Subpopulations of human T lymphocytes. VII. Cellular basis of concanavalin A-induced T cell-mediated suppression of immunoglobulin production by B lymphocytes from normal humans.

Purified peripheral blood T lymphocytes from normal subjects were pretreated with varying concentrations of concanavalin A (Con A) for a period of 18 or 48 hr. Following treatment, these T lymphocytes were examined for the proportions of Tμ and Tγ cells and their regulatory effect on immunoglobulin production by normal allogeneic B cells in presence of pokeweed mitogen. A significant decrease in the proportions of Tμ cells and increase in Tγ cells were observed when concentration of Con A, 40 μg/ml, was used to treat purified T cells for either 18 or 48 hr. Significant suppression of in vitro immunoglobulin synthesis was observed at a similar concentration in mixing experiments. The mechanism of Con A-induced T cell-mediated suppression of immunoglobulin secretion by allogeneic B cells is discussed.     

Characteristics and mechanisms of action of the concanavalin A-activated suppressor cell in man.

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes treated for 24 to 48 hr with optimally mitogenic doses of concanavalin A suppressed the proliferative response of autologous T cells to mitogens and antigens. Con A-treated cells also suppressed the proliferative response and the immunoglobulin synthetic response of autologous B cells stimulated in vitro by T cell helper factor. The human Con A suppressor cell was sensitive to treatment with mitomycin C and to exposure to radiation doses exceeding 1000 rads. The Con A suppressor cell was shown to reside in the nylon wool-nonadherent, sheep red cell rosette-forming, histamine receptor-bearing population of lymphocytes and to lack surface DRW antigens. One mechanism of action of Con A suppressor cells was shown to be the inactivation of nonspecific T cell helper factor.     

Characterization of the human blood lymphocytes that produce a histamine-induced suppressor factor (HSF)

The cells which elaborate a soluble suppressor factor in vitro in response to histamine (histamine-induced suppressor factor or HSF) were partially characterized in the present studies. Human blood T- and B-cell populations were purified by affinity chromatography with rabbit anti-human F(Ab′)₂ and examined for their ability to make HSF. Highly purified populations of T cells, but not B cells, produced HSF in response to varying concentrations of histamine (10^?4 to 10^?4M). The HSF-producing cells were characterized further by means of affinity chromatography with columns containing conjugates of insolubilized histamine as well as by rosette formation with IgG (Tγ)- or IgM (Tμ)-coated ox red blood cells. These studies revealed the following: (a) Cells that synthesize HSF are retained on histamine (but not control) columns; (b) cells with histamine receptors comprise approximately 50% of the Tγ subpopulation but are not found in the Tμ subpopulation; (c) cells not retained by histamine columns have a reduced capacity to develop into suppressor cells following stimulation by concanavalin A or specific antigen (compared to unfractionated or control column passed cells). In addition, it was shown that cells synthesizing HSF predominantly express histamine type 2 receptors: (d)4-Methyl histamine (H₂ agonist), but not 2-methyl histamine (H₁ agonist), was capable of inducing HSF production; (e) cimetidine (H₂ antagonist) inhibited HSF production but chlorpheniramine (H₁ antagonist) did not. Taken together, these experiments suggest that T lymphocytes capable of expressing suppressor function following activation by histamine, specific antigen, concanavalin A, or perhaps through their Fc receptors may either be heterogeneous within the same subpopulation or more likely be the same cell with the complement of receptors described above.     

Characterization of canine T-lymphocyte subpopulations: the detection of T mu and T gamma lymphocytes with homologous and heterologous immunoglobulins and the requirements for Fc receptor expression

Erythrocyte antibody (EA) rosette techniques employing sheep red blood cells sensitized with canine (homologous) and rabbit (heterologous) IgM and IgG antibodies were used to determine the number of cells with Fc receptors for IgM (Tμ) and IgG (Tγ) among T lymphocytes isolated from peripheral blood and lymph nodes of dogs. The percentages of Tμ and Tγ lymphocytes detected were found to be independent of the species origin of sensitizing antibody. Among peripheral blood T lymphocytes there were 53.0 ± 2.7% Tμ cells and 18.4 ± 3.6% Tγ cells. T lymphocytes obtained from lymph nodes were 62.1 ± 5.4% Tγ and 15.7 ± 2.6% Tγ. The number of Tμ cells detected increased from 20.0% when freshly isolated to 49.1 ± 4.1% after in vitro culture for 2–16 hr. The expression of the Fc-μ receptor in culture was inhibited by cycloheximide, demonstrating a requirement for active protein synthesis. In contrast, the number of Tγ lymphocytes detected did not vary between freshly isolated cells and those which had been cultured for 16 hr. Expression of the Fc-γ receptor during this time period was not inhibited by cycloheximide.     

