Amino acid similarity matrices based on force fields

MOTIVATION: We propose a general method for deriving amino acid substitution matrices from low resolution force fields. Unlike current popular methods, the approach does not rely on evolutionary arguments or alignment of sequences or structures. Instead, residues are computationally mutated and their contribution to the total energy/score is collected. The average of these values over each position within a set of proteins results in a substitution matrix. RESULTS: Example substitution matrices have been calculated from force fields based on different philosophies and their performance compared with conventional substitution matrices. Although this can produce useful substitution matrices, the methodology highlights the virtues, deficiencies and biases of the source force fields. It also allows a rather direct comparison of sequence alignment methods with the score functions underlying protein sequence to structure threading. AVAILABILITY: Example substitution matrices are available from http://www.rsc.anu.edu.au/~zsuzsa/suppl/matrices.html. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The list of proteins used for data collection and the optimized parameters for the alignment are given as supplementary material at http://www.rsc.anu.edu.au/~zsuzsa/suppl/matrices.html.     

Estimation of amino acid residue substitution rates at local spatial regions and application in protein function inference: a Bayesian Monte Carlo approach

The amino acid sequences of proteins provide rich information for inferring distant phylogenetic relationships and for predicting protein functions. Estimating the rate matrix of residue substitutions from amino acid sequences is also important because the rate matrix can be used to develop scoring matrices for sequence alignment. Here we use a continuous time Markov process to model the substitution rates of residues and develop a Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo method for rate estimation. We validate our method using simulated artificial protein sequences. Because different local regions such as binding surfaces and the protein interior core experience different selection pressures due to functional or stability constraints, we use our method to estimate the substitution rates of local regions. Our results show that the substitution rates are very different for residues in the buried core and residues on the solvent-exposed surfaces. In addition, the rest of the proteins on the binding surfaces also have very different substitution rates from residues. Based on these findings, we further develop a method for protein function prediction by surface matching using scoring matrices derived from estimated substitution rates for residues located on the binding surfaces. We show with examples that our method is effective in identifying functionally related proteins that have overall low sequence identity, a task known to be very challenging.     

Genome bias influences amino acid choices: analysis of amino acid substitution and re-compilation of substitution matrices exclusive to an AT-biased genome

The genomic era has seen a remarkable increase in the number of genomes being sequenced and annotated. Nonetheless, annotation remains a serious challenge for compositionally biased genomes. For the preliminary annotation, popular nucleotide and protein comparison methods such as BLAST are widely employed. These methods make use of matrices to score alignments such as the amino acid substitution matrices. Since a nucleotide bias leads to an overall bias in the amino acid composition of proteins, it is possible that a genome with nucleotide bias may have introduced atypical amino acid substitutions in its proteome. Consequently, standard matrices fail to perform well in sequence analysis of these genomes. To address this issue, we examined the amino acid substitution in the AT-rich genome of Plasmodium falciparum, chosen as a reference and reconstituted a substitution matrix in the genome's context. The matrix was used to generate protein sequence alignments for the parasite proteins that improved across the functional regions. We attribute this to the consistency that may have been achieved amid the target and background frequencies calculated exclusively in our study. This study has important implications on annotation of proteins that are of experimental interest but give poor sequence alignments with standard conventional matrices.     

A method of estimating from two aligned present-day DNA sequences their ancestral composition and subsequent rates of substitution,possibly different in the two lineages,corrected for multiple and parallel substitutions at the same site

