Direct and indirect impact of two common rotifer species (Keratella spp.) on two abundant ciliate species (Urotricha furcata, Balanion planctonicum)

1. We investigated the potential competition and feeding impact of the common rotifer species, Keratella cochlearis and K. quadrata , on the abundant prostomatid ciliates, Urotricha furcata and Balanion planctonicum, in laboratory batch culture experiments. All four species have similar feeding preferences, co-occur in many freshwater environments, and are thus potential competitors for the same algal food.
2. Two small Cryptomonas species served as food for the ciliates and the rotifers in the experiments. Growth rates of each ciliate species were measured when they grew alone and when they were paired with one of the rotifer species.
3. Both rotifer species reduced the growth rate of U. furcata , probably primarily by direct feeding on the ciliates. Growth rate of B. planctonicum was unaffected by K. cochlearis , but was drastically reduced by grazing and/or mechanical interference of K. quadrata .
4. These results suggest niche partitioning of the sympatric ciliates with respect to their rotifer competitors/predators.     

Contribution of rotifers to the diet and fitness of Boeckella (Copepoda: Calanoida)

1. The calanoid copepods, Boeckella triarticulata Sars and Boeckella hamata Brehm, are major components of the freshwater zooplankton of New Zealand. It was not known whether these copepods ingest rotifers, nor whether the inclusion of rotifers in their diets might improve their fitness. The present study aimed to identify rotifer taxa which are eaten by each copepod species, and to examine the fitness consequences of the inclusion of one species of rotifer in the diet of B. triarticulata .
2. In feeding experiments using natural rotifer assemblages, both species of copepod ingested the rotifer Anuraeopsis fissa (0.4–4% of daily carbon intake), and B. triarticulata also ingested Polyarthra dolichoptera (6–30% of daily carbon intake) and Keratella cochlearis tecta (1% of daily carbon intake).
3. The contribution of rotifers to the fitness of adult female B. triarticulata was assessed by comparing survival and reproduction among five diets that contained varying densities of algae ( Cryptomonas sp.) and/or Polyarthra dolichoptera (4 μg C L⁻¹). Boeckella triarticulata produced fewer clutches on a rotifer-only diet than on a solely algal diet, and addition of rotifers to a threshold algal diet did not affect copepod fitness relative to the solely algal diets. The present results suggest that Polyarthra at 4 μg C L⁻¹ is not a high-quality food for B. triarticulata .     

Spring bloom development of microbenthic algae and associated invertebrates in two reaches of a small lowland stream with contrasting sediment stability

SUMMARY. 1. Population growth rates and relative competitive abilities of the rotifer Keratella cochlearis f. tecta and the small-bodied cladoceran Daphnia ambigua were studied under different schedules of food addition but equal total food quantity (per 4-day interval). The initial population growth rate of Keratella was significantly affected by the feeding schedule and by the presence of competitors, while that of Daphnia was affected by neither factor. Population densities of both species tended to increase as the frequency of food addition increased.
2. Daphnia suppressed and excluded Keratella from mixed-species cultures when food was provided intermittently at a high concentration, but it failed to exclude the rotifer when food was provided in a near-continuous supply at low concentration. Keratella had only a minor suppressive effect on Daphnia in all mixed-species treatments.
3. Starvation experiments indicate that Daphnia is able to withstand food shortages for significantly longer periods of time than Keratella . These and other results indicate that the outcome of interspecific competition between these species may be influenced by me frequency and concentration at which food is supplied. Daphnia ambigua is competitively superior to K. cochlearis when food is concentrated or 'pulsed', but much less so when ambient food levels are chronically low. Patterns of food availability may have important effects in determining the relative abundance of rotifers and small cladocerans in natural zooplankton communities.     

Seasonal fluctuation of planktonic rotifers in Azibo reservoir (Portugal)

The rotifers of the recently-commissioned Azibo reservoir were studied during two years. The community was similar to that of other portuguese reservoirs with Keratella cochlearis, Polyarthra spp., Asplanchna priodonta and Collotheca pelagica dominant, although densities varied strongly. Maximum rotifer density was 640 ind l^–1 in 1987 and 315 ind l^–1 in 1988. During the first year two density peaks were observed, while in the second year fluctuations were irregular. Phytoplankton availability was considered the main reason for the fluctuation of rotifer density, although temperature, dissolved oxygen and cladoceran interference may also have played a role. A high density of Anabaena flos-aquae might have facilitated the dominance of K. cochlearis in 1988.     

