Choline import into chloroplasts limits glycine betaine synthesis in tobacco: analysis of plants engineered with a chloroplastic or a cytosolic pathway

The biosynthesis of the osmoprotectant glycine betaine (GlyBet) is a target for metabolic engineering to enhance stress resistance in crops. Certain plants synthesize GlyBet in chloroplasts via a two-step oxidation of choline (Cho). In previous work, a chloroplastic GlyBet synthesis pathway was inserted into tobacco (which lacks GlyBet) by expressing spinach choline monooxygenase (CMO). The transformants had low CMO enzyme activity, and produced little GlyBet (less than or = 70 nmol g(-1) fresh wt). In this study, transformants with up to 100-fold higher CMO activity showed no further increase in GlyBet. In contrast, tobacco expressing a cytosolic GlyBet synthesis pathway accumulated significantly more GlyBet (430 nmol g(-1) fresh wt), suggesting that subcellular localization influences pathway flux. Modeling of the labeling kinetics of Cho metabolites observed when [14C]Cho was supplied to engineered plants demonstrated that Cho import into chloroplasts indeed limits the flux to GlyBet in the chloroplastic pathway. A high-activity Cho transporter in the chloroplast envelope may therefore be an integral part of the GlyBet synthesis pathway in species that accumulate GlyBet naturally, and hence a target for future engineering.     

山菠菜胆碱单氧化物酶基因(CMO)的克隆与分析

甜菜碱是一类广泛存在于生物体内的渗透保护剂。高等植物中,甜菜碱的生物合成经由胆碱→甜菜碱醛→甜菜碱两步反应完成,其中第一步反应,也是甜菜碱生物合成的限速反应,由胆碱单氧化物酶(CMO)催化。本研究以耐盐植物山菠菜(Atriplex hortensis)为材料构建了盐胁迫下的cDNA文库,用菠菜CMO cDNA为探针从中筛选获得一个长1.77kb的cDNA克隆,测序结果表明该克隆包含一个完整的开放读码框,编码一个由438个氨基酸构成的多肽,与菠菜和甜菜CMO的氨基酸序列同源性分别为81%和72%。同菠菜和甜菜中的CMO序列相比,山菠菜CMO基因(AhCMO)也具有保守的RieskeType［2Fe2S］簇结合区和保守的多铁原子核结合域。对盐处理条件下山菠菜CMO基因转录水平的研究表明CMO基因在盐胁迫情况下表达量增加约3倍。将CMO与35S启动子连接后转化烟草(Nictiana tabacumvar.Xanthi),获得了具有一定耐盐性状的转基因植株,在1.2%NaCl的盐浓度下生长良好。     

Metabolic modeling identifies key constraints on an engineered glycine betaine synthesis pathway in tobacco

Previous work has shown that tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) plants engineered to express spinach choline monooxygenase in the chloroplast accumulate very little glycine betaine (GlyBet) unless supplied with choline (Cho). We therefore used metabolic modeling in conjunction with [(14)C]Cho labeling experiments and in vivo (31)P NMR analyses to define the constraints on GlyBet synthesis, and hence the processes likely to require further engineering. The [(14)C]Cho doses used were large enough to markedly perturb Cho and phosphocholine pool sizes, which enabled development and testing of models with rates dynamically responsive to pool sizes, permitting estimation of the kinetic properties of Cho metabolism enzymes and transport systems in vivo. This revealed that import of Cho into the chloroplast is a major constraint on GlyBet synthesis, the import rate being approximately 100-fold lower than the rates of Cho phosphorylation and transport into the vacuole, with which import competes. Simulation studies suggested that, were the chloroplast transport limitation corrected, additional engineering interventions would still be needed to achieve levels of GlyBet as high as those in plants that accumulate GlyBet naturally. This study reveals the rigidity of the Cho metabolism network and illustrates how computer modeling can help guide rational metabolic engineering design.     

