Characterization of helper factors distinct from interleukin 2 necessary for the generation of allospecific cytolytic T lymphocytes

The in vitro generation of primary murine allospecific cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) from BALB/c (H-2d) spleen cell precursors in response to x-irradiated RDM4 (H-2k) tumor cells did not occur unless the cultures were supplemented with exogenous helper factors. Such CTL helper factors (CHF) could be provided by conditioned medium from cultures in which Sendai virus-immune BALB/c spleen cells were stimulated either with Sendai-infected cells (SC-CM) or with peptides cleaved by CNBr from intact virions (SP-CM). CHF activity stimulated by both antigens reached a maximum after day 3 of culture. In contrast, interleukin 2 (IL 2) activity peaked at day 2 and had essentially disappeared by day 4. Fractionation of day-4 SC-CM and SP-CM preparations by gel filtration revealed peaks of activity at apparent m.w. of 17,000 (CHF17) and 30,000 (CHF30). Under certain conditions, a peak of CHF activity appeared in the void volume with an apparent m.w. of 75,000 or greater. These results indicate that CHF activity is mediated by molecules distinct from IL 2.     

Chromatographic separation from known cytokines of a helper factor necessary for the generation of murine cytolytic T lymphocytes

A helper factor (CHF) necessary for the generation of primary allospecific CTL using BALB/c (H-2d) responder spleen cell and x-irradiated RDM4 (H-2k) stimulator tumor cells was obtained from cultures of mouse spleen cells stimulated for the production of secondary anti-Sendai virus CTL and fractionated by gel filtration chromatography to obtain a 30,000 m.w. species (CHF30). DEAE-cellulose chromatography separated CHF activity from the majority of interleukin 1 (IL 1), interleukin 2 (IL 2), granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (CSF), and interferon (IFN). Interleukin 3 (IL 3) and CHF co-eluted when this procedure was used. Reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) of CHF30 with a variety of elution conditions allowed the separation of CHF activity from IL 1, IL 2, IL 3, CSF, and IFN. IL 3 and CSF in the CHF30 preparation were stable at 80 degrees C for more than an hour, whereas CHF activity decreased rapidly during the first 10 min of incubation. Trypsin treatment of the same material showed that CHF activity was resistant to digestion for 40 min, whereas IL 3 and CSF lost most of their activities during the first 5 min of incubation. These results indicate that CHF activity is mediated by molecules biologically and biochemically distinct from the well characterized cytokines.     

Specificity of the mouse cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to adenovirus 5. E1A is immunodominant in H-2b, but not in H-2d or H-2k mice

The Ag specificity and MHC restriction of the CTL response to adenovirus 5 (Ad5) in three strains of mice, C57BL/10 (H-2b), BALB/c (H-2d), and C3H/HeJ (H-2k), were tested. Polyclonal Ad5-specific CTL were prepared by priming mice in vivo with live Ad5 virus followed by secondary in vitro stimulation of the spleen cells with virus-infected syngeneic cells. The Ad5-specific CTL were Db restricted in C57BL/10 and Kk restricted in C3H/HeJ. In BALB/c mice both Kd- and Dd/Ld-restricted CTL were detected. The polyclonal Ad5-specific CTL response in C57BL/10 mice is directed exclusively against the products of the E1A region, which comprises only 5% of the Ad5 genome. In BALB/c mice E1A is at best a very minor target Ag and in C3H/HeJ mice E1A is not recognized at all. Using the H-2 congenic mouse strains B10.BR (H-2k) and C3H.SW (H-2b) it was shown that the immunodominance of E1A is H-2 dependent. The 19-kDa glycoprotein encoded in the E3 region of Ad5, which binds to class I MHC in the endoplasmic reticulum and prevents its translocation to the cell surface, does not affect the specificity of the CTL response in C57BL/10 mice toward E1A. However, it affects the MHC restriction of the Ad5-specific response in BALB/c mice, selectively inhibiting generation of Kd-restricted CTL.     

Primary in vitro cytotoxic response of F1 T lymphocytes against parental antigens.