Relative vulnerabilities of natural rotifer and ciliate communities to cladocerans: laboratory and field experiments

SUMMARY. 1. Two experiments with plankton communities from Storrs Pond (NH), one conducted in the laboratory and one in field enclosures, assessed the impact of different cladocerans on rotifers and ciliated protozoa.
2. The smallest cladoceran, Bosmina longirostris , did not depress rotifer or ciliate growth rates while the intermediate sized dadoceran, Daphnia galeata mendotae , reduced ciliate growth rates in the enclosure experiment but had only a marginal effect in the jar experiment. D. galeata mendotae had no effect on any of the rotifers in either experiment.
3. In both experiments the largest cladoceran, Daphniapulex , depressed the growth rates of ciliates and those rotifers known to be vulnerable to interference competition. Polyarthra vulgaris , previously shown to be resistant to cladoceran interference, was the only rotifer unaffected by D. pulex in the field experiment but was depressed by the much higher densities of this cladoceran in the laboratory experiment.
4. Cladocerans did not affect phytoplankton or bacterioplankton abundance in either experiment. Therefore the mechanism most likely to be responsible for the suppressive effect of cladocerans on rotifers and ciliates in these experiments is direct mechanical interference or predation, rather than exploitative competition.     

Spine development in the rotifer Keratella cochlearis: induction by cyclopoid copepods and Asplanchna

SUMMARY. 1. Spine development in a clone of unspined Keratella cochlearis was promoted by a water soluble factor released by the copepods Tropocyclops prasinus and Mesocyclops edax and by the predatory rotifer Asplanchna priodonta. Between 9 and 55% of K. cochlearis populations cultured in predator-conditioned media responded to the inducing chemical.
2. The K. cochlearis form possessing a posterior spine of medium length was much less susceptible to predation by small Tropocylops and Asplanchna than the form lacking the posterior spine. These predators consistently selected the unspined form over the spined form when offered equal densities of each. However, both spined and unspined forms were equally susceptible to predation by large Mesocyclops.
3. The phenotypic variation of offspring produced from induced unspined Keratella females encompassed much of the variation reported for the taxon in North America. These morphotypes are similar to the variation of forms reported for the K. cochlearis tecta series known from Europe. We suggest that the North American morphotypes be identified in studies of this species because the presence of the posterior spine can greatly affect predator selectivity.     

Effects of Daphnia on microzooplankton communities

Intact phytoplankton and microzooplankton communities from eutrophicStar Lake were incubated for 4 days with and without Daphniapulex, Daphnia galeaia mendotae, or a natural assemblage ofDaphnia species. They were sampled at the onset and terminationof the experiment for bacterial, phytoplankton, ciliate, rotifer,copepod and cladoceran densities. The cladocerans had variedeffects on the rotifers, ranging from significant suppressionof most rotifer species (Keratella cochlearis, Polyarthra remata,Keratella crassa) in the D.pulex jars, to the suppression ofone (K.crassa) or no species in the D.galeata mendotae and StarLake Daphnia assemblage jars, respectively. Small ciliates (<30µm, longest dimension), such as Strobilidium sp. and Pseudo-cyclidiumsp., were adversely affected by most of the cladoceran treatments,while several larger ciliates (>81 µm) were unaffectedin all such treatments. Ciliates were not consistently morevulnerable to cladoceran suppression than similarly sized rotifers.The suppression of ciliates and rotifers was attributable toboth direct effects (predation, interference, or both) and indirecteffects (e.g. resource competition) of the cladocerans. ¹Present address: Department of Biology, University of Louisville,Louisville, KY 40292, USA     

Long-term changes of planktonic rotifers in a subtropical Chinese lake dominated by filter-feeding fishes

