Effects of CO2 concentrations on the freshwater microalgae, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, Chlorella pyrenoidosa and Scenedesmus obliquus (Chlorophyta)

In order to investigate the possible impacts of increased atmospheric CO₂ levels on algal growth and photosynthesis, the influence of CO₂ concentration was tested on three planktonic algae (Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, Chlorella pyrenoidosa, and Scenedesmus obliquus). Increased CO₂ concentration enhanced significantly the growth rate of all three species. Specific growth rates reached maximal values at 30, 100, and 60 M CO₂ in C. reinhardtii, C. pyrenoidosa, and S. obliquus, respectively. Such significant enhancement of growth rate with enriched CO₂ was also confirmed at different levels of inorganic N and P, being more profound at limiting levels of N inC. pyrenoidosa and P in S. obliquus. The maximal rates of net photosynthesis, photosynthetic efficiency and light-saturating point increased significantly (p < 0.05) in high-CO₂-grown cells. Elevation of the CO₂ levels in cultures enhanced the photoinhibition of C. reinhardtii, but reduced that of C. pyrenoidosa and S. obliquus when exposed to high photon flux density. The photoinhibited cells recovered to some extent (from 71% to 99%) when placed under dim light or in darkness, with better recovery in high-CO₂-grownC. pyrenoidosa and S. obliquus. Although pH and pCO₂ effects cannot be distinguished from this study, it can be concluded that increased CO₂ concentrations with decreased pH could affect the growth rate and photosynthetic physiology of C. reinhardtii, C. pyrenoidosa, and S. obliquus.     

A culture method for microalgal forms using two-tier vessel providing carbon-dioxide environment: studies on growth and carotenoid production

A culture method was developed for photoautotrophic culture of Haematococcus pluvialis, Chlorella vulgaris, Scenedesmus obliquus, Spirulina platensis, Nostoc and Stigonema in a two-tier flask consisting of nutrient media in the upper chamber and CO₂ generating buffer mixture (KHCO₃/K₂CO₃) in the lower chamber. The concentration of buffer mixture was varied to obtain desired levels of CO₂. CO₂ at 2.0% (v/v) level enhanced growth and chlorophyll content over control cultures (without CO₂ supplementation) in all microalgal species. Haematococcus pluvialis culture in BBM and KM1 media showed 6.71- and 2.07-fold increase in biomass yields with astaxanthin productivity at 7.26 and 7.48 mg l^–1 level respectively. CO₂ supplementation to C. vulgaris and S. obliquus cultures resulted in 5.97- and 7.30-folds increase in biomass with 2–3 fold increase in chlorophyll and carotenoid contents over their respective controls. Similarly 2–3 fold increase in chlorophyll and carotenoid contents were observed in Sp. platensis, Nostoc and Stigonema spp. This culture methodology will provide information on CO₂ requirement for growth of algae and metabolite production and also facilitates studies on the influence of light and temperature conditions.     

Microalgae as a raw material for biofuels production

Biofuels demand is unquestionable in order to reduce gaseous emissions (fossil CO₂, nitrogen and sulfur oxides) and their purported greenhouse, climatic changes and global warming effects, to face the frequent oil supply crises, as a way to help non-fossil fuel producer countries to reduce energy dependence, contributing to security of supply, promoting environmental sustainability and meeting the EU target of at least of 10% biofuels in the transport sector by 2020. Biodiesel is usually produced from oleaginous crops, such as rapeseed, soybean, sunflower and palm. However, the use of microalgae can be a suitable alternative feedstock for next generation biofuels because certain species contain high amounts of oil, which could be extracted, processed and refined into transportation fuels, using currently available technology; they have fast growth rate, permit the use of non-arable land and non-potable water, use far less water and do not displace food crops cultures; their production is not seasonal and they can be harvested daily. The screening of microalgae (Chlorella vulgaris, Spirulina maxima, Nannochloropsis sp., Neochloris oleabundans, Scenedesmus obliquus and Dunaliella tertiolecta) was done in order to choose the best one(s), in terms of quantity and quality as oil source for biofuel production. Neochloris oleabundans (fresh water microalga) and Nannochloropsis sp. (marine microalga) proved to be suitable as raw materials for biofuel production, due to their high oil content (29.0 and 28.7%, respectively). Both microalgae, when grown under nitrogen shortage, show a great increase (~50%) in oil quantity. If the purpose is to produce biodiesel only from one species, Scenedesmus obliquus presents the most adequate fatty acid profile, namely in terms of linolenic and other polyunsaturated fatty acids. However, the microalgae Neochloris oleabundans, Nannochloropsis sp. and Dunaliella tertiolecta can also be used if associated with other microalgal oils and/or vegetable oils.     

