Muscle cell differentiation in ascidian embryos analysed with a tissue-specific monoclonal antibody

Utilizing a muscle-specific monoclonal antibody (Mu-2) as a probe, we analysed developmental mechanisms involved in muscle cell differentiation in ascidian embryos. The antigen recognized by Mu-2 was a single polypeptide with a relative molecular mass of about 220 X 10(3). It first appeared at the early tailbud stage and continued to be expressed until the swimming larva stage. There were distinct and separate puromycin and actinomycin D sensitivity periods during the occurrence of the antigen, suggesting the new synthesis of the polypeptide by developing muscle cells. Embryos that had been permanently arrested with aphidicolin in the early cleavage stages up to the 32-cell stage did not express the antigen. DNA replications may be required for the antigen expression. Embryos that had been arrested with cytochalasin B in the 8-cell and later stages developed the antigen, and the number and position of the arrested blastomeres exhibiting the differentiation marker almost corresponded to those of the B4.1-line muscle lineage. Furthermore, in quarter embryos developed from each blastomere pair isolated from the 8-cell embryo, all the B4.1 as well as a part of b4.2 partial embryos expressed the antigen, while the a4.2 and A4.1 partial embryos did not show the antigen expression. These results may provide further support for the existence of cytoplasmic determinants for muscle cell differentiation in this mosaic egg.     

Expression of an antigen specific for trunk lateral cells in quarter embryos of the ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi

Cell-lineage analysis has demonstrated that a pair of the right and left A7.6 cells of a 64-cell embryo of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi, descendants of A4.1 cells of an 8-cell embryo, give rise to trunk lateral cells (TLCs). In this study, in order to investigate cellular mechanisms involved in the specification of TLCs, we have examined the expression of a TLC-specific antigen in cleavage-arrested embryos and in quarter partial embryos. Although cleavage arrest of embryos by treatment with cytochalasin B at early stages, prior to and including the 16-cell stage, inhibited expression of the TLC-specific antigen, embryos arrested at the 32-cell stage and at later stages developed the antigen. The only blastomeres exhibiting expression of the antigen were the presumptive TLCs, as predicted by cell-lineage assignments. When the developmental potential of quarter embryos that originated from four isolated blastomere-pairs (a4.2, b4.2, A4.1, and B4.1 pairs) of an 8-cell embryo was examined, the A4.1 quarter embryos, which are developmentally fated to give rise to TLCs, rarely showed evidence of expression of the antigen. Expression of the antigen was not observed in a4.2 and b4.2 quarter embryos, which are not associated with the TLC fate. By contrast, expression of the antigen was detected in about a half of the B4.1 quarter embryos which are also not associated with the TLC fate. These results are discussed with reference to the relationship between TLCs and mesenchyme cells.     

Developmental autonomy of muscle fine structure in muscle lineage cells of ascidian embryos

We have observed ultrastructural features of muscle differentiation in the muscle lineage cells of cleavage-arrested whole embryos and partial embryos of ascidians. Whole embryos of Ciona intestinalis and Ascidia ceratodes were cleavage-arrested with cytochalasin B at the 8-cell stage and reared to an age equivalent to several hours after hatching; these embryos formed extensive myofilaments which were often further organized into myofibrils of different sizes and densities in the peripheral cytoplasm of the two muscle lineage blastomeres (B4.1 pair). Developing myofibrils in cleavage-arrested embryos resembled the muscle elements observed in normal hatched larvae, but were less uniformly organized. A similar development of myofilaments and myofibrils occurred in the muscle lineage cells of multicellular partial embryos reared to "hatching" age. These partial embryos resulted from the isolated muscle lineage pair (B4.1) of blastomeres of the 8-cell stage (Ciona and Ascidia), and from a muscle lineage blastomere pair (B5.2) isolated at the 16-cell stage (Ascidia). Muscle lineage cells in the partial embryos were readily identified by the dense aggregates of mitochondria in their cytoplasm. Taken together, these results from the two kinds of partial embryo effectively eliminate inductive interactions with embryonic tissues other than mesodermal as a necessary factor in the onset of self-differentiation in muscle lineage cells. The relative complexity of muscle phenotype expressed in cleavage-arrested and partial embryos attests to an unusually strong developmental autonomy in the ascidian muscle lineages. This autonomy lends further support to the theory that a localized and segregated egg cytoplasmic determinant is responsible for larval muscle development in ascidian embryos.     

