Comparison of the utility of barley retrotransposon families for genetic analysis by molecular marker techniques

The Sequence-Specific Amplification Polymorphism (S-SAP) method, and the related molecular marker techniques IRAP (inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism) and REMAP (retrotransposon-microsatellite amplified polymorphism), are based on retrotransposon activity, and are increasingly widely used. However, there have been no systematic analyses of the parameters of these methods or of the utility of different retrotransposon families in producing polymorphic, scorable fingerprints. We have generated S-SAP, IRAP, and REMAP data for three barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) varieties using primers based on sequences from six retrotransposon families (BARE-1, BAGY-1, BAGY-2, Sabrina, Nikita and Sukkula). The effect of the number of selective bases on the S-SAP profiles has been examined and the profiles obtained with eight MseI+3 selective primers compared for all the elements. Polymorphisms detected in the insertion pattern of all the families show that each can be used for S-SAP. The uniqueness of each transposition event and differences in the historic activity of each family suggest that the use of multiple retrotransposon families for genetic analysis will find applications in mapping, fingerprinting, and marker-assisted selection and evolutionary studies, not only in barley and other Hordeum species and related taxa, but also more generally.     

Gypsy-like retrotransposons in Pyrenophora: an abundant and informative class of molecular markers.

This paper describes the development of S-SAP (sequence-specific amplified polymorphism) using a primer derived from the LTR (long terminal repeat) of the Pyggy retrotransposon isolated from Pyrenophora graminea. Fragments were amplified by S-SAP from different Pyrenophora spp., indicating the presence of Pyggy-like sequences in these genomes. The bands were highly polymorphic between isolates and the number of bands differed by as much as 10-fold between species, demonstrating the potential of this method for genetic analysis in fungi. The phylogenetic relationship among the isolates as deduced using S-SAP data is presented, and shows evidence of genetic exchange between P. graminea and P. teres.     

S-SAP分子标记开发及其在苹果芽变鉴别上的应用

S-SAP(特异序列扩增多态性,Ssequence specific amplification polymorphism)是一种基于反转录转座元件的广泛应用于生物遗传多样性研究的分子标记。本研究从34对引物中筛选出7对具有谱带清晰、多态性高的引物组合,成功地开发了苹果基因组的S-SAP分子标记。27个元帅系芽变品种中,共扩增出588条谱带,每对引物组合平均扩增出84条谱带,其中多态性谱带48条,多态性谱带占总扩增出谱带数的8.2%,遗传相似系数介于0.73～0.90之间。对15个苹果芽变品种进行S-SAP分析,相似系数在0.42～0.94之间,以相似系数0.80为阈值,可以区分各芽变品系。开发的S-SAP分子标记可以有效地将苹果芽变品种区分,并为苹果生物遗传多样性与系统进化、品种鉴定提供新方法。     

Activation of transposable elements and insertional polymorphism in Opuntia offspring as assessed by inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism markers

Activation of retrotransposon is a pivotal factor in the genesis of genetic polymorphism. Retrotransposon-based molecular markers are excellent tools for detecting genetic diversity and genomic changes associated with their activity. The objective of this study was to use IRAP markers to detect integration events of retrotransposon in Opuntia, and to compare IRAP and ISSR polymorphisms. To achieve these aims, five IRAP and five ISSR markers were analyzed on three varieties and their progenies. All IRAP primers showed an increase in the percentage of polymorphism, number of total bands, and polymorphic bands in the seedlings compared to their mother plants; that is, the offspring showed 13, 24 and 27 more bands than the mother plants from Tobarito, Montesa and Copena varieties, respectively. Conversely, sexual reproduction did not proportionally affect the variation in the number of ISSR bands, and neither did polymorphisms between mother plants and their offspring. Cluster and multivariate analyses based on IRAP and ISSR data revealed a clear separation between varieties, and there was no overlapping between seedlings of different varieties. The activation of retrotransposons in seedlings of opuntia with variable frequencies was evidenced. The presence of insertion and active retrotransposons may help to undertake studies on genetic diversity and evolution of Opuntia.     

