Methylation of neutral pseudotetrahedral zinc thiolate complexes: model reactions for alkyl group transfer to sulfur by zinc-containing enzymes

Eight scorpionate-zinc thiolate complexes, [(L1O)ZnSPh], [(L1O)ZnSPhF5], [(L1O)ZnSBz], [(L1O)ZnSPh2,6-Me], [(L1O)ZnSPh2,4-Me], [(L1O)ZnSPh4-NO2], [(TpPh,Ph)ZnSPh], and [(L2S)ZnSPh], were reacted with methyl iodide in chloroform, liberating the corresponding methyl thioethers as determined by 1H NMR. Three of these complexes are new and their synthesis and structural characterization are reported here. Weak alkylating agents such as trimethyl phosphate failed to undergo methyl transfer to the zinc thiolates under these conditions. Analysis of kinetic data as a function of concentration, temperature, pKa of the exogenous thiolate, and donor atom of the tripodal ligand are consistent with a mechanism where the zinc-bound thiolate is the active nucleophile in an associative-type methyl transfer reaction. Our model studies also provide experimental evidence to support the hypothesis that some enzymes can use the charge of the metal coordination site to modulate catalytic activity.     

The mechanism of action of the nitrosourea anti-tumor drugs on thioredoxin reductase, glutathione reductase and ribonucleotide reductase

The nitrosoureas BCNU, CCNU, ACNU, and Fotemustine covalently deactivate thioredoxin reductase, glutathione reductase and ribonucleotide reductase by alkylating their thiolate active sites. Since thioredoxin reductase and glutathione reductase function as alternative electron donors in the biosynthesis of deoxyribonucleotides, catalyzed by ribonucleotide reductase, the inhibition of these electron transfer systems by the nitrosoureas could determine the cytostatic property of this homologous series of drugs. A detailed study of the kinetics and mechanism for the inhibition of purified thioredoxin reductases from human metastatic melanotic and amelanotic melanomas by the nitrosoureas showed significantly different inhibitor constants. This difference is due to the regulation of these proteins by calcium. Calcium protects thioredoxin reductase from deactivation by the nitrosoureas. In addition, it has been shown that reduced thioredoxin displaces the nitrosourea-inhibitor complex from the active site of thioredoxin reductase to fully reactivate enzyme purified from human metastatic amelanotic melanoma. It has been possible to label the active sites of thioredoxin reductase and glutathione reductase by using chloro[14C]ethyl Fotemustine, resulting in the alkylation of the thiolate active sites to produce chloro[14C]ethyl ether-enzyme inhibitor complexes. These complexes can be reactivated via reduced thioredoxin and reduced glutathione, respectively, by a beta-elimination reaction yielding [14C]ethylene and chloride ions as reaction products.     

Circular dichroism and magnetic circular dichroism of bismuth-induced,metallothionein-like proteins

Optical studies have been carried out on bismuth-containing proteins which were isolated from the livers and kidneys of rats following injections of BiCl₃. Absorption, circular dichroism and magnetic circular dichroism spectra of hepatic Bi,Zn-metallothionein 1 and 2 indicate that the spectra are dominated by transitions from the zinc thiolate chromophore. The data from the renal Bi,Cu-metallothionein 2 are quite different and it is suggested that these spectra involve a mixture of transitions from the bismuth and copper thiolate binding sites.     

Farnesyltransferase--new insights into the zinc-coordination sphere paradigm: evidence for a carboxylate-shift mechanism

Despite the enormous interest that has been devoted to the study of farnesyltransferase, many questions concerning its catalytic mechanism remain unanswered. In particular, several doubts exist on the structure of the active-site zinc coordination sphere, more precisely on the nature of the fourth ligand, which is displaced during the catalytic reaction by a peptide thiolate. From available crystallographic structures, and mainly from x-ray absorption fine structure data, two possible alternatives emerge: a tightly zinc-bound water molecule or an almost symmetrical bidentate aspartate residue (Asp-297beta). In this study, high-level theoretical calculations, with different-sized active site models, were used to elucidate this aspect. Our results demonstrate that both coordination alternatives lie in a notably close energetic proximity, even though the bidentate hypothesis has a somewhat lower energy. The Gibbs reaction and activation energies for the mono-bidentate conversion, as well as the structure for the corresponding transition state, were also determined. Globally, these results indicate that at room temperature the mono-bidentate conversion is reversible and very fast, and that probably both states exist in equilibrium, which suggests that a carboxylate-shift mechanism may have a key role in the farnesylation process by assisting the coordination/displacement of ligands to the zinc ion, thereby controlling the enzyme activity. Based on this equilibrium hypothesis, an explanation for the existing contradictions between the crystallographic and x-ray absorption fine structure results is proposed.     