Assay,Purification, and Partial Characterization of Choline Monooxygenase from Spinach

The osmoprotectant glycine betaine is synthesized via the path-way choline -> betaine aldehyde -> glycine betaine. In spinach (Spinacia oleracea), the first step is catalyzed by choline monooxygenase (CMO), and the second is catalyzed by betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase. Because betaine aldehyde is unstable and not easily detected, we developed a coupled radiometric assay for CMO. [14C]Choline is used as substrate; NAD+ and betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase prepared from Escherichia coli are added to oxidize [14C]betaine aldehyde to [14C]glycine betaine, which is isolated by ion exchange. The assay was used in the purification of CMO from leaves of salinized spinach. The 10-step procedure included polyethylene glycol precipitation, polyethyleneimine precipitation, hydrophobic interaction, anion exchange on choline-Sepharose, dimethyldiethanolamine-Sepharose, and Mono Q, hydroxyapatite, gel filtration, and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Following gel filtration, overall purification was about 600-fold and recovery of activity was 0.5%. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed a polypeptide with a molecular mass of 45 kD. Taken with the value of 98 kD estimated for native CMO (R. Brouquisse, P. Weigel, D. Rhodes, C.F. Yocum, A.D. Hanson [1989] Plant Physiol 90: 322-329), this indicates that CMO is a homodimer. CMO preparations were red-brown, showed absorption maxima at 329 and 459 nm, and lost color upon dithionite addition, suggesting that CMO is an iron-sulfur protein.     

Osmotic Stress Induces Expression of Choline Monooxygenase in Sugar Beet and Amaranth

Choline monooxygenase (CMO) catalyzes the committing step in the synthesis of glycine betaine, an osmoprotectant accumulated by many plants in response to salinity and drought. To investigate how these stresses affect CMO expression, a spinach (Spinacia oleracea L., Chenopodiaceae) probe was used to isolate CMO cDNAs from sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L., Chenopodiaceae), a salt- and drought-tolerant crop. The deduced beet CMO amino acid sequence comprised a transit peptide and a 381-residue mature peptide that was 84% identical (97% similar) to that of spinach and that showed the same consensus motif for coordinating a Rieske-type [2Fe-2S] cluster. A mononuclear Fe-binding motif was also present. When water was withheld, leaf relative water content declined to 59% and the levels of CMO mRNA, protein, and enzyme activity rose 3- to 5-fold; rewatering reversed these changes. After gradual salinization (NaCl:CaCl₂ = 5.7:1, mol/mol), CMO mRNA, protein, and enzyme levels in leaves increased 3- to 7-fold at 400 mm salt, and returned to uninduced levels when salt was removed. Beet roots also expressed CMO, most strongly when salinized. Salt-inducible CMO mRNA, protein, and enzyme activity were readily detected in leaves of Amaranthus caudatus L. (Amaranthaceae). These data show that CMO most probably has a mononuclear Fe center, is inducibly expressed in roots as well as in leaves of Chenopodiaceae, and is not unique to this family.     

Isolation and characterization of a novel peroxisomal choline monooxygenase in barley

Glycine betaine (GB) is a compatible solute accumulated by many plants under various abiotic stresses. GB is synthesized in two steps, choline → betaine aldehyde → GB, where a functional choline-oxidizing enzyme has only been reported in Amaranthaceae (a chloroplastic ferredoxin-dependent choline monooxygenase) thus far. Here, we have cloned a cDNA encoding a choline monooxygenase (CMO) from barley (Hordeum vulgare) plants, HvCMO. In barley plants under non-stress condition, GB had accumulated in all the determined organs (leaves, internodes, awn and floret proper), mostly in the leaves. The expression of HvCMO protein was abundant in the leaves, whereas the expression of betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase (BADH) protein was abundant in the awn, floret proper and the youngest internode than in the leaves. The accumulation of HvCMO mRNA was increased by high osmotic and low-temperature environments. Also, the expression of HvCMO protein was increased by the presence of high NaCl. Immunofluorescent labeling of HvCMO protein and subcellular fractionation analysis showed that HvCMO protein was localized to peroxisomes. [¹⁴C]choline was oxidized to betaine aldehyde and GB in spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts but not in barley, which indicates that the subcellular localization of choline-oxidizing enzyme is different between two plant species. We investigated the choline-oxidizing reaction using recombinant HvCMO protein expressed in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae). The crude extract of HvCMO-expressing yeast coupled with recombinant BBD2 protein converted [¹⁴C]choline to GB when NADPH was added as a cofactor. These results suggest that choline oxidation in GB synthesis is mediated by a peroxisomal NADPH-dependent choline monooxygenase in barley plants.     

