Insights into the Initiation of JC Virus DNA Replication Derived from the Crystal Structure of the T-Antigen Origin Binding Domain

JC virus is a member of the Polyomavirus family of DNA tumor viruses and the causative agent of progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML). PML is a disease that occurs primarily in people who are immunocompromised and is usually fatal. As with other Polyomavirus family members, the replication of JC virus (JCV) DNA is dependent upon the virally encoded protein T-antigen. To further our understanding of JCV replication, we have determined the crystal structure of the origin-binding domain (OBD) of JCV T-antigen. This structure provides the first molecular understanding of JCV T-ag replication functions; for example, it suggests how the JCV T-ag OBD site-specifically binds to the major groove of GAGGC sequences in the origin. Furthermore, these studies suggest how the JCV OBDs interact during subsequent oligomerization events. We also report that the OBD contains a novel “pocket”; which sequesters the A1 & B2 loops of neighboring molecules. Mutagenesis of a residue in the pocket associated with the JCV T-ag OBD interfered with viral replication. Finally, we report that relative to the SV40 OBD, the surface of the JCV OBD contains one hemisphere that is highly conserved and one that is highly variable.     

Quantitative analysis of the binding of simian virus 40 large T antigen to DNA

SV40 large T antigen (T-ag) is a multifunctional protein that successively binds to 5'-GAGGC-3' sequences in the viral origin of replication, melts the origin, unwinds DNA ahead of the replication fork, and interacts with host DNA replication factors to promote replication of the simian virus 40 genome. The transition of T-ag from a sequence-specific binding protein to a nonspecific helicase involves its assembly into a double hexamer whose formation is likely dictated by the propensity of T-ag to oligomerize and its relative affinities for the origin as well as for nonspecific double- and single-stranded DNA. In this study, we used a sensitive assay based on fluorescence anisotropy to measure the affinities of wild-type and mutant forms of the T-ag origin-binding domain (OBD), and of a larger fragment containing the N-terminal domain (N260), for different DNA substrates. We report that the N-terminal domain does not contribute to binding affinity but reduces the propensity of the OBD to self-associate. We found that the OBD binds with different affinities to its four sites in the origin and determined a consensus binding site by systematic mutagenesis of the 5'-GAGGC-3' sequence and of the residue downstream of it, which also contributes to affinity. Interestingly, the OBD also binds to single-stranded DNA with an approximately 10-fold higher affinity than to nonspecific duplex DNA and in a mutually exclusive manner. Finally, we provide evidence that the sequence specificity of full-length T-ag is lower than that of the OBD. These results provide a quantitative basis onto which to anchor our understanding of the interaction of T-ag with the origin and its assembly into a double hexamer.     

The crystal structure of the SV40 T-antigen origin binding domain in complex with DNA

DNA replication is initiated upon binding of “initiators” to origins of replication. In simian virus 40 (SV40), the core origin contains four pentanucleotide binding sites organized as pairs of inverted repeats. Here we describe the crystal structures of the origin binding domain (obd) of the SV40 large T-antigen (T-ag) both with and without a subfragment of origin-containing DNA. In the co-structure, two T-ag obds are oriented in a head-to-head fashion on the same face of the DNA, and each T-ag obd engages the major groove. Although the obds are very close to each other when bound to this DNA target, they do not contact one another. These data provide a high-resolution structural model that explains site-specific binding to the origin and suggests how these interactions help direct the oligomerization events that culminate in assembly of the helicase-active dodecameric complex of T-ag.     

Asymmetric assembly of Merkel cell polyomavirus large T-antigen origin binding domains at the viral origin

The double-stranded DNA polyomavirus Merkel cell polyomavirus (MCV) causes Merkel cell carcinoma, an aggressive but rare human skin cancer that most often affects immunosuppressed and elderly persons. As in other polyomaviruses, the large T-antigen of MCV recognizes the viral origin of replication by binding repeating G(A/G)GGC pentamers. The spacing, number, orientation, and necessity of repeats for viral replication differ, however, from other family members such as SV40 and murine polyomavirus. We report here the 2.9 Å crystal structure of the MCV large T-antigen origin binding domain (OBD) in complex with a DNA fragment from the MCV origin of replication. Consistent with replication data showing that three of the G(A/G)GGC-like binding sites near the center of the origin are required for replication, the crystal structure contains three copies of the OBD. This stoichiometry was verified using isothermal titration calorimetry. The affinity for G(A/G)GGC-containing double-stranded DNA was found to be ∼ 740 nM, approximately 8-fold weaker than the equivalent domain in SV40 for the analogous region of the SV40 origin. The difference in affinity is partially attributable to DNA-binding residue Lys331 (Arg154 in SV40). In contrast to SV40, a small protein-protein interface is observed between MCV OBDs when bound to the central region of the origin. This protein-protein interface is reminiscent of that seen in bovine papilloma virus E1 protein. Mutational analysis indicates, however, that this interface contributes little to DNA binding energy.     

