Is the midsummer decline of Daphnia really induced by age-0 fish predation? Comparison of fish consumption and MDaphnia mortality and life history parameters in a biomanipulated reservoir

We analysed the temporal pattern of a Daphnia galeata populationand the development of the age-0 Ash community in a long-termbiomanipulated lake (Bautzen reservoir, Germany) during springand early summer of two successive years. In Bautzen reservoir,the age-0 Rsh-Daphnia interaction is a key process within thefood web due to the low abundance of adult zooplanktivorousfish. Daily consumption of daphnids by age-0 fish, as estimatedby a bioenergetics model, was compared to daily mortality ratesof daphnids. In addition, we estimated life history parametersof Daphnia that may indicate predation impact by fish. A midsummerdecline of daphnids occurred only in July of 1996, whereas in1995 the Daphnia biomass remained >4 mg wet weight 1^–1for the entire summer. The percentage of total Daphnia mortalitydue to fish predation before the onset of the midsummer declinewas –2% day^–1. Temporal patterns of individual size,clutch size and size at maturity also indicated that the 1996midsummer decline of daphnids was not the exclusive consequenceof age-0 fish predation. Instead, low reproductive capacityof daphnids also contributed significantly to the decline. Consequently,year-to-year variation of the Daphnia dynamics may be determinedby a fine-tuned ‘timing’ between the period of reducedfecundity and the time of the strongest predation impact byage-0 fish.     

How do migrating daphnids cope with fish predation risk in the epilimnion under anoxic conditions in the hypolimnion?

The vertical distribution of Daphnia in experimental tubes isinfluenced by fish kairomone concentration in the ‘epilimnion’and oxygen conditions in the ‘hypolimnion’. Daphnidstrade off reduced predation mortality in a refuge against disadvantagesdue to unfavourable oxygen conditions.     

Life history of Daphnia galeata in a hypertrophic reservoir and consequences of non-consumptive mortality for the initiation of a midsummer decline

SUMMARY 1. Field and laboratory investigations were combined in a 2‐year study on the initiation of a midsummer decline of Daphnia galeata Sars in a hypertrophic reservoir. Quantitative field samples were taken twice a week, and, adult and juvenile mortality rates were calculated. Patterns of reproduction and survival of daphnids born during spring and early summer under fluctuating food conditions were determined in life‐table experiments. 2. The abundance of Daphnia increased strongly in early May and declined in June 1998 (midsummer decline). In 1999, Daphnia density increased only slowly in spring and remained constantly high throughout the summer. 3. Food conditions (concentrations of POC_{<30 μm}) for daphnids deteriorated in both years in response to increasing Daphnia densities, resulting in a clear‐water phase of about 4 weeks. When Daphnia abundance declined in 1998, POC_{<30 μm} concentrations increased greatly, whereas in 1999 food conditions improved only slightly and Secchi depth remained high. 4. Survival of daphnids in life‐table experiments decreased greatly after food became rare and was strongly reduced in those animals born during the clear‐water phase compared with those born later. In addition, age at first reproduction was retarded during the clear‐water phase, resulting in very low population growth rates. Survivorship patterns in life‐table experiments suggest a strong impact of non‐consumptive mortality on Daphnia population dynamics. 5. Field data of mortality point to differences in mortality patterns between years, probably resulting from different predation impacts of juvenile fish. In both years, however, adult mortality contributed substantially to overall mortality at the end of the clear‐water phase. As bottom‐up effects on D. galeata were very similar in both years, the significance of non‐consumptive mortality on the initiation of midsummer declines appears to depend largely on recruitment patterns before the clear‐water phase. A high impact can be expected when Daphnia populations are dominated by a peak cohort of nearly identical age during the clear‐water phase.     

'Shore avoidance' in zooplankton: a predator-induced behavior or predator-induced mortality?