1. The long-term changes (1956–1998) in density and species composition of planktonic rotifers were studied at two sampling stations (I, II) of Lake Donghu, a shallow eutrophic Chinese Lake densely stocked with filter-feeding fishes. Annual average densities of rotifers increased with an increase in fish yield and eutrophication, whilst species number decreased from 82 in 1962–1963 to 62 in 1994–1998.
2. During 1962–98, some species such as Anuraeopsis fissa , Polyarthra spp. (including P. dolichoptera & P. vulgaris ) , Trichocerca pusilla and Synchaeta oblonga increased their percentage in abundance remarkably, whilst the proportion of Keratella cochlearis decreased at two relatively eutrophic stations from 19 to 4.2% at Station I and from 30 to 3.2% at Station II.
3. The high r _max of A. fissa probably made it more successful than other rotifers under high predation pressure by planktivorous fish. The decrease in the K. cochlearis population might be attributed partly to predation by Cyclops vicinus .
4. Small rotifers were less vulnerable to fish predation than large-sized cladocerans. Decreases in cladocerans coincided with increases in rotifers, suggesting that the indirect effect of fish predation on cladocerans might have partly contributed to the population development of rotifers in Lake Donghu during recent decades.
5. We also conducted surveys (1994–1998) of seasonal dynamics of rotifers at four sampling stations (I–IV) which have varied in trophic status after fragmentation of the lake in the 1960s. A total of 75 species were identified at the four stations. Both densities and biomass of rotifers were considerably higher in the two more eutrophic stations than in the two less eutrophic stations. This indicates that the population increase of rotifers at Stations I and II during recent decades might be partly attributed to eutrophication of the lake water.     

Differences in rotifer communities in two freshwater bodies of different trophic degree (Lake Ohrid and Lake Dojran,Macedonia)

We investigated monogonont rotifers in two natural Macedonian lakes that greatly differ in age, size and trophic state: Lake Ohrid and Lake Dojran. A main characteristic of Lake Ohrid is the scarcity of nutrients and consequently a low level of primary production. Lake Dojran represents a typical eutrophic lake. Results clearly indicate that species numbers are negatively correlated with trophic degree. Qualitative analyses of rotifer compositions in Lakes Ohrid and Dojran showed the presence of 70 and 55 taxa, respectively. Rotifer assemblages differed in their community structure, population densities, and the occurrence pattern of dominant species. The density of rotifers increased with increasing nutrient concentration, varying from min. 0.67 ind. L⁻¹ in June, 2006 to max. 8.2 ind. L⁻¹ in July, 2004 in Lake Ohrid, whereas min. 28.8 ind. L⁻¹ (in December, 2005) and max. 442.5 ind. L⁻¹ (in September, 2005) were recorded in Lake Dojran. Gastropus stylifer and Keratella cochlearis were the most abundant species in the pelagic zone of Lake Ohrid, averaging monthly densities of 1.2 ind. L⁻¹ and 0.6 ind. L⁻¹, respectively, thereby contributing 29% and 15% to rotifer abundance. In contrast, Lake Dojran rotifers were dominated by Brachionus spp. Brachionus diversicornis and Brachionus calyciflorus f. amphiceros were most abundant, comprising 40% and 25% of the total rotifer density. These results corroborate our idea, that the trophic state is an important factor in determining the composition of rotifer communities.     

Correlations between nutrient concentrations and zooplankton populations in a mesotrophic reservoir

1. A year-round study was conducted in a mesotrophic reservoir to determine the dynamics of zooplankton populations as a function of food availability (edible phytoplankton), nutrient concentration, temperature and hydraulic regime.
2. Rotifer biomass was correlated with soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) concentration. The abundance of the rotifers Keratella cochlearis and Anuraeopsis fissa were not correlated with food availability (measured by chlorophyll and cell counts) but showed a strong dependence on P availability. Another rotifer, Synchaeta oblonga , and crustacean species were not related to nutrient availability but seemed to be dependent on food concentrations, especially of some phytoplankton taxa.
3. In this field study, rotifers seemed more susceptible than Daphnia or copepods to P-limitation. Among rotifer species, Keratella seemed to be more susceptible than Anuraeopsis to P limitation. Different susceptibilities of zooplankton species to nutrient limitation may be important in explaining the dynamics of these organisms in natural situations. Further analyses are warranted to clarify the interactions between nutrient limitation and energy limitation among zooplankton.     

