Survival of a Salmonella typhimurium poultry isolate in the presence of propionic acid under aerobic and anaerobic conditions

Propionic acid is commonly found as a fermentation product in the gastrointestinal tracts of food animals and has also been used to limit the microbial contaminants in animal feeds. Because propionic acid is known to have antibacterial activity, the propionic acid encountered by foodborne pathogens during their life cycles may play an important role in inhibiting the survival of the pathogens. The survival patterns of Salmonella typhimurium poultry isolate were determined both in aerobic and anaerobic tryptic soy broth (TSB; pH 5.0 or 7.0) containing various concentrations of propionic acid (0-200 mM). The levels of recovered cells were consistently greater at pH 7.0 compared to those at pH 5.0. For the first 4 days, the levels were significantly decreased by incubation under anaerobic conditions as compared to aerobic condition at pH 7.0 (P<0.05). However, there were fluctuations of cell populations with different patterns depending on both concentrations and growth conditions. To characterize the nature of the capability which allowed the cell multiplication following decreases in cell population during incubation at pH 7.0, the cells isolated from the outgrowth cultures were tested for survival in aerobic or anaerobic TSB (pH 5.0 or pH 7.0) containing propionic acid (50 mM). The outgrowth isolates did not show significant differences in the level of recovered cells in the presence of propionic acid when compared to the wild type strain (P>0.05), suggesting that the cells in the outgrowth cultures did not harbour mutation(s) conferring increased resistance to propionic acid. In addition, the level of recovered cells of isogenic rpoS mutant strain of S. typhimurium was not significantly different from that of the wild type strain in the same assay conditions (P<0.05). The results of this study show that the bactericidal activity of propionic acid on S. typhimurium can be affected by environmental conditions such as acidic pH levels and anaerobiosis in food materials and gastrointestinal tracts. However, S. typhimurium is also able to multiply in the presence of sublethal concentrations of propionic acid at neutral pH during prolonged incubation under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions.     

Survivability of indigenous microflora and a Salmonella typhimurium marker strain in poultry mash treated with buffered propionic acid

Buffered propionic acid (BPA) was evaluated as a potential treatment for the elimination of Salmonella spp. in poultry mash. A primary poultry isolate marker strain of Salmonella typhimurium was added as either a broth or in a dry chalk carrier form to poultry mash containing soybean meal as a protein supplement. The mash was supplemented with buffered propionic acid at 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 20, 30, 50 and 100 g kg⁻¹ diet and samples were enumerated for indigenous aerobic bacteria, fungi and the S. typhimurium marker strain. Total indigenous aerobic bacteria and fungal populations were generally decreased by addition of more than 20 g BPA kg⁻¹, but an addition of 100 g BPA kg⁻¹ mash was usually required to achieve reductions of approximately 90% of indigenous aerobic bacteria and 99% of indigenous fungi. After 7 days of storage, 8 g BPA kg⁻¹ mash also reduced S. typhimurium populations by more than 90% in mash inoculated via chalk, while at least 50 g BPA kg⁻¹ mash was required to provide the same level of reduction in mash inoculated with a liquid culture of S. typhimurium. Although BPA does not appear to be an overly effective antimicrobial agent with respect to indigenous aerobic bacterial populations in animal feed, higher concentrations may have the potential for reducing fungal and Salmonella spp. contamination in poultry mash.     

Laboratory tests of 8-quinolinol as an additive to volatile fatty acids for preserving hay and other feedstuffs

One part of 8-quinolinol in ten parts of propionic acid, either free or part-neutralised with ammonia, halved the acid required for preserving grass and lucerne hays, beans, rape seed and cereal grains containing sufficient moisture to mould. Propionic acid with 8-quinolinol delays moulding and diminishes the rate of spread of mould growth so that maximum temperatures attained are lowered and growth of thermophilic organisms is prevented. The application of 8-quinolinol and propionic acid to grass on cutting with, or without, use of formic acid as desiccant assisted inhibition of moulding especially in conjunction with ammonium propionate treatment after drying. The additive acts by inhibiting the growth of fungi which tolerate and degrade propionic and related fatty acids. The growth of two such fungi, Paecilomyces varioti and Aspergillus glaucus, is inhibited in culture by much smaller concentrations (less than 200 μM or 30 ppm) of 8-quinolinol than are required on hay, which strongly absorbs the additive and makes it less effective.     

