DEVELOPMENT AND STRUCTURE OF THE VASCULAR CONNECTION BETWEEN THE PRIMARY AND SECONDARY ROOT OF GLYCINE MAX (L.) MERR.

The primary vascular connection between primary and secondary root of Glycine max (L.) Merr. was derived from stelar parenchyma and pericycle. Inner stelar parenchyma, associated with the parent metaxylem and outer stelar parenchyma adjacent to the pericycle, were resonsible for the histogenesis of the primary xylem connection. Acropetal maturation of the diarch xylem connection occurred after the lateral root emerged from the parent root. Development of tetrarchy occurred distal to the diarch xylem connection. The concentric primary phloem connection was derived from the pericycle and outer stelar parenchyma. Acropetal maturation of the primary phloem connection occurred prior to lateral root emergence from the parent root. Secondary growth quickly augmented the primary vascular connection. A substantial amount of mature secondary xylem formed prior to maturation of the secondary phloem. The structure of the primary and secondary vascular connections is described.     

Effect of Lateral Root Formation on the Vascular Pattern of Barley Roots

The vascular pattern in the root of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), characterized by discontinuous xylem, is markedly affected by its branching. The roots become divided into unbranched segments alternating with branched segments with a more complex vascular pattern, formed by two systems differing in origin and age: the primary vascular system derived from the procambium and ontogenetically younger connective vascular system derived from stelar parenchyma. Adjacent to the sites of the lateral root initiation, reprogramming of parent stelar parenchyma for connective vascular elements occurs. The connecting phloem is represented by small sieve elements and companion cells, the connecting xylem is composed of small vessel elements with reticulate or scalariform-reticulate wall thickenings and simple perforations. Development of the connective vascular system secures continuous lateral and axial vascular connection between lateral root and parent root. The extent of the vascular connection in the parent root increases in an acropetal direction. Hydraulic effects of connective vascular tissue formation and parent root segmentation are discussed.     

STUDIES ON THE ROOT OF HORDEUM VULGARE L.– ULTRASTRUCTURE OF THE SEMINAL ROOT WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE PHLOEM

Seminal root tissue of Hordeum vulgare L. var. Barsoy was fixed in glutaraldehyde and osmium tetroxide and studied with the light and electron microscopes. The roots consist of an epidermis, 6–7 layers of cortical cells, a uniseriate endodermis and a central vascular cylinder. Cytologically, the cortical and endodermal cells are similar except for the presence of tubular-like invaginations of the plasmalemma, especially near the plasmodesmata, in the former. The vascular cylinder consists of a uniseriate pericycle surrounding 6–9 phloem strands occurring on alternating radii with an equal number of xylem bundles. The center of the root contains a single, late maturing metaxylem vessel element. Each phloem strand consists of one protophloem sieve element, two companion cells and 1–3 metaphloem sieve elements. The protophloem element and companion cells are contiguous with the pericycle. Metaphloem sieve elements are contiguous with companion cells and are separated from tracheary elements by xylem parenchyma cells. The protoplasts of contiguous cells of the root are joined by various numbers of cytoplasmic connections. With the exception of the pore-plasmodesmata connections between sieve-tube members and parenchymatic elements, the plasmodesmata between various cell types are similar in structure. The distribution of plasmodesmata supports a symplastic pathway for organic solute unloading and transport from the phloem to the cortex. Based on the arrangement of cell types and plasmodesmatal frequencies between various cell types of the root, the major symplastic pathway from sieve elements to cortex appears to be via the companion and xylem parenchyma cells.     

DEVELOPMENTAL ANATOMY IN ROOTS OF IPOMOEA PURPUREA. II. INITIATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF SECONDARY ROOTS

In seedlings of Ipomoea purpurea secondary roots are initiated in the primary root pericycle opposite immature protoxylem. Cells derived from immature endodermis, pericycle, and incipient protoxylem and stelar parenchyma contribute to the primordium. The derivatives of the endodermis become a uniseriate covering over the tip and flanks of the primordium and emerged secondary root; the endodermal covering is sloughed off when the lateral root reaches 1–5 mm in length. A series of periclinal and anticlinal divisions in the pericycle and its derivatives gives rise to the main body of the secondary root. The initials for the vascular cylinder, cortex, and rootcap-epidermis complex are established very early during primordium enlargement. After emergence from the primary root, the cortical initials undergo significant structural modifications related to enlargement of the ground meristem and cortex, and the rootcapepidermal initials are partitioned into columellar initials and lateral rootcapepidermal initials. Procambium diameter increases by periclinal divisions in peripheral sectors. The mature vascular cylinder is comprised of several vascular patterns, ranging from diarch to pentarch, that are probably related ontogenetically. Cells derived from incipient protoxylem and stelar parenchyma cells of the primary root form the vascuar connection between primary and secondary roots.     

