Simultaneous quantification of DNA and RNA in tissue sections. A comparative analysis of the Methyl Green-Pyronin technique with the Gallocyanin chromalum and Feulgen procedures using image cytometry

Summary For simultaneous cytophotometric measurement of DNA and RNA, the standardized Methyl Green-Pyronin Y technique is an obvious choice. It is, however, first necessary to correlate the uptake of Pyronin Y to the staining intensity of RNA.The material consisted of paraffin sections of formalin- or Carnoy-fixed rat liver. The sections were pretreated with water, buffer, deoxyribonuclease, ribonuclease, or both enzymes in sequence, and stained with the standardized Methyl Green-Pyronin Y procedure, Gallocyanin chromalum, or the Feulgen analtion. Sections stained directly without pretreatment served as controls. Staining intensities were measured with an image analyser for cell nuclei, nucleoli and cytoplasm.After deoxyribonuclease treatment, nuclear staining intensity with Methyl Green, Gallocyanin chromalum, and Schiff's reagent dropped nearly to zero. The same was seen for both nucleoli and cytoplasm with Pyronin Y and Gallocyanin chromalum after ribonuclease treatment. Staining intensity of Pyronin Y correlated directly with that of Gallocyanin chromalum for nucleoli and cytoplasm. After ribonuclease treatment, a direct correlation was found between the nuclear staining intensity of Methyl Green and nuclear absorption of Gallocyanin chromalum.We conclude that the standardized Methyl Green-Pyronin Y stain is reliable for the simultaneous quantitative assessment of both RNA and DNA. The simplicity of this technique makes it a valuable tool even for daily routine.     

Standardization of the Papanicolaou stain. I. A comparison of five nuclear stains.

The staining characteristics of five nuclear stains used in a Papanicolaou staining procedure were investigated. Alcohol-fixed cervical smears were stained with a modified Papanicolaou procedure using hematoxylin, alcoholic thionin bromide, alcoholic Victoria blue B, gallocyanin or the thionin Feulgen reagent (thionin-SO2) as the nuclear stain. The same anionic counterstain was used for all slides, and the optical densities of cell nuclei and cytoplasm were measured with the IBAS 2000 image analyzer. Alcoholic thionin gave the most intense nuclear stain, with a very high reproducibility of the staining pattern. Hematoxylin showed the highest coefficient of variation of the staining intensity. Both hematoxylin and gallocyanin gave some nonspecific cytoplasmic staining. Thionin-SO2 allowed a quantitative assessment of DNA, but gave a low staining intensity. Staining with the metal complex dyes interfered with subsequent staining with the pararosaniline Feulgen reagent. Alcoholic thioinin is thus recommended as a nuclear stain for cervical cytology in the Papanicolaou procedure, both for image analysis and for visual microscopy.     

Standardization of the Feulgen reaction: the influence of chromatin condensation on the kinetics of acid hydrolysis.

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the influence of chromatin compactness on the kinetics of acid hydrolysis in the Feulgen reaction in cytology. Tissue imprints of rabbit liver, of human bronchial carcinoma and of human blood smears, fixed with alcohol, formaldehyde or with B?hm's solution with and without prior air drying, were stained with a standardized pararosanilin-Feulgen reagent. The time for hydrolysis varied between 7.5 and 120 min. The integrated optical density (IOD) of the cell nuclei was measured with an image analyzer (IBAS 2000). Cells with condensed chromatin (lymphocytes, small cell carcinoma, formaldehyde fixed cells) showed a slow increase of staining intensity and late plateau phase as compared with cells with decondensed chromatin. DNA in condensed nuclei was less susceptible to acid hydrolysis. The degree of chromatin compactness which determines the sensitivity of DNA to hydrolysis is influenced by the type of fixation, cell type and by the functional status of the cell. The conclusion is that Feulgen staining intensities of cells with different degrees of chromatin compactness cannot be compared unless measured in the respective plateau phases of the relevant hydrolysis curves which must be determined individually for each cell type.     

