Structural and thermodynamic principles of viral packaging

Packaging of genetic material inside a capsid is one of the major processes in the lifecycle of bacteriophages. To establish the basic principles of packing double-stranded DNA into a phage, we present a low-resolution model of bacteriophage varphi29 and report simulations of DNA packaging. The simulations show excellent agreement with available experimental data, including the forces of packaging and the average structures seen in cryo-electron microscopy. The conformation of DNA inside the bacteriophage is primarily determined by the shape of the capsid and the elastic properties of DNA, but the energetics of packaging are dominated by electrostatic repulsions and the large entropic penalty associated with DNA confinement. In this slightly elongated capsid, the DNA assumes a folded toroidal conformation, rather than a coaxial spool. The model can be used to study packaging of other bacteriophages with different shapes under a range of environmental conditions.     

The three-dimensional structure of a DNA translocating machine at 10 A resolution.

BACKGROUND: Head-tail connectors are viral substructures that are very important in the viral morphogenetic cycle, having roles in the formation of the precursor capsid (prohead), DNA packaging, tail binding to the mature head and in the infection process. Structural information on the connector would, therefore, help us to understand how this structure is related to a multiplicity of functions. RESULTS: Recombinant bacteriophage phi29 connectors have been crystallized in two-dimensional aggregates. An average projection image and a three-dimensional map have been obtained at 8 A and 10 A resolution, respectively, from untilted and tilted images of vitrified specimens of the two-dimensional crystals. The average projection image reveals a central mass surrounding a channel with 12 appendages protruding from the central mass. The three-dimensional map reveals a wide domain surrounded by 12 appendages that interact with the prohead vertex, and a narrow domain that interacts with the bacteriophage tail. At the junction of the two domains, 12 smaller appendages are visualized. A channel runs along the axis of the connector structure and is sufficiently wide to allow a double-stranded DNA molecule to pass through. CONCLUSIONS: The propeller-like structure of the phi29 connector strengthens the notion of the connector rotating during DNA packaging. The groove formed by the two lanes of large and small appendages may act as a rail to prevent the liberation of the connector from the prohead vertex during rotation.     

Ion-dependent DNA configuration in bacteriophage capsids

Bacteriophages densely pack their long double-stranded DNA genome inside a protein capsid. The conformation of the viral genome inside the capsid is consistent with a hexagonal liquid crystalline structure. Experiments have confirmed that the details of the hexagonal packing depend on the electrochemistry of the capsid and its environment. In this work, we propose a biophysical model that quantifies the relationship between DNA configurations inside bacteriophage capsids and the types and concentrations of ions present in a biological system. We introduce an expression for the free energy that combines the electrostatic energy with contributions from bending of individual segments of DNA and Lennard-Jones-type interactions between these segments. The equilibrium points of this energy solve a partial differential equation that defines the distributions of DNA and the ions inside the capsid. We develop a computational approach that allows us to simulate much larger systems than what is possible using the existing molecular-level methods. In particular, we are able to estimate bending and repulsion between the DNA segments as well as the full electrochemistry of the solution, both inside and outside of the capsid. The numerical results show good agreement with existing experiments and with molecular dynamics simulations for small capsids.     

Bacteriophage P22 portal protein is part of the gauge that regulates packing density of intravirion DNA.

The complex double-stranded DNA bacteriophages assemble DNA-free protein shells (procapsids) that subsequently package DNA. In the case of several double-stranded DNA bacteriophages, including P22, packaging is associated with cutting of DNA from the concatemeric molecule that results from replication. The mature intravirion P22 DNA has both non-unique (circularly permuted) ends and a length that is determined by the procapsid. In all known cases, procapsids consist of an outer coat protein, an interior scaffolding protein that assists in the assembly of the coat protein shell, and a ring of 12 identical portal protein subunits through which the DNA is presumed to enter the procapsid. To investigate the role of the portal protein in cutting permuted DNA from concatemers, we have characterized P22 portal protein mutants. The effects of several single amino acid changes in the P22 portal protein on the length of the DNA packaged, the density to which DNA is condensed within the virion, and the outer radius of the capsid have been determined. The results obtained with one mutant (NT5/1a) indicate no change (+/- 0.5%) in the radius of the capsid, but mature DNA that is 4.7% longer and a packing density that is commensurately higher than those of wild-type P22. Thus, the portal protein is part of the gauge that regulates the length and packaging density of DNA in bacteriophage P22. We argue that these findings make models for DNA packaging less likely in which the packing density is a property solely of the coat protein shell or of the DNA itself.     