Summary The course of evolutionary change in DNA sequences has been modeled as a Markov process. The Markov process was represented by discrete time matrix methods. The parameters of the Markov transition matrices were estimated by least-squares direct-search optimization of the fit of the calculated divergence matrix to that observed for two aligned sequences. The Markov process corrected for multiple and parallel substitutions of bases at the same site. The method avoided the incorrect assumption of all previously described methods that the divergence between two present-day sequences is twice the divergence of either from the common and unknown ancestral sequence. The three previous methods were shown to be equivalent. The present method also avoided the undesirable assumptions that sequence composition has not changed with time and that the substitution rates in the two descendant lineages were the same. It permitted simultaneous estimation of ancestral sequence composition and, if applicable, of different substitution rates for the two descendant lineages, provided the total number of estimated parameters was less than 16. Properties of the Markov chain were discussed. It was proved for symmetric substitution matrices that all elements of the equilibrium divergence matrix equal 1/16, and that the total difference in the divergence matrix at epoch k equals the total change in the common substitution matrix at epoch 2k for all values of k. It was shown how to resolve an ambiguity in the assignment of two different substitution rates to the two descendant lineages when four or more similar sequences are available. The method was applied to the divergence matrix for codon site 3 for the mouse and rabbit beta-globins. This observed divergence matrix was significantly asymmetric and required at least two different substitution rates. This result could be achieved only by using different asymmetric substitution matrices for the two lineages.     

Predicting functional sites in proteins: site-specific evolutionary models and their application to neurotransmitter transporters

Currently there exist several computational methods for predicting the functional sites in a set of homologous proteins based on their sequences. Due to difficulties in defining the functional site in a protein, it is not trivial to compare the performance of these methods, evaluate their limitations and quantify improvements by new approaches. Here, we use extensive mutation data from two proteins, Lac repressor and subtilisin, to perform such an analysis. Along with the evaluation of existing approaches, we describe a site class model of evolution as a tool to predict functional sites in proteins. The results indicate that this model, which simulates the evolution process at the amino acid level using site-specific substitution matrices, provides the most accurate information on functional sites in a given protein family. Secondly, we present an application of this model to neurotransmitter transporters, a superfamily of proteins of which we have limited experimental knowledge. Based on this application we present testable hypotheses regarding the mechanism of action of these proteins.     

Protein sequence-similarity search acceleration using a heuristic algorithm with a sensitive matrix

Protein database search for public databases is a fundamental step in the target selection of proteins in structural and functional genomics and also for inferring protein structure, function, and evolution. Most database search methods employ amino acid substitution matrices to score amino acid pairs. The choice of substitution matrix strongly affects homology detection performance. We earlier proposed a substitution matrix named MIQS that was optimized for distant protein homology search. Herein we further evaluate MIQS in combination with LAST, a heuristic and fast database search tool with a tunable sensitivity parameter m, where larger m denotes higher sensitivity. Results show that MIQS substantially improves the homology detection and alignment quality performance of LAST across diverse m parameters. Against a protein database consisting of approximately 15 million sequences, LAST with m?=?10⁵ achieves better homology detection performance than BLASTP, and completes the search 20 times faster. Compared to the most sensitive existing methods being used today, CS-BLAST and SSEARCH, LAST with MIQS and m?=?10⁶ shows comparable homology detection performance at 2.0 and 3.9 times greater speed, respectively. Results demonstrate that MIQS-powered LAST is a time-efficient method for sensitive and accurate homology search.     

The estimation of relative site variability among aligned homologous protein sequences

MOTIVATION: Maximum likelihood-based methods to estimate site by site substitution rate variability in aligned homologous protein sequences rely on the formulation of a phylogenetic tree and generally assume that the patterns of relative variability follow a pre-determined distribution. We present a phylogenetic tree-independent method to estimate the relative variability of individual sites within large datasets of homologous protein sequences. It is based upon two simple assumptions. Firstly that substitutions observed between two closely related sequences are likely, in general, to occur at the most variable sites. Secondly that non-conservative amino acid substitutions tend to occur at more variable sites. Our methodology makes no assumptions regarding the underlying pattern of relative variability between sites. RESULTS: We have compared, using data simulated under a non-gamma distributed model, the performance of this approach to that of a maximum likelihood method that assumes gamma distributed rates. At low mean rates of evolution our method inferred site by site relative substitution rates more accurately than the maximum likelihood approach in the absence of prior assumptions about the relationships between sequences. Our method does not directly account for the effects of mutational saturation, However, we have incorporated an 'ad-hoc' modification that allows the accurate estimation of relative site variability in fast evolving and saturated datasets.     

