Three-dimensional structural views of damaged-DNA recognition: T4 endonuclease V, E. coli Vsr protein, and human nucleotide excision repair factor XPA

Genetic information is frequently disturbed by introduction of modified or mismatch bases into duplex DNA, and hence all organisms contain DNA repair systems to restore normal genetic information by removing such damaged bases or nucleotides and replacing them by correct ones. The understanding of this repair mechanism is a central subject in cell biology. This review focuses on the three-dimensional structural views of damaged DNA recognition by three proteins. The first protein is T4 endonuclease V (T4 endo V), which catalyzes the first reaction step of the excision repair pathway to remove pyrimidine-dimers (PD) produced within duplex DNA by UV irradiation. The crystal structure of this enzyme complexed with DNA containing a thymidine-dimer provided the first direct view of DNA lesion recognition by a repair enzyme, indicating that the DNA kink coupled with base flipping-out is important for damaged DNA recognition. The second is very short patch repair (Vsr) endonuclease, which recognizes a TG mismatch within the five base pair consensus sequence. The crystal structure of this enzyme in complex with duplex DNA containing a TG mismatch revealed a novel mismatch base pair recognition scheme, where three aromatic residues intercalate from the major groove into the DNA to strikingly deform the base pair stacking but the base flipping-out does not occur. The third is human nucleotide excision repair (NER) factor XPA, which is a major component of a large protein complex. This protein has been shown to bind preferentially to UV- or chemical carcinogen-damaged DNA. The solution structure of the XPA central domain, essential for the interaction of damaged DNA, was determined by NMR. This domain was found to be divided mainly into a (Cys)4-type zinc-finger motif subdomain for replication protein A (RPA) recognition and the carboxyl terminal subdomain responsible for DNA binding.     

Recognition of a TG mismatch: the crystal structure of very short patch repair endonuclease in complex with a DNA duplex

The crystal structure of very short patch repair (Vsr) endonuclease, in complex with Mg2+ and with duplex DNA containing a TG mismatch, has been determined at 2.3 A resolution. In E. coli, the enzyme recognizes a TG mismatched base pair, generated after spontaneous deamination of methylated cytosines, and cleaves the phosphate backbone on the 5' side of the thymine. Extensive interactions between the DNA and the protein characterize a novel recognition mechanism, where three aromatic residues intercalate from the major groove into the DNA to strikingly deform the base pair stacking. With the presence of a cleaved DNA intermediate in the active center, the structure of the Vsr/DNA complex provides detailed insights into the catalytic mechanism for endonuclease activity.     

Physical and functional interactions between Escherichia coli MutL and the Vsr repair endonuclease

DNA mismatch repair (MMR) and very-short patch (VSP) repair are two pathways involved in the repair of T:G mismatches. To learn about competition and cooperation between these two repair pathways, we analyzed the physical and functional interaction between MutL and Vsr using biophysical and biochemical methods. Analytical ultracentrifugation reveals a nucleotide-dependent interaction between Vsr and the N-terminal domain of MutL. Using chemical crosslinking, we mapped the interaction site of MutL for Vsr to a region between the N-terminal domains similar to that described before for the interaction between MutL and the strand discrimination endonuclease MutH of the MMR system. Competition between MutH and Vsr for binding to MutL resulted in inhibition of the mismatch-provoked MutS- and MutL-dependent activation of MutH, which explains the mutagenic effect of Vsr overexpression. Cooperation between MMR and VSP repair was demonstrated by the stimulation of the Vsr endonuclease in a MutS-, MutL- and ATP-hydrolysis-dependent manner, in agreement with the enhancement of VSP repair by MutS and MutL in vivo. These data suggest a mobile MutS–MutL complex in MMR signalling, that leaves the DNA mismatch prior to, or at the time of, activation of downstream effector molecules such as Vsr or MutH.     

Crystallographic and functional studies of very short patch repair endonuclease.

Vsr endonuclease plays a crucial role in the repair of TG mismatched base pairs, which are generated by the spontaneous degradation of methylated cytidines; Vsr recognizes the mismatched base pair and cleaves the phosphate backbone 5' to the thymidine. We have determined the crystal structure of a truncated form of this endonuclease at 1.8 A resolution. The protein contains one structural zinc-binding module. Unexpectedly, its overall topology resembles members of the type II restriction endonuclease family. Subsequent mutational and biochemical analyses showed that certain elements in the catalytic site are also conserved. However, the identification of a critical histidine and evidence of an active site metal-binding coordination that is novel to endonucleases indicate a distinct catalytic mechanism.     

