The role of succinate dehydrogenase and oxaloacetate in metabolic suppression during hibernation and arousal

Hibernation elicits a major reduction in whole-animal O₂ consumption that corresponds with active suppression of liver mitochondrial electron transport capacity at, or downstream of, succinate dehydrogenase (SDH). During arousal from the torpor phase of hibernation this suppression is reversed and metabolic rates rise dramatically. In this study, we used the 13-lined ground squirrel (Ictidomys tridecemlineatus) to assess isolated liver mitochondrial respiration during the torpor phase of hibernation and various stages of arousal to elucidate a potential role of SDH in metabolic suppression. State 3 and state 4 respiration rates were seven- and threefold lower in torpor compared with the summer-active and interbout euthermic states. Respiration rates increased during arousal so that when body temperature reached 30°C in late arousal, state 3 and state 4 respiration were 3.3- and 1.8-fold greater than during torpor, respectively. SDH activity was 72% higher in interbout euthermia than in torpor. Pre-incubating with isocitrate [to alleviate oxaloacetate (OAA) inhibition] increased state 3 respiration rate during torpor by 91%, but this rate was still fourfold lower than that measured in interbout euthermia. Isocitrate pre-incubation also eliminated differences in SDH activity among hibernation bout stages. OAA concentration correlated negatively with both respiration rates and SDH activity. These data suggest that OAA reversibly inhibits SDH in torpor, but cannot fully account for the drastic metabolic suppression observed during this hibernation phase.     

Remodeling mitochondrial membranes during arousal from hibernation

During arousal from hibernation, body temperature (T(b)) increases by ～30°C and liver mitochondrial respiration increases threefold in as little as 2 h. We analyzed liver mitochondria purified from ground squirrels (Ictidomys tridecemlineatus) to see whether membrane phospholipids were remodeled during spontaneous arousal. Cardiolipin content did not change among animals in torpor (T ～ 5°C), the early phase of arousal (T ～ 15°C), late arousal (T ～ 30°C), interbout euthermia (T ～ 37°C), and summer-active animals (T ～ 37°C) that do not hibernate. Phosphatidylcholine content increased in late arousal relative to interbout euthermia, while phosphatidylethanolamine decreased. Phospholipid monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs) did not change throughout arousal, but polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) and MUFA/PUFA decreased and increased, respectively. In the fatty acid conjugates of phospholipids, neither unsaturation index nor n-3/n-6 differed. Few changes in individual fatty acids were noted, but palmitoleic acid (16:1, n-7) was higher in interbout euthermia and summer. Although 16:1 accounted for less than 1.5% of phospholipid fatty acids, it correlated strongly and positively with succinate-fueled state 3 mitochondrial respiration. No other phospholipid characteristic measured here correlated with mitochondrial respiration. These data show that mitochondrial membranes are remodeled rapidly during arousal, but the contribution to reversible suppression of mitochondrial respiration remains unclear.     

Reversible depression of oxygen consumption in isolated liver mitochondria during hibernation

The biochemical mechanisms by which hibernators cool as they enter torpor are not fully understood. In order to examine whether rates of substrate oxidation vary as a function of hibernation, liver mitochondria were isolated from telemetered ground squirrels (Spermophilus lateralis) in five phases of their annual hibernation cycle: summer active, and torpid, interbout aroused, entrance, and arousing hibernators. Rates of state 3 and state 4 respiration were measured in vitro at 25 degrees C. Relative to mitochondria from summer-active animals, rates of state 3 respiration were significantly depressed in mitochondria from torpid animals yet fully restored during interbout arousals. These findings indicate that a depression of ADP-dependent respiration in liver mitochondria occurs during torpor and is reversed during the interbout arousals to euthermia. Because this inhibition was determined to be temporally independent of entrance and arousal, it is unlikely that active suppression of state 3 respiration causes entrance into torpor by facilitating metabolic depression. In contrast to the observed depression of state 3 respiration in torpid animals, state 4 respiration did not differ significantly among any of the five groups, suggesting that alterations in proton leak are not contributing appreciably to downregulation of respiration in hibernation.     

