Phosphorothioate-Based Site-Directed Mutagenesis: Extending the Basic Methodology

Abstract

The versatility of the phosphorothioate-based site-directed mutagenesis method has been extended by employing 5′-3′ exonucleases in the gapping reaction. Mutational frequencies of 70–95% were routinely achieved.     

New insights into the QuikChangeTM process guide the use of Phusion DNA polymerase for site-directed mutagenesis

The QuikChange^TM site-directed mutagenesis method is popular but imperfect. An improvement by using partially overlapping primers has been reported several times; however, it is incompatible with the proposed mechanism. The QuikChange^TM method using complementary primers is proposed to linearly amplify a target plasmid with the products annealing to produce double-stranded DNA molecules with 5′-overhangs. The overhang annealing is supposed to form circular plasmids with staggered breaks, which can be repaired in Escherichia coli after transformation. Here, we demonstrated that the PCR enzyme fills the 5′-overhangs in the early cycles, and the product is then used as the template for exponential amplification. The linear DNA molecules with homologous ends are joined to generate the plasmid with the desired mutations through homologous recombination in E. coli. The correct understanding is important to method improvements, guiding us to use partially overlapping primers and Phusion DNA polymerase for site-directed mutagenesis. Phusion did not amplify a plasmid with complementary primers but used partially overlapping primers to amplify the plasmid, producing linear DNA molecules with homologous ends for site-directed mutagenesis.     

5''-3'' exonucleases in phosphorothioate-based oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis.

The application of T7 and lambda exonuclease to phosphorothioate-based oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis was investigated. Oligonucleotide primers designed to introduce single or double base mismatches, an insertion or a deletion (each of 16 bases) were annealed to M13 phage derivatives. Double stranded closed circular DNA (RF IV) containing phosphorothioate internucleotidic linkages in the (-)strand was prepared enzymatically from these templates. A nick was introduced into the (+)strand of the hetroduplex DNA. This nicked DNA (RF II) was subjected to treatment with T7 or lambda exonuclease. Both of these enzymes were able to degrade almost all of the viral (+)strand when presented with DNA containing one or two base mismatches. Repolymerisation of the DNA after the gapping reaction, followed by transfection into E. coli cells gave mutational efficiencies of up to 95%. In the case of RF II DNA prepared with insertion or deletion primers these exonucleases could only partially degrade the viral (+)strand but were nevertheless highly efficient in such mutagenesis experiments.     

Efficient site directed in vitro mutagenesis using ampicillin selection.

A novel plasmid vector pSELECT-1 is described which can be used for highly efficient site-directed in vitro mutagenesis. The mutagenesis method is based on the use of single-stranded DNA and two primers, one mutagenic primer and a second correction primer which corrects a defect in the ampicillin resistance gene on the vector and reverts the vector to ampicillin resistance. Using T4 DNA polymerase and T4 DNA ligase the two primers are physically linked on the template. The non-mutant DNA strand is selected against by growth in the presence of ampicillin. In tests of the vector, highly efficient (60-90%) mutagenesis was obtained.     

Simple and efficient oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis using one primer and circular plasmid DNA template

A rapid and simple procedure for site-directed mutagenesis is described. This method uses only a single oligonucleotide primer with the double-stranded circular plasmid DNA as the template for mutagenesis. The phage T4 gene 32 product is included during primer extension in vitro to increase efficiency. Single and multiple changes as well as deletions have been obtained at an efficiency of 1–2%.     

''Sticky feet''-directed mutagenesis and its application to swapping antibody domains.

We describe a novel technique for precisely cutting and pasting two DNA sequences without using restriction sites. The method is based on site-directed mutagenesis and uses a long primer, generated by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), to transfer large segments of DNA into a single-stranded template. The primer anneals to the template by virtue of 'sticky feet' sequences (complementary to the template) which are introduced at the ends of the primer by the PCR. Yields of desired recombinants were high (approximately 36%) and the transplanted sequences (approximately 400bp) free of errors. We have used this technique to swap CH2 domains between two mouse antibodies, and find that this domain can carry features critical for triggering complement lysis, in addition to the C1q binding motif.     

