Pure forms of the singlet oxygen sensors TEMP and TEMPD do not inhibit Photosystem II

In a recent article (Hakala-Yatkin and Tyystj?rvi BBA 1807 (2011) 243-250) it was reported that the singlet oxygen spin traps 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine (TEMP) and 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidone (TEMPD) inhibit Photosystem II (PSII), the water oxidizing enzyme. O? evolution, chlorophyll fluorescence and thermoluminescence were measured and were shown to be greatly affected by these chemicals. This work casts doubts over an earlier body of work in which these chemicals were used as spin traps for monitoring 1O? production when PSII was inhibited by high light intensities. Here we show that these spin probes hardly affect PSII. We show that the commercial batches of TEMPD and TEMP used by Hakala-Yatkin and Tyystj?rvi contained impurities and/or derivatives that inhibited PSII and caused the specific effects on fluorescence. Earlier work that used pure spin traps to measure 1O? during photoinhibition, thus remains valid. However, concern must be expressed towards using these spin traps without proper controls.     

Inhibition of Photosystem II by the singlet oxygen sensor compounds TEMP and TEMPD

2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine (TEMP) and 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidinone (TEMPD) have earlier been used to quantify singlet oxygen produced by plant material. Both compounds were found to cause severe side effects on Photosystem II. Addition of TEMP or TEMPD to thylakoids immediately stabilized the reduced state of the Q(A) electron acceptor and destabilized the reduced state of the Q(B) acceptor, causing decrease in the driving force of forward electron transfer. Oxygen evolution, thermoluminescence and fluorescence measurements indicated that the number of functional PSII units decreased during incubation of thylakoids with TEMP or TEMPD. Singlet oxygen determinations in photosynthetic systems with piperidine derivatives should be interpreted with care.     

Effect of proline on the production of singlet oxygen

Molecular oxygen in electronic singlet state is a very powerful oxidant. Its damaging action in a variety of biological processes has been well recognized. Here we report the singlet oxygen quenching action of proline. Singlet oxygen (1O2) was produced photochemically by irradiating a solution of sensitiser and detected by following the formation of stable nitroxide radical yielded in the reaction of 1O2 with the sterically hindered amine (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine, TEMP). Illumination of a sensitiser, toluidine blue led to a time dependent increase in singlet oxygen production as detected by the formation of 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO) by EPR spectrometry. Interestingly, the production of TEMPO was completely abolished by the presence of proline at concentration as low as 20mM. These results show that proline is a very effective singlet oxygen quencher. Other singlet oxygen generating photosensitizer like hematopophyrin and fluorescein also produced identical results with proline. Since proline is one of the important solutes which accumulate in many organisms when they are exposed to environmental stresses, it is likely that proline accumulation is related to the protection of these organisms against singlet oxygen production during stress conditions. A possible mechanism of singlet oxygen quenching by proline is discussed.     

Characterization of processes responsible for the distinct effect of herbicides DCMU and BNT on Photosystem II photoinactivation in cells of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942

Light-induced modification of Photosystem II (PS II) complex was characterized in the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942 treated with either DCMU (a phenylurea PS II inhibitor) or BNT (a phenolic PS II inhibitor). The irradiance response of photoinactivation of PS II oxygen evolution indicated a BNT-specific photoinhibition that saturated at relatively low intensity of light. This BNT-specific process was slowed down under anaerobiosis, was accompanied by the oxygen-dependent formation of a 39 kDa D1 protein adduct, and was not related to stable Q_A reduction or the ADRY effect. In the BNT-treated cells, the light-induced, oxygen-independent initial drop of PS II electron flow was not affected by formate, an anion modifying properties of the PS II non-heme iron. For DCMU-treated cells, anaerobiosis did not significantly affect PS II photoinactivation, the D1 adduct was not observed and addition of formate induced similar initial decrease of PS II electron flow as in the BNT-treated cells. Our results indicate that reactive oxygen species (most likely singlet oxygen) and modification of the PS II acceptor side are responsible for the fast BNT-induced photoinactivation of PS II. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Evidence of singlet oxygen evolution by whole living cells of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The oxygen evolved by Chlamydomonas reinhardtii in the light is measured simultaneously with a Clark electrode and with the nitrosodimethylaniline-imidazole colorimetric method which is specific for singlet oxygen. Experiments with wild-type and FuD7 mutant cells (unable to synthesize the D1 protein of Photosystem II), with dichlorophenyldimethylurea (which blocks electron transfer from Photosystem II to Photosystem I) and with dibromothymoquinone (which diverts electrons from their normal path between the two photosystems), as well as with hydroxylamine (an inactivator of the water-splitting part of Photosystem II and a competitor of water for electron donation to it), all point to the dependence of detected singlet oxygen on photolysis of water by Photosystem II.Abbreviations DBMIB Dibromothymoquinone - DCMU Dichlorophenyldimethylurea - PS I and PS II Photosystems I and II - RNO para-nitrosodimethylaniline Contribution of the Centre interdisciplinaire de Biochimie de Oxygène.     