ETHYL ALCOHOL REDUCTION OF SALMONELLA TYPHIMURIUM IN POULTRY FEED

This study was designed to evaluate the effect of ethyl alcohol as a potential treatment for reduction of Salmonella populations in poultry feed. Growth rate of S. typhimurium in tryptic soy broth was significantly reduced by addition of greater than 0.3% volume/volume of ethyl alcohol and growth was completely inhibited by addition of 5% ethyl alcohol. Ethyl alcohol concentrations of 20% volume/weight and greater significantly reduced initial S.typhimurium populations in poultry feed (for 20% treated, 2.31 ± 0.31 vs 3.39 ± 0.29 for untreated; P < 0.05). When feed treatment was administered either before or after inoculation of S. typhimurium with 60% ethyl alcohol or 0.04% buffered propionic acid, populations in feeds treated after inoculation were decreased to a nondetection level (< 1.0 log₁₀ CFU/g) by ethyl alcohol treatment but not by other treatments. Ethyl alcohol treatment may have the potential for reducing Salmonella spp. contamination in poultry feed.     

Influence of short chain fatty acids and lysine on Salmonella typhimurium cadA expression

In Salmonella typhimurium, cadA has a role in virulence expression and is an inducible gene that responds to external lysine concentration. In this study, a strain of S. typhimurium carrying a cadA: lacZ fusion was used to determine if the induction of cadA occurred under different lysine concentrations and mildly acid conditions in the presence of short chain fatty acids. Aliquots of an 18-h culture of S. typhimurium were placed on fresh media containing different lysine concentrations at pH 5.8 adjusted by addition of HCl or by 1 M short chain fatty acids (SCFA, acetic, propionic and butyric acid) stock solution. After an induction period of 2 h, -galactosidase activities were assayed. Expression of cadA in rich medium was significantly higher than that of minimal medium at neutral pH and different lysine concentrations. In contrast, at pH 5.8, there was a significant increase in cadA expression, particularly when pH was adjusted using HCl at all lysine levels. Addition of a mixture of organic acids yielded an overall lower cadA expression at all lysine levels studied when compared to HCl. However, each SCFA challenge (individual or as a mixture) caused a high level of expression, both at neutral and acidic pH. Based on these results it is apparent that in the presence of external lysine, SCFA and nutrient availability can influence cadA expression in S. typhimurium.     

Influence of propionate on growth and fermentative activity of lactobacilli

Propionic acid was added to cultures of Lactobacillus helveticus and Lact. casei growing in a complex medium. The effect of different concentrations of this fatty acid on the growth kinetic, substrate consumption rate and coefficient and product formation rate was examined. Low concentrations of propionic acid produced a low increase or no modification of the growth rate of lactobacilli. By contrast, higher concentrations reduced the growth rate and substrate yields in all the strains. The fermentative activity of lactobacilli increased in all the cultures with propionate. When the concentration of glucose in the medium was low, the population density of all the strains at the stationary growth phase was lower in the presence of propionate than in control cultures. An increase in the concentration of glucose in the medium counteracted the inhibitory effect of propionate. The addition of lithium lactate to the medium gave greater inhibition even at low propionate concentrations. The inhibition results were explained by assuming that propionic acid could diffuse through cell membranes in the undissociated form, increasing the inward leak of H⁺ in the cells. The extrusion of H⁺ by the H⁺-ATPase is possible by increasing the fermentative activity of the cells. When metabolism cannot supply the ATP required for proton extrusion, growth rate and biomass production decrease.     

INDIGENOUS POULTRY FEED MICROFLORA RESPONSE TO ETHYL ALCOHOL AND BUFFERED PROPIONIC ACID ADDITION

The present study was designed to compare ethyl alcohol with buffered propionic acid feed treatment on the survival of indigenous poultry feed bacteria and fungi. The aerobic bacterial poultry feed populations were not substantially reduced by either ethyl alcohol or buffered propionic acid treatments. Likewise, indigenous poultry feed fungal populations also were not markedly reduced by buffered propionic acid treatment of the feed but fungal poultry feed populations exposed to ethyl alcohol treatments were significantly lower (P<0.05) than fungal populations recovered from either control and buffered propionic acid treated feeds. Ethyl alcohol treatment may have potential for reducing fungal contamination in poultry feed.     

