Mesophyll conductance to CO2 in Arabidopsis thaliana

The close rosette growth form, short petioles and small leaves of Arabidopsis thaliana make measurements with commercial gas exchange cuvettes difficult. This difficulty can be overcome by growing A. thaliana plants in 'ice-cream cone-like' soil pots. This design permitted simultaneous gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence measurements from which the first estimates of mesophyll conductance to CO(2) (g(m)) in Arabidopsis were obtained and used to determine photosynthetic limitations during plant ageing from c. 30-45 d. Estimations of g(m) showed maximum values of 0.2 mol CO(2) m(-2) s(-1) bar(-1), lower than expected for a thin-leaved annual species. The parameterization of the response of net photosynthesis (A(N)) to chloroplast CO(2) concentrations (C(c)) yielded estimations of the maximum velocity of carboxylation (V(c,max_Cc)) which were also lower than those reported for other annual species. As A. thaliana plants aged from 30 to 45 d, there was a 40% decline of A(N) that was entirely the result of increased diffusional limitations to CO(2) transfer, with g(m) being the largest. The results suggest that in A. thaliana A(N) is limited by low g(m) and low capacity for carboxylation. Decreased g(m) is the main factor involved in early age-induced photosynthetic decline.     

Rapid variations of mesophyll conductance in response to changes in CO2 concentration around leaves

The effects of short-term (minutes) variations of CO2 concentration on mesophyll conductance to CO2 (gm) were evaluated in six different C3 species by simultaneous measurements of gas exchange, chlorophyll fluorescence, online carbon isotope discrimination and a novel curve-fitting method. Depending on the species, gm varied from five- to ninefold, along the range of sub-stomatal CO2 concentrations typically used in photosynthesis CO2-response curves (AN)-Ci curves; where AN is the net photosynthetic flux and Ci is the CO2 concentrations in the sub-stomatal cavity), that is, 50 to 1500 micromol CO2 mol(-1) air. Although the pattern was species-dependent, gm strongly declined at high Ci, where photosynthesis was not limited by CO2, but by regeneration of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate or triose phosphate utilization. Moreover, these changes on gm were found to be totally independent of the velocity and direction of the Ci changes. The response of gm to Ci resembled that of stomatal conductance (gs), but kinetic experiments suggested that the response of gm was actually faster than that of gs. Transgenic tobacco plants differing in the amounts of aquaporin NtAQP1 showed different slopes of the gm-Ci response, suggesting a possible role for aquaporins in mediating CO2 responsiveness of gm. The importance of these findings is discussed in terms of their effects on parameterization of AN-Ci curves.     

Soil water deficits decrease the internal conductance to CO2 transfer but atmospheric water deficits do not

The internal conductance to CO₂ supply from substomatal cavitiesto sites of carboxylation poses a large limitation to photosynthesis.It is known that internal conductance is decreased by soil waterdeficits, but it is not known if it is affected by atmosphericwater deficits (i.e. leaf to air vapour pressure deficit, VPD).The aim of this paper was to examine the responses of internalconductance to atmospheric and soil water deficits in seedlingsof the evergreen perennial Eucalyptus regnans F. Muell and theherbaceous plants Solanum lycopersicum (formerly Lycopersiconesculentum) Mill. and Phaseolus vulgaris L. Internal conductancewas estimated with the variable J method from concurrent measurementsof gas exchange and fluorescence. In all three species steady-statestomatal conductance decreased by 30% as VPD increased from1 kPa to 2 kPa. In no species was internal conductance affectedby VPD despite large effects on stomatal conductance. In contrast,soil water deficits decreased stomatal conductance and internalconductance of all three species. Decreases in stomatal andinternal conductance under water deficit were proportional,but this proportionality differed among species, and thus therelationship between stomatal and internal conductance differedamong species. These findings indicate that soil water deficitsaffect internal conductance while atmospheric water deficitsdo not. The reasons for this distinction are unknown but areconsistent with soil and atmospheric water deficits having differingeffects on leaf physiology and/or root–shoot communication. Key words: Carbon dioxide, drought, internal conductance, mesophyll conductance, photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, transfer conductance, vapour pressure deficit, water deficit Received 11 October 2007; Revised 9 November 2007 Accepted 15 November 2007     