Comparison of the Papanicolaou and Feulgen staining methods for DNA quantification by image analysis.

The possibility of using archival cytology material to study the evolution of neoplastic disease with regard to DNA content abnormalities was investigated. The accuracy of measuring the integrity optical density (OD) of nuclei that correlates to DNA amounts of those nuclei, on slides stained by the Papanicolaou method, was assessed and compared with a standard Feulgen method. Our data on rat liver nuclei peritoneal washings from patients with ovarian cystadenofibromas and ovarian cystadenocarcinomas suggested that analysis of cytological material using the Papanicolaou method is not reliable and that destaining the slides followed by Feulgen staining provides an optimal and reliable method of DNA quantification.     

Influence of smear preparation and fixatives on the DNA ploidy and the morphonuclear features of the MXT mammary tumor and normal tissues in the mouse

We compared cytomorphonuclear parameters--related to DNA histogram and chromatin distribution--on MXT mouse mammary tumor and murine normal cells from fresh squash smears or from deparaffinized tissue smears fixed in several fluids. We used the SAMBA 200 cell image processor with software allowing for the discrimination of parameters computed on Feulgen-stained nuclei. The spectrophotometric results--assessed by integrated optical density values--indicate that the nuclei from deparaffinized tissue fixed in Bouin's fluid are around 50% less stained than those fixed in formalin or ethanol-formalin-acetic acid (EFA). The fresh smears of nuclei fixed in formalin contain a less well-defined and more homogeneous chromatin than after Bouin's or EFA fixation. This has led to the conclusion that morphonuclear parameter comparisons performed on tissues differently processed or from different origins present severe limitations.     

Gallocyanin as a Nuclear Stain in Autoradiography

In autoradiography, staining sections with gallocyanin and counterstaining with metanil yellow produces clear autoradiograms and avoids the staining of the emulsion encountered by using hematoxylin. Gallocyanin is a gradually progressive stain and by appropriate timing the intensity of staining is readily controlled. It is unnecessary to subject the plates to differentiating solutions.     

Plain Water as a Rinsing Agent Preferable to Sulfurous Acid After the Feulgen Nucleal Reaction

After staining for the Feulgen nucleal reaction with Schiff's reagent, slides were immediately submerged in running distilled or tap water and washed for 30 sec or longer. Rapid and complete removal of residual Schiff's reagent from the stained tissue will give preparations which show all details characterizing the nucleal reaction, and which are more durable in storage than those processed with the customary washing in a solution of SO₂. Care must be taken to insure that all parts of the slides are thoroughly washed and that, on the surface of the sections, no spilled adhesive or other interfering coating retards the washing. Standardization of the procedure for quantitative DNA determination may be facilitated by this modification.     

Use of Gallocyanin as a Myelin Stain for Brain and Spinal Cord

Tissue fixed in 10% formalin, formol saline, CaCO₃ or phosphate buffer neutralized formalin, Baker's formol calcium, Cajal's formol ammonium bromide, formalin-95% ethanol 1:9, formalin-methanol 1:9, Lillie's methanol-chloroform or Salthouse's formol cetyltrimethylammonium bromide was dehydrated and embedded in paraffin. Sections were attached to slides with either albumen or gelatine adhesive and processed throughout at room temperature of 22-25 C. Mordanting 30-60 min in 1% iron alum was followed by a 10 min wash in 4 changes of distilled water. Myelin was stained in a gallocyanin self-differentiating solution for 1-2.5 hr; thick sections requiring the longer time. The staining solution (pH approximately 7.4) consisted of Na₂CO₃, 90 mg; distilled water, 100 ml; gallocyanin, 250 mg; and ethanol, 5 ml. The ethanol was added to this mixture last, and after the other ingredients had been boiled and then cooled to room temperature. After a staining and thorough washing, Nissl granules were stained for 5-10 min in a solution consisting of: 0.1 M acetic acid, 60 ml; 0.1 M sodium acetate, 40 ml; methyl green, 500 mg. Washing, dehydration, clearing and mounting completed the process. Myelin sheaths were stained dark violet; neuronal nuclei, light green with dark granules of chromatin; nucleoli of motor cells and erythrocytes, dark violet; cytoplasm, green with dark green Nissl granules. The simple and reliable method can be adapted easily for use with automatic tissue processors.     