In vitro Ig heavy chain isotype suppression of spleen cells from immunized rabbits.

We tested whether purified antibodies (Ab) to immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy chain isotoypes could suppress immune Ig-secreting lymphocytes in vitro. Rabbit immune spleen cells (SpC) were treated with purified goat Ab to IgM (anti-μ Ab) or to IgG (anti-γ Ab) in vitro for 24 hr (Day 1). After this treatment, the SpC were washed and recultured to Day 5. The cells were again washed and then tested for Ig-bearing cells by a rosette forming cell assay and tested for Ab-secreting cells by the conventional plaque forming cell assay. In addition, the supernatant fluids were quantitated for secreted Ig by a radial immune hemolysis in gel assay. The number of Ig-bearing cells, the number of Ab-secreting cells and the amount of secreted b4 Ig decreased when “primary immune” SpC were pretreated with anti-μ but not when the SpC were pretreated with anti-γ Ab. Thus, SpC from rabbits injected once with SE were suppressed by anti-μ but not by anti-γ Ab. In contrast, SpC from rabbits injected several times with SE (hyperimmunized) were not suppressed by either anti-μ or by anti-γ Ab. This susceptibility of primary immune (IgM-secreting) SpC and resistance of hyperimmune (IgG-secreting) SpC to suppression may depend on the stage of B lymphocyte differentiation. That is, more differentiated cells such as IgG-secreting cells are insensitive to anti-μ and anti-γ Ab presumably due to lack of surface Ig molecules or for other reasons.     

Subpopulations of human T lymphocytes. III. Distribution and quantitation in peripheral blood, cord blood, tonsils, bone marrow, thymus, lymph nodes, and spleen.

Human T cell subpopulations (Tμ and Tγ) were examined for their distribution in the peripheral blood, cord blood, bone marrow, tonsils, thymus, lymph nodes and spleen. The proportions of Tμ and Tγ cells are comparable in the peripheral blood, tonsils and bone marrow. The proportions of Tγ cells in cord blood are significantly higher than those in the peripheral blood. Almost complete lack of Tγ cells was observed in lymph nodes. Spleen has very high proportions of Tγ cells. Thymuses have very low proportions of both Tμ and Tγ cells when compared with peripheral blood, cord blood, tonsils, and bone marrow. The receptors for IgM on Tμ cells appear to be masked by passively absorbed IgM and require prior in vitro incubation in medium containing fetal calf serum for the full expression of this marker.     

Inhibition of rat mixed lymphocyte cultures by suppressor macrophages.

Normal rat spleens contain suppressor cells which can inhibit proliferative and cytotoxic responses of lymphocytes to alloantigens in vitro. The suppressor cells are adherent, phagocytic, resistant to treatment with ATS and C, radioresistant, resistant to treatment with mitomycin C, apparently absent from the thymus, and found in very high concentrations in peritoneal exudates. These characteristics indicate that the suppressor cell is a macrophages and not a T cell. When suppressor cells were removed from spleen cell suspensions, strong in vitro proliferative and cytotoxic responses to alloantigens could consistently be observed.     