Effect of pH on organic acid production byClostridium propionicum in test tube and fermentor cultures

Summary Clostridum propionicum is a chemical autotroph that metabolizes alanine to propionic acid (reduction product) and acetic acid (oxidation product). The ratio of propionate/acetate predicted by the electron balance is 2:1. This study reports the effect of pH on growth and organic acid production by this organism when grown in both test tube cultures initially buffered from pH 7.0 to 5.0, and in fermentors maintained at pH 7.0 and 6.5. Highest growth and organic acid production was found at pH 7.0 in both cases. HPLC analysis showed that at pH 7.0, the ratios of propionate to acetate were 0.45:1 (stationary tube, 24 h). The highest ratio observed was 1.8:1 (stationary tube, pH 6.0, 24h). This tube produced 8.5% of the acids produced in the pH 7.0 culture tube. The identify of the major portion of the reduction products of the organism remains unknown.     

Cecal Propionic Acid as a Biological Indicator of the Early Establishment of a Microbial Ecosystem Inhibitory toSalmonellain Chicks

Experiments were conducted to evaluate the effects of different competitive exclusion (CE) cultures on the concentration of cecal propionic acid in 3-day-old broiler chicks, and the correlation between cecal propionic acid concentration and protection againstSalmonellacolonization. CE cultures that significantly (P < 0.05) increased cecal propionic acid in 3-day-old chicks decreased (P < 0.05) cecalSalmonellacolonization in 10-day-old chicks compared with the untreated controls. CE cultures that failed to significantly (P > 0.05) increase cecal propionic acid concentrations in 3-day-old chicks failed to protect (P > 0.05) against cecalSalmonellacolonization in 10-day-old chicks compared with untreated controls. A significant (P < .05) correlation (−.88) was found between cecal propionic acid concentration in 3-day-old chicks and cecalSalmonellacolonization in 10-day-old chicks.     

Effect of Solvents and Kinetic Parameters on Synthesis of Ethyl Propionate Catalysed by Poly (AAc-co-HPMA-cl-MBAm)-Matrix-Immobilized Lipase of Pseudomonas aeruginosa BTS-2.

Summary A purified alkaline thermo-tolerant bacterial lipase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa BTS-2 was immobilized on a poly (AAc-co-HPMA-cl-MBAm) hydrogel network. The hydrogel showed approximately 95% binding efficiency for lipase (specific activity 1.96 U mg⁻¹). The immobilized enzyme achieved 65.1% conversion of ethanol and propionic acid (100 mM each) into ethyl propionate in n-nonane at 65 °C in 9 h. When alkane of C-chain length lower than n-nonane was used as the organic solvent, the conversion of ethanol and propionic acid into ethyl propionate decreased with a decrease in the log P value of alkanes. The immobilized lipase retained approximately 30% of its original catalytic activity after five cycles of reuse for esterification of ethanol and propionic acid into ethyl propionate at temperature 65 °C in 3 h. Addition of a molecular sieve (3 ?) to the reaction mixture enhanced the formation of ethyl propionate to 89.3%. Moreover, ethanol and propionic acid when taken a molar ratio of 3:1 further promoted the conversion rate to 94%. However, an increase in the molar ratio of propionic acid with respect to ethanol resulted in a decline of ethyl propionate synthesis.     

Induction of Acid Resistance of Salmonella typhimurium by Exposure to Short-Chain Fatty Acids

Exposure to short-chain fatty acids (SCFA) is one of the stress conditions Salmonella typhimurium encounters during its life cycle, because SCFA have been widely used as food preservatives and SCFA are also present at high concentrations in the gastrointestinal tracts of host animals. The effects of SCFA on the acid resistance of the organism were examined in an attempt to understand the potential role of SCFA in the pathogenesis of S. typhimurium. The percent survival of S. typhimurium at pH 3.0 was determined after exposure to SCFA for 1 h at pH 7.0. The percent acid survival, which varied depending on the SCFA species and the concentration used, was 42 after exposure to 100 mM propionate at pH 7.0 under aerobic incubation conditions, while less than 1% could survive without exposure. The SCFA-induced acid resistance was markedly enhanced by anaerobiosis (64%), lowering pH conditions (138% at pH 5.0), or increasing incubation time (165% with 4 h) during exposure to propionic acid. When protein synthesis during exposure to propionate was blocked by chloramphenicol, the percent acid survival was less than 1, indicating that the protein synthesis induced by exposure to propionate is required for the induction of the acid resistance. The percent acid survival determined with the isogenic mutant strains defective in acid tolerance response revealed that AtrB protein is necessary for the full induction of acid resistance by exposure to propionate, while unexpectedly, inactivation of PhoP significantly increased acid resistance over that of the wild type (P < 0.05). The results suggest that the virulence of S. typhimurium may be enhanced by increasing acid resistance upon exposure to SCFA during its life cycle and further enhanced by anaerobiosis, low pH, and prolonged exposure time.     

