65–97 DH lines and 110 SSD lines per cross were used for selection. PS lines were developed by repeated selections from 1500 F₂ plants. Yield evaluation was performed at the F₆ generation of SSD and PS lines along with DH lines in a 2-year field experiment. It took only 2 years from the planting of wheat materials for DH production to the planting of selected DH lines for yield evaluation. There was no significant difference in grain yield between DH lines and PS lines selected from an F₁ cross whose parental varieties were closely related in their pedigrees. In two crosses with low coefficients of parentage and a large variation in their progenies, grain yield of selected DH lines was significantly lower than those of selected SSD and PS lines. These results confirm that the DH method can save time in obtaining recombinant inbred lines ready for yield evaluation. However, a larger DH population is required to achieve the same level of genetic advance with the PS method in crosses containing greater genetic variation. Received: 23 December 1997 / Accepted: 12 March 1998     

The feasibility of producing inbred rather than F1 hybrid cultivars in Brussels sprouts: a preliminary genetical analysis and choice of material for inbreeding

The feasibility of producing commercially acceptable inbred lines of Brussels sprouts is investigated. Two experiments are described which examined the nature and extent of heterosis in this crop using the techniques of biometrical genetics. They indicate incomplete dominance for several production traits, lower F₁ uniformity and the presence of inbreds that outyield some F₁'s. These results strongly suggest that recombinant inbred lines, possibly outyielding the better F₁'s could be produced. Five crosses were identified for inbreeding by SSD and 1000 lines are being produced from each. The principles upon which these crosses were identified are described.     

Genetic variability and advance under four selection procedures in wheat pedigree breeding programme

Summary Four methods of generation advance (SPS, SSD, BP and MMS) were compared in F₃ and F₄ generations. In the F₃ generation, the SPS and SSD methods of generation advance proved superior to the BP and MMS methods for grain yield per plant and for at least one of the yield component traits. The F₃ SSD population did not differ significantly from the F₃ SPS for any of the traits. However, the F₃ SSD population retained more range and cv for different traits than with other methods of generation advance. F₄ progenies derived from F₃ SSD population were significantly superior for grain yield than lines derived from the other three F₃ populations. The MMS method of generation advance proved useful for increasing the 1,000-grain weight for which initial selection was made.Part of Ph.D. Thesis submitted by senior author to Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar     

Genetic mapping of QTLs conditioning soybean sprout yield and quality

Soybean sprouts have been used as a food in the Orient since ancient times. In this study, 92 restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) loci and two morphological markers (W1 and T) were used to identify quantitative trait loci (QTLs) associated with soybean sprout-related traits in 100 F₂-derived lines from the cross of ’Pureunkong’×’Jinpumkong 2’. The genetic map consisted of 76 loci which covered about 756 cM and converged into 20 linkage groups. Eighteen markers remained unlinked. Phenotypic data were collected in 1996 and 1997 for hypocotyl length, percentage of abnormal seedlings, and sprout yield 6 days after germination at 20°C. Hypocotyl length was determined as the average length from the point of initiation of the first secondary root to the point of attachment of the cotyledons. The number of decayed seeds and seedlings, plus the number of stunted seedlings (less than 2-cm growth), was recorded a s abnormal seedlings. Seed weight was determined based on the 50-seed sample. Sprout yield was recorded as the total fresh weight of soybean sprouts produced from the 50-seed sample divided by the dry weight of the 50-seed sample. Four QTLs were associated with sprout yield in the combined analysis across 2 years. For the QTL linked to L154 on the Linkage Group (LG) G the positive allele was derived from Pureunkong (R ² = 0.19), whereas at the other three QTLs (A089 on LG B1, A668n on LG K and B046 on LG L) the positive alleles were from Jinpumkong 2. QTLs conditioning seed weight were linked to markers A802n (LG B1), A069 (LG E), Cr321 (LG F) and A235 (LG G). At these four markers, the Jinpumkong allele increased seed weight. Markers K011n on LG B1, W1 on LG F and A757 on LG L were linked to QTLs conditioning hypocotyl length; and Bng119, K455n and K418n to QTLs conditioning the abnormal seedlings. The QTLs conditioning sprout yield were in the same genomic locations as the QTLs for seed weight identified in this population or from previously published research, indicating that QTLs for sprout yield are genetically linked to seed-weight QTLs or else that seed-weight QTLs pleiotropically condition sprout yield. These data demonstrate that effective marker-assisted selection may be feasible for enhancing sprout yield in a soybean. The transgressive segregation of sprout yield, as well as the existence of two QTLs conditioning greater than 10% of the phenotypic variation in sprout yields provides an opportunity to select for progeny lines with a greater sprout yield than currently preferred cultivars such as Pureunkong. Received: 23 August 2000 / Accepted: 23 January 2001     