Differential coordination of stomatal conductance,mesophyll conductance,and leaf hydraulic conductance in response to changing light across species

Stomatal conductance (g_s) and mesophyll conductance (g_m) represent major constraints to photosynthetic rate (A), and these traits are expected to coordinate with leaf hydraulic conductance (K_leaf) across species, under both steady‐state and dynamic conditions. However, empirical information about their coordination is scarce. In this study, K_leaf, gas exchange, stomatal kinetics, and leaf anatomy in 10 species including ferns, gymnosperms, and angiosperms were investigated to elucidate the correlation of H₂O and CO₂ diffusion inside leaves under varying light conditions. Gas exchange, K_leaf, and anatomical traits varied widely across species. Under light‐saturated conditions, the A, g_s, g_m, and K_leaf were strongly correlated across species. However, the response patterns of A, g_s, g_m, and K_leaf to varying light intensities were highly species dependent. Moreover, stomatal opening upon light exposure of dark‐adapted leaves in the studied ferns and gymnosperms was generally faster than in the angiosperms; however, stomatal closing in light‐adapted leaves after darkening was faster in angiosperms. The present results show that there is a large variability in the coordination of leaf hydraulic and gas exchange parameters across terrestrial plant species, as well as in their responses to changing light.     

Chloride as a macronutrient increases water‐use efficiency by anatomically driven reduced stomatal conductance and increased mesophyll diffusion to CO2

Chloride (Cl^?) has been recently described as a beneficial macronutrient, playing specific roles in promoting plant growth and water‐use efficiency (WUE). However, it is still unclear how Cl^? could be beneficial, especially in comparison with nitrate (NO₃^?), an essential source of nitrogen that shares with Cl^? similar physical and osmotic properties, as well as common transport mechanisms. In tobacco plants, macronutrient levels of Cl^? specifically reduce stomatal conductance (g_s) without a concomitant reduction in the net photosynthesis rate (A_N). As stomata‐mediated water loss through transpiration is inherent in the need of C₃ plants to capture CO₂, simultaneous increase in photosynthesis and WUE is of great relevance to achieve a sustainable increase in C₃ crop productivity. Our results showed that Cl^?‐mediated stimulation of larger leaf cells leads to a reduction in stomatal density, which in turn reduces g_s and water consumption. Conversely, Cl^? improves mesophyll diffusion conductance to CO₂ (g_m) and photosynthetic performance due to a higher surface area of chloroplasts exposed to the intercellular airspace of mesophyll cells, possibly as a consequence of the stimulation of chloroplast biogenesis. A key finding of this study is the simultaneous improvement of A_N and WUE due to macronutrient Cl^? nutrition. This work identifies relevant and specific functions in which Cl^? participates as a beneficial macronutrient for higher plants, uncovering a sustainable approach to improve crop yield.     

Mesophyll conductance to CO2: current knowledge and future prospects

During photosynthesis, CO2 moves from the atmosphere (C(a)) surrounding the leaf to the sub-stomatal internal cavities (C(i)) through stomata, and from there to the site of carboxylation inside the chloroplast stroma (C(c)) through the leaf mesophyll. The latter CO2 diffusion component is called mesophyll conductance (g(m)), and can be divided in at least three components, that is, conductance through intercellular air spaces (g(ias)), through cell wall (g(w)) and through the liquid phase inside cells (g(liq)). A large body of evidence has accumulated in the past two decades indicating that g(m) is sufficiently small as to significantly decrease C(c) relative to C(i), therefore limiting photosynthesis. Moreover, g(m) is not constant, and it changes among species and in response to environmental factors. In addition, there is now evidence that g(liq) and, in some cases, g(w), are the main determinants of g(m). Mesophyll conductance is very dynamic, changing in response to environmental variables as rapid or even faster than stomatal conductance (i.e. within seconds to minutes). A revision of current knowledge on g(m) is presented. Firstly, a historical perspective is given, highlighting the founding works and methods, followed by a re-examination of the range of variation of g(m) among plant species and functional groups, and a revision of the responses of g(m) to different external (biotic and abiotic) and internal (developmental, structural and metabolic) factors. The possible physiological bases for g(m), including aquaporins and carbonic anhydrases, are discussed. Possible ecological implications for variable g(m) are indicated, and the errors induced by neglecting g(m) when interpreting photosynthesis and carbon isotope discrimination models are highlighted. Finally, a series of research priorities for the near future are proposed.     