Structural Based Analyses of the JC Virus T-Antigen F258L Mutant Provides Evidence for DNA Dependent Conformational Changes in the C-Termini of Polyomavirus Origin Binding Domains

The replication of human polyomavirus JCV, which causes Progressive Multifocal Leukoencephalopathy, is initiated by the virally encoded T-antigen (T-ag). The structure of the JC virus T-ag origin-binding domain (OBD) was recently solved by X-ray crystallography. This structure revealed that the OBD contains a C-terminal pocket, and that residues from the multifunctional A1 and B2 motifs situated on a neighboring OBD molecule dock into the pocket. Related studies established that a mutation in a pocket residue (F258L) rendered JCV T-ag unable to support JCV DNA replication. To establish why this mutation inactivated JCV T-ag, we have solved the structure of the F258L JCV T-ag OBD mutant. Based on this structure, it is concluded that the structural consequences of the F258L mutation are limited to the pocket region. Further analyses, utilizing the available polyomavirus OBD structures, indicate that the F258 region is highly dynamic and that the relative positions of F258 are governed by DNA binding. The possible functional consequences of the DNA dependent rearrangements, including promotion of OBD cycling at the replication fork, are discussed.     

Analyses of the interaction between the origin binding domain from simian virus 40 T antigen and single-stranded DNA provide insights into DNA unwinding and initiation of DNA replication

DNA helicases are essential for DNA metabolism; however, at the molecular level little is known about how they assemble or function. Therefore, as a model for a eukaryotic helicase, we are analyzing T antigen (T-ag) the helicase encoded by simian virus 40. In this study, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods were used to investigate the transit of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) through the T-ag origin-binding domain (T-ag OBD). When the residues that interact with ssDNA are viewed in terms of the structure of a hexamer of the T-ag OBD, comprised of residues 131 to 260, they indicate that ssDNA passes over one face of the T-ag OBD and then transits through a gap in the open ring structure. The NMR-based conclusions are supported by an analysis of previously described mutations that disrupt critical steps during the initiation of DNA replication. These and related observations are discussed in terms of the threading of DNA through T-ag hexamers and the initiation of viral DNA replication.     

T-antigen binding to site I facilitates initiation of SV40 DNA replication but does not affect bidirectionality.

SV40 origin auxiliary sequence 1 (aux-1) encompasses T-antigen (T-ag) binding site I and facilitates origin core (ori-core) activity in whole cells or cell extracts. Aux-1 activity depended completely upon its sequence, orientation and spacing relative to ori-core. Aux-1 activity was lost either by inserting 10 base pairs between aux-1 and ori-core or by placing either orientation of aux-1 on the opposite side of ori-core. Reversing the orientation of aux-1 in its normal position actually inhibited replication. Easily unwound DNA sequences that stimulate yeast or E. coli origins of replication could not replace aux-1. Aux-1 did not affect bidirectional replication. Replication remained bidirectional even when aux-1 was inactivated, and deletion of aux-1 did not affect selection of RNA-primed DNA synthesis initiation sites in the origin region: the transition from discontinuous to continuous DNA synthesis that marks the origin of bidirectional replication occurred at the same nucleotide locations in both wild-type and aux-1 deleted origins. These results support a model for initiation of SV40 DNA replication in which T-ag binding to aux-1 (T-ag binding site I) facilitates the efficiency with which T-ag initiates replication at ori-core (T-ag binding site II) without affecting the mechanism by which initiation of DNA replication occurs.     

Simian virus 40 and polyomavirus large tumor antigens have different requirements for high-affinity sequence-specific DNA binding.