Base pair opening kinetics and dynamics in the DNA duplexes that specifically recognized by very short patch repair protein (Vsr)

In Escherichia coli, the very short patch (VSP) repair system is a major pathway for removal of T·G mismatches in Dcm target sequences. In the VSP repair pathway, the very short patch repair (Vsr) endonuclease selectively recognizes a T·G mismatch in Dcm target sequences and hydrolyzes the 5′-phosphate group of the mismatched thymine. The hydrogen exchange NMR studies here revealed that the T5·G18 mismatch in the Dcm target sequence significantly stabilizes own base pair but destabilizes the two neighboring G4·C19 and A6·T17 base pairs compare to other T·G mismatches. These unusual patterns of base pair stability in the Dcm target sequence can explain how the Vsr endonuclease specifically recognizes the mismatched Dcm target sequence and intercalates into the DNA.     

Crystal structure of NaeI-an evolutionary bridge between DNA endonuclease and topoisomerase

NAE:I is transformed from DNA endonuclease to DNA topoisomerase and recombinase by a single amino acid substitution. The crystal structure of NAE:I was solved at 2.3 A resolution and shows that NAE:I is a dimeric molecule with two domains per monomer. Each domain contains one potential DNA recognition motif corresponding to either endonuclease or topoisomerase activity. The N-terminal domain core folds like the other type II restriction endonucleases as well as lambda-exonuclease and the DNA repair enzymes MutH and Vsr, implying a common evolutionary origin and catalytic mechanism. The C-terminal domain contains a catabolite activator protein (CAP) motif present in many DNA-binding proteins, including the type IA and type II topoisomerases. Thus, the NAE:I structure implies that DNA processing enzymes evolved from a few common ancestors. NAE:I may be an evolutionary bridge between endonuclease and DNA processing enzymes.     

Repair of hydrolytic DNA deamination damage in thermophilic bacteria: cloning and characterization of a Vsr endonuclease homolog from Bacillus stearothermophilus

Hydrolytic deamination of 5-methyl cytosine in double stranded DNA results in formation of a T/G mismatch that—if left unrepaired—leads to a C→T transition mutation in half of the progeny. In addition to several mismatch-specific glycosylases that have been found in both pro- and eukaryotes to channel this lesion into base excision repair by removing the T from the mismatch, Vsr endonuclease from Escherichia coli has been described which initiates repair by an endonucleolytic strand incision 5′ to the mismatched T. We have isolated a gene coding for a homolog of E.coli Vsr endonuclease from the thermophilic bacterium Bacillus stearothermophilus H3 (Vsr.Bst) using a method that allows PCR amplification with degenerated primers of gene segments which code for only one highly conserved amino acid region. Vsr.Bst was produced heterologously in E.coli and purified to apparent homogeneity. Vsr.Bst specifically incises heteroduplex DNA with a preference for T/G mismatches. The selectivity of Vsr.Bst for the sequence context of the T/G mismatch appears less pronounced than for Vsr.Eco.     

Functional interactions between the MutL and Vsr proteins of Escherichia coli are dependent on the N-terminus of Vsr

The crystal structure of the Escherichia coli Vsr endonuclease bound to a C(T/G)AGG substrate revealed that the DNA is held by a pincer composed of a trio of aromatic residues which intercalate into the major groove, and an N-terminus alpha helix which lies across the minor groove. We have constructed an N-terminus truncation (Delta14) which removes most of the alpha helix. The mutant is still fairly proficient in mediating very short patch repair. However, its endonuclease activity is considerably reduced and, in contrast to that of the wild type protein, cannot be stimulated by MutL. We had shown previously that excess Vsr in vivo causes mutagenesis, probably by inhibiting the participation of MutL in mismatch repair. The Delta14 mutant has diminished mutagenicity. In contrast, four enzymatically inactive mutants, with intact N-termini, are as mutagenic as the wild type protein. On the basis of these results we suggest that MutL causes a conformational change in the N-terminus of Vsr which enhances Vsr activity, and that this functional interaction between Vsr and MutL decreases the ability of MutL to carry out mismatch repair.     

