Insertion of the dibasic motif in the flanking region of a cryptic self-determinant leads to activation of the epitope-specific T cells

Efficient induction of self tolerance is critical for avoiding autoimmunity. The T cells specific for the well-processed and -presented (dominant) determinants of a native self protein are generally tolerized in the thymus, whereas those potentially directed against the inefficiently processed and presented (cryptic) self epitopes escape tolerance induction. We examined whether the crypticity of certain determinants of mouse lysozyme-M (ML-M) could be attributed to the nonavailability of a proteolytic site, and whether it could be reversed to immunodominance by engraftment of a novel cleavage site in the flanking region of the epitope. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we created the dibasic motif (RR or RK; R = arginine, K = lysine), a target of intracellular proteases, in the region adjoining one of the three cryptic epitopes (46-61, 66-79, or 105-119) of ML-M. Interestingly, the mutated lysozyme proteins, but not unmutated ML-M, were immunogenic in mice. The T cell response to the altered lysozyme was attributable to the efficient processing and presentation of the previously cryptic epitope, and this response was both epitope and MHC haplotype specific. In addition, the anti-self T cell response was associated with the generation of autoantibodies against self lysozyme. However, the results using one of three mutated lysozymes suggested that the naturally processed, dibasic motif-marked epitope may not always correspond precisely to the cryptic determinant within a synthetic peptide. This is the first report describing the circumvention of self tolerance owing to the targeted reversal of crypticity to dominance in vivo of a specific epitope within a native self Ag.     

Breakdown of tolerance to a self-peptide of acetylcholine receptor alpha-subunit induces experimental myasthenia gravis in rats

Experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis (EAMG), a model for human myasthenia (MG), is routinely induced in susceptible rat strains by a single immunization with Torpedo acetylcholine receptor (TAChR). TAChR immunization induces anti-AChR Abs that cross-react with self AChR, activate the complement cascade, and promote degradation of the postsynaptic membrane of the neuromuscular junction. In parallel, TAChR-specific T cells are induced, and their specific immunodominant epitope has been mapped to the sequence 97-116 of the AChR alpha subunit. A proliferative T cell response against the corresponding rat sequence (R97-116) was also found in TAChR-immunized rats. To test whether the rat (self) sequence can be pathogenic, we immunized Lewis rats with R97-116 or T97-116 peptides and evaluated clinical, neurophysiological, and immunological parameters. Clinical signs of the disease were noted only in R97-116-immunized animals and were confirmed by electrophysiological signs of impaired neuromuscular transmission. All animals produced Abs against the immunizing peptide, but anti-rat AChR Abs were observed only in animals immunized with the rat peptide. These findings suggested that EAMG in rats can be induced by a single peptide of the self AChR, that this sequence is recognized by T cells and Abs, and that breakdown of tolerance to a self epitope might be an initiating event in the pathogenesis of rat EAMG and MG.     

Linked foreign T-cell help activates self-reactive CTL and inhibits tumor growth

Transgenic mice expressing membrane-bound OVA under the rat insulin promoter, RIP-mOVA, has previously been suggested to display deletional tolerance toward the dominant CTL epitope, SIINFEKL, and provide an elegant model system to test the hypothesis that the lack of T cell help contributes to the tolerance. To understand how the CD8 tolerance is maintained in these mice, a set of neo-self-Ags, OVA, modified to contain a foreign Th peptide, were constructed and tested for their ability to induce CTL responses in RIP-mOVA mice. Immunization with these Th peptide-modified OVA molecules and not with the wild-type OVA induced self-reactive CTLs recognizing dominant CTL peptide, SIINFEKL. Importantly, immunization with the modified OVA constructs also prevented the growth of OVA-expressing tumors in transgenic mice. Since endogenous OVA Th peptides did not contribute toward breaking self CTL tolerance, these results also highlighted a very robust CD4 T cell tolerance toward OVA in RIP-mOVA mice that has not been previously described. These results therefore provide direct evidence that it is the tolerance in the CD4 Th cell compartment that helps maintain the CTL tolerance against self-Ag in these mice. Since the CTL tolerance can be broken or bypassed by foreign Th peptides inserted into a self Ag, potential of using this approach in generating effective therapeutic cancer vaccines is discussed.     