Characteristics of the splenic suppressor cell--target cell interaction in experimental African trypanosomiasis

We have examined further the relationship between immunosuppression and suppressor cell activity in experimental African trypanosomiasis. In the present study we describe the nature of the interaction between splenic suppressor macrophages from Trypanosoma rhodesiense-infected C57BL/6 mice and target effector cells in the primary in vitro PFC response to SRBC. Suppressor cell potential was expressed only when cell-cell contact of a noncytolytic nature was established between infected spleen cells and normal splenic responder cells. Isolation of suppressor cells from responder cells by a cell-impermeable membrane completely abrogated suppression. Similarly, supernatant fluids from infected spleen cell cultures could not passively transfer suppression. Suppressor cells did not act via prostaglandin synthesis in that indomethacin failed to restore responsiveness to infected spleen cells or to passively suppressed normal cultures. Inhibition of DNA synthesis by irradiation of mitomycin C treatment did not block suppressor cell function, but suppressor cell effects were inhibited by exposure of infected spleen cells to silica particles or to heat treatment. We conclude that suppressor cell effects in experimental African trypanosomiasis are consistent with a suppressor macrophage acting via a noncytolytic cell-cell interaction with responder target cells.     

Suppressor T cell activation by human leukocyte interferon

Murine fibroblast interferon (IFN beta) activates murine suppressor T lymphocytes in vitro, which suppress plaque-forming cell responses by spleen cells. Suppression of human in vitro immune responses by IFN was investigated to determine whether human IFN also activates suppressor T cells. Human leukocyte IFN (IFN alpha) suppressed pokeweed mitogen-induced polyclonal immunoglobulin production by human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) by 80 to 90% at doses of 200 to 350 U/ml. Responses by IFN alpha-treated PBMC were suppressed in a dose-dependent manner; control cultures had maximal responses on day 7. PBMC incubated with 10,000 U/ml of IFN alpha contained activated suppressor cells that decreased pokeweed mitogen-stimulated, polyclonal immunoglobulin production by autologous cells by 70 to 80%. Suppression mediated by these cells was prevented by catalase, ascorbic acid, and 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME). In murine systems, these reagents interfere with expression of suppressor T cell activity by preventing activation of soluble immune response suppressor. Selection procedures with monoclonal antibodies identified the suppressor cell as an OKT8+ (suppressor/cytotoxic) T lymphocyte. Selected OKT8+ cells required less IFN alpha (1000 U/ml) for activation and were effective in smaller numbers than unfractionated activated PBMC. IFN alpha-activated suppressor cells also inhibited proliferation in mixed lymphocyte and mitogen-stimulated PBMC cultures; again, catalase and 2-ME blocked suppression. These results indicate that IFN alpha activates suppressor T cells in human PBMC cultures; the ability of catalase, 2-ME, and ascorbic acid to block suppression suggests that these suppressor T cells have certain similarities to IFN beta or to concanavalin A-activated murine suppressor T cells.     

Induction and suppression of immunoglobulin synthesis in cultures of human lymphocytes: effects of pokeweed mitogen and Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I

The synthesis and secretion of immunoglobulins by human peripheral blood mononuclear cells in cultures stimulated with pokeweed mitogen or Staphylococcus aureus Cowan I were evaluated by enumeration of cells containing cytoplasmic immunoglobulins and cells actively secreting immunoglobulins, and by quantitation of immunoglobulins released into culture supernatants. The two mitogens caused comparable stimulation of immunoglobulin production; however, in contrast to pokeweed mitogen, S. aureus was active in cultures depleted of T lymphocytes, and its stimulatory effects were resistant to the influence of suppressor T cells generated by co-stimulation with concanavalin A or by preincubation without mitogenic stimulus. These results indicate distinct pathways of induction and suppression of immunoglobulin synthesis for these two polyclonal B cell activators, and suggest that stimulation by S. aureus is less thymus dependent than that induced by pokeweed mitogen.     

Concanavalin A-inducible suppressor cells in pleural effusions and peripheral blood of cancer patients

Summary Carcinomatous pleural effusions of 18 of 20 patients with lung cancer contained suppressor cell precursors that could be activated by concanavalin A (Con A) to suppress the proliferative responses of autologous and allogeneic lymphocytes to phytohemagglutinin and Con A. However, pleural effusion cells showed no suppressor function without prior activation by Con A. In contrast, the peripheral blood of the cancer patients exhibiting impaired mitogenic response contained nonspecific spontaneous suppressor cells capable of inhibiting the lymphoproliferative response to mitogens without prior activation by Con A, but these cells were not able to show further suppressor function even after activation by Con A. The maximum suppression was observed after 48-h treatment of lymphocytes with optimally mitogenic doses of Con A. The Con A-inducible suppressor cells of the pleural effusion and spontaneous suppressor cells of the peripheral blood of cancer patients had the same characteristics with regard to the capacity to suppress the mitogenic responses of autologous and allogeneic lymphocytes, belonging to the group of nylon wool-nonadherent T cells and being sensitive to in vitro culture and resistant to treatment with mitomycin C.     

