Dominant role of the 5' TAR bulge in dimerization of HIV-1 genomic RNA, but no evidence of TAR-TAR kissing during in vivo virus assembly

The 5' untranslated region of HIV-1 genomic RNA (gRNA) contains two stem-loop structures that appear to be equally important for gRNA dimerization: the 57-nucleotide 5' TAR, at the very 5' end, and the 35-nucleotide SL1 (nucleotides 243-277). SL1 is well-known for containing the dimerization initiation site (DIS) in its apical loop. The DIS is a six-nucleotide palindrome. Here, we investigated the mechanism of TAR-directed gRNA dimerization. We found that the trinucleotide bulge (UCU24) of the 5' TAR has dominant impacts on both formation of HIV-1 RNA dimers and maturation of the formed dimers. The ΔUCU trinucleotide deletion strongly inhibited the first process and blocked the other, thus impairing gRNA dimerization as severely as deletion of the entire 5' TAR, and more severely than deletion of the DIS, inactivation of the viral protease, or most severe mutations in the nucleocapsid protein. The apical loop of TAR contains a 10-nucleotide palindrome that has been postulated to stimulate gRNA dimerization by a TAR-TAR kissing mechanism analogous to the one used by SL1 to stimulate dimerization. Using mutations that strongly destabilize formation of the TAR palindrome duplex, as well as compensatory mutations that restore duplex formation to a wild-type-like level, we found no evidence of TAR-TAR kissing, even though mutations nullifying the kissing potential of the TAR palindrome could impair dimerization by a mechanism other than hindering of SL1. However, nullifying the kissing potential of TAR had much less severe effects than ΔUCU. By not uncovering a dimerization mechanism intrinsic to TAR, our data suggest that TAR mutations exert their effect 3' of TAR, yet not on SL1, because TAR and SL1 mutations have synergistic effects on gRNA dimerization.     

Structural requirement for the two-step dimerization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genome

Generation of RNA dimeric form of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genome is crucial for viral replication. The dimerization initiation site (DIS) has been identified as a primary sequence that can form a stem-loop structure with a self-complementary sequence in the loop and a bulge in the stem. It has been reported that HIV-1 RNA fragments containing the DIS form two types of dimers, loose dimers and tight dimers. The loose dimers are spontaneously generated at the physiological temperature and converted into tight dimers by the addition of nucleocapsid protein NCp7. To know the biochemical process in this two-step dimerization reaction, we chemically synthesized a 39-mer RNA covering the entire DIS sequence and also a 23-mer RNA covering the self-complementary loop and its flanking stem within the DIS. Electrophoretic dimerization assays demonstrated that the 39-mer RNA reproduced the two-step dimerization process, whereas the 23-mer RNA immediately formed the tight dimer. Furthermore, deletion of the bulge from the 39-mer RNA prevented the NCp7-assisted tight-dimer formation. Therefore, the whole DIS sequence is necessary and sufficient for the two-step dimerization. Our data suggested that the bulge region regulates the stability of the stem and guides the DIS to the two-step dimerization process.     

HIV-2 RNA dimerization is regulated by intramolecular interactions in vitro

Genomic RNA dimerization is an essential process in the retroviral replication cycle. In vitro, HIV-2 RNA dimerization is mediated at least in part by direct intermolecular interaction at stem-loop 1 (SL1) within the 5'-untranslated leader region (UTR). RNA dimerization is thought to be regulated via alternate presentation and sequestration of dimerization signals by intramolecular base-pairings. One of the proposed regulatory elements is a palindrome sequence (pal) located upstream of SL1. To investigate the role of pal in the regulation of HIV-2 dimerization, we randomized this motif and selected in vitro for dimerization-competent and dimerization-impaired RNAs. Energy minimization folding analysis of these isolated sequences suggests the involvement of pal region in several short-distance intramolecular interactions with other upstream and downstream regions of the UTR. Moreover, the consensus predicted folding patterns indicate the altered presentation of SL1 depending on the interactions of pal with other regions of RNA. The data suggest that pal can act as a positive or negative regulator of SL1-mediated dimerization and that the modulation of base-pairing arrangements that affect RNA dimerization could coordinate multiple signals located within the 5'-UTR.     