A modified tyrosinase-related protein 2 epitope generates high-affinity tumor-specific T cells but does not mediate therapeutic efficacy in an intradermal tumor model

The generation of tumor-specific T cells is hampered by the presentation of poorly immunogenic tumor-specific epitopes by the tumor. Here, we demonstrate that, although CD8+ T cells specific for the self/tumor Ag tyrosinase-related protein 2 (TRP2) are readily detected in tumor-bearing hosts, vaccination of either tumor-bearing or naive mice with an epitope derived from TRP2 fails to generate significant numbers of tetramer-staining TRP2-specific T cells or antitumor immunity. We identified an altered peptide epitope, called deltaV, which elicits T cell responses that are cross-reactive to the wild-type TRP2 epitope. Immunization with deltaV generates T cells with increased affinity for TRP2 compared with immunization with the wild-type TRP2 epitope, although TRP2 immunization often generates a greater number of TRP2-specific T cells based on intracellular IFN-gamma analysis. Despite generating higher affinity responses, deltaV immunization alone fails to provide any greater therapeutic efficacy against tumor growth than TRP2 immunization. This lack of tumor protection is most likely a result of both the deletion of high affinity and functional tolerance induction of lower affinity TRP2-specific T cells. Our data contribute to a growing literature demonstrating the ability of variant peptide epitopes to generate higher affinity T cell responses against tumor-specific Ags. However, consistent with most clinical data, simple generation of higher affinity T cells is insufficient to mediate tumor immunity.     

Immunogenicity and arthritogenicity of recombinant CB10 in B10.RIII mice

Two major T cell determinants are recognized by I-Ar-specific T cells in CII, the immunodominant CII610-618 (GPAGT AGA R) within CB10 and the subdominant CII445-453 (GPAGP AGE R) within CB8. Although the determinants differ by only two residues, CB8 is capable of inducing collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), while CB10 is not. We, therefore, investigated the structural differences between the two determinants that are critical to inducing arthritis. When the CB10 determinant was mutated to that of CB8 using recombinant techniques, the resulting mutant rCB10T614P,A617E product became arthritogenic. Conversely, when the CB8 determinant was mutated to that of CB10, the resulting mutant CB8P449T,E452A was no longer arthritogenic. Comparison of the epitope specificity of the autoantibodies induced by wild-type CB10 and mutant rCB10T614P, A617E revealed no qualitative differences. T cells from mice immunized with either CB10 or mutant rCB10 produced predominantly Th1 cytokines when cultured with the immunizing Ag. In contrast, when cultured with mouse CII, T cells from mice immunized with the nonarthritogenic CB10 produced predominantly Th2 (IL-4 and IL-10) cytokines whereas the arthritogenic mutant rCB10 induced predominantly Th1 (IFN-gamma) cytokines. We conclude that the T cell cytokine response most critical for the induction of CIA is that induced against the corresponding homologous murine T cell determinant and, further, that the structural differences between the T cell determinants in CB8 and -10 are important in breaking self tolerance and inducing autoimmune response.     

Intraperitoneal immunization led to T cell hyporesponsiveness to Helicobacter pylori infection in mice