Spleen cells from adult female (AKR/J x BALB/(c)F1 mice can respond to mitomycin C-treated spleen from AKR/J mice and can generate effector CTL in a 5-day primary in vitro culture. The response is comparable in magnitude to the response to allogeneic H-2K or H-2D antigens. The response is T cell mediated and is directed to antigen(s) present only on the parental cells. The target cell must be homozygous at H-2Kk to be lysed and H-2Dk antigens do not serve as a target in this response. Spleen cells from (B10.BR x B10.D2) hybrids that have been stimulated with AKR/J lyse B10.Br as well as AKR/J target cells. Similar H-2k/d hybrid F1 anti-H-2k parent responses are seen in certain other strain combinations. A number of possible interpretations of these responses are discussed.     

Differential resistance to growth of a tumor expressing incompatible minor alloantigens reflects regulatory influences rather than differences in anti-minor-CTL-P frequencies

In previous studies it was found that BALB/c (H-2d) was more susceptible than (BALB/c X A)F1 (H-2d X H-2a) to a tumor bearing multiple mismatched minor histocompatibility antigens, the DBA/2 (H-2d) mastocytoma P815, and that this resistance was H-2 linked. In the present studies the immunologic basis of this effect was examined by comparing the cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses of BALB/c with those of (BALB/c X A)F1. Despite the BALB/c X A)F1's 34-fold greater resistance to P815 in vivo, the numbers of effector cell precursors were found to be similar in the two hosts as shown by (a) similar anti-P815 CTL responses in vitro with T-cell growth factor, (b) similar secondary anti-DBA/2 MiHA responses after in vivo priming with irradiated P815, and (c) similar frequencies of anti-DBA/2 CTL precursors by limiting-dilution analysis. However, priming with proliferating P815 in vivo revealed a defect in the BALB/c animals: Spleen cells from such animals were unable to control the growth of contaminating P815 cells in vitro or to mount strong secondary CTL responses to DBA/2 antigens. The defective priming of BALB/c could be corrected when DBA/2 spleen cells were added to the P815 inoculum. This impaired priming by living tumor cells was not seen in (BALB/c X A)F1. It is concluded that the use of living P815 tumor cells revealed a defect in immunoregulation in BALB/c mice, which rendered them susceptible to tumor growth in spite of apparently adequate numbers of anti-minor-CTL precursors. How the additional H-2 products expressed in the (BALB/c X A)F1 might correct this defect is discussed.     

CD3- bone marrow cells augment the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes showing a preference for the X-chromosome linked gene product of stimulator cells

Responder cells, composed of both a limited number of nylon wool-passed lymph node (NW-LN) cells and an excess number of CD3+ cell-depleted bone marrow (CD3- BM) cells from the same strain of mice, were stimulated with allogeneic spleen cells in vitro. The CD3- BM cells augmented the generation of allogeneic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from NW-LN cells. C3H/He (H-2k, C3H background) responder cells were stimulated with either B10.D2 (H-2d, B10 background) or BALB/c (H-2d, BALB background) spleen cells. In the former stimulation, the CTL induced lysed B10.D2 target cells more efficiently than the BALB/c cells. Furthermore, these CTL lysed more (B10.D2 x BALB/c) F1 male target cells than (BALB/c x B10.D2) F1 male. In the latter stimulation, the CTL lysed more BALB/c than B10.D2 cells, and more (BALB/c) x B10.D2) F1 male than (B10.D2 x BALB/c) F1 male. The reciprocal mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) were carried out, in which BALB/c responder cells were stimulated with either C3H/He or B10.BR (H-2k, B10 background) spleen cells. In the former stimulation, the CTL induced lysed more C3H/He or (C3H/He x B10.BR) F1 male target cells than B10.BR or (B10.BR x C3H/He) F1 male, and in the latter, the reciprocal results were obtained. These results suggested that the CTL induced had a preference for the X-chromosome linked gene products (Xlgp), besides the specificity for the allogeneic MHC class I, of the mice used as stimulator.     