DISTRIBUTION AND RELATIONSHIP OF CELL DIVISION AND MATURATION EVENTS IN PISUM SATIVUM (FABACEAE) SEEDLING ROOTS

Pea roots have open apical organization, where discrete initial cells do not exist. Differentiation of all tissues occurs in cylinders and vascular sectors that blend gradually with each other. This study reports the distribution of dividing cells and their relationship to maturation events in the 2 mm root tip, and in the 8–10 and 18–20 mm segments. Up to 200 μm from the root body/cap junction, cell division is uniformly distributed throughout all meristem regions. By 350 to 500 μ, xylem tracheary elements and cells of the pith parenchyma and middle cortex have stopped dividing. At this level cell division is almost entirely restricted to two cylinders, one composed of the inner root cap, the epidermis, and the outer cortex (outer cortex cylinder) and another composed of cells of the inner cortex, the pericycle and vascular tissue (inner cortex cylinder). When the protophloem matures, all cells in the phloem sector of the inner cortex cylinder, including the 1 layered pericycle, the endodermis and the phloem parenchyma, stop dividing. The 3–4 layered pericycle in the xylem sectors continues dividing until about 10 mm from the body/cap junction following the maturation of the protoxylem tracheary elements.     

ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF LATERAL ROOTS IN TYPHA GLAUCA

Lateral roots of Typha glauca arose from the pericycle of the parent adventitious root. Periclinal divisions of the pericycle gave rise to two layers; the outermost initially produced the ground meristem and protoderm, and the innermost produced the procambium. The immature endodermis of the parent root contributed to the early stages of the root tip as an endodermal covering. Prior to emergence, the ground meristem/protoderm produced cells into the endodermal covering. After emergence, the endodermal covering was replaced by a calyptrogen, which was derived from the ground meristem/protoderm and which, in turn, formed the rootcap. A typical monocotyledonous three-tiered meristem was then produced. An outer ground meristem also arose before emergence to form a hypodermis in many lateral roots; in these, crystalliferous cell production began in midcortex cells before emergence, and a small aerenchyma developed in their cortices. The rootcap columella stored small amounts of starch shortly after emergence. Lateral roots of T. glauca were smaller than their parental adventitious roots; they normally had only two to six poles of xylem and phloem, and the cortex was less than six cells across. During 1–3-cm elongation, the lateral root apical meristem and mature regions narrowed, stored starch disappeared, fewer crystals formed, aerenchyma production ceased, and the roots stopped elongation.     

MORPHOLOGY OF HUMULUS LUPULUS. II. SECONDARY GROWTH IN THE ROOT AND SEEDLING VASCULARIZATION

Miller , Robert H. (U. Nevada, Reno.) Morphology of Humulus luppulus. II. Secondary growth in the root and seedling vascularization. Amer. Jour. Bot. 46(4): 269–277. Illus. 1959.—In the primary state the roots of Humulus lupulus L. have a diarch xylem plate with 2 strands of primary phloem lying on either side of the primary xylem. Secondary histogenesis is described for the primary root. Fibrous and fleshy storage roots are developed by the hop plant and their respective developmental and anatomical structures are described. Lateral roots are initiated in the pericycle opposite the protoxylem poles. The architecture of these secondary roots is similar to that of the primary root. The seedling develops a fleshy storage organ through secondary growth of the primary root and the hypocotyl. The hypocotyl eventually resembles a fleshy taproot throughout most of its extent. The vascular cambium differentiates large amounts of parenchymatous tissues. A relatively smaller amount of tracheary tissue is formed. The secondary phloem comprises a high percentage of phloem parenchyma and ray cells containing numerous large starch grains, and constitutes the larger portion of the fleshy storage root. Numerous thick-walled lignified fibers occur throughout the secondary vascular tissues. Resin and tannin cells are abundantly distributed. A phellogen is differentiated from the pericycle and develops a persistent periderm on the outer surface of the fleshy storage organ. A relatively short transition region occurs in the upper part of the hypocotyl. The transition takes place from a radially alternate arrangement of the vascular tissues in the root to a collateral arrangement in the cotyledons.     

