Direct three-dimensional localization and positive identification of RNA helices within the ribosome by means of genetic tagging and cryo-electron microscopy

BACKGROUND: Ribosomes are complex macromolecular machines that perform the translation of the genetic message. Cryo-electron microscopic (cryo-EM) maps of the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome are approaching a resolution of 10 A and X-ray maps of the 30S and 50S subunits are now available at 5 A. These maps show a lot of details about the inner architecture of the ribosome and ribosomal RNA helices are clearly visible. However, in the absence of further biological information, even at the higher resolution of the X-ray maps many rRNA helices can be placed only tentatively. Here we show that genetic tagging in combination with cryo-EM can place and orient double-stranded RNA helices with high accuracy. RESULTS: A tRNA sequence inserted into the E. coli 23S ribosomal RNA gene, at one of the points of sequence expansion in eukaryotic ribosomes, is visible in the cryo-EM map as a peripheral 'foot' structure. By tracing its acceptor-stem end, the location of helix 63 in domain IV and helix 98 in domain VI of the 50S subunit could be precisely determined. CONCLUSIONS: Our study demonstrates for the first time that features of a three-dimensional cryo-EM map of an asymmetric macromolecular complex can be interpreted in terms of secondary and primary structure. Using the identified helices as a starting point, it is possible to model and interpret, in molecular terms, a larger portion of the ribosome. Our results might be also useful in interpreting and refining the current X-ray maps.     

Protein binding sites on Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA; RNA regions that are protected by proteins S7, S9 and S19, and by proteins S8, S15 and S17.

Selected groups of isolated 14C-labelled proteins from E. coli 30S ribosomal subunits were reconstituted with 32P-labelled 16S RNA, and the reconstituted complexes were partially digested with ribonuclease A. RNA fragments protected by the proteins were separated by gel electrophoresis and subjected to sequence analysis. Complexes containing proteins S7 and S19 protected an RNA region comprising helices 29 to 32, part of helix 41, and helices 42 and 43 of the 16S RNA secondary structure. Addition of protein S9 had no effect. When compared with previous data for proteins S7, S9, S14 and S19, these results suggest that S14 interacts with helix 33, and that S9 and S14 together interact with the loop-end of helix 41. Complexes containing proteins S8, S15 and S17 protected helices 7 to 10 as well as the "S8-S15 binding site" (helices 20, 22 and parts of helices 21 and 23). When protein S15 was omitted, S8 and S18 showed protection of part of helix 44 in addition to the latter regions. The results are discussed in terms of our model for the detailed arrangement of proteins and RNA in the 30S subunit.     

The three transfer RNAs occupying the A, P and E sites on the ribosome are involved in viral programmed -1 ribosomal frameshift

The -1 programmed ribosomal frameshifts (PRF), which are used by many viruses, occur at a heptanucleotide slippery sequence and are currently thought to involve the tRNAs interacting with the ribosomal P- and A-site codons. We investigated here whether the tRNA occupying the ribosomal E site that precedes a slippery site influences -1 PRF. Using the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) frameshift region, we found that mutating the E-site codon altered the -1 PRF efficiency. When the HIV-1 slippery sequence was replaced with other viral slippery sequences, mutating the E-site codon also altered the -1 PRF efficiency. Because HIV-1 -1 PRF can be recapitulated in bacteria, we used a bacterial ribosome system to select, by random mutagenesis, 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) mutations that modify the expression of a reporter requiring HIV-1 -1 PRF. Three mutants were isolated, which are located in helices 21 and 22 of 16S rRNA, a region involved in translocation and E-site tRNA binding. We propose a novel model where -1 PRF is triggered by an incomplete translocation and depends not only on the tRNAs interacting with the P- and A-site codons, but also on the tRNA occupying the E site.     

Binding of tRNA alters the chemical accessibility of nucleotides within the large ribosomal RNAs of E. coli ribosomes.

Functionally active 70S ribosomes were chemically modified with dimethylsulfate (DMS) in the presence and absence of bound tRNA. The ribosomal 16S RNA and 23S RNA were extracted, separated and labeled radioactively at their 3'-ends. DMS modification sites within the last 200 nucleotides from the 3'-ends were investigated on sequencing gels, after borohydride reduction and aniline catalyzed strand scission of the isolated RNA's. tRNA binding caused enhanced reactivity at 9 nucleotide positions while three sites showed decreased reactivity in the 16S RNA. The effects of bound tRNA on the modification of 23S RNA were limited. Only one enhancement was observed in the presence of bound tRNA. mRNA binding alone showed two more sites with enhanced reactivity, however. The results are consistent with the view that the sequence 1400-1500 of the 16S RNA plays an important functional role in the translating ribosome and possibly constitutes part of the tRNA binding site.     