Victoria blue B--a nuclear stain for cytology. A cytophotometric study

The aim of this study was to investigate the staining characteristics of Victoria Blue B in alcohol solutions. Cytological specimens (liver and spleen tissue imprints, blood smears) were stained with methanol solutions of commercially available Victoria Blue B-Cl and with pure Victoria Blue B-BF4. The dye concentration, staining time, and protone concentration of the dye solution were varied. The dye solutions were characterized using spectrophotometry and thin-layer chromatography. Cytophotometry and image analysis were used to quantitate the staining pattern of cell nuclei. Feulgen-stained slides were used as controls. Victoria Blue B-BF4 gave excellent nuclear staining exhibiting a quantitative dye-substrate relationship, whereas commercial dyes resulted in lower staining intensity and less distinct nuclear texture. Dye concentration and staining time were, over wide ranges, not of critical importance for the quality of the staining. Under certain staining conditions, only cell nuclei were stained, with the background remaining completely unstained. We presume that, in alcohol solutions, Victoria Blue dye binds as a neutral dye molecule in conjunction with its anion. Victoria Blue B-BF4 staining provides a simple and reproducible staining technique for cytology which is suitable for use in automated cell-pattern recognition.     

On the interspecific comparison of nuclear DNA amounts using the Feulgen and Gallocyanin Chromalum methods

Summary Quantitative determinations of nuclear DNA amounts by both the Feulgen and the Gallocyanin Chromalum methods vary considerably and systematically depending on the interpretation of the measurements. Before such determinations can be interpreted to the limits of accuracy set by the optical methods, the measurements will have to be standardized against determinations obtained by other methods, and the mechanisms underlying the production of stainable groups in the two cytochemical reactions will have to be better understocd.     

A rapid, simple method for staining bacterial flagella.

A simple modification of Gray's flagellar staining procedure is described. It can be used on air-dried smears or directly on wet mounts of motile bacteria. The stained bacterial flagella can be observed with phase-contrast or bright-field optics. No rigorous cleaning of slides, counterstains, or any washing procedures are required with the staining method, making it very suitable for routine examinations.     

Gallocyanin-chromalum for improved scanning electron microscopy of whole nuclei without critical point drying.

Bone marrow nuclei fixed with modified Carnoy's, then stained with gallocyanin chromalum followed by air drying showed no difference in morphology when compared by means of scanning electron microscopy with similar nuclei prepared by critical point drying. Glutaraldehyde at pH 4.0 and 7.1, mercury-containing Zenker's fluid, and chromalum alone, all of which are considered to be nuclear protein cross-linking fixatives, failed to preserve the nuclear morphology as well as gallocyanin-chromalum or critical point prepared bone marro nuclei.     

Modifcation of the French Azure C Tissue Stain

A staining procedure for monocytes in specimens of blood and bone marrow was developed. The technique was a two step procedure in which unfixed cells were exposed first to a methanolic solution of C.I. basic blue 54. Next, an aqueous alkaline buffered solution of C.I. basic blue 141 was added to the first staining solution. After staining for 10 min in the solution with two stains, slides or coverslips were washed for 5 sec in pH 5.6 phosphate buffer and drained dry. The cytoplasm of monocytes stained intensely deep purple and frequently nuclei were stained red. Similar staining was not found in other types of normal or abnormal blood and bone marrow cells.     

