Bone marrow cells from allogeneic bone marrow chimeras inhibit the generation of cytotoxic lymphocyte responses against both donor and recipient cells

When added to a mixed lymphocyte culture, bone marrow cells suppress the generation of CTL activity against H-2 Ag shared by the BM cells and the stimulator cells. These cells have been referred to as veto cells and are thought to play a role in maintaining self-tolerance. We analyzed the H-2 specificity of the suppression expressed by the veto cells from H-2 incompatible bone marrow chimeras, because lymphocytes of such chimeras had been shown to be tolerant to both donor and recipient Ag when tested by CTL responses. We found that the bone marrow cells of such chimeras which were featured by non-T and non-B cell characteristics inhibited the generation of CTL directed against either donor or recipient Ag, but not against third-party Ag. These observations suggest that in allogeneic chimeras the veto or veto-like cells alter the inhibitory specificity exhibited in the recipient microenvironment and indicate that these cells are directly involved in the induction and maintenance of self-tolerance.     

Induction of linked suppression in addition to the donor H-2 class I-specific unresponsiveness in recipient T cells by transfusing class I plus class II-disparate, but not class I alone-disparate, bone marrow cells

This study was undertaken to determine whether bone marrow (BM) cells contain a cell population with the capacity to induce an unresponsiveness of T cells specific to the BM self-H-2 class I antigens in vivo, i.e., veto cell population. Recombinant or congenic mice were infused intravenously with H-2-incompatible BM cells. One to several weeks later, donor H-2-and irrelevant H-2-specific responses in mixed lymphocyte reaction cultures of recipient T cells were assessed. Transfusion of H-2-incompatible BM of C57BL/10 (B10) recombinant strains caused a long-lasting cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) unresponsiveness to the donor class I antigens in recipient lymph node cells. When class I plus class II-disparate BM cells were transfused, an anti-donor class I CTL response and a response against a third-party class I antigen, which was presented on the stimulator cells coexpressing the donor class I and class II, were significantly suppressed. This linked suppression lasted for less than 2 weeks after transfusion. Transfusion of class I-alone-disparate BM induced the donor class I-specific CTL unresponsiveness, but not the linked suppression. The induction of linked suppression was prevented considerably by transfusing nylon wool-nonadherent BM or by treating recipients with cyclophosphamide 2 days before transfusion. An anti-third-party class I CTL response, stimulated in vitro with fully allogeneic spleen cells, was not hampered by the BM transfusion. Coculturing the lymph node (LN) cells obtained from the class I plus class II-disparate BM recipient with normal LN cells interfered with the generation of both anti-donor class I and anti-linked third-party class I CTL, whereas, coculturing LN cells from the class I alone-disparate BM recipient inhibited neither specificity of CTL generation. Transfusion of class I plus class II-disparate BM resulted in a significant suppression of the donor class II-specific proliferative response. In contrast, transfusion of class I alone-disparate BM did not suppress any proliferative responses, including even a "linked" third-party class II-specific response. Transfusion of bm 1, (B6 X bm 1)F1, or (bm 1 X bm 12)F1 BM to B6 did not induce unresponsiveness in bm 1-specific CTL responses. However, the transfusion resulted in a significant suppression of bm 1-reactive proliferative response of recipient LN cells.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Mls-1a-induced peripheral tolerance to host minor histocompatibility antigens in radiation bone marrow chimeras. Modification of T cell repertoire associated with active suppression and permanent presentation of host antigens.