Determinative properties of muscle lineages in ascidian embryos

Blastomeres removed from early cleavage stage ascidian embryos and reared to 'maturity' as partial embryos often elaborate tissue-specific features typical of their constituent cell lineages. We used this property to study recent corrections of the ascidian larval muscle lineage and to compare the ways in which different lineages give rise to muscle. Our evaluation of muscle differentiation was based on histochemical localization and quantitative radiometric measurement of a muscle-specific acetylcholinesterase activity, and the development of myofilaments and myofibrils as observed by electron microscopy. Although the posterior-vegetal blastomeres (B4.1 pair) of the 8-cell embryo have long been believed to be the sole precursors of larval muscle, recent studies using horseradish peroxidase to mark cell lineages have shown that small numbers of muscle cells originate from the anterior-vegetal (A4.1) and posterior-animal (b4.2) blastomeres of this stage. Fully differentiated muscle expression in isolated partial embryos of A4.1-derived cells requires an association with cells from other lineages whereas muscle from B4.1 blastomeres develops autonomously. Clear differences also occurred in the time acetylcholinesterase activity was first detected in partial embryos from these two sources. Isolated b4.2 cells failed to show any muscle development even in combination with anterior-animal cells (a4.2) and are presumably even more dependent on normal cell interactions and associations. Others have noted an additional distinction between the different sources of muscle: muscle cells from non-B4.1 lineages occur exclusively in the distal part of the tail, while the B4.1 descendants contribute those cells in the proximal and middle regions. During the course of ascidian larval evolution tail muscle probably had two origins: the primary lineage (B4.1) whose fate was set rigidly at early cleavage stages and secondarily evolved lineages which arose later by recruitment of cells from other tissues resulting in increased tail length. In contrast to the B4.1 lineage, muscle development in the secondary lineages is controlled less rigidly by processes that depend on cell interactions.     

Autonomous muscle cell differentiation in partial ascidian embryos according to the newly verified cell lineages

Recent analysis of cell lineages in ascidian embryos by the intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme has clearly demonstrated that muscle cells are derived not only from the B4.1-cell pair of the eight-cell stage embryo, as has hitherto been believed, but also from both the b4.2- and A4.1-cell pairs (H. Nishida and N. Satoh, 1983, Dev. Biol.99, 382–394). In order to reexamine the developmental autonomy in muscle lineage cells, the B4.1 pair was isolated from the eight-cell stage embryo. The progeny cells of the B4.1 pair, as well as those of the six other blastomeres, were then allowed to develop in isolation into partial embryos. Autonomous muscle cell differentiation not only in partial embryos originating from the B4.1 cells but also in those from the six other blastomeres was substantiated by (a) occurrence of localized histospecific muscle acetylcholinesterase and (b) development of myofibrils. These results support the validity of the recent cell lineage study and confirmed the self-differentiation potency of muscle lineage cells in ascidian embryos according to the newly verified cell lineages.     

Cell lineage and determination of cell fate in ascidian embryos

A detailed cell lineage of ascidian embryos has been available since the turn of the century. This cell lineage was deduced from the segregation of pigmented egg cytoplasmic regions into particular blastomeres during embryogenesis. The invariant nature of the cell lineage, the segregation of specific egg cytoplasmic regions into particular blastomeres, and the autonomous development of most embryonic cells suggests that cell fate is determined primarily by cytoplasmic determinants. Modern studies have provided strong evidence for the existence of cytoplasmic determinants, especially in the primary muscle cells, yet the molecular identity, localization, and mode of action of these factors are still a mystery. Recent revisions of the classic cell lineage and demonstrations of the lack of developmental autonomy in certain embryonic cells suggest that induction may also be an important mechanism for the determination of cell fate in ascidians. There is strong evidence for the induction of neural tissue and indirect evidence for inductive interactions in the development of the secondary muscle cells. In contrast to the long-accepted dogma, specification of cell fate in ascidians appears to be established by a combination of cytoplasmic determinants and inductive cell interactions.     