Coordination between leaf CO2 diffusion and Rubisco properties allows maximizing photosynthetic efficiency in Limonium species

High photosynthetic efficiency intrinsically demands tight coordination between traits related to CO₂ diffusion capacity and leaf biochemistry. Although this coordination constitutes the basis of existing mathematical models of leaf photosynthesis, it has been barely explored among closely related species, which could reveal rapid adaptation clues in the recent past. With this aim, we characterized the photosynthetic capacity of 12 species of Limonium, possessing contrasting Rubisco catalytic properties, grown under optimal (WW) and extreme drought conditions (WD). The availability of CO₂ at the site of carboxylation (C_c) determined the photosynthetic capacity of Limonium under WD, while both diffusional and biochemical components governed the photosynthetic performance under WW. The variation in the in vivo caboxylation efficiency correlated with both the concentration of active Rubisco sites and the in vitro‐based properties of Rubisco, such as the maximum carboxylase turnover rate (k_cat^c) and the Michaelis–Menten constant for CO₂ (K_c). Notably, the results confirmed the hypothesis of coordination between the CO₂ offer and demand functions of photosynthesis: those Limonium species with high total leaf conductance to CO₂ have evolved towards increased velocity (i.e. higher k_cat^c), at the penalty of lower affinity for CO₂ (i.e. lower specificity factor, S_c/o).     

On the relationship between leaf anatomy and CO2 diffusion through the mesophyll of hypostomatous leaves

Internal conductances to CO₂ transfer from the stomatal cavity to sites of carboxylation (g_i) in hypostomatous sun-and shade-grown leaves of citrus, peach and Macadamia trees (Lloyd et al. 1992) were related to anatomical characteristics of mesophyll tissues. There was a consistent relationship between absorptance of photosynthetically active radiation and chlorophyll concentration (mmol m^?2) for all leaves, including sclerophyllous Macadamia, whose transmittance was high despite its relatively thick leaves. In thin peach leaves, which had high g_i, the chloro-plast volume and mesophyll surface area exposed to intercellular air spaces (ias) per unit leaf area were similar to those in the thicker leaves of the evergreen species. Peach leaves, however, had the lowest leaf dry weight per area (D/a), the lowest tissue density (T_d) and the highest chloro-plast surface area (S_c) exposed to ias. There were negative correlations between g_i and leaf thickness or D/a, but positive correlations between g_i and S_c or S_c/T_d. We developed a one-dimensional diffusion model which partitioned g_i into a gaseous diffusion conductance through the ias (g_ias) plus a liquid-phase conductance through mesophyll cell walls (g_cw). The model accounted for a significant amount of variation (r₂=0.80) in measured g_i by incorporating both components. The g_ias component was related to the one-dimensional path-length for diffusion across the mesophyll and so was greater in thinner peach leaves than in leaves of evergreen species. The g_cw component was related to tissue density and to the degree of chloroplast exposure to the ias. Thus the negative correlations between g_i and leaf thickness or D/a related to g_ias whereas positive correlations between g_i and S_c or S_c/T_d, related to g_cw. The g_cw was consistently lower than g_ias, and thus represented a greater constraint on CO₂ diffusion in the mesophylls of these hypostomatous species.     

Low stomatal and internal conductance to CO2 versus Rubisco deactivation as determinants of the photosynthetic decline of ageing evergreen leaves