Scope and limitations of the TEMPO/EPR method for singlet oxygen detection: the misleading role of electron transfer

For many biological and biomedical studies, it is essential to detect the production of ¹O₂ and quantify its production yield. Among the available methods, detection of the characteristic 1270-nm phosphorescence of singlet oxygen by time-resolved near-infrared (TRNIR) emission constitutes the most direct and unambiguous approach. An alternative indirect method is electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) in combination with a singlet oxygen probe. This is based on the detection of the TEMPO free radical formed after oxidation of TEMP (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine) by singlet oxygen. Although the TEMPO/EPR method has been widely employed, it can produce misleading data. This is demonstrated by the present study, in which the quantum yields of singlet oxygen formation obtained by TRNIR emission and by the TEMPO/EPR method are compared for a set of well-known photosensitizers. The results reveal that the TEMPO/EPR method leads to significant overestimation of singlet oxygen yield when the singlet or triplet excited state of the photosensitizer is efficiently quenched by TEMP, acting as electron donor. In such case, generation of the TEMP⁺ radical cation, followed by deprotonation and reaction with molecular oxygen, gives rise to an EPR-detectable TEMPO signal that is not associated with singlet oxygen production. This knowledge is essential for an appropriate and error-free application of the TEMPO/EPR method in chemical, biological, and medical studies.     

Quality Control of Photosystem II: Lipid Peroxidation Accelerates Photoinhibition under Excessive Illumination

Environmental stresses lower the efficiency of photosynthesis and sometimes cause irreversible damage to plant functions. When spinach thylakoids and Photosystem II membranes were illuminated with excessive visible light (100–1,000 µmol photons m⁻¹ s⁻¹) for 10 min at either 20°C or 30°C, the optimum quantum yield of Photosystem II decreased as the light intensity and temperature increased. Reactive oxygen species and endogenous cationic radicals produced through a photochemical reaction at and/or near the reaction center have been implicated in the damage to the D1 protein. Here we present evidence that lipid peroxidation induced by the illumination is involved in the damage to the D1 protein and the subunits of the light-harvesting complex of Photosystem II. This is reasoned from the results that considerable lipid peroxidation occurred in the thylakoids in the light, and that lipoxygenase externally added in the dark induced inhibition of Photosystem II activity in the thylakoids, production of singlet oxygen, which was monitored by electron paramagnetic resonance spin trapping, and damage to the D1 protein, in parallel with lipid peroxidation. Modification of the subunits of the light-harvesting complex of Photosystem II by malondialdehyde as well as oxidation of the subunits was also observed. We suggest that mainly singlet oxygen formed through lipid peroxidation under light stress participates in damaging the Photosystem II subunits.     