ONTOGENY AND STRUCTURE OF THE SECONDARY PHLOEM IN PYRUS MALUS

Evert , Ray F. (U. Wisconsin, Madison.) Ontogeny and structure of the secondary phloem in Pyrus malus. Amer. Jour. Bot. 50(1): 8–37. Illus. 1963.—The secondary phloem of apple consists of sieve-tube elements, companion cells, phloem parenchyma cells, fiber-sclereids, and ray parenchyma cells. The sieve-tube elements are generally long, slender cells with very oblique end walls and much-compounded sieve plates. All sieve-tube elements initially possess nacreous thickenings. Similar wall thickenings were observed in the differentiating fiber-sclereids and xylem elements. Of the 245 sieve-tube elements critically examined, 242 were associated with companion cells. All of the companion cells were shorter than their associated sieve-tube elements. Young companion cells possess slime bodies which later become dispersed. Callose is often found on the sieve-tube element side of the common wall between sieve-tube element and companion cell. In several collections, callose was found on both sides of that wall. The parenchyma cells are of 3 types: crystal-containing cells; tannin-and/or starch-containing cells; and those with little or no tannins or starch. Any type parenchyma cell may be on to genetically related to a sieve-tube element, that is, may be derived from the same phloem initial as the sieve-tube element. Morphologically, the phloem parenchyma cells intergrade with the companion cells, the tannin- and starch-free parenchyma cells often being difficult to distinguish from companion cells. Most of the tannin- and starch-free parenchyma cells collapse when the contiguous sieve-tube elements become nonfunctional. The fiber-sclereids arise from parenchyma cells which overwinter on the margin of the cambial zone and differentiate in nonfunctional phloem.     

VASCULAR CONNECTION BETWEEN LATERAL ROOTS AND STEM IN THE OPHIOGLOSSACEAE

The vascular connection between lateral roots and stem in the Ophioglossaceae and in two leptosporangiate fern species was examined. Two types of connections were found: “gradual” connections, which resemble leaf traces in ontogeny and morphology, and “abrupt” connections, which resemble the connections between lateral roots and their parent roots. Gradual root-stem connections occur in the genera Ophioglossum and Helminthostachys and in Woodwardia virginica. They are initiated in shoot apices distal to the level where cauline xylem elements mature. They resemble leaf traces in being provascular (procambial) strands that connect the cauline stele with the future vasculature of lateral appendages. As with leaf traces, gradual connections are part of the provascular and, later, protoxylem continuity between stems and lateral appendages. Gradual connections have many features in common with leaf traces, and the term root trace is applicable to them. The order of radial maturation of the primary xylem in gradual connections varies in different parts of the connections. It is endarch near the intersection with the cauline stele and exarch where the connections intersect root steles. Gradual connections resemble the transition regions of certain seed plants where protoxylem is also continuous from stem to root and the order of maturation is found to change continuously from stem to root. Abrupt connections occur in Botrychium and Osmunda cinnamomea. They develop in shoot apices at levels where cauline xylem is mature or maturing. The mature xylem does not dedifferentiate, so provascular and protoxylem continuity of the kind found in root traces does not occur. Also, reorientation of the order of maturation does not occur in abrupt connections. Xylem connectors are found in the region where radially oriented elements of the connections abut the longitudinally oriented cauline elements. Abrupt connections resemble the connection of secondary roots with their parent root systems since xylem connectors and the lack of continuity are also features found in these vascular systems. The resemblance of the vascular pattern of the fern root trace to the transition region of seed plants suggests that the radicle is more closely comparable to the cladogenous roots of pteridophytes than hitherto supposed.     