A novel A-Ci curve (net CO2 assimilation rate of a leaf -An- as a function of its intercellular CO2 concentration -Ci) analysis method (Plant, Cell & Environment 27, 137-153, 2004) was used to estimate the CO2 transfer conductance (gi) and the maximal carboxylation (Vcmax) and electron transport (Jmax) potentials of ageing, non-senescing Pseudotsuga menziesii leaves in relation to their nitrogen (N) content and protein and pigment composition. Both gi and the stomatal conductance (gsc) of leaves were closely coupled to Vcmax, Jmax and An with all variables decreasing with increasing leaf age. Consequently, both Ci and Cc (chloroplastic CO2 concentration) remained largely conserved through successive growing seasons. The N content of leaves, as well as the amount of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) and other sodium dodecyl sulfate-soluble proteins, increased during the first three growing seasons, then stabilized or decreased only slightly afterwards. Thus, the age-related photosynthetic nitrogen use efficiency (PNUE) decline of leaves was not a consequence of decreased allocation of N towards Rubisco and other proteins involved in bioenergetics and light harvesting. Rather, loss of photosynthetic capacity was the result of the decreased activation state of Rubisco and proportional down-regulation of electron transport towards the photosynthetic carbon reduction (PCR) and photorespiratory (PCO) cycles in response to a reduction of CO2 supply to the chloroplasts' stroma. This study emphasizes the regulatory potential and homeostaticity of Cc- rather than photosynthetic metabolites or Ci- in relation to the commonly observed correlation between photosynthesis and gsc.     

Construction of a chloroplast protein interaction network and functional mining of photosynthetic proteins in Arabidopsis thaliana

Chloroplast is a typical plant cell organelle where photosynthesis takes place. In this study, a total of 1 808 chloroplast core proteins in Arabidopsis thaliana were reliably identified by combining the results of previously published studies and our own predictions. We then constructed a chloroplast protein interaction network primarily based on these core protein interactions. The network had 22 925 protein interaction pairs which involved 2 214 proteins. A total of 160 previously uncharacterized proteins were annotated in this network. The subunits of the photosynthetic complexes were modularized, and the functional relationships among photosystem Ⅰ （PSI）, photosystem Ⅱ （PSII）, light harvesting complex of photosystem Ⅰ （LHC Ⅰ） and light harvesting complex of photosystem Ⅰ （LHC Ⅱ） could be deduced from the predicted protein interactions in this network. We further confirmed an interaction between an unknown protein AT1G52220 and a photosynthetic subunit PSI-D2 by yeast two-hybrid analysis. Our chloroplast protein interaction network should be useful for functional mining of photosynthetic proteins and investigation of chloroplast-related functions at the systems biology level in Arabidopsis.     

Theoretical reconsiderations when estimating the mesophyll conductance to CO2 diffusion in leaves of C3 plants by analysis of combined gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence measurements

Existing methods to estimate the mesophyll conductance to CO₂ diffusion ( g _m) are often based on combined gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence measurements. However, estimations of average g _m by these methods are often unreliable either because the range of usable data is too narrow or because the estimations are very sensitive to measurement errors. We describe three method variants to estimate g _m, for which a wider range of data are usable. They use curve-fitting techniques, which minimise the sum of squared model deviations from the data for A (CO₂ assimilation rate) or for J (linear electron transport rate). Like the existing approaches, they are all based on common physiological principles assuming that electron transport limits A . The proposed variants were far less sensitive than the existing approaches to 'measurement noise' either created randomly in the generated data set or inevitably existing in real data sets. Yet, the estimates of g _m from the three variants differed by approximately 15%. Moreover, for each variant, a stoichiometric uncertainty in linear electron transport-limited photosynthesis can cause another 15% difference. Any estimation of g _m using gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence measurements should be considered with caution, especially when g _m is high.     

Use of the response of photosynthesis to oxygen to estimate mesophyll conductance to carbon dioxide in water-stressed soybean leaves

Methods of estimating the mesophyll conductance (g_m) to the movement of CO₂ from the substomatal airspace to the site of fixation are expensive or rely upon numerous assumptions. It is proposed that, for C₃ species, measurement of the response of photosynthesis to [O₂] at limiting [CO₂], combined with a standard biochemical model of photosynthesis, can provide an estimate of g_m. This method was used to determine whether g_m changed with [CO₂] and with water stress in soybean leaves. The value of g_m estimated using the O₂ response method agreed with values obtained using other methods. The g_m was unchanged over the tested range of substomatal [CO₂]. Water stress, which decreased stomatal conductance (g_s) by about 80%, did not affect g_m, while the model parameter V_Cmax was reduced by about 25%. Leaves with g_s reduced by about 90% had g_m values reduced by about 50%, while V_Cmax was reduced by about 64%. It is concluded that g_m in C₃ species can be conveniently estimated using the response of photosynthesis to [O₂] at limiting [CO₂], and that g_m in soybean was much less sensitive to water stress than g_s, and was somewhat less sensitive to water stress than V_Cmax.     