Splicing together different regions of a gene by modified polymerase chain reaction-based site-directed mutagenesis

A modified polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based site-directed mutagenesis method used to splice together different regions of a gene by deleting hundreds of nucleotides of undesired sequences is described. This method was inspired by a PCR-based site-directed mutagenesis method developed by Stratagene (La Jolla, CA, USA); the procedure and primer design were modified to enable the method to generate deletions several hundreds of nucleotides in length with an efficiency of 80-100%, and to delete two DNA fragments simultaneously in a single PCR. This method should be useful for deletion of large DNA fragments from a gene.     

Parallel assembly for multiple site-directed mutagenesis of plasmids

A parallel assembly method for multiple site-directed mutagenesis of plasmids was developed here based on Golden Gate cloning. It takes advantage of type IIs restriction enzymes and T4 DNA ligase to assemble multiple DNA fragments into a plasmid by a defined order. This method can accommodate multiple plasmid mutagenesis at any desired position with all three sequence modification types (substitution, deletion, and insertion) simultaneously. Furthermore, it can be used to create otherwise difficult-to-make mutants-larger deletions and insertions and mutagenesis on larger plasmids. The processes of mutagenesis can be completed quickly by a single restriction-ligation reaction.     

Strand specific cleavage of phosphorothioate-containing DNA by reaction with restriction endonucleases in the presence of ethidium bromide.

A method for achieving strand specific nicking of DNA has been developed. Phosphorothioate groups were incorporated enzymatically into the (-)strand of M13 RF IV DNA. When such DNA is reacted with restriction endonucleases in the presence of ethidium bromide nicked DNA (RF II) is produced. All of the restriction enzymes tested linearised phosphorothioate-containing DNA in the absence of this dye. The strand specificity of the reaction was investigated by employing the ethidium bromide mediated nicking reaction in the phosphorothioate-based oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis method. The mutational efficiencies obtained were in the region of 64-89%, indicating that these restriction enzymes hydrolyse the phosphodiester bond at the cleavage site of the unsubstituted (+)strand.     

A rapid and efficient method for site-directed mutagenesis using one-step overlap extension PCR.

A rapid method is described to efficiently perform site-directed mutagenesis based on overlap extension polymerase chain reaction (OE-PCR). Two template DNA molecules in different orientations relative to only one universal primer were amplified in parallel. By choosing a high dilution of mutagenic primers it was possible to run an overlap extension PCR in only one reaction without purification of intermediate products. This method which we have named one-step overlap extension PCR (OOE-PCR) can in principle be applied to every DNA fragment which can be cloned into a multiple cloning site of any common cloning vector.     

A gradient PCR-based screen for use in site-directed mutagenesis

Site-directed mutagenesis is widely used to study protein and nucleic acid structure and function. Despite recent advancements in the efficiency of procedures for site-directed mutagenesis, the fraction of site-directed mutants by most procedures rarely exceeds 50% on a routine basis and is never 100%. Hence it is typically necessary to sequence two or three clones each time a site-directed mutant is constructed. We describe a simple and robust gradient-PCR-based screen for distinguishing site-directed mutants from the starting, unmutated plasmid. The procedure can use either purified plasmid DNA or colony PCR, starting from a single colony. The screen utilizes the primer used for mutagenesis and a common outside primer that can be used for all other mutants constructed with the same template. Over 30 site-specific mutants in a variety of templates were successfully screened and all of the mutations detected were subsequently confirmed by DNA sequencing. A single base pair mismatch could be detected in an oligonucleotide of 36 bases. Detection efficiency was relatively independent of starting template concentration and the nature of the outside primer used.     