Secondary structure model for 23S ribosomal RNA.

A secondary structure model for 23S ribosomal RNA has been constructed on the basis of comparative sequence data, including the complete sequences from E. coli. Bacillus stearothermophilis, human and mouse mitochondria and several partial sequences. The model has been tested extensively with single strand-specific chemical and enzymatic probes. Long range base-paired interactions organize the molecule into six major structural domains containing over 100 individual helices in all. Regions containing the sites of interaction with several ribosomal proteins and 5S RNA have been located. Segments of the 23S RNA structure corresponding to eucaryotic 5.8S and 25 RNA have been identified, and base paired interactions in the model suggest how they are attached to 28S RNA. Functionally important regions, including possible sites of contact with 30S ribosomal subunits, the peptidyl transferase center and locations of intervening sequences in various organisms are discussed. Models for molecular 'switching' of RNA molecules based on coaxial stacking of helices are presented, including a scheme for tRNA-23S RNA interaction.     

Higher order structure in the 3'-minor domain of small subunit ribosomal RNAs from a gram negative bacterium, a gram positive bacterium and a eukaryote

An experimental approach was used to determine and compare the highest order structure within the 150 to 200 nucleotides at the 3'-ends of the RNAs from the small ribosomal subunits of Escherichia coli, Bacillus stearothermophilus and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Chemical reagents were employed to establish the degree of stacking and/or accessibility of each adenosine, guanosine and cytidine. The double helices were probed with a cobra venom ribonuclease from Naja naja oxiana, and the relatively unstructured and accessible sequences were localized with the single strand-specific ribonucleases A, T1, T2 and S1. The data enabled the various minimal secondary structural models, proposed for the 3'-regions of the E. coli and S. cerevisiae RNAs, to be critically examined, and to demonstrate that the main common features of these models are correct. The results also reveal the presence and position of additional higher order structure in the renatured free RNA. It can be concluded that a high level of conservation of higher order structure has occurred during the evolution of the gram negative and gram positive eubacteria and the eukaryote in both the double helical regions and the "unstructured" regions. Several unusual structural features were detected. Multiple G X A pairings in two of the putative helices, which are compatible with phylogenetic sequence comparisons, are strongly supported by the occurrence of cobra venom ribonuclease cuts adjacent to, and in one case between, these pairings. Evidence is also provided for the stacking of an A X A pair within a double helix of the yeast RNA. Other special structural features include adenosines bulged out from double helices; such nucleotides, which are hyper-reactive, have been implicated in protein recognition in 5 S ribosomal RNA. The 3'-terminal regions of the RNAs are particularly important for the functioning of the ribosome. They are involved in mRNA, tRNA and ribosomal factor binding. The results reveal that while the functionally important RNA sequences tend to be conserved, they are not always accessible in the free RNA; the pyrimidine-rich "Shine and Dalgarno" sequence, for example, which is involved in mRNA recognition, occurs in a double helix in both eubacterial RNAs.     

Detection of specific sequences among DNA fragments separated by gel electrophoresis.

Ribosomal RNA and precursor ribosomal RNA from at least one representative of each vertebrate class have been analyzed by electron microscopic secondary structure mapping. Reproducible patterns of hairpin loops were found in both 28 S ribosomal and precursor ribosomal RNA, whereas almost all the 18 S ribosomal RNA molecules lack secondary structure under the spreading conditions used. The precursor ribosomal RNA of all species analyzed have a common design. The 28 S ribosomal RNA is located at or near the presumed 5′-end and is separated from the 18 S ribosomal RNA region by the internal spacer region. In addition there is an external spacer region at the 3′-end of all precursor ribosomal RNA molecules. Changes in the length of these spacer regions are mainly responsible for the increase in size of the precursor ribosomal RNA during vertebrate evolution. In cold blooded vertebrates the precursor contains two short spacer regions; in birds the precursor bears a long internal and a short external spacer region, and in mammals it has two long spacer regions. The molecular weights, as determined from the electron micrographs, are 2·6 to 2·8 × 10⁶ for the precursor ribosomal RNA of cold blooded vertebrates, 3·7 to 3·9 × 10⁶ for the precursor of birds, and 4·2 to 4·7 × 10⁶ for the mammalian precursor. Ribosomal RNA and precursor ribosomal RNA of mammals have a higher proportion of secondary structure loops when compared to lower vertebrates. This observation was confirmed by digesting ribosomal RNAs and precursor ribosomal RNAs with single-strandspecific S₁ nuclease in aqueous solution. Analysis of the double-stranded, S₁-resistant fragments indicates that there is a direct relationship between the hairpin loops seen in the electron microscope and secondary structure in aqueous solution.     