During Helicobacter pylori infection, T cell response is critical in the development of active gastritis and in protective immunity against infection. We studied gastric inflammation and T cell response in H. pylori-challenged mice following an intraperitoneal immunization, using whole H. pylori lysate (HpAg) in the absence of adjuvants. H. pylori-challenged mice without immunization developed moderate to severe gastric inflammation, and splenocytes from these mice produced Th1 polarizing cytokines in response to HpAg and Con A during the acute infection. On the other hand, immunized-challenged mice (those inoculated with H. pylori following immunization) had little or no gastric inflammation despite persistent H. pylori colonization. Our immunization primed splenocytes to produce IL-2, IFN-gamma, and IL-4 in response to HpAg and Con A before infection. However, these cells became hyporesponsive to both stimulants immediately after live bacterial challenge in terms of the production of these cytokines, especially IL-2 and IFN-gamma. CTLA-4 has been documented to be a negative regulator of IL-2 production and lymphoproliferation that induces peripheral tolerance and functions 24-72 hr after the initiation of T cell activation. Compared with challenged mice, T cells from immunized-challenged mice showed higher levels of CTLA-4 expression at 72 hr after oral challenge. These data suggested that our immunization inhibited the development of H. pylori-associated gastritis and induced T cell hyporesponsiveness to H. pylori infection, which might be mediated by the early induction of CTLA-4 following challenge.     

Spontaneous and prostatic steroid binding protein peptide-induced autoimmune prostatitis in the nonobese diabetic mouse

Chronic nonbacterial prostatitis is a poorly defined syndrome of putative autoimmune origin. To further understand its pathogenesis, we have analyzed autoimmune prostatitis in the NOD mouse, a strain genetically prone to develop different organ-specific autoimmune diseases. Spontaneous development of autoimmune prostatitis in the NOD male, defined by lymphomonuclear cell infiltration in the prostate gland, is well-established by approximately 20 wk of age and is stably maintained afterward. Disease development is indistinguishable in NOD and NOR mice, but is markedly delayed in IFN-gamma-deficient NOD mice. A T cell response to the prostate-specific autoantigen prostatic steroid-binding protein (PSBP) can be detected in NOD males before development of prostate infiltration, indicating lack of tolerance to this self Ag. The intraprostatic inflammatory infiltrate is characterized by Th1-type CD4(+) T cells, which are able to transfer autoimmune prostatitis into NOD.SCID recipients. We characterize here experimental autoimmune prostatitis, detected by intraprostatic infiltrate and PSBP-specific T cell responses, induced in 6- to 8-wk-old NOD males by immunization with synthetic peptides corresponding to the C1 subunit of PSBP. Three PSBP peptides induce in NOD mice vigorous T and B cell responses, paralleled by a marked lymphomononuclear cell infiltration in the prostate. Two of these peptides, PSBP(21-40) and PSBP(61-80), correspond to immunodominant self epitopes naturally processed in NOD mice after immunization with PSBP, whereas peptide PSBP(91-111) represents a cryptic epitope. These model systems address pathogenetic mechanisms in autoimmune prostatitis and will facilitate testing and mechanistic analysis of therapeutic approaches in this condition.     

Regulatory T cell responses: potential role in the control of atherosclerosis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Atherosclerosis is an inflammatory disease of the arterial wall where both innate and adaptive Th1-driven immunoinflammatory responses contribute to disease development. Th2-related responses have been shown to be either protective or pathogenic. Thus, it is unclear whether immunoregulatory activity can modulate disease development. RECENT FINDINGS: Novel subtypes of T cells, called the regulatory T cells, have been shown recently to play a critical role in the maintenance of immunological tolerance against self and non-self antigens and prevent the development of various immunoinflammatory diseases. Preliminary studies suggest a potential role for this type of regulatory T cell response in atherosclerosis. SUMMARY: Here we present a novel view of the immunoinflammatory response in atherosclerosis where natural and/or adaptive regulatory T cell responses modulate both Th1 and Th2 pathogenic responses and play a central role in counteracting disease initiation and progression.     