By using a DNA fragment immunoassay, the binding of simian virus 40 (SV40) and polyomavirus (Py) large tumor (T) antigens to regulatory regions at both viral origins of replication was examined. Although both Py T antigen and SV40 T antigen bind to multiple discrete regions on their proper origins and the reciprocal origin, several striking differences were observed. Py T antigen bound efficiently to three regions on Py DNA centered around an MboII site at nucleotide 45 (region A), a BglI site at nucleotide 92 (region B), and another MboII site at nucleotide 132 (region C). Region A is adjacent to the viral replication origin, and region C coincides with the major early mRNA cap site. Weak binding by Py T antigen to the origin palindrome centered at nucleotide 3 also was observed. SV40 T antigen binds strongly to Py regions A and B but only weakly to region C. This weak binding on region C was surprising because this region contains four tandem repeats of GPuGGC, the canonical pentanucleotide sequence thought to be involved in specific binding by T antigens. On SV40 DNA, SV40 T antigen displayed its characteristic hierarchy of affinities, binding most efficiently to site 1 and less efficiently to site 2. Binding to site 3 was undetectable under these conditions. In contrast, Py T antigen, despite an overall relative reduction of affinity for SV40 DNA, binds equally to fragments containing each of the three SV40 binding sites. Py T antigen, but not SV40 T antigen, also bound specifically to a region of human Alu DNA which bears a remarkable homology to SV40 site 1. However, both tumor antigens fail to precipitate DNA from the same region which has two direct repeats of GAGGC. These results indicate that despite similarities in protein structure and DNA sequence, requirements of the two T antigens for pentanucleotide configuration and neighboring sequence environment are different.     

Murine polyomavirus and simian virus 40 large T antigens produce different structural alterations in viral origin DNA.

Murine polyomavirus (Py) and simian virus (SV40) encode homologous large T antigens (T Ags) and also have comparable sequence motifs in their core replication origins. While the ability of SV40 T Ag to produce specific distortions within the SV40 core replication origin (ori) in a nucleotide-dependent fashion has been well documented, little is known about related effects of Py T Ag on Py ori DNA. Therefore, we have examined viral origin DNA binding in the presence of nucleotide and the resulting structural changes induced by Py and SV40 T Ags by DNase I footprinting and KMnO4 modification assays. The structural changes in the Py ori induced by Py T Ag included sites within both the A/T and early side of the core origin region, consistent with what has been shown for SV40. Interestingly, however, Py T Ag also produced sites of distortion within the center of the origin palindrome and at several sites within both the early and late regions that flank the core ori. Thus, Py T Ag produces a more extensive and substantially different pattern of KMnO4 modification sites than does SV40 T Ag. We also observed that both T Ags incompletely protected and distorted the reciprocal ori region. Therefore, significant differences in the interactions of Py and SV40 T Ags with ori DNA may account for the failure of each T Ag to support replication of the reciprocal ori DNA in permissive cell extracts.     

Structure-based analysis of the interaction between the simian virus 40 T-antigen origin binding domain and single-stranded DNA

The origin-binding domain (OBD) of simian virus 40 (SV40) large T-antigen (T-Ag) is essential for many of T-Ag's interactions with DNA. Nevertheless, many important issues related to DNA binding, for example, how single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) transits along the T-Ag OBD, have yet to be established. Therefore, X-ray crystallography was used to determine the costructure of the T-Ag OBD bound to DNA substrates such as the single-stranded region of a forked oligonucleotide. A second structure of the T-Ag OBD crystallized in the presence of poly(dT)(12) is also reported. To test the conclusions derived from these structures, residues identified as being involved in binding to ssDNA by crystallography or by an earlier nuclear magnetic resonance study were mutated, and their binding to DNA was characterized via fluorescence anisotropy. In addition, these mutations were introduced into full-length T-Ag, and these mutants were tested for their ability to support replication. When considered in terms of additional homology-based sequence alignments, our studies refine our understanding of how the T-Ag OBDs encoded by the polyomavirus family interact with ssDNA, a critical step during the initiation of DNA replication.     

Strand and face: the topography of interactions between the SV40 origin of replication and T-antigen during the initiation of replication.