Integration of Retrotransposons-Based Markers in a Linkage Map of Barley

A deeper understanding of random markers is important if they are to be employed for a range of objectives. The sequence specific amplified polymorphism (S-SAP) technique is a powerful genetic analysis tool which exploits the high copy number of retrotransposon long terminal repeats (LTRs) in the plant genome. The distribution and inheritance of S-SAP bands in the barley genome was studied using the Steptoe × Morex (S × M) double haploid (DH) population. Six S-SAP primer combinations generated 98 polymorphic bands, and map positions were assigned to all but one band. Eight putative co-dominant loci were detected, representing 16 of the mapped markers. Thus at least 81 of the mapped S-SAP loci were dominant. The markers were distributed along all of the seven chromosomes and a tendency to cluster was observed. The distribution of S-SAP markers over the barley genome concurred with the knowledge of the high copy number of retrotransposons in plants. This experiment has demonstrated the potential for the S-SAP technique to be applied in a range of analyses such as genetic fingerprinting, marker assisted breeding, biodiversity assessment and phylogenetic analyses.     

Retrotransposon insertional polymorphism in sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) lines revealed by IRAP and REMAP markers

Retrotransposons are ubiquitous components of plants genomes, making them useful molecular markers for genetic diversity studies. We used inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism (IRAP) and retrotransposon-microsatellite amplified polymorphism (REMAP) markers to assess genetic diversity and survey activity of LTR retrotransposon elements in 106 sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) genotypes from different research centers. We found 118 (out of 128) and 113 (out of 120) polymorphic loci using 14 IRAP and 14 REMAP primers, respectively. The Mantel test between IRAP and REMAP cophenetic matrices revealed low correlation (r = 0.55) between them. Dice similarities based on combined (IRAP + REMAP) data ranged from 0.34 to 0.93 among (“11 × 12” and “F1250/03”) and (“HA335B” and “TMB51”) genotypes, respectively. Classification of genotypes using the Dice similarity matrix derived from IRAP+REMAP data based on the un-weighted pair-group method using the arithmetic average algorithm resulted in nine distinct groups. The studied genotypes were divided into seven groups considering their origins (research centers). Classification of genotypes can be useful to assess the genetic variation and gene flow between and within research centers. Analysis of molecular variance based on IRAP+REMAP data revealed a higher level of genetic variation within (94%) than between (6%) research centers. A high amount of gene flow was detected among USDA, ASGROW, and ENSAT groups. Because environmental factors have no influence on molecular markers, the construction of heterotic groups based on retrotransposon markers will be useful for the selecting of parents with a high probability of producing superior hybrids.     

Ty1-copia retrotransposon-based S-SAP (sequence-specific amplified polymorphism) for genetic analysis of sweetpotato

RNaseH-LTR regions of the Ty1-copia retrotransposon were amplified and cloned from the sweetpotato genome using RNaseH gene-specific degenerate primers and restriction site-specific adaptor primers. Ninety clones out of the 240 sequenced were identified with a variable degree of homology to the Ty1-copia RNaseH gene. Three ( Str6, Str85, Str187) of the 90 had characteristic RNaseH-gene, stop codon, polypurine track and putative 3' LTR sequence elements. Analysis of nine selected genotypes representing Africa, South and Central America, as well as Papua New Guinea, by the established S-SAP technique revealed that the majority of the Ty1-copia transposon insertions were unique (33 to 64%) and only few common bands were detected. Analysis of 177 East African varieties further supported this finding and showed that most of the copia retrotransposon locations were represented only by some genotypes. Considering that sweetpotato has been present in the East African region for only about 500 years, and the number of genotypes introduced was possibly limited, a surprisingly high level of genetic variability of the transposon insertion sites was detected. These findings may indicate the putative activity of the retrotransposon in sweetpotato in the recent past. Comparison of the copia retrotransposon insertion-based S-SAP method to AFLP and RAPD showed that the majority of the markers were more polymorphic (97-99%) in the case of S-SAP in comparison to AFLP (70-90%) and RAPD (88%). Thus demonstrating the transposon-based molecular marker system was very efficient for genotyping.     