Performance of recombinant inbred lines in Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera)

Summary Performance of a random array of recombinant inbred lines derived by single seed descent from five different source populations of Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera) is presented. A total of 2,356 lines were tested in trials during 1985 and 1986. Three of the source populations were derived from double crosses between F₁ hybrids. These hybrids show a considerable heterotic advantage over their inbred parents for the most important agronomic traits. The recombinant inbred lines performed, on average, less well than the parental inbred material, indicating that additive x additive genie interactions may make a significant contribution to the performance of current inbred material. Nevertheless, the very large variation among the recombinant inbred lines permitted many lines to be identified which outperformed the best parental inbred for all traits. Two lines outperformed the reference F₁ hybrid, Gower, for an index that included marketable yield and quality. Consideration was also given to the dangers of misinterpreting phenotypically based proportions. Accordingly, response equations were used to ascertain the real genetic progress that was made. Advance seemed small when compared with the large heterotic effect, which is consistent with the segregation of a large number of loci. The distribution of the recombinant inbred lines was compared to predictions made from early generation trials. There was broad agreement but significant discrepancies existed which, it is suggested, may arise from the effects of genotype-environment interactions.     

Improvement of Rice Biomass Yield through QTL-Based Selection

Biomass yield of rice (Oryza sativa L.) is an important breeding target, yet it is not easy to improve because the trait is complex and phenotyping is laborious. Using progeny derived from a cross between two high-yielding Japanese cultivars, we evaluated whether quantitative trait locus (QTL)-based selection can improve biomass yield. As a measure of biomass yield, we used plant weight (aboveground parts only), which included grain weight and stem and leaf weight. We measured these and related traits in recombinant inbred lines. Phenotypic values for these traits showed a continuous distribution with transgressive segregation, suggesting that selection can affect plant weight in the progeny. Four significant QTLs were mapped for plant weight, three for grain weight, and five for stem and leaf weight (at α = 0.05); some of them overlapped. Multiple regression analysis showed that about 43% of the phenotypic variance of plant weight was significantly explained (P < 0.0001) by six of the QTLs. From F₂ plants derived from the same parental cross as the recombinant inbred lines, we divergently selected lines that carried alleles with positive or negative additive effects at these QTLs, and performed successive selfing. In the resulting F₆ lines and parents, plant weight significantly differed among the genotypes (at α = 0.05). These results demonstrate that QTL-based selection is effective in improving rice biomass yield.     

Prediction of the performance of inbred lines derived from a population cross in autumn-sown onions (Allium cepa L.)

Summary A design and model are presented to allow the prediction, in early generations, of the mean and distribution of recombinant inbred lines derived from a cross between two parental populations or partially inbred lines. The procedure has been tested in autumn-sown onions (in the UK) using a wide cross between the openpollinated Japanese cultivar, Senshyu, and a partially inbred line derived from the European cultivar, Rawska. The early generations used for prediction included the first self-pollinated generation of the two parental populations and the F₃ generation produced from the hybrid population. The predictions were tested by reference to the field performance of a random array of inbred lines, which were produced by single-seed descent (SSD) and had been selfed for three generations. The early generations, used for prediction, and a sample of SSD lines were raised alongside each other in each of two seasons. Within each season, good agreement was found between the predicted and observed performance of the recombinant inbred lines for three characters — yield, quality and maturity. This is used as evidence of the validity of the genetical model and the assumptions made. The effects of genotype x environment interactions prevented predictions made in one season being reliably applied to those made in the other and, therefore, reduce the attraction of this type of prediction study to the plant breeder.     

Genotype-environment interaction effects on reproductive performance in Tribolium castaneum

Summary The genetical expectations of the means, variances and covariances of populations of doubled haploid lines derived from f₁, F₂, F₃ and intermated F₂ (S₃) generations are presented. These expectations are identical, regardless of genetical architecture, providing there is no linkage disequilibrium. In the presence of linkage disequilibrium differences will occur whose magnitude and direction will depend on the degree of disequilibrium, recombination frequency and the presence or absence of epistasis.Data from an experiment to detect linkage disequilibrium in a cross between two spring barley varieties are presented. This involved a comparison of means, variances and covariances of doubled haploid populations derived from the F₁ and F₂ generations using the H. bulbosum system. Linkage disequilibrium was detected for important agronomic characters and the effect of this disequilibrium on the choice of generation for doubled haploid production is discussed.     