Construction of non-symmetric substitution matrices derived from proteomes with biased amino acid distributions

Automatic comparison of compositionally biased genomes, such as that of the malarial causative agent Plasmodium falciparum (82% adenosine + thymidine), with genomes of average composition, is currently limited. Indeed, popular tools such as BLAST require that amino acid distributions be similar in aligned sequences. However, the P. falciparum genome is so biased that six amino acids account for more than 50% of the protein composition. One reason for the comparison methods failure lies in the compositional difference between the query and the subject proteomes, which is not taken into account in the amino acid substitution matrices. This paper introduces a method to derive substitution matrices, in particular BLOSUM 62, in the frame of the information theory. It allows the construction of non-symmetrical matrices, taking into account the non-symmetric amino acid distributions. The dirAtPf family of matrices allowing the comparison of P. falciparum and A. thaliana is given as an example. This paper further provides an analysis of the obtained matrices in the frame of the information theory, supporting the discrimination advantage they bring.     

Periodic distributions of hydrophobic amino acids allows the definition of fundamental building blocks to align distantly related proteins

Several studies on large and small families of proteins proved in a general manner that hydrophobic amino acids are globally conserved even if they are subjected to high rate substitution. Statistical analysis of amino acids evolution within blocks of hydrophobic amino acids detected in sequences suggests their usage as a basic structural pattern to align pairs of proteins of less than 25% sequence identity, with no need of knowing their 3D structure. The authors present a new global alignment method and an automatic tool for Proteins with HYdrophobic Blocks ALignment (PHYBAL) based on the combinatorics of overlapping hydrophobic blocks. Two substitution matrices modeling a different selective pressure inside and outside hydrophobic blocks are constructed, the Inside Hydrophobic Blocks Matrix and the Outside Hydrophobic Blocks Matrix, and a 4D space of gap values is explored. PHYBAL performance is evaluated against Needleman and Wunsch algorithm run with Blosum 30, Blosum 45, Blosum 62, Gonnet, HSDM, PAM250, Johnson and Remote Homo matrices. PHYBAL behavior is analyzed on eight randomly selected pairs of proteins of >30% sequence identity that cover a large spectrum of structural properties. It is also validated on two large datasets, the 127 pairs of the Domingues dataset with >30% sequence identity, and 181 pairs issued from BAliBASE 2.0 and ranked by percentage of identity from 7 to 25%. Results confirm the importance of considering substitution matrices modeling hydrophobic contexts and a 4D space of gap values in aligning distantly related proteins. Two new notions of local and global stability are defined to assess the robustness of an alignment algorithm and the accuracy of PHYBAL. A new notion, the SAD-coefficient, to assess the difficulty of structural alignment is also introduced. PHYBAL has been compared with Hydrophobic Cluster Analysis and HMMSUM methods.     

Statistical evaluation of pairwise protein sequence comparison with the Bayesian bootstrap

MOTIVATION: Protein sequence comparison methods are routinely used to infer the intricate network of evolutionary relationships found within the rapidly growing library of protein sequences, and thereby to predict the structure and function of uncharacterized proteins. In the present study, we detail an improved statistical benchmark of pairwise protein sequence comparison algorithms. We use bootstrap resampling techniques to determine standard statistical errors and to estimate the confidence of our conclusions. We show that the underlying structure within benchmark databases causes Efron's standard, non-parametric bootstrap to be biased. Consequently, the standard bootstrap underpredicts average performance when used in the context of evaluating sequence comparison methods. We have developed, as an alternative, an unbiased statistical evaluation based on the Bayesian bootstrap, a resampling method operationally similar to the standard bootstrap. RESULTS: We apply our analysis to the comparative study of amino acid substitution matrix families and find that using modern matrices results in a small, but statistically significant improvement in remote homology detection compared with the classic PAM and BLOSUM matrices. AVAILABILITY: The sequence sets and code for performing these analyses are available from http://compbio.berkeley.edu/. Contact: brenner@compbio.berkeley.edu.     