Resumption of DNA Synthesis and Cell Division in Wheat Roots as Related to Lateral Root Initiation

The arrest of DNA synthesis and termination of cell division in basal meristematic cells as well as the resumption of these processes as related to the initiation of lateral root primordia (LRP) were studied in tissues of Triticum aestivumroots incubated with ³H-thymidine. All cells of the stelar parenchyma and cortex as well as most endodermal and pericycle cells left the mitotic cycle and ceased proliferative activity at the basal end of the meristem and at the beginning of the elongation zone. Some endodermal and pericycle cells started DNA synthesis in the basal part of the meristem and completed it later on during their elongation, but they did not divide. In the cells of these tissues, DNA synthesis resumed above the elongation zone, the cells being located much closer to the root tip than the first newly dividing cells. Thus, the initiation of LRP started much closer to the root tip than it was previously believed judging from the distance of the first dividing pericycle cells from the root tip. DNA synthesizing and dividing cells first appeared in the stelar parenchyma, then, in the pericycle, and later, in the endodermis and cortex. It seems likely that a release from the inhibition of DNA synthesis allows the cells that completed mitotic cycle in the basal part of meristem in the G₁phase to cease the proliferative arrest above the elongation zone and to continue their cycling. The location of the first DNA synthesizing and dividing cells in the stelar parenchyma and pericycle did not strictly correspond to the LRP initiation sites and proximity to the xylem or phloem poles. This indicates that LRP initiation results from the resumption of DNA synthesis in all pericycle and stelar parenchyma cells that retained the ability to synthesize DNA and occurs only in the pericycle sector situated between the two tracheal protoxylem strands, all cells of which terminated their mitotic cycles in the G₁phase.     

The structure and development of the haustorium in parasitic Scrophulariaceae*

The structure and development of roots and haustoria in 37 species of parasitic Scrophulariaceae was studied using light microscopy. The mature haustorium consists of two regions: the swollen “body” and the parent root, which resembles non-haustorial roots in structure. The body arises from the parent root and is composed of an epidermis, cortex, central region of xylem (the vascular core), a region of parenchyma (the central parenchymatous core), and the portion of the haustorium contained in the host tissue (the endophyte). The xylem of the vascular core is composed predominately of vessel elements. The central parenchymatous core is composed of parenchyma and col-lenchyma. Vessels extend from the vascular core through the central parenchymatous core to the endophyte. The endophyte is composed of parenchyma cells and vessel elements. No phloem is present in the body of the haustorium. Early stages in the development of the haustorium are exogenous. Initial periclinal divisions in the epidermis or outer cortex are followed by hypertrophy of cortical parenchyma. These events are followed by development of the vascular core from the pericycle, attachment of haustorium to the host by a specialized layer of cementing cells or root hairs, and penetration of the host by dissolution of host cells.     

西洋参根的发育解剖学研究

西洋主根顶端的原分生组织由三群原始细胞组成。初生木质部为三原型。维管形成层产生的次生维管组织中薄壁细胞占主导地位;维管分子量少、聚集成群,分散在薄壁组织中。周皮加、周皮发生较迟,其木栓形成层由紧靠内皮层的皮层细胞产生。不同年龄西洋参主根随着龄龄的增加,周皮、次生真心皮部和木质部面积均呈增加趋势,但韧皮部与木质部面积比值自５：１下降至１：１。一年生根由中柱鞘产生初生分泌道,由维管形成层产生一圈次生分     

PHLOEM OF SPHENOPHYLLUM

The phloem of most fossil plants, including that of Sphenophyllum, is very poorly known. Sphenophyllum was a relatively small type of fossil arthrophyte with jointed stems bearing whorls of leaves ranging in form from wedge or fan-shaped to bifid, to linear. The aerial stem systems of the plant exhibited determinate growth involving progressive reduction in the dimensions of the stem primary bodies, fewer leaves per whorl, and smaller and simpler leaves distally. The primary phloem occurs in three areas alternating in position with the arms of the triarch centrally placed primary xylem. Cells of the primary phloem, presumably sieve elements, are axially elongate with horizontal to slightly tapered end walls. In larger stems with abundant secondary xylem and secondary cortex or periderm, a zone of secondary phloem occurs whose structure varies in the three areas opposite the arms of the primary xylem, as opposed to the three areas lying opposite the concave sides of the primary xylem. The axial system of the secondary phloem consists of vertical series of sieve elements with horizontal end walls. In the areas opposite the protoxylem the parenchyma is present as a prominent ray system showing dilation peripherally. Sieve elements in the areas opposite the protoxylem arms have relatively small diameters. In the areas between the protoxylem poles the secondary phloem sieve elements have large diameters and are less obviously in radial files, while the parenchyma resembles that of the secondary xylem in these areas in that it consists of strands of cells extending both radially and tangentially. An actively meristematic vascular cambium has not been found, indicating that this layer changed histologically after the cessation of growth in the determinate aerial stem systems and was replaced by a post-meristematic parenchyma sheath made up of axially elongate parenchyma lacking cells indicative of being either fusiform or ray initials. A phellogen arose early in development in a tissue believed to represent pericycle and produced tissue comparable to phellem externally. Normally, derivatives of the phellogen underwent one division prior to the maturation of the cells. Concentric bands of cells with dark contents apparently represent secretory tissue in the periderm and cell arrangements indicate that a single persistent phellogen was present. Sphenophyllum is compared with other arthrophytes as to phloem structure and is at present the best documented example of a plant with a functionally bifacial vascular cambium in any exclusively non-seed group of vascular plants.     