On the molecular mechanism of liver alcohol dehydrogenase: Monte Carlo simulations and X-ray studies of water in the substrate channel

Water structure in the substrate channel of liver alcohol dehydrogenase as a function of the oxidation state of the coenzyme nicotinamide ring has been studied with Monte Carlo simulations. X-ray data on water structure has been analyzed. The simulations show an order-disorder effect in the water distribution produced by the charge state of the ring; also, solvation-desolvation effects are detected. For positively charged ring, the water molecules form a fluctuated H-bonded network that connects the deeply buried active site zinc to the bulk solvent. This network together with the side chain of Ser-48 most likely is the support for a proton relay system thereby providing a mechanism responsible of the pKa shift of the zinc-bound water as it is produced by the oxidized coenzyme binding.     

Zinc coordination sphere in biochemical zinc sites

Zinc is known to be indispensable to growth and development and transmission of the genetic message. It does this through a remarkable mosaic of zinc binding motifs that orchestrate all aspects of metabolism. There are now nearly 200 three dimensional structures for zinc proteins, representing all six classes of enzymes and covering a wide range of phyla and species. These structures provide standards of reference for the identity and nature of zinc ligands in other proteins for which only the primary structure is known. Three primary types of zinc sites are apparent from examination of these structures: structural, catalytic and cocatalytic. The most common amino acids that supply ligands to these sites are His, Glu, Asp and Cys. In catalytic sites zinc generally forms complexes with water and any three nitrogen, oxygen and sulfur donors with His being the predominant amino acid chosen. Water is always a ligand to such sites. Structural zinc sites have four protein ligands and no bound water molecule. Cys is the preferred ligand in such sites. Cocatalytic sites contain two or three metals in close proximity with two of the metals bridged by a side chain moiety of a single amino acid residue, such as Asp, Glu or His and sometimes a water molecule. Asp and His are the preferred amino acids for these sites. No Cys ligands are found in such sites. The scaffolding of the zinc sites is also important to the function and reactivity of the bound metal. The influence of zinc on quaternary protein structure has led to the identification of a fourth type of zinc binding site, protein inteface. In this case zinc sites are formed from ligands supplied from amino acid residues residing in the binding surface of two proteins. The resulting zinc site usually has the coordination properties of a catalytic or structural zinc binding site.     

Crystallographic studies of inhibitor binding sites in human carbonic anhydrase II: a pentacoordinated binding of the SCN- ion to the zinc at high pH

The binding of four inhibitors--mercuric ion, 3-acetoxymercuri-4-aminobenzenesulfonamide (AMS), acetazolamide (Diamox), and thiocyanate ion--to human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) has been studied with X-ray crystallography. The binding of mercury to HCA II at pH 7.0 has been investigated at 3.1 A resolution. Mercuric ions are observed at both nitrogens in the His-64 ring. One of these sites is pointing toward the zinc ion. The only other binding site for mercury is at Cys-206. The binding of the two sulfonamide inhibitors AMS and Diamox, has been reinvestigated at 2.0 and 3.0 A, respectively. Only the nitrogen of the sulfonamide group binds to the zinc ion replacing the hydroxyl ion. The sulfonamide oxygen closest to the zinc ion is 3.1 A away. Thus the tetrahedral geometry of the zinc is retained, refuting earlier models of a pentacoordinated zinc. The structure of the thiocyanate complex has been investigated at pH 8.5 and the structure has been refined at 1.9 A resolution using the least-squares refinement program PROLSQ. The crystallographic R factor is 17.6%. The zinc ion is pentacoordinated with the anion as well as a water molecule bound in addition to the three histidine residues. The nitrogen atom of the SCN- ion is 1.9 A from the zinc ion but shifted 1.3 A with respect to the hydroxyl ion in the native structure and at van der Waals' distance from the O gamma l atom of Thr-199. This is due to the inability of the O gamma l atom of Thr-199 to serve as a hydrogen bond donor, thus repelling the nonprotonated nitrogen. The SCN- molecule reaches into the deep end of the active site cavity where the sulfur atom has displaced the so-called "deep" water molecule of the native enzyme. The zinc-bound water molecule is 2.2 A from the zinc ion and 2.4 A from the SCN- nitrogen. In addition, this water is hydrogen bonded to the O gamma l atom of Thr-199 and to another water molecule. We have observed that solvent and inhibitor molecules have three possible binding sites on the zinc ion and their significance for the catalysis and inhibition of HCA II will be discussed. All available crystallographic data are consistent with a proposed catalytic mechanism in which both the OH moiety and one oxygen of the substrate HCO3- ion are ligated to the zinc ion.     