Generality of the structurally constrained protein evolution model: assessment on representatives of the four main fold classes

The Structurally Constrained Protein Evolution (SCPE) model simulates protein evolution by introducing random mutations into the evolving sequences and selecting them against too much structural perturbation. Given a single protein structure, the SCPE model can be used to obtain a whole set of site-dependent amino acid substitution matrices. The set of SCPE substitution matrices for a given protein family can be seen as an independent-sites model of evolution for that family. Thus, these matrices can be compared with other substitution-matrix-based models of evolution. So far, SCPE has been tested only on left-handed parallel beta helix (LbetaH) proteins. Here, we address the question of generality by assessing the SCPE model on representatives of the four main classes of folds: alpha, beta, alpha+beta, and alpha/beta. We compare with other models using the likelihood ratio test with parametric bootstrapping. We show that SCPE performs better than the popular JTT model for all cases considered. Furthermore, by considering the relative contributions of mutation and selection, we found that the key to the success of the SCPE model is the selection step.     

Rapid assessment of correlated amino acids from pair-to-pair (P2P) substitution matrices

Identification of correlated amino acids in proteins has been a topic of broad interest in view of its functional implications and importance in protein design. A new set of pair-to-pair (P2P) substitution matrices for amino acids was recently introduced as a useful tool for inferring information on such correlated sites. We present a website developed for automated application of these matrices for analysis of query sequences. The site offers options for graphical analysis of correlations, as well as visualization of correlated amino acids on representative, structurally characterized, members of the examined family of sequences. Availability: http://www.ccbb.pitt.edu/p2p.     

Searching for frameshift evolutionary relationships between protein sequence families

The protein sequence database was analyzed for evidence that some distinct sequence families might be distantly related in evolution by changes in frame of translation. Sequences were compared using special amino acid substitution matrices for the alternate frames of translation. The statistical significance of alignment scores were computed in the true database and shuffled versions of the database that preserve any potential codon bias. The comparison of results from these two databases provides a very sensitive method for detecting remote relationships. We find a weak but measurable relatedness within the database as a whole, supporting the notion that some proteins may have evolved from others through changes in frame of translation. We also quantify residual homology in the ordinary sense within a database of generally unrelated sequences.     

Proteomic analysis of highly purified peroxisomes from etiolated soybean cotyledons

To identify previously unknown peroxisomal proteins, we establishedan optimized method for isolating highly purified peroxisomesfrom etiolated soybean cotyledons using Percoll density gradientcentrifugation followed by iodixanol density gradient centrifugation.Proteins in highly purified peroxisomes were separated by two-dimensionalPAGE. We performed peptide mass fingerprinting of proteins separatedin the gel with matrix-assisted laser desorption ionizationtime-of-flight mass spectrometry and used the peptide mass fingerprintsto search a non-redundant soybean expressed sequence tag database.We succeeded in assigning 92 proteins to 70 sequences in thedatabase. Among them, proteins encoded by 30 sequences werejudged to be located in peroxisomes. These included enzymesfor fatty acid β-oxidation, the glyoxylate cycle, photorespiratoryglycolate metabolism, stress response and metabolite transport.We also show experimental evidence that plant peroxisomes containa short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase family protein, enoyl-CoAhydratase/isomerase family protein, 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase-likeprotein and a voltage-dependent anion-selective channel protein.     

