Modulation of granulomatous hypersensitivity. I. Characterization of T lymphocytes involved in the adoptive suppression of granuloma formation in Schistosoma mansoni-infected mice.

The cellular basis of the spontaneous modulation of the granulomatous response to schistosome eggs was analyzed in mice infected with Schistosoma mansoni. Spleen cells of 20 or 32 week-infected mice undergoing modulation, when transferred to 6 week-infected recipients, suppressed the maximal granulomatous response at 8 weeks. Suppression of both naturally forming asynchronous liver and synchronously induced lung lesions was achieved. Specificity of this effect was demonstrated by the suppression of egg granulomas but not antigen-coated bead granulomas developing simultaneously in the lungs of cell recipients. Further characterization showed that suppression was abrogated by pretreating transferred cells with either anti-Thy 1.2 or anti-Iak alloantisera and C. Transfer of macrophage-depleted or fractionated T and B spleen cells confirmed that T cells alone transferred suppression. Moreover, an Ia antigen-bearing (Ia+) subpopulation of T cells was required in the transferred suppression. Moreover, an Ia antigen-bearing (Ia+) subpopulation of T cells was required in the transferred population. An examination of T cells obtained from isolated, dispersed lung granulomas from control and adoptively suppressed mice revealed an increased proportion of Ia+ cells in the latter. It is suggested that Ia+ T cells may be involved in the local modulation of the granulomatous response.     

Role of dextran-specific suppressor T cells in the regulation of the immune response by a reactive form of dextran

Reactive forms of antigens or haptens have been shown to induce a state of hyporesponsiveness mediated in part by suppressor T cells. Injection of Balb/c x C57B16 F1 (CB6F1) mice with a reactive form of dextran B1355S (periodate oxidized dextran, dex-P) specifically reduced responses to dextran immunization within 1 day after dex-P treatment. This unresponsiveness lasted at least 23 days and required a reactive form of dextran for its induction since native dextran and oxidized/reduced dextran failed to induce tolerance. Furthermore, hyporesponsiveness could be induced by iv injection of dextran-coupled cells, especially peripheral blood lymphocytes, a result which suggests that in vivo coupling to cellular antigens is involved in dex-P-induced hyporesponsiveness. Suppression of the anti-dextran response could be transferred to normal mice with T-cell-enriched spleen cell populations from dex-P-injected mice. Interestingly, the presence of B cells in the transferred cell preparations interfered with detection of suppression. Both Lyt 1+2- and Lyt 1-2+ cells were involved in the dex-P-induced suppression; indeed, mixtures of these types of T cells led to the most profound degree of suppression. The suppressive activity of spleen cells from dex-P-injected mice could be removed by passage over dextran-coated plates. Moreover, cells eluted from the plates specifically suppressed anti-dextran responses of normal mice, indicating that dex-P injection induces a population of antigen-binding suppressor cells. This system will allow the study of the suppressor-T-cell receptors in a well-defined idiotypic system.     

Asialo-GM1+ natural killer cells directly suppress antibody-producing B cells

Natural killer (NK) cells were tested for their ability to suppress antigen-induced antibody responses in vitro. Asialo-GM1+ (ASGM1+) cells were prepared from nylon-wool-nonadherent spleen cells obtained from normal mice. After depletion of Ig+, L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ cells, the ASGM1+-enriched cell population had high NK activity which was abrogated by treatment with anti-ASGM1 and C'. This NK-enriched ASGM1+ cell fraction significantly suppressed the generation of antibody-producing cells when added to in vitro immunization cultures of primed spleen cells. Treatment of the NK-enriched cell population with anti-ASGM1 and C' abrogated the ability of these cells to suppress antibody responses. In vitro antibody production by purified B cells was also suppressed in the presence of the NK-enriched cell population, although the kinetics of the suppression differed from that observed with unfractionated spleen cells. In addition, the NK-enriched cell population suppressed the proliferation of the B cell line WEHI-279.1. Suppression of WEHI-279.1 cells was abrogated when the NK-enriched cell population was treated with anti-ASGM1 and C'. These results suggest that normal NK cells suppress the generation of antibody-producing B cells and that this occurs, at least in part, through a direct regulation of the B cell.     