Cell lineage analysis in ascidian embryos by intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme: I. Up to the eight-cell stage

Cell lineages during development of ascidian embryos were analyzed by injection of horseradish peroxidase as a tracer enzyme into identified cells at the one-, two-, four-, and eight-cell stages of the ascidians, Halocynthia roretzi, Ciona intestinalis, and Ascidia ahodori. Identical results were obtained with eggs of the three different species examined. The first cleavage furrow coincided with the bilateral symmetry plane of the embryo. The second furrow did not always divide the embryo into anterior and posterior halves as each of the anterior and posterior cell pairs gave rise to different tissues according to their destinies, which became more definitive in the cell pairs at the eight-cell stage. Of the blastomeres constituting the eight-cell stage embryo, the a4.2 pair (the anterior animal blastomeres) differentiated into epidermis, brain, and presumably sense organ and palps. Every descendant cell of the b4.2 pair (the posterior animal blastomeres) has been thought to become epidermis; however, the horseradish peroxidase injection probe revealed that the b4.2 pair gave rise to not only epidermis but also muscle cells at the caudal tip region of the developing tailbud-stage embryos. The A4.1 pair (the anterior vegetal blastomeres) developed into endoderm, notochord, brain stem, spinal cord, and also muscle cells next the caudal tip muscle cells. From the B4.1 pair (the posterior vegetal blastomeres) originated muscle cells of the anterior and middle parts of the tail, mesenchyme, endoderm, endodermal strand, and also notochord at the caudal tip region. These results clearly demonstrate that muscle cells are derived not only from the B4.1 pair, as has hitherto been believed, but also from both the b4.2 and A4.1 pairs.     

A Monoclonal Antibody Specific to Embryonic Trunk-Lateral Cells of the Ascidian Halocynthia roretzi Stains Coelomic Cells of Juvenile and Adult Basophilic Blood Cells

In spite of extensive knowledge on the structure and function of ascidian blood cells, little is known about their embryological origin. In the present investigation, the developmental fate of trunk lateral cells (TLCs) was explored using a specific monoclonal antibody. TLCs comprise a group of undefined embryonic cells of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi , which arise from the A7.6 blastomeres of a 64-cell embryo. The antigenicity first appeared at the middle tailbud stage in a pair of TLC-clusters situated lateral to the brain stem of the bilaterally symmetrical embryo. The position and number of stained cells did not change during later embryogenesis until hatching. After hatching, the stained cells were found in the entire trunk region of the swimming larva. After metamorphosis, cells that expressed the antigen were present within the coelom and within the tunic layer of the juvenile. In addition, the antibody stained adult basophilic blood cells. These observations suggest a relationship of this group of embryonic cells with the prospective blood forming mesenchymal cells.     

Maternal information and localized maternal mRNAs in eggs and early embryos of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi

Summary

The mosaic behavior of blastomeres isolated from ascidian embryos has been taken as evidence that localized ooplasmic factors (cytoplasmic determinants) specify tissue precursor cells during embryogenesis. Experiments involving the transfer of egg cytoplasm have revealed the presence and localization of various kinds of cytoplasmic determinants in eggs of Halocynthia roretzi. Three cell fates, epidermis, muscle and endoderm, are fixed by cytoplasmic determinants. The three kinds of tissue determinants move in different directions during ooplasmic segregation. Prior to the onset of the first cleavage the three kinds of determinants reside in egg regions that correspond to the future fate map of the embryo and then they are differentially partitioned into specific blastomeres. In addition to tissue-specific determinants, there is evidence suggesting that ascidian eggs contain localized cytoplasmic factors that are responsible for controlling the cleavage pattern and morphogenetic movements. Transplantation of posterior-vegetal egg cytoplasm to an anterior-vegetal position causes a reversal of the anterior-posterior polarity of the cleavage pattern. Localized cytoplasmic factors in the posterior-vegetal region are involved in the generation of a unique cleavage pattern. When vegetal pole cytoplasm is transplanted to the animal pole or equatorial position of the egg, ectopic gastrulation occurs at the site of transplantation. This finding supports the idea that vegetal pole cytoplasm specifies the site of gastrulation. Recently, we started a cDNA project to analyze maternal mRNAs. An arrayed cDNA library of fertilized eggs of H. roretzi was constructed, and more than 2000 clones have been partially sequenced so far. To estimate the proportion of the maternal mRNAs that are localized in the egg and embryo, 150 randomly selected clones were examined by in situ hybridization. We found eight mRNAs that are localized in the eight-cell embryo, of which three were localized to the myoplasm (a specific region of the egg cytoplasm that is partitioned into muscle-lineage blastomeres) of the egg, and then to the postplasm of cleavage-stage embryos. These results indicate that the proportion of localized messages is much higher than we expected. These localized maternal messages may be involved in the regulation of various developmental processes.     