Functional characterization of choline monooxygenase,an enzyme for betaine synthesis in plants

In plants, the first step in betaine synthesis was shown to be catalyzed by a novel Rieske-type iron-sulfur enzyme, choline monooxygenase (CMO). Although CMO so far has been found only in Chenopodiaceae and Amaranthaceae, the recent genome sequence suggests the presence of a CMO-like gene in Arabidopsis, a betaine non-accumulating plant. Here, we examined the functional properties of CMO expressed in Escherichia coli, cyanobacterium, and Arabidopsis thaliana. We found that E. coli cells in which choline dehydrogenase (CDH) was replaced with spinach CMO accumulate betaine and complement the salt-sensitive phenotype of the CDH-deleted E. coli mutant. Changes of Cys-181 in spinach CMO to Ser, Thr, and Ala and His-287 to Gly, Val, and Ala abolished the accumulation of betaine. The Arabidopsis CMO-like gene was transcribed in Arabidopsis, but its protein was not detected. When the Arabidopsis CMO-like gene was expressed in E. coli, the protein was detected but was found not to promote betaine sysnthesis. Overexpression of spinach CMO in E. coli, Synechococcus sp. PCC7942, and Arabidopsis conferred resistance to abiotic stress. These facts clearly indicate that CMO, but not the CMO-like protein, could oxidize choline and that Cys-181 and His-287 are involved in the binding of Fe-S cluster and Fe, respectively.     

The occurrence of phosphatidyl choline exchange protein in leaves

The transfer of phosphatidyl choline between liposomes was stimulated by the protein fractions from spinach leaves, etiolated and greening leaves of $\text{Avena}$ seedlings. This is confirmed by the transfer of [¹⁴C]phosphatidyl choline or spin-labeled phosphatidyl choline between donor and acceptor liposomes. ESR spectrum changes also indicated that no spin-labeled phosphatidyl choline was released from donor liposomes by spinach leaf protein unless acceptor liposomes were present. [¹⁴C]phospholipids were transferred from liposomes to both spinach chloroplasts and $\text{Avena}$ etiochloroplasts by phosphatidyl choline exchange protein from germinated castor bean endosperms and further from liposomes to spinach chloroplasts by spinach leaf protein. These results support the view that phosphatidyl choline in the plastid is supplied from the synthesis site, the endoplasmic reticulum, by phospholipid exchange protein.     

Accumulation of glycinebetaine in rice plants that overexpress choline monooxygenase from spinach and evaluation of their tolerance to abiotic stress

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Glycinebetaine (GB), a quaternary ammonium compound, is a very effective compatible solute. In higher plants, GB is synthesized from choline (Cho) via betaine aldehyde (BA). The first and second steps in the biosynthesis of GB are catalysed by choline monooxygenase (CMO) and by betaine aldehyde dehydrogenase (BADH), respectively. Rice (Oryza sativa), which has two genes for BADH, does not accumulate GB because it lacks a functional gene for CMO. Rice plants accumulate GB in the presence of exogenously applied BA, which leads to the development of a significant tolerance to salt, cold and heat stress. The goal in this study was to evaluate and to discuss the effects of endogenously accumulated GB in rice. METHODS: Transgenic rice plants that overexpressed a gene for CMO from spinach (Spinacia oleracea) were produced by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. After Southern and western blotting analysis, GB in rice leaves was quantified by (1)H-NMR spectroscopy and the tolerance of GB-accumulating plants to abiotic stress was investigated. KEY RESULTS: Transgenic plants that had a single copy of the transgene and expressed spinach CMO accumulated GB at the level of 0.29-0.43 micromol g(-1) d. wt and had enhanced tolerance to salt stress and temperature stress in the seedling stage. CONCLUSIONS: In the CMO-expressing rice plants, the localization of spinach CMO and of endogenous BADHs might be different and/or the catalytic activity of spinach CMO in rice plants might be lower than it is in spinach. These possibilities might explain the low levels of GB in the transgenic rice plants. It was concluded that CMO-expressing rice plants were not effective for accumulation of GB and improvement of productivity.     

