Genome-Wide Comparative Analysis Reveals Similar Types of NBS Genes in Hybrid Citrus sinensis Genome and Original Citrus clementine Genome and Provides New Insights into Non-TIR NBS Genes

In this study, we identified and compared nucleotide-binding site (NBS) domain-containing genes from three Citrus genomes (C. clementina, C. sinensis from USA and C. sinensis from China). Phylogenetic analysis of all Citrus NBS genes across these three genomes revealed that there are three approximately evenly numbered groups: one group contains the Toll-Interleukin receptor (TIR) domain and two different Non-TIR groups in which most of proteins contain the Coiled Coil (CC) domain. Motif analysis confirmed that the two groups of CC-containing NBS genes are from different evolutionary origins. We partitioned NBS genes into clades using NBS domain sequence distances and found most clades include NBS genes from all three Citrus genomes. This suggests that three Citrus genomes have similar numbers and types of NBS genes. We also mapped the re-sequenced reads of three pomelo and three mandarin genomes onto the C. sinensis genome. We found that most NBS genes of the hybrid C. sinensis genome have corresponding homologous genes in both pomelo and mandarin genomes. The homologous NBS genes in pomelo and mandarin suggest that the parental species of C. sinensis may contain similar types of NBS genes. This explains why the hybrid C. sinensis and original C. clementina have similar types of NBS genes in this study. Furthermore, we found that sequence variation amongst Citrus NBS genes were shaped by multiple independent and shared accelerated mutation accumulation events among different groups of NBS genes and in different Citrus genomes. Our comparative analyses yield valuable insight into the structure, organization and evolution of NBS genes in Citrus genomes. Furthermore, our comprehensive analysis showed that the non-TIR NBS genes can be divided into two groups that come from different evolutionary origins. This provides new insights into non-TIR genes, which have not received much attention.     

Use of an expressed sequence tag-based method for single nucleotide polymorphism identification and discrimination of Citrus species and cultivars

Sweet orange [Citrus sinensis (L.) Osbeck] represents the most important Citrus species, followed by clementine (C. clementina Hort. ex Tan.). Citrus species and genotypes are difficult to recognize as they have a moderate level of diversity due to nucellar selection, vegetative propagation and origin by single spontaneous mutation. Despite the large number of available sequences and the existence of a draft assembly of sweet orange and clementine, there are currently no single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) databases for Citrus species. For this purpose, the QualitySNP software was used to discover SNPs in 19 Citrus species starting from 540,000 expressed sequence tags (ESTs) assembled in 52,000 contigs. The vast majority of ESTs, contigs and SNPs were found in C. clementina and C. sinensis: 4,400 out of 16,000 contigs (27 %) of C. clementina and 4,100 out of 17,000 contigs (24 %) of C. sinensis contained putative SNPs. A total of 3,634 sequences were associated with enzymes belonging to 121 metabolic KEGG (Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes) pathways, among which the secondary metabolite pathway was the most represented. A total of 163 SNPs from 52 contigs and genes of specific functional categories were validated and 81 polymorphic sites were found. Thirty-seven selected SNPs, validated by Sanger sequencing, confirmed that polymorphisms were mainly between species, while poor within-species variability was discovered. This work provides a collection of 15,879 putative SNP markers that could be exploited by the Citrus community. Furthermore, the validated SNPs associated with specific genes could be used for functional genetic studies in germplasm diversity analysis, mapping and breeding.     

Intron-exon organization and phylogeny in a large superfamily, the paralogous cytochrome P450 genes of Arabidopsis thaliana

The cytochrome P450 gene superfamily is represented by 80 genes in animal genomes and perhaps more than 300 genes in plant genomes. We analyzed about half of all Arabidopsis P450 genes, a very large dataset of truly paralogous genes. Sequence alignments were used to draw phylogenetic trees, and this information was compared with the intron-exon organization of each P450 gene. We found 60 unique intron positions, of which 37 were phase 0 introns. Our results confirm the polyphyletic origin of plant P450 genes. One group of these genes, the A-type P450s, are plant specific and characterized by a simple organization, with one highly conserved intron. Closely related A-type P450 genes are often clustered in the genome with as many as a dozen genes (e.g., of the CYP71 subfamily) on a short stretch of chromosome. The other P450 genes (non-A-type) form several distinct clades and are characterized by numerous introns. One such clade contains the two CYP51 genes, which are thought to encode obtusifoliol 14a demethylase. The two CYP51 genes have a single intron that is not shared with CYP51 genes from vertebrates or fungi, or with any other Arabidopsis P450 gene. Only a few of the Arabidopsis P450 genes are intronless (e.g., the CYP710A and CYP96A subfamilies). There was a relatively good correlation between intron conservation and phylogenetic relationships between members of the P450 subfamilies. Gene organization appears to be a useful tool in establishing the evolutionary relatedness of P450 genes, which may help in predictions of P450 function.     

