Evaluation of the Cost Effectiveness of Establishing A Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology Clinic In A Hospital Out-Patient Department

In an attempt to reduce the number of inadequate smears processed by our laboratory and the false negative rate of fine needle aspiration cytodiagnosis, we have introduced a fine needle aspiration cytology service where aspirates are taken by the cytopathologist in a clinic. In the 12 month period since the introduction of this service, the number of inadequate smears fell sharply. Nine per cent of the specimens were inadequate compared with 43% of specimens from other sources. The establishment of the clinic resulted in a threefold reduction in the cost of diagnosing breast lesions.     

The utility of transbronchial (Wang) fine needle aspiration in lung cancer diagnosis

We evaluated our experience with transbronchial fine needle aspiration (TBNA) in cancer diagnosis over a period of 1 year. A total of 51 aspirates were performed by specialist chest physicians in the presence of a cytopathologist who made on spot evaluation of Diff-Quik smears for adequacy and guided the aspirator for additional sampling if necessary. Two clusters of at least 10 malignant cells were required on the Diff-Quik smears to render an on the spot positive diagnosis of malignancy. Aspirates showing atypical cells or few malignant cells not fulfilling the above criteria were placed in a suspicious category and additional material was requested. The TBNA results were correlated with the transbronchial biopsy when available.     

Fine Needle Aspiration of Palpable Breast Lumps: A 1-Year Audit Using the Cytospin Method

A fine-needle aspiration (FNA) service for the diagnosis of palpable breast lumps was started at the Royal Preston Hospital, Preston, UK, in November 1989. Over the subsequent year, 407 FNAs were taken from 393 women. A simple technique was used which involved the surgeon flushing the aspirate into 10 ml of Cytospin collection fluid; cytocentrifuge preparations were then safely and conveniently prepared in the laboratory. Slides were stained with Papanicolaou and H&E. The method detected 112 out of a total of 121 cancers (92.6%); of the nine that were undetected, five aspirates were inadequate and four were falsely reported as negative. There were no false positives. The overall inadequate rate was 11.0%. Excluding inadequate samples, the absolute sensitivity was 89.7% and complete sensitivity 96.6% with 94.4% specificity. This 1-year audit has shown the Cytospin method of FNA in palpable breast disease to have a favourable sensitivity and specificity, and therefore to be an alternative to conventional FNA using direct smears.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of thyroid nodules: how accurate is it and what are the causes of discrepant cases?

Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is widely accepted as the most accurate, sensitive, specific and cost-effective diagnostic procedure in the assessment of thyroid nodules and helps to select people preoperatively for surgery. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of thyroid FNAC in our institution and to determine the reasons for discrepancies between the cytological and histological diagnosis. We evaluated the cytological and histological results of 254 FNACs obtained from 231 patients who underwent subsequent thyroid surgery. All of the material was blindly reviewed for quality control, by one experienced cytopathologist. All FNACs were carried out under ultrasound guidance. The cytological diagnosis was classified as benign, suspicious, malignant or unsatisfactory. The definitive histological study showed benign lesions in 195 of the 231 patients (84%). A benign diagnosis based on FNAC was correct in 105 of the 108 benign cases (97%). FNACs diagnosed as 'suspicious' resulted in a distribution of 49 benign (79%) and 13 malignant (21%) diagnoses. FNAC showed malignancy in 34 cases (13%) and in only one case did the final histology differ from cytology (correlation 97%). The percentage of FNACs that were inadequate for diagnosis was 20%. Review of cytological and histological slides did not lead to any change in the original diagnosis. Our study revealed a cytological-histological discrepancy (2%) in only 4 out of 231 cases over a period of 10 years, due to either a diagnostic or sampling error.     

