Rapid, Direct Fluorescent-Antibody Method for the Detection of Salmonellae in Food and Feeds

An improved immunofluorescent-antibody (FA) method for the detection of salmonellae in foods and feeds was developed. This FA method combines a rapid cultural phase and a serological phase that allow for propagation of salmonellae in a minimum time, employing the industrial 8-hr work day as a guide. Two hundred fifty naturally contaminated human food and animal feed samples, representing 647 trials, were tested by the FA method. A total of 18 different food and feed samples was used. The method used by the Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC) for the detection of salmonellae was the control method. The percent agreement when comparing the FA slide method to the AOAC method ranged from 87.1 to 95.3%, depending upon the conjugated antisera used in comparative studies.     

Isolation of Salmonellae From Food Samples: VI. Comparison of Methods for the Isolation of Salmonella From Egg Products

The recovery of salmonellae from egg products was studied, by use of three different enrichment procedures: (i) selenite broth, (ii) selenite broth containing 10% sterile feces, and (iii) the lactose pre-enrichment procedure. Brilliant Green Agar was used throughout as the recovery medium. Although the lactose pre-enrichment methodology promoted Salmonella recovery from samples containing small numbers of dormant organisms, the efficiency of this enrichment method is adversely affected by unfavorable coliform-Salmonella ratios. Under such conditions, early subculture of lactose broth into selenite broth is indicated. Selenite broth containing 10% sterile feces was more efficient than the lactose pre-enrichment methodology in promoting the growth of “dormant” salmonellae. Albumen adversely affected recovery of salmonellae from selenite broth, whereas whole egg and egg yolk enhanced Salmonella recovery from this medium. The selenite-feces medium presents a solution to the major problems encountered in the detection of salmonellae in egg products and offers an approach to a single medium in which food-borne salmonellae will manifest themselves with a minimum of laboratory manipulation.     

Detection of Salmonellae in the Environment

The incidence of salmonellae in contrasting environments was compared in this study. Samples collected from or near surface waters in a lush hardwood forest yielded four salmonellae serotypes from six culturally positive samples. A total of 76 samples collected from the top of a granite outcropping over a 3-month period yielded 10 positive samples. Only two salmonellae serotypes were isolated, and one of these was isolated only once. The nature of the sample material had no significant effect on the detection of salmonellae from the two sampling sites. However, the presence or absence of visible moisture in the sample significantly affected the recovery of salmonellae. The results showed that even a harsh environment such as that found on top of Stone Mountain may serve as an ecological niche for the survival and transmission of salmonellae.     

Isolation of Salmonellae from Foods Samples: V. Determination of the Method of Choice for Enumeration of Salmonella

Comparison of three methods by which salmonellae may be isolated and enumerated from dried albumen, direct inoculation of enrichment media, centrifugation of samples, and pre-enrichment in noninhibitory media, reveals pre-enrichment to be the method of choice.

The superiority of pre-enrichment manifests itself in replicate aliquots of the same sample by producing a statistically significant increase in numbers of isolations of salmonellae and in empirical use with various albumen samples by consistently higher values of most probable numbers (MPN).

The primary factor involved in this superiority appears to be the greater ability of small numbers of salmonellae to initiate growth in the nonselective mannitol purple sugar broth than in the inhibitory enrichment media.

The method of analysis recommended entails inoculation of mannitol broth pre-enrichment medium, transfer of 24-hr culture aliquots to tetrathionate broth, and streaking on brilliant green agar for isolation of salmonellae.

     

Agar Concentration in Counting Clostridium Colonies

Decreasing the agar concentration of a counting medium from the usual 1.5% resulted in larger colonies with less interference from gas in Clostridium botulinum 115B and C. sporogenes PA 3679. Optimal agar concentration was 0.65% for C. botulinum with 24-hr incubation and 0.50% for C. sporogenes with 48-hr incubation. Lower concentrations yielded growth too diffuse for counting. Motility was considered the explanation for increased colony size in softer agar. The greater the degree of motility, the greater would be the diffusibility expected, and thus the higher the agar concentration required to insure discrete colonies. For quantitating motility, evaluations were made by use of microscopic examination of liquid cultures and rate of diffusion in a semisolid medium. With both criteria, the degree of motility of C. botulinum 115B clearly exceeded that of C. sporogenes PA 3679. Small-colony variants of C. botulinum in 0.65% agar yielded only small colonies on subculture, with a corresponding decrease in degree of motility of the cells by both criteria. Colony size of the nonmotile C. perfringens ATCC 3624 was unaffected by lowered agar concentrations.     