Regulation of granulomatous inflammation in murine schistosomiasis. IV. Antigen-induced suppressor T cells down-regulate proliferation and IL-2 production

In murine schistosomiasis mansoni the cell-mediated immune response to the deposited eggs is mediated by CD4+ delayed-type hypersensitivity effector T (TDH) cells that produce vigorous granulomatous responses in the liver and intestines of acutely infected animals. The response is significantly down-modulated in chronically infected mice by Ag-specific Ts cells. The present study was undertaken to establish an in vitro model by which TDH-Ts cell interactions could be analyzed. To this end, Ts cells were induced in vitro by preculture of chronic or acute infection spleen cells with soluble egg Ag (SEA) for 48 h. The induced cells suppressed the SEA-specific proliferation of acute infection spleen cells by 80 to 95%. The induced suppressor cells were Ag specific in both induction and elicitation of function, and were not cytotoxic to the acute infection splenic target cells. Suppression by the induced cells was manifested within the first 24 h of the SEA-induced response as IL-2 produced by acute infection spleen cells was suppressed 62%. Phenotypic analysis by flow cytometry of the induced suppressor cells showed that CD8+ cells from acute infection spleens and CD4+ and CD8+ cells from chronic infection spleens were effector Ts cells. Taken together, CD4+ and CD8+ SEA-specific Ts cells can be induced in vitro to effectively suppress the SEA-specific lymphoproliferation and IL-2 production of acute infection spleen cells. Establishment of this in vitro model will allow us to further analyze the mechanisms of Ts cell-mediated suppression of TDH cells.     

Suppression of delayed-type hypersensitivity to third party "bystander" alloantigens by antigen-specific suppressor T cells

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) against alloantigens can be induced by sc immunization with allogeneic cells. The induction of DTH can be suppressed by iv preimmunization of the mice with similar allogeneic spleen cells, provided the cells are irradiated before injection. This suppression is mediated by T cells. The suppressor activity can be induced not only by H-2-and non-H-2-coded antigens, but also by H-2 subregion-coded antigens. Suppression induced by K, I, or D subregion-coded antigens is specific for that particular subregion as well as for its haplotype. I-J-coded alloantigens were found to not be necessary for the induction of antigen-specific suppressor T cells. After restimulation of suppressor T cells by the "specific" alloantigens, the DTH to simultaneously administered third-party alloantigens becomes suppressed as well. This nonspecific suppression of DTH to third party "bystander" alloantigens also occurs when the specific and the third-party antigens are presented on separate cells, provided that both cell types are administered together at the same site. The simultaneous presentation of both sets of alloantigens during the induction phase of DTH only is sufficient to prevent the normal development of DTH to the third-party antigens.     

Ontogeny of Nk-1+ natural killer cells. I. Promotion of Nk-1+ cells in fetal, baby, and old mice

Using anti-Nk-1.1 serum, the alloantiserum specific for murine natural killer (NK) cells, we followed the ontogenetic development of Nk-1+ cells in fetal thymus, liver, and spleen. A transient population of Nk-1+ cells in fetal thymus was observed on day 14 but not on day 16 of gestation. On day 16 of gestation, Nk-1+ cells were detected only in liver and spleen. The proportion of Nk-1+ cells in spleen remained high (20 to 30%) at birth and persisted until 2 to 3 wk old. The Nk-1+ cells in "baby" (1 to 2 wk old) spleen bound to YAC cells but failed to lyse them in 51Cr-release assay. Upon induction with interferon (IF), the proportion of Nk-1+ cells increased, but the lytic activity remained low, suggesting that the "baby" NK-1+ cells are immature in lytic function. In old mice (12 to 14 mo), Nk-1+ cells were also detectable, even though NK activities were lower compared with those of the young adult (6 to 8 wk old) mice. The Nk-1+ cells of old mice were readily induced by IF to exhibit activities, and the induced NK cells were Nk-1+. We have thus established Nk-1.1 antigen as an early hemopoietic differentiation antigen. Splenic Nk-1- cells could be induce by IF to become NK-1+ cells, which could be inactive or active in NK assays, dependent on the age of the mice.     