Hydration of CO2 by carbonic anhydrase: intramolecular proton transfer between Zn2+-bound H2O and histidine 64 in human carbonic anhydrase II

The energy barrier for the intramolecular proton transfer between zinc-bound water and His 64 in the active site of human carbonic anhydrase II (HCA II) has been studied at the partial retention of diatomic differential overlap (PRDDO) level. The most important stabilizing factor for the intramolecular proton transfer is the zinc ion, which lowers the pKa of zinc-bound water and electrostatically repels the proton. The energy barrier of 127.5 kcal/mol for proton transfer between a water dimer is completely removed in the presence of the zinc ion. The zinc ligands, which donate electrons to the zinc ion, raise the barrier slightly to 34 kcal/mol for a 4-coordinated zinc complex including three imidazole ligands from His 94, His 96, and His 119 and to 54 kcal/mol for the 5-coordinated zinc complex including the fifth water ligand. A few model calculations indicate that these energy barriers are expected to be reduced to within experimental range (approximately 10 kcal/mol) when large basis set, correlation energies, and molecular dynamics are considered. The proton-transfer group, which functions as proton receiver in the intramolecular proton transfer, helps to attract the proton; and the partially ordered active site water molecules are important for proton relay function.     

Metals on the move: zinc ions in cellular regulation and in the coordination dynamics of zinc proteins

Homeostatic control maintains essential transition metal ions at characteristic cellular concentrations to support their physiological functions and to avoid adverse effects. Zinc is especially widely used as a catalytic or structural cofactor in about 3000 human zinc proteins. In addition, the homeostatic control of zinc in eukaryotic cells permits functions of zinc(II) ions in regulation and in paracrine and intracrine signaling. Zinc ions are released from proteins through ligand-centered reactions in zinc/thiolate coordination environments, and from stores in cellular organelles, where zinc transporters participate in zinc loading and release. Muffling reactions allow zinc ions to serve as signaling ions (second messengers) in the cytosol that is buffered to picomolar zinc ion concentrations at steady-state. Muffling includes zinc ion binding to metallothioneins, cellular translocations of metallothioneins, delivery of zinc ions to transporter proteins, and zinc ion fluxes through cellular membranes with the result of removing the additional zinc ions from the cytosol and restoring the steady-state. Targets of regulatory zinc ions are proteins with sites for transient zinc binding, such as membrane receptors, enzymes, protein–protein interactions, and sensor proteins that control gene expression. The generation, transmission, targets, and termination of zinc ion signals involve proteins that use coordination dynamics in the inner and outer ligand spheres to control metal ion association and dissociation. These new findings establish critically important functions of zinc ions and zinc metalloproteins in cellular control.     

