SPECIAL PAPER: MERISTEMS AND EVOLUTION: DEVELOPMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE AMONG THE RHIZOMORPHS OF THE LYCOPSIDS

This paper deals with a comparison of the rooted axes (rhizomorphs) of Isoetes with those of Stigmaria, Pleuromeia and other fossil lycopsids from the standpoint of developmental correspondence. The objective is to present a mechanistic approach to the problem of evaluating possible interrelationships among the genera. The results complement those from other comtemporary approaches to the same problem. These main points are advocated: 1) The rhizomorphs of Isoetes and Stylites correspond. Because neither of these contains an apical meristem, neither corresponds to Stigmaria with respect to organization of the axis or root production. 2) Rooted portions of Isoetes and Pleuromeia correspond, although external lobing in Pleuromeia parallels lobing of the stele, whereas in Isoetes external lobing occurs between the lobes of the stele. In both cases, lobing of the stele is associated with root production. 3) Paurodendron rhizomorphs appear to correspond to Stigmaria developmentally with regard to the presence of an apical meristem and the arrangement of roots, but Paurodendron rhizomorphs are shorter. If several lines of root production were added to the vascular cambium of the kind of rhizomorph seen in Paurodendron, a plant part like the rooted portion of Pleuromeia could result. Further extrapolations of the Paurodendron form of growth are explored for their bearing on comparison of rhizomorphs among the lycopsids.     

PAURODENDRON,A RHIZOMORPHIC LYCOPOD

From middle Pennsylvanian coal balls collected in Kansas and Illinois the ligules and rhizomorph of Paurodendron have been illustrated. Assignment of Paurodendron to the Lycopsida is corroborated. Discovery of the root-bearing portion of this Carboniferous lycopod establishes a diminutive, phyletic line in the Paleozoic with rhizomorphs smaller than many species of Isoeles. Paurodendron resembles the selaginelloid line more closely than other rhizomorphic types. Anatomical comparisons of Paurodendron with roots and root-bearing structures of lycopods are made; the root-bearing and a representative leaf-bearing portion of Paurodendron fraiponti have been reconstructed. The specific diagnosis has been emended, and the three species described by Fry have been reduced to one.     

FURTHER OBSERVATIONS ON NATHORSTIANA (ISOETACEAE)

The patterns of root arrangement and stelar morphology in the Lower Cretaceous fossil Nathorstiana are essentially identical with those of extant Isoetes. These structural similarities imply a similar mode of development in both plants and are used to infer an Isoetes-like, linear, root-producing meristem along the lower end of the stele in Nathorstiana. The root-bearing base of Nathorstiana differs from that of Isoetes principally in two respects. In earlier developmental stages, the rooting base of Nathorstiana was unlobed and radially symmetrical, whereas Isoetes is originally bilobed. Unlike Isoetes, which lacks stelar elongation and sheds its root-bearing cortex at the periphery of the cortical lobes, the downward growth of the root-bearing base of Nathorstiana resulted in the accumulation of a substantial extent of axial root-bearing surface.     

A new insight into the phylogeny of vascular cryptogams with special reference to Selaginella and Isoetes inferred from nuclear ITS/5.8S rDNA sequences

In order to provide a better understanding of the evolutionary history of vascular cryptogams, phylogenetic framework was developed based on ITS1, ITS2 and 5.8S rDNA sequences of 102 extant taxa of vascular cryptogams using Maximum Parsimony (MP) analysis. The analysis revealed high GC content in Isoetaceae (60.5 %) in comparison with Selaginellaceae (54.4 %) that was envisaged to be the result of variation in selection, mutational bias, and biased recombination-associated DNA repair within these two plant lineages during evolution. Transition/transversion ratio was observed to be 0.9 in Isoetaceae, 0.68 in Selaginellaceae and 0.57 among all the 102 taxa belonging to lycophytes and ferns. It is hypothesized that the lycophytes have been separated very early during evolution and therefore acquired independent line of evolution from the other plant lineages. Although Selaginellaceae and Isoetaceae are closely related ancient plant groups, pairwise sequence divergence of sampled taxa on the basis of transition and transversion, and disparity index values per site between sampled sequence pairs pointed towards the differential investment of natural selection process. These lead to high rate of nucleotide substitution within nuclear genome of Selaginellaceae with respect to Isoetaceae. MP phylogenetic tree identified Isoetes subinermis, Isoetes durieui and Salvia microphylla as separate group among the studied taxa due to high sequence variation within these species through the time of evolution. Our result interpreted the polyphyletic origin of ferns and provides valuable information regarding the lycophytes and their fern allies.     

