A statistical thermodynamic model applied to experimental AFM population and location data is able to quantify DNA-histone binding strength and internucleosomal interaction differences between acetylated and unacetylated nucleosomal arrays

Imaging of nucleosomal arrays by atomic force microscopy allows a determination of the exact statistical distributions for the numbers of nucleosomes per array and the locations of nucleosomes on the arrays. This precision makes such data an excellent reference for testing models of nucleosome occupation on multisite DNA templates. The approach presented here uses a simple statistical thermodynamic model to calculate theoretical population and positional distributions and compares them to experimental distributions previously determined for 5S rDNA nucleosomal arrays (208-12,172-12). The model considers the possible locations of nucleosomes on the template, and takes as principal parameters an average free energy of interaction between histone octamers and DNA, and an average wrapping length of DNA around the octamers. Analysis of positional statistics shows that it is possible to consider interactions between nucleosomes and positioning effects as perturbations on a random positioning noninteracting model. Analysis of the population statistics is used to determine histone-DNA association constants and to test for differences in the free energies of nucleosome formation with different types of histone octamers, namely acetylated or unacetylated, and different DNA templates, namely 172-12 or 208-12 5S rDNA multisite templates. The results show that the two template DNAs bind histones with similar affinities but histone acetylation weakens the association of histones with both templates. Analysis of locational statistics is used to determine the strength of specific nucleosome positioning tendencies by the DNA templates, and the strength of the interactions between neighboring nucleosomes. The results show only weak positioning tendencies and that unacetylated nucleosomes interact much more strongly with one another than acetylated nucleosomes; in fact acetylation appears to induce a small anticooperative occupation effect between neighboring nucleosomes.     

Nucleosomal arrays can be salt-reconstituted on a single-copy MMTV promoter DNA template: their properties differ in several ways from those of comparable 5S concatameric arrays

Subsaturated nucleosomal arrays were reconstituted on a single-copy MMTV promoter DNA fragment by salt dialysis procedures and studied by atomic force microscopy. Up to an occupation level of approximately eight nucleosomes on this 1900 bp template, salt reconstitution produces nucleosomal arrays which look very similar to comparably loaded 5S rDNA nucleosomal arrays; i.e., nucleosomes are dispersed on the DNA template. Thus, at these occupation levels, the single-copy MMTV template forms arrays suitable for biophysical analyses. A quantitative comparison of the population features of subsaturated MMTV and 5S arrays detects differences between the two: a requirement for higher histone levels to achieve a given level of nucleosome occupation on MMTV templates, indicating that nucleosome loading is thermodynamically less favorable on this template; a preference for pairwise nucleosome occupation of the MMTV (but not the 5S) template at midrange occupation levels; and an enhanced salt stability for nucleosomes on MMTV versus 5S arrays, particularly in the midrange of array occupation. When average occupation levels exceed approximately eight nucleosomes per template, MMTV arrays show a significant level of mainly intramolecular compaction; 5S arrays do not. Taken together, these results show clearly that the nature of the underlying DNA template can affect the physical properties of nucleosomal arrays. DNA sequence-directed differences in the physical properties of chromatin may have important consequences for functional processes such as gene regulation.     

Mapping nucleosome locations on the 208-12 by AFM provides clear evidence for cooperativity in array occupation

Concatameric sea urchin 5S rDNA templates reconstituted with histones provide very popular chromatin models for many kinds of in vitro studies. We have used AFM to characterize the locational aspects of nucleosome occupation on one such array, the 208-12, by determining the internucleosomal- and end-distance distributions for arrays reconstituted to various subsaturating levels with nonacetylated or hyperacetylated HeLa histones. A simulation analysis of the experimental distributions confirms the qualitative conclusions and provides quantitative parameter values for the identified features. For nonacetylated arrays, the end-distance data demonstrate the nucleosome positioning ability of the 5S sequence and detect an enhanced preference for nucleosomes to bind at DNA termini. The internucleosomal-distance data provide clear evidence for cooperativity in nucleosome location on these templates, detectable even at subsaturated loading levels. Hyperacetylated arrays show no change in the preference of nucleosomes to bind at termini and a slight change in nucleosome positioning behavior but, most strikingly, little or no evidence for cooperativity in nucleosome location. Thus, acetylation of the N-terminal histone tails abolishes the cooperativity.     