Synergism between coenzyme and alcohol binding to liver alcohol dehydrogenase

Heterotropic cooperativity effects in the binding of alcohols and NAD+ or NADH to liver alcohol dehydrogenase have been examined by equilibrium measurements and stopped-flow kinetic studies. Equilibrium data are reported for benzyl alcohol, 2-chloroethanol, 2,2-dichloroethanol, and trifluoroethanol binding to free enzyme over the pH range 6-10. Binary-complex formation between enzyme and alcohols leads to inner-sphere coordination of the alcohol to catalytic zinc and shows a pH dependence reflecting the ionization states of zinc-bound water and the zinc-bound alcohol. The affinity of the binding protonation state of the enzyme for unionized alcohols increases approximately by a factor of 10 on complex formation between enzyme and NAD+ or NADH. The rate and kinetic cooperativity with coenzyme binding of the alcohol association step indicates that enzyme-bound alcohols participate in hydrogen bonding interactions which affect the rates of alcohol and coenzyme equilibration with the enzyme without providing any pronounced contribution to the net energetics of alcohol binding. The pKa values determined for alcohol deprotonation at the binary-complex level are linearly dependent on those of the free alcohols, and can be readily reconciled with the pKa values attributed to ionization of zinc-bound water. Alcohol coordination to catalytic zinc provides a major contribution to the pKa shift which ensures that the substrate is bound predominantly as an alcoholate ion in the catalytically productive ternary complex at physiological pH. The additional pKa shift contributed by NAD+ binding is less pronounced, but may be of particular mechanistic interest since it increases the acidity of zinc-bound alcohols relatively to that of zinc-bound water.     

Exploring the role and the binding affinity of a second zinc equivalent in B. cereus metallo-beta-lactamase

Metallo-beta-lactamases are a newly characterized family of zinc enzymes present in several pathogenic strains that represent an emerging clinical threat. Enzymes from different organisms exhibit an outstanding functional diversity, particularly in the metal ion requirements for activity. We have investigated the effect of the second zinc(II) equivalent in the enzyme betaLII from Bacillus cereus, naturally active in the mono-zinc(II) form. The enzyme is reversibly inactivated at low pH, due to dissociation of the two zinc(II) equivalents. The pH profile indicates that zinc-bound water in the mono-zinc(II) enzyme possesses a pK(a) below 4.9, indicating that a second zinc(II) equivalent is not needed for nucleophile activation. Instead, the second zinc(II) may contribute to properly anchor Asp120, that ultimately orients the attacking nucleophile in binuclear enzymes. This role may be fulfilled by Arg121 in mono-zinc enzymes, as suggested by the kinetic study of the R121C mutant in betaLII. In addition, it is demonstrated that Arg121 is not responsible for the low binding affinity of betaLII toward a second zinc(II) equivalent.     

Electrostatic field effects of coenzymes on ligand binding to catalytic zinc in liver alcohol dehydrogenase

The synergism between coenzyme and anion binding to liver alcohol dehydrogenase has been examined by equilibrium measurements and transient-state kinetic methods to characterize electrostatic interactions of coenzymes with ligands which are bound to the catalytic zinc ion of the enzyme subunit. Inorganic anions typically exhibit an at least 200-fold higher affinity for the general anion-binding site than for catalytic zinc on complex formation with free enzyme. Acetate and SCN- interact more strongly with catalytic zinc in the enzyme X NAD+ complex than with the general anion-binding site in free enzyme. CN- shows no significant affinity for the general anion-binding site, but combines to catalytic zinc in the absence as well as the presence of coenzymes. Coordination of CN- to catalytic zinc weakens the binding of NADH by a factor of 50, and tightens the binding of NAD+ to approximately the same extent through interactions which do not include any contributions from covalent adduct formation between CN- and NAD+. These observations provide unambiguous information about the magnitude of electrostatic field effects of coenzymes on anion (e.g. hydroxyl ion) binding to catalytic zinc. They lead to the important inference that coenzyme binding must be strongly affected by ionization of zinc-bound water irrespective of the actual acidity of the latter group. It is concluded on such grounds that the much debated pH dependence of coenzyme binding to liver alcohol dehydrogenase must derive from ionization of zinc-bound water. The assumption that such is not the case leads to the inference that there is no detectable effect of ionization of zinc-bound water on coenzyme binding over the pH range 6-12, a possibility which is definitely excluded by the present results.     