Rapid detection of salmonellae by immunoassays with titanous hydroxide as the solid phase

Radioimmunometric and enzyme-immunometric assays were developed for the detection of salmonellae in pure and mixed cultures as well as in 59 food samples. The performances of titanous hydroxide suspension and microtiter plates as the solid phase for the immobilization of microorganisms were compared in these immunoassays. Detection of populations of salmonella cells in pure culture, diluted with saline, was 4- to 10-fold more sensitive with the microtiter plates. However, with mixed culture of salmonella and other enterobacterial species, the detection sensitivity with titanous hydroxide was 100- to 160-fold more sensitive than with microtiter plates. Good correlation existed between results of a standard cultural method for the detection of salmonellae in foods and those obtained from radioimmunometric and enzyme-immunometric assays utilizing titanous hydroxide. However, a high incidence of false-positive and false-negative results with food samples occurred with the enzyme-immunometric assay utilizing microtiter plates. The results provided strong evidence for the merits of substituting titanous hydroxide for microtiter plates as the solid phase for the immobilization of salmonellae for their detection by immunoassays. The immunoassays were rapid and enabled the analysis of a large number of selective enrichment cultures of food samples for salmonellae within 8 h.     

Rapid detection of salmonellae by immunoassays with titanous hydroxide as the solid phase.

Radioimmunometric and enzyme-immunometric assays were developed for the detection of salmonellae in pure and mixed cultures as well as in 59 food samples. The performances of titanous hydroxide suspension and microtiter plates as the solid phase for the immobilization of microorganisms were compared in these immunoassays. Detection of populations of salmonella cells in pure culture, diluted with saline, was 4- to 10-fold more sensitive with the microtiter plates. However, with mixed culture of salmonella and other enterobacterial species, the detection sensitivity with titanous hydroxide was 100- to 160-fold more sensitive than with microtiter plates. Good correlation existed between results of a standard cultural method for the detection of salmonellae in foods and those obtained from radioimmunometric and enzyme-immunometric assays utilizing titanous hydroxide. However, a high incidence of false-positive and false-negative results with food samples occurred with the enzyme-immunometric assay utilizing microtiter plates. The results provided strong evidence for the merits of substituting titanous hydroxide for microtiter plates as the solid phase for the immobilization of salmonellae for their detection by immunoassays. The immunoassays were rapid and enabled the analysis of a large number of selective enrichment cultures of food samples for salmonellae within 8 h.     

Salmonellae as an Index of Pollution of Surface Waters

Screening enrichments of surface water specimens by means of a polyvalent fluorescent antibody reagent for the salmonellae yielded approximately 60% more positive specimens than was obtained by cultural procedures. It is not known what fraction of the excess of fluorescent antibody-positive over culturally positive specimens represents staining of non-salmonellae or non-arizonae as opposed to the staining of non-cultivatable organisms of these two genera. Cotton gauze and rayon-polypropylene fiber swabs were equally sensitive for collecting salmonellae from the streams examined. Tetrathionate enrichment incubated at 41.5 C appeared to be superior to selenite-cystine for isolation of salmonellae from surface waters. Twenty-eight serotypes of Salmonella and two serotypes of Arizona were identified in the 121 positive specimens. In water rated moderately polluted, 65% of all specimens tested were positive; in minimally polluted waters, 38% were positive; and in unpolluted streams, 44% were positive.     

Salmonella Contamination in a Poultry-Processing Plant

Bacteriological examination of 1,427 samples from a poultry-processing plant over a 2-year period yielded 202 (14.2%) cultures positive for salmonellae. The results indicate that contamination is reduced by washing procedures within the plant but that recontamination of the carcasses occurred in at least two different stages of processing, i.e., during evisceration and chilling. There was evidence of spread of salmonellae from flock to flock during the serial processing of flocks, but the spread was usually not extensive. The serotypes of salmonellae isolated in this study were similar to those of chicken origin reported from other areas of the country.     

Salmonella detection in foods and feeds in 27 hours by an enzyme immunoassay

A heterogeneous enzyme immunoassay (EIA), which could be completed within 27 h, was developed for the detection of salmonellae in foods. Samples were subjected to the usual non-selective enrichment for 16–18 at 35°C and to a short (6 h) post-enrichment in a moderately selective broth. The EIA was carried out on polystyrene microtitration plates. A pooled polyvalent Salmonella flagellar antiserum and a protein A-alkaline phosphatase conjugate were used. The sensitivity of the enzyme immunoassay compared favorably with that of the conventional cultural technique for detection of Salmonella in 40 naturally contaminated food and feed samples. No sample was positive only by the cultural technique; samples positive only by the enzyme immunoassay were observed for feeds. Some specimens yielded high background values indicating possible interference from food proteins.     

Ambient-temperature primary nonselective enrichment for isolation of Salmonella spp. from an estuarine environment.