Chemical acetylation, trypsinolysis and stability of nucleosomes

Gel electrophoretic analysis of the histone chemical acetylation in the nucleosome core particles with acetic andydride revealed availability of about 14 lysine residues of histone H2A, 15-21 of H2B, 8-11--H3 and 6-9--H4. Moderately lysine-rich histones H2A and H2B were found to be more susceptible to acetylation than arginine-rich H3 and H4. Chemical acetylation enhanced the rate of trypsin digestion in acetylated nucleosomes as evidenced by gel electrophoresis of histone fragments. A more pronounced trypsin digestion was evident at acetylation of only 3-5 histone amino groups per nucleosome. However, even heavily acetylated nucleosomes yielded in familiar trypsin limit digest pattern of histone fragments thus indicating persistence of histone octamer. Nucleosomes which were trace acetylated (up to 3-5 histone amino groups neutralized per nucleosome) and treated with trypsin to remove highly charged terminal histone regions revealed remarkable unfolding and partial dissociation when analyzed by gel electrophoresis. The same trace acetylated nucleosomes did not show such destabilization prior to trypsin digestion.     

Chromatin compaction at the mononucleosome level

Using a previously described FRET technique, we measured the distance between the ends of DNA fragments on which nucleosomes were reconstituted from recombinant and native histones. This distance was analyzed in its dependence on the DNA fragment length, concentration of mono- and divalent counterions, presence of linker histone H1, and histone modifications. We found that the linker DNA arms do not cross under all conditions studied but diverge slightly as they leave the histone core surface. Histone H1 leads to a global approach of the linker DNA arms, confirming the notion of a "stem structure". Increasing salt concentration also leads to an approach of the linker DNAs. To study the effect of acetylation, we compared chemically acetylated recombinant histones with histones prepared from HeLa cells, characterizing the sites of acetylation by mass spectroscopy. Nucleosomes from chemically acetylated histones have few modifications in the core domain and form nucleosomes normally. Acetylating all histones or selectively only H3 causes an opening of the nucleosome structure, indicated by the larger distances between the linker DNA ends. Selective acetylation of H4 distances the linker ends for short fragments but causes them to approach each other for fragments longer than 180 bp.     

Characterization of lysine 56 of histone H3 as an acetylation site in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Post-translational histone modifications abound and regulate multiple nuclear processes. Most modifications are targeted to the amino-terminal domains of histones. Here we report the identification and characterization of acetylation of lysine 56 within the core domain of histone H3. In the crystal structure of the nucleosome, lysine 56 contacts DNA. Phenotypic analysis suggests that lysine 56 is critical for histone function and that it modulates formamide resistance, ultraviolet radiation sensitivity, and sensitivity to hydroxyurea. We show that the acetylated form of histone H3 lysine 56 (H3-K56) is present during interphase, metaphase, and S phase. Finally, reverse genetic analysis indicates that none of the known histone acetyltransferases is solely responsible for H3-K56 acetylation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.     

Differential Histone Acetylation in Alfalfa (Medicago sativa) Due to Growth in NaCl : Responses in Salt Stressed and Salt Tolerant Callus Cultures

The steady state distribution of histone variant proteins and their modifications by acetylation were characterized in wild type and salinity stress adapted alfalfa (Medicago sativa). Isotopic labeling detected dynamic acetylation at four sites in the histone H3 variants and five sites in histones H4 and H2B. Histone variant H3.2 was the most highly acetylated histone with 25% higher steady state acetylation and a two- to threefold higher acetylation labeling than histone H3.1. Histone phosphorylation was limited to histone variants H1.A, H1.B, and H1.C and to histone H2A.3, which was also acetylated. Histone variant composition was unaffected by cellular exposure to NaCl. Histone acetylation was qualitatively similar in salt-tolerant and salt-sensitive cells under normal growth conditions. However, short term salt stress in salt sensitive cells or continued growth at 1% NaCl in salt tolerant cells led to major increases in the multiacetylated forms of histone H4 and the two variants of histone H3. These changes were more pronounced in the diploid than in the tetraploid alfalfa strains. The increase in multiacetylation of core histones serves as an in vivo reporter suggesting an altered intranuclear ionic environment in the presence of salt. It may also represent an adaptive response in chromatin structure to permit chromatin function in a more saline intranuclear environment.     