Predatory and toxic effects of the turbellarian (Stenostomum cf leucops) on the population dynamics of Euchlanis dilatata,Plationus patulus (Rotifera) and Moina macrocopa (Cladocera)

Catenulid turbellarians, common in shallow, tropical ponds, affect their rotifer prey via the production of toxins. There is, however, no quantitative information on their effect on the demography of their prey. Here, we test the impact of Stenostomum cf leucops on the population dynamics of the rotifers Euchlanis dilatata and Plationus patulus, and the cladoceran Moina macrocopa. Experiments were initiated with rotifers at 0.5 ind. ml⁻¹ and the cladoceran at 0.2 ind. ml⁻¹; growth patterns were compared in the absence and presence of worms (2 Stenostomum ind. per 50 ml). Results revealed that brachionids were most adversely affected: there was a lower growth rate of the rotifers in the presence of worms (P < 0.01, repeated measures ANOVA), although at the densities applied, the predator did not wipe out its prey. These littoral predators may therefore regulate rotifer prey in natural conditions. In Moina, the population evolved differently; initially, we found no difference between control and treatment, but after about 10 days, the population collapsed, irrespective of a direct or indirect contact with the predator. This delayed effect deserves more study, as it could represent flatworm toxin accumulation by the cladoceran.     

Species-specific interactions between small planktonic ciliates (Urotricha spp.) and rotifers (Keratella spp.)

We investigated the potential impact of four isolates of smallciliates of the genus Urotricha on the common rotifer speciesKeratella cochlearis and Keratella quadrata in laboratory batchculture experiments. Two small Cryptomonas species served asfood for the ciliates and the rotifers in the experiments. Populationgrowth rates of the rotifers were measured when they grew aloneand when they were paired with one of their potential ciliatecompetitors. Growth rates of K. cochlearis were enhanced andtheir mortality rates reduced in the presence of Urotricha furcata,most likely because the rotifers preyed upon the ciliates. Thelarger rotifer species, K. quadrata, also feeds upon small Urotricha,yet their population growth rates were negatively affected byUrotricha. This was because the mortality rate of K. quadrataincreased in the presence of all three isolates of U. furcataand the one isolate of Urotricha farcta. It needs to be investigatedwhether this effect is chemically mediated and ecologicallyrelevant.     

Population growth rates of two closely related rotifer species: effects of food quantity, particle size, and nutritional quality

SUMMARY. 1. The relationship between population growth rates and the concentrations of several algal species was determined in laboratory experiments with the rotifers Brachionus rubens and B. calyciflorus .
2. The effects of food quantity were well described by a modified Monod model with a threshold for zero population growth. The model parameters depended on particle size and nutritional quality of the food algae. Differences between the rotifer species were significant and reflected their varying food-size preferences.
3. For each rotifer species, thresholds were lowest for algae in the most readily ingested size range. The lowest thresholds were 0.07–0.09 mgC 1⁻¹ with algae of about 5 μm equivalent spherical diameter (ESD) for B. rubens , and 0.19 mgC 1⁻¹ with algae of about 10 μm ESD for B. calyciflorus .
4. Maximal growth rates ( r _max) were slightly below 0.8 day⁻¹ for both rotifers with most algal species. The highest r _max values for both rotifers were observed when Cyclotella meneghiniana was provided as food. With this alga, B. calyciflorus had a significantly higher r_max (1.02 day⁻¹) than B. rubens (0.838 day⁻¹).
5. From a comparison of the relationship between growth rates and ingestion rates, Chlamydomonas reinhardii appeared to be of low nutritional quality for B. rubens .
6. Egg ratios were related to growth rate and were not influenced by the algal food used. Egg development times and average mortality rates were estimated from the relationship between egg ratio and growth rate. B. calyciflorus appeared to have a high average mortality rate (0.383 day⁻¹) compared to B. rubens (0.083 day⁻¹).     