Propionibacterium freudenreichii thrives in microaerobic conditions by complete oxidation of lactate to CO2

In this study we show increased biomass formation for four species of food-grade propionic acid bacteria (Acidipropionibacterium acidipropionici, Acidipropionibacterium jensenii, Acidipropionibacterium thoenii and Propionibacterium freudenreichii) when exposed to oxygen, implicating functional respiratory systems. Using an optimal microaerobic condition, P. freudenreichii DSM 20271 consumed lactate to produce propionate and acetate initially. When lactate was depleted propionate was oxidized to acetate. We propose to name the switch from propionate production to consumption in microaerobic conditions the ‘propionate switch’. When propionate was depleted the ‘acetate switch’ occurred, resulting in complete consumption of acetate. Both growth rate on lactate (0.100 versus 0.078 h⁻¹) and biomass yield (20.5 versus 8.6 g* mol⁻¹ lactate) increased compared to anaerobic conditions. Proteome analysis revealed that the abundance of proteins involved in the aerobic and anaerobic electron transport chains and major metabolic pathways did not significantly differ between anaerobic and microaerobic conditions. This implicates that P. freudenreichii is prepared for utilizing O₂ when it comes available in anaerobic conditions. The ecological niche of propionic acid bacteria can conceivably be extended to environments with oxygen gradients from oxic to anoxic, so-called microoxic environments, as found in the rumen, gut and soils, where they can thrive by utilizing low concentrations of oxygen.     

DNA Microarray Analyses of the Long-Term Adaptive Response of Escherichia coli to Acetate and Propionate

In its natural environment, Escherichia coli is exposed to short-chain fatty acids, such as acetic acid or propionic acid, which can be utilized as carbon sources but which inhibit growth at higher concentrations. DNA microarray experiments revealed expression changes during exponential growth on complex medium due to the presence of sodium acetate or sodium propionate at a neutral external pH. The adaptive responses to acetate and propionate were similar and involved genes in three categories. First, the RNA levels for chemotaxis and flagellum genes increased. Accordingly, the expression of chromosomal fliC′-′lacZ and flhDC′-′lacZ fusions and swimming motility increased after adaptation to acetate or propionate. Second, the expression of many genes that are involved in the uptake and utilization of carbon sources decreased, indicating some kind of catabolite repression by acetate and propionate. Third, the expression of some genes of the general stress response increased, but the increases were more pronounced after short-term exposure for this response than for the adaptive response. Adaptation to propionate but not to acetate involved increased expression of threonine and isoleucine biosynthetic genes. The gene expression changes after adaptation to acetate or propionate were not caused solely by uncoupling or osmotic effects but represented specific characteristics of the long-term response of E. coli to either compound.     

Growth inhibition of Erwinia amylovora and related Erwinia species by neutralized short-chain fatty acids

Short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) are used to preserve food and could be a tool for control of fire blight caused by Erwinia amylovora on apple, pear and related rosaceous plants. Neutralized acids were added to buffered growth media at 0.5–75 mM and tested at pHs ranging from 6.8 to 5.5. Particularly at low pH, SCFAs with a chain length exceeding that of acetic acid such as propionic acid were effective growth inhibitors of E. amylovora possibly due to uptake of free acid and its intracellular accumulation. We also observed high inhibition with monochloroacetic acid. An E. billingiae strain was as sensitive to the acids as E. amylovora or E. tasmaniensis. Fire blight symptoms on pear slices were reduced when the slices were pretreated with neutralized propionic acid. Propionic acid is well water soluble and could be applied in orchards as a control agent for fire blight.     

Oxidation of glycerol,lactate, and propionate by Propionibacterium freudenreichii in a poised-potential amperometric culture system

Growth of Propionibacterium freudenreichii was studied with glycerol, lactate, and propionate as energy sources and a three-electrode poised-potential amperometric electrode system with hexacyanoferrate (III) as mediator. In batch culture experiments with glycerol and lactate as substrates, hexacyanoferrate (III) was completely reduced. Growth yields increased and the fermentation patterns were shifted towards higher acetate formation with increasing hexacyanoferrate (III) concentrations (0.25–8.0 mM). In experiments with regulated electrodes, glycerol, lactate, and propionate were oxidized to acetate and CO₂, and the electrons were quantitatively transferred to the working electrode. Growth yields of 29.0, 13.4 and 14.2 g cell material per mol were calculated, respectively. The high cell yield obtained during propionate oxidation cannot be explained solely by substrate level phosphorylation indicating that additional energy was conserved via electron transport phosphorylation. Furthermore, this result indicated complete reversibility of the methyl-malonyl-CoA pathway in propionic acid bacteria.     