The distribution of two Daphnia species dominant in near-surfacewaters of a eutrophic lake, Lake Ros, showed offshore-inshoregradients in density with a dramatic decrease towards nearshorewaters, suggesting a strong ‘shore-avoidance’ behavior.Much smaller body sizes and much smaller clutches in the nearshorefractions of the two populations, however, showed that the lowerpopulation density of each species in the nearshore areas wasrather a direct effect of high mortality selectively generatedin more conspicuous larger individuals and in individuals withgreater clutches that are more vulnerable to predation by littoralfish, mostly abundant perch juveniles. Hydroacoustic and trawlingdata revealed that young perch move offshore in the eveningto feed on pelagic zooplankton, but their feeding cannot beas efficient later in the dark when they eventually reach themost distant Daphnia patch in the center of the lake. High predationrisk in the littoral neighborhood may be considered an ultimatefactor behind the evolution of shore-avoidance behavior in zooplankton.     

Demography of a natural population of Daphnia retrocurva in a lake with low food quality

The hypothesis was tested that Daphnia exhibit low populationrecruitment in a lake with phosphorus (P)-deficient food, whereDaphnia populations failed to increase in response to greatlylowered minnow density. Egg ratio analysis was performed onDaphnia retrocurva from L110 of the Experimental Lakes Area,Ontario, in 1994. L110 has high food abundance (seston carbon(C) 100 µM C), but the seston is P deficient (C:P atomic- 600). Chrysophytes dominated the algal community. The fishcommunity in this lake was manipulated in 1993 and 1994 by theaddition of northern pike, Esox lucius. Zooplanktivorous minnowswere greatly reduced after the piscivore addition, but the expectedincrease in abundance of the Daphnia to this altered predationregime was not observed, If food quality constrains the responseof the Daphnia to changed predation, there should be low recruitment in the relatively sparse Daphnia population in this lake.Birth rates estimated by standard egg ratio analysis were <0.1day^–1 for most of the sample period. In comparison toannual averages from the literature, recruitment in L110 wasmoderately, but not dramatically, low. Daphnia exhibited pronounced‘normal’ vertical migration (up at night, down duringthe day) all year, and a strongly declining size at first reproductionthrough the season. Population density and birth rates seemedto show much less short-term change than previously observedin other lakes. Although the demo graphic predictions for foodquality constraints seemed clear, in situ demography unfortunatelyneither supported nor strongly rejected the overall hypothesisof food quality limitation in this lake with very high C:P ratios.Possibly, direct demographic effects of low food quality willbe difficult to observe in nature.     

Cyclomorphosis as a factor explaining success of a Daphnia hybrid in Tjeukemeer

Recent studies have shown that Daphnia hybrids are intermediate to their parental species for several life history traits, and that they combine advantageous traits of the parental species, thereby decreasing their risk of being preyed upon by planktivorous fish. In this study D. galeata, D. cucullata and their interspecific hybrid are compared with respect to cyclomorphosis and juvenile growth as a potential mechanism to avoid invertebrate predation. Helmets and tail spines are known to reduce predation risk, whereas fast juvenile growth reduces the period that Daphnia are vulnerable to predation. In laboratory cultures, I tested the hypothesis that, with regard to cyclomorphosis, juvenile hybrids are more comparable to the juveniles of D. cucullata, and with respect to growth rate, they are more comparable to D. galeata. The hybrid did not differ significantly from D. galeata in the time needed to reach 0.9 mm body length. In contrast, the relative spine and helmet length of juvenile hybrids were more comparable with those of D. cucullata, whereas in adult instars these characters were more similar to D. galeata. Thus during the first juvenile instars, the hybrids combine the relative long helmet and spine of D. cucullata, with the faster growth of D. galeata. This combination of characteristics might reduce hybrid vulnerability to invertebrate predation in field situations.     