Tocopherol as singlet oxygen scavenger in photosystem II

Singlet oxygen is formed in the photosystem II reaction center in the quench of P680 triplets, and the yield is dependent on light intensity and the reduction level of plastoquinone. Singlet oxygen in PS II triggers the degradation of the D1 protein. We investigated the participation of tocopherol as a singlet oxygen scavenger in this system. For this purpose, we inhibited tocopherol biosynthesis at the level of the HPP-dioxygenase in the alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii under conditions in which plastoquinone did not limit the photosynthesis rate. In the presence of the inhibitor and in high light for 2 h, photosynthesis in vivo and photosystem II was inactivated, the D1 protein was degraded, and the tocopherol pool was depleted and fell below its turnover rate/h. The inhibited system could be fully resuscitated upon the addition of a chemical singlet oxygen quencher (diphenylamine), and partly by synthetic cell wall permeable short chain alpha- and gamma-tocopherol derivatives. We conclude that under conditions of photoinhibition and extensive D1 protein turnover tocopherol has a protective function as a singlet oxygen scavenger.     

The cyanobacterium Synechococcus modulates Photosystem II function in response to excitation stress through D1 exchange

In this minireview we discuss effects of excitation stress on the molecular organization and function of PS II as induced by high light or low temperature in the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942. Synechococcus displays PS II plasticity by transiently replacing the constitutive D1 form (D1:1) with another form (D1:2) upon exposure to excitation stress. The cells thereby counteract photoinhibition by increasing D1 turn over and modulating PS II function. A comparison between the cyanobacterium Synechococcus and plants shows that in cyanobacteria, with their large phycobilisomes, resistance to photoinhibition is mainly through the dynamic properties (D1 turnover and quenching) of the reaction centre. In contrast, plants use antenna quenching in the light-harvesting complex as an important means to protect the reaction center from excessive excitation.Abbreviations D1 reaction center protein of Photosystem II - P₆₈₀ the reaction center of Photosystem II - Q_A the primary quinone acceptor of Photosystem II - Tyr_Z tyrosine electron donor to P₆₈₀     

Photosystem II in a mutant of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii lacking the 23 kDa psbP protein shows increased sensitivity to photoinhibition in the absence of chloride

The psbP gene product, the so called 23 kDa extrinsic protein, is involved in water oxidation carried out by Photosystem II. However, the protein is not absolutely required for water oxidation. Here we have studied Photosystem II mediated electron transfer in a mutant of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, the FUD 39 mutant, that lacks the psbP protein. When grown in dim light the Photosystem II content in thylakoid membranes of FUD 39 is approximately similar to that in the wild-type. The oxygen evolution is dependent on the presence of chloride as a cofactor, which activates the water oxidation with a dissociation constant of about 4 mM. In the mutant, the oxygen evolution is very sensitive to photoinhibition when assayed at low chloride concentrations while chloride protects against photoinhibition with a dissociation constant of about 5 mM. The photoinhibition is irreversible as oxygen evolution cannot be restored by the addition of chloride to inhibited samples. In addition the inhibition seems to be targeted primarily to the Mn-cluster in Photosystem II as the electron transfer through the remaining part of Photosystem II is photoinhibited with slower kinetics. Thus, this mutant provides an experimental system in which effects of photoinhibition induced by lesions at the donor side of Photosystem II can be studied in vivo.Abbreviations Chl chlorophyll - DCIP 2,6-dichlorophenolindophenol - DPC 2,2-diphenylcarbonic dihydrazide - HEPES 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazinethanesulfonic acid - P₆₈₀ the primary electron donor to PS II - PpBQ phenyl-p-benzoquinone - PS II Photosystem II - Q_A the first quinone acceptor of PS II - Q_B the second quinone acceptor of PS II - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate - Tris tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane - Tyr_D accessory electron donor on the D₂-protein - Tyr_Z tyrosine residue, acting as electron carrier between P₆₈₀ and the water oxidizing system     

Superoxide,Hydrogen Peroxide and Hydroxyl Radical in D1/D2/cytochrome b-559 Photosystem II Reaction Center Complex

Spin-trapping electron spin resonance (ESR) was used to monitor the formation of superoxide and hydroxyl radicals in D1/D2/cytochrome b-559 Photosystem II reaction center (PS II RC) Complex. When the PS II RC complex was strongly illuminated, superoxide was detected in the presence of ubiquinone. SOD activity was detected in the PS II RC complex. A primary product of superoxide, hydrogen peroxide, resulted in the production of the most destructive reactive oxygen species, *OH, in illuminated PS II RC complex. The contributions of ubiquinone, SOD and H(2)O(2) to the photobleaching of pigments and protein photodamage in the PS II RC complex were further studied. Ubiquinone protected the PS II RC complex from photodamage and, interestingly, extrinsic SOD promoted this damage. All these results suggest that PS II RC is an active site for the generation of superoxide and its derivatives, and this process protects organisms during strong illumination, probably by inhibiting more harmful ROS, such as singlet oxygen.     