Quantitative aspects of the cytochemical Feulgen-DNA procedure studied on model systems and cell nuclei

Quantitative aspects of DNA losses during fixation and pararosaniline(SO2)-Feulgen staining of microscopic preparations were studied. The preparation of a new cytochemical model, consisting of DNA-protein layers (with thicknesses between 0.1 and 5.0 micrometer) on microscopic glass slides is described and potentialities and limitations of this model are discussed. Polyacrylamide films into which high molecular weight calf thymus DNA or chicken erythrocyte nuclei had been constrained served as another model. As biological objects chicken erythrocyte nuclei and rat liver nuclei either in suspension or on microscopical glass slides were used. The experimental results indicate a loss of about 5% of the DNA due to the fixation procedure applied. Hydrolysis in 5 N HCl at room temperature, staining with the pararosaniline-Schiff medium and rinsing with sulfurous acid induced losses of DNA too, varying in amount depending on the type of preparation used. About 10% of the original DNA content is lost in total from chicken erythrocyte nuclei and rat liver nuclei dried on microscopical glass slides, from chicken erythrocyte nuclei constrained in polyacrylamide films, and from DNA-protein layers on microscopic glass slides. For nuclei fixed and stained in suspension the total losses amount to about 40%. The differences in losses between various types of preparations are discussed. Biochemically, the content of DNA originally present per chicken erythrocyte nucleus was determined to be 2.52 pg, a value, which is in good accordance with reliable biochemical data published already. It is shown that calibration of cytochemical staining intensities into biochemical units or absolute amounts of material by use of a model system, is only reliable when it is known or to be expected that both the loss of material due to fixation and staining, and the stoichiometric relation between material present and dye molecules is identical. The same holds for the application of internal biological reference systems.     

IMMUNOENZYME FOR RAPID SCREENING of CLOSTRIDIUM BOTULINUM TYPE A CELLS

A staining procedure was developed for screening Clostridium botulinum type A (tox⁺) cells fixed (smear) on glass slides. the method is based on reaction between cells and an immunoenzyme-conjugate consisting of antibody against type A toxin linked to horseradish peroxidase (HRPO) enzyme. Fixed smears were stained for perioxidase activity (30 min), using one drop of 3,3'-diaminobenzidine-hydrogen peroxide solution (pH 7.6) as oxidizable substrate, followed by washing, drying and microscopic examination (1000 X). the cell-walls of vegetative C. botulinum type A appeared reddish brown and periphery of spores (if present), stained dark brown. However, C. botulinum type B (tox⁺) cross-reacted (faint brown) with the same antibody-HRPO-conjugate. Specificity and sensitivity of this procedure compared well with the immunodiffusion method of Ferreira et al. (1981, 1983). Factors affecting cell-staining were: fixation time and type used, incubation time of antibody-HRPO-conjugate with cells, growth medium, culture age, and crowding of cells in smears. Ethanol fixation (5 min) of logarithmic and/or stationary phase cells and 30 min incubation with antibody-HRPO-conjugate were optimal and yielded the most appropriate procedure for detecting cells containing type A botulinum toxin.     

Factors affecting the immunoperoxidase demonstration of intracellular immunoglobulins and J chain from cytocentrifuged cell smears

Immunohistochemical methods were used to study 1) the optimum fixation conditions for the preservation of human J chain and immunoglobulin (Ig) immunoreactivity and 2) the relation of J chain synthesis by plasmablasts and plasma cells to Ig synthesis in cell smears of cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes stimulated with pokeweed mitogen (PWM). J chain was demonstrated using the indirect immunoperoxidase method, and intracellular Ig was demonstrated with the unlabeled antibody--enzyme method. In the sequential double staining procedure, J chain was demonstrated using the indirect immunoperoxidase method followed by the demonstration of Ig with the direct immunofluorescence method. Optimum preservation of J chain immunoreactivity was obtained with fixation in neutral buffered formalin at 22 degrees C for 5 min followed by immediate immunoperoxidase staining. False negative results were seen when the slides were stained 2 weeks after fixation. In PWM-stimulated smears, J chain appeared on day three, simultaneously with or after the onset of Ig synthesis. In double stained smears most IgG-positive cells also showed immunoreactivity for J chain from the third day on.     