Spatial and temporal patterns of sexual reproduction in a hybrid Daphnia species complex

Evidence for extensive interspecific hybridization among speciesof the genus Daphnia has been accumulating on a global scale.Although there is evidence for limited gene flow between taxavia hybridization, many species still maintain discrete morphologicaland molecular characteristics. We studied temporal and spatialpatterns of sexual reproduction within the Daphnia galeata–hyalina–cucullatahybrid species complex in a lake (Plußsee), located innorthern Germany. Allozyme electrophoresis allowed us to trackseasonal changes in taxon composition as well as the quantificationof back-crosses. Sexually-reproducing animals (ephippial femalesand males) were mainly found in autumn. The simultaneous presenceof sexual morphs of D. galeata and D. galeata x hyalina withthe dominant D. hyalina taxa makes recent hybridization, aswell as back-crossing, plausible. Males and ephippial femalesof D. hyalina were not back-crossed as were the parthenogeneticfemales. The low number of sexual clones of the hybrid D. galeatax hyalina might reflect its reduced fertility, although thesefew clones were detected in high densities. Only hybrid-clonesthat had a back-cross genotype (towards D. hyalina) exhibitedephippial females and males. This indicates that male and ephippialfemale production within the Daphnia taxa is not random, whichmight increase the chance for the parental Daphnia species toremain distinct.     

Dynamics of Daphnia hyalina × galeata in Castelo-do-Bode Reservoir: The effect of food availability and flatworm predation

Daphnia hyalina × galeata in Castelo-do-Bode Reservoir was regulated mainly by food availability during the summers of 1993 and 1994. Because of high temperatures and low rainfall in 1994, the reservoir was, apparently, more eutrophic relatively to 1993. Higher chlorophyll-a concentrations and higher clutch size in 1994 suggest that Daphnia population benefited from better feeding conditions in 1994. The analysis of the contributions from fecundity and adult proportion to birth rate variation suggest that vertebrate predation and predation by copepods were negligible factors as population organisers. A general decrease in the abundance of large crustaceans during the periods of high density of typhloplanid flatworms, in both years, points to the importance of flatworm predation on zooplankton. A decrease in the number of individuals in all Daphnia size classes was observed during the periods of flatworms population increase.     

Limiting effect of abioseston on food ingestion, postembryonic development time and fecundity of daphnids in Lake Balaton (Hungary)

During ice-free periods, seston ranges from 10 to 600 and averages29.2 mg dry wt 1^–1 in Lake Balaton, the largest shallowlake in Central Europe. Most (80–99%) of the seston consistsof 1–10 µm sized mineral particles. The abiosestoncauses permanent food limitation in the ingestion of the ediblephytoplankton (1–22 µm fraction) by Daphnia cucullataand D.galeata. The postembryonic development time of D.galeataincreases and its fecundity decreases with increasing abioseston.The fecundity and the mortality of D.galeata are balanced atan abioseston concentration of 20.0 mg dry wt 1^–1.     

Instar-specific mortalities of coexisting Daphnia species in relation to food and invertebrate predation

Instar-specific mortalities of Daphnia hyalina and D.cucullatawere studied from May 19 to September 29, 1988 in combinationwith invertebrate predator and phytoplankton abundance. Simultaneouslife-table experiments were conducted under semi-natural conditionsin the laboratory to estimate juvenile mortality in a predator-freeenvironment. Juvenile mortality by predation was calculatedas the difference between juvenile mortality in the field andin the experiments and was the most important factor for thedifferences in abundance of the two species. For D.hyalina juvenilemortality was higher in early summer and probably caused byselective predation by Chaoborus flavicans. Predation by Leptodorakindtii was probably more important during the rest of the summer.Estimated mortality by predation adequately explained juvenilemortality, except for a 3-week period in August. Decreasingflagellate densities in July were accompanied by increased juvenilemortalities of D.hyalina and D.cucullata in the life-table experimentsin August and coincided with a Daphnia population decrease.     

Environmentally controlled Daphnia spring increase with implications for sockeye salmon fry in Lake Washington, USA