Minor histocompatibility Ag (mHAg) can be responsible for the development of graft vs host reaction (GVHR) after bone marrow transplantation. In a mouse model, B10.D2 donor immunization against Mls-1a prevents lethal GVHR developed by CD4+ T cells against DBA mHAg in irradiated (DBA/2 x B10.D2)F1 hosts. Such F1 hosts become 100% chimeric and show long term survival (LS mice). The cellular mechanisms underlying the tolerance in LS mice was investigated. It was found that a state of tolerance can be induced in thymectomized F1 hosts. Although spleen cells from LS mice are able to initiate lethal GVHR in third-party H-2k-incompatible hosts, no GVHR is observed in secondary hosts incompatible for specific DBA/2 mHAg. Mixed lymphocyte experiments in vitro confirm that T cells from LS mice are unresponsive toward specific DBA/2 mHAg, although they are able to proliferate in response to H-2 or Mls-1a Ag. The responsiveness to Mls-1a correlates with the presence of V beta 6+ cells in LS mice, probably derived from mature T cells present in the donor inoculum. The tolerance in LS mice is not due to the lack of DBA/2 mHAg presentation; instead, permanent presentation of Ag (Ag I and Ag II) previously described as being responsible for lethal GVHR is consistently observed. A significant protection against GVHR is obtained by transferring normal B10.D2 cells together with spleen cells from LS mice, clearly indicating the contribution of active suppression in the state of tolerance; this is further confirmed by in vitro results obtained in limiting dilution assays. It is concluded that tolerance in chimeric LS mice 1) is due to a peripheral (thymus-independent) mechanism; 2) is specific for mHAg; 3) correlates with unresponsiveness of the repertoire to host mHAg, without alteration of the repertoire for H-2 and Mls-1a Ag; and 4) is associated with an active suppression and with a permanent presentation of at least two mHAg responsible for GVHR mortality.     

In vitro induction of immunological tolerance

IL-2 was previously shown to induce cytotoxic effectors with a broad spectrum of target specificities in thymus and spleen cell cultures. This study was designed to show whether T cells activated by H-2 allogeneic cells in MLC or by syngeneic tumor cells in MLTC are also potential targets for these cytotoxic effectors. We found that thymocytes activated in vitro for 5 days by rIL-2 were capable of killing tumor cells as well as activated T cells. Thymocytes activated by IL-2 were accordingly utilized as a means of effecting clonal deletion of T cells activated by H-2 allogeneic target cells in MLC. To establish whether the unresponsiveness is specific. IL-2-activated thymocytes were added as third party cells to MLC and MLTC. The results showed that both T cells, proliferating in response to H-2 allogeneic cells, and CTL, reactive against syngeneic tumors or H-2 allogeneic cells, are eliminated from the T cell pool. Only alloreactive T cells are specifically eliminated in MLC by IL-2-activated thymocytes, as the remaining T cells are capable of proliferating and generating CTL in response to antigenically unrelated third party allogeneic cells. The possibility that unresponsiveness might be due to soluble factors was ruled out by studies performed with a diffusable "chamber insert" culture system. The results provide evidence that IL-2-activated thymocytes induce in vitro T cell tolerance.     

Split tolerance in nude mice transplanted with 2'-deoxyguanosine-treated allogeneic thymus lobes

To elucidate the acquisition of self tolerance in the thymus, full-allogeneic thymic chimeras were constructed. Athymic C3H and BALB/c nude mice were reconstituted with the thymic lobes of BALB/c and B10.BR fetuses, respectively, that were organ cultured for 5 days in the presence of 2'-deoxyguanosine. T cells in these chimeras were tolerized to the host MHC in both MLR and CTL assays. In contrast, T cells in the chimeras exhibited split tolerance for the thymic MHC haplotype. CTL specific for class I MHC of the thymic haplotype were generated not only from the peripheral T cells of the chimeras but also from thymocytes re-populated in the engrafted thymic lobes. However, T cells in these chimeras responded poorly to the class II MHC of the thymic haplotype in a standard MLR assay. In a syngeneic MLR culture upon stimulation with enriched APC of the thymic haplotype, only 22 to 48% of the responses were mediated by CD4+ cells, and proliferations of CD4- cells were prominent. There were no haplotype-specific suppressor cells detected which would cause the unresponsiveness to the thymic class II MHC. These results indicated that the thymic lobes treated with 2'-deoxyguanosine were defective in the ability to induce the transplantation tolerance for the class I MHC expressed on the thymus, although the same thymic lobes were able to induce the transplantation tolerance for the thymic class II MHC.     