Quantitative trait loci for grain moisture at harvest and field grain drying rate in maize (Zea mays, L.)

Hybrids with low grain moisture (GM) at harvest are specially required in mid- to short-season environments. One of the most important factors determining this trait is field grain drying rate (FDR). To produce hybrids with low GM at harvest, inbred lines can be obtained through selection for either GM or FDR. Thus, a single-cross population (181 F _2:3-generation plants) of two divergent inbred lines was evaluated to locate QTL affecting GM at harvest and FDR as a starting point for marker assisted selection (MAS). Moisture measurements were made with a hand-held moisture meter. Detection of QTL was facilitated with interval mapping in one and two dimensions including an interaction term, and a genetic linkage map of 122 SSR loci covering 1,557.8 cM. The markers were arranged in ten linkage groups. QTL mapping was made for the mean trait performance of the F _2:3 population across years. Ten QTL and an interaction were associated with GM. These QTL accounted for 54.8 and 65.2% of the phenotypic and genotypic variation, respectively. Eight QTL and two interactions were associated with FDR accounting for 35.7 and 45.2% of the phenotypic and genotypic variation, respectively. Two regions were in common between traits. The interaction between QTL for GM at harvest had practical implications for MAS. We conclude that MAS per se will not be an efficient method for reducing GM at harvest and/or increasing FDR. A selection index including both molecular marker information and phenotypic values, each appropriately weighted, would be the best selection strategy.     

Genetic Variation of Hypocotyl Length in the Brussels Sprout

A study was made of variation in the hypocotyl length of twoinbred lines of Brassica oleracea gemmifera (Brussels sprout).The pattern of means and variances obtained from parental, F₁,F₂ and backcross generations suggested polygenic control ofhypocotyl length. Measurements of parental seed weights, embryocell numbers, and the growth of seedlings from seeds of knownweight support the view that variation between the lines inhypocotyl length, when the seedlings were exposed to light,was determined by differential extension rather than by initialdifferences in seed weight. The effect of reduction in lightintensity on hypocotyl extension was studied and the differencesbetween the lines was maintained under all light intensities.Differential reaction of the lines was only observed when theperiod allowed for growth was short. The inbred line with thelonger hypocotyl was shown to suppress the other under competitiveconditions.     

Genetic analysis of resistance in Brussels sprout to cauliflower mosaic and turnip mosaic viruses

A total of 28 inbred lines of Brussels sprout were assessed in the glasshouse for their reaction to inoculation with cauliflower mosaic (CaMV) or turnip mosaic (TuMV) virus. There was significant variation for resistance to both viruses. From the 28 inbred lines parents were chosen for two 9 × 9 diallel crossing programmes. The parents and their F₁ progeny were assessed for their reaction to CaMV or TuMV in the field. There was significant additive and non-additive (dominance) variation but no maternal effects. Resistance to both viruses was generally dominant but with some evidence of a recessive gene for resistance to CaMV. Resistance to TuMV and CaMV was apparently controlled by at least four genes and two genes respectively. The heritability of resistance to each virus was high. The implications for breeding F₁ hybrid Brussels sprout cultivars are discussed.     

Fine-mapping QTLs in advanced intercross lines and other outbred populations

Quantitative genetic studies in model organisms, particularly in mice, have been extremely successful in identifying chromosomal regions that are associated with a wide variety of behavioral and other traits. However, it is now widely understood that identification of the underlying genes will be far more challenging. In the last few years, a variety of populations have been utilized in an effort to more finely map these chromosomal regions with the goal of identifying specific genes. The common property of these newer populations is that linkage disequilibrium spans relatively short distances, which permits fine-scale mapping resolution. This review focuses on advanced intercross lines (AILs) which are the simplest such population. As originally proposed in 1995 by Darvasi and Soller, an AIL is the product of intercrossing two inbred strains beyond the F₂ generation. Unlike recombinant inbred strains, AILs are maintained as outbred populations; brother–sister matings are specifically avoided. Each generation of intercrossing beyond the F₂ further degrades linkage disequilibrium between adjacent makers, which allows for fine-scale mapping of quantitative trait loci (QTLs). Advances in genotyping technology and techniques for the statistical analysis of AILs have permitted rapid advances in the application of AILs. We review some of the analytical issues and available software, including QTLRel, EMMA, EMMAX, GEMMA, TASSEL, GRAMMAR, WOMBAT, Mendel, and others.     

