Production of Biodiesel Using Immobilized Lipase—A Critical Review

Increase in volume of biodiesel production in the world scenario proves that biodiesel is accepted as an alternative to conventional fuel. Production of biodiesel using alkaline catalyst has been commercially implemented due to its high conversion and low production time. For the product and process development of biodiesel, enzymatic transesterification has been suggested to produce a high purity product with an economic, environment friendly process at mild reaction conditions. The enzyme cost being the main hurdle can be overcome by immobilization. Immobilized enzyme, which has been successfully used in various fields over the soluble counterpart, could be employed in biodiesel production with the aim of reducing the production cost by reusing the enzyme. This review attempts to provide an updated compilation of the studies reported on biodiesel production by using lipase immobilized through various techniques and the parameters, which affect their functionality.     

An overview of enzymatic production of biodiesel

Biodiesel production has received considerable attention in the recent past as a biodegradable and nonpolluting fuel. The production of biodiesel by transesterification process employing alkali catalyst has been industrially accepted for its high conversion and reaction rates. Recently, enzymatic transesterification has attracted much attention for biodiesel production as it produces high purity product and enables easy separation from the byproduct, glycerol. But the cost of enzyme remains a barrier for its industrial implementation. In order to increase the cost effectiveness of the process, the enzyme (both intracellular and extracellular) is reused by immobilizing in a suitable biomass support particle and that has resulted in considerable increase in efficiency. But the activity of immobilized enzyme is inhibited by methanol and glycerol which are present in the reacting mixture. The use of tert-butanol as solvent, continuous removal of glycerol, stepwise addition of methanol are found to reduce the inhibitory effects thereby increasing the cost effectiveness of the process. The present review analyzes these methods reported in literature and also suggests a suitable method for commercialization of the enzymatic process.     

Biotechnological production of biodiesel fuel using biocatalysed transesterification: A review

Biotechnological production of biodiesel has attracted considerable attention during the past decade compared to chemical-catalysed production since biocatalysis-mediated transesterification has many advantages. Currently, there are extensive reports on enzyme-catalysed transesterification for biodiesel production; the related research can be classified into immobilised-extracellular and immobilised-intracellular biocatalysis and this review focusses on these forms of biocatalyst for biodiesel production. The optimisation of the most important operating conditions affecting lipase-catalysed transesterification and the yield of alkyl esters, such as the type and form of lipase, the type of alcohol, the presence of organic solvents, the content of water in the oil, temperature and the presence of glycerol, are discussed. However, there is still a need to optimise lipase-catalysed transesterification and reduce the cost of lipase production before it is applied commercially. Optimisation research of lipase-catalysed transesterification could include development of new reactor systems with immobilised biocatalysts, the use of lipases tolerant to organic solvents, intracellular lipases (whole microbial cells) and genetically modified microorganisms (intelligent yeasts). Biodiesel fuel is expensive in comparison with petroleum-based fuel and 60–70% of the cost is associated with feedstock oil and enzyme. Therefore ways of reducing the cost of biodiesel with respect to enzyme and substrate oils reported in literature are also presented.     

酶法合成生物柴油工业化研究进展

介绍了北京化工大学近年来酶法合成生物柴油工业化研究的结果。主要内容包括以下几个方面:高产脂肪酶菌株的选育、脂肪酶发酵工艺优化及放大、脂肪酶固定化方法、酶反应器放大、生物柴油分离精制及副产物甘油综合利用。该脂肪酶假丝酵母Candida sp.99-125在5 m3罐发酵活力不低于8 000 IU/mL,然后将该脂肪酶吸附固定在织物膜上并进行表面改性,用于搅拌罐式反应器生产每吨甲酯的需酶量仅为4.2 kg,产品经分离精制调质后,其各项指标完全符合德国生物柴油生产标准。副产物甘油可用于1,3-丙二醇发酵,30 L发酵罐中1,3-丙二醇的产量可达到76.1 g/L。     

Lipase-catalyzed biodiesel production with methyl acetate as acyl acceptor

Biodiesel is an alternative diesel fuel made from renewable biological resources. During the process of biodiesel production, lipase-catalyzed transesterification is a crucial step. However, current techniques using methanol as acyl acceptor have lower enzymatic activity; this limits the application of such techniques in large-scale biodiesel production. Furthermore, the lipid feedstock of currently available techniques is limited. In this paper, the technique of lipase-catalyzed transesterification of five different oils for biodiesel production with methyl acetate as acyl acceptor was investigated, and the transesterification reaction conditions were optimized. The operation stability of lipase under the obtained optimal conditions was further examined. The results showed that under optimal transesterification conditions, both plant oils and animal fats led to high yields of methyl ester: cotton-seed oil, 98%; rapeseed oil, 95%; soybean oil, 91%; tea-seed oil, 92%; and lard, 95%. Crude and refined cottonseed oil or lard made no significant difference in yields of methyl ester. No loss of enzymatic activity was detected for lipase after being repeatedly used for 40 cycles (ca. 800 h), which indicates that the operational stability of lipase was fairly good under these conditions. Our results suggest that cotton-seed oil, rape-seed oil and lard might substitute soybean oil as suitable lipid feedstock for biodiesel production. Our results also show that our technique is fit for various lipid feedstocks both from plants and animals, and presents a very promising way for the large-scale biodiesel production.     