Lineage segregation and developmental autonomy in expression of functional muscle acetylcholinesterase mRNA in the ascidian embryo

Acetylcholinesterase is a histospecific marker of cell differentiation occurring only in the muscle and mesenchyme tissues of the ascidian embryo. The distribution of functional mRNA coding for this enzyme has been investigated and it is shown here that only cells of muscle and mesenchyme lineages possess such a template. Blastomeres of four cell lineage quadrants were separated microsurgically from eight-cell-stage embryos of Ciona intestinalis and raised in isolation until muscle development was well advanced. Measurement of enzyme activity in the resulting partial embryos revealed that acetylcholinesterase was limited to descendants of one blastomere pair, the B4.1 blastomeres containing muscle and mesenchyme lineages. To study the tissue distribution of acetylcholinesterase mRNA, RNA from partial embryos was translated in Xenopus laevis oocytes. When oocytes were injected with an appropriate template, they synthesized a biologically active acetylcholinesterase that could be selectively immunopurified with an antiserum to the ascidian enzyme. Under the conditions used the quantity of acetylcholinesterase mRNA was directly related to the enzyme activity in immunoprecipitates. Acetylcholinesterase mRNA was found only in B4.1 lineage partial embryos where it occurred in approximately the same amount as in whole embryos of the same age. Since there is a limited period from gastrulation until the middle tail-formation stage when functional acetylcholinesterase mRNA accumulates, the results of our mRNA distribution experiments strongly suggest that the gene for ascidian acetylcholinesterase is active only in muscle and mesenchyme tissues. The histospecific occurrence of this enzyme apparently does not involve selective, cell-specific control of translation.     

Two pathways of maternal RNA localization at the posterior-vegetal cytoplasm in early ascidian embryos

A cDNA library prepared from fertilized eggs of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi was screened for prelocalized mRNAs in the early embryo by means of whole-mount in situ hybridization using a digoxigenin-labeled antisense RNA of each clone. Random mass screening of 150 cDNAs in a fertilized egg yielded six different clones which showed mRNA localization in the posterior-vegetal cytoplasm of the 8-cell embryo. An in situ hybridization study of the detailed spatial distribution of each mRNA in embryos of various stages revealed that there are, in contrast to the identical localization in embryos after the 16-cell stage, two distinct patterns of RNA distribution at earlier stages. One is colocalization with the myoplasm from the prefertilization stage to the 8-cell stage (type I postplasmic RNAs). The other is delayed accumulation of RNA at the posterior-vegetal cytoplasm after fertilization (type II postplasmic RNAs). We found that both types of RNAs associate with the cytoskeleton, but that they show different sensitivities to inhibitors of the cytoskeleton; translocation of the type I RNAs is dependent upon microfilaments during the first phase of ooplasmic segregation and dependent upon microtubules during the second phase of segregation, whereas translocation of the type II RNAs is dependent upon microfilaments throughout ooplasmic segregation. These results show that there are two pathways for the localization of the RNAs at the posterior-vegetal cytoplasm in the 8-cell embryo of the ascidian H. roretzi.     