THE ROOT APEX OF LINUM

Several developmental stages of primary roots of 13 species of Linum were studied. The basic pattern of root apex organization in three species consisted of a single tier of cortical initials. Ten species had a basic pattern of two tiers of cortical initials. Variations, manifested by either an increase or a decrease in the tiers of cortical initials, were observed in some roots in those species that had a basic pattern of two tiers of cortical initials. Although these variations were interpreted as being ontogenetic, there was no total reorganization of the root apex. There was anatomical and cytological evidence that a quiescent center is established in Linum roots.     

THE WOOL-LIKE COVERING OF THE ROOTS OF LANNEA ALATA I. THE ORIGIN AND MORPHOLOGY OF THE WOOLY COAT

Lannea alata (Engl.) Engl., Anacardiaceae, a tree or shrub of East Africa, has roots covered with dense wool-like hair. Cork cambium of the root produces a closely appressed cork from which the hairs (modified cork cells) arise. Cork cells and wooly hair are rich in sterol and carotin-oid-like compounds and have thick walls. It is suggested that the root wool plays a role in the soil-air, soil-water relations of Lannea alata and other plants.     

Casparian Strips in the Leaf Intrastelar Canals of Isoetes duriei Bory, a Mediterranean Terrestrial Species

Anatomical observations, using light and fluorescence microscopy,were made on leaves of Isoetes duriei to verify the presenceof casparian bands around the intrastelar canals. This peculiaranatomical feature, previously reported for some Isoetes species,is confirmed. The possible role of this endodermis-like structure,in the transport of water due to root pressure or in the accumulationof certain metabolites, is discussed in relation to the ecologicaland anatomical features of the species. Copyright 2000 Annalsof Botany Company Isoetes duriei, Lycopsida, Mediterranean, leaf anatomy, endodermis, casparian strips, fluorescence microscopy     

The quillworts (Isoetes) of India: distribution, endemism and species radiation

The genus Isoetes L. in India is represented by 14species, of which eight species are recognized as being local endemics [confinedto one particular phyto-geographical division (PGD)] while the remaining sixoccur in more than one PGD and are described as endemic to a wider range. Thelocal endemic species are Isoetes dixitei,Isoetes panchganiensis and Isoetessahyadriensis in Western Ghats region; Isoetespantii, Isoetes bilaspurensis, Isoetesreticulata and Isoetes tuberculata inChotanagpur Malwa Vindhya Plateau and Isoetes debii innortheastern India. The wider endemic species are Isoetespanchananii, Isoetes sampathkumaranii,Isoetes rajasthanensis, Isoetesmahadevensis, Isoetes indica andIsoetes coromandelina. Our studies on the patterns ofendemism suggest that the radiation of quillworts advanced from dry lowlandareas to the rainy uplands and mountains. Isoetescoromandelina is the first Indian quillwort to colonize in lowlandsof the coastal zone (Coromandel), from where it spread to different parts of thesub-continent and gave rise to new species. Thus this species is a key Indianspecies which has played an important role in the radiation of quillwort in thecountry and appeared as the connecting link among the quillwort flora of variousPGDs. The centres of diversity for almost all the presently known Indianquillworts species are recognized.     

Changes in the Rooting and Growth of Willows and Poplars Induced by Cadmium

Growth parameters of six fast growing trees showed that the roots responded to Cd treatment more sensitively than the shoots. Cd-treatment suppressed rooting and root growth (length and biomass production) as well as its development in all tested species. Root systems of Salix cinerea, Salix alba, and Populus cv. Robusta were more tolerant to Cd stress than the root system of the other studied species. Shoot growth parameters of Salix species were significantly reduced unlike Populus species, which were not affected by Cd treatment.     