THE ONTOGENY OF THE PRIMARY THICKENING MERISTEM OF ATRIPLEX HORTENSIS L. (CHENOPODIACEAE)

Seedlings of Atriplex hortensis were studied to ascertain; 1) in which organ the primary thickening meristem (PTM) first differentiates; 2) the direction of differentiation of the PTM, and 3) the pattern of differentiation of conjunctive tissue. The PTM initially differentiates in pericycle of the primary root base 11 days after emergence of the primary root. It then differentiates in the transition region of the hypocotyl, mostly in cells of pericycle between pairs of vascular bundles. In the upper hypocotyl, PTM differentiates by day 20 in the inner layer of cortical parenchyma. In the epicotyl, PTM apparently differentiates in the inner layer of cortex, by day 24. Desmogic xylem differentiates from radial files of internal conjunctive tissue cells and desmogic phloem differentiates opposite desmogic xylem strands from newly formed cells of external conjunctive tissue. No interfascicular cambium differentiates in the root, hypocotyl, or epicotyl.     

Wood Anatomy and the Development of Interxylary Phloem of Ipomoea hederifolia Linn. (Convolvulaceae)

In Ipomoea hederifolia Linn., stems increase in thickness by forming successive rings of cambia. With the increase in stem diameter, the first ring of cambium also gives rise to thin-walled parenchymatous islands along with thick-walled xylem derivatives to its inner side. The size of these islands increases (both radially and tangentially) gradually with the increase in stem diameter. In pencil-thick stems, that is, before the differentiation of a second ring of cambium, some of the parenchyma cells within these islands differentiate into interxylary phloem. Although all successive cambia forms secondary phloem continuously, simultaneous development of interxylary phloem was observed in the innermost successive ring of xylem. In the mature stems, thick-walled parenchyma cells formed at the beginning of secondary growth underwent dedifferentiation and led to the formation of phloem derivatives. Structurally, sieve tube elements showed both simple sieve plates on transverse to slightly oblique end walls and compound sieve plates on the oblique end walls with poorly developed lateral sieve areas. Isolated or groups of two to three sieve elements were noticed in the rays of secondary phloem. They possessed simple sieve plates with distinct companion cells at their corners. The length of these elements was more or less similar to that of ray parenchyma cells but their diameter was slightly less. Similarly, in the secondary xylem, perforated ray cells were noticed in the innermost xylem ring. They were larger than the adjacent ray cells and possessed oval to circular simple perforation plates. The structures of interxylary phloem, perforated ray cells, and ray sieve elements are described in detail.     

VASCULAR SYSTEM OF LODICULES OF DACTYLIS GLOMERATA L.

The vascular system for the two lodicules in a floret of Dactylis glomerata L. was studied in serial sections. The floret stele contained a few modified tracheary elements and xylem transfer cells enveloped by a phloem of squat sieve-tube members and intermediary cells. A single sieve tube and associated phloem parenchyma exited the right and left sides of the stele and upon nearing the base of each lodicule branched and formed the minor veins of the lodicule. The minor veins underwent limited branching and anastomosing to form a small three-dimensional system which described an arc during its ascent in the adaxial portion of each lodicule. The sieve tubes in the minor veins extended halfway up the lodicule and contained short sieve-tube members with transverse, slightly oblique, or lateral simple sieve plates. The associated phloem parenchyma cells were intermediary cells, companion cells, and less intimate parenchyma cells. Intermediary cells terminated the minor veins and touched the distal ends of the terminal sieve-tube members, which lacked distal sieve plates. Although the transverse area of the sieve-tube members remained constant up the lodicule, the transverse area of the associated phloem parenchyma fluctuated.     