Distribution of cytoplasmic determinants in unfertilized eggs of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi

 Cytoplasmic determinants that specify the fate of endoderm, muscle and epidermis cells are known to be localized in specific areas of fertilized eggs of ascidians. The presence of such cytoplasmic determinants in unfertilized eggs was demonstrated in previous studies, but no information has yet been proved about their distribution. To investigate the distribution of cytoplasmic determinants in unfertilized eggs, we devised a method for distinguishing the polarity of unfertilized eggs using vital staining and we performed cytoplasmic-transfer experiments by fusing blastomeres and cytoplasmic fragments from various identified regions of unfertilized eggs. Cytoplasmic fragments, that contained cortical and subcortical material, from five different positions along the animal-vegetal axis were prepared, and they were fused with a4.2 (presumptive-epidermis) or A4.1 (non-epidermis) blastomeres. The ectopic development of endoderm, muscle and epidermis cells that was promoted by the transplanted cytoplasm was assessed by examining the expression of alkaline phosphatase (ALP), myosin and epidermis-specific antigen, respectively. Differentiation of endoderm and muscle was observed at higher frequencies as cytoplasmic fragments closer to the vegetal pole were transplanted. Conversely, formation of epidermis was observed at higher frequencies as cytoplasmic fragments closer to the animal pole were transplanted. The results suggest that, in cortical and subcortical regions of unfertilized ascidian eggs, endoderm and muscle determinants are widely distributed along a gradient, with maximum activity at the vegetal pole, whilst epidermis determinants are also distributed along a gradient but with maximum activity at the animal pole. Recieved: 10 June 1996 / Accepted: 12 September 1996     

Expression of epidermis-specific antigens during embryogenesis of the ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi

We have produced two monoclonal antibodies (Epi-1 and Epi-2) which specifically recognize epidermal cells and their derivative, the larval tunic, of developing embryos of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi. The antigens, examined by indirect immunofluorescence staining, first appear at the early tailbud stage and are present until at least the swimming larval stage. There were distinct and separate puromycin and actinomycin D sensitivity periods for each antigen. Aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor of DNA synthesis, prevented the appearance of each antigen when embryos were exposed to the drug continuously from cleavage stages. These results suggest that the antigens are synthesized during embryogenesis by developing epidermal cells and that several rounds of DNA replication are required for the antigen expression. Early cleavage stage embryos, including fertilized but unsegmented eggs, in which cytokinesis had been blocked with cytochalasin B expressed the antigens, and blastomeres exhibiting the antigens were always of the epidermis lineage. In partial embryos produced by four separated blastomere pairs of the 8-cell embryos, the expression of antigens was seen only in those developed from the animal blastomere pairs, which are progenitors of epidermal cells. These observations indicate that differentiation of epidermal cells in ascidian embryos takes place in a typical "mosaic" fashion.     

Introduction and Expression of Recombinant Genes in Ascidian Embryos

In order to examine the expression of exogenous genes introduced into ascidian eggs, two recombinant plasmids pmiwZ and pHrMA4aCAT were microinjected into the cytoplasm of fertilized eggs of Ciona savignyi and Halocynthia roretzi , respectively. The plasmid pmiwZ contains the coding sequence of bacterial β-galactosidase gene ( lac-Z ) fused with animal gene promoters, while pHrMA4aCAT was constructed by fusing about 1.4-kb long 5' flanking region of H. roretzi muscle actin gene HrMA4a with bacterial chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene ( CAT ). Injection of approximately 160 pl of 10 μg/ml pmiwZ DNA into Ciona eggs did not affect the embryogenesis, although introduction of the same volume of 30 μg/ml pmiwZ DNA resulted in abnormal development of injected eggs. When the expression of lac-Z was examined by histochemical detection of the enzyme activity, the expression was evident in the early tailbud embryos and later stage embryos, and larvae, irrespective of linear or circular form of the plasmid. The enzyme activity appeared in various cell-types including epidermis, nervous system, endoderm, mesenchyme, notochord, and muscle. In contrast, when pHrMA4aCAT was introduced into Halocynthia eggs and the appearance of CAT protein was examined later by the anti-CAT antibody, the CAT expression was restricted to muscle cells. These results indicate that the recombinant genes introduced into ascidian eggs could express during embryogenesis and that the 1.4-kb long 5' flanking region of HrMA4a contains regulatory sequences enough for the appropriate spatial and temporal expression of the gene.     