The cytomorphologic spectrum of Wilms tumour on fine needle aspiration: a single institutional experience of 110 cases

A. Nayak, V.K. Iyer and S. Agarwala
The cytomorphologic spectrum of Wilms tumour on fine needle aspiration: a single institutional experience of 110 cases Objective: To analyse the cytomorphologic spectrum of Wilms tumour (WT) on aspirates, the largest series reported to date. Study design: Adequate aspirates from paediatric renal tumours over a period of 17 years were reviewed and selected if subsequent excision showed WT or aspirates were diagnostic for WT and clinical/radiological evidence consistent with that diagnosis. Smears were re‐examined for the proportion of components, degree of pleomorphism and mitosis. Results: Of 110 aspirates, smears were triphasic in 44 (40.0%), biphasic (blastema and tubules) in 36 (32.7%) and monophasic (blastema alone) in 30 (27.3%). Stromal predominance was seen in 11 aspirates (10.0%) and five showed rhabdomyoblastic differentiation; all 11 were triphasic. Mean mitotic rate was 9.3/5000 cells (range 4–39/5000). Nuclear atypia not amounting to anaplasia and without atypical mitoses was seen in 15 (13.6%); these presented diagnostic problems. Two aspirates (1.8%) were considered anaplastic (unfavourable), both having atypical mitoses. Criteria similar to histology (i.e. 3‐fold or more variation in nuclear size, marked hyperchromasia with bizarre nuclei and atypical mitoses in a biphasic or triphasic aspirate) helped in distinguishing anaplastic WT. Histopathological correlation in 67 cases showed good correlation of blastemal predominance, stromal predominance and anaplastic histology with the corresponding cytology. However, 9/27 (33.3%) triphasic tumours had only blastemal cells on corresponding aspiration because of sampling error. Cytokeratin was positive in 4 of 20 aspirates with blastema alone. Conclusions: Aspirates from WT were triphasic or biphasic in the majority (72.7%), permitting cytological diagnosis, which was improved by cytokeratin immunocytochemistry. Blastemal and stromal predominance on histology correlated well with cytology, but many triphasic tumours showed only blastema on aspiration. Anaplastic WT can be detected on aspirates using criteria similar to histology.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of medullary carcinoma of the thyroid with a focus on rare variants: a review of 78 cases

S. Kaushal, V. K. Iyer, S. R. Mathur and R. Ray
Fine needle aspiration cytology of medullary carcinoma of the thyroid with a focus on rare variants: a review of 78 cases Background: The cytological features of variants of medullary carcinoma of the thyroid (MCT) are sparsely documented in the literature from case reports. Detailed cytomorphological analysis of MCT variants and features helping to distinguish them from usual MCT are presented here. Materials and methods: A total of 78 aspirates with a diagnosis of MCT over a period of 10 years were re‐evaluated. Cytomorphological details were reviewed and semiquantitatively analysed. Histology slides were reviewed in 36 cases. Results: Most aspirates showed classical features of dispersed polygonal or plasmacytoid cells with areas of spindling. In 54 aspirates, a definite cytological diagnosis of medullary carcinoma was made, which in 87.1% was based on cytomorphology alone and in 12.9% was based on immunocytochemistry for calcitonin. In 30.1% of aspirates from MCT, a guarded report of tumour was given in the absence of calcitonin immunocytochemistry. Of the 78 cases, nuclear grooves were seen in 5.1%, intranuclear cytoplasmic inclusions in 28.2%, cytoplasmic granularity in 23.1% and bizarre cells with abrupt anisocytosis in 85.9%. A follicular arrangement was seen in 14.1% and was more frequent in the follicular type (one case) and mixed follicular and medullary carcinoma (one case). Melanin production was seen in aspirates from two cases. One case of the giant cell type of MCT was seen, in which background cells showed large pleomorphic nuclei and numerous bizarre tumour giant cells, prompting a differential diagnosis with anaplastic carcinoma. One example each of the small cell type, paraganglioma‐like MCT and papillary MCT were seen. Conclusions: MCT has uniform cytological features in the majority of aspirates, including many of the histological variants. Searching for pigment in every aspirate of MCT may be rewarding. The giant cell type of MCT is rare and has to be differentiated from anaplastic carcinoma.     