A network of enzymes involved in repair of oxidative DNA damage in Neisseria meningitidis

Although oxidative stress is a key aspect of innate immunity, little is known about how host‐restricted pathogens successfully repair DNA damage. Base excision repair is responsible for correcting nucleobases damaged by oxidative stress, and is essential for bloodstream infection caused by the human pathogen, Neisseria meningitidis. We have characterized meningococcal base excision repair enzymes involved in the recognition and removal of damaged nucleobases, and incision of the DNA backbone. We demonstrate that the bi‐functional glycosylase/lyases Nth and MutM share several overlapping activities and functional redundancy. However, MutM and other members of the GO system, which deal with 8‐oxoG, a common lesion of oxidative damage, are not required for survival of N. meningitidis under oxidative stress. Instead, the mismatch repair pathway provides back‐up for the GO system, while the lyase activity of Nth can substitute for the meningococcal AP endonuclease, NApe. Our genetic and biochemical evidence shows that DNA repair is achieved through a robust network of enzymes that provides a flexible system of DNA repair. This network is likely to reflect successful adaptation to the human nasopharynx, and might provide a paradigm for DNA repair in other prokaryotes.     

The Escherichia coli MutL protein stimulates binding of Vsr and MutS to heteroduplex DNA.

Vsr DNA mismatch endonuclease is the key enzyme of very short patch (VSP) DNA mismatch repair and nicks the T-containing strand at the site of a T-G mismatch in a sequence-dependent manner. MutS is part of the mutHLS repair system and binds to diverse mismatches in DNA. The function of the mutL gene product is currently unclear but mutations in the gene abolish mutHLS -dependent repair. The absence of MutL severely reduces VSP repair but does not abolish it. Purified MutL appears to act catalytically to bind Vsr to its substrate; one-hundredth of an equivalent of MutL is sufficient to bring about a significant effect. MutL enhances binding of MutS to its substrate 6-fold but does so in a stoichiometric manner. Mutational studies indicate that the MutL interaction region lies within the N-terminal 330 amino acids and that the MutL multimerization region is at the C-terminal end. MutL mutant monomeric forms can stimulate MutS binding.     

Crystal structure of the Escherichia coli dcm very-short-patch DNA repair endonuclease bound to its reaction product-site in a DNA superhelix

Very-short-patch repair (Vsr) enzymes occur in a variety of bacteria, where they initiate nucleotide excision repair of G:T mismatches arising by deamination of 5-methyl-cytosines in specific regulatory sequences. We have now determined the structure of the archetypal dcm-Vsr endonuclease from Escherichia coli bound to the cleaved authentic hemi-deaminated/hemi-methylated dcm sequence 5′-C-OH-3′ 5′-p-T-p-A-p-G-p-G-3′/3′-G-p-G-p-T-p^Me5C-p-C formed by self-assembly of a 12mer oligonucleotide into a continuous nicked DNA superhelix. The structure reveals the presence of a Hoogsteen base pair within the deaminated recognition sequence and the substantial distortions of the DNA that accompany Vsr binding to product sites.     

Incision at hypoxanthine residues in DNA by a mammalian homologue of the Escherichia coli antimutator enzyme endonuclease V

Deamination of DNA bases can occur spontaneously, generating highly mutagenic lesions such as uracil and hypoxanthine. In Escherichia coli two enzymes initiate repair at hypoxanthine residues in DNA. The alkylbase DNA glycosylase, AlkA, initiates repair by removal of the damaged base, whereas endonuclease V, Endo V, hydrolyses the second phosphodiester bond 3′ to the lesion. We have identified and characterised a mouse cDNA with striking homology to the E.coli nfi gene, which also has significant similarities to motifs required for catalytic activity of the UvrC endonuclease. The 37-kDa mouse enzyme (mEndo V) incises the DNA strand at the second phosphodiester bond 3′ to hypoxanthine- and uracil-containing nucleotides. The activity of mEndo V is elevated on single-stranded DNA substrate in vitro. Expression of the mouse protein in a DNA repair-deficient E.coli alkA nfi strain suppresses its spontaneous mutator phenotype. We suggest that mEndo V initiates an alternative excision repair pathway for hypoxanthine removal. It thus appears that mEndo V has properties overlapping the function of alkylbase DNA glycosylase (Aag) in repair of deaminated adenine, which to some extent could explain the absence of phenotypic abnormalities associated with Aag knockout in mice.     