Plastid-expressed choline monooxygenase gene improves salt and drought tolerance through accumulation of glycine betaine in tobacco

Glycine betaine (GlyBet), a quaternary ammonium compound, functions as an osmoprotectant in many organisms including plants. Previous research has shown that over-expression of enzymes for GlyBet biosynthesis in transgenic plants improved abiotic stress tolerance, but so far no study on the effects of plastid-expression of choline monooxygenase, the enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of choline into betaine aldehyde, has been reported. In the present study, tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Wisconsin 38) plants were transformed with a gene for choline monooxygenase (BvCMO) from beet (Beta vulgaris) via plastid genetic engineering. Transplastomic plants constitutively expressing BvCMO under the control of the ribosomal RNA operon promoter and a synthetic T7 gene G10 leader were able to accumulate GlyBet in leaves, roots and seeds, and exhibited improved tolerance to toxic level of choline and to salt/drought stress when compared to wild type plants. Transplastomic plants also demonstrated higher net photosynthetic rate and apparent quantum yield of photosynthesis in the presence of 150 mM NaCl. Salt stress caused no significant change on the maximal efficiency of PSII photochemistry (Fv/Fm) in both wild type and transplastomic plants, but a decrease in the actual efficiency of PSII (PhiPSII) was observed, and such a decrease was much greater in wild type plants. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of improving salt and drought tolerance in plants through plastid transformation with BvCMO gene.     

Choline Synthesis in Spinach in Relation to Salt Stress

Choline metabolism was examined in spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) plants growing under nonsaline and saline conditions. In spinach, choline is required for phosphatidylcholine synthesis and as a precursor for the compatible osmolyte glycine betaine (betaine). When control (nonsalinized) leaf discs were incubated for up to 2 h with [1,2-14C]ethanolamine, label appeared in the N-methylated derivatives of phosphoethanolamine including phosphomono-, phosphodi-, and phosphotri- (i.e. phosphocholine) methyl-ethanolamine, as well as in choline and betaine, whereas no radioactivity could be detected in the mono- and dimethylated derivatives of the free base ethanolamine. Leaf discs from salinized plants showed the same pattern of labeling, although the proportion of label that accumulated in betaine was almost 3-fold higher in the salinized leaf discs. Enzymes involved in choline metabolism were assayed in crude leaf extracts of plants. The activites of ethanolamine kinase and of the three S-adenosylmethionine:phospho-base N-methyltransferase enzymes responsible for N-methylating phosphoethanolamine to phosphocholine were all higher in extracts of plants salinized step-wise to 100, 200, or 300 mM NaCI compared with controls. In contrast, choline kinase, phosphocholine phosphatase, and cytidine 5[prime]-triphosphate: phosphocholine cytidylyltransferase activities showed little variation with salt stress. Thus, the increased diversion of choline to betaine in salt-stressed spinach appears to be mediated by the increased activity of several key enzymes involved in choline biosynthesis.     

C Tracer Evidence for Synthesis of Choline and Betaine via Phosphoryl Base Intermediates in Salinized Sugarbeet Leaves

Like other chenopods, sugarbeets (Beta vulgaris L. cv Great Western D-2) accumulate glycine betaine when salinized; this may be an adaptive response to stress. The pathway of betaine synthesis in leaves of salinized (150-200 millimolar NaCl) sugarbeet plants was investigated by supplying [¹⁴C]formate, phosphoryl[¹⁴C]monomethylethanolamine ([¹⁴C][unk] MME) or phosphoryl[¹⁴C]choline ([¹⁴C][unk] choline) to leaf discs and following ¹⁴C incorporation into prospective intermediates. The ¹⁴C kinetic data were used to develop a computer model of the betaine pathway.

When [¹⁴C]formate was fed, [unk] MME, phosphoryldimethylethanolamine ([unk] DME) and [unk] choline were the most prominent methylated products at short labeling times, after which ¹⁴C appeared in free choline and in betaine. Phosphatidylcholine labeled more slowly than [unk] choline, choline, and betaine, and behaved as a minor end product. Very little ¹⁴C entered the free methylethanolamines. When [¹⁴C][unk] MME was supplied, a small amount was hydrolyzed to the free base but the major fate was conversion to [unk] DME, [unk] choline, free choline, and betaine; label also accumulated slowly in phosphatidylcholine. Label from supplied [¹⁴C][unk] choline entered choline and betaine rapidly, while phosphatidylcholine labeled only slowly and to a small extent.