Scrape cell-block technique for fine needle aspiration cytology smears

An inconclusive diagnosis on fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) may be due to poor spreading and presence of thick tissue fragments despite aspiration of adequate material. Repeat aspiration may not be possible especially when aspirates of deep seated organs have been obtained by image guided techniques. We have resorted to a 'scrape cell-block' (SCB) technique in such cases. In this technique the cellular material on the slides which had already been fixed and stained, was carefully removed by scraping following destaining and then processed as a cell block. SCB interpretation was then compared with the smear diagnosis and histological diagnosis, wherever available. A total of 27 cases were studied. In 12 cases SCB slides added information to the FNAC smears. In 14 cases SCB did not offer any additional information. SCB was inconclusive in one case. Final histological correlation was available in eight cases and the SCB diagnosis was confirmed in six cases, whereas in two cases SCB failed to identify the tumour. Immunocytochemistry (ICC) was done in one case. SCB is a useful technique to make the best use of the available material when reaspiration is difficult.     

Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology of Breast In Invasive Carcinoma of Tubular Type and In Radial Scar/Complex Sclerosing Lesions

Fine needle aspirates (FNA) from 31 invasive carcinomas of tubular type and 22 radial scar/complex sclerosing lesions (RS/CSL), diagnosed in Edinburgh between 1986 and 1991, were reviewed. the lesions in this study varied in size and palpability at presentation, but are of increasing interest in the differential diagnosis of non-palpable areas of increased mammographic density. In agreement with previously published information^1'5'8, it was found that the tubular cancers were usually selected for biopsy following aspiration, but less often definitively diagnosed as malignant. Nearly 50% of the RS/CSL group were correctly reported benign on cytology, but in 40%, biopsy was recommended to exclude malignancy. In addition, cytological features helpful in suggesting malignancy in aspirates from tubular cancers, also raised suspicion in aspirates from the RS/CSL group, with a risk of overdiagnosis of cancer.     

Routine audit of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology specimens and aspirator inadequate rates

Routine audit of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology specimens and aspirator inadequate rates In an attempt to improve the quality of the breast FNA specimens we instigated a continuing audit of this procedure in this hospital. All FNAs since 1990 have had the following recorded: mode of aspiration, e.g. freehand or image guided, patient presentation (screening or symptomatic), patient diagnostic category, cytological diagnosis and final histological diagnosis. Aspirator performance was assessed by means of the inadequate aspiration rate (IR) of FNAs performed on patients with a final diagnosis of cancer (FDC) and diagnostic category A patients (clinically or radiologically malignant lesions). An ongoing annual review of the performance of all the aspirators was undertaken, all of whom received individual feedback. Counselling and further training were offered where indicated by poor performance. Over the period 1990–1995 a total of 13 537 FNAs were performed by 27 aspirators. The IR on category A and FDC cases over this period was 16.0% and 18.1%. The best performance achieved by an aspirator in a calendar year was an IR of 3.6% with no inadequate specimens in either FDC or category A lesions, and the best performance over the entire period was an average IR of 11.75% and 14.25% for FDC and category A groups, respectively. The overall IR on category A patients ranged from 15.9% to 23.8% and on FDC cases from 12.2% to 21.7%. There was a significant improvement in individual junior aspirator performance when their first year was compared with their last year on the unit. In some cases a deterioration in intra-aspirator performance was observed, from an IR of 6% to 33%. The overall IR rate of the unit remained stable for FDC patients, 15.5% in 1990 compared with 15.1% in 1995. This appeared to be largely due to a high proportion of the aspirations being performed by experienced personnel with consistent IRs. However, concealed within the overall rate there were some poor performers who benefited from counselling and/or further training. These results indicate an important role for audit in identifying poor aspirators who benefit from targeted training and advice, thereby improving the quality of FNA specimens, and ultimately patient care.     