Evaluation of in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte assays as a predictive test for the occureence of graft vs host disease

The potential value of in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) assays for predicting the occurrence of graft vs host disease (GVHD) following allogeneic bone marrow transplantation was evaluated in 12 mouse donor-host combinations associated with various degrees of GVHD. These donor-host combinations were selected after evaluation of GVHD triggered by minor histocompatibility antigens (MiHA) in 24 allogeneic strain combinations derived from six strains of H-2 ^b mice. Recipients (n=475), previously submitted to total body irradiation (9.5 Gy), were transplanted with 10⁷ bone marrow cells along with 5 x 10⁷ spleen cells. While lethal GVHD was observed in half of the strain combinations, it was possible to select 12 donor-host combinations characterized by severe, mild, or absent GVHD. When levels of anti-host CTL activity were assessed following in vivo priming and in vitro boosting, strong CTL-mediated cytotoxicity was observed in all combinations wheteer they developed GVHD or not. CTL frequency measured by limiting dilution analysis (LDA) ranged from 1/16880-1/306. The Spearman rank test revealed no positive correlation between GVHD intensity and donor anti-host CTL activity assayed either in bulk culture experiments or in LDA conditions. These results indicate that MiHA capable of triggering potent CTL responses in vitro do not necessarily initiate GVHD, and that in vitro measurement of donor CTL activity against host-type Con A blasts is not a predictive assay for anti-MiHA GVHD. However, the possibility to recruit CTL populations targeting host MiHA expressed specifically on hematopoietic cells suggests a novel therapeutic strategy for the cure of hematopoietic malignancies. Indeed, transplantation of donor hematopoietic stem cells supplemented with T cells aimed at MiHA specifically expressed by host hematopoietic cells, could possibly potentiate the desirable graft vs leukemia effect without increasing the risk of GVHD.     

Cyclosporine A and peripheral tolerance. Inhibition of veto cell-mediated clonal deletion of postthymic precursor cytotoxic T lymphocytes.

Veto cell-mediated suppression of CTL responses has been proposed as one mechanism by which self tolerance is maintained in mature T cell populations. We have reported that murine bone marrow cells cultured in the presence of high-dose IL-2 (activated bone marrow cells) mediate strong veto suppressor function in vitro and in vivo, and that such veto activity is effected through clonal deletion of cytotoxic T cell precursors. In our studies, we have determined that bone marrow cell populations from athymic NCr-nu mice (H-2d) mediate strong veto cell activity without exposure to exogenous IL-2 in vitro. To examine mechanisms by which these naturally occurring veto cell populations in BM suppress precursor CTL (pCTL) responses, we used as a responding cell population in MLC, spleen cells of transgenic mice expressing at high frequency TCR specific for H-2 Ld encoded Ag with stimulation by H-2d-expressing cells in culture. Flow cytometric analysis was performed by staining the responding MLC cell population with the mAb 1B2 specific for the transgene-encoded TCR and determined changes of 1B2+ T cells. Such experiments demonstrated that the anti-H-2d cytotoxic response by these cell populations was specifically suppressed by NCr-nu (H-2d) bone marrow, and that 1B2+ pCTL were in fact specifically deleted from the responding cell population by incubation with such naturally occurring veto cell populations expressing the appropriate target Ag. In addition, to further understand the interactions of pCTL and veto cells and possible contributions by the latter to peripheral tolerance, we evaluated the effect of cyclosporine A (CsA) on veto cell-mediated suppression of pCTL of the transgenic mice. CsA inhibited veto cell-mediated suppression of cytotoxic T cell responses, and this inhibition correlated with a lack of clonal deletion of pCTL by veto cells in the presence of CsA. Furthermore, CsA exerted its effect through pCTL and not through veto cells, indicating that pCTL may play an active role in their own deletion by veto cells.     

Induction of peripheral T cell tolerance by antigen-presenting B cells. II. Chronic antigen presentation overrules antigen-presenting B cell activation

Ag presentation in the absence of danger signals and Ag persistence are the inductive processes of peripheral T cell tolerization proposed so far. Nevertheless, it has never been definitively shown that chronic Ag presentation per se can induce T cell tolerance independent of the state of activation of APCs. In the present work, we investigated whether chronic Ag presentation by either resting or activated B cells can induce tolerance of peripheral Ag-specific T cells. We show that CD4(+) T cells that re-encounter the Ag for a prolonged period, presented either by resting or activated Ag-presenting B cells, become nonfunctional and lose any autoimmune reactivity. Thus, when the main APCs are B cells, the major mechanism responsible for peripheral T cell tolerization is persistent Ag exposure, independent of the B cell activation state.     