The Evolutionary History of the Structure of 5S Ribosomal RNA

5S rRNA is the smallest nucleic acid component of the large ribosomal subunit, contributing to ribosomal assembly, stability, and function. Despite being a model for the study of RNA structure and RNA–protein interactions, the evolution of this universally conserved molecule remains unclear. Here, we explore the history of the three-domain structure of 5S rRNA using phylogenetic trees that are reconstructed directly from molecular structure. A total of 46 structural characters describing the geometry of 666 5S rRNAs were used to derive intrinsically rooted trees of molecules and molecular substructures. Trees of molecules revealed the tripartite nature of life. In these trees, superkingdom Archaea formed a paraphyletic basal group, while Bacteria and Eukarya were monophyletic and derived. Trees of molecular substructures supported an origin of the molecule in a segment that is homologous to helix I (α domain), its initial enhancement with helix III (β domain), and the early formation of the three-domain structure typical of modern 5S rRNA in Archaea. The delayed formation of the branched structure in Bacteria and Eukarya lends further support to the archaeal rooting of the tree of life. Remarkably, the evolution of molecular interactions between 5S rRNA and associated ribosomal proteins inferred from a census of domain structure in hundreds of genomes established a tight relationship between the age of 5S rRNA helices and the age of ribosomal proteins. Results suggest 5S rRNA originated relatively quickly but quite late in evolution, at a time when primordial metabolic enzymes and translation machinery were already in place. The molecule therefore represents a late evolutionary addition to the ribosomal ensemble that occurred prior to the early diversification of Archaea.     

THE SYNTHESIS OF 5S RNA AND ITS REGULATION DURING EARLY SEA URCHIN DEVELOPMENT

De novo synthesis of 5S RNA and of transfer RNA (tRNA) has been demonstrated previously to occur by mid-cleavage (128-cell stage) in sea urchin embryos (24). The present study focused on determining more precisely the time of onset of activity of the genes for 5S RNA and for tRNA during sea urchin embryogenesis by preloading the GTP precursor pools of unfertilized eggs. The results showed that newly-made 5S RNA and tRNA could be detected as early as the 32-cell stage. In order to determine whether newly-synthesized 5S RNA accumulates coordinately during development with newly-made 26S (34) and 18S ribosomal RNAs (rRNAs), the relative rates of accumulation of these three RNA molecules were measured and compared at each of several stages of sea urchin embryogenesis. In contrast to the coordinated accumulation of newly-synthesized 26S and 18S rRNAs, newly-made 5S RNA accumulated in excess at the mesenchyme blastula (9-fold excess), midgastrula (5-fold excess) and prism (3-fold excess) stages. The 5S RNA/26S RNA molar ratios only approached unity in advanced (48 hr) plutei. The non-coordinated accumulation of newly-made 5S RNA with that of 26S and 18S rRNAs suggests that the accumulation of these newly-synthesized RNAs is differentially regulated during early sea urchin development.     

Time of action of 4.5 S RNA in Escherichia coli translation

A new class of suppressor mutants helps to define the role of 4.5 S RNA in translation. The suppressors reduce the requirement for 4.5 S RNA by increasing the intracellular concentration of uncharged tRNA. Suppression probably occurs by prolonging the period in which translating ribosomes have translocated but not yet released the uncharged tRNA, indicating that this is the point at which 4.5 S RNA enters translation. The release of 4.5 S RNA from polysomes is affected by antibiotics that inhibit protein synthesis. The antibiotic-sensitivity of this release indicates that 4.5 S RNA exits the ribosome following translocation and prior to release of protein synthesis elongation factor G. These results indicate that 4.5 S RNA acts immediately after ribosomal translocation. A model is proposed in which 4.5 S RNA stabilizes the post-translocation state by replacing 23 S ribosomal RNA as a binding site for elongation factor G. The 4.5 S RNA-requirement of mutants altered in 23 S ribosomal RNA support this model.     