Ascidian embryos as a model system to analyze expression and function of developmental genes

Ascidians have served as an appropriate experimental system in developmental biology for more than a century. The fertilized egg develops quickly into a tadpole larva, which consists of a small number of organs including epidermis, central nervous system with two sensory organs, endoderm and mesenchyme in the trunk, and notochord and muscle in the tail. This configuration of the ascidian tadpole is thought to represent the most simplified and primitive chordate body plan. Their embryogenesis is simple, and lineage of embryonic cells is well documented. The ascidian genome contains a basic set of genes with less redundancy compared to the vertebrate genome. Cloning and characterization of developmental genes indicate that each gene is expressed under discrete spatio-temporal pattern within their lineage. In addition, the use of various molecular techniques in the ascidian embryo system highlights its advantages as a future experimental system to explore the molecular mechanisms underlying the expression and function of developmental genes as well as genetic circuitry responsible for the establishment of the basic chordate body plan. This review is aimed to highlight the recent advances in ascidian embryology.     

Suppression of macho-1-directed muscle fate by FGF and BMP is required for formation of posterior endoderm in ascidian embryos

Specification of germ layers is a crucial event in early embryogenesis. In embryos of the ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi, endoderm cells originate from two distinct lineages in the vegetal hemisphere. Cell dissociation experiments suggest that cell interactions are required for posterior endoderm formation, which has hitherto been thought to be solely regulated by localized egg cytoplasmic factors. Without cell interaction, every descendant of posterior-vegetal blastomeres, including endoderm precursors, assumed muscle fate. Cell interactions are required for suppression of muscle fate and thereby promote endoderm differentiation in the posterior endoderm precursors. The cell interactions take place at the 16- to 32-cell stage. Inhibition of cell signaling by FGF receptor and MEK inhibitor also supported the requirement of cell interactions. Consistently, FGF was a potent signaling molecule, whose signaling is transduced by MEK-MAPK. By contrast, such cell interactions are not required for formation of the anterior endoderm. Our results suggest that another redundant signaling molecule is also involved in the posterior endoderm formation, which is likely to be mediated by BMP. Suppression of the function of macho-1, a muscle determinant in ascidian eggs, by antisense oligonucleotide was enough to allow autonomous endoderm specification. Therefore, the cell interactions induce endoderm formation by suppressing the function of macho-1, which is to promote muscle fate. These findings suggest the presence of novel mechanisms that suppress functions of inappropriately distributed maternal determinants via cell interactions after embryogenesis starts. Such cell interactions would restrict the regions where maternal determinants work, and play a key role in marking precise boundaries between precursor cells of different tissue types.     

Identification of a cytoskeletal protein localized in the myoplasm of ascidian eggs: localization is modified during anural development

The myoplasm of ascidian eggs is a localized cytoskeletal domain that is segregated to presumptive larval tail muscle cells during embryonic development. We have identified a cytoskeletal protein recognized by a vertebrate neurofilament monoclonal antibody (NN18) which is concentrated in the myoplasm in eggs and embryos of a variety of ascidian species. The NN18 antigen is localized in the periphery of unfertilized eggs, segregates with the myoplasm after fertilization, and enters the larval tail muscle cells during embryonic development. Western blots of one-dimensional and two-dimensional gels showed that the major component recognized by NN18 antibody is a 58 x 10(3) Mr protein (p58), which exists in at least three different isoforms. The enrichment of p58 in the Triton X-100-insoluble fraction of eggs and its reticular staining pattern in eggs and embryos suggests that it is a cytoskeletal protein. In subsequent experiments, p58 was used as a marker to determine whether changes in the myoplasm occur in eggs of anural ascidian species, i.e. those exhibiting a life cycle lacking tadpole larvae with differentiated muscle cells. Although p58 was localized in the myoplasm in eggs of four urodele ascidian species that develop into swimming tadpole larvae, this protein was distributed uniformly in eggs of three anural ascidian species. The eggs of two of these anural species contained the actin lamina, another component of the myoplasm, whereas the third anural species lacked the actin lamina. There was no detectible localization of p58 after fertilization or segregation into muscle lineage cells during cleavage of anural eggs. NN18 antigen was uniformly distributed in pre-vitellogenic oocytes and then localized in the perinuclear zone during vitellogenesis of urodele and anural ascidians. Subsequently, NN18 antigen was concentrated in the peripheral cytoplasm of post-vitellogenic oocytes and mature eggs of urodele, but not anural, ascidians. It is concluded that the myoplasm of ascidian eggs contains an intermediate filament-like cytoskeletal network which is missing in anural species that have modified or eliminated the tadpole larva.