Multiple site-directed mutagenesis of more than 10 sites simultaneously and in a single round

Site-directed mutagenesis is a powerful tool to explore the structure-function relationship of proteins, but most traditional methods rely on the mutation of only one site at a time and efficiencies drop drastically when more than three sites are targeted simultaneously. Many applications in functional proteomics and genetic engineering, including codon optimization for heterologous expression, generation of cysteine-less proteins, and alanine-scanning mutagenesis, would greatly benefit from a multiple-site mutagenesis method with high efficiency. Here we describe the development of a simple and rapid method for site-directed mutagenesis of more than 10 sites simultaneously with up to 100% efficiency. The method uses two terminal tailed primers with a unique 25-nucleotide tail each that are simultaneously annealed to template DNA together with the set of mutagenic primers in between. Following synthesis of the mutant strand by primer extension and ligation with T4 DNA polymerase and ligase, the unique mutant strand-specific tails of the terminal primers are used as anchors to specifically amplify the mutant strand by high-fidelity polymerase chain reaction. We have employed this novel method to mutate simultaneously all 9 and 11 CUG leucine codons of the Hyg and Neo resistance genes, respectively, to the Candida albicans-friendly UUG leucine codon at 100% efficiency.     

Development of a technique for multiple site-directed mutagenesis of the ftf gene of Streptococcus salivarius containing palindromic sequences

Attempts at site-directed mutagenesis of the fructosyltransferase (ftf) gene of Streptococcus salivarius ATCC 25975 using standard protocols were unsuccessful and resulted in a series of deletions. These deletions appeared to commence at points within the ftf gene where there were palindromic sequences which were capable of forming closed loop structures that acted as terminators under the conditions of mutagenesis. To overcome this problem, two modified mutagenic techniques were developed. They made use of T4 DNA polymerase in conjunction with either T7 DNA polymerase at 37°C or Vent DNA polymerase from Thermococcus litoralis at an elevated temperature. These methods eliminated the need for a single-stranded DNA template and allowed polymerisation through palindromic sequences to rapidly produce multiple site-directed mutations.     

Restriction enzyme-free mutagenesis via the light regulation of DNA polymerization

The effects of photocaged nucleosides on the DNA polymerization reaction was investigated, finding that most polymerases are unable to recognize and read through the presence of a single caging group on the DNA template. Based on this discovery, a new method of introducing mutations into plasmid DNA via a light-mediated mutagenesis protocol was developed. This methodology is advantageous over several common approaches in that it requires the use of only two polymerase chain reaction primers, and does not require any restriction sites or use of restriction enzymes. Additionally, this approach enables not only site-directed mutations, but also the insertion of DNA strands of any length into plasmids and the deletion of entire genes from plasmids.     

Site-specific forced misincorporation mutagenesis using modified T7 DNA polymerase

A new method for forced misincorporation site-specific mutagenesis is described. The method uses an exonuclease-deficient modified version of T7 DNA polymerase in the presence of one dNTP to force a misincorporation. Analysis by PAGE is used to monitor the efficiency of such misincorporation reactions. Brief extension of the terminally mismatched primer/template using the same enzyme in the presence of all four dNTPs is followed by chase/ligation using unmodified T7 DNA polymerase and T4 DNA ligase to give heteroduplex DNA. We have applied the method to mutagenesis of the Lac Z region of M13 and found that, using strand selection, efficiencies of mutagenesis at one site are greater than 50%. When the mutating dNTP is complementary to a neighbouring homopolymeric tract on the template, multiple mutation is observed and efficiences are lower. The method is more general than internal mismatch mutagenesis and, because of its rapidity, is more expedient than existing methods of forced misincorporation mutagenesis.     