In vitro anther culture of sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck) genotypes and of a C. clementina × C. sinensis ‘Hamlin’ hybrid

Citrus, and particularly sweet oranges, are very recalcitrant to anther culture. In this paper it was evaluated for the first time the response of 27 genotypes of Citrus sinensis and of one hybrid C. clementina × C. sinensis, to in vitro anther culture. Ten genotypes of sweet oranges showed embryogenic callus induction, mostly blood sweet oranges genotypes, such as Tarocco, Moro and Sanguinelli. In vitro microspore developmental switches from the gamethophytic to the sporophytic pathway were shown by DAPI staining in microspores of these responsive genotypes, after 10 months in culture. However, microsatellite marker analyses showed that these calli were heterozygous. The flow-cytometric analysis of these embryogenic calli showed the presence of two peaks, corresponding to haploid (n) and diploid (2n) genotypes. Differently, anther cultures of the hybrid C. clementina × C. sinensis produced tri-haploid (3n) embryogenic calli and the embryos obtained were homozygous when analyzed by molecular markers (sample sequence repeats), confirming the more responsive characteristic of clementine to microspore embryogenesis through anther culture.     

Complete Chloroplast Genome Sequence of Omani Lime (Citrus aurantiifolia) and Comparative Analysis within the Rosids

The genus Citrus contains many economically important fruits that are grown worldwide for their high nutritional and medicinal value. Due to frequent hybridizations among species and cultivars, the exact number of natural species and the taxonomic relationships within this genus are unclear. To compare the differences between the Citrus chloroplast genomes and to develop useful genetic markers, we used a reference-assisted approach to assemble the complete chloroplast genome of Omani lime (C. aurantiifolia). The complete C. aurantiifolia chloroplast genome is 159,893 bp in length; the organization and gene content are similar to most of the rosids lineages characterized to date. Through comparison with the sweet orange (C. sinensis) chloroplast genome, we identified three intergenic regions and 94 simple sequence repeats (SSRs) that are potentially informative markers with resolution for interspecific relationships. These markers can be utilized to better understand the origin of cultivated Citrus. A comparison among 72 species belonging to 10 families of representative rosids lineages also provides new insights into their chloroplast genome evolution.     

LTR retrotransposons from the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Citrus x clementina</Emphasis> genome: characterization and application

Long terminal repeat retrotransposons (LTR-RTs) are a large portion of most plant genomes, and can be used as a powerful molecular marker system. The first citrus reference genome (Citrus x clementina) has been publicly available since 2011; however, previous studies in citrus have not utilized the whole genome for LTR-RT marker development. In this study, 3959 full-length LTR-RTs were identified in the C. x clementina genome using structure-based (LTR_FINDER) and homology-based (RepeatMasker) methods. LTR-RTs were first classified by protein domain into Gypsy and Copia superfamilies, and then clustered into 1074 families based on LTR sequence similarity. Three hundred fifty Copia families were grouped into four lineages: Retrofit, Tork, Sire, and Oryco. One hundred seventy-eight Gypsy families were sorted into six lineages: Athila, Tat, Renia, CRM, Galadriel, and Del. Most LTR-RTs (3218 or 81.3%) were anchored to the nine Clementine mandarin linkage groups, accounting for 9.74% of chromosomes currently assembled. Accessions of 25 Rutaceae species were genotyped using 17 inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism (IRAP) markers developed from conserved LTR regions. Sequence-specific amplified polymorphism (SSAP) makers were used to distinguish ‘Valencia’ and ‘Pineapple’ sweet oranges (C. x sinensis), and 24 sweet orange clones. LTR-RT markers developed from the Clementine genome can be transferred within the Rutaceae family demonstrating that they are an excellent tool for citrus and Rutaceae genetic analysis.     

The plastome of Citrus. Physical map,variation among Citrus cultivars and species and comparison with related genera

Summary A physical plastome map was constructed for Citrus aurantium, and the plastomes of species and cultivars of Citrus and of two Citrus relatives were analysed by Southern blot-hybridisation of labelled total tobacco cpDNA to digests of total Citrus DNA. A resemblance was found between the plastomes of cultivars of C. limon (lemon), C. sinensis (orange), C. aurantium (sour orange), C. paradisii (grapefruit) and C. grandis (pomello). The plastomes of other Citrus types such as mandarin (C. reticulata) and citron (C. medico) differed from each other as well as from the plastomes of the aforementioned group. The plastomes of Poncirus trifoliata and Microcitrus sp. are distinct from each other as well as from the Citrus types.     