Transfer of agammaglobulinemia in the chicken. I. Generation of suppressor activity by injection of bursa cells

Spleen cells from adult agammaglobulinemic (bursectomized) chickens taken 1 to 3 weeks after an injection of histocompatible bursa cells can inhibit the adoptive antibody response to B. abortus of normal spleen or bursa cells in irradiated recipients. Spleen cells from Aγ chickens not injected with bursa cells generally do not. Moreover, bursectomized chickens which have been reconstituted with spleen cells within the first week after hatching do not respond with suppressor cell formation upon bursa cell injection. This apparent “autoimmunization” with bursa cells induces suppressor T cells which are only minimally sensitive to treatment with mitomycin C or to 5000 R γ irradiation. The suppressor activity is neither induced nor potentiated by concanavalin A in vivo. It is much stronger in spleen than in thymus cells and appears to be macrophage independent and to require intact cells. The cell component which stimulates the suppressor activity is more pronounced on bursa than on spleen cells, and is at most present to a very limited extent on bone marrow, thymus, or peritoneal exudate cells. It is better represented in comparable cell numbers of Day 17 than of Day 14 embryonic bursa. The inducing cell component is present in the membrane fraction of disrupted bursa cells. Immunization with bursa cells from B locus histoincompatible chickens leads to suppressor activity against histocompatible bursa cells. Although the removal of Ig-bearing cells from bursa greatly diminishes its immunizing capacity, injection of serum IgM and IgG does not induce suppressor cells. It is suggested that tolerance to a B-cell antigen is lacking in adult Aγ chickens, resulting in an autoimmune response upon exposure to B cells. The B-cell antigen may be a cell surface-specific form of Ig, a complex of Ig and a membrane component, or a differentiation antigen which appears simultaneously with Ig during ontogeny.     

Production of human suppressor T cell hybridomas

To study human T cell suppression of immunoglobulin (Ig) synthesis with homogeneous populations of immunoregulatory cells, human suppressor T cell hybridomas were prepared by somatic cell fusion of concanavalin A-activated peripheral blood T cells with hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase-(HGPRT, EC 2.4.2.8) deficient human leukemic CEM T cells. After selection in hypoxanthine-aminopterin-thymidine (HAT) medium and cloning by limiting cell dilution, two human T cell hybridomas were identified that produced 60 to 80% suppression of in vitro polyclonal immunoglobulin production when cocultured with pokeweed mitogen- (PWM) stimulated peripheral blood lymphocytes. Further, one of the suppressor T cell hybridomas constitutively secreted a soluble suppressor factor(s) (TsF) of m.w. 70,000 to 85,000 daltons, which produced reversible noncytotoxic inhibition of lectin-activated B cell Ig production. In contrast, this TsF did not inhibit lectin- or antigen-induced T cell proliferation, nor did it interfere with the generation or effector function of cytotoxic T cells. Additional studies indicated that this Tsf acts directly on B cells or monocytes rather than indirectly modulating the activity of immunoregulatory T cells. In summary, these studies suggest that techniques of somatic cell fusion may provide a valuable approach to further study human immunoregulatory cell-cell interactions as well as provide a source of sufficient quantities of important lymphokines for further purification and characterization.     

Cellular interaction between cytotoxic and suppressor T cells against syngeneic tumors in the mouse.