Pitfalls in the diagnosis of Wegener''s granulomatosis on fine needle aspiration cytology

OBJECTIVE: To review the clinical and pathological findings in six suspected cases of Wegener's granulomatosis (WG) and highlight the diagnostic difficulties faced by the cytopathologist. METHODS: Retrospective review of records of the Cytopathology Department to identify patients who underwent image-guided transthoracic pulmonary fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) for pulmonary lesions of suspected WG and those who were subsequently confirmed to have WG. Detailed evaluation of cytomorphological features was carried out. RESULTS: A total of six cases were identified in whom the initial procedure to obtain a pathological diagnosis was transthoracic FNAC. In one case, atypical squamous cells on cytology initially suggested a diagnosis of squamous cell carcinoma while in another a diagnosis of WG was made on cytology; however, a subsequent lung biopsy revealed silicosis. CONCLUSION: Acute inflammation and necrosis are the most consistent cytopathological findings in WG. In selected cases FNAC can provide supportive pathological evidence to establish a diagnosis of WG.     

Impact of cytopathologist expert on diagnosis and treatment of pancreatic lesions in current clinical practice. A series of 106 endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine needle aspirations

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the role of a cytopathologist expert in interpreting difficult pancreatic endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration (EUS-FNA) in terms of impact on diagnostic yield and therapy in current clinical practice. METHODS: Retrospective study of 106 EUS-FNA performed between January 2002 and September 2004. Forty-seven cases of difficult interpretation by the local cytopathologist were mailed to an expert cytopathologist. The final diagnosis was established by histology obtained by either surgery (n=30), non-equivocal FNA (n=40) or core (n=8) biopsies, or by a mean follow-up of 14 months (n=28). RESULTS: EUS-FNA involved 68 solid lesions (SL). Specimens collected were adequate in 63%. The overall sensitivity of EUS-FNA for the diagnosis of malignancy of SL was 88% versus 72% for local cytopathologist and 89% for expert. EUS-FNA with the reevaluation by expert of 39 SL gave a therapeutic impact in 47% of SL. Thirty-eight cystic lesions (CL) were evaluated. Specimens collected were adequate for cytology in 84% of cases and for biochemistry in 79%. The sensitivity of imaging+EUS-FNA+/-biochemistry for the diagnosis of a surgical CL was 58% with a therapeutic impact in 39.5%. CONCLUSION: Pancreatic EUS-FNA is an easy technique for experienced endosonographers, which can be safely performed on an outpatient basis. The possibility of mailing difficult cases to an expert cytopathologist increases the diagnostic yield. In these circumstances, EUS-FNA has a therapeutic impact in current practice in nearly one out of two pancreatic lesions.     

Evaluation of fine needle aspiration of the male breast for the diagnosis of gynaecomastia

Fine needle aspiration of the male breast can present problems of diagnosis because the cytological presentation of gynaecomastia can be confused with that of adenocarcinoma. We reviewed breast aspirates from 24 male patients in order to determine the accuracy of cytology as a method of diagnosing gynaecomastia. Discrepancies were observed between the original cytology reports on one hand and the review cytology and biopsies on the other. Of the 24 aspirates from the male breast, the cytology was reported as negative in 16 cases, suspicious in three cases and malignant in five. In four cases of the negative group, a specific diagnosis of gynaecomastia was made. In two of the negative cases the subsequent biopsies revealed adenocarcinoma. Of the five cases reported on the original cytology as adenocarcinoma, two on review showed the features of florid gynaecomastia and this was confirmed on biopsy and three confirmed the initial diagnosis of adenocarcinoma. The cytological features of gynaecomastia which distinguish it from adenocarcinoma are discussed.     

Evaluation of aspiration cytology of ovarian masses with histopathological correlation

T. Sood, U. Handa, H. Mohan and P. Goel
Evaluation of aspiration cytology of ovarian masses with histopathological correlation Objectives: To evaluate the efficacy and diagnostic accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in distinguishing non‐neoplastic and neoplastic ovarian lesions and to determine reliable cytological criteria for typing neoplastic ovarian masses into benign and malignant tumours and their subtypes. Methods: FNAC was performed on 50 patients diagnosed as having an ovarian mass clinically and/or ultrasonographically. Detailed history, clinical examination and ultrasound findings in each case were recorded. The cytological diagnoses were categorized as neoplastic and non‐neoplastic and further into benign and malignant neoplasms. These cytological diagnoses were then compared subsequently with the histopathological diagnoses. Results: The study material consisted of 57 aspirates from 50 patients. A comparison of cytological findings with the histological diagnosis was possible in 53 aspirates; in the remaining four cases (7%) the smears were acellular. On cytology, 31 lesions were diagnosed as neoplastic and 22 as non‐neoplastic. The overall sensitivity of cytology in diagnosing neoplastic and non‐neoplastic ovarian lesions was 93.9% and the specificity was 100%. The positive predictive value was 100% and negative predictive value 90.9%. The overall diagnostic accuracy was 96.2 %. Conclusion: FNAC of ovarian masses is a minimally invasive procedure that can differentiate neoplastic from non‐neoplastic ovarian lesions. It may help avoid unnecessary operations and preserve the reproductive ability in young patients. Furthermore, it also enables a satisfactory sub‐categorization of ovarian tumours, which facilitates the choice of appropriate therapy.     