Biodiesel production via enzymatic catalysis

A review of current work in biodiesel production via enzymatic catalysis has been done. The parameters of the process as determined by laboratories are represented and analyzed. The main factors affecting interesterification are considered. The major types of oils and alcohols used in biodiesel synthesis are listed. The means of lipase enzyme immobilization, including exposure on the cell surface, are discussed.     

Biodiesel fuel production via transesterification of oils using lipase biocatalyst

Biodiesel has gained widespread importance in recent years as an alternative, renewable liquid transportation fuel. It is derived from natural triglycerides in the presence of an alcohol and an alkali catalyst via a transesterification reaction. To date, transesterification based on the use of chemical catalysts has been predominant for biodiesel production at the industrial scale due to its high conversion efficiency at reasonable cost. Recently, biocatalytic transesterification has received considerable attention due to its favorable conversion rate and relatively simple downstream processing demands for the recovery of by-products and purification of biodiesel. Biocatalysis of the transesterification reaction using commercially purified lipase represents a major cost constraint. However, more cost-effective techniques based on the immobilization of both extracellular and intracellular lipases on support materials facilitate the reusability of the catalyst. Other variables, including the presence of alcohol, glycerol and the activity of water can profoundly affect lipase activity and stability during the reaction. This review evaluates the current status for lipase biocatalyst-mediated production of biodiesel, and identifies the key parameters affecting lipase activity and stability. Pioneer studies on reactor-based lipase conversion of triglycerides are presented.     

A novel enzymatic route for biodiesel production from renewable oils in a solvent-free medium

A new enzymatic route for biodiesel production from soybean oil was developed using methyl acetate as a novel acyl acceptor. Novozym 435 (immobilized Candida antarctica lipase) gave the highest methyl ester (ME) yield of 92%. The optimum conditions of the transesterification were 30% enzyme based on oil weight; a molar ratio of methyl acetate/oil of 12:1; temperature 40 °C and reaction time 10 h. Since no glycerol was produced in the process, this method is very convenient for recycling the catalyst and by-product triacetylglycerol showed no negative effect on the fuel property.     

Biocatalysis: Towards ever greener biodiesel production

The cost of lipases and the relatively slower reaction rate remain as the major obstacles for enzymatic production of biodiesel as opposed to the conventional chemical processes. This paper reviews the starting oils usually employed in biodiesel production, the processes for transforming them to biodiesel placing particular emphasis on enzymatic transesterification. The pros and cons of the lipase-based process, the key operational variables and the technological alternatives for attenuating lipase deactivation are also discussed. Finally, suggestions are made for future studies, paying particular attention to the use of whole cell immobilization in the production process, as this methodology may reduce both the cost of the biocatalyst and dependence on lipase manufacturers.     

脂肪酶催化合成生物柴油的研究

生物柴油是用动植物油脂或长链脂肪酸与甲醇等低碳醇合成的脂肪酸甲酯,是一种替代能源。这里探讨了生物法制备生物柴油的过程,采用脂肪酶酯化和酯交换两条工艺路线进行催化合成。深入研究制备过程中,不同脂肪酶、酶的用量和纯度、有机溶剂、低碳醇的抑制作用、吸水剂的作用、反应时间和进程、底物的特异性和底物摩尔比等参数对酯化过程的影响。试验结果表明,采用最佳酯化反应参数和分批加入甲醇并用硅胶作脱水剂的工艺过程,酯化率可以达到92％,经分离纯化后的产品GC分析的纯度可达98％以上,固定化酶的使用半衰期可达到360h。同时对酯交换制备生物柴油过程中,甲醇的用量和甲醇的加入方式对脂肪酶催化过程的影响作了初步研究,优化后的酯交换率可达到83％。     

Biodiesel production from Jatropha curcas: a critical review

The fuel crisis and environmental concerns, mainly due to global warming, have led researchers to consider the importance of biofuels such as biodiesel. Vegetable oils, which are too viscous to be used directly in engines, are converted into their corresponding methyl or ethyl esters by a process called transesterification. With the recent debates on “food versus fuel,” non-edible oils, such as Jatropha curcas, are emerging as one of the main contenders for biodiesel production. Much research is still needed to explore and realize the full potential of a green fuel from J. curcas. Upcoming projects and plantations of Jatropha in countries such as India, Malaysia, and Indonesia suggest a promising future for this plant as a potential biodiesel feedstock. Many of the drawbacks associated with chemical catalysts can be overcome by using lipases for enzymatic transesterification. The high cost of lipases can be overcome, to a certain extent, by immobilization techniques. This article reviews the importance of the J. curcas plant and describes existing research conducted on Jatropha biodiesel production. The article highlights areas where further research is required and relevance of designing an immobilized lipase for biodiesel production is discussed.     