Splenic T cells from animals bearing growing syngeneic tumors specifically inhibited the effector process of tumor cell lysis by the cytotoxic T cell which had been activated in vitro by mitomycin C treated homologous tumor. The suppression was strictly specific for the individual tumor by which suppressor cells were generated, whereas in some cases cytotoxic T cells generated by two closely related sarcomas showed a certain degree of crossreactivity. This suggests that suppressor and cytotoxic T cells recognize different antigenic moieties on tumor cells; one unique to the individual tumor and the other shared by related tumor cell lines.The suppressor T cell from tumor bearing animals possessed Ia antigen controlled by a gene in I-J subregion of H-2 major histocompatibility complex. Cytotoxic T cells generated by some but not all syngeneic tumors were also killed by anti-Ia and complement; however, the Ia antigen on such cytotoxic T cells was found to be controlled by a locus in I-A subregion. In general, the cytotoxic T cells generated by newly established tumor cell lines had Ia antigen, whereas some old cell lines, which were capable of growing across the H-2 barrier, activated the Ia negative cytotoxic T cell. These results collectively indicate that the immunological resistance against tumors is dependent on the balance of activations of the cytotoxic and suppressor T cells with different specificities and phenotypic expressions.     

Immunoregulation in disseminated histoplasmosis: Characterization of splenic suppressor cell populations

Potent immunosuppressor cell activity was induced during the course of disseminated histoplasmosis in C3H/Anf mice. Spleen cells from infected mice severely suppressed the primary antibody response in vitro of normal syngeneic spleen cells to both a T-dependent antigen (sheep red blood cells) and a T-independent antigen (trinitrophenyl-lipopolysaccharide) at Weeks 1 and 3 of infection, respectively. Likewise, marked suppressor cell activity was present within lymph nodes. In a kinetic study, suppressor activity was detected first on Day 2 and increased to the maximum level on Day 4 after inoculation of Histoplasma capsulatum. Two populations of spleen cells express suppressor function in this model. One population, identified as T cells, was nonadherent to nylon wool columns; its suppressor capacity was abolished by anti-Thy 1 and reduced greatly by low-dosage X-irradiation (500 R). Cells of the second suppressor population had macrophage-like properties; although poorly adherent to plastic surfaces, they adhered to nylon wool columns and could be removed from spleen cell suspensions by carbonyl iron treatment; high-dosage X-irradiation (3000 R) and mitomycin C treatment failed to abrogate suppression by these cells.     

Immunoregulatory function of T cells activated in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction

This study was undertaken to define the functional properties of T cells stimulated in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) by purified B cells or macrophages. In preliminary experiments, it was found that T cells that had been cultured with autologous non-T cells inhibited pokeweed mitogen- (PWM) stimulated immunoglobulin synthesis by autologous B cells. In addition, the T cell-mediated suppression was eliminated by x-irradiation and hydrocortisone treatment, was mediated by a mechanism that occurred early in the PWM-stimulated cultures, and did not involve killing of mature immunoglobulin-secreting cells. T cells were then cultured with either autologous B cells or macrophages in order to determine whether such autoreactive T cells had a similar capacity to regulate PWM-induced immunoglobulin synthesis. Although T cell populations stimulated either by B cells or by macrophages suppressed proliferative responses and immunoglobulin synthesis, both these populations of autoreactive T cells provided help for immunoglobulin synthesis that was not significantly different from that provided by fresh T cells. These results suggest that the predominant functional consequence of activation of T cells in the autologous MLR is the generation of suppressor T cells capable of inhibiting immunoglobulin synthesis. Thus, the autologous MLR may represent a negative feedback mechanism for the regulation of the immune response.     

Suppression of myeloma establishment in adult mice with anti-micron antiserum.

Uniform suppression of MOPC-104E tumor development was observed in adult BALB/c mice to which 0.4 ml of high titered anti-μ antiserum had been administered intraperitoneally or intravenously one day before subcutaneous tumor implantation. In contrast, when MOPC-104E cells were exposed to anti-μ antiserum in vitro for 10 min and subsequently injected into adult BALB/c mice, inhibition of tumor development was observed in only about half of the subject animals. Nude mice treated intraperitoneally with anti-μ antiserum were also uniformly refractory to MOPC-104E challenge. Anti-μ antiserum exhibited virtually no cytotoxicity against MOPC-104E cells in vitro. These observations suggest that neither complement-mediated cytotoxicity nor T cell-mediated immunity is likely to be the primary mechanism for anti-μ-mediated suppression of myeloma development in adult BALB/c mice. More plausible explanations for this type of suppression include macrophage arming, some type of antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity, and/or opsonization.     