Packaging of DNA by bacteriophage epsilon15: structure, forces, and thermodynamics

The structure of bacteriophage epsilon15 has recently been determined by 3D reconstruction of single particle cryo-electron microscopy images. Although this study revealed that the viral genome inside the bacteriophage is on average coaxially spooled, individual DNA conformations inside the capsid could not be determined. In the current study, we present the results of 40 independent simulations of DNA packaging into epsilon15 using the previously described low-resolution model for bacteriophages. In addition to coaxially spooled conformations, we also observe a number of folded-toroidal patterns, but the density averaged over all conformations closely resembles the experimental density. Thermodynamic analysis of the simulations predicts that a force of approximately 125 pN would be required to package DNA into epsilon15. We also show that the origin of this force is predominantly due to electrostatic and entropic contributions. However, the DNA conformation is determined primarily by the need to minimize the DNA bending energy.     

The protein capsid of filamentous bacteriophage PH75 from Thermus thermophilus

The PH75 strain of filamentous bacteriophage (Inovirus) grows in the thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus at 70 degrees C. We have characterized the viral DNA and determined the amino acid sequence of the major coat protein, p8. The p8 protein is synthesized without a leader sequence, like that of bacteriophage Pf3 but unlike that of bacteriophage Pf1, both of which grow in the mesophile Pseudomonas aeruginosa. X-ray diffraction patterns from ordered fibres of the PH75 virion are similar to those from bacteriophages Pf1 and Pf3, indicating that the protein capsid of the PH75 virion has the same helix symmetry and subunit shape, even though the primary structures of the major coat proteins are quite different and the virions assemble at very different temperatures. We have used this information to build a molecular model of the PH75 protein capsid based on that of Pf1, and refined the model by simulated annealing, using fibre diffraction data extending to 2.4 A resolution in the meridional direction and to 3.1 A resolution in the equatorial direction. The common design may reflect a fundamental motif of alpha-helix packing, although differences exist in the DNA packaging and in the means of insertion of the major coat protein of these filamentous bacteriophages into the membrane of the host bacterial cell. These may reflect differences in the assembly mechanisms of the virions.     

Comparison of the physical properties and assembly pathways of the related bacteriophages T7, T3 and phi II

To understand constraints on the evolution of bacteriophage assembly, the structures, electrophoretic mobilities (mu) and assembly pathways of the related double-stranded DNA bacteriophages T7, T3 and phi II, have been compared. The characteristics of the following T7, T3 and phi II capsids in these assembly pathways have also been compared: (1) a DNA-free procapsid (capsid I) that packages DNA during assembly; (b) a DNA packaging-associated conversion product of capsid I (capsid II). The molecular weights of the T3 and phi II genomes were 25.2 X 10(6) and 25.9 (+/- 0.2) X 10(6) (26.44 X 10(6) for T7, as previously determined), as determined by agarose gel electrophoresis of intact genomes. The radii of T7, T3 and phi II bacteriophages were indistinguishable by sieving during agarose gel electrophoresis (+/- 4%) and measurement of the bacteriophage hydration (+/- 2%) (30.1 nm for T7, as previously determined). Assuming a T = 7 icosahedral lattice for the arrangement of the major capsid subunits (p10A) of T7, T3 and phi II best explains these data and data previously obtained for T7. At pH 7.4 and an ionic strength of 1.2, the solid-support-free mu values (mu 0 values) of T7, T3 and phi II bacteriophages, obtained by extrapolation of mu during agarose gel electrophoresis to an agarose concentration of 0 and correction for electro-osmosis, were -0.71, -0.91 and -1.17(X 10(-4) cm2V-1 s-1. The mu 0 values of T7, T3 and phi II capsids I were -1.51, -1.58 and -2.07(X 10(-4] cm2V-1 s-1. For the capsids II, these mu 0 values were -0.82, -1.07 and -1.37(X 10(-4] cm2V-1 s-1. The tails of all three bacteriophages were positively charged and the capsid envelopes (heads) were negatively charged. In all cases the procapsid had a negative mu 0 value larger in magnitude than the negative mu 0 value for bacteriophage or capsid II. A trypsin-sensitive region in capsid I-associated, but not capsid II-associated, T3 p10A was observed (previously observed for T7). The largest fragment of trypsinized capsid I-associated p10A had the same molecular weight in T7 and T3, although the T3 p10A is 18% more massive than the T7 p10A. It is suggested that the trypsin-resistant region of capsid I-associated p10A determines the radius of the bacteriophage capsid.     