In Lake Washington, juvenile sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka)strongly prefer Daphnia over other prey, switching uniformlyto Daphnia when the threshold abundance of 0.4 Daphnia L^–1is achieved. Using long-term Lake Washington data (1978–2001)and fry trap data (1992–2001) from a major tributary,we examined the following: (i) factors that predict Daphniapulicaria and Daphnia thorata increase to this threshold "switching"abundance, (ii) trends in Daphnia dynamics that may affect sockeyeforaging and (iii) temporal correspondence of Daphnia increaseand fry arrival. The winter abundance of D. pulicaria, in combinationwith basic parameters of spring conditions, was an importantpredictor of the date of D. pulicaria spring increase, indicatinggreater reliance on pelagic population dynamics (versus diapausehatch) than D. thorata exhibited. In addition, D. pulicariawas a more consistent prey than D. thorata, the latter exhibitinglarger population fluctuations. Thus, recently increasing D.thorata prominence could decrease diet consistency for sockeyefry. Additionally, the timing of sockeye arrival to Lake Washingtonand Daphnia’s increase to the switching threshold hasbecome less concordant, so that fry in recent years have hadto rely upon less profitable prey for longer periods. Long-termtrends and species-specific differences in Daphnia phenologymay affect fry through altering diet composition, with additionalimplications for other zooplankton withstanding greater predationpressure in Daphnia’s absence. Recent decades of warmingin Lake Washington are consistent with the warming of lakesworldwide, and complex phenological responses such as thosereported here may be common as the climate continues to change.     

Climate-driven warming during spring destabilises a Daphnia population: a mechanistic food web approach

Temperature-driven changes in interactions between populations are crucial to the estimation of the impact of global warming on aquatic food webs. We analysed inter-annual variability in two data sets from Bautzen reservoir, Germany. In a long-term data set (1981–1999) we examined the pelagic phenology of Daphnia galeata, a keystone species, the invertebrate predator Leptodora kindtii, phytoplankton and Secchi depth in relation to water temperature and the North Atlantic Oscillation index. In a short-term data set (1995–1998) we examined food web relations, particularly the consumption of D. galeata by young-of-the-year (YOY) percids and L. kindtii and rates of population change of D. galeata (abundance, recruitment pattern and non-consumptive mortality). The start of the clear-water stage (CWS) was correlated with winter temperatures. It started 5.8 days earlier per degree warming after warm winters (mean January–March temperature ≥2.5°C) compared to cold winters (mean temperature <2.5°C). However, the end of the CWS remained relatively constant. Predation by L. kindtii and YOY percids on D. galeata started distinctly earlier, i.e. by 13.0 and 6.5 days per degree warming, respectively, in years when the average May temperature was high (≥14°C) compared to years when it was low (<14°C). Significant reductions of Daphnia abundance in midsummer occurred only in years in which the mean May temperature exceeded 14°C. This temperature regime resulted in a match of over-exploitation of food resources by Daphnia during the CWS and strong predation by YOY percids and L. kindtii. Consumptive mortality increased at higher rates with a rise in temperature than net recruitment, resulting in lower Daphnia densities at the end of the CWS. Our data suggest that even low warming by 1.7°C during a short, but critical seasonal period, resulting in the coincidence of two or more factors adversely affecting a keystone species, such as Daphnia, may induce changes in whole lake food webs and thus alter entire ecosystems. Priority programme of the German Research Foundation—contribution 9.     

Interrelations between the vertical distribution of Daphnia and chlorophyll a in two large limnetic enclosures

This paper summarises the major factors influencing the daytimevertical distribution of Daphnia hyalina var. laciutris (Sars)in two large experimental enclosures (Lund Tubes). In both tubes,the depth at which the Daphnia aggregated during the day wasclosely related to sub-surface ir-radiance. On a few occasionsaggregations of Daphnia were found in ‘dark’ waterassociated with a deep chlorophyll maximum. On many occasions,however, the animals' light response per se ensured their aggregationat depths of maximum phytoplankton abundance. The most importantfactor influencing the dispersion of animals in the water columnwas the steepness of the light gradient. In turbid water verticalaggregations were well defined, whereas in clear water the animalswere widely dispersed around their depth of maximum abundance.Daphnia also tended to disperse in the water column when theirpopulation density was high or when food was scarce. A simplemodel based on surface irradiance, water turbidity and populationdensity explained the basic pattern of vertical distributionthroughout the season. The implications of these findings arediscussed in relation to the effects of zooplankton grazingand speculations on the adaptive significance of depth regulation.     