These results are consistent with the pathway [unk] MME →[unk] DME → [unk] choline → choline → → betaine, with a minor side branch leading from [unk] choline into phosphatidylcholine. This contrasts markedly (a) with the pathway of stress-induced choline and betaine synthesis in barley, in which phosphatidylcholine apparently acts as an intermediate (Hitz, Rhodes, Hanson 1981, Plant Physiol 68: 814-822); (b) with choline biogenesis in mammalian liver and microorganisms. Computer modeling of the experimental data pointed strongly to regulation at the [unk] choline → choline step, and also indicated that the rate of [unk] choline synthesis is subject to feedback inhibition by [unk] choline.

     

Evidence for a ferredoxin-dependent choline monooxygenase from spinach chloroplast stroma

Chenopods synthesize betaine in the chloroplast via a two-step oxidation of choline: choline → betaine aldehyde → betaine. Our previous experiments with intact chloroplasts, and in vivo¹⁸O₂ labeling studies, led us to propose that the first step is mediated by a monooxygenase which uses photosynthetically generated reducing power (C Lerma, AD Hanson, D Rhodes [1988] Plant Physiol 88: 695-702). Here, we report the detection of such an activity in vitro. In the presence of O₂ and reduced ferredoxin, the stromal fraction from spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts converted choline to betaine aldehyde at rates similar to those in intact chloroplasts (20-50 nanomoles per hour per milligram protein). Incorporation of ¹⁸O from ¹⁸O₂ by the in vitro reaction was demonstrated by fast atom bombardment mass spectrometry. Ferredoxin could be reduced either with thylakoids in the light, or with NADPH plus ferredoxin-NADP reductase in darkness; NADPH alone could not substitute for ferredoxin. No choline-oxidizing activity was detected in the stromal fraction of pea (Pisum sativum L.), a species that does not accumulate betaine. The spinach choline-oxidizing enzyme was stimulated by 10 millimolar Mg²⁺, had a pH optimum close to 8, and was insensitive to carbon monoxide. The specific activity was increased threefold in plants growing in 200 millimolar NaCl. Gel filtration experiments gave a molecular weight of 98 kilodaltons for the choline-oxidizing enzyme, and provided no evidence for other electron carriers which might mediate the reduction of the 98-kilodalton enzyme by ferredoxin.     

A single-vial biphasic liquid extraction assay for choline acetyltransferase using [3H]choline

A single-vial liquid extraction assay for choline acetyltransferase that uses [³H]choline as the labeled substrate has been devised. [³H]Choline is incubated with an excess of acetyl-CoA in a small reaction vial which also serves as a scintillation vial. After a suitable reaction period, unreacted [³H]choline is quickly and quantitatively converted to phosphoryl-[³H]choline by the addition of an excess of choline kinase. This treatment is followed by the addition of scintillation fluid containing sodium tetraphenylboron after which the vial is capped, shaken, and counted. A two-phase system is produced in which product [³H]acetylcholine is selectively extracted into the scintillation fluid, where it is counted. Phosphoryl-[³H]choline remains in the aqueous phase and is not counted. This assay is rapid, simple, and quite sensitive. In comparison to assays using acetyl-CoA as the labeled substrate, it is less sensitive to interference by other enzymes and thus more suitable for measuring choline acetyltransferase in crude extracts and in the initial stages of purification. Similar single-vial radiometric assays are described for choline kinase and acetyl-CoA hydrolases.     

Acetylcholine formation from glucose following acute choline supplementation

The effects of choline administration on acetylcholine metabolism in the central nervous system are controversial. Although choline supplementation may elevate acetylcholine (ACh) content in brain, turnover studies with labelled choline precursors suggest that systemic choline administration either has no effect or actually diminishes brain ACh synthesis. Since choline supplementation elevates brain choline levels, the apparent decreases in previous turnover studies may reflect dilution of the labelled choline precursor pool rather than altered ACh formation. Therefore, brain ACh formation from [U-¹⁴C]glucose was determined after choline supplementation. A two to three fold elevation of brain choline did not alter ACh levels or [U-¹⁴C]glucose incorporation into ACh in the cortex, hippocampus or striatum. Although atropine stimulated ACh formation from [U-¹⁴C]glucose in hippocampus, two to three fold increases in brain choline did not augment ACh synthesis or content in atropine pretreated animals. Atropine depressed brain regional glucose utilization and this effect was not reversed by choline treatment. These results suggest that shorttern elevation of brain choline does not enhance ACh formation from [U-¹⁴C]glucose, and argue against enhanced presynaptic cholinergic function after acute, systemic choline administration.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Louis Sokoloff.