Generation of suppressor T cells after local immunization with histocompatibility antigens

Subcutaneous (sc) hind-foot immunization (HFI) of mice with allogeneic spleen cells can induce a state of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) as well as a state of suppression of DTH. This paper deals with the suppression induced by HFI. The state of suppression could be adoptively transferred by spleen cells and lymph node cells between Days 3 and 7 after HFI only. However, in the hind-foot-immunized mice the state of suppression lasted at least 25 days. The suppressor cells expressed the Thy-1+, Lyt-1-2+ phenotype and suppressed DTH antigen-specifically. The suppressor cells, however, also suppressed DTH responses to unrelated third-party alloantigens, provided the latter were administered during the induction of DTH together with the same alloantigens that were used for HFI. The HFI-induced T-suppressor cells suppressed the induction phase of DTH (i.e., the proliferative activity of the draining lymph node cells after secondary sc immunization), but not the expression phase of DTH (i.e., the activity of previously activated DTH effector T cells). H-2D compatibility between the donors of the HFI-induced T-suppressor cells and the recipients was required for the adoptive transfer of suppression. The differences in effect of local immunization versus systemic immunization on the induction and functional activity of T-suppressor cells are discussed.     

Effects of environmental temperature on the population of T-cell subsets, the blastogenic responses of lymphocytes in blood and spleen and splenic NK cell activity in mice

The population of T-cell subsets, the blastogenic responses of lymphocytes in blood and spleen and splenic NK cell activity were examined in mice transferred from 22 degrees C to 12 degrees C or 32 degrees C environments. The percentage of Thy-1.2 positive cells and Lyt-1.2 positive cells in the spleen decreased after the transfer. However the percentage of Lyt-2.2 positive cells in the spleen was not affected. Thy-1.2 and Lyt-1.2 positive cells in the blood also decreased. The percentage of Lyt-2.2 positive cells in the blood was not affected in mice exposed to 12 degrees C. However, Lyt-2.2 positive cells in the blood decreased on day 1 but increased on day 3 in mice exposed to 32 degrees C. Blastogenic responses of spleen lymphocytes to concanavalin A (Con A) and pokeweed mitogen (PWM) were suppressed in transferred mice, but responses to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and phytohemagglutinin-P (PHA-P) were not affected in any group. Blastogenic responses of blood lymphocytes to Con A, PHA-P, and PWM tended to be weaker in transferred mice than in mice kept in the 22 degrees C environment. In particular the response to PWM in mice exposed to 12 degrees C was less than 8% of that in the 22 degrees C mice. Splenic NK cell activity decreased in transferred mice, but was not suppressed as much as in mice administered 5mg of cortisone acetate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Effects of adriamycin on the activity of mouse natural killer cells

Adriamycin, a widely employed anti-neoplastic agent, was found to have either inhibitory or stimulatory effects on NK activity, depending on the site examined. A single i.p. administration of ADM resulted in a rapid increase of cytolytic activity by PEC of various mouse strains. The effector cells appeared to be NK cells, being nonadherent and nonphagocytic; they expressed low amounts of Thy 1.2 antigen and had the same pattern of specificity as splenic NK cells. In contrast to the stimulatory effects of NK activity of PEC, ADM caused a transient dose-dependent depression of NK activity in the spleen, with a peak reduction at day 3 and recovery within a few days thereafter. The depressed NK activity could be reversed by removal of adherent cells by passage through a nylon column. Moreover, ADM induced cytostatic activity against tumor cells by macrophages, suggesting that activated macrophages may be responsible for suppression of splenic NK activity. The possible modulation of the levels of NK activity by ADM-induced macrophages was supported by mixture experiments, in which plastic adherent spleen cells from ADM-treated mice, but not from normal mice, inhibited the NK activity of normal spleen cells.     

Mechanisms of suppressed cell-mediated immunity and impaired antigen-induced interleukin 2 production in granuloma-bearing mice