Chemical,physical and biological changes associated with chara succession in farm ponds

Four farm ponds in various stages of Chara vulgaris succession -from the initial invasion of the alga to its nearly complete replacement-were followed each week from ice cover to ice cover. Chemical, physical, and biological parameters were analyzed in order to determine differences between ponds and to discover the biological and physicochemical factors associated with succession in Chara vulgaris ponds. The data were analyzed statistically by intraclass (single factor) analysis of variance, the Student's t-test, and stepwise multiple regression analysis.The initial invasion of C. vulgaris appeared to be preceded by a lowering of the nutrient levels of the pond by Zygnematales growth and by the substrate-stabilizing growth of Rhizoclonium sp. Chara-dominated ponds had significantly lower free CO₂, bicarbonate alkalinity, and total hardness readings. Carbonate alkalinity, low phytoplankton productivity, high dissolved O₂, low phosphate, and high Secchi disk readings were also characteristic of ponds in which C. vulgaris was dominant.In ponds where C. vulgaris appeared in the process of being replaced, the physicochemical factors were more closely associated with phytoplankton productivity and diversity and less closely with submerged vegetation species.Succession from C. vulgaris domination to a Najas-Potamogeton community appeared to involve shading of the former by the latter and was accelerated by the smothering effect of decaying debris caused by Gloeotrichia sp.In the final stages of succession, turbid conditions resulting from the lack of substrate-stabilizing vegetation and increased phytoplankton growth appear to have discouraged C. vulgaris growth early in the season.     

Influence of enhanced CO2 on growth and photosynthesis of the red algaeGracilaria sp. andG. chilensis

The influence of elevated CO₂ concentrations on growth and photosynthesis ofGracilaria sp. andG. chilensis was investigated in order to procure information on the effective utilization of CO₂. Growth of both was enhanced by CO₂ enrichment (air + 650 ppm CO₂, air + 1250 ppm CO₂, the enhancement being greater inGracilaria sp. Both species increased uptake of NO₃ ^– with CO₂ enrichment. Photosynthetic inorganic carbon uptake was depressed inG. chilensis by pre-culture (15 days) with CO₂ enrichment, but little affected inGracilaria sp. Mass spectrometric analysis showed that O₂ uptake was higher in the light than in the dark for both species and in both cases was higher inGracilaria sp. The higher growth enhancement inGracilaria sp. was attributed to greater depression of photorespiration by the enrichment of CO₂ in culture.     

Effect of external CO2 concentrations on protein synthesis in the green algae Scenedesmus obliquus (Turp.) Kütz and Chlorella vulgaris (Kosikov)

Unicellular algae grown under low-CO₂ conditions (0.03% CO₂) have developed a means of concentrating CO₂ at the site of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase. Cells with the CO₂-concentrating mechanism (CCM) acquire the ability to accumulate inorganic carbon to a level higher than that obtained by simple diffusion. To identify proteins which are involved in the organization of the CCM, cells of Scenedesumus obliquus and Chlorella vulgaris grown in high CO₂ (5% CO₂ in air) were transferred to low-CO₂ (0.03%) conditions in the presence of ³⁵SO _inf4 ^sup2? and, thereafter, polypeptides labeled with ³⁵S were detected. Under low-CO₂ conditions the inducton of 36-, 39-, 94- and 110- to 116kDa polypeptides were particularly observed in S. obliquus and 16-, 19-, 27-, 36-, 38- and 45-kDa polypeptides were induced in C. vulgaris. Western blots with antibodies raised against 37-kDa subunits of the periplasmic carbonic anhydrase (CA) of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii showed immunoreactive bands with the 39-kDa polypeptide in the whole-cell homogenates from S. obliquus and with 36 and 38-kDa polypeptides in both high- and low-CO₂grown cells of C. vulgaris. Anti-pea-chloroplast CA antibodies cross-reacted with a single polypeptide of 30 kDa in the whole-cell homogenates but not with thylakoid membranes. The CA activity was associated with soluble and membrane-bound fractions, except thylakoid membranes.     