A primary, nonselective, ambient-temperature enrichment procedure for isolation of Salmonella spp. is described. The procedure was superior to elevated-temperature selective enrichment for Salmonella when estuarine water samples were examined. Five Chesapeake Bay stations were monitored, over an 8-month period, for the presence of salmonellae. Of 72 water and sediment samples collected, 17 (23.6%) yielded Salmonella spp. Seven serotypes were identified among the isolates. A seasonal pattern was noted for the incidence of the salmonellae. A most probable number procedure, performed by membrane filtration and nonselective enrichment, yielded Salmonella most probable number indices as high as 110 per 100 g of sediment. The results suggest that new methods, such as the one described in this report, are required for isolation of human intestinal pathogens from estuaries and coastal waters.     

Ambient-temperature primary nonselective enrichment for isolation of Salmonella spp. from an estuarine environment.

A primary, nonselective, ambient-temperature enrichment procedure for isolation of Salmonella spp. is described. The procedure was superior to elevated-temperature selective enrichment for Salmonella when estuarine water samples were examined. Five Chesapeake Bay stations were monitored, over an 8-month period, for the presence of salmonellae. Of 72 water and sediment samples collected, 17 (23.6%) yielded Salmonella spp. Seven serotypes were identified among the isolates. A seasonal pattern was noted for the incidence of the salmonellae. A most probable number procedure, performed by membrane filtration and nonselective enrichment, yielded Salmonella most probable number indices as high as 110 per 100 g of sediment. The results suggest that new methods, such as the one described in this report, are required for isolation of human intestinal pathogens from estuaries and coastal waters.     

Rapid Determination of Salmonella in Samples of Egg Noodles, Cake Mixes, and Candies

A glass apparatus system was compared with a standard enrichment broth-selective agar method to test samples of egg noodles, cake mixes, and candy for the presence or absence of salmonellae. The glass apparatus system used fermentation of mannitol, production of H(2)S, or motility, in conjunction with a serological test of flagellar antigens, to detect salmonellae. No salmonellae were detected in 173 samples of food products. Of these samples, 171 were found to be Salmonella-negative after 48 hr with the glass apparatus system. After 72 hr, the standard Salmonella procedure yielded 38 samples which produced Salmonella false-positive results on selective agars. Inoculation of samples with cultures of Salmonella showed that approximately one inoculated cell could be detected after 48 hr of incubation with the glass apparatus. The standard Salmonella test requires a minimum of 72 hr for completion. Compared with the standard Salmonella test, the glass apparatus system is a more rapid and simple system that can be used to determine the presence or absence of Salmonella in these food products.     

Salmonella Survey of Plant Foods Used in and Around the Home

Nine of 100 plant food samples investigated yielded salmonellae. A brilliant green tetrathionate-brilliant green agar combination gave the most salmonellae recoveries.     

Evaluation of a Fluorescent Antibody-Enrichment Serology Combination Procedure for the Detection of Salmonellae in Condiments, Food Products, Food By-Products, and Animal Feeds

The reliability of the enrichment serology (ES), fluorescent antibody (FA), and a combination of the FA and ES procedures for the detection of salmonellae were compared to the Salmonella cultural procedure outlined in the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's Bacteriological Analytical Manual (BAM). A total of 126 subsamples from 22 different products were analyzed. By utilizing the BAM procedure as the reference standard, a total of 66 samples were positive for salmonellae. Within 44 h approximately 65% of the Salmonella-negative samples could be cleared by the FA test. At the end of 50 h 97% of the Salmonella-negative samples could be cleared by the combination FA-ES test. The FA procedure detected all 66 BAM positives but exhibited a high incidence of presumptive positives which were cultural negatives. The ES procedure detected 64 of the 66 BAM positives but exhibited a low incidence of presumptive positives which were cultural negatives. Incorporating positive FA and positive ES results in a combination FA-ES technique revealed that FA-ES positives were statistically equivalent to BAM positives.     

The Fluorescent Antibody Technique for the Detection of Salmonella in Routine Use

S ummary : The direct and indirect fluorescent antibody technique (FAT) were compared with cultural methods for detecting salmonellae in meat products, animal feedingstuffs, poultry carcase swabs, giblets and poultry plant and equipment swabs. Salmonellae were not isolated from meat products and fluorescent cells were not seen on slides prepared by either FAT. The indirect and direct FAT recorded 13% and 9% respectively, false positive results, with samples of animal feedingstuffs, but the direct FAT recorded a single false negative result. Salmonellae were not isolated from poultry carcase swabs but 3% and 4·5% respectively, of false positive results were obtained with the indirect and direct FAT. Salmonellae were isolated from both giblet samples and poultry plant swabs and both gave rise to false negative FAT results. Preliminary studies of the efficacy of the FAT for screening animal faecal material for salmonellae indicated that no single combination of enrichment broth and FAT gives unequivocal results, but the staining of smears from tetrathionate broth by either FAT gives rise to a high percentage of false negative results.     