Searching for RET/PTC rearrangements and BRAF V599E mutation in thyroid aspirates might contribute to establish a preoperative diagnosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: Searching for multiple molecular markers in thyroid aspirates appears to be a promising approach for establishing a preoperative diagnosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC). METHODS: Based on this hypothesis, a total of 63 samples from 55 patients, were collected at random. RNA was extracted from the residue cells inside the needle used for fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) and thereafter molecular analysis was carried out both for RETrearrangements (type 1, 2, 3) and BRAF codon 599 mutation molecule. Results were compared with the cytological and histopathological diagnoses in 24 patients submitted to surgery. RESULTS: 58% PTCs presented a genetic alteration either RET/PTC rearrangement, BRAF V599E mutation or both: three cases of PTCs (25%) presented a RET/PTC rearrangement; three cases of PTCs (25%) presented a BRAF V599E mutation and in one case (8%) both alterations were identified. CONCLUSIONS: The present results suggest that searching for multiple molecular markers in thyroid aspirates may enhance the accuracy of FNAC and refine preoperative diagnosis of PTC.     

C-Erbb-2 Expression and Dna Ploidy Status In Breast Cancer Cells Obtained By Fine Needle Aspiration (Fna)

The aim of this study was to determine the relative rate of c-erbB-2 oncoprotein immuno-detection on matched fine needle aspiration (FNA) smears and surgical specimens of breast cancer, and to correlate the c-erbB-2 expression with the assessment of the DNA ploidy status. the expression of c-erbB-2 oncoprotein was evaluated using an immunoalkaline phosphatase technique in 49 breast aspirates (four benign and 45 malignant lesions) and 21 matched surgical specimens. the DNA ploidy status was assessed by densitometric techniques on Feulgen-stained smears. Fifty-eight per cent of the smears obtained from 45 malignant lesions and 43% of the 21 corresponding paraffin sections contained cells that were stained by the antibody. the higher incidence of c-erbB-2 expression on smears seems to be due mainly to the better antigen preservation in the fresh cytological preparations. the correlation between c-erbB-2 oncogene expression and DNA ploidy assessment showed an increased incidence of oncogene expression in aneuploid tumours (71% vs 29%; P > 0.05).     

Morphometric analysis of fine needle aspirates from breast lesions

In an attempt to discover the morphometric variables with the most diagnostic power in the differentiation of benign from malignant breast disease, 20 unequivocally benign and 20 unequivocally malignant and histologically confirmed breast aspirates were examined on an image analyser. It was found that standard deviation of nuclear area was the most discriminant variable. Then 23 aspirates initially diagnosed as 'suspicious of malignancy' were measured by the same technique, and standard deviation of nuclear area correctly differentiated all but three cases.     

Ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration cytology in the diagnosis and management of thyroid nodules

OBJECTIVE: To examine the accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules and compare the inadequacy rates for ultrasound-guided and freehand FNAC. METHODS: A retrospective study of 434 patients with thyroid nodules who underwent diagnostic FNAC over a 2-year period. Cytological diagnoses have been compared with the histological assessment of resection specimens in 69 cases. RESULTS: The inadequacy rate was significantly lower from ultrasound guided FNAC (24/373 cases, 6.4%) than from freehand FNAC (8/61 cases, 13.1%) (P = 0.043). Seventy-six percentage of patients had a non-neoplastic cytological diagnosis and, after multidisciplinary review, the patients were reassured and assigned to clinical follow-up. Sixty-seven patients had a resection for cytological appearances consistent with non-neoplastic disease (n = 34), suspicious of follicular neoplasia (n = 23), or suspicious of malignancy (n = 10), and two patients had resections following inadequate cytology with ultrasound appearances suspicious of a neoplasm. The overall accuracy of FNAC analysis for malignancy was 97.0%, with sensitivity 83.3%, specificity 98.0%, positive predictive value 71.4% and negative predictive value 98.4%. The overall accuracy of FNAC analysis for the prediction of neoplasia was 97.5%, with sensitivity 80.5%, specificity 97.8%, positive predictive value 89.2% and negative predictive value 95.9%. Difficulties in cytological diagnosis were associated with lymphoid infiltrates and with degenerative changes in follicular adenomas. CONCLUSION: Ultrasound-guided FNAC has a significantly lower yield of inadequate aspirates than palpable FNAC. The ability of FNAC to predict neoplasia in 89% patients and to exclude neoplasia in 95.9% patients makes an important contribution to the multidisciplinary assessment of patients.     

Fine Needle Aspiration Cytodiagnosis of Subacute (De Quervain's) Thyroiditis In an Endemic Goitre Area

Between 1977 and 1989 252 fine needle aspirates (FNAs) of the thyroid from patients with a clinical suspicion of subacute granulomatous (de Quervain's) thyroiditis were examined in the Department of Pathology of the University of Innsbruck, Austria. In the same period 31 cases with preoperative FNA were diagnosed histologically as subacute thyroiditis. Only in three of these cases were the cytological features of de Quervain's thyroiditis found in the preoperative FNA. However, in 13 of these 31 cases a cytological suspicion of malignancy was obtained. Subsequent histological examination revealed an acute phase inflammation of de Quervain's thyroiditis in most of these cases. We conclude that an accurate FNA diagnosis of de Quervain's thyroiditis, particularly in the acute stage, may cause difficulties due to a lack of typical features and the appearance of atypical thyroid follicular cells. For the cytopathologist, accurate clinical information relating to the possibility of de Quervain's thyroiditis is essential if unnecessary surgery is to be avoided.     

Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology of the Breast: Factors Affecting Sensitivity

At Northampton General Hospital a pathologist takes, stains and immediately reports aspirates at a fine needle aspiration clinic which is run in conjunction with a busy surgical breast clinic. the effect of various factors on the sensitivity of the technique have been quantified. Small tumour size, certain types of tumour and lesions difficult to palpate are causes of reduced sensitivity. Acellular samples had little effect on sensitivity. In this clinic trainee aspirators achieved good results early in their experience. After one year each had improved to the level of an experienced aspirator.     

Fine needle aspiration biopsy of the spleen in pyrexia of unknown origin

To evaluate the diagnostic utility, value and potential risk of fine needle aspiration biopsy of spleen (sFNAB) in patients with splenomegaly in pyrexia of unknown origin (PUO), a retrospective analysis of medical records and cytological material of 31 patients on whom FNAB was performed between April 1994 and October 1997 was done. The patients were HIV- and presented with PUO. All other relevant investigations were negative. The spleen was either palpable or detected to have space-occupying lesions on ultrasonography (USG). The splenic aspirates showed tuberculosis in 11 patients (35.4%) and inconclusive or reactive changes in nine patients (25.8%). One case out of this group proved to be Kaposi's sarcoma on autopsy. The other diseases encountered were leishmaniasis (n = 3), non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (n = 4), fungal infections (n = 2), Hodgkin's lymphoma (n = 1). The patients who were diagnosed as having tuberculosis had epithelioid cells, giant cells, necrosis and inflammatory cells in various combinations. AFB positivity was 63.6%. The other cases which showed granulomas but no AFB were diagnosed on empirical grounds and all responded to the anti-tuberculosis therapy. No complications were encountered with the procedure. Therefore the authors conclude that sFNAB is rewarding in patients where all other non-invasive modalities of diagnosis have failed.