Role of the 5' TAR stem--loop and the U5-AUG duplex in dimerization of HIV-1 genomic RNA

The HIV-1 genome consists of two identical RNAs that are linked together through noncovalent interactions involving nucleotides from the 5' untranslated region (5' UTR) of each RNA strand. The 5' UTR is the most conserved part of the HIV-1 RNA genome, and its 335 nucleotide residues form regulatory motifs that mediate multiple essential steps in the viral replication cycle. Here, studying the effect of selected mutations both singly and together with mutations disabling SL1 (SL1 is a 5' UTR stem-loop containing a palindrome called the dimerization initiation site), we have done a rather systematic survey of the 5' UTR requirements for full genomic RNA dimerization in grown-up (i.e., predominantly >/=10 h old) HIV-1 viruses produced by transfected human and simian cells. We have identified a role for the 5' transactivation response element (5' TAR) and a contribution of a long-distance base pairing between a sequence located at the beginning of the U5 region and nucleotides surrounding the AUG Gag initiation codon. The resulting intra- or intermolecular duplex is called the U5-AUG duplex. The other regions of the 5' UTR have been shown to play no systematic role in genomic RNA dimerization, except for a sequence located around the 3' end of a large stem-loop enclosing the primer binding site, and the well-documented SL1. Our data are consistent with a direct role for the 5' TAR in genomic RNA dimerization (possibly via a palindrome encompassing the apical loop of the 5' TAR).     

Identification of the in vitro HIV-2/SIV RNA dimerization site reveals striking differences with HIV-1

Although their genomes cannot be aligned at the nucleotide level, the HIV-1/SIVcpz and the HIV-2/SIVsm viruses are closely related lentiviruses that contain homologous functional and structural RNA elements in their 5'-untranslated regions. In both groups, the domains containing the trans-activating region, the 5'-copy of the polyadenylation signal, and the primer binding site (PBS) are followed by a short stem-loop (SL1) containing a six-nucleotide self-complementary sequence in the loop, flanked by unpaired purines. In HIV-1, SL1 is involved in the dimerization of the viral RNA, in vitro and in vivo. Here, we tested whether SL1 has the same function in HIV-2 and SIVsm RNA. Surprisingly, we found that SL1 is neither required nor involved in the dimerization of HIV-2 and SIV RNA. We identified the NarI sequence located in the PBS as the main site of HIV-2 RNA dimerization. cis and trans complementation of point mutations indicated that this self-complementary sequence forms symmetrical intermolecular interactions in the RNA dimer and suggested that HIV-2 and SIV RNA dimerization proceeds through a kissing loop mechanism, as previously shown for HIV-1. Furthermore, annealing of tRNA(3)(Lys) to the PBS strongly inhibited in vitro RNA dimerization, indicating that, in vivo, the intermolecular interaction involving the NarI sequence must be dissociated to allow annealing of the primer tRNA.     

Dimerization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA involves sequences located upstream of the splice donor site.

The retroviral genome consists of two homologous RNA molecules associated close to their 5' ends. We studied the spontaneous dimerization of four HIV-1 RNA fragments (RNAs 1-707, 1-615, 311-612, and 311-415) containing the previously defined dimerization domain, and a RNA fragment (RNA 1-311) corresponding to the upstream sequences. Significant dimerization of all RNAs is observed on agarose gels when magnesium is included in the electrophoresis buffer. In contrast to dimerization of RNAs 311-612 and 311-415, dimerization of RNAs 1-707, 1-615 and 1-311 strongly depends on the size of the monovalent cation present in the incubation buffer. Also, dimerization of RNAs 1-707, 1-615, and 1-311 is 10 times faster than that of RNAs 311-612 and 311-415. The dimers formed by the latter RNAs are substantially more stable than that of RNA 1-615, while RNA 1-311 dimer is 5-7 degrees C less stable than RNA 1-615 dimer. These results indicate that dimerization of HIV-1 genomic RNA involves elements located upstream of the splice donor site (position 305), i.e. outside of the previously defined dimerization domain.     