Growth of a manganese oxidizing Pseudomonas sp. in continuous culture

Strain S-36, a marine Pseudomonas sp., was grown under manganese limitation in continuous culture. At dilution rates below a maximal growth rate of 0.066 h^-1, the rate at which the organism fixed CO₂ into macromolecules was equal to the cell carbon production rate. In addition, the total amount of cell carbon or CO₂ fixed at steady-state was in proportion to the amount of energy available from the oxidation of Mn²⁺ in the medium. These data suggest that the organism can grow by obtaining the energy for CO₂ fixation from manganese oxidation.     

Effects of phenolic compounds on growth and metabolic activities of Chlorella vulgaris and Scenedesmus bijugatus isolated from soil

Phenol and three nitrophenols (o-nitrophenol, m-nitrophenol, p-nitrophenol), commonly occurring pollutants in natural eco-systems, were tested for their toxic effects on soil isolates of Chlorella vulgaris and Scenedesmus bijugatus, growing under phototrophic, photoheterotrophic and heterotrophic conditions. The toxicity criteria included cell number, chlorophyll, total protein and carbohydrate content, ¹⁴CO₂ uptake and in vivo nitrate reductase activity. Both C. vulgaris and S. bijugatus were sensitive to the pollutants when the cultures were grown under phototrophic or heterotrophic conditions. However, the toxicity was found reversed or alleviated upon photoheterotrophic growth of the cultures. Transmission electron microscope studies revealed various cytological abnormalities in C. vulgaris in the presence of phenolics at algistatic levels.     

On-line estimation of O<Subscript>2</Subscript> production,CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> uptake,and growth kinetics of microalgal cultures in a gas-tight photobioreactor

Growth of the green algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and Chlorella sp. in batch cultures was investigated in a novel gas-tight photobioreactor, in which CO₂, H₂, and N₂ were titrated into the gas phase to control medium pH, dissolved oxygen partial pressure, and headspace pressure, respectively. The exit gas from the reactor was circulated through a loop of tubing and re-introduced into the culture. CO₂ uptake was estimated from the addition of CO₂ as acidic titrant and O₂ evolution was estimated from titration by H₂, which was used to reduce O₂ over a Pd catalyst. The photosynthetic quotient, PQ, was estimated as the ratio between O₂ evolution and CO₂ up-take rates. NH₄ ⁺, NO₂ ⁻, or NO₃ ⁻ was the final cell density limiting nutrient. Cultures of both algae were, in general, characterised by a nitrogen sufficient growth phase followed by a nitrogen depleted phase in which starch was the major product. The estimated PQ values were dependent on the level of oxidation of the nitrogen source. The PQ was 1 with NH₄ ⁺ as the nitrogen source and 1.3 when NO₃ ⁻ was the nitrogen source. In cultures grown on all nitrogen sources, the PQ value approached 1 when the nitrogen source was depleted and starch synthesis became dominant, to further increase towards 1.3 over a period of 3–4 days. This latter increase in PQ, which was indicative of production of reduced compounds like lipids, correlated with a simultaneous increase in the degree of reduction of the biomass. When using the titrations of CO₂ and H₂ into the reactor headspace to estimate the up-take of CO₂, the production of O₂, and the PQ, the rate of biomass production could be followed, the stoichiometrical composition of the produced algal biomass could be estimated, and different growth phases could be identified.     

Influence of carbon-dioxide on the growth of Spirulina sp. (MCRC-A0003) isolated from Muttukadu backwaters,South India

Growth of Spirulina sp. (MCRC-A0003), a cyanobacterium, was evaluated under different concentrations of carbon-dioxide (CO₂) (4–50 %) in a closed glass photobioreactor. Although significant CO₂ utilization by the cyanobacterial strain was observed up to 50 % concentration, complete utilization was observed only at 4, 10 and 20 % concentrations on 3rd, 6th and 8th day respectively. However, considerable reduction was witnessed in reactors containing 30–50 % CO₂ only between 6th and 9th day. A corresponding increase in the biomass and primary metabolites like chlorophyll-a, carbohydrate and protein were observed. Biomass productivity of Spirulina in reactors sparged with 4, 10 and 20 % CO₂ were 13.7, 43 and 44 % more than that in control reactor without CO₂. While CO₂ increased the levels of primary metabolites in the cyanobacterial cells, it was quite prominent in 10 % CO₂ concentration with the chlorophyll-a, carbohydrate and protein contents were 64, 183 and 626 mg g^?1 respectively. While 10 and 6.6 % increase were noticed in chlorophyll-a and protein, 17 % increase in carbohydrate levels was observed in Spirulina cells, which could be attributed to the conversion of CO₂ to carbohydrate by the cyanobacterium.     