Effect of graft-versus-host disease on anti-tumor immunity

BCL1, a spontaneous B cell leukemia of BALB/c origin, is rejected by C.B-20 (Ighb, H-40b) but not BALB/c (Igha, H-40a) mice. Adoptive transfer of C.B-20 anti-BCL1 effector cells specific for the minor histocompatibility Ag H-40a protects irradiated C.B-20 but not BALB/c recipients. Because C.B-20 donor cells could potentially generate graft-vs-host disease (GVHD) in BALB/c recipients, we investigated the possibility that GVHD prevents the anti-tumor effect. GVHD was induced in (C.B-20 X B10.D2)F1 [H-2d, H-40b X H-2d,H-40b] recipients after injection of B10.D2-primed C.B-20 donor cells. GVHD was indicated by the histologic appearance of tissue sections from C.B-20----F1 livers, target organs of GVHD, which showed a marked mononuclear cell infiltrate around the portal tracts and central veins. In addition, splenic lymphocytes from these mice had altered CD4/CD8 ratios and were unable to respond to the polyclonal activators Con A and LPS. The mitogen unresponsiveness was at least partially due to the presence of a suppressor cell, because proliferation of normal spleen cells to Con A and LPS was suppressed upon addition of C.B-20----F1 spleen cells. Further immune dysfunction was evident by the inability of T cells from mice with GVHD to generate a CTL response to H-2 alloantigens. Addition of C.B-20----F1 spleen cells to F1 responder cells at the induction of culture did not prevent generation of CTL, indicating that a suppressor cell was not responsible for the lack of CTL activity. In this setting of GVHD, F1 recipients were able to reject BCL1 upon adoptive transfer of C.B-20 anti-BCL1 effector cells. These data indicate that GVHD-induced immune dysfunction does not inhibit the activity of antileukemia T cells.     

Induction and characterization of minor histocompatibility antigens. Specific primary cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses in vitro

A definite cytotoxic activity was developed in a BALB/c (H-2d) anti-DBA/2 primary mixed leukocyte culture (MLC), which received interleukin 2 (IL-2) on day 3 of culture. This cytotoxic activity was minor histocompatibility antigens (MIHA)-specific at the stimulator level, and was not developed in a syngeneic (BALB/c anti-BALB/c) MLC. The addition of IL-2 on day 3 of culture was crucial; no or very weak cytotoxic activity was developed in MLC receiving IL-2 on day 0 or on both day 0 and day 3. Only appropriate MIHA-allogeneic tumor cells were lysed as the target of the cytotoxic activity. The cytotoxic activity seemed MIHA-specific also at the target level; it lysed tumor cells of DBA/2 mouse origin but not those of BALB/c (syngeneic) origin. Phenotypes of the cytotoxic effector cell were Thy-1+ Lyt-2+. We concluded from these results that MIHA-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were generated in the MIHA-allogeneic primary MLC. In this newly developed system, we studied genetic and antigenic requirements for primary anti-MIHA CTL responses in vitro. We demonstrated; among spleen cells (SC) of seven B10 H-2-congenic strains only SC of B10.D2 strain whose major histocompatibility complex (MHC) (H-2d) was compatible with the responder MHC effectively stimulated responder BALB/c (H-2d) SC for an anti-MIHA (DBA-C57BL-common) CTL response. Similarly, only SC of two out of seven C x B recombinant inbred strains (C x B.H and C x B.D), which were compatible at the MHC with responder SC, activated responder BALB/c SC for the response. The possibility that cells responding to H-2 alloantigens suppressed the anti-MIHA response was ruled out. Additional experiments showed that compatibility at the H-2K-end or the H-2D-end of the MHC was sufficient for a definite anti-MIHA response. These provided formal evidence that primary anti-MIHA CTL responses in vitro were MHC-restricted at the stimulator level. We then showed that sonication-disrupted SC or Sephadex G-10 column-passed nonadherent SC failed to stimulate responder SC for a primary anti-MIHA CTL response, whereas G-10-passed nonadherent SC responded well to adherent stimulator cells. Further study demonstrated that Ia+ adherent cells were the most active cell type as stimulator. Finally, we confirmed that the primary anti-MIHA CTL responses to adherent stimulator cells was MHC-restricted.     

Enhancement of the recognition by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) of target membrane antigens after fusion with whole cells

Plasma membrane vesicles (R4-PM) prepared from mouse lymphoma cells (RDM4,H2k) were employed to investigate requirements for recognition of target cell membranes by allogeneic cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Using immunofluorescent staining and fluorescence microscopy, the R4-PM were tested for binding to CTL and were found to bind to these effector cells in a specific manner. However, this binding was very inefficient compared to the binding of whole RDM4 cells to CTL. The R4-PM were then attached to P388D1 cells (H-2d) in the presence of wheat germ agglutinin and polyethylene glycol (PEG), both under conditions which promote membrane fusion (40% PEG) and under conditions which do not (10% PEG). About 1 cell equivalent R4-PM becomes associated per P388D1 cell in both situations. In the cytotoxicity assays that were carried out, the P388D1 cells which had R4-PM attached under fusion conditions were lysed by CTL directed against H2k in a specific manner, while the P388D1 cells which had R4-PM attached under nonfusion conditions were not lysed above background levels by these CTL. These results suggest that recognition of target cells by allogeneic CTL such that lysis occurs requires more than presentation of the alloantigens as they are expressed in plasma membrane vesicles. However, fusion of these vesicles back into living cells apparently enhances the ability of the alloantigens to be recognized.     