NMR structure of the full-length linear dimer of stem-loop-1 RNA in the HIV-1 dimer initiation site

The packaging signal of HIV-1 RNA contains a stem-loop structure, SL1, which serves as the dimerization initiation site for two identical copies of the genome and is important for packaging of the RNA genome into the budding virion and for overall infectivity. SL1 spontaneously dimerizes via a palindromic hexanucleotide sequence in its apical loop, forming a metastable kissing dimer form. Incubation with nucleocapsid protein causes this form to refold to a thermodynamically stable mature linear dimer. Here, we present an NMR structure of the latter form of the full-length SL1 sequence of the Lai HIV-1 isolate. The structure was refined using nuclear Overhauser effect and residual dipolar coupling data. The structure presents a symmetric homodimer of two RNA strands of 35 nucleotides each; it includes five stems separated by four internal loops. The central palindromic stem is surrounded by two symmetric adenine-rich 1-2 internal loops, A-bulges. All three adenines in each A-bulge are stacked inside the helix, consistent with the solution structures of shorter SL1 constructs determined previously. The outer 4-base pair stems and, proximal to them, purine-rich 1-3 internal loops, or G-bulges, are the least stable parts of the molecule. The G-bulges display high conformational variability in the refined ensemble of structures, despite the availability of many structural restraints for this region. Nevertheless, most conformations share a similar structural motif: a guanine and an adenine from opposite strands form a GA mismatch stacked on the top of the neighboring stem. The two remaining guanines are exposed, one in the minor groove and another in the major groove side of the helix, consistent with secondary structure probing data for SL1. These guanines may be recognized by the nucleocapsid protein, which binds tightly to the G-bulge in vitro.     

HIV-1 viral RNA is selected in the form of monomers that dimerize in a three-step protease-dependent process; the DIS of stem-loop 1 initiates viral RNA dimerization

We have characterized the viral RNA conformation in wild-type, protease-inactive (PR-) and SL1-defective (DeltaDIS) human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), as a function of the age of the viruses, from newly released to grown-up (>or=24 h old). We report evidence for packaging HIV-1 genomic RNA (gRNA) in the form of monomers in PR- virions, viral RNA rearrangement (not maturation) within PR- HIV-1, protease-dependent formation of thermolabile dimeric viral RNAs, a new form of immature gRNA dimer at about 5 h post virion release, and slow-acting dimerization signals in SL1-defective viruses. The rates of gRNA dimer formation were >or=3-fold and >or=10-fold slower in DeltaDIS and PR- viruses than in wild-type, respectively. Thus, the DIS, i.e. the palindrome in the apical loop of SL1, is a dimerization initiation signal, but its role can be masked by one or several slow-acting dimerization site(s) when grown-up SL1-inactive virions are investigated. Grown-up PR- virions are not flawless models for immature virions because gRNA dimerization increases with the age of PR- virions, indicating that the PR- mutation does not "freeze" gRNA conformation in a nascent primordial state. Our study is the first on gRNA conformation in newly released mutant or primate retroviruses. It shows for the first time that the packaged retroviral gRNA matures in more than one step, and that formation of immature dimeric viral RNA requires viral protein maturation. The monomeric viral RNAs isolated from budding HIV-1, as modeled by newly released PR- virions, may be seen as dimers that are much more fragile than thermolabile dimers.     

The HIV-1(Lai) RNA dimerization. Thermodynamic parameters associated with the transition from the kissing complex to the extended dimer.

Retroviruses contain dimeric RNA consisting of two identical copies of the genomic RNA. The interaction between these two RNA molecules occurs near their 5' ends. A region upstream from the splice donor comprising an auto-complementary sequence has been identified as being responsible for the initiation of the formation of dimeric HIV-1(Lai) RNA. This region (SL1), part of the PSI encapsidation domain, can adopt a stem-loop structure. It has already been shown that this stem-loop structure can initiate the formation of two distinct dimers differing in their thermostability: a loop-loop dimer or 'kissing complex' and an extended dimer. We report here a study using UV and 1D NMR spectroscopy of the dimerization of a short oligoribonucleotide (23 nucleotides) spanning nucleotides 248-270 of the HIV-1(Lai) SL1 sequence, in order to derive the thermodynamic parameters associated with the transition from the loop-loop complex to the extended dimer. The temperature dependence of the UV absorbency shows an hypochromicity for this transition with a small enthalpy change equal to - 29.4 +/- 5 kcal x mol-1, together with a concentration independent transition which implies a monomolecular reaction. On the other hand, our NMR results don't indicate a dissociation of the GCGCGC sequence engaged in the loop-loop interaction during the rearrangement of the loop-loop complex into the extended dimer. Our data suggest that the loop-loop interaction is maintained during the temperature dependent conformational change while the intramolecular base-pairing of the stems is disrupted and then reconstituted to form an intermolecular base-pairing leading to an extended dimer.     