THE COMPARATIVE AND DEVELOPMENTAL MORPHOLOGY OF THE ROOT SYSTEM OF SELAGINELLA SELAGINOIDES (L.) LINK

All of the roots of Selaginella selaginoides are attached laterally to the base of the shoot, which has monopolar growth as is characteristic of Selaginella. The first three roots are produced by meristematic activity in the cortex of the hypocotyl as in several other species of Selaginella. The fourth root is produced in the same way as the first three, except that not all of the cortical cells which become meristematic mature into root tissue. Some of the meristematic tissue remains undifferentiated and continues to produce additional roots. Potentially an unlimited number of roots could be produced, but no plant was found to have more than eight. There is some secondary growth in the cortex of the basal swelling on the hypocotyl, but no secondary vascular tissue is produced and no cambium of any sort is ever organized. On the basis of comparisons with other living species of Selaginella. the centralized root system of S. selaginoides is interpreted as having been modified from a noncentralized type of root system by the persistence of the juvenile mode of root production.     

COMPARATIVE MORPHOLOGY AND PHYLOGENY OF THE RANALES

Comparative morphological studies of woody Ranales have established the primitive status of the group and hence their key place in angiosperm phylogeny. Significant advances in our knowledge of some ranalian families have been made in recent years. An attempt is made in the present review to bring together a range of morphological data (vegetative and floral anatomy, palynology and embryology) on the Ranales (sensu lato), with particular reference to research work published after the publication of Eames's (1961) book, and to discuss the relationships of the families. Recent ontogenetic studies have shown that the carpel of Drimys is ascidial and not conduplicate as earlier suggested. The inclusion of Degeneria in the Winteraceae is not supported by morphological data. Melville's gonophyll theory has been shown to be inapplicable to the magnoliaceous flower. The pollen of Schisandra is interpreted as derived and specialized rather than primitive as previously supposed. The removal of Schisandra from Magnoliaceae is upheld by morphological evidence. Recent morphological studies do not support a close relationship between Schisandraceae and Illiciaceae suggested by earlier authors. The Canellaceae shows similarities to Winteraceae, Magnoliaceae, Illiciaceae, Eupteleaceae and Myristicaceae. Transitional types of division of pollen mother cells found in Winteraceae, Schisandraceae and Annonaceae and their probable phylogenetic significance have been discussed. The Annonaceae, Winteraceae, Degeneriaceae, Magnoliaceae, Schisandraceae and Cercidiphyllaceae share several embryological features in addition to similarities in floral structure. Ruminate endosperm is regarded either as an archaic feature retained in some taxa or as a later and parallel development in others. Thus its value in assessing relationships seems to be doubtful. Myristicaceae has been shown to be closely related neither to the the Annonaceae nor to the Lauraceae. The suggested relationship of Eupomatiaceae to Annonaceae is not supported by palynology. Floral cortical vascular systems in Magnoliaceae, Annonaceae, Calycanthaceae and Myristicaceae have been compared and it is concluded that they may be vestigial structures. A great deal of similarity has been found between Lauraceae and Calycanthaceae in wood, node, flower structure and embryology. Further floral anatomical evidence has been adduced to support the removal of Scyphostegia from Monimiaceae. The Hernandiaceae show similarities to some members of Monimiaceae while the Gyrocarpaceae resemble the Lauraceae, Gomortegaceae and certain other genera of Monimiaceae. Available evidence from wood and floral anatomy and embryology indicates close relationships among Lauraceae, Monimiaceae and Hernandiaceae. Vegetative and floral anatomical and embryological data seem to indicate a place for the Chloranthaceae in the ranalian complex. Recent anatomical studies in the Nymphaeaceae show that the floral structure is of a primitive type with similarities to the woody Ranales. Available morphological evidence is considered inadequate to express an opinion on the splitting of the family. Ceratophyllaceae is regarded as a highly reduced ranalian family derived most probably from a nymphaeaceous stock. The gynoecium in Berberidaceae is interpreted as monocarpellate. No evidence has been found to support the tricarpellate view. Berberidaceae, Lardizabalaceae and Menispermaceae share several embryological features, while at the same time showing evidence of specialization, each in its own way. Thus they might have arisen from a common stock and early diverged along different lines. The occurrence of several types of embryo sac in Ranunculaceae may well be an indication of specialization, but their probable taxonomic value, if any, is not yet clear. The occurrence of numerous primitive features in Paeonia has been suggested as an argument for its retention in the Ranales. No evidence has been found to preclude the inclusion of Dilleniaceae in the Ranales. On the other hand, as opposed to similarities in wood and pollen characters between Dilleniaceae and Theaceae, floral anatomical and embryological features offer a sharp contrast between the two. The Ranales are believed to be polyphyletic. It has been tentatively suggested that two major phyletic lines may be recognized in each of the woody and herbaceous series: the magnolialian and lauralian lines in the former and the nymphaealian and berberidalian lines in the latter.     