A differential assay for the reduced and oxidized states of metallothionein and thionein

In the cellular environment, the sulfur ligands in zinc/thiolate coordination sites of proteins can be oxidized with concomitant mobilization of zinc. The characterization of such "redox zinc switches" requires the determination of three species, i.e., the zinc-containing complex and the zinc-free complex with the thiolate ligands either reduced or oxidized. Differential chemical modification of thiol groups in the presence and absence of either reducing or chelating agents allows the analytical speciation of such systems as demonstrated here for the characterization of the redox and metal-binding states of mammalian metallothionein. Thiol derivatization with 6-iodoacetamidofluorescein in the presence and absence of the reducing agent tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine, high-performance liquid chromatographic separation, and photometric detection are employed to determine the reduced and oxidized protein. Because the holoprotein reacts only in the presence of a chelating agent such as ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) its amount can be determined as the difference between measurements in the presence and the absence of EDTA. This method is applied to the study of the chemical and enzymatic oxidation of metallothionein/thionein. It should also greatly facilitate the characterization of the redox and metal-binding properties of zinc/thiolate coordination environments of other proteins such as zinc finger proteins.     

S versus O alkylation and coordination in zinc complexes containing the bulky heteroscorpionate alkoxy ligand bis(3,5-dimethylpyrazol-2-yl) diphenylmethanol

A series of zinc complexes containing the tripodal heteroscorpionate ligand bis(3,5-dimethylpyrazol-2-yl)diphenylmethanol (L2H) have been synthesized and characterized by X-ray crystallography. The L2H/Zn complexes were designed to model the N₂OX coordination (with the zinc-bound O being a reactive nucleophile) that is characteristic of many protease and amidase zinc enzymes. The pseudotetrahedral mononuclear complexes characterized include [(L2)ZnI] (1), [(L2)Zn(CH₃)] (2), and [(L2)Zn(SPh)] (3). Alkylation of (1) with methyl iodide has revealed a modest nucleophilicity of the chelated zinc-bound alkoxide, and produces the penta-coordinate [(L2OCH₃)ZnI₂] (4) which contains a weakly bound ether in the fifth coordination site. However, when the coordination sphere also includes a thiolate sulfur as in (3), reaction with methyl iodide produces exclusive alkylation at the sulfur to produce thioanisole and (1). The coordination of the ether in the neutral (4) can be strengthened by reaction with various silver salts, Ag⁺X⁻, to produce other penta-coordinate complexes [(L2OCH₃)ZnI(Tf)] (5) and [(L2OCH₃)ZnI(H₂O)]BF₄ (6) which show enhanced coordination of the ether.     

Changes in zinc ligation promote remodeling of the active site in the zinc hydrolase superfamily.

The zinc hydrolase superfamily is a group of divergently related proteins that are predominantly enzymes with a zinc-based catalytic mechanism. The common structural scaffold of the superfamily consists of an eight-stranded beta-sheet flanked by six alpha-helices. Previous analyses, while acknowledging the likely divergent origins of leucine aminopeptidase, carboxypeptidase A and the co-catalytic enzymes of the metallopeptidase H clan based on their structural scaffolds, have failed to find any homology between the active sites in leucine aminopeptidase and the metallopeptidase H clan enzymes. Here we show that these two groups of co-catalytic enzymes have overlapping dizinc centers where one of the two zinc atoms is conserved in each group. Carboxypeptidase A and leucine aminopeptidase, on the other hand, no longer share any homologous zinc-binding sites. At least three catalytic zinc-binding sites have existed in the structural scaffold over the period of history defined by available structures. Comparison of enzyme-inhibitor complexes show that major remodeling of the substrate-binding site has occurred in association with each change in zinc ligation in the binding site. These changes involve re-registration and re-orientation of the substrate. Some residues important to the catalytic mechanism are not conserved amongst members. We discuss how molecules acting in trans may have facilitated the mutation of catalytically important residues in the active site in this group.     