用DREAM技术纠正人工合成基因中的突变

目的：介绍一种简便、有效的定点突变技术。方法：根据突变位点附近的DNA序列推导出氨基酸序列,再以此氨基酸序列进行逆翻译,这样在不改变氨基酸序列的前提下可以得到数目巨大的隐性突变体（silent mutants）,这些突变体中包含大量的限制性内切酶位点,选择合适的酶切位点设计引物用PCR技术扩增两侧DNA片段,然后以相应酶切融合这两个片段即可完成定点突变。结果：用该方法成功地在人工合成的含有缺失的可溶性组织因子基因的472位插入C,T两个碱基,校正了阅读框架,获得了预期的目的基因。结论：该方法简便、有效, 避免了多轮PCR和合成长引物导致突变的可能性,这种改进的PCR 定点诱变技术我们称之为“设计限制酶辅助突变”（Designed Restriction Enzyme Assisted Mutagenesis, DREAM）。此技术简单方便, 诱变的成功率高, 适于实验室常规应用。     

Variants of phage M13 DNA containing a fragment of the beta-galactosidase gene--a convenient mutation system for the study of oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis

A model system is developed to test oligonucleotide-directed mutations: T----C transition, T and C deletions (delta T and delta C), C insertion, double mutations (A----G, delta T), (T----C, A----G), and large oligonucleotide deletions (36 or 44 nucleotides). The system includes 9 variants of the phage M13 DNA carrying fragment of beta-galactosidase gene, and oligodeoxyribonucleotides partially noncomplementary to DNA sequence of this gene. Six variants are obtained by the site-localized mutagenesis, the other were described earlier. Induced mutations are easily tested by phenotype change of transformed bacteria (Lac+----Lac-); by formation or loss of the sites for BamHI and EcoRI restrictases; by DNA hybridization with 32P-labeled oligonucleotides; and by DNA sequencing by the Sanger method. The system is used to study the role of some factors, such as completeness of RF DNA synthesis, thermal stability of the oligonucleotide: DNA complex, quality of enzymes and substrates used in polymerase reaction, mutation type or the efficiency of mutagenesis. A number of unexpected mutations were observed in the course of oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. Lower yields of some mutants induced by oligonucleotides are shown to be due to the action of repair systems of bacteria.     

Multi-fragment site-directed mutagenic overlap extension polymerase chain reaction as a competitive alternative to the enzymatic assembly method

Methods for introducing multiple site-directed mutations are important experimental tools in molecular biology. Research areas that use these methods include the investigation of various protein modifications in cellular processes, modifying proteins for efficient recombinant expression, and the stabilization of mRNAs to allow for increased protein expression. Introducing multiple site-directed mutations is also an important tool in the field of synthetic biology. There are two main methods used in the assembling of fragments generated by mutagenic primers: enzymatic assembly and overlap extension polymerase chain reaction (OE–PCR). In this article, we present an improved OE–PCR method that can be used for the generation of large DNA fragments (up to 7.4 kb) where at least 13 changes can be introduced using a genomic template. The improved method is faster (due to fewer reaction steps) and more accurate (due to fewer PCR cycles), meaning that it can effectively compete with the enzymatic assembly method. Data presented here show that the site-directed mutations can be introduced anywhere between 50 and 1800 bp from each other. The method is highly reliable and predicted to be applicable to most DNA engineering when the introduction of multiple changes in a DNA sequence is required.     

一步法定点突变技术快速构建bsh基因突变启动子

目的：建立一种高效便捷的定点突变方法,为基因表达调控以及蛋白质结构和功能的研究提供技术支撑。方法：以构建单核细胞增生李斯特菌（Listeria monocytogenes）中编码胆碱水解酶（bile salt hydrolase,BSH）的bsh基因突变启动子为例,采用一对完全互补并带有突变位点的引物扩增携带bsh基因启动子的重组质粒DNA全序列,通过DpnⅠ消化PCR产物中剩余的甲基化的模板DNA,酶切后的PCR产物直接转化大肠杆菌,从而获得含有突变启动子的重组质粒。结果：通过一步法定点突变技术成功构建了bsh基因的三种突变启动子。结论：该方法简单高效,只要把握好对引物设计,高保真的DNA聚合酶、模板DNA的浓度以及PCR扩增程序的选择,突变成功率可以达到100%。