Construction of a bacterial artificial chromosome library from the spikemoss Selaginella moellendorffii: a new resource for plant comparative genomics

Background

The lycophytes are an ancient lineage of vascular plants that diverged from the seed plant lineage about 400 Myr ago. Although the lycophytes occupy an important phylogenetic position for understanding the evolution of plants and their genomes, no genomic resources exist for this group of plants.

Results

Here we describe the construction of a large-insert bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) library from the lycophyte Selaginella moellendorffii. Based on cell flow cytometry, this species has the smallest genome size among the different lycophytes tested, including Huperzia lucidula, Diphaiastrum digita, Isoetes engelmanii and S. kraussiana. The arrayed BAC library consists of 9126 clones; the average insert size is estimated to be 122 kb. Inserts of chloroplast origin account for 2.3% of the clones. The BAC library contains an estimated ten genome-equivalents based on DNA hybridizations using five single-copy and two duplicated S. moellendorffii genes as probes.

Conclusion

The S. moellenforffii BAC library, the first to be constructed from a lycophyte, will be useful to the scientific community as a resource for comparative plant genomics and evolution.     

HISTOCHEMISTRY OF THE RHIZOMORPH MERISTEM OF ARMILLARIA MELLEA

Histochemical studies disclose the presence of relatively large amounts of protein and nucleic acids in the apical region of the rhizomorph of Armillaria mellea. No specific center for the production of protein was noted, but nucleic acid studies suggest that RNA synthesis may be confined to a limited region of the rhizomorph tip. Intranuclear, crystalline protein bodies are present while selective fluorescent staining of DNA indicates that the relative amounts of that substance, per nucleus, may be quite small and may account for some of the difficulty in selective nuclear staining by more commonly employed methods. Large stores of glycogen in the area adjacent to the apical center and its apparent rapid turnover in that region implicates this polysaccharide as a participant in the differentiation of the primary medulla.     

VESSEL STRUCTURE OF GNETUM AND THE ORIGIN OF ANGIOSPERMS

Vessel structure of Gnetum gnemon L. and G. montanum Mgf. was investigated by means of light microscopy (brightfield, phase contrast and Nomarski interference optics), and scanning and transmission electron microscopy. The gyres of the first order framework are compound, consisting of three elementary strands (subunits). Pits ranging from slit-shaped to circular are formed either between the elementary strands of one gyre or between adjacent gyres. (Compound gyres are also figured for Alnus and lens-shaped pits in annular-helical elements are demonstrated for Juglans and Salix). In the two species of Gnetum studied, scalariform pits occur in addition to the well known circular pits. Scalariform perforation plates are present besides scalaroid, foraminate, and simple perforation plates as well as intermediates between the above types. These findings invalidate a common argument against the gnetalean origin of angiosperms, namely that pits and perforations of Gnetum are totally unlike those of primitive angiosperms and that therefore Gnetum must be ruled out as a potential ancestor of angiosperms. Variation in vessel structure of Gnetum is so great that it encompasses the typically circular pits of the coniferopsids as well as patterns of pits and perforation plates found in angiosperms. Some photographs of angiospermous taxa are interspersed with those of Gnetum to indicate the striking similarities. The determination of the patterns and shapes of pits and perforations is discussed in terms of four parameters: 1) the ratio of the width of the cell face to the distance between the gyres; 2) the types and distribution of the second order framework; 3) the stretching and distortion of gyres and/or second order framework; and in the case of perforations, 4) the pattern of wall and bar breakdown. Since the first parameter may change continuously, a continuum between circular pits or perforations and scalariform ones may occur. Such a continuum actually exists in Gnetum as well as in angiosperms. Patterns due to the other three of the above parameters are also formed in similar ways in both Gnetum and angiosperms. These similarities may, of course, be interpreted as the result of parallel evolution. However, when one considers the large number of angiospermous features of Gnetum, one is led to ask whether Gnetum may not have been close to the ancestral stock of all or at least some taxa of angiosperms.     