A helper factor needed for the generation of mouse cytolytic T lymphocytes is made by tumor cell lines, cloned T cells, and spleen cells exposed to a variety of stimuli

A helper factor termed cytolytic T lymphocyte helper factor (CHF) that is needed for the generation of allospecific mouse cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vitro was produced by mouse spleen cells 3 to 4 days after the time when interleukin 2 (IL 2) had reached its maximal production. These kinetics were observed by stimulation of immune spleen cells with allogeneic tumor or spleen cells, with Sendai or influenza viral peptides, with virus infected cells, or with concanavalin A (Con A). CHF produced by rat spleen cells was able to help in the generation of mouse CTL, indicating that this cytokine was not restricted genetically. CHF could also be made by WEHI-3 and EL4 cell lines, as well as cloned cytolytic and helper T cells. The production of CHF by WEHI-3 cells argues that CHF is not IL 2. In addition, if CHF was not present early in the in vitro stimulation no CTL were generated, suggesting that CHF participated in the activation of CTL precursors. The addition of IL 2-containing conditioned medium to the CHF assay resulted in no substantial CTL generation, although significant cellular proliferation was observed. In contrast, CHF-containing conditioned medium allowed the generation of CTL in the absence of the same level of proliferation.     

Non-H-2-linked genetic regulation of cytotoxic responses to hapten-modified syngeneic cells. I. Non-H-2-linked Ir gene defect expressed on T cells is not predetermined at the stage of bone marrow cells

Spleen cells from C3H/He or BALB.K mice immunized to the newly synthesized amino-reactive hapten 5-sulfo-1-naphthoxy acetic acid N-hydroxysuccinimide ester (AED-NH2) were stimulated in vitro with AED-NH2-modified syngeneic cells. After 5 days of culture, effector cells were assayed for their cytotoxic activity against AED-NH2-modified target blast cells. C3H/He and BALB.K mice exhibited the respective high and low anti-AED-NH2 cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses. This contrasted with the observation that both of these H-2k strains generated potent CTL responses against aminoreactive haptens, e.g., trinitrophenyl (TNP). Because C3H.SW and BALB.B strains, which are the H-2b counterpart of the above two strains, also represented the respective high and low responders to AED-NH2 hapten, this hapten model enabled us to investigate cellular mechanisms underlying the above non-H-2-associated genetic regulation of CTL responses (C3H vs BALB non-H-2 backgrounds). The results demonstrated that there was no detectable difference between C3H/He and BALB.K strains in the lysability of target cells and the ability of stimulating cells to activate primed spleen cells. Anti-AED-NH2 CTL responses were only marginal when antigen-presenting cells (APC) were eliminated from the primed spleen cells of high responder C3H/He or (C3H/He X BALB.K)F1 mice. The addition of APC to cultures free of APC regained an appreciable CTL response in C3H/He or (C3H/He X BALB.K)F1 mice, irrespective of whether APC were derived from high (C3H/He) or low (BALB.K) responders. We have also demonstrated that allogeneic radiation bone marrow chimera (BALB.K----C3H/He) exhibited a CTL response comparable to that induced by C3H/He mice, whereas the reverse direction of allogeneic chimera (C3H/He----BALB.K) induced a marginal CTL response. These results indicate that this non-H-2-associated Ir gene defect is expressed on T cells (CTL precursors and/or helper T cells) rather than APC, and that this T cell defect is not predetermined at the level of bone marrow cells. The results are discussed in the light of the genetic and cellular mechanisms underlying non-H-2-linked Ir gene control.     