Comparison of hibernation, estivation and daily torpor in the edible dormouse, Glis glis

Three major forms of dormancy in mammals have been classified: hibernation in endotherms is characterised by reduced metabolic rate (MR) and body temperature (T _b) near ambient temperature (T _a) over prolonged times in the winter. Estivation is a similar form of dormancy in a dry and hot environment during summertime. Daily torpor is defined as reduced MR and T _b lower than 32 °C, limited to a duration of less than 24 h. The edible dormouse (Glis glis) is capable for all three distinct forms of dormancy. During periods of food restriction and/or low T _a, daily torpor is displayed throughout the year, alternating with hibernation and estivation in winter and summer respectively. We recorded T _b, O₂-consumption and CO₂-production in unrestrained dormice at different T _a's for periods of up to several months. Cooling rate and rate of metabolic depression during entrance into the torpid state was identical in all three forms of dormancy. The same was true for thermal conductance, maximum heat production, duration of arousal and cost of an arousal. The only difference between hibernation and daily torpor was found in the bout duration. A daily torpor bout lasted 3–21 h, a hibernation bout 39–768 h. As a consequence of prolonged duration, MR, T _b and also the T _b − T _a gradient decreased to lower values during hibernation bouts when compared to daily torpor bouts. Our findings suggest that all three forms of dormancy are based on the same physiological mechanism of thermal and metabolic regulation. Accepted: 27 June 2000     

Substrate-specific changes in mitochondrial respiration in skeletal and cardiac muscle of hibernating thirteen-lined ground squirrels

During torpor, the metabolic rate (MR) of thirteen-lined ground squirrels (Ictidomys tridecemlineatus) is considerably lower relative to euthermia, resulting in part from temperature-independent mitochondrial metabolic suppression in liver and skeletal muscle, which together account for ~40 % of basal MR. Although heart accounts for very little (<0.5 %) of basal MR, in the present study, we showed that respiration rates were decreased up to 60 % during torpor in both subsarcolemmal (SS) and intermyofibrillar (IM) mitochondria from cardiac muscle. We further demonstrated pronounced seasonal (summer vs. winter [i.e., interbout] euthermia) changes in respiration rates in both mitochondrial subpopulations in this tissue, consistent with a shift in fuel use away from carbohydrates and proteins and towards fatty acids and ketones. By contrast, these seasonal changes in respiration rates were not observed in either SS or IM mitochondria isolated from hind limb skeletal muscle. Both populations of skeletal muscle mitochondria, however, did exhibit metabolic suppression during torpor, and this suppression was 2- to 3-fold greater in IM mitochondria, which provide ATP for Ca²⁺- and myosin ATPases, the activities of which are likely quite low in skeletal muscle during torpor because animals are immobile. Finally, these changes in mitochondrial respiration rates were still evident when standardized to citrate synthase activity rather than to total mitochondrial protein.     

Daily torpor in the gray mouse lemur (Microcebus murinus) in Madagascar: energetic consequences and biological significance

Patterns and energetic consequences of spontaneous daily torpor were measured in the gray mouse lemur (Microcebus murinus) under natural conditions of ambient temperature and photoperiod in a dry deciduous forest in western Madagascar. Over a period of two consecutive dry seasons, oxygen consumption (VO₂) and body temperature (T _b) were measured on ten individuals kept in outdoor enclosures. In all animals, spontaneous daily torpor occurred on a daily basis with torpor bouts lasting from 3.6 to 17.6 h, with a mean torpor bout duration of 9.3 h. On average, body temperatures in torpor were 17.3±4.9°C with a recorded minimum value of 7.8°C. Torpor was not restricted to the mouse lemurs’ diurnal resting phase: entries occurred throughout the night and arousals mainly around midday, coinciding with the daily ambient temperature maximum. Arousal from torpor was a two-phase process with a first passive, exogenous heating where the T _b of animals increased from the torpor T _b minimum to a mean value of 27.1°C before the second, endogenous heat production commenced to further raise T _b to normothermic values. Metabolic rate during torpor (28.6±13.2 ml O₂ h^–1) was significantly reduced by about 76% compared to resting metabolic rate (132.6±50.5 ml O₂ h^–1). On average, for all M. murinus individuals measured, hypometabolism during daily torpor reduced daily energy expenditure by about 38%. In conclusion, all these energy-conserving mechanisms of the nocturnal mouse lemurs, with passive exogenous heating during arousal from torpor, low minimum torpor T _bs, and extended torpor bouts into the activity phase, comprise an important and highly adapted mechanism to minimize energetic costs in response to unfavorable environmental conditions and may play a crucial role for individual fitness. Received: 8 July 1999 / Accepted: 3 December 1999     