Genotype Affects the Morphogenic Response in vitro of Epicotyl Segments of Citrus Rootstocks

The influence of light, hormones and explant orientation onin vitro regeneration in epicotyl cuttings was compared in fourCitrus species (C. aurantium, C. macrophylla, C. reshni andC.sinensis ) and the hybrid Troyer citrange (C. sinensis x Poncirustrifoliata). In all cases, explants planted vertically regeneratedshoots at the apical end by a process of direct organogenesiswithout callus formation. When the Troyer citrange explantswere incubated horizontally, regeneration at the apical endoccurred by an indirect organogenic pathway after callus formation.This change in the pathway of regeneration did not occur inany of the Citrus species, and incubation horizontally resultedin a reduction in the number of buds and shoots formed throughthe direct organogenic pathway. Shoot formation through thedirect organogenic pathway was inhibited by darkness, and thisinhibitory effect was counteracted by the cytokinin benzyladeninein Troyer citrange and, partly, in C. sinensis, but not in C.macrophylla. A non-organogenic callus formed at the basal endof most of the cuttings of C. reshni. InC. sinensis and C. aurantium,a non-organogenic callus formed only in a low proportion ofexplants. Troyer citrange formed an organogenic callus in whichbuds or roots differentiated depending on the auxin/cytokininbalance. C. macrophylla formed callus in the dark but not inthe light. Root formation occurred both in the presence of theauxin naphthaleneacetic acid or low concentrations (2.2 to 4.4µM) of the cytokinin benzyladenine, but no buds were formed.These qualitative and quantitative differences in the organogenicresponse indicate that the conditions for regeneration mustbe optimized for each genotype. Copyright 2000 Annals of BotanyCompany Benzyladenine, citrus, Citrus aurantium, Citrus macrophylla, Citrus sinensis, Citrus sinensis x Poncirus trifoliata, naphthaleneacetic acid, organogenesis, rooting, shoot regeneration, Troyer citrange     

Effects of boron toxicity on root and leaf anatomy in two Citrus species differing in boron tolerance

Key message

Typical toxic symptom only occurred in B-toxic C. grandis leaves. B-toxicity induced PCD of C. grandis leaf phloem tissue. The lower leaf free B might contribute to the higher B-tolerance of C. sinensis.

Abstract

Seedlings of ‘Xuegan’ (Citrus sinensis) and ‘Sour pummelo’ (Citrus grandis) differing in boron (B)-tolerance were irrigated with nutrient solution containing 10 (control) or 400 (B-toxic) μM H₃BO₃ for 15 weeks. Thereafter, the effects of B-toxicity on leaf photosynthesis, chlorophyll, plant B absorption and distribution, root and leaf anatomy were investigated to elucidate the possible B-tolerant mechanisms of Citrus plants. Typical toxic symptom only occurred in B-toxic C. grandis leaves. Similarly, B-toxicity only affected C. grandis photosynthesis and chlorophyll. Although total B concentration in B-toxic roots and leaves was similar between the two species, leaves from B-toxic C. grandis plant middle had higher free B and lower bound B as compared with those from C. sinensis. Effects of B-toxicity on leaf structure were mainly limited to the mesophyll cells and the phloem of leaf veins. Although irregular cell wall thickening was observed in leaf cortex cells and phloem tissue of B-toxic C. grandis and C. sinensis leaves, exocytosis only occurred in the companion cells and the parenchyma cells of B-toxic C. sinensis leaf phloem. Also, B-toxicity induced cell death of phloem tissue through autophagy in C. grandis leaf veins. B-toxicity caused death of root epidermal cells of the two Citrus species. B-toxicity restrained degradation of middle lamella, but did not alter ultrastructure of Golgi apparatus and mitochondria in root elongating zone cells. In conclusion, C. sinensis was more tolerant to B-toxicity than C. grandis. The lower leaf free B and higher bound B might contribute to the higher B-tolerance of C. sinensis.     