Pattern of amino acid substitutions in transmembrane domains of β-barrel membrane proteins for detecting remote homologs in bacteria and mitochondria

β-barrel membrane proteins play an important role in controlling the exchange and transport of ions and organic molecules across bacterial and mitochondrial outer membranes. They are also major regulators of apoptosis and are important determinants of bacterial virulence. In contrast to β-helical membrane proteins, their evolutionary pattern of residue substitutions has not been quantified, and there are no scoring matrices appropriate for their detection through sequence alignment. Using a Bayesian Monte Carlo estimator, we have calculated the instantaneous substitution rates of transmembrane domains of bacterial β-barrel membrane proteins. The scoring matrices constructed from the estimated rates, called bbTM for β-barrel Transmembrane Matrices, improve significantly the sensitivity in detecting homologs of β-barrel membrane proteins, while avoiding erroneous selection of both soluble proteins and other membrane proteins of similar composition. The estimated evolutionary patterns are general and can detect β-barrel membrane proteins very remote from those used for substitution rate estimation. Furthermore, despite the separation of 2-3 billion years since the proto-mitochondrion entered the proto-eukaryotic cell, mitochondria outer membrane proteins in eukaryotes can also be detected accurately using these scoring matrices derived from bacteria. This is consistent with the suggestion that there is no eukaryote-specific signals for translocation. With these matrices, remote homologs of β-barrel membrane proteins with known structures can be reliably detected at genome scale, allowing construction of high quality structural models of their transmembrane domains, at the rate of 131 structures per template protein. The scoring matrices will be useful for identification, classification, and functional inference of membrane proteins from genome and metagenome sequencing projects. The estimated substitution pattern will also help to identify key elements important for the structural and functional integrity of β-barrel membrane proteins, and will aid in the design of mutagenesis studies.     

Comparative modeling methods: application to the family of the mammalian serine proteases

Comparative modeling methods are described that can be used to construct a three-dimensional model structure of a new protein from knowledge of its sequence and of the experimental structures and sequences of other members of its homology family. The methods are illustrated with the mammalian serine protease family, for which seven experimental structures have been reported in the literature, and the sequences for over 35 different protein members of the family are available. The strategy for modeling these proteins is presented, and criteria are developed for determining and assigning the reliability of the modeled structure. Criteria are described that are specially designed to help detect cases in which it is likely that the local structure diverges significantly from the usual conformation of the family.     

Factors affecting the errors in the estimation of evolutionary distances between sequences

Phylogenetic methods that use matrices of pairwise distances between sequences (e.g., neighbor joining) will only give accurate results when the initial estimates of the pairwise distances are accurate. For many different models of sequence evolution, analytical formulae are known that give estimates of the distance between two sequences as a function of the observed numbers of substitutions of various classes. These are often of a form that we call "log transform formulae". Errors in these distance estimates become larger as the time t since divergence of the two sequences increases. For long times, the log transform formulae can sometimes give divergent distance estimates when applied to finite sequences. We show that these errors become significant when t approximately 1/2 |lambda(max)|(-1) logN, where lambda(max) is the eigenvalue of the substitution rate matrix with the largest absolute value and N is the sequence length. Various likelihood-based methods have been proposed to estimate the values of parameters in rate matrices. If rate matrix parameters are known with reasonable accuracy, it is possible to use the maximum likelihood method to estimate evolutionary distances while keeping the rate parameters fixed. We show that errors in distances estimated in this way only become significant when t approximately 1/2 |lambda(1)|(-1) logN, where lambda(1) is the eigenvalue of the substitution rate matrix with the smallest nonzero absolute value. The accuracy of likelihood-based distance estimates is therefore much higher than those based on log transform formulae, particularly in cases where there is a large range of timescales involved in the rate matrix (e.g., when the ratio of transition to transversion rates is large). We discuss several practical ways of estimating the rate matrix parameters before distance calculation and hence of increasing the accuracy of distance estimates.     