Growth characteristics of Geotrichum ingens on propionic acid and acetic acid in batch and continuous culture

Growth of Geotrichum ingens in batch cultures was completely inhibited by 47 g acetic acid/l or 33 g propionic acid/I. With mixtures of acetic and propionic acids, however, growth only ceased at 55 g/l. Acetic acid inhibited growth linearly, whereas propionic acid inhibited growth non-linearly. In continuous culture, two steady states at each dilution rate were observed at high dilution rates for acetic acid and propionic acid. The highest yield coefficient (0.69 g cells/g substrate) was achieved with propionic acid as substrate. On both substrates and their mixtures, the protein content of the biomass increased when the dilution rate was increased.The authors are with the Department of Microbiology and Biochemistry, University of the Orange Free State, P.O. Box 339, Bloemfontein 9300, South Africa     

pH gradients and a mirco-pore filter at the luminal surface affect fluxes of propionic acid across guinea pig large intestine

A neutral pH microclimate had been shown at the luminal surface of the large intestine. The aim was to estimate to what extent fluxes of propionic acid/propionate are affected by changes of the luminal pH when this microclimate is present, largely reduced or absent. Fluxes of propionic acid/propionate (J ^Pr) across epithelia from the caecum, the proximal and the distal colon of guinea pigs were measured in Ussing chambers with and without a filter at the luminal surface. With bicarbonate and with a neutral or an acid pH of mucosal solutions (pH 7.4 or 6.4), mucosal-to-serosal fluxes (J _ms^Pr) were 1.5 to 1.9-fold higher at the lower pH, in bicarbonate-free solutions and carbonic anhydrase (CA) inhibition 2.1 to 2.6-fold. With a filter at the mucosal surface and with bicarbonate containing solutions, J _ms^Pr was not or only little elevated at the lower pH. Without bicarbonate J _ms^Pr was clearly higher. We conclude that the higher J _ms^Pr after luminal acidification is due to vigorous mixing in Ussing chambers resulting in a markedly reduced unstirred layer. Therefore, an effective pH microclimate at the epithelial surface is missing. J _ms^Pr is not or is little affected by lowering of pH because in the presence of bicarbonate the filter maintains the pH microclimate. However, in bicarbonate-free solutions J _ms^Pr was higher at pH 6.4 because a pH microclimate does not develop. Findings confirm that 30–60% of J _ms^Pr results from non-ionic diffusion.     

Inhibition of growth by imadazol(on)e propionic acid: Evidence in vivo for coordination of histidine catabolism with the catabolism of other amino acids

Summary Imidazole propionic acid (ipa), a gratuitous inducer of the histidine-utilization (hut) system in Salmonella typhimurium, inhibits the organism's growth on succinate minimal medium. Induction of the hut system is necessary, but not sufficient, to cause inhibition. A study of the ability of single amino acids to relieve ipa-restricted growth suggests that insufficient glutamate is the cause of slow growth. The inhibition of growth by imidazolone propionic acid (iopa), an intermediate in the catabolism of histidine to glutamate, is similar to that by ipa. Studies using 2, 3, 5-triphenyl tetrazolium chloride plates to examine amino acid catabolism suggest that accumulation of ipa or iopa leads to inactivation of aspartate amino-transferase (AAT). This interpretation is supported by studies of an Escherichia coli mutant lacking AAT. The mutant grows poorly on succinate minimal medium, and the poor growth is relieved by the same amino acids that relieve ipa- and iopa-restricted growth. These and other findings are discussed in terms of coordination of the histidine-utilization system with enzymatic activities involved in the catabolism of other amino acids.     

Prolonged environmental stress via a two step process selects mutants of Escherichia,Salmonella and Pseudomonas that grow at 54°C

A prolonged incubation of Escherichia, Salmonella or Pseudomonas at 48°C with nalidixic acid selected mutants (T48) able to grow at 48°C. A prolonged incubation at 54°C of the T48 mutants selected mutants (T54) able to grow at 54°C. These mutants were susceptible to the same bacteriophages as the original mesophilic strains. Auxotrophic phenotypes of Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium mesophilic parents were demonstrated by these mutants if they were cultivated on minimal agar with cellobiose at 48°C or 54°C or on a minimal agar with glucose at 37°C. The T48 alleles mapped in the gyrA region of E. coli or S. typhimurium chromosome. In S. typhimurium the T54 alleles, which permit growth at 54°C, were shown by cotransductional analysis to be linked to gyrA.