Thionine-Feulgen-Congo red staining of cervical smears for the BioPEPR image-analysis system

A staining method developed for use with BioPEPR (Biological Precision Encoding and Pattern Recognition), an automated image-analysis system for cervical smears, is described. The stain is a combination of the Feulgen procedure, with thionine-SO2 as the Schiff reagent, and Congo red, which is used as a counterstain. The stain resulted in smears suitable both for microscopic diagnosis and for BioPEPR measurements made on photonegatives at a single wavelength 545 nm. A high level of reproducibility and accuracy of nuclear and cytoplasmic area measurements was obtained. Nuclear integrated optical density could be well measured and was shown to be useful in discriminating between normal and abnormal cells. Using a combination of morphologic features, a high level of cell classification accuracy was reached. The possibility of using the stain for more detailed studies is discussed.     

Sequential staining of DNA-aldehyde with Schiff's reagent and acriflavine-SO2.

Acid hydrolysed DNA of rat liver was stained with Schiff's reagent at pHs 1.7 or 3.0 followed by staining with acriflavine-SO2 at pH 2.0 as well as with acriflavine-SO2 followed by Schiff's reagent at pH 1.7 or 3.0. Nuclei stained with Schiff's reagent at pH 1.7 were brown-yellow and an analysis of their absorption characteristics revealed two peaks--one at 470 nm and the other at 570 nm. Although nuclei stained with Schiff's reagent at pH 3.0 followed by acriflavine-SO2 were deep magenta in colour, they also showed similar peaks of maximum absorption. Identical peaks were also seen when the sequence of staining was reversed. It is suggested that in the conventional Feulgen-type reactions only some of the DNA-aldehyde molecules are stained; the remaining molecules can be stained by sequential application of another Schiff or Schiff-type reagent such as acriflavine-SO2. The possible mechanism of staining in these cases has been discussed.     

A Two Step Stain for Normal and Leukemic Monocytes Using Two Different Dyes Applied in Sequence

A staining procedure for monocytes in specimens of blood and bone marrow was developed. The technique was a two step procedure in which unfixed cells were exposed first to a methanolic solution of C.I. basic blue 54. Next, an aqueous alkaline buffered solution of C.I. basic blue 141 was added to the first staining solution. After staining for 10 min in the solution with two stains, slides or coverslips were washed for 5 sec in pH 5.6 phosphate buffer and drained dry. The cytoplasm of monocytes stained intensely deep purple and frequently nuclei were stained red. Similar staining was not found in other types of normal or abnormal blood and bone marrow cells.     

A naphthol yellow S and erythrosin B staining procedure for use in studies of the acrosome reaction of rabbit spermatozoa.

Rabbit spermatozoa suspended in Krebs-Ringer-phosphate containing 0.25% glucose were smeared on polylysine-coated slides and dried in air at room temperature for 30 min at room temperature, blotted, rinsed in 1.0% aqueous acetic acid for 10-15 sec, drained and stained for 7 min in a mixture of equal parts of aqueous naphthol yellow S and erythrosin B (final concentration of each dye 0.1% w/v) at pH 4.6-5.0 (pH adjusted with acetic acid). Stained slides were well rinsed in distilled water adjusted to pH 4.6-5.0 with acetic acid, blotted, allowed to dry completely, rinsed in xylene and mounted in synthetic resin. Acrosomal caps were stained cherry-red (apical ridge) to pink (dorsal and ventral aspects); postnuclear caps stained pale pink; nuclei were either unstained or stained a very faint yellowish-pink. The mid-piece and flagellum were stained different shades of pink. The procedure is simple, rapid, and gives highly reproducible results. When present, acrosomes are easily detected regardless of the density of the smear.