Energetics of arousal episodes in hibernating arctic ground squirrels

Arctic ground squirrels overwintering in northern Alaska experience average soil temperature of −10°C. To examine energetic costs of arousing from hibernation under arctic compared to temperate conditions, captive ground squirrels were maintained in ambient temperatures (T _a) of 2, −5 and −12°C. Rates of oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production were used to estimate metabolic rate and fuel use during the three phases of arousal episodes: rewarming, euthermia, and recooling. Respiratory quotient comparisons suggest exclusive use of lipid during rewarming and mixed fuel use during euthermia. Animals rewarming from torpor at T _a −12°C took longer, consumed more oxygen, and attained higher peak rates of oxygen consumption when compared to 2°C. T _a had no significant effect on cost or duration of the euthermic phase. Animals recooled faster at −12°C than at 2°C, but total oxygen consumption was not different. T _a had no significant effect on the total cost of arousal episodes when all three phases are included. Arousal episodes account for 86% of estimated costs of a complete hibernation cycle including torpor when at 2°C and only 23% at −12°C. Thus, due to the higher costs of steady-state metabolism during torpor, proportional metabolic costs of arousal episodes at T _a characteristic of the Arctic are diminished compared to relative costs of arousals in more temperate conditions.     

Mitochondrial metabolism during fasting-induced daily torpor in mice

During fasting, mice (Mus musculus) undergo daily bouts of torpor, considerably reducing body temperature (T_b) and metabolic rate (MR). We examined females of different laboratory strains (Balb/c, C57/6N, and CD1) to determine whether liver mitochondrial metabolism is actively reduced during torpor. In all strains, we found that state 3 (phosphorylating) respiration rate measured at 37 °C was reduced up to 35% during torpor for at least one of the substrates (glutamate and succinate) used to fuel respiration. The extent of this suppression varied and was correlated with T_b at sampling. This suggests that, at the biochemical level, the transition to and from a hypometabolic torpid state is gradual. In fasted non-torpid animals, T_b and MR still fluctuated greatly: T_b dropped by as much as 4 °C and MR was reduced up to 25% compared to fed controls. Changes in T_b and MR in fasted, non-torpid animals were correlated with changes in mitochondrial state 3 respiration rate measured at 37 °C. This suggests that fasting mice may conserve energy even when not torpid by occasionally reducing T_b and mitochondrial oxidative capacity to reduce MR. Furthermore, proton conductance was higher in torpid compared to non-torpid animals when measured at 15 °C (the lower limit of torpid T_b). This pattern is similar to that reported previously for daily torpor in Phodopus sungorus.     

Heterothermy in an Australian passerine, the Dusky Woodswallow (Artamus cyanopterus)

Information regarding passerine heterothermy and torpor is scant, although many species are small and must cope with a fluctuating food supply and presumably would benefit from energy savings afforded by torpor. We studied whether insectivorous Dusky Woodswallows (Artamus cyanopterus; ∼35 g) enter spontaneous torpor (food ad libitum) when held outdoors as a pair in autumn/winter. Woodswallows displayed pronounced and regular daily fluctuations in body temperature (T _b) over the entire study period. The mean T _b ranged from ∼39°C to 40°C (photophase, day time) and ∼33°C to 36°C (scotophase, night time). However, on 88% of bird nights, nocturnal T _b minima fell to < 35°C. The lowest T _b observed in air was 29.2°C. However, when a bird fell into water its T _b dropped further to ∼22°C; this T _b was regulated for several hours and the bird survived. Our observations suggest that heterothermy is a normal part of the daily thermal regime for woodswallows to minimise energy expenditure. Spontaneous nocturnal torpor in captive woodswallows suggests that torpor in the wild may be more pronounced than recorded here because free-living birds are likely challenged by both low food availability and adverse weather.     