The importance of crustacean zooplankton in structuring rotifer and phytoplankton communities; an enclosure study

During the spring clear-water phase of 1993, an enclosure experimentwas performed in the mesotrophic Schöhsee (Plön, FRG)in order to assess the impact of crustacean zooplankton on therotifer and phytoplankton community. Among the crustacean plankton,calanoid and cyclopoid cope-pods were abundant, but Daphnia‘longispina’ reached the highest densities in thisexperiment. The colonial rotifer Conochilus unicomis was notaffected by crustacean plankton. The two most abundant species,Synchaeta peclinata and Keratella cochlearis, increased exponentiallywhen macrozooplankton had been excluded from the enclosures,but did not increase when crustaceans were present. Birth anddeath rates of K.cochlearis could be reliably determined inthis field experiment, suggesting that this rotifer specieswas mainly controlled by exploitative competition rather thanby mechanical interference or predation. Daphnia ‘longispina’generally grazed selectively on the smaller ciliates and algae,thus depriving the rotifers of their phytoplankton resources.The dominant alga, the chrysophycean Dinobryon, increased, whethercrustaceans were present or not, but appeared to be grazed uponto a certain extent despite its considerable cell size and colonialorganization.     

Size-specific swimming behavior of Daphnia pulex

Body length affects several aspects of the behavior of quietlyswimming Daphnia pulex Swimming and sinking rates were measuredat 0.033 s intervals during the ‘hops’ characteristicof Daphnia swimming behavior Larger animals swim faster, covermore distance, and produce more powerful swimming strokes. LargerDaphnia also sink faster, but the sinking rate scales as lengthto the 0 58 power, far lower than the power of 2 00 predictedby Stokes Law considerations. The number of hops s^–1 wasindependent of body size, although a theoretical analysis predictshopping rate (antennal beat frequency) should increase as bodylength squared. Turning behavior, measured as the ratio of displacementto total distance, during 5 s, is also independent of body sizeIndependence of several parameters of body motion and body sizeimplies that factors other than simple mechanics affect Daphniaswimming behavior     

Influence of spring warming on the predation rate of underyearling fish on Daphnia– a deterministic simulation approach

1. According to previous field studies in the biomanipulated Bautzen reservoir (Germany), a midsummer decline of the dominating zooplankter, Daphnia galeata, was suggested to be initiated by a simultaneous occurrence of low fecundity of the daphnids and a selective feeding of underyearling fish on mature daphnids. The timing of both processes was assumed to be triggered by spring water temperature. However, the field data were not appropriate for testing whether yearly differences in spring warming are strong enough to control the predation rate of underyearling fish on daphnids.
2. By combining field data on fish growth, feeding and population mortality, the daily uptake of Daphnia by a virtual population of underyearling perch (Perca fluviatilis) was simulated. In addition, the daily predatory mortality of mature daphnids was calculated independently. Scenarios with a warm and a cold spring were compared. Furthermore, the delayed warming of a pelagic zone of a lake versus a littoral one was simulated. Sensitivity of the simulation to changes in five parameters was tested.
3. In both the warm spring scenario and the littoral warming scenario, more daphnids in general and more mature daphnids in particular were eaten, compared with the cold spring and pelagic scenarios. The predatory mortality of mature daphnids was driven by the increasing gape size of growing fish such that in warmer years the fish reach earlier the size at which they can eat mature daphnids.
4. The simulation was most sensitive to changes in daily mortality rate of the fish and to the size at maturity of the daphnids. Since at least the fish mortality is also temperature‐dependent via the growth rates of fish, the predation rate of perch on D. galeata in Bautzen reservoir is substantially increased during a warm spring. This underlines the assumption that even a slight global warming may have a decisive influence on food web processes due to the fine‐scaled patterns of trophic interactions in lakes.     