Esterification using a liquid lipase to remove residual free fatty acids in biodiesel

Lately, the price of liquid formulated lipase enzymes, usable in biodiesel production, has been significantly reduced. This enables one-time use of these enzymes for transesterification, and the process is used industrially. However, the process suffers a drawback by leaving 2−3 % free fatty acids in the crude biodiesel, which reduces the profitability. This article discusses a novel enzymatic FFA esterification reaction utilizing liquid lipase B from Candida antarctica (CALB) along with glycerol at low water concentrations to eliminate the residual FFA. The reaction setup was found able to reduce the free fatty acid concentration to within biodiesel specifications of < 0.25 wt.% FFA. Additionally, two alternative process setups are proposed, which were both found viable through a combination of experiments and simulations, and can be developed into full-scale processes. The resulting two-step enzymatic biodiesel process - transesterification followed by esterification - provides a potential process layout for the industrial production of biodiesel.     

Continuous biodiesel production using in situ glycerol separation by membrane bioreactor system

Biodiesel is one of the most promising renewable fuel sources. Candida antarctica lipase B (CalB) has been used for biodiesel production because of its high activity and stability. However, CalB can only be utilized in industrial biodiesel production if the enzyme deactivation by methanol and the negative effects of glycerol can be mitigated. Methanol inhibition can be avoided by utilizing a stepwise addition of methanol, but there is no suitable method to reduce the glycerol effect. This study aims to use a membrane bioreactor system to remove glycerol during biodiesel production. In addition, methanol inhibition can be reduced by continuously feeding methanol through the membrane system. This continuous membrane bioreactor system can be used for efficient biodiesel production.     

Study of lipase immobilization on zeolitic support and transesterification reaction in a solvent free-system

In order to understand the role of the acid–base, electrostatic and covalent interactions between enzyme and support, the catalytic behavior of the Rhizomucor miehei lipase (RML) immobilized on zeolite materials has been studied. The highest lipase activities were obtained when this enzyme, immobilized by adsorption, interacts through acid–base binding forces with the support surface, resulting in activation of the enzyme catalytic center. Due to the interest in biodiesel production by mild enzymatic transesterification, this heterogeneous biocatalyst has been used in transesterification of fatty acids contained in olive oil. The results show a high oleic acid conversion for several reaction cycles with a higher total biodiesel productivity compared to that using the free enzyme.     

Simultaneous conversion of free fatty acids and triglycerides to biodiesel by immobilized Aspergillus oryzae expressing Fusarium heterosporum lipase

The presence of high levels of free fatty acids (FFA) in oil is a barrier to one‐step biodiesel production. Undesirable soaps are formed during conventional chemical methods, and enzyme deactivation occurs when enzymatic methods are used. This work investigates an efficient technique to simultaneously convert a mixture of free fatty acids and triglycerides (TAG). A partial soybean hydrolysate containing 73.04% free fatty acids and 24.81% triglycerides was used as a substrate for the enzymatic production of fatty acid methyl ester (FAME). Whole‐cell Candida antarctica lipase B‐expressing Aspergillus oryzae, and Novozym 435 produced only 75.2 and 73.5% FAME, respectively. Fusarium heterosporum lipase‐expressing A. oryzae produced more than 93% FAME in 72 h using three molar equivalents of methanol. FFA and TAG were converted simultaneously in the presence of increasing water content that resulted from esterification. Therefore, F. heterosporum lipase with a noted high level of tolerance of water could be useful in the industrial production of biodiesel from feedstock that has high proportion of free fatty acids.     

Biodiesel production with immobilized lipase: A review

Fatty acid alkyl esters, also called biodiesel, are environmentally friendly and show great potential as an alternative liquid fuel. Biodiesel is produced by transesterification of oils or fats with chemical catalysts or lipase. Immobilized lipase as the biocatalyst draws high attention because that process is “greener”. This article reviews the current status of biodiesel production with immobilized lipase, including various lipases, immobilization methods, various feedstocks, lipase inactivation caused by short chain alcohols and large scale industrialization. Adsorption is still the most widely employed method for lipase immobilization. There are two kinds of lipase used most frequently especially for large scale industrialization. One is Candida antartica lipase immobilized on acrylic resin, and the other is Candida sp. 99–125 lipase immobilized on inexpensive textile membranes. However, to further reduce the cost of biodiesel production, new immobilization techniques with higher activity and stability still need to be explored.     