Bone marrow-derived cells are essential for intrathymic deletion of self-reactive T cells in both the host- and donor-derived thymocytes of fully allogeneic bone marrow chimeras

The fate of self-reactive T cells was examined in both the host- and donor-derived thymocytes of fully allogeneic bone marrow (BM) chimeras of two strain combinations of AKR/J (H-2k, IE+, Thy-1.1, Mls-1a2b) and C57BL/6 (H-2b, IE-, Thy-1.2, Mls-1b2b). Sequential appearance of host- and donor-derived T cells occurred in the thymus of both AKR----B6 and B6----AKR chimeras in which 5 x 10(6) of T cell-depleted BM cells were used to reconstitute recipients lethally irradiated with 950 rad. Thymocytes bearing V beta 6 high, which recognize MHC class II IE-binding Ag encoded by Mls-1a allele, were detected in neither host- nor donor-derived thymocytes of AKR-B6 chimeras in which Mls-1a and IE were expressed only by the BM-derived cells. Thymocytes bearing V beta 11high capable of recognizing IE were also deleted in the host- and donor-derived thymocytes of the AKR----B6 chimeras. One million of BM cells were inadequate to deletion of the B beta 6high and V beta 11high T cells in the host-derived thymocytes of these chimeras. On the other hand, significant number of V beta 6high and V beta 11high thymocytes were detected in both the host- and donor-derived thymocytes in B6----AKR chimeras where sufficient dose of IE- stem cells were used to reconstitute irradiated Mls-1aIE+ recipients. These results suggest that clonal deletion of the host- and donor-reactive T cells in both the host- and donor-derived thymocytes is an important mechanism for the induction of transplantation tolerance in allogeneic BM chimeras and that BM-derived APC may be essential for the intrathymic elimination of both the host- and donor-reactive T cells in the BM chimeras.     

CD40 activation in vivo overcomes peptide-induced peripheral cytotoxic T-lymphocyte tolerance and augments anti-tumor vaccine efficacy.

The outcome of antigen recognition by naive CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) in the periphery is orchestrated by CD4+ T-helper cells, and can either lead to priming or tolerization. The presence of T-helper cells favors the induction of CTL immunity, whereas the absence of T-helper cells can result in CTL tolerance. The action of T helper cells in CTL priming is mediated by CD40-CD40 ligand interactions. We demonstrate here that triggering of CD40 in vivo can considerably enhance the efficacy of peptide-based anti-tumor vaccines. The combination of a tolerogenic peptide vaccine containing a minimal essential CTL epitope with an activating antibody against CD40 converts tolerization into strong CTL priming. Moreover, CD40 ligation can provide an already protective tumor-specific peptide vaccine with the capacity to induce therapeutic CTL immunity in tumor-bearing mice. These findings indicate that the CD40-CD40 ligand pair can act as a 'switch', determining whether naive peripheral CTLs are primed or tolerized, and support the clinical use of CD40-stimulating agents as components of anti-cancer vaccines.     

Induction of peripheral T cell tolerance by antigen-presenting B cells. I. Relevance of antigen presentation persistence

Various mechanisms of peripheral T cell tolerization have evolved to avoid responses mediated by autoreactive T cells that have not been eliminated in the thymus. In this study, we investigated the peripheral conditions of Ag presentation required to induce T cell tolerance when the predominant APCs are B cells. We show that transient Ag presentation, in absence of inflammation and in a self-context, induces CD4(+) T cell activation and memory formation. In contrast, chronic Ag presentation leads to CD4(+) T cell tolerance. The importance of long-lasting Ag presentation in inducing tolerance was also confirmed in the herpes stromal keratitis autoimmune disease model. Keratogenic T cells could be activated or tolerized depending on the APC short or long persistence. Thus, when APCs are B cells, the persistence of the Ag presentation itself is one of the main conditions to have peripheral T cell tolerance.     