Pulmonary granulomas were induced in BALB/c mice immunized with methylated bovine serum albumin in complete Freund's adjuvant by the intratracheal injection of plain agarose beads or beads conjugated to specific antigen. Large hypersensitivity granulomas developed around antigen-coupled beads in immunized animals. Smaller but still prominent granulomatous reactions developed around plain beads in immunized mice. In nonimmunized animals, both plain and antigen conjugated beads produced very small granulomas. Granuloma formation in sensitized animals was associated with suppressed delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions induced by the footpad injection of specific and nonspecific antigens. Lymph node cells from sensitized granuloma-bearing mice with cutaneous anergy showed suppressed specific and nonspecific antigen-induced proliferative responses in vitro. These cells also showed suppressed interleukin 2 production in response to specific antigen. Although no soluble suppressive factor was detected in granuloma extracts, suppressor cells were found in lymph nodes of granuloma-bearing mice, which could inhibit antigen-induced production of interleukin 2 by lymph node cells from immunized mice. Antigen-specific immunoglobulin G antibody production was not suppressed in immunized granuloma-bearing mice. Previous studies from our laboratory have demonstrated migration inhibition factor and interleukin 1 activities in aqueous extracts prepared from granuloma-bearing lungs of immunized mice. These results and the findings reported here indicate that granuloma formation and the associated anergy observed in this system are primarily expressions of cell-mediated immunity; selective suppression of in vivo and in vitro expressions of cell-mediated immunity in granuloma-bearing mice may be due to impaired antigen-induced interleukin 2 production; and such impairment is caused by suppressor cells.     

Subpopulations of splenic T and B lymphocytes producing and regulating leukocyte adherence inhibition factor

Picryl chloride induces contact hypersensitivity in mice, accompanied by spleen cell sensitization that is demonstrable in vitro by specific antigen-induced formation of leukocyte adherence inhibition factor (LAIF). This cellular activity was detected only up to 7 days after sensitization; thereafter the spleen cells appeared to be unreactive with the antigen. The cells were still normally reactive with the mitogen concanavalin A. Antigen reactivity of such “late” cells was restored by passage through a glass-bead column (provided resulting nonadherent cells were reconstituted with normal macrophages), and the restored reactivity was again suppressed by the eluted glass-bead-adherent cells. Suppression was antigen specific. Separation of T and B lymphocytes by affinity chromatography, after glass-bead treatment of sensitized spleen cells, showed that two subpopulations of B cells—those responsible for producing LAIF as well as those suppressing LAIF production by T cells—were glassbead adherent. This was extended by showing directly with anti-Thy-1.2 serum that B cells producing LAIF and suppressor T cells were glass adherent. Thus two suppressive cell populations, and the B cell producing LAIF, were glass adherent while the T-cell LAIF producer was not. Tests for adoptive transfer of cutaneous hypersensitivity in vivo demonstrated the relevance of many of the above observations to conditions in the whole animal. “Late” spleen cells from sensitized mice could not transfer hypersensitivity but this property was restored by glass-bead passage. The eluted adherent cells suppressed transfer. Both adoptive transfer and its suppression were antigen specific.     

Regulatory mechanism of delayed-type hypersensitivity in mice. I. Properties of memory cpells and suppressor cells for delayed-type hypersensitivity against ovalbumin.

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response in mice induced by sc injection of alum-absorbed ovalbumin (OA) was accelerated and enhanced by priming sc with a low dose of urea-denatured ovalbumin (UD-OA), 2 or more days earlier, whereas it was suppressed by priming sc with a high dose of UD-OA, 0 or more days earlier. The ability in primed mice to accelerate or suppress the DTH response could be transferred antigen specifically into cyclophosphamide (CY)-pretreated recipients or normal recipients by spleen cells from primed mice, but not by the T-cell-depleted spleen cells. Furthermore, the ability of spleen cells to transfer the acceleration or the suppression appeared transiently around 7 or 4 days after priming, although the acceleration or the suppression in donor mice persisted for a much longer time. Pretreatment with CY abolished the suppression of DTH response in high dose-primed mice and resulted in the acceleration of DTH response. These results suggest that the activity of DTH-related memory T cells which accelerate and enhance the response can be inhibited by suppressor T cells for the DTH response.     

The evolution of immunosuppressive cell populations in experimental mycobacterial infection.

Immunosuppressor activity of considerable potency and complexity was generated during the course of chronic, progressive infection of C3H/Anf mice by Mycobacterium lepraemurium. From the 5th through 10th week after inoculation, spleen cells from infected mice mildly but reproducibly suppressed the direct plaque-forming cell response of normal spleen cell cultures to sheep erythrocytes. Suppression at this stage of infection was mediated by cells with macrophage-like characteristics. A marked increase in splenic suppressor activity at 10 to 11 weeks was associated with the appearance of a second suppressor cell subpopulation composed of T lymphocytes. The appearance of these cells was closely related in time to the onset of rapid splenic enlargement and a loss of cutaneous delayed type hypersensitivity to antigens of M. lepraemurium in mice at 10 to 11 weeks of infection. Suppressor cells were not present in peripheral lymph nodes until terminal infection at 22 to 25 weeks. Suppressor spleen cells depressed the T-dependent antibody response most severely, but there was also a direct effect upon B cells as shown by moderate suppression of responses to TNP-LPS and DNP-Ficoll. Spleen cells from 14-week-infected mice generated a soluble suppressor factor(s) that induces depression of moderate severity, however, the immunosuppression by intact cells was far greater.     