Test of intron predictions reveals novel splice sites, alternatively spliced mRNAs and new introns in meiotically regulated genes of yeast

Correct identification of all introns is necessary to discern the protein-coding potential of a eukaryotic genome. The existence of most of the spliceosomal introns predicted in the genome of Saccharomyces cerevisiae remains unsupported by molecular evidence. We tested the intron predictions for 87 introns predicted to be present in non-ribosomal protein genes, more than a third of all known or suspected introns in the yeast genome. Evidence supporting 61 of these predictions was obtained, 20 predicted intron sequences were not spliced and six predictions identified an intron-containing region but failed to specify the correct splice sites, yielding a successful prediction rate of <80%. Alternative splicing has not been previously described for this organism, and we identified two genes (YKL186C/MTR2 and YML034W) which encode alternatively spliced mRNAs; YKL186C/MTR2 produces at least five different spliced mRNAs. One gene (YGR225W/SPO70) has an intron whose removal is activated during meiosis under control of the MER1 gene. We found eight new introns, suggesting that numerous introns still remain to be discovered. The results show that correct prediction of introns remains a significant barrier to understanding the structure, function and coding capacity of eukaryotic genomes, even in a supposedly simple system like yeast.     

Citrus biotechnology: Achievements,limitations and future directions

Citrus is one of the most important commercial and nutritional fruit crops in the world, hence it needs to be improved to cater to the diverse needs of consumers and crop breeders. Genetic manipulation through conventional techniques in this genus is invariably a difficult task for plant breeders as it poses various biological limitations comprising long juvenile period, high heterozygosity, sexual incompatibility, nucellar polyembryony and large plant size that greatly hinder cultivar improvement. Hence, several attempts were made to improve Citrus sps. by using various in vitro techniques. Citrus sps are widely known for their recalcitrance to transformation and subsequent rooting, but constant research has led to the establishment of improved protocols to ensure the production of uniformly transformed plants, albeit with relatively low efficiency, depending upon the genotype. Genetic modification through Agrobacterium-mediated transformation has emerged as an important tool for introducing agronomically important genes into Citrus sps. Somatic hybridization has been applied to overcome self and cross-incompatibility barriers and generated inter-specific and inter-generic hybrids. Encouraging results have been achieved through transgenics for resistance against viruses and bacteria, thereby augmenting the yield and quality of the fruit. Now, when major transformation and regeneration protocols have sufficiently been standardized for important cultivars, ongoing citrus research focuses mainly on incorporating such genes in citrus genotypes that can combat different biotic and abiotic stresses. This review summarizes the advances made so far in Citrus biotechnology, and suggests some future directions of research in this fruit crop.Key words: Citrus sinensis, Citrus tristeza virus, Citrus regeneration, Citrus transformation     

Analysis of the role of Caenorhabditis elegans GC-AG introns in regulated splicing

GC-AG introns represent 0.7% of total human pre-mRNA introns. To study the function of GC-AG introns in splicing regulation, 196 cDNA-confirmed GC-AG introns were identified in Caenorhabditis elegans. These represent 0.6% of the cDNA- confirmed intron data set for this organism. Eleven of these GC-AG introns are involved in alternative splicing. In a comparison of the genomic sequences of homologous genes between C.elegans and Caenorhabditis briggsae for 26 GC-AG introns, the C at the +2 position is conserved in only five of these introns. A system to experimentally test the function of GC-AG introns in alternative splicing was developed. Results from these experiments indicate that the conserved C at the +2 position of the tenth intron of the let-2 gene is essential for developmentally regulated alternative splicing. This C allows the splice donor to function as a very weak splice site that works in balance with an alternative GT splice donor. A weak GT splice donor can functionally replace the GC splice donor and allow for splicing regulation. These results indicate that while the majority of GC-AG introns appear to be constitutively spliced and have no evolutionary constraints to prevent them from being GT-AG introns, a subset of GC-AG introns is involved in alternative splicing and the C at the +2 position of these introns can have an important role in splicing regulation.     

Cross-reactive Antigens between Xanthomonas campestris pv. citri Pathotypes and Citrus Species

Cross-reactive antigens were detected in crude and semi-purified preparations from acetone powder of Citrus aurantifolia and Citrus sinensis leaves with antisera to Xanthomonas campestris pv. citri pathotypes A and C by DAS-ELISA. Antiserum to X. campestris pv. citri pathotype C revealed an antigenic disparity between C. aurantifolia (susceptible host to pathotype C) and C. sinensis (resistant host to pathotype C) whereas antiserum to X, campestris pv. citri pathotype A did not reveal any antigenic disparity between these hosts, both susceptible to pathotype A. The occurrence of “key” cross-reactive antigens in Citrus species and X. campestris pv. citri and their possible involvement in such interaction are discussed.