Isolation and characterization of acetylated histones H3 and H4 and their assembly into nucleosomes

Nucleosome and chromatin structure/function relationships of histone acetylations are not understood. To address these questions we have developed chromatographic procedures that separate subtypes of H3 and the acetylated states of histone H3 and H4 in exceptionally pure forms. The sites of acetylation of the intermediately acetylated states of H3 have been determined and show a specific pattern of acetylation. An unexpected finding was the identification of a fifth site of acetylation in H3 at lysine 27. Nucleosome particles with fully acetylated H3 and H4 have been assembled on the Lytechinus variegatus 5 S rRNA DNA phasing sequence and characterized. These defined acetylated H3 and H4 particles migrate more slowly in polyacrylamide nucleoprotein particle gels than the control particles indicating a subtle effect of acetylation in nucleosome structure. However, DNA footprinting of these particles using DNase I show only small changes when compared to control particles over the core particle DNA length. It is shown further that H3 cysteines in the particle containing fully acetylated H3 and H4 were not accessible to iodoacetamide indicating that protein factors additional to H3 and H4 acetylation are required to make H3 cysteines accessible to the label. These findings are consistent with the proposal that histones H3, H4 acetylations exert their major effects outside of the core particle 146-base pair DNA, either on the DNA segment entering and leaving the nucleosome or possibly on the internucleosome interactions that involve the amino-terminal domains of the core histones in organization and stability of higher order chromatin structures.     

Parent-of-origin specific histone acetylation and reactivation of a key imprinted gene locus in Prader-Willi syndrome

To examine the chromatin basis of imprinting in chromosome 15q11-q13, we have investigated the status of histone acetylation of the SNURF-SNRPN locus, which is a key imprinted gene locus in Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS). Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) studies revealed that the unmethylated CpG island of the active, paternally derived allele of SNURF-SNRPN was associated with acetylated histones, whereas the methylated maternally derived, inactive allele was specifically hypoacetylated. The body of the SNURF-SNRPN gene was associated with acetylated histones on both alleles. Furthermore, treatment of PWS cells with the DNA methyltransferase inhibitor 5-azadeoxycytidine (5-aza-dC) induced demethylation of the SNURF-SNRPN CpG island and restoration of gene expression on the maternal allele. The reactivation was associated with increased H4 acetylation but not with H3 acetylation at the SNURF-SNRPN CpG island. These findings indicate that (1) a significant role for histone deacetylation in gene silencing is associated with imprinting in 15q11-q13 and (2) silenced genes in PWS can be reactivated by drug treatment.     

Effects of histone acetylation on nucleosome properties as evaluated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and hydroxylapatite dissociation chromatography

The release of acetylated histones from chick oviduct chromatin was analyzed by hydroxylapatite column chromatography. By raising of the NaCl concentration, acetylated histones were eluted from hydroxylapatite-bound chromatin depending on their release from nucleosomal DNA. Electrophoresis on acid-urea gel showed that hyperacetylated forms of histone H4 were eluted at a lower NaCl concentration than non-acetylated or hypoacetylated H4, suggesting that hyperacetylated H4 has decreased stability in nucleosomes. However, under milder ionic conditions which do not induce dissociation between histones and DNA, polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of purified nucleosome cores showed no evidence for their unfolding or for increased accessibility by high mobility group protein-17.     

DNA instructed displacement of histones H2A and H2B at an inducible promoter

Regulation of gene expression requires dynamic changes in chromatin, but the nature of these changes is not well understood. Here, we show that progesterone treatment of cultured cells leads to recruitment of progesterone receptor (PR) and SWI/SNF-related complexes to Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus (MMTV) promoter, accompanied by displacement of histones H2A and H2B from the nucleosome containing the receptor binding sites, but not from adjacent nucleosomes. PR recruits SWI/SNF to MMTV nucleosomes in vitro and facilitates synergistic binding of receptors and nuclear factor 1 to the promoter. In nucleosomes assembled on MMTV or mouse rDNA promoter sequences, SWI/SNF catalyzes ATP-dependent sliding of the histone octamer followed only on the MMTV promoter by displacement of histones H2A and H2B. In MMTV nucleosome arrays, SWI/SNF displaces H2A and H2B from nucleosome B and not from the adjacent nucleosome. Thus, the outcome of nucleosome remodeling by SWI/SNF depends on DNA sequence.     

Effect of histone acetylation on structure and in vitro transcription of chromatin.

n-Butyrate treatment of growing Hela cells produces a dramatic increase in the levels of histone acetylation. We have exploited this system to study the effect of histone acetylation on chromatin structure. Chromatin containing highly acetylated histones is more rapidly digested to acid-soluble material by DNase I, but not by micrococcal nuclease. The same pattern of nuclease sensitivity was exhibited by in vitro-assembled chromatin consisting of SV40 DNA Form I and the 2 M salt-extracted core histones from butyrate-treated cells. Using this very defined system, it was possible to demonstrate that acetylated nucleosomes do not have a greatly diminished stability. Stability was measured in terms of exhange of histone cores onto competing naked DNA or sliding of histone cores along ligated naked DNA. Finally, it was shown that acetylated nucleosomes are efficient inhibitors of in vitro RNA synthesis by the E. coli holoenzyme as well as by the mammalian polymerases A and B.