Luminescence decay kinetics in relation to quenching and stimulation of dark fluorescence from high and low CO2 adapted cells of Scenedesmus obliquus and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Two green algal species, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and Scenedesmus obliquus, exhibited a relative maximum during the decay of luminescence, when adapted to low CO₂ conditions that was not observed in high CO₂ adapted cells.From the kinetics of transient changes in the level of dark fluorescence, after illumination and parallel to the luminescence maxima, it was concluded that the maximum in Scenedesmus was mainly related to a decrease in nonphotochemical quenching, whereas in Chlamydomonas the maximum was mainly related to a dark reduction of the primary PS II acceptor Q_A.ATP/ADP ratios from low CO₂ adapted Scenedesmus showed transient high levels after a dark/light transition that was not observed in high CO₂ adapted cells. After 30 s of illumination the ATP/ADP ratios however stabilized at the same steady state level as in high CO₂ adapted cells.Dark addition of HCO₃ ^- to low CO₂ adapted cells of Chlamydomonas resulted in a rapid transient quenching of luminescence that was not observed in low CO₂ adapted cells of neither species.It is concluded that the luminescence maxima present in both low CO₂ adapted Scenedesmus and Chlamydomonas reflect adaptation of the cells to low CO₂ conditions. It is further suggested that the difference in mechanistic origin of luminescence maxima in the two species reflects differences in adaptation.Abbreviations ADP adenosine-diphosphate - ATP adenosine-triphosphate - C_i inorganic carbon - F_D dark fluorescence recorded under dark adapted conditions - F₀ fluorescence with all reaction centers open - FV variable fluorescence - PS I photosystem I - PS II photosystem II - Q_A the first quinone acceptor of PS II     

Nitrogen and Carbon Concentrations, and Stable Isotope Ratios in Mediterranean Shrubs Growing in the Proximity of a CO2 spring

Seasonal changes in foliage nitrogen (N) and carbon (C) concentrations and δ¹⁵N and δ¹³C ratios were monitored during a year in Erica arborea, Myrtus communis and Juniperus communis co-occurring at a natural CO₂ spring (elevated [CO₂], about 700 μmol mol⁻¹) and at a nearby control site (ambient [CO₂], 360 μmol mol⁻¹) in a Mediterranean environment. Leaf N concentration was lower in elevated [CO₂] than in ambient [CO₂] for M. communis, higher for J. communis, and dependent on the season for E. arborea. Leaf C concentration was negatively affected by atmospheric CO₂ enrichment, regardless of the species. C/N ratio varied concomitantly to N. Leaves in elevated [CO₂] showed lower δ¹³C, and therefore likely lower water use efficiencies than leaves at the control site, regardless of the species, suggesting substantial photosynthetic acclimation under long-term CO₂-enriched atmosphere. Leaves of E. arborea showed lower values of δ¹⁵N under elevated [CO₂], but this was not the case of M. communis and J. communis foliage. The use of the resources and leaf chemical composition are affected by elevated [CO₂], but such an effect varies during the year, and is species-dependent. The seasonal dependency and species specificity suggest that plants are able to exploit different available water and N resources within Mediterranean sites. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Innovative development of membrane sparger for carbon dioxide supply in microalgae cultures

The present study was aimed to develop a membrane sparger (MS) integrated into a tubular photobioreactor to promote the increase of the carbon dioxide (CO₂) fixation by Spirulina sp. LEB 18 cultures. The use of MS for the CO₂ supply in Spirulina cultures resulted not only in the increase of DIC concentrations but also in the highest accumulated DIC concentration in the liquid medium (127.4 mg L⁻¹ d⁻¹). The highest values of biomass concentration (1.98 g L⁻¹), biomass productivity (131.8 mg L⁻¹ d⁻¹), carbon in biomass (47.9% w w⁻¹), CO₂ fixation rate (231.6 mg L⁻¹ d⁻¹), and CO₂ use efficiency (80.5% w w⁻¹) by Spirulina were verified with MS, compared to the culture with conventional sparger for CO₂ supply. Spirulina biomass in both culture conditions had high protein contents varying from 64.9 to 69% (w w⁻¹). MS can be considered an innovative system for the supply of carbon for the microalgae cultivation and biomass production. Moreover, the use of membrane system might contribute to increased process efficiency with a reduced cost of biomass production.     