Photoinhibition of carotenoidless reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides by visible light. Effects on protein structure and electron transport

Inhibition of electron transport and damage to the protein subunits by visible light has been studied in isolated reaction centers of the non-sulfur purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Illumination by 1100 μEm⁻² s⁻¹ light induced only a slight effect in wild type, carotenoid containing 2.4.1. reaction centers. In contrast, illumination of reaction centers isolated from the carotenoidless R26 strain resulted in the inhibition of charge separation as detected by the loss of the initial amplitude of absorbance change at 430 nm arising from the P⁺Q_B ⁻ → PQ_B recombination. In addition to this effect, the L, M and H protein subunits of the R26 reaction center were damaged as shown by their loss on Coomassie stained gels, which was however not accompanied by specific degradation products. Both the loss of photochemical activity and of protein subunits were suppressed in the absence of oxygen. By applying EPR spin trapping with 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine we could detect light-induced generation of singlet oxygen in the R26, but not in the 2.4.1. reaction centers. Moreover, artificial generation of singlet oxygen, also led to the loss of the L, M and H subunits. Our results provide evidence for the common hypothesis that strong illumination by visible light damages the carotenoidless reaction center via formation of singlet oxygen. This mechanism most likely proceeds through the interaction of the triplet state of reaction center chlorophyll with the ground state triplet oxygen in a similar way as occurs in Photosystem II. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The role of chloroplast-encoded protein biosynthesis on the rate of D1 protein degradation in Dunaliella salina

Mechanistic aspects of the Photosystem II (PS II) damage and repair cycle in Dunaliella salina were investigated. The work addressed the role of chloroplast-encoded protein biosynthesis on the rate of the D1 protein (chloroplast psbA gene product) degradation, following photoinhibition of PS II under in vivo conditions. Cells were grown under different light-intensities and the rate of D1 photodamage and degradation was measured via pulse-chase measurements with (³⁵S)sulfate. It is shown that no detectable difference exists in the rate of D1 degradation in D. salina, measured in the presence or absence of lincomycin, a chloroplast protein biosynthesis inhibitor. The results suggest that de novo D1 biosynthesis does not play a role in the regulation of D1 degradation. In low-light (100 mol photons m^–2 s^–1) grown cells, the rate of photodamage to D1 did not exceed the rate of its degradation and replacement. In high-light (2200 mol photons m^–1 s^–1) grown cells, the rate of D1 photodamage was faster than the rate of its degradation, resulting in a significant accumulation of photoinactivated PS II centers in the chloroplast thylakoids (chronic photoinhibition). The latter was coincident with the appearance of a 160 kD complex that contained photodamaged D1. Electron micrographs of D. salina thylakoids revealed extensive grana stacks in the thylakoid membrane of low-light grown cells. Only rudimentary appressions consisting of simple membrane pairings were found in the high-light grown cells. The results are discussed in terms of the regulation of D1 degradation in chloroplasts under in vivo conditions.Abbreviations Chl chlorophyll - D1 the 32 kD reaction center protein of PS II, encoded by the chloroplast psbA gene - D2 the 34 kD reaction center protein of PS II, encoded by the chloroplast psbD gene - HL high light - LL low light - Linc lincomycin     

Mathematical modelling of photoinhibition and Photosystem II repair cycle. I. Photoinhibition and D1 protein degradation in vitro and in the absence of chloroplast protein synthesis in vivo

The kinetics of photoinhibition of Photosystem II and D1 protein degradation were studied by applying mathematical modelling to new and published data. The word photoinhibition refers here only to such inhibition of PS II activity that requires chloroplast protein synthesis for recovery. It is shown that acceptor-side photoinhibition in vitro as well as in vivo photoinhibition in higher plants and cyanobacteria in the presence of prokaryotic translation inhibitors follow first-order kinetics. Degradation of damaged D1 protein also fits in a first-order reaction equation with respect to the concentration of photoinhibited PS II centres. It is shown that photoprotective lowering of the ratio of variable to maximum fluorescence can be distinguished from the lowering of this ratio associated with photoinhibition.     