Hibernation patterns of Turkish hamsters: influence of sex and ambient temperature

Turkish hamsters (Mesocricetus brandti) are a model organism for studies of hibernation, yet a detailed account of their torpor characteristics has not been undertaken. This study employed continuous telemetric monitoring of body temperature (T _b) in hibernating male and female Turkish hamsters at ambient temperatures (T _as) of 5 and 13 °C to precisely characterize torpor bout depth, duration, and frequency, as well as rates of entry into and arousal from torpor. Hamsters generated brief intervals of short (<12 h), shallow test bouts (T _b > 20 °C), followed by deep torpor bouts lasting 4–6 days at T _a = 5 °C and 2–3 days at T _a = 13 °C. Females at T _a = 5 °C had longer bouts than males, but maintained higher torpor T _b; there were no sex differences at T _a = 13 °C. Neither body mass loss nor food intake differed between the two T _as. Hamsters entered torpor primarily during the scotophase (subjective night), but timing of arousals was highly variable. Hamsters at both T _as generated short, shallow torpor bouts between deep bouts, suggesting that this species may be capable of both hibernation and daily torpor.     

Daily torpor and energetics in a tropical mammal, the northern blossom-bat Macroglossus minimus (Megachiroptera)

Little is known about torpor in the tropics or torpor in megachiropteran species. We investigated thermoregulation, energetics and patterns of torpor in the northern blossom-bat Macroglossus minimus (16 g) to test whether physiological variables may explain why its range is limited to tropical regions. Normothermic bats showed a large variation in body temperature (T _b) (33 to 37 °C) over a wide range of ambient temperatures (T _as) and a relatively low basal metabolic rate (1.29 ml O₂ g⁻¹h⁻¹). Bats entered torpor frequently in the laboratory at T _as between 14 and 25 °C. Entry into torpor always occurred when lights were switched on in the morning, independent of T _a. MRs during torpor were reduced to about 20–40% of normothermic bats and T _bs were regulated at a minimum of 23.1 ± 1.4 °C. The duration of torpor bouts increased with decreasing T _a in non-thermoregulating bats, but generally terminated after 8 h in thermoregulating torpid bats. Both the mean minimum T _b and MR of torpid M. minimus were higher than that predicted for a 16-g daily heterotherm and the T _b was also about 5 °C higher than that of the common blossom-bat Syconycteris australis, which has a more subtropical distribution. These observations suggest that variables associated with torpor are affected by T _a and that the restriction to tropical areas in M. minimus to some extent may be due to their ability to enter only very shallow daily torpor. Accepted: 22 September 1997     

Thermoregulation in free‐ranging ground woodpeckers Geocolaptes olivaceus: no evidence of torpor

Heterothermic responses characterised by pronounced hypometabolism and reductions in body temperature (T_b) are one of the most effective ways in which small endotherms can offset the energetic cost of endothermic homeothermy. It remains unclear, therefore, why daily torpor and hibernation are restricted to only a subset of avian lineages. To further our understanding of the phylogenetic distribution of avian torpor, we investigated winter thermoregulation in the southern African ground woodpecker Geocolaptes olivaceus. We considered this species a good candidate for heterothermy, because it is resident year‐round in mountainous regions with cold winters and reliant on small ectothermic prey. We recorded T_b patterns in free‐ranging individuals and measured T_b and metabolic rates in captive individuals. Neither free‐ranging nor captive woodpeckers showed any indication of daily torpor or even shallow rest‐phase hypothermia. All birds maintained bimodally distributed T_b characteristic of classic endothemic homeothermy, with a mean rest‐phase T_b of 37.9 ± 0.2°C and no data below 37.0°C. The mean circadian amplitude of T_b was 4.2°C, equivalent to approximately twice the expected value. There was some evidence of seasonal acclimatisation in T_b, with a small decrease in rest‐phase T_b with the onset of the austral winter. Captive birds showed patterns of resting metabolic rate and T_b consistent with the classic model of endothermic homeothermy. The apparent absence of torpor in G. olivaceus supports the notion that, unlike the case in mammals, many avian taxa that may a priori be expected to benefit from deep heterothermy do not use it.     