TRIM retrotransposons occur in apple and are polymorphic between varieties but not sports

Retrotransposon markers have been demonstrated to be powerful tools for investigating linkage, evolution and genetics diversity in plants. In the present study, we identified and cloned three full-size TRIM (terminal-repeat retrotransposon in miniature) group retrotransposon elements from apple (Malus domestica) cv. ‘Antonovka’, the first from the Rosaceae. To investigate their utility as markers, we designed primers to match the long terminal repeats (LTRs) of the apple TRIM sequences. We found that PCR reactions with even a single primer produced multiple bands, suggesting that the copy number of these TRIM elements is relatively high, and that they may be locally clustered or nested in the genome. Furthermore, the apple TRIM primers employed in IRAP (inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism) or REMAP (retrotransposon-microsatellite amplified polymorphism) analyses produced unique, reproducible profiles for 12 standard apple cultivars. On the other hand, all seven of the sport mutations in this study were identical to their mother cultivar. Genetic similarity values calculated from the IRAP/REMAP analyses or the STMS (sequence tagged microsatellite sites) analysis were generally comparable. PAUP cluster analysis based on IRAP and REMAP markers in apple and Japanese quince generated an NJ tree that is in good accordance with both a tree based on SMTS markers and the origin of the studied samples. Our results demonstrate that, although they do not encode the proteins necessary to carry out a life cycle and are thereby non-autonomous, TRIMs are at least as polymorphic in their insertion patterns as conventional complete retrotransposons. Kristiina Antonius-Klemola, Ruslan Kalendar are the first two authors contributed equally to this work     

IRAP and REMAP for retrotransposon-based genotyping and fingerprinting

Retrotransposons can be used as markers because their integration creates new joints between genomic DNA and their conserved ends. To detect polymorphisms for retrotransposon insertion, marker systems generally rely on PCR amplification between these ends and some component of flanking genomic DNA. We have developed two methods, retrotransposon-microsatellite amplified polymorphism (REMAP) analysis and inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism (IRAP) analysis, that require neither restriction enzyme digestion nor ligation to generate the marker bands. The IRAP products are generated from two nearby retrotransposons using outward-facing primers. In REMAP, amplification between retrotransposons proximal to simple sequence repeats (microsatellites) produces the marker bands. Here, we describe protocols for the IRAP and REMAP techniques, including methods for PCR amplification with a single primer or with two primers and for agarose gel electrophoresis of the product using optimal electrophoresis buffers and conditions. This protocol can be completed in 1-2 d.     

利用S-SAP鉴定富士苹果芽变

利用银染S-SAP技术对苹果'富士'及其14个芽变品种进行研究,结果发现,筛选出的6对引物中,L12/E7能够将所有'富士'芽变品种同'富士'区分开来,其余5对引物能够在芽变品种中区分'秋富5号'、'烟富1'、'盛放富1'和'长富1号'.由于S-SAP多态性主要由基因组内逆转座子的转座引起,因此'富士'苹果芽变品种的产生可能与逆转座子的插入有关.     

IRAP,a retrotransposon-based marker system for the detection of somaclonal variation in barley

The retrotransposon-based marker system, inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism (IRAP), and inter-simple sequence repeats (ISSRs) were used to detect somaclonal variation induced by tissue culture. IRAPs use a single primer designed to amplify out from the 5′ LTR sequence of the BARE-1 retrotransposon combined with a degenerate 3′ anchor, similar to that of ISSR primers. We analysed DNA polymorphisms in 147 primary regenerants and parental controls from three cultivars of barley (Hordeum vulgare). The ISSR marker system generated an average of 218 bands per primer, with 29 polymorphisms of which 12 were novel non-parental bands. In comparison, the IRAP system generated an average of 121 bands per primer, with 15 polymorphisms of which nine were novel non-parental bands. Polymorphism detected for IRAP and ISSR markers was more than twofold higher in Golden Promise than Mackay and Tallon cultivars. However, there was no significant difference in the frequency of novel non-parental bands. Cluster analysis revealed that the level of polymorphism and genetic variability detected was comparable between IRAP and ISSR markers. This suggests that retrotransposon-based marker systems, such as IRAP, based on retrotransposons such as BARE-1, are valuable tools for the detailed characterisation of mutation profiles that arise during tissue culture. Their use should improve our understanding of processes influencing mutation and somaclonal variation and allow for the design of methods that yield fewer genome changes in applications where maintaining clonal integrity is important.     