Combined Density Functional Theory (DFT) and Continuum Calculations of pK(a) in Carbonic Anhydrase

Deprotonation of zinc-bound water in carbonic anhydrase II is the rate-limiting step in the catalysis of carbon dioxide between gas- and water-soluble forms. To understand the factors determining the extent of dissociation, or pK(a), of the zinc-bound water, we apply quantum chemistry calculations to the active site coupled with a continuum model of the surrounding environment. Experimentally determined changes in pK(a) associated with mutations of the active site are well reproduced by this approach. Analysis of the active site structure and charge/dipole values provides evidence that mutations cause changes in both conformation of the active site structure and local polarization, which accounts for the shifts in pK(a). More specifically, the shifts in pK(a) correlate with the dipole moments of the zinc-bound water upon deprotonation. The data further support the conclusion that the distinct pK(a) values found in mutations of the same type, but applied to different sites, result from asymmetric ligation and different electronic environments around the zinc ion.     

Ions binding to S100 proteins. I. Calcium- and zinc-binding properties of bovine brain S100 alpha alpha, S100a (alpha beta), and S100b (beta beta) protein: Zn2+ regulates Ca2+ binding on S100b protein

Flow dialysis measurements of calcium binding to bovine brain S100 alpha alpha, S100a (alpha beta), and S100b (beta beta) proteins in 20 mM Tris-HCl buffer at pH 7.5 and 8.3 revealed that S100 proteins bind specifically 4 Ca2+ eq/mol of protein dimer. The specific calcium-binding sites had, therefore, been assigned to typical amino acid sequences on the alpha and beta subunit. The protein affinity for calcium is much lower in the presence of magnesium and potassium. Potassium strongly antagonizes calcium binding on two calcium-binding sites responsible for most of the Ca2+-induced conformational changes on S100 proteins (probably site II alpha and site II beta). Zinc-binding studies in the absence of divalent cations revealed eight zinc-binding sites/mol of S100b protein dimer that we assumed to correspond to 4 zinc-binding sites/beta subunit. Zinc binding to S100b studied with UV spectroscopy methods showed that the occupation of the four higher affinity sites and the four lower affinity sites on the protein dimer were responsible for different conformational changes in S100b structure. Zinc binding on the higher affinity sites regulates calcium binding to S100b by increasing the protein affinity for calcium and decreasing the antagonistic effect of potassium on calcium binding. Zinc-binding studies on S100a and S100 alpha alpha protein showed that the Trp-containing S100 proteins bind zinc more weakly than S100b protein. Calcium-binding studies on zinc-bound S100a proved that calcium- and zinc-binding sites were distinct although there was no increase in zinc-bound S100a affinity for calcium, as in S100b protein. Finally we provide evidence that discrepancies between previously published results on the optical properties of S100b protein probably result from oxidation of the sulfhydryl groups in the protein.     

Fluorescent probes for the structure and function of metallothionein

Fluorescence methods have been instrumental in demonstrating that the structure of human metallothionein in vivo depends on the availability of metal ions and the redox environment. Differential chemical modifications of its cysteine thiols with fluorescent probes allowed determination of three states: metallothionein (zinc-bound thiolate), thionein (free thiols), and thionin (disulfides). Interrogation of its zinc-binding properties with fluorescent chelating agents revealed that the affinities for the seven zinc ions vary over four orders of magnitude. Attachment of fluorescent labels generated metallothionein FRET (fluorescence resonance energy transfer) sensors for investigating its structure and function in living cells.     

The zinc/thiolate redox biochemistry of metallothionein and the control of zinc ion fluctuations in cell signaling

Free zinc ions are potent effectors of proteins. Their tightly controlled fluctuations ("zinc signals") in the picomolar range of concentrations modulate cellular signaling pathways. Sulfur (cysteine) donors generate redox-active coordination environments in proteins for the redox-inert zinc ion and make it possible for redox signals to induce zinc signals. Amplitudes of zinc signals are determined by the cellular zinc buffering capacity, which itself is redox-sensitive. In part by interfering with zinc and redox buffering, reactive species, drugs, toxins, and metal ions can elicit zinc signals that initiate physiological and pathobiochemical changes or lead to cellular injury when free zinc ions are sustained at higher concentrations. These interactions establish redox-inert zinc as an important factor in redox signaling. At the center of zinc/redox signaling are the zinc/thiolate clusters of metallothionein. They can transduce zinc and redox signals and thereby attenuate or amplify these signals.