Hibernation induces glutathione redox imbalance in ground squirrel intestine

Glutathione (GSH) is the major thiol-disulfide redox buffer in cells and is a critical component of antioxidant defense. Here we examined GSH redox balance in the intestinal mucosa during the annual cycle of 13-lined ground squirrels (Spermophilus tridecemlineatus). The ratio of reduced GSH to its oxidized form (glutathione disulfide, GSSG), which is an index of oxidative stress, was five-fold lower in hibernating compared with summer-active squirrels, an effect due primarily to elevated GSSG concentration in hibernators. During hibernation the total pool of GSH equivalents was lowest in squirrels undergoing arousal and highest in squirrels during interbout arousals. Hibernation decreased intestinal GSSG reductase activity by approximately 50%, but had no effect on activities of glutathione peroxidase or glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase. Within the hibernation season, expression of the stress protein HSP70 in intestinal mucosa was highest in squirrels entering torpor and early in a torpor bout, and lowest in squirrels arousing from torpor and during interbout euthermia. The results suggest that hibernation in ground squirrels is associated with a shift in intestinal GSH redox balance to a more oxidized state. Higher levels of HSP70 during the early phases of torpor may reflect induction of the stress response due to aberrations in protein folding or may be a mechanism to increase enterocyte tolerance to subsequent stress imposed by extended torpor or the arousal process.     

How to budget metabolic energy: torpor in a small Neotropical mammal

Neotropical nectar-feeding bats (Glossophaginae) are highly specialized in the exploitation of floral nectar and have one of the highest mass-specific metabolic rates among mammals. Nevertheless, they are distributed throughout the tropics and subtropics over a wide elevational range, and thus encounter many extreme and energetically challenging environmental conditions. Depressing their otherwise high metabolic rate, e.g., in situations of food restriction, might be an important adaptive physiological strategy in these dietary specialists. We investigated the thermoregulatory behavior of captive 10-g nectar feeding bats (Glossophaga soricina; Chiroptera, Phyllostomidae) under variable ambient temperatures (T _a) and feeding regimes and predicted that bats would use torpor as an energy-conserving behavior under energetic constraints. All tested animals entered torpor in response to energetic restrictions and the depth of torpor was dependent on the body condition of the animals and hence on their degree of physiological constraints. Periods of torpor with body temperatures (T _b) below 34°C were precisely adjusted to the photoperiod. The median length of diurnal torpor was 11.43 h. The lowest T _b measured was 21°C at a T _a of 19°C. Estimated energy savings due to torpor were considerable, with reductions in metabolic rate to as low as 5% of the metabolic rate of normothermic bats at the same T _a. However, contrary to temperate zone bats that also employ diurnal torpor, G. soricina regulated their T _b to the highest possible levels given the present energetic supplies. To summarize, G. soricina is a precise thermoregulator, which strategically employs thermoregulatory behavior in order to decrease its energy expenditure when under energetic restrictions. This adaptation may play a crucial role in the distribution and the assembly of communities of nectar-feeding bats and may point to a general capacity for torpor in tropical bats.     

Overwinter body temperature patterns in captive jerboas (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Jaculus orientali</Emphasis>s): influence of sex and group

The jerboa (Jaculus orientalis) has been described in the past as a hibernator, but no reliable data exist on the daily and seasonal rhythmicity of body temperature (T _b). In this study, T _b patterns were determined in different groups of jerboas (isolated males and females, castrated males and grouped animals) maintained in captivity during autumn and winter, and submitted to natural variations of light and ambient temperature (T _a). T _b and T _a variations were recorded with surgically implanted iButton temperature loggers at 30-min intervals for two consecutive years. About half (6/13) of isolated female jerboas hibernated with a T _b < 33°C, with hibernation bouts interspersed with short periods of normothermy from November to February. Hibernation bout durations were longer (4–5 days) than those of normothermia phases (1–4 days). During hibernation, the minimum T _b was low (T _bmin ~10.7°C). In contrast, one of the 12 isolated males showed short hibernation bouts of ca. 2 days late in the hibernation season, February–March. The males had T _bmin values of 15.1°C. In contrast to predictions, no castrated males hibernated. When jerboas were grouped, females and males exhibited concomitant torpor bouts. In males, the longest bouts were observed during the late hibernation season. These data suggest complex regulation of hibernation in jerboas.     