固定化全细胞催化可再生油脂合成生物柴油的稳定性

酶法合成生物柴油具有反应条件温和、醇用量小、无污染物排放、产物易分离回收等优点,越来越得到关注。全细胞催化剂,无需酶的提取和纯化,减少了酶活损失,有望大幅降低生产成本;Rhizopus oryzae IFO4697全细胞可以有效催化植物油脂合成生物柴油,进一步提高全细胞在催化植物油脂甲醇解制备生物柴油过程中的稳定性,对于工业放大具有重要意义。本实验对固定化全细胞Rhizopus oryzae IFO4697催化植物油脂合成生物柴油的稳定性进行了系统地研究,结果表明:反应体系水含量对于全细胞催化剂的反应活性和催化稳定性有重要影响,5%～15%含水量适宜;研究范围内,载体粒度及干燥方式对稳定性影响不显著;经过戊二醛交联后,全细胞催化油脂甲醇解反应的稳定性显著提高,1200h反应后,仍然可以保持75%的生物柴油得率;真空抽滤直接回用的方式有利于稳定性的保持。在优化条件下,回用20个批次,生物柴油得率可维持在80%。     

Evaluation of diatomaceous earth as a support for sol–gel immobilized lipase for transesterification

Enzymatic production of biodiesel by triglyceride transesterification is a promising alternative to chemically catalyzed biodiesel production despite the challenges involved with using enzymes. Celite^® supported lipase sol–gels were investigated as an option for solving some of the challenges associated with the use of enzymes for biodiesel production addressing such problems as activity, stability and reusability of the enzyme. Three types of Celite^® were considered (R633, R632, and R647) and compared to unsupported lipase sol–gels. Various factors were considered with regard to comparing the support materials. They included surface morphology characterized using surface area analysis and scanning electron microscopy, physical properties including adhesion of the sol–gel to the Celite^® and the protein loading on the Celite^®, and finally enzymatic properties based on the conversion of methanol to methyl oleate and the enzymatic activity of lipase. All the sol–gels showed good conversion and initial lipase activity, and all the Celite^® supports had similar sol–gel adhesion and protein loading. Sol–gel immobilized lipase supported on Celite^® R632 had an average 6-h percent conversion of approximately 60%, and an average initial lipase activity comparable to that of the unsupported sol–gel formulation.     

Study on acyl migration in immobilized lipozyme TL-catalyzed transesterification of soybean oil for biodiesel production

During enzymatic transesterification of soybean oils with methanol for biodiesel production, it was supposed that the maximum biodiesel yield was only 66% since lipozyme TL was a typical lipase with a strict 1,3-positional specificity. However, it has been observed that over 90% biodiesel yield could be obtained. It was therefore assumed, and subsequently demonstrated, that acyl migration occurred during the reaction process. Different factors which may influence the acyl migration were explored further and it has been found that the silica gel acting as the immobilized material contributes significantly to the promotion of acyl migration in the transesterification process. The final biodiesel yield was only 66% when 4% lipozyme TL used, while about 90% biodiesel yield could be achieved when combining 6% silica gel with 4% lipozyme TL, almost as high as that of 10% immobilized lipase used for the reaction.     

Lipase-catalyzed biodiesel production from waste activated bleaching earth as raw material in a pilot plant

The production of fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) from waste activated bleaching earth (ABE) discarded by the crude oil refining industry using lipase from Candida cylindracea was investigated in a 50-L pilot plant. Diesel oil or kerosene was used as an organic solvent for the transesterification of triglycerides embedded in the waste ABE. When 1% (w/w) lipase was added to waste ABE, the FAME content reached 97% (w/w) after reaction for 12 h at 25 degrees C with an agitation rate of 30 rpm. The FAME production rate was strongly dependent upon the amount of enzyme added. Mixtures of FAME and diesel oil at ratios of 45:55 (BDF-45) and 35:65 (BDF-35) were assessed and compared with the European specifications for biodiesel as automotive diesel fuel, as defined by pr EN 14214. The biodiesel quality of BDF-45 met the EN 14214 standard. BDF-45 was used as generator fuel, and the exhaust emissions were compared with those of diesel oil. The CO and SO2 contents were reduced, but nitrogen oxide emission increased by 10%. This is the first report of a pilot plant study of lipase-catalyzed FAME production using waste ABE as a raw material. This result demonstrates a promising reutilization method for the production of FAME from industrial waste resources containing vegetable oils for use as a biodiesel fuel.