Immunization with soluble murine CD4 induces an anti-self antibody response without causing impairment of immune function

The T cell surface molecule CD4 (L3T4 in mouse) is important in the T lymphocyte response to Ag presented in association with MHC class II molecules. To examine the role of CD4 in immune function, we expressed a soluble form of murine CD4 by deleting the transmembrane and cytoplasmic regions of the L3T4 gene and transfecting the altered gene into Chinese hamster ovary cells. The recombinant soluble mouse CD4 (smCD4) retained the native conformation of the external portion, as indicated by the binding of L3T4 mAb. In vitro, smCD4 did not inhibit class II-dependent, Ag-specific, T cell proliferation or MLR, even at concentrations 300-fold greater, on a molar basis, than that of anti-CD4 mAb. Immunization of mice with smCD4 induced a strong anti-CD4 response. These antibodies showed some binding to native cell surface CD4, indicating that immunization with smCD4 generated an anti-self response. Analysis of lymphoid cells from spleen, lymph node, and thymus of smCD4-treated mice revealed no alteration in subset phenotypes. Also, Th cell function, as measured by response to soluble Ag, was not compromised. Thus, smCD4 did not inhibit T cell activity in vitro, and the autoimmune response arising from immunization with smCD4 had no apparent consequences for normal immune function.     

Further implications of a theory of immunity.

A theory of immunity presented previously showed that many immune phenomena could be explained in terms of a simple model involving interactions between (i) the receptors on immunologically competent cells, (ii) antigenic determinants, (iii) natural antibody and (iv) complement. Several features of the theory subsequently gained experimental support. The present paper extends the analysis and predicts that two mechanisms operate in the induction of immunological tolerance to self antigenic determinants. High specificity anti-self cells are destroyed by a mechanism involving complement. In contrast, low specificity anti-self cells are stimulated by self determinants and increase in numbers. This increases the concentration of the natural antibody secreted by these cells which acts as a “blocking” antibody preventing their continued stimulation by self determinants.The expanded clones of low specificity anti-self cells, which may be of high specificity for “near-self” determinants, (i) are responsible for the greater immunological responsiveness between non-identical members of the same species than between members of different species (“alloaggression”), and (ii) provide a barrier opposing the progressive evolution of the surface determinants of a pathogen into forms identical with the surface determinants of its host.Following exposure to a given self or not-self antigenic determinant, the distribution curve for cells of varying specificities for the determinant shows a sharp cut-off point between high and low specificity cells. The position of this cut-off point is critical in determining the subsequent response of the organism to the determinant. Variables affecting the cut-off point include, antibody present prior to the exposure of cells to the determinant, complement, complement inhibitors, the cell membrane and certain drugs. Autoimmune diseases are improved by drugs (e.g. chloroquine) which move the position of the cut-off point towards cells of low specificities for self determinants.     

The link between lymphocyte deficiency and autoimmunity: roles of endogenous T and B lymphocytes in tolerance

We demonstrate that transfer of OVA-specific DO11 CD4(+) T cells into mice that lack T and B cells and produce secreted OVA as an endogenous self-protein results in a severe systemic autoimmune reaction with skin inflammation, wasting, and death. The transferred DO11 T cells undergo massive expansion and produce IL-2 and IFN-gamma abundantly. Transfer of DO11 cells into OVA-expressing animals in which T cells are absent but B cells are present, leads to mild disease with no death. In this situation, the DO11 cells undergo similar expansion but show poor Th1 differentiation. This regulatory effect of B cells correlates with profound TCR down-regulation. If T cells are present, the DO11 cells fail to expand independent of B cells. These results suggest that both endogenous T and B lymphocytes control T cell tolerance induction and pathogenicity, but at different stages of an anti-self response. Although endogenous T cells prevent expansion and maintain homeostasis, endogenous B cells limit subsequent effector responses of autoreactive CD4(+) T cells.     

Neonatal exposure to immunogenic peptides. Differential susceptibility to tolerance induction of helper T cells and B cells reactive to malarial circumsporozoite peptide epitopes

The effects of neonatal administration of immunogenic peptides on subsequent T and B cell function were tested using defined T and B cell peptide epitopes from the circumsporozoite (CS) protein of the human malaria parasite, Plasmodium falciparum. We observed that neonatal exposure of responder strain mice to either of the two major murine T sites on the CS protein resulted in specific tolerance of both helper and proliferating T cells. One of these T sites, (NANP)n, is also the immunodominant B epitope on the CS protein. We took advantage of this fact to directly compare the effects of neonatal peptide administration on B and T cell function and observed that mice whose helper and proliferating T cells were tolerant to (NANP)n nevertheless produced normal levels of anti-(NANP)n antibodies after immunization with keyhole limpet hemocyanin-(NANP)n. Our results demonstrate differential susceptibility of the Th cells and B cells to toleragens and suggest that self-tolerance to peptide epitopes during the neonatal period reflects predominantly Th cell tolerance.     