Heterothermy in the southern African hedgehog, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Atelerix frontalis</Emphasis>

Most research on mammalian heterothermic responses in southern Africa tends to be laboratory based and biased towards rodents and smaller members of the Afrotheria. In this study, we continuously measured body temperature of southern African hedgehogs (Atelerix frontalis) between April and August 2009 (−10°C < T _a < 43°C), kept under semi-captive conditions. A. frontalis showed a high propensity for torpor with animals spending up to 84% of the measurement period torpid. During this study, A. frontalis displayed the lowest T _b min (ca 1°C) yet recorded in an Afrotropical placental heterotherm. Bout lengths of between 0.7 h (40 min) and 116.3 h (4.8 days) were recorded. Differences in bout length were observed between lighter individuals compared with an individual exhibiting a higher body mass at the onset of winter, with low M _b individuals exhibiting daily torpor whereas a heavier individual exhibited torpor bouts that were indicative of hibernation. Our results suggest that heterothermic responses are an important feature in the energy balance equation of this species and that body mass at the onset of winter may determine the patterns of heterothermy utilised in this species.     

Torpor and thermal energetics in a tiny Australian vespertilionid,the little forest bat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Vespadelus vulturnus</Emphasis>)

Data on thermal energetics for vespertilionid bats are under-represented in the literature relative to their abundance, as are data for bats of very small body mass. Therefore, we studied torpor use and thermal energetics in one of the smallest (4 g) Australian vespertilionids, Vespadelus vulturnus. We used open-flow respirometry to quantify temporal patterns of torpor use, upper and lower critical temperatures (T _uc and T _lc) of the thermoneutral zone (TNZ), basal metabolic rate (BMR), resting metabolic rate (RMR), torpid metabolic rate (TMR), and wet thermal conductance (C _wet) over a range of ambient temperatures (T _a). We also measured body temperature (T _b) during torpor and normothermia. Bats showed a high proclivity for torpor and typically aroused only for brief periods. The TNZ ranged from 27.6°C to 33.3°C. Within the TNZ T _b was 33.3±0.4°C and BMR was 1.02±0.29 mlO₂ g⁻¹ h⁻¹ (5.60±1.65 mW g⁻¹) at a mean body mass of 4.0±0.69 g, which is 55 % of that predicted for a 4 g bat. Minimum TMR of torpid bats was 0.014±0.006 mlO₂ g⁻¹ h⁻¹ (0.079±0.032 mW g⁻¹) at T _a=4.6±0.4°C and T _b=7.5±1.9. T _lc and C _wet of normothermic bats were both lower than that predicted for a 4 g bat, which indicates that V. vulturnus is adapted to minimising heat loss at low T _a. Our findings support the hypothesis that vespertilionid bats have evolved energy-conserving physiological traits, such as low BMR and proclivity for torpor.     

The Dynamics of Adaptive Changes in the Spleen of the Hibernating Ground Squirrel <Emphasis Type="Italic">Spermophilus undulatus</Emphasis>

In hibernation season during torpor bouts, the spleen weight and the hemoglobin level, as well as the total and extracted protein contents in the spleen of the ground squirrel Spermophilus undulatus are increased when animals enter torpor and reach maximum values when the body temperature drops below 25°C. All these parameters return to the characteristic values of the euthermic animals during arousal, before the body temperature increases to 20°C. There were no significant differences in the numbers of splenocytes between ground squirrels in interbout euthermia and torpor. The minimum number of splenocytes was observed in animals that entered torpor when the core body temperature was approximately 18°C. The activity of ornithine decarboxylase, a key enzyme in polyamine synthesis, which is correlated with the functional and proliferative status of lymphoid tissue, was the same for the euthermic and summer ground squirrels and decreased monotonically during torpor. Upon arousal of the animals when body temperature was below 29°C, no resumption of the spleen ornithine decarboxylase activity was observed.