Tolerance to Mls-disparate cells induces suppressor T cells that act at the helper level to prevent in vivo generation of cytolytic lymphocytes to hapten-altered self

We have been examining the mechanisms that control in vivo development and down regulation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-altered self antigens. In vivo generation of hapten-specific CTL requires an auxiliary antigenic stimulus, which can be provided by H-2 compatible but Mls-disparate cells. These experiments were designed to study the effect of tolerization with such Mls-disparate cells on CTL development. C3H/HeN (H-2k, Mlsc ) mice sensitized in the footpads with C3H-TNP spleen cells plus CBA/J (H-2k, Mlsd ) spleen cells develop CTL in the draining lymph nodes that will lyse 51Cr-labeled TNP-modified C3H targets. However, we have found that if C3H/HeN mice are given tolerizing doses of CBA/J spleen cells 5 to 7 days before sensitization, a splenic suppressor T cell (Ts) appears. This Ts will suppress CTL development in its tolerant host, and can be transferred adoptively to function in naive mice. Ts and its precursor are cyclophosphamide insensitive and therefore different from the naturally existing suppressor cell present in mice. When triggered by cells with Mlsd , the Ts produces a factor (TsF) that hinders helper factors from functioning in an in vitro CTL assay. Furthermore, TsF acts to prevent utilization of IL 2 by an IL 2-dependent cell line. Thus, evidence has been provided that the in vivo generation of CTL toward hapten-altered self can be down regulated at the level of helper signals by a Ts. The latter is inducible by the Mls-disparate cells that are needed at a different site to trigger the helper factors in this CTL system.     

In vivo development of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) to hapten-altered self: MIs-disparate cells facilitate the response by neutralizing IL 2 inhibitor

Inability to develop CTL in vivo to hapten-altered self can be attributed in part to an inhibitor of interleukin 2 (IL 2) that is present in the serum of normal mice. We have shown earlier that hapten-specific CTL can be generated in C3H mice (H-2k, MIsc) provided CBA/J (H-2k MIsd) spleen cells are injected simultaneously with hapten-modified syngeneic spleen cells into the hind foot paws. In efforts to determine whether serum levels of the inhibitor of IL 2 are altered as a consequence of this successful immunization method, we have compared the activity of the inhibitor in serum at intervals after the injection of syngeneic spleen cells, CBA spleen cells, or TNP-C3H spleen cells alone or together with CBA spleen cells, by using a murine IL 2-dependent, cloned cytotoxic T cell line, CT-6. The results indicate that inhibitor was neutralized optimally 48 to 72 hr after injection of TNP-C3H spleen cells mixed with CBA/J spleen cells. The order in which neutralization occurred was as follows: TNP-C3H cells + CBA/J cells greater than CBA cells greater than TNP-C3H cells greater than normal C3H spleen cells. Furthermore, supernatants from cultures of C3H lymph node cells stimulated in vivo with CBA/J cells also contained IL 2 activity. Thus, injection of CBA/J cells with TNP-modified syngeneic spleen cells produces IL 2 in vivo in sufficient quantity to neutralize the activity of the inhibitor as well as to facilitate the maturation of pre-CTL into hapten-altered self-specific CTL.     

Defining cytolytic T lymphocyte recognition of chemically modified self. I. Response to trinitrophenyl-H-2Kk

We used purified class I antigen incorporated into liposomes to examine the response of secondary cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) to chemically modified self. By generating the secondary response in the presence of T cell helper factor, the level of CTL response was limited by CTL recognition of added antigen rather than by helper cell generation of lymphokines. We found a strong secondary response against chemically modified self when spleen cells from trinitrophenyl (TNP)-primed C3H/HeJ mice were stimulated with a) TNP-modified liposomes containing H-2Kk, b) liposomes containing H-2Kk purified from TNP-modified RDM-4 (H-2k) cells, or c) liposomes containing the limited trypsin proteolysis product of H-2Kk that had been directly modified with TNP. In contrast, we were not able to generate a significant CTL response with unmodified H-2Kk incorporated into vesicles along with TNP-modified membrane components lacking H-2Kk. These results suggest that TNP-modified H-2Kk is a major antigenic site recognized by CTL from C3H/HeJ mice after priming against TNP-modified self.     

Induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes against herpes simplex virus type i: role of accessory cells and amplifying factor

Spleen cells from mice primed with herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) could be induced to differentiate into cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) by in vitro culture with infectious HSV-1 but not by heat-inactivated virus. Induction of CTL failed to occur if the spleen cells were depleted of adherent cells by passage over columns of nylon wool before culture with virus. The CTL response could be restored by adding normal syngeneic peritoneal cells (PC) or L cell fibroblasts but not by allogeneic PC or BALB/c 3T3 fibroblasts. Thus, the induction of HSV-1-specific CTL was H-2 restricted. The response of HSV-1-stimulated nylon wool-depleted spleen cells could also be restored by adding amplifying factor (AF) produced in 24 hr mixed lymphocyte cultures. The addition of AF to nondepleted spleen cells also permitted the generation of CTL with heat-inactivated HSV-1 as a viral stimulant. Our results indicated that induction of a HSV-1 CTL response requires two signals, one provided by virus and a second, presumably nonspecific, by helper T cells. It was suggested that only the helper cells require H-2 restriction and need to be presented virus in the context of a macrophage.     

Generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in vitro. VII. Suppressive effect of irradiated MLC cells on CTL response.

Irradiated cells obtained from MLC at the peak of the CTL response caused profound suppression of generation of CTL when added in small numbers at the initiation of primary MLC prepared with normal spleen cells. The inhibitory activity of the MLC cells was not affected by irradiation (1000 rads) but was abolished by treatment with anti-theta serum and complement. The suppression was immunologically specific. The response of A (H-2a) spleen cells toward C3H (H-2k) alloantigens was suppressed by irradiated MLC cells obtained from MLC prepared with A spleen cells and irradiated C3H-stimulating cells, whereas the response of A spleen cells toward DBA/2 (H-2d) alloantigens was affected relatively little. However, if irradiated C3H X DBA/2 F1 hybrid spleen cells were used to stimulate A spleen cells in MLC, addition of irradiated MLC cells having cytotoxic activity toward C3H antigens abolished the response to both C3H and DBA/2 antigens. The response to DBA/2 antigens was much less affected when a mixture of irradiated C3H and DBA/2 spleen cells was used as stimulating cells. Thus, the presence of MLC cells having cytotoxic activity toward one alloantigen abolished the response to another non-cross reacting antigen only when both antigens were present on the same F1 hybrid-stimulating cells. This suppression of generation of CTL by irradiated MLC cells apparently involves inactivation of alloantigen-bearing stimulating cells as a result of residual cytotoxic activity of the irradiated MLC cells. This mechanism may be active during the decline in CTL activity noted in the normal immune response in vivo and in vitro.     

Generation of cytotoxic T cells specific for minor histocompatibility antigens by cross challenge in vitro with H-2 disparate adherent cells

Although it is well known that an H-2-restricted cytotoxic T cell response to minor histocompatibility antigens (MIHA) can be primed in vivo with H-2 disparate spleen cells, it has not been previously possible to induce cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors (CTLp) in vitro by this type of challenge. In this work, we demonstrate that the inability to cross challenge in vitro is due to the existence of inhibitory effects that can be obviated by cell fractionation, and to insufficient priming in vivo. BALB/c CTLp (H-2d) that have been repeatedly primed in vivo with B10.D2 can be challenged in vitro with C57BL10/J (H-2b) or B10.BR (H-2k)-adherent cells to generate CTL able to lyse B10.D2 (H-2d) target cells. The H-2 restriction properties of the cross-challenged CTL specific for MIHA were analyzed by using the technique of cold target competition. Within the limits of detection in bulk cultures, the entire response appeared to be H-2 unrestricted, whether the cross challenge was with intact C57BL10/J-adherent cells, or with membrane fragments of C57BL10/J presented by BALB/c adherent cells. The frequency of CTLp responsive to cross challenge was analyzed by limiting dilution, with cold target competition at each cell number to establish the restriction properties of the MIHA-specific CTL induced. We were able to detect two subsets of H-2-unrestricted CTLp responsive to intact C57BL10/J-adherent cells; one present at high frequency (1/250 T cells) and subject to suppressive effects at high cell number, and a second present at lower frequency (1/9800 T cells). There appeared to be a relatively infrequent subset of H-2-restricted CTLp as well (1/52,500 T cells). The frequency of CTLp responsive to cross challenge is of comparable magnitude to the frequency of H-2-restricted CTLp responsive to H-2-matched cells bearing MIHA. These observations are discussed in relationship to immunodominance and clonal dominance effects in the response to MIHA.     