The mechanism by which a replicator (origin of replication) becomes denatured during the initiation of replication is not understood for any prokaryotic or eukaryotic system. To address this question, we chemically probed the molecular contacts on the SV40 origin of replication (ori) that are used by the SV40 large T-antigen and a single-stranded DNA-binding protein (SSB) during ori denaturation. Prior to the actual denaturation step, the T-antigen double hexamer bound ori utilizing sugar-phosphate contacts that were located on opposite strands in each flanking domain of ori. Each set of flanking phosphate contacts were also located on approximately opposite faces of the ori duplex. While the phosphate contacts had a 2-fold symmetry with respect to the ori center, T-antigen contacts with nucleotide bases were polar with critical interactions detected in only one of the two flanking domains. During origin denaturation catalyzed by T-antigen and a SSB, numerous new contacts to flanking phosphates were observed on the strand not initially bound by T-antigen, suggesting movement of each T-antigen hexamer outward from ori. These data suggest that T-antigen initially binds ori in a manner that facilitates transfer of each T-antigen hexamer to opposite strands during the initiation of SV40 replication.     

In vitro initiation of DNA replication in simian virus 40 chromosomes

A soluble system has been developed that can initiate DNA replication de novo in simian virus 40 (SV40) chromatin isolated from virus-infected monkey cells as well as in circular plasmid DNA containing a functional SV40 origin of replication (ori). Initiation of DNA replication in SV40 chromatin required the soluble fraction from a high-salt nuclear extract of SV40-infected cells, a low-salt cytosol fraction, polyethylene glycol, and a buffered salts solution containing all four standard deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates. Purified SV40 large tumor antigen (T-ag) partially substituted for the high-salt nucleosol, and monoclonal antibodies directed against SV40 T-ag inhibited DNA replication. Replication began at ori and proceeded bidirectionally to generate replicating DNA intermediates in which the parental strands remained covalently closed, as observed in vivo. Partial inhibition of DNA synthesis by aphidicolin resulted in accumulation of newly initiated replicating intermediates in this system, a phenomenon not observed under conditions that supported completion of replication only. However, conditions that were optimal for initiation of replication repressed conversion of late-replicating intermediates into circular DNA monomers. Most surprising was the observation that p-n-butylphenyl-dGTP, a potent and specific inhibitor of DNA polymerase-alpha, failed to inhibit replication of SV40 chromatin under conditions that completely inhibited replication of plasmid DNA containing the SV40 ori and either purified or endogenous DNA polymerase-alpha activity. In contrast, all of these DNA synthesis activities were inhibited equally by aphidicolin. Therefore, DNA replication in mammalian cells is carried out either by DNA polymerase-alpha that bears a unique association with chromatin or by a different enzyme such as DNA polymerase-delta.     

Papillomavirus contains cis-acting sequences that can suppress but not regulate origins of DNA replication.

Bovine papillomavirus (BPV) DNA has been reported to restrict its own replication and that of the lytic simian virus 40 (SV40) origin to one initiation event per molecule per S phase, which suggests BPV DNA replication as a model for cellular chromosome replication. Suppression of the SV40 origin required two cis-acting BPV sequences (NCOR-1 and -2) and one trans-acting BPV protein. The results presented in this paper confirm the presence of two NCOR sequences in the BPV genome that can suppress polyomavirus (PyV) as well as SV40 origin-dependent DNA replication as much as 40-fold. However, in contrast to results of previous studies on SV40, most of the suppression of the PyV origin was due to NCOR-1, a 512-bp sequence that functioned independently of distance or orientation with respect to the PyV origin and that was not required for BPV DNA replication. Moreover, NCOR-1 alone or together with NCOR-2 did not restrict the ability of the PyV ori to reinitiate replication within a single S phase and did not require any BPV protein to exert suppression. Furthermore, NCOR-1 did not suppress BPV origin-dependent DNA replication except in the presence of PyV large tumor antigen (T-ag). Since NCOR-1 suppression of PyV origin activity also varied with T-ag concentration, suppression of origins by NCOR sequences appeared to require papovavirus T-ag. Therefore, it is unlikely that NCOR sequences are involved in regulating BPV DNA replication. When these results are taken together with those from other laboratories, BPV appears to be a slowly replicating version of papovaviruses rather than a model for origins of DNA replication in eukaryotic cell chromosomes.     

cis-Acting components of human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA replication: linker substitution analysis of the HPV type 11 origin.