Modulation of F1 cytotoxic potentials by GvHR. Host- and donor-derived cytotoxic lymphocytes arise in the unirradiated F1 host spleens under the condition of GvHR-associated immunosuppression

As an approach to dissect complex cellular events that lead to GvHR-associated immune disorders, we followed cytotoxic activities, including NK cytotoxicity, in the spleens of unirradiated F1 hosts undergoing GvHR induced by parental spleen cells. Spleen cells of (B10 X DBA/2)F1 or (B10 X AKR/J)F1 hosts undergoing GvHR induced by parental B10 spleen cells displayed a prompt and marked increase in NK cell activity within 36 hr, and the heightened activity lasted until day 8. The activity then declined abruptly and disappeared on day 12 of GvHR. Inversely, donor B10-derived CTL specifically directed to the opposite parental alloantigens of the F1 hosts emerged in these F1 host spleens on day 8, and the CTL activity reached a peak on day 12 when the host NK cell activity disappeared. During the period that the donor-derived anti-host CTL were present, these F1 host spleen cells lost not only NK cell activity but also the ability to mount in vitro CTL responses. In contrast, the respective F1 strain mice undergoing GvHR induced by the parental DBA/2 or AKR/J spleen cells showed only transient but marked increases in NK cell activity during the initial 36 hr, and then the activity decreased gradually to return to the normal level on day 10. In such GvHR F1 host spleens, donor-derived CTL could never be detected, and the spleen cells showed normal in vitro CTL responsiveness during the entire observation period of 16 days. These results are discussed from the viewpoint of genetically defined cellular events that lead to the GvHR-associated immune disorders.     

BCG-induced macrophage suppression in mice: Suppression of specific and nonspecific antibody-medicated and cellular immunologic responses

The intravenous injection of killed BCG in an oil-in-saline emulsion (BCG-E) results in the development of intense chronic granulomatous inflammation in the lungs and spleen of C57B1/6 (B6) but not CBA mice. B6 mice injected intravenously with BCG-E exhibited marked suppression of antibody responsiveness and delayed hypersensitivity to sheep erythrocytes, as well as proliferation in response to PPD. In contrast, CBA mice similarly treated with BCG-E were not suppressed in any of these reactivities. The spleen is an important organ in this phenomenon since suppression was reversed by splenectomy and could be transferred to normal recipients with spleen cells from BCG-treated mice. Spleen cells responsible for suppression were adherent to plastic petri plates, removed with carbonyl iron, and were not eliminated with either anti-Thy-1 or anti-immunoglobulin serum + C. This study indicates that macrophages from BCG-inflamed spleen are capable of potent suppression of both antibody- and cellular-mediated immunologic reactivity.     

Contribution of the antioxidative property of astaxanthin to its protective effect on the promotion of cancer metastasis in mice treated with restraint stress

We investigated the effects of astaxanthin on the antitumor effector activity of natural killer (NK) cells suppressed by stress in mice in order to define the immunological significance of astaxanthin (ASX) when combined with restraint stress treatment. When the mice were treated with restraint stress alone, the total number of spleen cells, and the level NK cell activity per spleen were reduced to a nadir on day 3. The stress also caused a significant increase in the lipid peroxidation of liver tissue. ASX (100 mg/kg/day, p.o., 4 days) improved the immunological dysfunction induced by restraint stress. On the other hand, metastatic nodules were observed in the livers of syngenic DBA/2 mice on day 12 after inoculation of P815 mastocytoma cells. Hepatic metastasis was promoted further by restraint stress when applied on day 3 before the inoculation of P815. Daily oral administration of ASX (1 mg/kg/day, p.o., 14 days) markedly attenuated the promotion of hepatic metastasis induced by restraint stress. These results suggested that astaxanthin improves antitumor immune responses by inhibiting of lipid peroxidation induced by stress.     