Comparative studies on photosynthetic enzymes of the symbiotic Chlorella from Paramecium bursaria and other symbiotic and non-symbiotic Chlorella strains

The activities of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase and of carbonic anhydrase were studied in cell-free extracts of two symbiotic Chlorella strains isolated from Paramecium bursaria and from Spongilla sp., and of two nonsymbiotic strains of Chlorella (Chlorella fusca and Chlorella vulgaris) cultivated at varied CO₂-concentrations. The symbiotic Chlorella of Paramecium bursaria differs distinctly from the other Chlorella strains by a higher activity of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase, which is independent of the actual CO₂-concentration, and by a lack of carbonic anhydrase activity. These properties are discussed with respect to their ecological significance.Abbreviations CA carbonic anhydrase - Pbi Paramecium bursaria isolate - RuBP ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate Dedicated to Prof. Dr. André Pirson on the occasion of his 70th birthday     

Acetate and carbon dioxide assimilation by Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Marburg), growing on hydrogen and sulfate as sole energy source

Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Marburg) was grown on hydrogen plus sulfate as sole energy source and acetate plus CO₂ as the sole carbon sources. The incorporation of U-¹⁴C acetate into alanine, aspartate, glutamate, and ribose was studied. The labelling data show that alanine is synthesized from one acetate (C-2 + C-3) and one CO₂ (C-1), aspartate from one acetate (C-2 + C-3) and two CO₂ (C-1 + C-4), glutamate from two acetate (C-1–C-4) and one CO₂ (C-5), and ribose from 1.8 acetate and 1.4 CO₂. These findings indicate that in Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Marburg) pyruvate is formed via reductive carboxylation of acetyl-CoA, oxaloacetate via carboxylation of pyruvate or phosphoenol pyruvate, and -ketoglutarate from oxaloacetate plus acetyl-CoA via citrate and isocitrate. Since C-5 of glutamate is derived from CO₂, citrate must have been formed via a (R)-citrate synthase rather than a(S)-citrate synthase. The synthesis of ribose from 1.8 mol of acetate and 1.4 mol of CO₂ excludes the operation of the Calvin cycle in this chemolithotrophically growing bacterium.     

Characterisation of CO2 and HCO3 − uptake in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC6803

The availability of a complete genome database for the cyanobacterium Synechocystissp. PCC6803 (glucose-tolerant strain) has raised expectations that this organism would become a reference strain for work aimed at understanding the CO₂-concentrating mechanism (CCM) in cyanobacteria. However, the amount of physiological data available has been relatively limited. In this report we provide data on the relative contributions of net HCO₃ ⁻ uptake and CO₂ uptake under steady state photosynthetic conditions. Cells were compared after growth at high CO₂ (2% v/v in air) or limiting CO₂ conditions (20 ppm CO₂). Synechocystishas a very high dependence on net HCO₃ ⁻ uptake at low to medium concentrations of inorganic carbon (Ci). At high Ci concentrations net CO₂ uptake became more important but did not contribute more than 40% to the rate of photosynthetic O₂ evolution. The data also confirm that high Ci cells of Synechocystissp. PCC6803 possess a strong capacity for net HCO₃ ⁻ uptake under steady state photosynthetic conditions. Time course experiments show that induction of maximal Ci uptake capacity on a shift from high CO₂ to low CO₂ conditions was near completion by four hours. By contrast, relaxation of the induced state on return of cells to high CO₂, takes in excess of 230 h. Experiments were conducted to determine if Synechocystissp. PCC6803 is able to exhibit a `fast induction' response under severe Ci limitation and whether glucose was capable of causing a rapid inactivation in Ci uptake capacity. Clear evidence for either response was not found. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

A correlation between changes in luminescence decay kinetics and the appearance of a CO2-accumulating mechanism in Scenedesmus obliquus