The role of the T cell in autoimmune inflammation

T cells, in particular CD4+ T cells, have been implicated in mediating many aspects of autoimmune inflammation. However, current evidence suggests that the role played by CD4+ T cells in the development of rheumatoid inflammation exceeds that of activated proinflammatory T-helper (Th)1 effector cells that drive the chronic autoimmune response. Subsets of CD4+ T cells with regulatory capacity, such as CD25+ regulatory T (Treg) cells and Th2 cells, have been identified, and recent observations suggest that in rheumatoid arthritis the function of these regulatory T cells is severely impaired. Thus, in rheumatoid arthritis, defective regulatory mechanisms might allow the breakdown of peripheral tolerance, after which the detrimental Th1-driven immune response evolves and proceeds to chronic inflammation. Here, we review the functional abnormalities and the contribution of different T cell subsets to rheumatoid inflammation.     

Inducing experimental arthritis and breaking self-tolerance to joint-specific antigens with trackable, ovalbumin-specific T cells

The importance of T cell Ag specificity and Th1 vs Th2 phenotype in synovial inflammation remains controversial. Using OVA-specific TCR transgenic T cells from DO11.10 mice, we demonstrate that mice receiving Th1, but not Th2, cells display a transient arthritis following immunization that is characterized by synovial hyperplasia, cellular infiltration, and cartilage erosion. OVA-specific T cells also accumulated in inflamed joints, suggesting that they could exert their inflammatory effect locally in the joint or in the draining lymph node. Importantly, this pathology was accompanied by a breakdown in self-tolerance, as evidenced by the induction of collagen-specific T and B cell responses. This model directly demonstrates a pivotal role for Th1 cells of an irrelevant specificity in the development of inflammatory arthritis. Furthermore, the ability to track these cells in vivo will make feasible studies revealing the dynamic role of T cells in arthritis.     

T cell tolerance induced by cross-reactive TCR ligands can be broken by superagonist resulting in anti-inflammatory T cell cytokine production

Cross-reactive activation of potentially autoreactive T cells by high-affinity nonself ligands may be important in breaking self-tolerance in autoimmunity. In a mouse transgenic for a cross-reactive TCR, we have previously shown that a hyper-stimulating altered peptide ligand, L144, induced unresponsiveness to the self peptide, proteolipid protein 139-151. In this study, we demonstrate that a superagonist ligand can break T cell tolerance induced by the lower affinity cognate Ag. T cells tolerant to the cognate ligand, Q144, responded to superagonist, L144, by proliferation and the production of mainly IL-4 and IL-10 in vitro. In contrast, T cells that were tolerized to the superagonist were unable to respond to any peptide that cross-reacted with the transgenic TCR. Low-dose immunization with the superagonist L144 was able to break tolerance to the cognate ligand in vivo and resulted in a blunted proliferative response with production of Th2 cytokines.     

Arthritis protective regulatory potential of self-heat shock protein cross-reactive T cells

Immunization with heat shock proteins has protective effects in models of induced arthritis. Analysis has shown a reduced synovial inflammation in such protected animals. Adoptive transfer and immunization with selected T cell epitopes (synthetic peptides) have indicated the protection to be mediated by T cells directed to conserved hsp epitopes. This was shown first for mycobacterial hsp60 and later for mycobacterial hsp70. Fine specificity analysis showed that such T cells were cross-reactive with the homologous self hsp. Therefore protection by microbial hsp reactive T cells can be by cross-recognition of self hsp overexpressed in the inflamed tissue. Preimmunization with hsp leads to a relative expansion of such self hsp cross-responsive T cells. The regulatory nature of such T cells may originate from mucosal tolerance maintained by commensal flora derived hsp or from partial activation through recognition of self hsp as a partial agonist (Altered Peptide Ligand) or in the absence of proper costimulation. Recently, we reported the selective upregulation of B7.2 on microbial hsp600 specific T cells in response to self hsp60. Through a preferred interaction with CTLA-4 on proinflammatory T cells this may constitute an effector mechanism of regulation. Also, regulatory T cells produced IL10.     