Empirical models for substitution in ribosomal RNA

Empirical models of substitution are often used in protein sequence analysis because the large alphabet of amino acids requires that many parameters be estimated in all but the simplest parametric models. When information about structure is used in the analysis of substitutions in structured RNA, a similar situation occurs. The number of parameters necessary to adequately describe the substitution process increases in order to model the substitution of paired bases. We have developed a method to obtain substitution rate matrices empirically from RNA alignments that include structural information in the form of base pairs. Our data consisted of alignments from the European Ribosomal RNA Database of Bacterial and Eukaryotic Small Subunit and Large Subunit Ribosomal RNA ( Wuyts et al. 2001. Nucleic Acids Res. 29:175-177; Wuyts et al. 2002. Nucleic Acids Res. 30:183-185). Using secondary structural information, we converted each sequence in the alignments into a sequence over a 20-symbol code: one symbol for each of the four individual bases, and one symbol for each of the 16 ordered pairs. Substitutions in the coded sequences are defined in the natural way, as observed changes between two sequences at any particular site. For given ranges (windows) of sequence divergence, we obtained substitution frequency matrices for the coded sequences. Using a technique originally developed for modeling amino acid substitutions ( Veerassamy, Smith, and Tillier. 2003. J. Comput. Biol. 10:997-1010), we were able to estimate the actual evolutionary distance for each window. The actual evolutionary distances were used to derive instantaneous rate matrices, and from these we selected a universal rate matrix. The universal rate matrices were incorporated into the Phylip Software package ( Felsenstein 2002. http://evolution.genetics.washington.edu/phylip.html), and we analyzed the ribosomal RNA alignments using both distance and maximum likelihood methods. The empirical substitution models performed well on simulated data, and produced reasonable evolutionary trees for 16S ribosomal RNA sequences from sequenced Bacterial genomes. Empirical models have the advantage of being easily implemented, and the fact that the code consists of 20 symbols makes the models easily incorporated into existing programs for protein sequence analysis. In addition, the models are useful for simulating the evolution of RNA sequence and structure simultaneously.     

Using physical-chemistry-based substitution models in phylogenetic analyses of HIV-1 subtypes

HIV-1 subtype phylogeny is investigated using a previously developed computational model of natural amino acid site substitutions. This model, based on Boltzmann statistics and Metropolis kinetics, involves an order of magnitude fewer adjustable parameters than traditional substitution matrices and deals more effectively with the issue of protein site heterogeneity. When optimized for sequences of HIV-1 envelope (env) proteins from a few specific subtypes, our model is more likely to describe the evolutionary record for other subtypes than are methods using a single substitution matrix, even a matrix optimized over the same data. Pairwise distances are calculated between various probabilistic ancestral subtype sequences, and a distance matrix approach is used to find the optimal phylogenetic tree. Our results indicate that the relationships between subtypes B, C, and D and those between subtypes A and H may be closer than previously thought.     

BATMAS30: amino acid substitution matrix for alignment of bacterial transporters

Aligned amino acid sequences of three functionally independent samples of transmembrane (TM) transport proteins have been analyzed. The concept of TM-kernel is proposed as the most probable transmembrane region of a sequence. The average amino acid composition of TM-kernels differs from the published amino acid composition of transmembrane segments. TM-kernels contain more alanines, glycines, and less polar, charged, and aromatic residues in contrast to non-TM-proteins. There are also differences between TM-kernels of bacterial and eukaryotic proteins. We have constructed amino acid substitution matrices for bacterial TM-kernels, named the BATMAS (BActerial Transmembrane MAtrix of Substitutions) series. In TM-kernels, polar and charged residues, as well as proline and tyrosine, are highly conserved, whereas there are more substitutions within the group of hydrophobic residues, in contrast to non-TM-proteins that have fewer, relatively more conserved, hydrophobic residues. These results demonstrate that alignment of transmembrane proteins should be based on at least two amino acid substitution matrices, one for loops (e.g., the BLOSUM series) and one for TM-segments (the BATMAS series), and the choice of the TM-matrix should be different for eukaryotic and bacterial proteins.