A three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopy structure of the bacteriophage phiKZ head

The three-dimensional structure of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacteriophage phiKZ head has been determined by cryo-electron microscopy and image reconstruction to 18A resolution. The head has icosahedral symmetry measuring 1455 A in diameter along 5-fold axes and a unique portal vertex to which is attached an approximately 1800 A-long contractile tail. The 65 kDa major capsid protein, gp120, is organized into a surface lattice of hexamers, with T = 27 triangulation. The shape and size of the hexamers is similar to the hexameric building blocks of the bacteriophages T4, phi29, P22, and HK97. Pentameric vertices of the capsid are occupied by complexes composed of several special vertex proteins. The double-stranded genomic DNA is packaged into a highly condensed series of layers, separated by 24 A, that follow the contour of the inner wall of the capsid.     

Stability and in vitro DNA packaging of bacteriophages: effects of dextrans, sugars, and polyols.

Attempts were made to increase the efficiency of infectious particle formation during the in vitro assembly of bacteriophage T7 from procapsids and DNA. It was found that dextrans and some smaller, related compounds (sucrose and sorbitol) increase this efficiency by a factor of 8 to 50. Dextrans also inhibited elevated temperature-induced emptying of DNA from bacteriophages T7, P22, and T4, suggesting that the stimulation of assembly is caused, at least in part, by the stabilization of packaged DNA in capsids. The data indicated that the sugars and polyols can slow DNA emptying from bacteriophages at elevated temperature whether they permeate the bacteriophage capsid or not. In contrast, the data suggested that permeation of some particle, probably a capsid, results in inhibition of in vitro T7 assembly.     

A conformational switch in bacteriophage p22 portal protein primes genome injection

Double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) viruses such as herpesviruses and bacteriophages infect by delivering their genetic material into cells, a task mediated by a DNA channel called "portal protein." We have used electron cryomicroscopy to determine the structure of bacteriophage P22 portal protein in both the procapsid and mature capsid conformations. We find that, just as the viral capsid undergoes major conformational changes during virus maturation, the portal protein switches conformation from a procapsid to a mature phage state upon binding of gp4, the factor that initiates tail assembly. This dramatic conformational change traverses the entire length of the DNA channel, from the outside of the virus to the inner shell, and erects a large dome domain directly above the DNA channel that binds dsDNA inside the capsid. We hypothesize that this conformational change primes dsDNA for injection and directly couples completion of virus morphogenesis to a new cycle of infection.     

Langevin dynamics simulations of genome packing in bacteriophage

We use Langevin dynamics simulations to study the process by which a coarse-grained DNA chain is packaged within an icosahedral container. We focus our inquiry on three areas of interest in viral packing: the evolving structure of the packaged DNA condensate; the packing velocity; and the internal buildup of energy and resultant forces. Each of these areas has been studied experimentally, and we find that we can qualitatively reproduce experimental results. However, our findings also suggest that the phage genome packing process is fundamentally different than that suggested by the inverse spool model. We suggest that packing in general does not proceed in the deterministic fashion of the inverse-spool model, but rather is stochastic in character. As the chain configuration becomes compressed within the capsid, the structure, energy, and packing velocity all become dependent upon polymer dynamics. That many observed features of the packing process are rooted in condensed-phase polymer dynamics suggests that statistical mechanics, rather than mechanics, should serve as the proper theoretical basis for genome packing. Finally we suggest that, as a result of an internal protein unique to bacteriophage T7, the T7 genome may be significantly more ordered than is true for bacteriophage in general.     

The mechanism for producing two symmetries at the head-tail junction of bacteriophages: a hypothesis

Some double-stranded DNA bacteriophages consist of DNA packaged in a proteinaceous capsid. The capsid has a DNA-enclosing outer shell (head) attached to an external projection (tail). At the head-tail junction is a ring of subunits (connector) that has either six or twelve-fold rotational symmetry, and is joined to the head at an axis of the head's five-fold rotational symmetry. The head is made of subunits in either an icosahedral array or an array consisting of two icosahedral hemispheres separated by a cylinder of subunits. During infection of a host, the head with connector is assembled as a procapsid that subsequently packages DNA and joins a tail. The mechanism for producing two symmetries at the head-tail junction has in the past been an unsolved problem. The observation that the connector of bacteriophage T7 does not nucleate assembly of the outer shell of T7's icosahedral procapsid (P. Serwer and R. H. Watson [1982] J. Virol. 42, 595-601) places a constraint on a solution for the above problem. To solve the above problem for icosahedral procapsids, it is proposed here that: (a) assembly of the outer shell of procapsids is nucleated by a six-membered ring of hexameric aggregates of the major outer shell protein, (b) the connector is assembled in the center of this ring, (c) one of the hexamers dissociates from the ring, creating a five-membered ring and forcing the connector to the inside of the outer shell. A related mechanism is proposed for nucleation of the elongated procapsid of bacteriophage T4.     