Dissociation of H-2 recognition by antibody and cytotoxic T cells of a cloned murine leukemia cell line

The differential expression of H-2 specificities recognized by antibody and by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) has been studied using a clone (FY7) of the C57BL/6 leukemia cell line FBL-3 (H-2b/H-2b). Unlike C57BL/10 spleen cells, EL-4 lymphoma cells and Y57-2C leukemia cells (all H-2b/H-2b), FY7 failed to induce the primary in vitro generation of anti-H-2b CTL by (B10.A x A)F1 (H-2a/H-2a) or B10.D2 x BALB/c)F1 (H-2d/H-2d) responder spleen cells. In addition, FY7 was not lysed by, and did not competitively inhibit anti-H-2b CTL. Quantitative absorption tests with H-2Kb and H-2Db antisera revealed that FY7 expressed these antigens in quantitatively similar amounts to EL-4. The H-2Kb product of FY7 appeared to be identical with that of C57BL/10 spleen cells both in apparent molecular weight and isoelectric point. Yet FY7 failed to inhibit anti-H-2Kb CTL competitively in a cold target inhibition assay. Possible mechanisms are discussed for the lack of T-lymphocyte recognition of the H-2Kb-gene product expressed by FY7.     

T-cell responses induced by the parenteral injection of antigen-modified syngeneic cells. II. Mechanisms, specificity, and cellular analysis of 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (TNP)-specific cytolytic response priming by intravenous versus subcutaneous injection with TNP-modified syngeneic cells

We have examined the underlying mechanisms accounting for the enhanced in vitro TNP-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response following the parenteral injection of syngeneic hapten-modified lymphoid cells. Augmented CTL activity noted following parenteral injection (iv vs sc) of 2,4,6-trinitrophenol-modified syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-SC) is most apparent when limiting numbers of TNP-modified stimulator cells are used in the in vitro sensitization phase. Enhanced CTL responses seen following sc and iv priming is due to distinct mechanisms. Spleen and lymph node (LN) cells from sc primed mice were found to contain significant levels of radioresistant helper activity upon coculture with either viable normal spleen cells in bulk culture or with thymocytes as the source of precursor CTLs in a limiting dilution assay. The helper activity was found to be mediated by a Lyt 1+2- T cells. In addition, Lyt 2-depleted spleen and LN cells from sc primed BALB/c mice could restore the ability of tolerant spleen cells from 2,4,6-trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS)-injected BALB/c mice to generate TNP-specific CTLs. Conversely, Lyt 2-depleted spleen and LN cells from iv primed mice provided no measurable helper activity either in bulk culture or in the limiting dilution assay and did not restore the ability of TNBS-tolerant BALB/c spleen cells to generate TNP-specific CTLs. CTL priming via the iv route was found to be completely antigen specific as iv injection of either 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP)- or fluorescein isothiocyanatel (FITC)-modified cells caused no enhanced CTL activity. Priming via the sc route exhibited a unique specificity pattern as it was shown that sc injection of both TNP-SC and DNP-SC, but not FITC-SC, resulted in enhanced TNP-specific CTL responses. CTL T-helper (Th)-cell induction via the sc route was correlated with (1) the presence of H-2 I region determinants on the inducer cells as the sc injection of TNP-modified erythrocytes led to no enhanced CTL responses or CTL Th activity (while iv injection of TNP-erythrocytes did lead to enhanced CTL responses without detectable helper activity) and (2) the detection of both hapten-specific T-cell proliferation and Interleukin 2 (IL-2) production upon restimulation in culture. We conclude that the sc injection of TNP-SC leads preferentially to an increase of specific Lyt 1+ helper activity, while iv injection leads preferentially to an apparent expansion of Lyt 2+ prelytic effector CTLs.     

Production and characterization of T-cell clones specific for trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-self)

Using serial antigenic challenge as the method of selection and stimulation, continuous lines of cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTL) directed against TNBS-modified syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-self) have been generated. Spleen cells from C3H/HeJ (H-2k) mice were primed in vitro with autologous spleen cells modified with TNBS, and subsequently cloned by limiting dilution and in soft agar in the presence of IL2. These CTL clones grew continuously in medium supplemented with IL2 and in the presence of antigen. They are antigen specific and H-2 restricted in their target cell recognition. They all express Thyl and Lyt2 surface markers. None of the clones exhibit natural killer (NK) cell activity. All CTL clones tested so far are restricted in their target cell recognition to H-2Kk-TNP and none were found to be restricted to H-2Dk-TNP. These findings demonstrate at the clonal level the H-2K/D restriction of TNP-self specific CTL. These clones provide tools that may facilitate an understanding of the development and regulation of antigen specific CTL. They may also serve as models useful towards an understanding of the mechanism of lysis by CTL.