A novel nucleotide excision repair for the conversion of an A/G mismatch to C/G base pair in E. coli

A protein that binds specifically to A/G mismatches has been detected in E. coli by a gel electrophoresis DNA binding assay. A specific endonuclease is associated with the A/G mismatch-binding protein through two chromatographic steps. The endonuclease is specific for A/G-containing DNA fragments and has no cleavage activity on DNA containing the other seven possible mispairs or homoduplex DNA. The endonuclease simultaneously makes incisions at the first phosphodiester bond 3' to and the second phosphodiester bond 5' to the dA of the A/G mismatch. No incision site was detected on the other strand. These results are consistent with the unidirectional A to C conversion and short repair tract of a novel dam- and mutHLS-independent A/G repair pathway we have recently described. A nucleotide excision repair model is proposed for the conversion of an A/G mismatch to a C/G base pair.     

Neisseria gonorrhoeae FA1090 Carries Genes Encoding Two Classes of Vsr Endonucleases

A very short patch repair system prevents mutations resulting from deamination of 5-methylcytosine to thymine. The Vsr endonuclease is the key enzyme of this system, providing sequence specificity. We identified two genes encoding Vsr endonucleases V.NgoAXIII and V.NgoAXIV from Neisseria gonorrhoeae FA1090 based on DNA sequence similarity to genes encoding Vsr endonucleases from other bacteria. After expression of the gonococcal genes in Escherichia coli, the proteins were biochemically characterized and the endonucleolytic activities and specificities of V.NgoAXIII and V.NgoAXIV were determined. V.NgoAXIII was found to be multispecific and to recognize T:G mismatches in every nucleotide context tested, whereas V.NgoAXIV recognized T:G mismatches in the following sequences: GTGG, CTGG, GTGC, ATGC, and CTGC. Alanine mutagenesis of conserved residues showed that Asp50 and His68 of V.NgoAXIII and Asp51 and His69 of V.NgoAXIV are essential for hydrolytic activity. Glu25, His64, and Asp97 of V.NgoAXIV and Glu24, Asp63, and Asp97 of V.NgoAXIII are important but not crucial for the activity of V.NgoAXIII and V.NgoAXIV. However, Glu24 and Asp63 are also important for the specificity of V.NgoAXIII. On the basis of our results concerning features of Vsr endonucleases expressed by N. gonorrhoeae FA1090, we postulate that at least two types of Vsr endonucleases can be distinguished.The existence of methylated DNA in procaryotes and eucaryotes has been well documented, with 5-methylcytosine (m5C) being the most commonly modified base (1). Organisms use m5C as an epigenetic tag, but this modified base is very unstable and can undergo spontaneous deamination (15), resulting in a T:G mismatch. In the absence of an appropriate repair mechanism, cytosine deamination is highly mutagenic. Since the deamination usually occurs in a nonreplicating background, the lesion is refractory to methyl-directed mismatch repair. If the T:G mismatch is repaired by a general repair mechanism, the creation of an A·T substitution is as likely as the restoration of the original G·C base pair. In DNA, thymine resulting from deamination of m5C cannot be removed by general repair mechanisms because they do not recognize this thymine as erroneous. As a result, in the absence of a specific repair mechanism, deamination of m5C is highly mutagenic.In Escherichia coli, a repair