Induction of CD4 suppressor T cells with anti-Leu-8 antibody

To characterize the conditions under which CD4 T cells suppress polyclonal immunoglobulin synthesis, we investigated the capacity of CD4 T cells that coexpress the surface antigen recognized by the monoclonal antibody anti-Leu-8 to mediate suppression. In an in vitro system devoid of CD8 T cells, CD4, Leu-8+ T cells suppressed pokeweed mitogen-induced immunoglobulin synthesis. Similarly, suppressor function was induced in unfractionated CD4 T cell populations after incubation with anti-Leu-8 antibody under cross-linking conditions. This induction of suppressor function by anti-Leu-8 antibody was not due to expansion of the CD4, Leu-8+ T cell population because CD4 T cells did not proliferate in response to anti-Leu-8 antibody. However, CD4, Leu-8+ T cell-mediated suppression was radiosensitive. Finally, CD4, Leu-8+ T cells do not inhibit immunoglobulin synthesis when T cell lymphokines were used in place of helper CD4 T cells (CD4, Leu-8- T cells), suggesting that CD4 T cell-mediated suppression occurs at the T cell level. We conclude that CD4 T cells can be induced to suppress immunoglobulin synthesis by modulation of the membrane antigen recognized by anti-Leu-8 antibody.     

The role of suppressor cells in the pathogenesis of common variable hypogammaglobulinemia and the immunodeficiency associated with myeloma.

The role of suppressor cells in the pathogenesis of immunodeficiency was analyzed using a technique that permits study of the differentiation of B lymphocytes into immunoglobulin-synthesizing plasma cells. Lymphocytes from normals synthesized 4,910 ng of IgM, 1,270 ng of IgA, and 1,625 ng of IgG per 2 X 10(6) cells when cultured for 7 days in the presence of pokeweed mitogen. In contrast the lymphocytes from patients with common variable hypogammaglobulinemia did not synthesize significant quantities of immunoglobulin. When lymphocytes from 9 of 13 patients with common variable hypogammaglobulinemia studied were cocultured with normal lymphocytes, the synthesis of immunoglobulin by the normal lymphocytes was depressed by 75-100%. A comparable suppression of immunoglobulin synthesis by normal lymphocytes was observed when they were cocultured with T cells from hypogammaglobulinemic patients. These studies suggest that in some patients the disease common variable hypogammaglobulinemia may not be due to an intrinsic defect of B cells alone but may be cuased or perpetuated by an abnormality of regulatory T cells that act to suppress B-cell maturation and antibody production. Peripheral blood lymphocytes from myeloma patients also had a drastically reduced capacity to produce polyclonal immunoglobulins. Three of 6 myeloma patients tested had circulating mononuclear cells that suppressed immunoglobulin production by cocultured normal lymphocytes. Purified T cells from myeloma patients did not mediate this suppressor effect. These observations suggest that one mechanism for the humoral immune deficiency observed in myeloma patients is a block of polyclonal B-cell maturation by suppressor cells.     

Mechanism of Epstein-Barr virus-induced human B-lymphocyte activation

The mechanism of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) activation of human B lymphocytes toward Ig synthesis was investigated in a direct anti-sheep red blood cell (SRBC) antibody plaque-forming cell (PFC) system. Exposure of human peripheral blood lymphocytes to EBV in vitro resulted in an anti-SRBC PFC response in 12 of 16 normal donors. The EBV-induced anti-SRBC PFC response did not require the presence of autologous helper T lymphocytes, but was inhibited by the presence of autologous concanavalin A-generated suppressor T cells. Live virus was required for B-cell activation since the EBV-induced PFC response was inhibited by exposure of EBV to ultraviolet light. Using fluorescent techniques which detected simultaneous intracytoplasmic (ICP) Ig production and the presence of EB nuclear antigen, we found that most, if not all, EBV-activated ICP Ig-positive cells were virally infected. Thus, these studies suggest that viral infection of Ig-producing B lymphocytes is required for EBV-induced polyclonal B-lymphocyte activation. Although the participation of T lymphocytes is not required for the induction of EBV-triggered B-lymphocyte Ig production, activated T lymphocytes can serve as modulators of this response.