Effects of mesophyll conductance on vegetation responses to elevated CO2 concentrations in a land surface model

Mesophyll conductance (g_m) is known to affect plant photosynthesis. However, g_m is rarely explicitly considered in land surface models (LSMs), with the consequence that its role in ecosystem and large‐scale carbon and water fluxes is poorly understood. In particular, the different magnitudes of g_m across plant functional types (PFTs) are expected to cause spatially divergent vegetation responses to elevated CO₂ concentrations. Here, an extensive literature compilation of g_m across major vegetation types is used to parameterize an empirical model of g_m in the LSM JSBACH and to adjust photosynthetic parameters based on simulated A_n ? C_i curves. We demonstrate that an explicit representation of g_m changes the response of photosynthesis to environmental factors, which cannot be entirely compensated by adjusting photosynthetic parameters. These altered responses lead to changes in the photosynthetic sensitivity to atmospheric CO₂ concentrations which depend both on the magnitude of g_m and the climatic conditions, particularly temperature. We then conducted simulations under ambient and elevated (ambient + 200 μmol/mol) CO₂ concentrations for contrasting ecosystems and for historical and anticipated future climate conditions (representative concentration pathways; RCPs) globally. The g_m‐explicit simulations using the RCP8.5 scenario resulted in significantly higher increases in gross primary productivity (GPP) in high latitudes (+10% to + 25%), intermediate increases in temperate regions (+5% to + 15%), and slightly lower to moderately higher responses in tropical regions (?2% to +5%), which summed up to moderate GPP increases globally. Similar patterns were found for transpiration, but with a lower magnitude. Our results suggest that the effect of an explicit representation of g_m is most important for simulated carbon and water fluxes in the boreal zone, where a cold climate coincides with evergreen vegetation.     

The light response of mesophyll conductance is controlled by structure across leaf profiles

Mesophyll conductance to CO₂ (g_m) may respond to light either through regulated dynamic mechanisms or due to anatomical and structural factors. At low light, some layers of cells in the leaf cross‐section approach photocompensation and contribute minimally to bulk leaf photosynthesis and little to whole leaf g_m (g_m,leaf). Thus, the bulk g_m,leaf will appear to respond to light despite being based upon cells having an anatomically fixed mesophyll conductance. Such behaviour was observed in species with contrasting leaf structure using the variable J or stable isotope method of measuring g_m,leaf. A species with bifacial structure, Arbutus × ‘Marina’, and an isobilateral species, Triticum durum L., had contrasting responses of g_m,leaf upon varying adaxial or abaxial illumination. Anatomical observations, when coupled with the proposed model of g_m,leaf to photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) response, successfully represented the observed gas exchange data. The theoretical and observed evidence that g_m,leaf apparently responds to light has large implications for how g_m,leaf values are interpreted, particularly limitation analyses, and indicates the importance of measuring g_m under full light saturation. Responses of g_m,leaf to the environment should be treated as an emergent property of a distributed 3D structure, and not solely a leaf area‐based phenomenon.     

The importance of mesophyll conductance in regulating forest ecosystem productivity during drought periods

Water availability is the most limiting factor to global plant productivity, yet photosynthetic responses to seasonal drought cycles are poorly understood, with conflicting reports on which limiting process is the most important during drought. We address the problem using a model‐data synthesis approach to look at canopy level fluxes, integrating twenty years of half hour data gathered by the FLUXNET network across six Mediterranean sites. The measured canopy level, water and carbon fluxes were used, together with an inverse canopy ecophysiological model, to estimate the bulk canopy conductance, bulk mesophyll conductance, and the canopy scale carbon pools in both the intercellular spaces and at the site of carboxylation in the chloroplasts. Thus the roles of stomatal and mesophyll conductance in the regulation of internal carbon pools and photosynthesis could be separated. A quantitative limitation analysis allowed for the relative seasonal responses of stomatal, mesophyll, and biochemical limitations to be gauged. The concentration of carbon in the chloroplast was shown to be a potentially more reliable estimator of assimilation rates than the intercellular carbon concentration. Both stomatal conductance limitations and mesophyll conductance limitations were observed to regulate the response of photosynthesis to water stress in each of the six species studied. The results suggest that mesophyll conductance could bridge the gap between conflicting reports on plant responses to soil water stress, and that the inclusion of mesophyll conductance in biosphere–atmosphere transfer models may improve their performance, in particular their ability to accurately capture the response of terrestrial vegetation productivity to drought.     