The effect of food on protein content in rotifer and cladoceran species

SUMMARY. 1. The protein content of individuals of four species of cladoceran and two species of rotifer in eight ponds was measured over several time periods. The protein content in coarsely filtered water, which includes particulate (less than 31 μm for cladoceran and less than 10μm for rotifers) and dissolved proteins, was also analysed to estimate the amount of food available to the animals.
2. A positive relationship between protein content of individuals and protein in the food was found for all the species. The increase in protein content of the animals was less pronounced when food was more abundant.
3. When food concentration was lower, a greater reduction in protein content was observed in two species of rotifers than in four cladoceran species. Moreover, when comparing among species of Cladocera, the reduction in protein content at low food concentrations was more marked in the small-bodied than in the large-bodied species. These results are consistent with the size-efficiency hypothesis.     

Food limitation of planktonic rotifers: field experiments in two mountain ponds

1. Resource competition is thought to be important in controlling zooplankton population dynamics and structuring zooplankton communities. Resource competition requires that resources are limiting. Ten field experiments were conducted to determine the presence and intensity of resource limitation of herbivorous planktonic rotifers in two mountain ponds. The intensity of food limitation was measured as Δ r , the difference between population growth rates in food supplemented versus control enclosures.
2. Rotifers were significantly food limited (Δ r  > 0) in most experiments. The intensity of food limitation varied between species. In Grady Lake, mean Δ r was 0.26 day⁻¹ for Polyarthra vulgaris and 0.43 day⁻¹ for an unidentified Synchaeta sp. In L1 Pond, mean Δ r was 0.07 day⁻¹ for Keratella cochlearis and 0.28 day⁻¹ for S. oblonga . The frequent and intense food limitation suggests that edible phytoplankton in both ponds were often present at low densities, were of low nutritional quality, or both. The intensity of food limitation often changed rapidly over time, indicating rapid temporal variation in resource availability.
3. For P. vulgaris , Δ r was not correlated with its population growth rate in Grady Lake. Thus, although food limitation was common, population dynamics may have been more strongly affected by other factors. For K. cochlearis , Δ r increased as population density increased, suggesting the existence of intraspecific resource competition that may regulate population dynamics.     

The influence of macrophytes on the spatial distribution of littoral rotifers

1. The effect of macrophytes on the spatial distribution of littoral rotifers was examined in Lake Rotomanuka, New Zealand (37°55'S, 175°19'E). Total rotifer abundances and those of abundant species, were compared between three macrophyte species, Myriophyllum propinquum , Eleocharis sphacelata and Egeria densa , and spatially across a littoral transect in relation to these species.
2. The abundances of many species, for example Euchlanis dilatata, Lecane closterocerca and L. lunaris, differed significantly between macrophyte species. More planktonic forms, Ascomorpha saltans , Keratella cochlearis and Synchaeta oblonga, however, showed no significant preference for macrophyte species.
3. Differences in rotifer abundances were evident even when different species of macrophyte grew in close proximity to one another, indicating that variations in physical and chemical conditions, which occur in the littoral of Lake Rotomanuka, could be largely discounted for much of the variation between macrophyte species.
4. Variation in rotifers between macrophytes was probably the result of a number of factors, including differences in macrophyte morphology, macrophyte age, epiphytic algal growths and the differential effects of predation by invertebrates and fish between macrophytes.
5. Variability of rotifer abundances spatially across the ecotone was less marked than between macrophyte species. The species of macrophyte occurring, and therefore the community composition and distribution of macrophyte species in the littoral, appears to be a major influence in the spatial structuring of rotifer communities in the littoral region of lakes.     