A Fourier transform infrared spectroscopic study of the effects of hydrogen peroxide and high light on protein conformations of Photosystem II

Degradation of the reaction center-binding protein D1 of Photosystem II (PS II) during photoinhibition is dependent on the action of active oxygen species and/or D1-specific proteases. Protein conformational changes may be involved in the process of D1 degradation. In the present study, we determined the effect of H₂O₂ on spinach PS II-enriched membranes and core complexes with respect to electron transport, Mn content and protein secondary structural changes as measured by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. H₂O₂ is effective in removing catalytic Mn in PS II, especially in PS II core complexes depleted of OEC18 and OEC24, impairing the donor-side. By quantitative analysis of the amide I band (1600 – 1700 cm^-1) with both aqueous and dehydrated PS II samples, we found that no significant secondary structural changes are associated with H₂O₂ treatment in the dark, even though there is some cleavage of the D1 protein by H₂O₂ treatment as determined by Western analysis with specific antibodies. In contrast, a large decrease in the -helices in the PS II core occurs, with or without H₂O₂ treatment, after 20 min strong illumination and there is more extensive degradation of the D1 protein. Our results suggest that high light enhances the cleavage of the D1 protein which is reflected in the large protein secondary structural changes in PS II detected by FTIR measurements.     

Superoxide radicals are not the main promoters of acceptor-side-induced photoinhibitory damage in spinach thylakoids

Superoxide anion radical formation was studied with isolated spinach thylakoid membranes and oxygen evolving Photosystem II sub-thylakoid preparations using the reaction between superoxide and Tiron (1,2-dihydroxybenzene-3,5-disulphonate) which results in the formation of stable, EPR detectable Tiron radicals.We found that superoxide was produced by illuminated thylakoids but not by Photosystem II preparations. The amount of the radicals was about 70% greater under photoinhibitory conditions than under moderate light intensity. Superoxide production was inhibited by DCMU and enhanced 4–5 times by methyl viologen. These observations suggest that the superoxide in illuminated thylakoids is from the Mehler reaction occurring in Photosystem I, and its formation is not primarily due to electron transport modifications brought about by photoinhibition.Artificial generation of superoxide from riboflavin accelerated slightly the photoinduced degradation of the Photosystem II reaction centre protein D1 but did not accelerate the loss of oxygen evolution supported by a Photosystem II electron acceptor. However, analysis of the protein breakdown products demonstrated that this added superoxide did not increase the amount of fragments brought about by photoinhibition but introduced an additional pathway of damage.On the basis of the above observations we propose that superoxide redicals are not the main promoters of acceptor-side-induced photoinhibition of Photosystem II.Abbreviations DCBQ- 2,5-dichloro-p-benzoquinone - DCMU- 3- (3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea - DMBQ- 2,5-dimethyl-p-benzoquinone - DMPO- 5,5-dimethyl-pyrrolin N-oxide - Hepes- N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-piperazine-N-(2-ethanesulfonic acid) - Mes- 2-(N-morpholino)-ethanesulfonic acid - methyl viologen- 1,1-dimethyl-4,4-bipyridinium dichloride - PS- Photosystem - SOD- Superoxide dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) - Tiron- 1,2-dihydroxybenzene-3,5-disulphonate - Tris- 2-amino-2-hydroxymethylpropane-1,3-diol     

Kok's oxygen clock: What makes it tick? The structure of P680 and consequences of its oxidizing power

New insights in the structure of P680, the primary electron donor in Photosystem II, are summarized and the implications of its oxidizing power for energy transfer and singlet oxygen production are discussed.Abbreviations BChl bacteriochlorophyll - Chl chlorophyll - LD linear dichroism - Pheo pheophytin - PS II Photosystem II     

Do oxidative stress conditions impairing photosynthesis in the light manifest as photoinhibition?