Localization of minor protein components of the head of bacteriophage T4.

The bacteriophage T4 capsid contains a number of minor proteins that are required for head assembly but whose detailed function and position in the head are unknown. We have found that by systematically varying the conditions of extraction, some of these minor proteins can be removed while the main capsid structure is left substantially intact. Electron microscopic examination of the residual capsids showed that the extraction of the product of gene 20 is correlated with the loss of a plug that distinguishes one vertex position (presumably the tail attachment site) from the others. Extraction of the product of gene 24 is correlated with the loss of the other 11 (nonproximal) vertexes of the capsid. We further show that antibody to P24 binds specifically to the nonproximal vertexes of both T4 preheads and T4 phages. On the basis of our findings, we suggest that P20 is located at or near the tail attachment site of the capsid, whereas P24 forms the 11 nonproximal vertexes of preheads and P24 forms the nonproximal vertexes of the mature head.     

Stalked Bacteria: Properties of Deoxriybonucleic Acid Bacteriophage φCbK

The Caulobacter crescentus bacteriophage phiCbK was studied with respect to the physical and chemical properties of both the phage and its deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). Electron micrographs reveal the phage to be among the largest DNA bacteriophages reported, with head dimensions of 64 by 195 nm and a flexible tail 275 nm in length. The phage is composed of 57% DNA. This DNA is double-stranded as indicated by (i) the sharp increase in extinction coefficient over a narrow range of temperature increase, (ii) an increase in density in CsCl upon thermal denaturation, and (iii) the equivalence of guanine and cytosine as well as adenine and thymine, determined by chemical analysis. phiCbK DNA cosediments with Escherichia coli phage T2 DNA and has therefore been assigned an S(20,w) value of 63.5S. The size of the phage and its DNA and the percentage of DNA indicate that the phiCbK phage head is relatively loosely packed. The properties of the DNA from bacteriophage phiCbK are similar to those of host C. crescentus DNA with respect to buoyant density, thermal transition point, and guanine plus cytosine content.     

The structural organization of DNA packaged within the heads of T4 wild-type,isometric and giant bacteriophages

We present electron microscopic and X-ray diffraction evidence concerning the structural organization of condensed DNA within a series of T4 bacteriophage with the following head morphologies: prolate (wild-type), isometric and giant (with greatly increased axial ratio). In all cases, the DNA helix segments are locally parallel and 27 Å apart. For the giant particles, we show that the DNA forms a large coil whose axis is perpendicular to the axis of the phage tail. This evidence, combined with previous results from a series of isometric bacteriophages (Earnshaw and Harrison, 1977), leads to a model for the organization of condensed DNA that may apply to most dsDNA-containing bacteriophages.     

Double-stranded DNA bacteriophage prohead protease is homologous to herpesvirus protease

Double-stranded DNA bacteriophages and herpesviruses assemble their heads in a similar fashion; a pre-formed precursor called a prohead or procapsid undergoes a conformational transition to give rise to a mature head or capsid. A virus-encoded prohead or procapsid protease is often required in this maturation process. Through computational analysis, we infer homology between bacteriophage prohead proteases (MEROPS families U9 and U35) and herpesvirus protease (MEROPS family S21), and unify them into a procapsid protease superfamily. We also extend this superfamily to include an uncharacterized cluster of orthologs (COG3566) and many other phage or bacteria-encoded hypothetical proteins. On the basis of this homology and the herpesvirus protease structure and catalytic mechanism, we predict that bacteriophage prohead proteases adopt the herpesvirus protease fold and exploit a conserved Ser and His residue pair in catalysis. Our study provides further support for the proposed evolutionary link between dsDNA bacteriophages and herpesviruses.     

Role of φ29 connector channel loops in late-stage DNA packaging

Double-stranded DNA bacteriophages and their eukaryotic virus counterparts have 12-fold head-tail connector assemblages embedded at a unique capsid vertex. This vertex is the site of assembly of the DNA packaging motor, and the connector has a central channel through which viral DNA passes during genome packaging and subsequent host infection. Crystal structures of connectors from different phages reveal either disordered residues or structured loops that project into the connector channel. Given the proximity to the translocating DNA substrate, these loops have been proposed to play a role in DNA packaging. Previous models have proposed structural motions in either the packaging ATPase or the connector channel loops as the driving force that translocates the DNA into the prohead. Here, we mutate the channel loops of the Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage φ29 connector and show that these loops have no active role in translocation of DNA. Instead, they appear to have an essential function near the end of packaging, acting to retain the packaged DNA in the head in preparation for motor detachment and subsequent tail assembly and virion completion.     