Influence of a Small Number of Mature T Cells in Donor Bone Marrow Inocula on Reconstitution of Lymphoid Tissues and Negative Selection of a T Cell Repertoire in the Recipient

Allo-chimerism and clonal elimination of self antigen (Ag) (Ia + Mls-1^a) reactive Vβ6+ T cells were analyzed and compared between allogeneic bone marrow (BM) chimeras reconstituted with BM cells which had been treated with anti-Thy-1 monoclonal antibody (mAb) plus complement (C) (T^– chimeras) and BM chimeras which had been reconstituted with BM cells pretreated with anti-Thy-1 mAb alone (T⁺ chimeras). When lethally irradiated AKR (Mls-1^a) mice were reconstituted with BM cells from B10 or B10 H-2 congenic mice, both T⁺ and T^– chimeras were entirely free of signs of graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR). However, complete replacement of the AKR lymphoid tissues by donor BM cells was accomplished at an early stage in T⁺ chimeras but not in T^– chimeras. On the other hand, clonal elimination of Vβ6⁺ T cells reactive to the recipient Ag (Mls-1^a) was abolished in T⁺ chimeras but successfully induced in T^– chimeras. The Vβ6⁺ T cells not eliminated in T⁺ chimeras showed depressed responses against Mls-1^a antigens. The findings herein demonstrate that T cells which contaminate a BM inoculum survive in recipient mice after treatment with anti-Thy-1 mAb without C in vitro followed by BMT. The surviving T cells have been estimated to represent fewer than 0.5% of the BM cells inoculated. These cells appear to accelerate the full replacement of recipient lymphoid tissues by donor cells. Furthermore, the T cells which survive in the marrow inoculum influence eventually the development of a tolerant state in the T cell repertoire of the donor.     

Abrogation of tolerance to a chronic viral infection

This study documents failure of peripheral tolerance mechanisms in a chronic viral infection and shows that T cell tolerance to a viral Ag seen as self from fetal life can be broken despite the presence of this Ag in extrathymic tissues. Congenital infection of mice with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) results in T cell tolerance to the virus. Such mice become carriers for life harboring virus in many tissues including the thymus and exhibit no LCMV-specific CTL responses. Our previous studies have documented the curing of this congenitally acquired chronic infection after adoptive transfer of CD8+ T cells from LCMV-immune mice and the presence of host-derived, LCMV-specific CTL in these "cured" carriers. In this study we have examined the mechanism by which these carriers acquired T cell competence and show that these CTL differentiated from the bone marrow after elimination of viral Ag from the thymus. These results demonstrate that even when a chronic infection has been established in utero, the adult thymus retains the ability to restore immunocompetence to the host and to provide protection against reinfection. Surprisingly, these LCMV specific CTL were acquired at a time when infectious virus and intracellular viral Ag, although cleared from the thymus, were readily detectable in organs such as the kidney, testes, and brain. In fact, active viral replication in peripheral tissues was ongoing when these mice acquired new virus-specific T cells. These results show that clearance of virus form the thymus was sufficient to abrogate tolerance to a congenitally acquired chronic infection and that Ag in peripheral tissues did not tolerize newly developing T cells. These findings suggest that mechanisms that operate on immature cells within the thymus to silence self-reactive T cells are effective in induction of tolerance to viruses, but mechanisms of tolerizing mature T cells are likely to breakdown. This has implications for virus-induced autoimmunity and for treatment of chronic infections.     

Self-tolerance checkpoints in CD4 T cells specific for a peptide derived from the B cell antigen receptor

Linked recognition of Ag by B and T lymphocytes is ensured in part by a state of tolerance acquired by CD4 T cells to germline-encoded sequences within the B cell Ag receptor (BCR). We sought to determine how such tolerance is attained when a peptide from the BCR variable (V) region is expressed by small numbers of B cells as it is in the physiological state. Mixed bone marrow (BM) chimeras were generated using donor BM from mice with B cells that expressed a transgene (Tg)-encoded κ L chain and BM from TCR Tg mice in which the CD4 T cells (CA30) were specific for a Vκ peptide encoded by the κTg. In chimeras where few B cells express the κTg, many CA30 cells were deleted in the thymus. However, a substantial fraction survived to the CD4 single-positive stage. Among single-positive CA30 thymocytes, few reached maturity and migrated to the periphery. Maturation was strongly associated with, and likely promoted by, expression of an endogenous TCR α-chain. CD4(+) CA30 cells that reached peripheral lymphoid tissues were Ag-experienced and anergic, and some developed into regulatory cells. These findings reveal several checkpoints and mechanisms that enforce a state of self-tolerance in developing T cells specific for BCR V region sequences, thus ensuring that T cell help to B cells occurs through linked recognition of foreign Ag.     