Papillomavirus DNA replication requires the viral trans-acting factors E1 and E2 in addition to the host cell's general replication machinery. The origins of DNA replication in bovine and human papillomavirus genomes have been localized to a specific part of the upstream regulatory region (URR) which includes recognition sites for E1 and E2 proteins. To fine map cis-acting elements influencing human papillomavirus type 11 (HPV-11) DNA replication and to determine the relative contributions of such sites, we engineered consecutive linker substitution mutations across a region of 158 bp in the HPV-11 origin and tested mutant origins for replication function in a cell-based transient replication assay. Our results both confirm and extend the findings of others. E2 binding sites are the major cis components of HPV-11 DNA replication, and there is evidence for synergy between these sites. Differential capacity of the three E2 binding sites within the origin to affect replication may be attributed, at least in part, to context. At least one E2 binding site is essential for replication. The imperfect AT-rich palindrome of the E1 helicase binding site is not essential since replication occurs even in the absence of this sequence. However, replication is enhanced by the presence of the palindromic sequence in the HPV-11 origin. Sequence components adjacent to the E1 and E2 binding sites, comprising AT-rich and purine-rich elements and the consensus TATA box sequence, probably contribute to the overall efficiency of replication, though they are nonessential. None of the other cis elements of the HPV-11 origin region analyzed seems to influence replication significantly in the system described. The HPV-11 origin of DNA replication therefore differs from those of the other papovaviruses, simian virus 40 and polyomavirus, inasmuch as an intact helicase binding site and adjacent AT-rich components, while influential, are not absolutely essential.     

Characterization of the DNA-binding properties of the origin-binding domain of simian virus 40 large T antigen by fluorescence anisotropy

The affinity of the origin-binding domain (OBD) of simian virus 40 large T antigen for its cognate origin was measured at equilibrium using a DNA binding assay based on fluorescence anisotropy. At a near-physiological concentration of salt, the affinities of the OBD for site II and the core origin were 31 and 50 nM, respectively. Binding to any of the four 5'-GAGGC-3' binding sites in site II was only slightly weaker, between 57 and 150 nM. Although the OBD was shown previously to assemble as a dimer on two binding sites spaced by 7 bp, we found that increasing the distance between both binding sites by 1 to 3 bp had little effect on affinity. Similar results were obtained for full-length T antigen in absence of nucleotide. Addition of ADP-Mg, which promotes hexamerization of T antigen, greatly increased the affinity of full-length T antigen for the core origin and for nonspecific DNA. The implications of these findings for the assembly of T antigen at the origin and its transition to a non-specific DNA helicase are discussed.     

SV40 large T antigen hexamer structure: domain organization and DNA-induced conformational changes

Simian Virus 40 replication requires only one viral protein, the Large T antigen (T-ag), which acts as both an initiator of replication and as a replicative helicase (reviewed in ). We used electron microscopy to generate a three-dimensional reconstruction of the T-ag hexameric ring in the presence and absence of a synthetic replication fork to locate the T-ag domains, to examine structural changes in the T-ag hexamer associated with DNA binding, and to analyze the formation of double hexamers on and off DNA. We found that binding DNA to the T-ag hexamer induces large conformational changes in the N- and C-terminal domains of T-ag. Additionally, we observed a significant increase in density throughout the central channel of the hexameric ring upon DNA binding. We conclude that conformational changes in the T-ag hexamer are required to accommodate DNA and that the mode of DNA binding may be similar to that suggested for some other ring helicases. We also identified two conformations of T-ag double hexamers formed in the presence of forked DNA: with N-terminal hexamer-hexamer contacts, similar to those formed on origin DNA, or with C-terminal contacts, which are unlike any T-ag double hexamers reported previously.     

The origin of bidirectional DNA replication in polyoma virus.

The nucleotide locations of RNA-p-DNA covalent linkages in polyoma virus (PyV) replicating DNA were mapped in the region containing the genetically required origin of DNA replication (ori). These linkages mark the initiation sites for RNA-primed DNA synthesis. A clear transition was identified between the presence of these linkages (discontinuous DNA synthesis) and their absence (continuous DNA synthesis) on each strand of ori. This demonstrated that PyV DNA replication, like simian virus 40 (SV40), is semi-discontinuous, and thus revealed the location of the origin of bidirectional DNA replication (OBR). The transition site on the template encoding PyV late mRNA occurred at the junction of ori-core and T-antigen binding site A. This was essentially the same site as previously observed in SV40 (Hay and DePamphilis, 1982). However, in contrast to SV40, the transition site on the template encoding PyV early mRNA was displaced towards the late gene side of ori. This resulted in a 16 nucleotide gap within ori in which no RNA-p-DNA linkages were observed on either strand. A model for the initiation of PyV DNA replication is presented.