Assembly-associated structural changes of bacteriophage T7 capsids. Detection by use of a protein-specific probe.

To detect changes in capsid structure that occur when a preassembled bacteriophage T7 capsid both packages and cleaves to mature-size longer (concatameric) DNA, the kinetics and thermodynamics are determined here for the binding of the protein-specific probe, 1,1'-bi(4-anilino)naphthalene-5,5'-di-sulfonic acid (bis-ANS), to bacteriophage T7, a T7 DNA deletion (8.4%) mutant, and a DNA-free T7 capsid (metrizamide low density capsid II) known to be a DNA packaging intermediate that has a permeability barrier not present in a related capsid (metrizamide high density capsid II). Initially, some binding to either bacteriophage or metrizamide low density capsid II occurs too rapidly to quantify (phase 1, duration < 10 s). Subsequent binding (phase 2) occurs with first-order kinetics. Only the phase 1 binding occurs for metrizamide high density capsid II. These observations, together with both the kinetics of the quenching by ethidium of bound bis-ANS fluorescence and the nature of bis-ANS-induced protein alterations, are explained by the hypothesis that the phase 2 binding occurs at internal sites. The number of these internal sites increases as the density of the packaged DNA decreases. The accompanying change in structure is potentially the signal for initiating cleavage of a concatemer. Evidence for the following was also obtained: (a) a previously undetected packaging-associated change in the conformation of the major protein of the outer capsid shell and (b) partitioning by a permeability barrier of the interior of the T7 capsid.     

Simulations of knotting in confined circular DNA

The packing of DNA inside bacteriophages arguably yields the simplest example of genome organization in living organisms. As an assay of packing geometry, the DNA knot spectrum produced upon release of viral DNA from the P4 phage capsid has been analyzed, and compared to results of simulation of knots in confined volumes. We present new results from extensive stochastic sampling of confined self-avoiding and semiflexible circular chains with volume exclusion. The physical parameters of the chains (contour length, cross section, and bending rigidity) have been set to match those of P4 bacteriophage DNA. By using advanced sampling techniques, involving multiple Markov chain pressure-driven confinement combined with a thermodynamic reweighting technique, we establish the knot spectrum of the circular chains for increasing confinement up to the highest densities for which available algorithms can exactly classify the knots. Compactified configurations have an enclosing hull diameter ∼2.5 times larger than the P4 caliper size. The results are discussed in relation to the recent experiments on DNA knotting inside the capsid of a P4 tailless mutant. Our investigation indicates that confinement favors chiral knots over achiral ones, as found in the experiments. However, no significant bias of torus over twist knots is found, contrary to the P4 results. The result poses a crucial question for future studies of DNA packaging in P4: is the discrepancy due to the insufficient confinement of the equilibrium simulation or does it indicate that out-of-equilibrium mechanisms (such as rotation by packaging motors) affect the genome organization, hence its knot spectrum in P4?     

Structural study of the lipid-containing bacteriophage PRD1 and its capsid and DNA components by laser Raman spectroscopy

The Raman spectrum of a virus contains the structural signature of each of its molecular components (Thomas, 1987). We report the first Raman spectrum obtained from an intact, lipid-containing virus--the icosahedral bacteriophage PRD1--and show that this spectrum contains characteristic structure markers for the major capsid protein, the packaged double-stranded DNA genome, and the viral membrane which resides between the capsid and DNA. We find that the packaged genome of PRD1 exhibits Raman markers typical of the B-DNA secondary structure. Comparison of the Raman spectrum of the packaged DNA with that of protein-free DNA extracted from the virion shows further that the B-form secondary structure is not significantly perturbed by packaging in the virion. The Raman signature of the PRD1 membrane, monitored within the virion at 4 degrees C, is that of a phospholipid liquid-crystalline phase. The PRD1 capsid, which comprises several hundred copies of the major coat protein P3 (product of viral gene III) and a few copies of minor proteins, incorporates P3 capsomers predominantly in the beta-sheet conformation. The beta-sheet structure of P3 is maintained in the fully assembled PRD1 virion, as well as in the empty capsid. The present results demonstrate the feasibility of obtaining structural information from the three different classes of biomolecules--nucleic acid, protein, and lipid--which constitute a membrane-lined virus particle. Our results also demonstrate that the coat protein and double-stranded DNA components of a lipid-containing bacteriophage share many structural features in common with bacteriophage lacking a lipid membrane.