In vitro selection of RNAs that bind to the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 gag polyprotein.

RNA ligands that bind to the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) gag polyprotein with 10(-9) M affinity were isolated from a complex pool of RNAs using an in vitro selection method. The ligands bind to two different regions within gag, either to the matrix protein or to the nucleocapsid protein. Binding of a matrix ligand to gag did not interfere with the binding of a nucleocapsid ligand, and binding of a nucleocapsid ligand to gag did not interfere with the binding of a matrix ligand. However, binding of a nucleocapsid ligand to gag did interfere with binding of an RNA containing the HIV-1 RNA packaging element (psi), even though the sequence of the nucleocapsid ligand is not similar topsi. The minimal sequences required for the ligands to bind to matrix or nucleocapsid were determined. Minimal nucleocapsid ligands are predicted to form a stem-loop structure that has a self-complementary sequence at one end. Minimal matrix ligands are predicted to form a different stem-loop structure that has a CAARU loop sequence. The properties of these RNA ligands may provide tools for studying RNA interactions with matrix and nucleocapsid, and a novel method for inhibiting HIV replication.     

Modulation of homo- and heterodimerization of Harvey sarcoma virus RNA by GACG tetraloops and point mutations in palindromic sequences

Retroviruses harbour a diploid genome of two plus-strand RNAs linked non-covalently at the dimer linkage structure. Co-packaging of two parental RNAs is a prerequisite for recombination in retroviruses, but formation of heterodimers has not been demonstrated directly in vivo. Here, we explore elements in Harvey sarcoma virus (HaSV) RNA involved in homodimerization and heterodimerization with RNA of Moloney (Mo) and Akv murine leukemia viruses (MLV).By an in vitro assay, we found that HaSV dimerization specificity could be modulated by mutations in a decanucleotide palindrome (Pal) probably folded into a kissing-loop. Autocomplementary and non-autocomplementary sequences introduced into the putative loop directed the specificity towards formation of homodimers and heterodimers, respectively. Two stem-loop (SL) structures, both exposing a GACG tetraloop, enhanced the formation of stable HaSV dimers.A similar decanucleotide palindrome has been implicated in homodimerization of MLVs. Heterodimers between HaSV RNA and Mo- or Akv MLV were unstable, but could be stabilized by introduction of two point mutations in the putative HaSV kissing-loop, creating exact complementarity with Mo/Akv MLV palindromes. Moreover, such changes increased the HaSV RNA affinity for the two MLV RNAs. Similar to HaSV RNA homodimers, formation of heterodimers with Mo- or Akv MLV RNAs was induced by the presence of GACG loops.On the basis of these results, we propose that palindromic sequences act as variable determinants of specificity and GACG tetraloops as conserved determinants in the formation of homodimers and heterodimers of gamma-retrovirus retroviral RNAs in vivo. The complementarity of loop sequences in the packaging signal upstream of the GACG tetraloops might therefore determine homo- and heterodimerization specificity and recombination activity of these viruses.     

SL1 revisited: functional analysis of the structure and conformation of HIV-1 genome RNA

Background

The dimer initiation site/dimer linkage sequence (DIS/DLS) region of HIV is located on the 5′ end of the viral genome and suggested to form complex secondary/tertiary structures. Within this structure, stem-loop 1 (SL1) is believed to be most important and an essential key to dimerization, since the sequence and predicted secondary structure of SL1 are highly stable and conserved among various virus subtypes. In particular, a six-base palindromic sequence is always present at the hairpin loop of SL1 and the formation of kissing-loop structure at this position between the two strands of genomic RNA is suggested to trigger dimerization. Although the higher-order structure model of SL1 is well accepted and perhaps even undoubted lately, there could be stillroom for consideration to depict the functional SL1 structure while in vivo (in virion or cell).