Influence of different sized Daphnia species on chlorophyll concentration and summer phytoplankton community structure in eutrophic Wisconsin lakes

We conducted field observations on 13 eutrophic Wisconsin lakesdominated by either the larger bodied Daphnia pulicaria or thesmaller bodied Daphnia galeata mendotae. While Daphnia numericaldensities were not significantly different between groups oflakes, pulicaria lakes had much higher Daphnia biomasses andfiltration potentials than galeata lakes. Although we foundsignificant differences in chlorophyll (Chl) a between bothgroups of lakes during June, on a seasonal basis populationsof different sized Daphnia were not associated with significantdifferences in Chl a. Filtration potential per se was the majordeterminant of Chl a, regardless of which Daphnia species dominated.However, in pulicaria lakes, the clear-water phase started earlier,lasted longer, and was usually characterized by greater Secchidisc readings than in galeata lakes. For large blue-green algaesuch as Aphanizomenon, D.pulicaria appeared to delay bloom conditions,but ultimately did not prevent the alga from growing. Our resultssuggest that high densities of large-sized Daphnia are a desirablegoal of biomanipulation because they can attain filtration potentialshigh enough to increase summer water clarity in eutrophic lakes.     

The evaluation of the role of pelagic invertebrate versus vertebrate predators on the seasonal dynamics of filtering Cladocera in a shallow, eutrophic reservoir

An evaluation of the role of invertebrate (Leptodora kindtii) versus vertebrate (juvenile fish) predators in the dynamics of filtering zooplankton (Daphnia sp.) in the pelagic zone of the Sulejow Reservoir was conducted during summer from 1994 to 1996. Leptodora kindtii appeared in high densities (mid-July: 2–6 ind. l^?1) in the pelagic zone. Its predation impact on the dominant filtering zooplankter population Daphnia cucullata, expressed by consumption, was significant and accounted for a reduction of 10 to 51% of Daphnia biomass. Although D. cucullata was a preferred food of juvenile pikeperch in June, due to low biomass, these fish were able to eliminate daily only 0.1–5.4% of Daphnia biomass in the pelagic zone. Thus, the role of juvenile fish in the midsummer decline of D. cucullata density in the pelagic zone seems to be much smaller than that of Leptodora kindtii.     

Estimation of phosphorus metabolic rates of Daphnia galeata using a three-compartment model

A compartment model to estimate the different phosphorus metabolicrates in Daphnia galeata is presented. The model has three compartments:gut, metabolic pool and structural pool. Existing two-compartmentmodels used for carbon and phosphorus turnover in Daphnia donot allow estimation of ingestion and egestion rates. We extendedexisting two-compartment models with one more compartment, thegut, which allowed us to estimate both the ingestion and theegestion rates. Parameters of the model are estimated from asingle experiment of feeding unlabelled Daphnia with ³²P-labelledScenedesmus obliquus. Separate experiments with juvenile andadult daphnids were carried out in order to compare their metabolisms.This model permits a reliable estimation of the different metabolicrates of Daphrna in a single experiment and discriminates clearlybetween animals of different sizes.     

Comparison of fish and phantom midge influence on cladocerans diel vertical migration in a dual basin lake

Diurnal vertical migrations (DVM) behaviour of cladocerans was investigated in two mesotrophic Irish lakes connected by a canal, characterised by interesting differences in the presence of zooplanktivorous predators. In Doon Upper, fish (mostly juvenile perch and roach) and a little-studied phantom midge Mochlonyx fuliginosus (Chaoboridae) were found, but Doon Lower was solely inhabited by fish. As the presence of diverse predators may alter spatial avoidance behaviour of zooplankton prey in different ways, the aim of this study was to determine whether and how two predator types, fish and phantom midge larvae, have changed DVM pattern of cladocerans during day and night in Doon lakes. Two sampling series of phytoplankton, zooplankton, fish, and water physical analyses were conducted on 09–10 June and 19–20 September 2007 in both lakes. In the study conducted in June, under a similar distribution of M. fuliginosus and juvenile fish in Doon Upper, a reverse migration of Daphnia galeata was observed as a strategy allowing them to avoid both types of predators. However, in September, when M. fuliginosus lived in a 24 h refugium below the oxycline as a response to increasing predation risk posed by YOY fish penetrated the upper strata of water during day and night, reverse migrations of D. galeata were not clear. In Doon Lower, normal migration was observed as an advantageous behavioural response against visual predators (fish), in both large and small Cladocera species: D. galeata, Diaphanosoma branchyurum and Bosmina sp. Thus, our results indicate dissimilar migration patterns of D. galeata depending on the presence of one (Doon Lower) or two predators with different predation behaviour (Doon Upper).