pathway counteracting the mutagenic effects of hydrolytic deamination of m5C is based on the action of a very short patch (VSP) repair system (2, 5, 8, 18, 23). The central enzyme of this pathway is Vsr, an endonuclease whose coding sequence overlaps the gene for M.EcoKDcm, an m5C methyltransferase (m5C-MTase) (19, 23). In genomes of other bacteria, the vsr genes are invariably associated with genes coding for m5C-MTases (3, 16, 20). The Vsr endonucleases that accompany m5C-MTases are believed to exhibit sequence specificity based on the recognition sequence of the accompanying MTase. However, only a few MTases have been studied in detail and the data indicate that methylation at sites other than that ascribed to the corresponding restriction endonuclease can occur with significant frequency (4), indicating that the recognition sequence of an MTase is somewhat arbitrarily assigned. The best-characterized Vsr endonuclease, V.EcoKDcm (9, 10, 29), is a gene product of E. coli K-12. This endonuclease recognizes the sequence CTWGG (W is A or T), where the underlined thymine is mispaired with guanine. The enzyme nicks the DNA backbone on the 5′ side of the mispaired thymine (12). The crystal structure of V.EcoKDcm shows that its catalytic center consists of two conserved aspartic acid residues (D51 and D97), glutamic acid (E25), threonine (T63), and two histidines (H64 and H69). Alanine-scanning mutagenesis of these conserved residues revealed that E25A, H64A, and D97A mutants have reduced activity, while D51A and H69A mutants have no detectable activity (28-30).An individual strain of Neisseria gonorrhoeae may produce up to 16 different DNA MTases, with the bulk of these enzymes adding m5C to one of the cytosines in the recognition sequence (20, 25). Due to the high degree of potential cytosine methylation in the gonococcus, one might predict that genes containing any of these recognition sequences would represent hot spots for mutation. However, to date, no hot spots have been identified. Furthermore, we were only able to identify two potential Vsr endonucleases. While the genes encoding both of these proteins appear to be linked to restriction-modification system genes in a variety of gonococcal strains, these systems appear to be inactive (16). To understand the biochemical basis of VSP repair in the Neisseriaceae, we studied the properties of Vsr endonucleases from N. gonorrhoeae FA1090. Given the large number of m5C-MTases found in the gonococcus and the paucity of vsr genes identified using bioinformatic analysis based on amino acid sequence similarity with known Vsr proteins, it is possible that the Vsr endonucleases expressed by N. gonorrhoeae could have more general sequence recognition properties than those found in E. coli or Bacillus stearothermophilus. Alternatively, this species could have genes encoding more Vsr endonucleases which are too divergent structurally to be identified by bioinformatic methods. Our results indicate that N. gonorrhoeae FA1090 expresses two Vsr endonucleases. The first, V.NgoAXIII, recognizes T:G mismatches in all nucleotide contexts of known gonococcal MTases tested, and the second, V.NgoAXIV, recognizes only a subset. Moreover, comparison of their amino acid sequences has shown that these Vsr endonucleases differ in a region responsible for the recognition and cleavage of T:G mismatches, suggesting the existence of two different families of enzymes.     