Studies on functional response and prey selection using zooplankton in the anostracan Chirocephalus diaphanus Prevost, 1803

Freshwater cladocerans and rotifers were used as prey to study functional response and prey selection by adult females of Chirocephalus diaphanus under laboratory conditions. For functional response studies, we offered three rotifer species (Brachionus calyciflorus, B. patulus and Euchlanis dilatata) and three cladoceran species (Alona rectangula, Ceriodaphnia dubia and Moina macrocopa) at various densities ranging from 0.5 to 16 ind. ml^–1. We found increased zooplankton consumption with increasing prey density but beyond 4 ind ml^–1 cladocerans and 8 ind. ml^–1 rotifers, the number of animals eaten plateaued. In general, C. diaphanus consumed fewer large prey (cladocerans) and many more smaller zooplankton (rotifers). For prey selection experiments, we used B. calyciflrous, B. patulus, C. dubia and M. macrocopa, offered at the ratio of two rotifers: one cladoceran and at three prey densities (total zooplankton numbers: 3, 6 and 12 ind. ml^–1). Prey selectivity patterns followed the functional response trends. In general, regardless of prey types, with an increase in the available zooplankton, there was an increase in the number of prey consumed. At any given prey density, C. diaphanus consumed higher numbers of rotifers than cladocerans. Among the prey offered, B. patulus and M. macrocopa were positively selected. Results are discussed in light of possible control of zooplankton by anostracans in temporary ponds.     

Effects of an Ostracod (Cypris pubera) on the Rotifer Keratella tropica: Predation and Reduced Spine Development

This study investigates two different effects of an ostracod on a rotifer. The rotifer Keratella tropica and the ostracod Cypris pubera were cultured on the alga Cryptomonas erosa. Adult ostracods (2.2 mm body length) significantly reduced the population growth rate (r day^–1) of K. tropica from 0.42 to 0.13. Individuals of this size ingested live rotifers and produced fecal pellets with rotifer loricas. Smaller ostracods (both 0.59 and 1.61 mm body lengths) did not affect K. tropica 's population growth rate. Surprisingly, C. pubera significantly inhibited spine development in K. tropica. Rotifers cultured with juvenile, non‐predatory ostracods had similar lorica lengths but right and left posterior spines that were 10 and 30% shorter, respectively. The spine reduction induced by the ostracod kairomone is in striking contrast to the spine elongation induced in this rotifer by kairomones from copepods, cladocerans and Asplanchna. In shallow ecosystems, large ostracods that swim in the plankton may be important predators of rotifers. In addition, the presence of ostracods in plankton communities may be one of many factors affecting rotifer spine development. (© 2012 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)     

水蕹菜浮床对草鱼主养池塘轮虫群落结构的影响

研究了水蕹菜浮床对草鱼主养池塘轮虫群落结构的影响,共检出轮虫38种,隶属于2纲14属,其中浮床池塘出现轮虫36种,而非浮床池塘28种。浮床池塘与非浮床池塘的优势种组成基本类似,萼花臂尾轮虫（Brachionus calyciflorus）、裂足臂尾轮虫（Brachionus diversicornis）、裂痕龟纹轮虫（Anuraeopsis fissa）、暗小异尾轮虫（Trichocerca pusilla）以及长肢多肢轮虫（Polyarthra dolichoptera）为共有优势种;浮床池塘与非浮床池塘的轮虫平均密度分别为1892和2255 ind./L,差异极显著（p0.01）;浮床池塘与非浮床池塘轮虫平均生物量分别为1.535和1.405 mg/L,差异不显著（p0.05）。结果表明,水蕹菜浮床显著促进了轮虫种类数增加,提高了轮虫多样性和均匀度,并在一定程度上减缓了轮虫小型化。       

Spring-Summer Succession of Planktonic Rotifers in a South Andes Lake

The dynamics of planktonic rotifer in Laguna Ezquerra (Rio Negro, Argentina) was studied from October 1988 to March 1989, in relation to food resources and cladoceran populations. During the spring and summer period, total rotifer density differed markedly. In spring rotifer populations remained at low density and an inverse relationship with cladoceran biomass was found. In contrast, in summer, the rotifer densities increased greatly and a positive relationship with cladoceran biomass was observed. Food resources decreased during mid January and this seemed to give rotifers a competitive advantage over cladocerans. Bosmina longirostris and Ceriodaphnia dubia were both present during the spring, but only Bosmina prevailed in summer. The composition of cladoceran assemblages together with food resources seem to be an important factor in rotifer dynamics.