Suppression of B-cell differentiation by natural killer (asialo GM1+) cells in mice

Mice were injected intravenously with rabbit antiserum to ganglio-n-tetraosylceramide (asialo GM1, ASGM1), a neutral glycosphingolipid present at high quantities on the surface of natural killer (NK) cells. Spleen cells prepared from the mice were then examined for NK activity against YAC-1 targets, for phagocytic cells and by flow cytometric analysis for Thy1, Lyt1, Lyt2, ASGM1 and surface Ig (SIg) phenotypes. Administration of anti-ASGM1 in mice resulted in a complete depletion of NK activity and ASGM+1 cells in the spleen, but no changes in the proportions of Thy1+ cells and their Lyt1+ and Lyt2+ subsets and phagocytic cells. Corresponding to this selective depletion of ASGM+1 cells and NK activity, the spleen cells showed an increased number of SIg+ B cells and augmented mitogenic responses to B-cell but not T-cell mitogens. These NK-depleted spleen cells also showed production of pokeweek mitogen (PWM)-driven plaque-forming cells (PFC) to much higher levels than those of control spleens. In the spleens of mice treated with varying concentrations of anti-ASGM+1, a good correlation was found between the decreased NK activity and the enhanced PFC response. To directly test the possible suppressor activity of NK cells on PWM-induced PFC response, NK (ASGM+1) cells were highly purified from the spleen by a combination of Percoll gradients and cytolysis of T cells by monoclonal antibodies followed by indirect panning. When added to NK-depleted spleen cells, they suppressed the augmented PFC response of NK-depleted spleen cells, depending on the number of cells added. These results suggest that NK (ASGM+1) cells in mice exhibit a suppressor property on B cells, which are undergoing spontaneous or mitogen-induced differentiation.     

In vivo bidirectional regulation of mouse natural killer (NK) cell cytotoxic activities by Leu-enkephalin: reversibility by naloxone.

Intraperitoneal injection of Leu-enkephalin (LENK, 10 or 7.5 mg/kg) induced bidirectional modulation of natural cytotoxic activities in spleens of CBA mice (suppression followed by enhancement). NK-cytotoxic activity was more affected than the ADCC. Early suppression of NK activity could be reversed by 4 x M excess of naloxone injected 20 min before LENK, suggesting that the suppression was mediated by opioid receptors. Subsequent increase of NK activity could not be abrogated by naloxone, at least not completely. Naloxone itself decreased NK activity 12 hours after treatment, but enhanced ADCC at 24 and 48 hours. This increase was abrogated by LENK. In addition to functional alterations, LENK also induced phenotypic changes of spleen cells, i.e. a decrease in the percentage of asialo-GM-1+ cells 24 hours posttreatment. There was no correlation between LENK-induced alterations of cytotoxic function and the percentage of cells with NK phenotype (GM-1+). Thus, LENK modulates cytolytic functions and the phenotype of NK cells in vivo in a complex way, which besides opioid mechanisms may also include non-opioid ones.     

Suppressive effects of monocytic cells and transforming growth factor-beta on natural killer cell differentiation in autoimmune viable motheaten mutant mice.

Viable motheaten (mev) mice are homozygous for a recessive single gene mutation at chromosome 6. These mice develop numerous inflammatory and arthritic syndromes and exhibit abnormal B cell functions as well as lower T and NK cell activity. In this study, the differentiation of NK cells in mev mice was examined to elucidate the underlying basis for decreased NK activity. Although NK cells appear to be present in mev mice, their activity was demonstrable only when the spleen cells were enriched by nylon wool passage. Similarly bone marrow cells from these mice could be shown to contain precursors of NK cells when they were passed over nylon wool and transplanted into irradiated recipients. The adherent cells from both the spleen and bone marrow of mev mice suppressed the differentiation of NK cells from normal splenic populations. These suppressive adherent cells were F4/80(+), AsGm-1(+), Qa-5(+), and NK-1.1(+). They were not cytolytic when cultured in IL-2. Antibodies to a number of cytokines, such as IFN-alpha, -beta, and gamma, or TNF-alpha, could not reverse the suppressive effect of the adherent cells. Addition of anti-TGF-beta antibody could, however, overcome the suppression, suggesting that TGF-beta was partly responsible for the defective NK differentiation in the mev mice.