侧柏扦插不定根发生模式研究

该研究以侧柏一年生硬枝插穗为实验材料,利用连续组织切片技术观察插穗不定根发生发育过程中的组织结构变化,分析插穗外部形态变化、不定根原基起源和不定根的形成过程,探讨侧柏插穗不定根发生模式和不定根的组织学起源。结果显示:侧柏扦插后可由愈伤组织、皮部诱导产生不定根,出现皮部生根、愈伤组织生根、愈伤组织兼具皮部生根3种类型;侧柏插穗中存在少量潜伏根原基,但插穗生根类型以诱导生根为主;不定根原基诱导产生于愈伤组织、木质部、形成层及次生韧皮部等部位。研究认为侧柏扦插生根属于多位点发生模式,不定根原基的组织学起源是愈伤组织、髓射线、射线原始细胞、尚未分化成熟的木质部细胞,通过人工诱导同时激活这些不定根起源位点能够显著提高生根率和生根质量。     

Parallel evolution of auxin regulation in rooting systems

During much of the Palaeozoic Era, canopy vegetation was dominated by lycopsid trees (members of the Isoetales). Independently of other vascular plants, isoetalean lycopsids evolved bipolar growth, consisting of an aerial shoot system and the rhizomorph, a novel rooting organ. In this study we examine developmental regulation of fossilized isoetalean lycopsids by documenting the position of disrupted tracheary elements in secondary xylem. Such disrupted tracheids reveal the directional flow of signals that regulate wood development, allowing us to infer both the existence of, and the direction of, polar auxin transport in these extinct trees. Anatomical evidence presented here suggests that, in the isoetalean lycopsid trees, auxin transport occurred from the apex to the base of the aerial shoot system, then towards the apex of the rhizomorph, a shoot modified for rooting, thus mimicking the directional signal regulating shoot and root systems in seed plants. These data reveal that similar physiological mechanisms underlie the convergent evolution of bipolar growth in both isoetalean lycopsids and seed plants.     

Exogenous trehalose affects morphogenesis in vitro of jojoba

Trehalose is a stress protecting and reserve carbohydrate in a variety of organisms. The effect of trehalose on micropropagation of jojoba [Simmondsia chinensis (Link) Schneider] was investigated using a modified Murashige–Skoog as the basal medium (BM). Proliferation rate was significantly higher in explants grown on BM + 1 mM trehalose compared to that in the phytohormone control medium. In multiplication stage, shoot proliferation rate of 4.8 was achieved in BM with 4.44 μM BA and 1 mM trehalose. The rooting induction with 14.7 μM IBA had a significant effect on root regeneration; the highest rooting percentage (46.6%) was obtained with 7 days of induction. The incorporation of trehalose to the IBA-rhizogenesis media decreased basal callus but with trehalose alone, root development was scant. In vitro plants showed anatomical features typical for the acclimatization stage.     

Root evolution at the base of the lycophyte clade: insights from an Early Devonian lycophyte

Background and Aims The evolution of complex rooting systems during the Devonian had significant impacts on global terrestrial ecosystems and the evolution of plant body plans. However, detailed understanding of the pathways of root evolution and the architecture of early rooting systems is currently lacking. We describe the architecture and resolve the structural homology of the rooting system of an Early Devonian basal lycophyte. Insights gained from these fossils are used to address lycophyte root evolution and homology.Methods Plant fossils are preserved as carbonaceous compressions at Cottonwood Canyon (Wyoming), in the Lochkovian–Pragian (∼411 Ma; Early Devonian) Beartooth Butte Formation. We analysed 177 rock specimens and documented morphology, cuticular anatomy and structural relationships, as well as stratigraphic position and taphonomic conditions.Key Results The rooting system of the Cottonwood Canyon lycophyte is composed of modified stems that bear fine, dichotomously branching lateral roots. These modified stems, referred to as root-bearing axes, are produced at branching points of the above-ground shoot system. Root-bearing axes preserved in growth position exhibit evidence of positive gravitropism, whereas the lateral roots extend horizontally. Consistent recurrence of these features in successive populations of the plant preserved in situ demonstrates that they represent constitutive structural traits and not opportunistic responses of a flexible developmental programme.Conclusions This is the oldest direct evidence for a rooting system preserved in growth position. These rooting systems, which can be traced to a parent plant, include some of the earliest roots known to date and demonstrate that substantial plant–substrate interactions were under way by Early Devonian time. The morphological relationships between stems, root-bearing axes and roots corroborate evidence that positive gravitropism and root identity were evolutionarily uncoupled in lycophytes, and challenge the hypothesis that roots evolved from branches of the above-ground axial system, suggesting instead that lycophyte roots arose as a novel organ.