Physical studies of the interaction of a calf thymus helix-destablizing protein with nucleic acids

UP1, a calf thymus protein that destabilizes both DNA and RNA helices, dramatically accelerates the conversion of the inactive conformers of several small RNA molecules to their biologically active forms [Karpel, R. L., Swistel, D. G., Miller, N. S., Geroch, M. E., Lu, C., & Fresco, J. R. (1974) Brookhaven Symp. Biol. 26, 165-174]. Using circular dichroic and spectrophotometric methods, we have studied the interaction of this protein with a variety of synthetic polynucleotides and yeast tRNA3Leu. As judged by perturbations in polynucleotide ellipticity or ultraviolet absorbance, the secondary structures of the single-stranded helices poly(A) and poly(C), as well as the double-stranded helices poly[d(A-T)] and poly(U.U), are largely destroyed upon interaction with UP1 at low ionic strength. This effect can be reversed by an increase in [Na+]: half the UP1-induced perturbation of the poly(A) CD spectrum is removed at 0.05 M Na+. The variation of poly(A) ellipticity and ultraviolet absorbance with [UP1]/[poly(A)]p is used to determine the length of single-stranded polynucleotide chain covered by the protein: 7 +/- 1 residues. A model is presented in which the specificity of UP1 for single strands and their concomitant distortion are a consequence of maximal binding of nucleic acid phosphates to a unique matrix of basic residues on the protein. Analogous to the effect on polynucleotides, UP1-facilitated renaturation of yeast tRNA3Leu follows the partial destruction of the inactive tRNA's secondary structure. At the tRNA absorbance maximum, UP1 effects a hyperchromic change of 10%, representing one-third of the secondary structure of the inactive conformer. This change is also clearly observable as a perturbation of the tRNA's circular dichroism spectrum.     

Small Stable RNAs from Escherichia coli: Evidence for the Existence of New Molecules and for a New Ribonucleoprotein Particle Containing 6S RNA

Small stable RNA molecules of Escherichia coli other than 5S (rRNA) and 4S (tRNA) were studied. Two of the molecules corresponded to 4.5S and 6S RNA, which have been reported previously. The third stable RNA molecule, 10S RNA, has not been described before. RNA labeled with (32)P(i) or [(14)C]uracil for a relatively long time, when separated in 5%/12% tandem polyacrylamide gels, displayed three bands corresponding to 10S, 6S, and 4.5S RNA in addition to rRNA and tRNA bands. These RNAs were stable in pulse-chase-labeling experiments. The amount of these RNAs was small, comprising only 0.2 to 0.5% of the total (32)P incorporation. However, this amount represented a large number of molecules; for 6S and 4.5S, it was about 1,000/DNA molecule. These three RNAs were found in the postribosomal supernatant fraction. None of them was found in purified nucleoid fractions in which the tightly coiled DNA molecules were contained. Of these three RNAs, 6S RNA was unique in that it seemed to exist in a ribonucleoprotein particle. All these RNAs, as well as tRNA, were very stable in the cell under various physiological conditions. 5S RNA was less stable. On the other hand, purified 6S RNA was more susceptible than tRNA to cell nucleases when incubated with cell extracts, suggesting that, being in a particle, it is protected from cell nucleases.     

Chemical reactivity of E. coli 5S RNA in situ in the 50S ribosomal subunit.

E. coli 50S ribosomal subunits were reacted with monoperphthalic acid under conditions in which non-base paired adenines are modified to their 1-N-oxides. 5S RNA was isolated from such chemically reacted subunits and the two modified adenines were identified as A73 and A99. The modified 5S RNA, when used in reconstitution of 50S subunits, yielded particles with reduced biological activity (50%). The results are discussed with respect to a recently proposed three-dimensional structure for 5S RNA, the interaction of the RNA with proteins E-L5, E-L18 and E-L25 and previously proposed interactions of 5S RNA with tRNA, 16S and 23S ribosomal RNAs.