Results

In this study, we performed several analyses to identify the nucleotides and/or basepairing within SL1 which are necessary for HIV-1 genome dimerization, encapsidation, recombination and infectivity. We unexpectedly found that some nucleotides that are believed to contribute the formation of the stem do not impact dimerization or infectivity. On the other hand, we found that one G–C basepair involved in stem formation may serve as an alternative dimer interactive site. We also report on our further investigation of the roles of the palindromic sequences on viral replication. Collectively, we aim to assemble a more-comprehensive functional map of SL1 on the HIV-1 viral life cycle.

Conclusion

We discovered several possibilities for a novel structure of SL1 in HIV-1 DLS. The newly proposed structure model suggested that the hairpin loop of SL1 appeared larger, and genome dimerization process might consist of more complicated mechanism than previously understood. Further investigations would be still required to fully understand the genome packaging and dimerization of HIV.

     

Mutation of mapped TIA-1/TIAR binding sites in the 3' terminal stem-loop of West Nile virus minus-strand RNA in an infectious clone negatively affects genomic RNA amplification

Previous data showed that the cellular proteins TIA-1 and TIAR bound specifically to the West Nile virus 3' minus-strand stem-loop [WNV3'(-)SL] RNA (37) and colocalized with flavivirus replication complexes in WNV- and dengue virus-infected cells (21). In the present study, the sites on the WNV3'(-)SL RNA required for efficient in vitro T-cell intracellular antigen-related (TIAR) and T-cell intracellular antigen-1 (TIA-1) protein binding were mapped to short AU sequences (UAAUU) located in two internal loops of the WNV3'(-)SL RNA structure. Infectious clone RNAs with all or most of the binding site nucleotides in one of the 3' (-)SL loops deleted or substituted did not produce detectable virus after transfection or subsequent passage. With one exception, deletion/mutation of a single terminal nucleotide in one of the binding sequences had little effect on the efficiency of protein binding or virus production, but mutation of a nucleotide in the middle of a binding sequence reduced both the in vitro protein binding efficiency and virus production. Plaque size, intracellular genomic RNA levels, and virus production progressively decreased with decreasing in vitro TIAR/TIA-1 binding activity, but the translation efficiency of the various mutant RNAs was similar to that of the parental RNA. Several of the mutant RNAs that inefficiently interacted with TIAR/TIA-1 in vitro rapidly reverted in vivo, indicating that they could replicate at a low level and suggesting that an interaction between TIAR/TIA-1 and the viral 3'(-)SL RNA is not required for initial low-level symmetric RNA replication but instead facilitates the subsequent asymmetric amplification of genome RNA from the minus-strand template.     

Insight into the intrinsic flexibility of the SL1 stem-loop from genomic RNA of HIV-1 as probed by molecular dynamics simulation

The SL1 stem-loop is the dimerization initiation site for linking the two copies of the RNA forming the HIV-1 genome. The 26 nucleotides stem contains a defect consisting on a highly conserved G-rich 1-3 asymmetrical internal loop, which is a major site for nucleocapsid protein binding. Several NMR attempts were undertaken to determine the internal loop structure in the SL1 monomer. However, the RNA constructs used in the different studies were largely mutated, in particular with replacement of the nine nucleotides apical loop by a tetraloop, and divergent results were obtained ranging from a rigid structure to a particularly large flexibility. To investigate the reasons for such discrepancies, we used molecular dynamics simulation of the SL1 monomer to probe the effect of mutations on the conformational stability of the internal loop and of the whole stem. It is found that in the wild-type sequence, the internal loop displays conformational variability originating mainly from the nine nucleotides apical loop flexibility that causes large conformational fluctuations (without changing the average structure) in the 7 bp duplex linking the apical and internal loops. The large amplitude atomic motions in the duplex are transmitted to the internal loop in which they induce conformational changes characterized by a labile hydrogen bond network such as G5 successively H-bonded to A29 and G30. On the contrary, with a four nucleotides apical loop, conformational fluctuations in the duplex are reduced by a factor of 2 and are not sufficiently energizing for promoting changes in the internal loop structure at the time scale of the simulations.     