Nonspecific suppressor elements in murine allogeneic radiation chimeras.

Spleen cells from long-term mouse allogeneic radiation chimeras were tested for their ability to modulate the graft-versus-host (GVH) or plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of normal lymphocytes transplanted in lethally X-irradiated recipients. In vivo GVH proliferation of normal lymphocytes (syngeneic to donor cells of the chimera) against antigens of host-type in which the chimeric state had been established was reduced by chimera cells. Inhibition varied, some chimeras suppressing GVH more than others and a few not suppressing at all. The suppressive effect was abrogated if the chimera cells were treated with anti-θ; treatment with anti-IgM did not eliminate this activity. When mixtures of normal donor lymphocytes and chimera cells were given to irradiated recipients genetically different from host or donor, reduction of donor cell GVH also occurred. Further, chimera cells reduced the GVH activity of normal host cells in irradiated recipients differing from the host at one H-2 locus and from the donor at minor histocompatibility loci. The modulating effect of spleen cells from chimeras on the PFC response by normal lymphocytes also varied. Six chimeras induced a 25 to 90% suppression, two enhanced the response, and one showed no effect. Where suppression occurred, treatment of chimera cells with anti-θ most often, but not always, restored PFC production. Our results show that the suppressive action of splenic lymphoid cells by chimeras is highly nonspecific and variable in expression. We suggest that tolerance in chimeras may be mediated by nonspecific suppressor elements leading to unresponsiveness to a variety of antigens including SRBC.     

Inability of mice to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes to vesicular stomatitis virus restricted to H-2Kk or H-2Dk

H-2k mice are unable to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) to vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV). This apparent unresponsiveness is found for both major serotypes of VSV, VSV-Indiana and VSV-New Jersey. CTL unresponsiveness occurs despite the ability of H-2k mice to generate a humoral immune response against VSV that is comparable to that found in responder (H-2b and H-2a) strains. All H-2k mice regardless of background genes, including various Ig allotypes, were found to be nonresponders. H-2k-linked unresponsiveness mapped to both H-2Kk and H-2Dk and occurred despite the presence of responder alleles in (responder x nonresponder)F1 mice. The unresponsiveness cannot be attributed to an inability of VSV-infected H-2k target cells to express viral surface antigens of H-2 molecules. Further, unresponsiveness cannot be overcome by using secondary stimulation in vivo or in vitro. H-2k-linked unresponsiveness does not appear to be due to suppression, and no complementation has been found in various (nonresponder x nonresponder)F1 mice. Thus unresponsiveness to VSV in association with H-2Kk or H-2Dk appears to represent an extensive defect of immune responsiveness that probably occurs because VSV is not a natural mouse pathogen.     

Pretreatment with minor histocompatibility antigens prevents the development of functional CTL helper cell activity

We have been studying the regulation of allogeneic cytotoxic cells (CTL) in vivo. CBA/J (H-2k, mls d) responder mice are unable to develop CTL after an allogeneic footpad immunization if they are pretreated i.p. with spleen cells from either C3H/HeN (H-2k, mls c) or B10.BR (H-2k, mls b) mice. These mouse strain combinations are H-2 compatible but differ at the Mls and other minor histocompatibility loci. We reported that this state of CTL unresponsiveness is specific and that the allogeneic cells used for footpad immunization and the pretreatment strain must share both minor antigens and part of the MHC. In this paper, we describe some of the characteristic features of this CTL unresponsiveness. The CBA host plays an active role and appears to down-regulate its subsequent response against minor antigens after the initial pretreatment. This statement is based on the following: 1) The inhibition of in vivo CTL generation can be achieved by injecting F1 or irradiated C3H cells, i.e., under conditions where GVHD was not a factor; and 2) the state of unresponsiveness is abolished by host treatment with cyclophosphamide. In addition, we demonstrate that the lack of CTL development in pretreated responder animals is the result of impaired helper cell activity. Draining LNC from unresponsive mice can become functionally cytolytic if cultured in a Con A-activated spleen cell supernatant. However, normal CTL responses were not restored after adult thymectomy or splenectomy. Thus, the state of CTL inhibition that is induced by the minor antigen pretreatment is the result of a host-mediated regulatory circuit.     