In experiments with the unicellular green algae Scenedesmus obliquus a correlation was found between the presence of the CO₂-accumulating mechanism and the appearance of polyphasic luminescence decay kinetics. A potentiometric titration method was used to measure and calculate photosynthetic carbon uptake.Polyphasic luminescence decay kinetics was found when the algae showed photosynthetic characteristics typical of algae adapted to low-CO₂ conditions. When high-CO₂ grown algae were transferred to low-CO₂ conditions they gradually developed polyphasic decay kinetics during the first 25–30 minutes. When low-CO₂ grown algae were transferred to high-CO₂ conditions the polyphasic decay kinetics disappeared. To account for these results a working hypothesis is presented on the basis of the energy requirement for a CO₂-accumulating mechanism.     

Use of Chlorella vulgaris for CO(2) mitigation in a photobioreactor

Carbon dioxide (CO₂) is a colorless gas that exists at a concentration of approximately 330 ppm in the atmosphere and is released in great quantities when fossil fuels are burned. The current flux of carbon out of fossil fuels is about 600 times greater than that into fossil fuels. With increased concerns about global warming and greenhouse gas emissions, there have been several approaches proposed for managing the levels of CO₂ emitted into the atmosphere. One of the most understudied methods for CO₂ mitigation is the use of biological processes in engineered systems such as photobioreactors. This research project describes the effectiveness of Chlorella vulgaris, used in a photobioreactor with a very short gas residence time, in sequestering CO₂ from an elevated CO₂ airstream. We evaluated a flow-through photobioreactor's operational parameters, as well as the growth characteristics of the C. vulgaris inoculum when exposed to an airstream with over 1850 ppm CO₂. When using dry weight, chlorophyll, and direct microscopic measurements, it was apparent that the photobioreactor's algal inoculum responded well to the elevated CO₂ levels and there was no build-up of CO₂ or carbonic acid in the photobioreactor. The photobioreactor, with a gas residence time of approximately 2 s, was able to remove up to 74% of the CO₂ in the airstream to ambient levels. This corresponded to a 63.9-g/m³/h bulk removal for the experimental photobioreactor. Consequently, this photobioreactor shows that biological processes may have some promise for treating point source emissions of CO₂ and deserve further study. Received 25 April 2002/ Accepted in revised form 27 July 2002     

Harvesting of Chlorella vulgaris using a bioflocculant from Paenibacillus sp. AM49

Microbial flocculants for harvesting mass cultured Chlorella vulgaris were screened and that from Paenibacillussp. AM49 was identified as the best. The flocculation efficiency of this bioflocculant increased with the pH within a range of pH 5–11 and was 83%, which was higher than the 72% and 78% produced by aluminum sulfate and polyacrylamide, respectively. The highest flocculation efficiency was with 6.8 mm CaCl₂ as co-flocculant. The bioflocculant from Paenibacillussp. AM49 can be used effectively to harvest C. vulgaris from large-scale cultures.     

Short-term carbon-isotope discrimination in C3−C4 intermediate species

Short-term discrimination in assimilation of stable isotopes of carbon was measured for leaves of the C₃ speciesPhaseolus vulgaris L. cv. Hawkesbury Wonder andFlaveria pringlei Gandoger, the C₄ speciesAmaranthus edulis Speg., and the C₃–C₄ intermediate speciesPanicum milioides Nees ex. Trin,Flaveria floridana Johnson, andFlaveria anomala B.L. Robinson. Discriminations in the C₃ and C₄ species were similar to those expected from theoretical considerations. When ambient CO₂ pressure was 330 bar the mean discriminations in the C₃ species andPanicum milioides were similar, whereas the mean discriminations inF. floridana andF. anomala were less than discrimination in C₃ species andPanicum milioides. When ambient CO₂ pressure was 100 bar the mean discriminations inPanicum milioides andF. anomala were greater, and that inF. floridana was less, than that inPhaseolus vulgaris. We conclude that the pattern of discrimination inPanicum milioides is consistent with the presence of a glycine shuttle; inF. floridana andF. anomala, discrimination is consistent with the presence of a C₄ pathway coupled with the operation of a glycine shuttle.Abbreviations and symbols PEP phosphoenolpyruvate - Rubisco ribulose, 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase (EC 4.1.1.39) - p _a ambient CO₂ pressure - p _i intercellular CO₂ pressure - carbon-isotope discrimination - carbonisotope composition relative to PeeDee Belemnite