Tobacco aquaporin NtAQP1 is involved in mesophyll conductance to CO2 in vivo

Leaf mesophyll conductance to CO(2) (g(m)) has been recognized to be finite and variable, rapidly adapting to environmental conditions. The physiological basis for fast changes in g(m) is poorly understood, but current reports suggest the involvement of protein-facilitated CO(2) diffusion across cell membranes. A good candidate for this could be the Nicotiana tabacum L. aquaporin NtAQP1, which was shown to increase membrane permeability to CO(2) in Xenopus oocytes. The objective of the present work was to evaluate its effect on the in vivo mesophyll conductance to CO(2), using plants either deficient in or overexpressing NtAQP1. Antisense plants deficient in NtAQP1 (AS) and NtAQP1 overexpressing tobacco plants (O) were compared with their respective wild-type (WT) genotypes (CAS and CO). Plants grown under optimum conditions showed different photosynthetic rates at saturating light, with a decrease of 13% in AS and an increase of 20% in O, compared with their respective controls. CO(2) response curves of photosynthesis also showed significant differences among genotypes. However, in vitro analysis demonstrated that these differences could not be attributed to alterations in Rubisco activity or ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate content. Analyses of chlorophyll fluorescence and on-line (13)C discrimination indicated that the observed differences in net photosynthesis (A(N)) among genotypes were due to different leaf mesophyll conductances to CO(2), which was estimated to be 30% lower in AS and 20% higher in O compared with their respective WT. These results provide evidence for the in vivo involvement of aquaporin NtAQP1 in mesophyll conductance to CO(2).     

Photorespiration in the context of Rubisco biochemistry,CO2 diffusion and metabolism

Photorespiratory metabolism is essential for plants to maintain functional photosynthesis in an oxygen‐containing environment. Because the oxygenation reaction of Rubisco is followed by the loss of previously fixed carbon, photorespiration is often considered a wasteful process and considerable efforts are aimed at minimizing the negative impact of photorespiration on the plant’s carbon uptake. However, the photorespiratory pathway has also many positive aspects, as it is well integrated within other metabolic processes, such as nitrogen assimilation and C₁ metabolism, and it is important for maintaining the redox balance of the plant. The overall effect of photorespiratory carbon loss on the net CO₂ fixation of the plant is also strongly influenced by the physiology of the leaf related to CO₂ diffusion. This review outlines the distinction between Rubisco oxygenation and photorespiratory CO₂ release as a basis to evaluate the costs and benefits of photorespiration.     

Temperature response of in vivo Rubisco kinetics and mesophyll conductance in Arabidopsis thaliana: comparisons to Nicotiana tabacum

Biochemical models are used to predict and understand the response of photosynthesis to rising temperatures and CO₂ partial pressures. These models require the temperature dependency of ribulose‐1,5‐bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) kinetics and mesophyll conductance to CO₂ (g_m). However, it is not known how the temperature response of Rubisco kinetics differs between species, and comprehensive in vivo Rubisco kinetics that include g_m have only been determined in the warm‐adapted Nicotiana tabacum. Here, we measured the temperature response of Rubisco kinetics and g_m in N. tabacum and the cold‐adapted Arabidopsis thaliana using gas exchange and ¹³CO₂ isotopic discrimination on plants with genetically reduced levels of Rubisco. While the individual Rubisco kinetic parameters in N. tabacum and A. thaliana were similar across temperatures, they collectively resulted in significantly different modelled rates of photosynthesis. Additionally, g_m increased with temperature in N. tabacum but not in A. thaliana. These findings highlight the importance of considering species‐dependent differences in Rubisco kinetics and g_m when modelling the temperature response of photosynthesis.