Possible role of dimerization in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genome RNA packaging

The dimer initiation site/dimer linkage sequence (DIS/DLS) region in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA genome is suggested to play important roles in various steps of the virus life cycle. However, due to the presence of a putative DIS/DLS region located within the encapsidation signal region (E/psi), it is difficult to perform a mutational analysis of DIS/DLS without affecting the packaging of RNA into virions. Recently, we demonstrated that duplication of the DIS/DLS region in viral RNA caused the production of partially monomeric RNAs in virions, indicating that the region indeed mediated RNA-RNA interaction. We utilized this system to assess the precise location of DIS/DLS in the 5' region of the HIV-1 genome with minimum effect on RNA packaging. We found that the entire lower stem of the U5/L stem-loop was required for packaging, whereas the region important for dimer formation was only 10 bases long within the lower stem of the U5/L stem-loop. The R/U5 stem-loop was required for RNA packaging but was completely dispensable for dimer formation. The SL1 lower stem was important for both dimerization and packaging, but surprisingly, deletion of the palindromic sequence at the top of the loop only partially affected dimerization. These results clearly indicated that the E/psi of HIV-1 is much larger than the DIS/DLS and that the primary DIS/DLS is completely included in the E/psi. Therefore, it is suggested that RNA dimerization is a part of RNA packaging, which requires multiple steps.     

Requirements for kissing-loop-mediated dimerization of human immunodeficiency virus RNA.

Sequences from the 5' end of type 1 human immunodeficiency virus RNA dimerize spontaneously in vitro in a reaction thought to mimic the initial step of genomic dimerization in vivo. Dimer initiation has been proposed to occur through a "kissing-loop" interaction involving a specific RNA stem-loop element designated SL1: the RNA strands first interact by base pairing through a six-base GC-rich palindrome in the loop of SL1, whose stems then isomerize to form a longer interstrand duplex. We now report a mutational analysis aimed at defining the features of SL1 RNA sequence and secondary structure required for in vitro dimer formation. Our results confirm that mutations which destroy complementarity in the SL1 loop abolish homodimer formation, but that certain complementary loop mutants can heterodimerize. However, complementarity was not sufficient to ensure dimerization, even between GC-rich loops, implying that specific loop sequences may be needed to maintain a conformation that is competent for initial dimer contact; the central GC pair of the loop palindrome appeared critical in this regard, as did two or three A residues which normally flank the palindrome. Neither the four-base bulge normally found in the SL1 stem nor the specific sequence of the stem itself was essential for the interaction; however, the stem structure was required, because interstrand complementarity alone did not support dimer formation. Electron microscopic analysis indicated that the RNA dimers formed in vitro morphologically resembled those isolated previously from retroviral particles. These results fully support the kissing-loop model and may provide a framework for systematically manipulating genomic dimerization in type 1 human immunodeficiency virus virions.     

A heterologous, high-affinity RNA ligand for human immunodeficiency virus Gag protein has RNA packaging activity

Retroviral RNA encapsidation depends on the specific binding of Gag proteins to packaging (psi) signals in genomic RNA. We investigated whether an in vitro-selected, high-affinity RNA ligand for the nucleocapsid (NC) portion of the Gag protein from human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) could mediate packaging into HIV-1 virions. We find that this ligand can functionally substitute for one of the Gag-binding elements (termed SL3) in the HIV-1 psi locus to support packaging and viral infectivity in cis. By contrast, this ligand, which fails to dimerize spontaneously in vitro, is unable to replace a different psi element (termed SL1) which is required for both Gag binding and dimerization of the HIV-1 genome. A single point mutation within the ligand that eliminates high-affinity in vitro Gag binding also abolishes its packaging activity at the SL3 position. These results demonstrate that specific binding of Gag or NC protein is a critical determinant of genomic RNA packaging.