Breaking T cell tolerance with foreign and self co-immunogens. A study of autoimmune B and T cell epitopes of cytochrome c.

The initiation of autoimmune B cell and T cell responses by self Ag or by foreign pathogens (molecular mimics) is not well understood. In the present study, cytochrome c (cyt c) was used as a model autoantigen to investigate how self-proteins are involved in the priming of autoimmune T cell responses. Immunization with foreign cyt c has been extensively analyzed in previous studies as a model for both humoral and cellular immune responses. Mice do not, however, make antibody or T cell responses to immunization with self (mouse) cyt c. In addition, T cell tolerance can be broken by autoreactive B cells that are readily elicited by immunization with cross-reactive foreign cyt c. These immune B cells presumably bind self cyt c and process and present the self Ag to stimulate an autoreactive T cell response. Autoreactive T cell clones derived by this mechanism are all specific for determinants within amino acids 1-80 of the cyt c protein presented by I-Ek. No T cell responses were observed to the carboxyl terminal 81-104 fragment that dominates the response to foreign cyt c. All clones derived in this study are stimulated by a polypeptide encompassing amino acids 54-68 and utilized the V beta 8.2 TCR gene. In contrast, T cells stimulated by foreign cyt c did indeed respond to fragment 81-104 and appear to utilize alternate TCR genes. Our data demonstrate that B cells specific for linear determinants distributed along the entire length of the foreign cyt c molecule can provide the stimulus required for breaking T cell tolerance to self cyt c. The applications of this work to understanding the mechanisms of autoimmune disease are discussed.     

DNA vaccine with discontinuous T‐cell epitope insertions into HSP65 scaffold as a potential means to improve immunogenicity of multi‐epitope Mycobacterium tuberculosis vaccine

DNA‐based vaccine is a promising candidate for immunization and induction of a T‐cell‐focused protective immune response against infectious pathogens such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tb). To induce multi‐functional T response against multi‐TB antigens, a multi‐epitope DNA vaccine and a ‘protein backbone grafting’ design method is adopted to graft five discontinuous T‐cell epitopes into HSP65 scaffold protein of M. tb for enhancement of epitope processing and immune presentation. A DNA plasmid with five T‐cell epitopes derived from ESAT‐6, Ag85B, MTB10.4, PPE25 and PE19 proteins of H37Rv strain of M. tb genetically inserted into HSP65 backbone was constructed and designated as pPES. After confirmation of its in vitro expression efficiency, pPES DNA was i.m. injected into C57BL/6 mice with four doses of 50 µg DNA followed by mycobacterial challenge 4 weeks after the final immunization. It was found that pPES DNA injection maintained the ability of HSP65 backbone to induce specific serum IgG. ELISPOT assay demonstrated that pPES epitope‐scaffold construct was significantly more potent to induce IFN‐γ⁺ T response to five T‐cell epitope proteins than other DNA constructs (with epitopes alone or with epitope series connected to HSP65), especially in multi‐functional‐CD4⁺ T response. It also enhanced granzyme B⁺ CTL and IL‐2⁺ CD8⁺ T response. Furthermore, significantly improved protection against Mycobacterium bovis BCG challenge was achieved by pPES injection compared to other DNA constructs. Taken together, HSP65 scaffold grafting strategy for multi‐epitope DNA vaccine represents a successful example of rational protein backbone engineering design and could prove useful in TB vaccine design.