Development of retrotransposon primers and their utilization for germplasm identification in Diospyros spp. (Ebenaceae)

Retrotransposons play an important role in plant genetic instability and genome evolution. Retrotransposon-based molecular markers are valuable tools to reveal the behavior of retrotransposons in their host genome. In this study, suppression polymerase chain reaction was used, for the first time, to develop retrotransposon long terminal repeat (LTR) and polypurine tract (PPT) primers in Japanese persimmon (Diospyros kaki Thunb.), which were then employed for germplasm identification by means of interretrotransposon-amplified polymorphism (IRAP), sequence-specific amplified polymorphism (SSAP) and retrotransposon-microsatellite-amplified polymorphism (REMAP) molecular markers. The results showed that 16 out of 26 primers produced expected amplifications and abundant polymorphisms by IRAP in 28 genotypes of Diospyros. Moreover, some of these primers were further successfully used in REMAP and SSAP analysis. Each type of molecular markers produced unique fingerprint in 28 genotypes analyzed. Among the primers/primer combinations, two IRAP primers and four SSAP primer combinations could discriminate all of the germplasm solely. Further comparative analysis indicated that IRAP was the most sensitive marker system for detecting variability. High level of retrotransposon insertion polymorphisms between bud sports were detected by IRAP and SSAP, and the primers/primer combinations with powerful discrimination capacity for two pairs of bud sports lines were further obtained. Additionally, possible genetic relationships between several Japanese persimmon were discussed. To our knowledge, this is the first report on the development of retrotransposon LTR and PPT primers in Diospyros, and the retrotransposon primers developed herein might open new avenue for research in the future.     

Genetic variability in sunflower (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Helianthus annuus</Emphasis> L.) and in the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Helianthus</Emphasis> genus as assessed by retrotransposon-based molecular markers

The inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism (IRAP) protocol was applied for the first time within the genus Helianthus to assess intraspecific variability based on retrotransposon sequences among 36 wild accessions and 26 cultivars of Helianthus annuus L., and interspecific variability among 39 species of Helianthus. Two groups of LTRs, one belonging to a Copia-like retroelement and the other to a putative retrotransposon of unknown nature (SURE) have been isolated, sequenced and primers were designed to obtain IRAP fingerprints. The number of polymorphic bands in H. annuus wild accessions is as high as in Helianthus species. If we assume that a polymorphic band can be related to a retrotransposon insertion, this result suggests that retrotransposon activity continued after Helianthus speciation. Calculation of similarity indices from binary matrices (Shannon’s and Jaccard’s indices) show that variability is reduced among domesticated H. annuus. On the contrary, similarity indices among Helianthus species were as large as those observed among wild H. annuus accessions, probably related to their scattered geographic distribution. Principal component analysis of IRAP fingerprints allows the distinction between perennial and annual Helianthus species especially when the SURE element is concerned.     

RAPD markers for confirmation of somatic hybrids in the dihaploid breeding of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.)

Summary The applicability and reliability of RAPD markers were evaluated for an examination of the possible use of RAPD markers to confirm hybridity of somatic hybrids between dihaploids of potato (Solanum tuberosum L.). Most of the primers examined detected polymorphism among either tetraploids or dihaploids, and polymorphism was easily detected even among closely related clones. Most of the examples of polymorphism were confirmed as being the result of amplification from the nuclear genome by a comparison of patterns generated by PCR of clones that carried the same cytoplasm. All the bands of dihaploids were transmitted stably to the respective hybrids. In the absence of primers that generated complementary polymorphic bands for both parents, a mixture of two appropriate primers, each of which generated a band specific to one parent, permitted the simple confirmation of hybridity. Hybridity of all the fusion-derived regenerants of 32 fusion combinations was unequivocally confirmed, a result that suggests that RAPD analysis could be universally applicable to the confirmation of hybridity in the dihaploid breeding of potato.     