Comparative efficiency of four selection methods for deriving high-yielding lines in mungbean [Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek]

The comparative efficiency of four selection methods, viz., honeycomb (HC), pedigree selection (PS), single-seed descent (SSD) and the bulk method (BM), was assessed in three crosses of mungbean. The lines derived by each method, along with check varieties, were yield-tested in a compact family block design in F₅ and F₆ generations during summer and kharif of 1990. On the basis of the mean of the lines, the range, the number of superior lines over the best check, and the proportion of the top 10% lines in all the crosses and generations, the honeycomb method exhibited superiority over PS, SSD and BM for yield per plant and its component traits. PS, SSD and BM did not differ from each other. The honeycomb and SSD methods were found suitable for deriving superior lines for seed yield and pods per plant in mungbean.     

Genetic studies of yield contributing traits in Amaranthus

Summary Genetical studies on grain yield and its contributing traits were made in a six parent complete diallel in the F₁ and F₂ generations of one of the most widely grown grain species of grain amaranths (Amaranthus hypochondriacus L.). Graphical analysis indicated that epistasis exists for 1,000-grain weight in the F₁. Grain weight/panicle, yield/plant and harvest index indicated absence of non-allelic gene interaction. The harvest index in the F₁ and F₂ and grain weight/ panicle, 1,000-grain weight, yield/plant in the F₂ appeared to be controlled by overdominance effects. Higher grain yield appeared to be associated with dominant genes. Both additive and non-additive gene effects were responsible for the genetic variation in the diallel population. However, dominance variance was more important than additive variance in grain yield/ plant and harvest index in the F₁ and F₂. For 1,000-grain weight additive genetic variance was more important in the F₁ and non-additive in F₂. There was overdominance of a consistent nature in the two analyses for harvest index in the F₁ and F₂, grain weight/ panicle, 1,000-grain weight and yield/plant in the F₂ and partial dominance for 1,000-grain weight in the F₁.     

Epistatic contributions to quantitative traits in Tribolium castaneum

Summary Triple-testcross experiments were used to analyze epistatic contributions to larva weight, pupa weight, pupa width and adult weight in Tribolium castaneum. Seven diverse inbred lines and the F₁. produced by crossing the two tester lines were examined for indications of epistasis. Larva weight was the only trait for which no significant epistasis was detected. There was significant epistasis for pupa weight in three of the inbred lines; for pupa width in four of the inbred lines; for adult weight in five of the inbred lines. Only one inbred line and the F₁ line failed to exhibit significant epistasis for any trait. Each inbred line had a unique pattern of epistasis, suggesting that a number of different loci were contributing to the detected epistasis.This paper (No. 76-5-158) is published with the approval of the Director of the Kentucky Agricultural Experiment Station.     

Detection of QTL affecting harvest traits in a commercial Atlantic salmon population

Genetic variation in performance and quality traits measured at harvest has previously been demonstrated in Atlantic salmon aquaculture populations. To map major loci underlying this variation, we utilized data from 10 families from a commercial breeding programme. Significant QTL were detected affecting harvest weight and length traits on linkage group 1, and affecting waste weight on linkage group 5. In total, 11 of the 29 linkage groups examined showed at least suggestive evidence for a QTL. These data suggest that major loci affecting economically important harvest characteristics are segregating in commercial salmon populations.     

超甜玉米种子萌发物质利用性状杂种优势及亲子回归关系分析

为阐明超甜玉米(Zea mays L.var.saccharata Bailey)亲本对F_1种子物质利用性状遗传效应,研究了19份自交系和其测配的10个杂交组合的杂种优势及亲子回归关系。结果表明,超甜玉米自交系及F_1种子的淀粉含量、蛋白质含量、脂肪含量、百粒重、种子物质动用量和种子物质利用率差异较大,10个杂交组合中亲本和F_1种子的淀粉含量、脂肪含量、百粒重均存在显著差异。F_1种子淀粉含量和百粒重均表现出正向超亲优势,即近高亲本遗传;而F_1种子的蛋白质含量、脂肪含量、种子物质动用量和种子物质利用率为近低亲本遗传。聚类分析和杂种优势分析表明,性状差异较大的FH14、Q26、GT22、GT2等亲本测配的杂交组合在种子百粒重或种子物质利用率等性状上具有较强的超亲优势。回归分析表明,母本对F_1种子的淀粉含量、百粒重有负效应,对种子物质动用量和种子物质利用率有正效应;父本对种子淀粉含量有负效应,对种子物质利用率有正效应。