Eukaryotic endonuclease VIII-Like proteins: New components of the base excision DNA repair system

Base excision DNA repair is necessary for removal of damaged nucleobases from the genome and their replacement with normal nucleobases. Base excision repair is initiated by DNA glycosylases, the enzymes that cleave the N-glycosidic bonds of damaged deoxynucleotides. Until recently, only eight DNA glycosylases with different substrate specificity were known in human cells. In 2002, three new human DNA glycosylases (NEIL1, NEIL2, and NEIL3) were discovered, all homologous to endonuclease VIII, a bacterial protein, which also participates in DNA repair. The role of these enzymes remains mostly unknown. In this review we discuss recent data on the substrate specificity of the NEIL enzymes, their catalytic mechanism, structure, interactions with other components of DNA repair system, and possible biological role in preventing diseases associated with DNA damage.     

Excision repair of DNA base damage

Exposure of cells to exogenous physical and chemical agents can result in damage to the DNA bases. DNA damage can lead to mutation, malignant transformation and cell death and may possibly be involved in cellular aging. Structurally related base modifications are expected to have similar biological effects regardless of the agent responsible for their formation. The biological effects may be a consequence of the local distortion of the DNA conformation by the lesion rather than of the chemical properties of the modified base $\text{per se}$. It may be useful, therefore, to classify DNA base damage according to their effect on DNA conformation. The elucidation of the structures of the DNA lesions produced $\text{in situ}$ in the living cell represents a prerequisite for the correlation of specific lesions with the biological effects and for the study of the cellular repair processes.Excision repair represents an ubiquitous mechanism in cells for the removal of damaged residues from the DNA. The most specific first step in excision repair is the recognition of the damage by an endonuclease followed by incision of the damaged DNA strand in the proximity of the damage. Several “repair endonucleases” have been characterized from bacteria while the search for the corresponding mammalian enzymes is only beginning. The second, probably less specific step, is the exonucleolytic degradation of the damaged portion of the DNA leading to the removal of the damaged residue. In $\text{E. coli}$ the removal of both cyclobutane-type photodimers and γ-ray products of the 5,6-dihydroxy-dihydrothymine type is accomplished by the 5′→3′ exonuclease associated with polymerase I. All three $\text{E. coli}$ polymerases appear to participate in the rebuilding of the degraded portion of the DNA. Studies on the corresponding enzymes in mammalian cells have been initiated. The last step of exicison repair involves the sealing of a phosphodiester bond of the DNA backbone and is accomplished by the enzyme polynucleotide ligase in bacterial and mammalian cells.     

Abasic site recognition by two apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease families in DNA base excision repair: the 3' ends justify the means

DNA damage occurs unceasingly in all cells. Spontaneous DNA base loss, as well as the removal of damaged DNA bases by specific enzymes targeted to distinct base lesions, creates non-coding and lethal apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites. AP sites are the central intermediate in DNA base excision repair (BER) and must be processed by 5' AP endonucleases. These pivotal enzymes detect, recognize, and cleave the DNA phosphodiester backbone 5' of, AP sites to create a free 3'-OH end for DNA polymerase repair synthesis. In humans, AP sites are processed by APE1, whereas in yeast the primary AP endonuclease is termed APN1, and these enzymes are the major constitutively expressed AP endonucleases in these organisms and are homologous to the Escherichia coli enzymes Exonuclease III (Exo III) and Endonuclease IV (Endo IV), respectively. These enzymes represent both of the conserved 5' AP endonuclease enzyme families that exist in biology. Crystal structures of APE1 and Endo IV, both bound to AP site-containing DNA reveal how abasic sites are recognized and the DNA phosphodiester backbone cleaved by these two structurally unrelated enzymes with distinct chemical mechanisms. Both enzymes orient the AP-DNA via positively charged complementary surfaces and insert loops into the DNA base stack, bending and kinking the DNA to promote flipping of the AP site into a sequestered enzyme pocket that excludes undamaged nucleotides. Each enzyme-DNA complex exhibits distinctly different DNA conformations, which may impact upon the biological functions of each enzyme within BER signal-transduction pathways.     

UvrABC incision of N-methylmitomycin A-DNA monoadducts and cross-links

The Escherichia coli UvrABC endonuclease is a multisubunit enzyme that initiates the repair of a wide variety of DNA lesions in vivo by making dual incisions on a damaged strand at the eighth or ninth phosphodiester bond 5' and the fourth or fifth phosphodiester bond 3' to the modified base. It has been hypothesized that UvrABC is able to recognize a broad spectrum of lesions because it does not recognize the lesion per se but rather gross helical distortions that the lesion induces in the DNA. Several lesions have recently been studied which are thermal stabilizing and are not believed to distort the DNA grossly, including the CC-1065-N-3-adenine and anthramycin-N-2-guanine adducts. We have studied the activity of UvrABC in vitro on another thermal stabilizing and nondistortive adduct, N-methylmitomycin A (NMA), a bifunctional DNA-alkylating agent that reacts with guanine on the side facing the minor groove, yielding either monoadducts or interstrand cross-links. NMA adducts increase the thermal stability of DNA, and theoretical calculations indicate that NMA adducts do not grossly distort the DNA helix. Our results show that UvrABC makes incisions at the eighth phosphodiester bond 5' and the fifth phosphodiester bond 3' to an NMA monoadduct, consistent with the incision pattern observed for the majority of other lesions that are also recognized by UvrABC. DNA containing a site-specific NMA cross-link was also recognized and incised by UvrABC. The rate of incision of NMA cross-linked DNA was about 200-fold higher in supercoiled molecules than in relaxed molecules, whereas the rate of incision of DNA containing NMA monoadducts was stimulated approximately 2-fold by supercoiling. The signal for UvrABC recognition and incision of damaged DNA is discussed in relation to the ability of UvrABC to incise NMA adducts as well as other nondistortive lesions.