Modified agar medium for detecting environmental salmonellae by the most-probable-number method.

Salmonellae in the environment remain a potential source of disease. Low numbers of salmonellae have been detected and enumerated from environmental samples by most-probable-number methods which require careful colony selection from a plated agar medium. A modified xylose lysine brilliant green medium was prepared to control the loss of selectivity caused by heating the brilliant green component. Added agar reduced colony spreading. The medium contained 47 g of xylose lysine agar base per liter; the agar content was adjusted to 2%, autoclaved, cooled to 50 degrees C, and then amended just before pouring to include H2S indicator and 7 ppm (7 ml of 1:1,000 brilliant green per liter) of unheated brilliant green dye. H2S-positive salmonellae were easily detected from sewage sludge compost to the exclusion of most other gram-negative bacteria. As a result, fewer non-salmonellae were picked for further most-probable-number analysis, greatly reducing the work load associated with the most-probable-number method. Direct plating was possible for enumerating salmonellae in laboratory composts containing ca. 10(3) or more salmonellae.     

Modified agar medium for detecting environmental salmonellae by the most-probable-number method

Salmonellae in the environment remain a potential source of disease. Low numbers of salmonellae have been detected and enumerated from environmental samples by most-probable-number methods which require careful colony selection from a plated agar medium. A modified xylose lysine brilliant green medium was prepared to control the loss of selectivity caused by heating the brilliant green component. Added agar reduced colony spreading. The medium contained 47 g of xylose lysine agar base per liter; the agar content was adjusted to 2%, autoclaved, cooled to 50 degrees C, and then amended just before pouring to include H2S indicator and 7 ppm (7 ml of 1:1,000 brilliant green per liter) of unheated brilliant green dye. H2S-positive salmonellae were easily detected from sewage sludge compost to the exclusion of most other gram-negative bacteria. As a result, fewer non-salmonellae were picked for further most-probable-number analysis, greatly reducing the work load associated with the most-probable-number method. Direct plating was possible for enumerating salmonellae in laboratory composts containing ca. 10(3) or more salmonellae.     

Comparison of Brilliant Green Agar and Hektoen Enteric Agar Media in the Isolation of Salmonellae from Food Products

Brilliant Green (BG) agar and Hektoen enteric (HE) agar media were compared for their efficiency in isolating salmonellae from various food products. Of the 11,226 food specimens examined, 1,662 (or 14.9%) yielded salmonellae. Of this number, 1,475 (88.7%) were recovered from BG agar and 1,315 (79.1%) were recovered from HE agar media. The results indicate that BG agar is more effective in isolating salmonellae from food products. A smaller subsidiary study showed HE agar to be more selective than BG agar. Four hundred ten specimens yielded 92 nonlactose-fermenting isolants other than salmonellae on BG agar and only 11 such isolants on HE agar.     

Delayed secondary enrichment for the isolation of salmonellae from broiler chickens and their environment.

Specimens collected from six broiler flocks were cultured for salmonellae by three methods. (i) For direct enrichment, the specimen was homogenized, and 1 ml of the homogenate was inoculated into tetrathionate-brillant green broth; (ii) for preenrichment, liquid specimens and homogenates were incubated at 37 degrees C, and on the next day 1 ml was inoculated into tetrathionate-brillant green broth; and (iii) for delayed secondary enrichment, incubated preenrichment cultures were held at room temperature for 7 to 10 days and then subcultured to fresh tetrathionate-brilliant green broth. All tetrathionate-brilliant green broth cultures were incubated at 42 degrees C for 24 to 48 h before plating. Significantly more isolations of salmonellae were obtained by delayed secondary enrichment than by direct enrichment or preenrichment. Salmonellae were isolated from 417 of 2,283 (18.3%) samples of litter, intestinal contents, and feces cultured by all three methods. Of these positive specimens, direct enrichment detected 208 (49.9%), preenrichment detected 282 (67.6%), and delayed secondary enrichment detected 373 (89.4%). Of 896 specimens of swabs and rinse fluids that were cultured by preenrichment and delayed secondary enrichment, 259 (28.9%) yielded salmonellae. Delayed secondary enrichment detected 254 (98.1%) of these, and preenrichment detected 147 (56.8%). A total of 23 serotypes of salmonellae were identified. The greater effectiveness of delayed secondary enrichment for the isolation of salmonellae was not likely due to the selection of certain serotypes or to an increased inhibition of competing flora.