In vivo priming of mouse CTL precursors directed to product of a newly defined minor H-42 locus is under a novel control of class II MHC gene

In a previous study, we discovered a new mouse minor histocompatibility antigen encoded by a locus at 8.5 cM apart from the H-2 complex, and we have since named the locus H-42. One allele of H-42, which is named H-42a, had been elucidated, but the other alleles, which we tentatively named H-42b, have not been elucidated. In the present study, we explored MHC control on the anti-H-42a cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responsiveness in H-42b mice. In vivo immunization (i.v. injection) of H-42b mice with 5 to 30 X 10(6) spleen cells (SC) bearing allogeneic H-42a antigen but carrying H-2 complex (mouse MHC) matched with the H-42b mice failed to prime anti-H-42a CTL but induced stable and specific anti-H-42a CTL unresponsiveness, i.e., tolerance, in the H-42b recipient mice. In contrast, H-2 heterozygous H-42b F1 mice injected with SC bearing H-42a alloantigen on either of the parental H-2 haplotypes were effectively primed to generate anti-H-42a CTL. Exploration of the region or subregion in the H-2 complex of H-42a donor SC that should be compatible with H-42b recipient mice for the induction of their anti-H-42a CTL tolerance demonstrated that the compatibility at I region, most probably I-A subregion, but not at K, S, or D region, determined the induction of the tolerance. MHC class II compatible H-42a skin graft (SG) to H-42b mice, however, consistently primed the anti-H-42a CTL in the H-42b recipients. These results were discussed in several aspects, including uniqueness of MHC class II control on the CTL response to minor H-42a antigen, possibility of inactivation of responding anti-H-42a precursor CTL or helper T cells in H-42b mice by encountering the veto cells present in MHC class II-matched H-42a SC population, and significance of the present observations as a mechanism of CTL tolerance to self-components.     

A splenic requirement for the generation of suppressor T cells.

Tolerance to contact sensitization with DNFB may be induced by DNBSO3. This specific unresponsiveness may occur via one or both of two mechanisms--production of suppressor T cells or clone inhibition. We investigated the role of the spleen in this unresponsiveness. Splenectomized mice may be tolerized by i.v. injection of DNBSO3, but they are incapable of serving as donors of lymph node cells for transfer of tolerance to normal recipients. Kinetic studies indicated that the spleen must be present at least three days after tolerization in order to permit development of a significant number of suppressor cells in the peripheral lymph nodes. We interpret these results to indicate that 1) clone inhibition does not require the spleen, 2) the generation of suppressor T cells is dependent on the presence of the spleen, and 3) it is likely that tolerogens in this system induce suppressor cells in the spleen and some of these cells or their products leave the spleen to reach the peripheral lymph nodes.     

Prediction of reactivity to noninherited maternal antigen in MHC-mismatched, minor histocompatibility antigen-matched stem cell transplantation in a mouse model

The immunologic effects of developmental exposure to noninherited maternal Ags (NIMAs) are quite variable. Both tolerizing influence and inducing alloreaction have been observed on clinical transplantation. The role of minor histocompatibility Ags (MiHAs) in NIMA effects is unknown. MiHA is either matched or mismatched in NIMA-mismatched transplantation because a donor of the transplantation is usually limited to a family member. To exclude the participation of MiHA in a NIMA effect for MHC (H-2) is clinically relevant because mismatched MiHA may induce severe alloreaction. The aim of this study is to understand the mechanism of NIMA effects in MHC-mismatched, MiHA-matched hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Although all offsprings are exposed to the maternal Ags, the NIMA effect for the H-2 Ag was not evident. However, they exhibit two distinct reactivities, low and high responder, to NIMA in utero and during nursing depending on the degree of maternal microchimerism. Low responders survived longer with less graft-versus-host disease. These reactivities were correlated with Foxp3 expression of peripheral blood CD4(+)CD25(+) cells after graft-versus-host disease induction and the number of IFN-γ-producing cells stimulated with NIMA pretransplantation. These observations are clinically relevant and suggest that it is possible to predict the immunological tolerance to NIMA.