We compared the effect of photoinhibition by excess photosynthetically active radiation (PAR), UV-B irradiation combined with PAR, low temperature stress and paraquat treatment on photosystem (PS) II. Although the experimental conditions ensured that the four studied stress conditions resulted in approximately the same extent of PS II inactivation, they clearly followed different molecular mechanisms. Our results show that singlet oxygen production in inactivated PS II reaction centres is a unique characteristic of photoinhibition by excess PAR. Neither the accumulation of inactive PS II reaction centres (as in UV-B or chilling stress), nor photo-oxidative damage of PS II (as in paraquat stress) is able to produce the special oxidizing conditions characteristic of acceptor-side-induced photoinhibition.     

Reversible phosphorylation and turnover of the D1 protein under various redox states of Photosystem II induced by low temperature photoinhibition

Reversible phosphorylation and turnover of the D1 protein in vivo were studied under low-temperature photoinhibition of pumpkin leaves and under subsequent recovery at low light at 4 °C or 23 °C. The inactivation of PS II and photodamage to D1 were not enhanced during low-temperature photoinhibition when compared to that at room temperature. The PS II repair cycle, however, was completely blocked at 4 °C at the level of D1 degradation. Both the recovery of the photochemical activity of PS II and the degradation of the damaged D1 protein at low light at 23 °C were delayed about 1 hour after low-temperature photoinhibition, suggesting that in addition to the decrease in catalytic turnover of the enzyme, the protease was specifically inactivated in vivo at low temperature. The effect of low temperature on the other regulatory enzymes of PS II repair, protein kinase and phosphatase [Rintamäki et al. (1996) J Biol Chem 271: 14870-14875] was variable. The D1 protein kinase was operational at low temperature while dephosphorylation of the D1 protein seemed to be completely inhibited during low temperature treatment. Under subsequent recovery conditions at low light and 23 °C, the high phosphorylation level of D1 was sustained in leaf discs photoinhibited at low temperature, despite the recovery of the phosphatase activity. This high phosphorylation level of D1 was due to the persistently active kinase. The D1 kinase, previously shown to get activated by reduction of plastoquinone, was, however, found to be maximally active already at relatively low redox state of the plastoquinone pool. We suggest that phosphorylation of PS II centers increases the stability of PS II complexes and concomitantly improves their survival under stress conditions.     

The effect of Photosystem II inhibitors DCMU and BNT on the high-light induced D1 turnover in two cyanobacterial strains Synechocystis PCC 6803 and Synechococcus PCC 7942

The effect of the Photosystem II (PSII) inhibitors dichlorophenyldimethylurea (DCMU) and bromonitrothymol (BNT) on the rate of the high-light induced D1 protein turnover was studied in whole cells of two cyanobacterial strains Synechocystis PCC 6803 and Synechococcus PCC 7942. In Synechocystis the D1 degradation was slowed down to a similar extent in the presence of either inhibitor compared with control cells. This slower degradation corresponded with the retardation of Photosystem II photoinactivation (PSIIPI) measured as a decline of PS II activity in the illuminated cells treated with chloramphenicol (CAP). The ongoing D1 synthesis in the presence of both PS II inhibitors was confirmed by unchanging PS II activity and the steady-state level of D1 during illumination in the absence of CAP. In Synechococcus cells both DCMU and BNT blocked the turnover of the 'low-light' D1 form (D1:1) but did not prevent the exchange of the 'high-light' form D1:2 for the D1:1 form. The similar effect of both herbicides on the D1 exchange was in contrast with their influence on the rate of PSIIPI. While DCMU had a pronounced protective effect, BNT significantly increased the rate of PS II photodamage. The fast BNT-induced decline of PS II activity was also observed in Synechocystis cells treated with azide, an inhibitor of reactive oxygen species scavenging enzymes. Therefore, we assume that the distinct sensitivity of the two cyanobacterial strains to BNT can be caused by different content and/or activity of these enzymes in each strain.