ONTOGENY OF THE PRIMARY THICKENING MERISTEM IN SEEDLINGS OF BOUGAINVILLEA SPECTABILIS

Anomalous secondary thickening occurs in the main axis of Bougainvillea spectabilis as a result of a primary thickening meristem which differentiates in pericycle. The primary thickening meristem first appears in the base of the primary root about 6 days after germination and differentiates acropetally as the root elongates. It begins differentiating from the base of the hypocotyl toward the shoot apex about 33 days after germination. The primary thickening meristem is first observable at the base of the first internode about 60 days after germination. It then becomes a cylinder in the main axis of the seedling. No stelar cambial cylinder forms in the primary root, hypocotyl, or stem because vascular cambium differentiation occurs neither in the pericycle opposite xylem points in the primary root nor in interfascicular parenchyma in the hypocotyl or stem. The primary vascular system of the stem appears anomalous because an inner and an outer ring of vascular bundles differentiate in the stele. Bundles of the inner ring anastomose in internodes, whereas those of the outer ring do not. Desmogen strands each of which is composed of phloem, xylem with both tracheids and vessels, and a desmogic cambium, differentiate from prodesmogen strands in conjunctive tissue. The parenchymatous cells surrounding desmogen strands then differentiate into elongated simple-pitted fibers and thick-walled fusiform cells that are about the same length as the primary thickening meristem initials.     

PHLOEM ANATOMY IN STAUROPTERIS BISERIATA FROM THE PENNSYLVANIAN OF NORTH AMERICA

Phloem anatomy in the coenopterid fern Stauropteris biseriata is detailed from Lower-Middle Pennsylvanian coal ball specimens from eastern Kentucky. Axes exhibit a cruciate-shaped xylem trace in transverse section. Phloem tissue completely surrounds the xylem, but is more extensively developed in the embayments between the xylem arms. Phloem is composed of elongate conducting elements with a few scattered parenchyma cells. Large and small sieve cells are present, with larger ones occurring in the embayments within the primary plane of symmetry of the axes. Large elements are approximately twice the diameter of the smaller sieve elements. Oval sieve areas and pores have been observed on lateral and oblique end walls of both large and small elements. The structure and composition of Stauropteris phloem is discussed in relationship to the available information on phloem anatomy in other fossil cryptogams.     

灵武长枣果实维管束韧皮部及周围细胞的超微结构特征

为了探讨灵武长枣果实光合同化物韧皮部卸载和运输的途径,该研究采用透射电镜技术,对不同发育时期灵武长枣果实维管束韧皮部及其周围薄壁细胞的超微结构特征进行了分析.结果表明:筛管/伴胞复合体及其周围韧皮薄壁细胞间在果实膨大前期富含胞间连丝,而韧皮薄壁细胞与周围库细胞以及相邻库细胞间几乎不存在胞间连丝,形成共质体隔离;筛管/伴...     

FINE STRUCTURE OF PHLOEM CELLS IN RELATION TO TRANSLOCATION IN THE COTTON SEEDLING

When special precautions were taken to permit killing and fixation of sieve elements before they were cut, sieve pores were found to be open. Companion cells were shown to be highly resistant to freezing injury and less plasmolyzable than phloem parenchyma. Plasmodesmata connected parenchyma to parenchyma, parenchyma to companion cells, and companion cells to sieve elements. Their general absence between parenchyma cells and sieve elements points to a specific role of companion cells in sieve tube functioning. EM studies of these cells revealed an ER system which connects the central core of the plasmodesma to the sieve tube. This system may be responsible for active sucrose transport. Callose was always present on sieve plates of mature functioning sieve elements even with the most rapid killing and fixing possible. Extra callose promoted by heating (45 C) an intact stem segment was found to constrict the sieve pores almost completely. Constriction of plasmodesmata in lateral sieve areas also was evident. Fine structure analysis of the blocking mechanism is in accord with evidence obtained by tracer studies.