Genetic Diversity in Old Portuguese Durum Wheat Cultivars Assessed by Retrotransposon-Based Markers

Retrotransposon-based markers, such as the inter-retrotransposon-amplified polymorphism (IRAP) and the retrotransposon microsatellite-amplified polymorphism (REMAP) are highly informative, multilocus, and reveal insertional polymorphisms among plant individuals. These markers have been used for evolutionary studies, genetic diversity assessment, DNA fingerprinting, genetic mapping linkage, and for the detection of genetic rearrangements induced by polyploidization. In this study, we used IRAP and REMAP markers to assess the genetic diversity among 51 old Portuguese durum wheat cultivars belonging to 27 botanical varieties and to define their genetic relationships. Five IRAP and four REMAP primer combinations were used. IRAP markers revealed 66.3% of polymorphism and an average of 18.4 bands per primer combination which ranged in size from 450 to 3,100?bp. The REMAP technique allowed the detection of 86.36% of inter-cultivar polymorphism and an average of 11 bands per primer combination. The molecular weight of the REMAP bands ranged from 250 to 2,750?bp. The durum wheat cultivars analyzed here belong to 27 botanical varieties of the subspecies Triticum turgidum subsp. turgidum L. [syn. T. turgidum] and Triticum turgidum L. subsp. durum [syn. T. durum] (Desf.) Husn.. Our results showed that the genetic variability assessed by both the IRAP and REMAP markers did not allow the clustering of the durum wheat cultivars according to their taxonomical criteria (subspecies or botanical variety) or homonymy. Nonetheless, these markers were useful for the assessment of genetic diversity at the individual level, for the definition of genetic relationships among cultivars, and for estimation of the genetic structure of the Old collection under analysis. The achieved data could be valuable for future experiments of DNA fingerprinting, genetic improvement, and germplasm conservation in wheat.     

Analysis of intra-specific somatic hybrids of potato (Solanum tuberosum) using simple sequence repeats

We have utilised simple sequence repeat (SSR) polymorphism to analyse two sets of potential intra-specific hybrids of potato. Two primer pairs were used and both showed that one set of fusion products could not be true heterokaryons. In the other set, one of the primer pairs showed that unique bands in each of the parents were present in all of the hybrids, unambiguously demonstrating hybridity. This simple and robust, high-resolution assay can be used at the callus level and is amenable to automation, making it possible to reduce greatly the time required to screen a large number of potential somatic hybrids.     

The diversification of Citrus clementina Hort. ex Tan., a vegetatively propagated crop species.

Clementines, due to their high quality, are one of the most important cultivated citrus mandarins. As in the case of sweet orange and satsuma mandarins, genetic variability within this species is minimal when analyzed by molecular markers, because the existing varieties have not been obtained through hybridization, but through the selection of spontaneous mutations affecting traits of agronomic interest. This would explain, at least in part, the greater diversity for agronomic traits when compared to the variability for molecular markers. Another possible (nonexclusive) reason is that the types of molecular marker used are not focused on the kind of molecular change mainly involved in the origination of new clementine cultivars; i.e., are all sources of variation equally involved in the diversification of these plants? To answer this question, different kinds of markers based on primers of random sequence, simple sequence repeats, and retrotransposon sequences that may reveal point mutations, and somatic recombination and transposon activity, respectively, were used to compare the level of variability among 24 clementine varieties. Their ISSR, RAPD, and AFLP analysis provided only two polymorphic bands, distinguishing just two varieties. No variability was found by SSRs, i.e., no new allele arising through somatic recombination was detected. Instead, the amplification of sequences adjacent to retrotransposons yielded a higher number of polymorphisms (14.6 vs 2.4% for the previous mentioned marker types). Two geographical distant groups, one from North Africa and the other from Spain, have evolved in agreement with polymorphisms based on IRAP markers anchored to, at least, two different Copia-like retrotransposon sequences. Therefore, this study suggests that the DNA of this type of mobile elements is evolving faster than the DNA of other markers in this clonal lineage.     

Variations in BARE-1 insertion patterns in barley callus cultures

The stability of aging barley calli was investigated with the barley retroelement 1 (BARE-1) retrotransposon specific inter-retrotransposon amplified polymorphism (IRAP) technique. Mature embryos of barley (Hordeum vulgare cv. Zafer-160) were cultured on callus induction MS medium supplemented with 3 mg/L 2,4-D and maintained on the same medium for 60 days. Ten IRAP primers were used in 25 different combinations. The similarity index between 30-day-old and 45-day-old calli was 84%; however, the similarity index between mature embryos and 45-day-old calli was 75%. These culture conditions caused BARE-1 retrotransposon alterations to appear as different band profiles. This is the first report of the use of the IRAP technique in barley in an investigation of callus development.