Reliability of aneuploidy estimates in human sperm: Results of fluorescence in situ hybridization studies using two different scoring criteria

Aneuploidy estimates for chromosomes 1, 12, X, and Y were obtained in human sperm from five donors using multicolor fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis. Disomy frequencies were obtained by scoring a minimum of 10,000 sperm for each chromosome probe per donor. This analysis was replicated for two scoring criteria: one used one half of a signal domain as the minimum distance between two signals to be counted as two and thus disomic; the other set one signal domain as the minimum distance between two signals. A total of 120,870 sperm were assessed using one half of a domain as the criterion, and 113,478 were scored using one domain as the criterion. The percentage of disomy for chromosomes 1, 12, X, Y, and XY was 0.18, 0.16, 0.15, 0.19, and 0.25, respectively, using the one-half-domain criterion, and 0.08, 0.17, 0.07, 0.12, and 0.16, respectively, using the one-domain criterion. The percentage of disomy decreased significantly with use of one domain as the minimum distance for signal separation for all chromosomes except for chromosome number 12. These lower disomy frequencies correlated well with frequencies derived from human sperm karyotypes analyzed in our laboratory. This suggests that the fluorescent signals for chromosomes 1, X, and Y split into more than one domain in decondensed interphase sperm, and that the use of the one-half-domain criterion would lead to an overestimate of aneuploidy frequencies. The factors known to affect aneuploidy estimates derived from FISH studies are discussed, and recommendations for stringent scoring criteria are proposed. © 1995 wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Inter-rater agreement on chromosome 5 breakage in FISH-based mutagen sensitivity assays (MSAs)

In chromosome breakage assays, validated, universal criteria for selection of cells and classification of chromosome aberrations may enhance their utility for cancer susceptibility screening. To standardize a fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) modification of the mutagen sensitivity assay (MSA), scoring criteria were evaluated by web-based validation. Two hundred digital FISH images were assigned random identification numbers. With this set of images, criteria for inclusion of cells and measurement of the frequency of abnormal cells were evaluated by eight observers, all of whom had five or more years of experience. Observers included doctoral and MS/BS level cytogeneticists, and were drawn from a randomized pool of 54 volunteers. Questions addressed were: (1) how uniformly were criteria applied to analysis of a standard digital FISH image set and (2) did concordance vary with educational level? These data suggest inter-rater agreement within a factor of 2 for average breakage frequency, but revealed greater variability in cell selection. These results aid in estimating the components of assay variance due to definitions, technical parameters and biological variables.     

Labeling of human centromeres using an alphoid DNA consensus sequence: application to the scoring of chromosome aberrations

Precise identification of centromeres is required for accurate scoring of asymmetrical chromosome aberrations, such as dicentrics. The centromeric regions of all human chromosomes can be labeled by in situ hybridization of a 30 nucleotide oligomer having the sequence of a conserved region of an alphoid DNA consensus sequence. Fluorescent detection of the hybridized probe allows rapid identification of centromeres and accurate scoring of dicentrics, multicentrics, acentric fragments, and the centromeric content of ring chromosomes. This procedure provides a novel approach for scoring these complex chromosome aberrations, particularly damage induced by radiation or radiomimetic agents.     

Chromosomal rearrangements in children with idiopathic mental retardation using subtelomeric fluorescent in situ hybridization

To screen a selected group of children with idiopathic mental retardation for subtelomeric abnormalities using the fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), which has been reported to be cost-effective in routine applications. We also aimed to assess the availability of the scoring system which is used for selection of those children for FISH analysis. A total of 30 children aged 3-16 years with idiopathic mental retardation (moderate to severe) and normal karyotypes were included in this study. The children whose parents had consanguineous marriages were excluded from the study. All cases were evaluated using the scoring system published by de Vries et al. (5) Forty-one subtelomeric regions for each case were analyzed by fluorescent in situ hybridization. One case with a score value 5 presented terminal deletion of chromosome 9p by FISH (3.3 %). Analyzing chromosomes of the same case with higher resolution G-banding showed the same abnormality. The frequency of subtelomeric abnormalities in our study group was much lower than the frequencies reported in other studies and the scoring criterions suggested by de Vries et al. have not effectively increased our subtelomeric deletion detection rates. Autosomal recessive disorders may be a more common reason compared to subtelomeric abnormalities in this group of patients in the countries where consanguinity rate is high. Laboratories may be encouraged to analyze high-resolution G-banded karyotypes in those cases. Moreover more effective selection criteria for FISH are suggested by establishing thorough genotype-phenotype correlations besides case reports with different subtelomeric abnormalities.     

In vitro transmission of chromosomal aberrations through mitosis in human lymphocytes

Stable and unstable chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes exposed to 2 and 4Gy of X-rays in G(0) were analyzed in M1 and M2 cells harvested at 72h to investigate how the scoring protocol influences the yields of aberrations transmitted through one mitosis. Metaphase chromosomes 2, 3, and 5 were painted using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) whole chromosome probes, together with a pan-centromeric probe and stained by the harlequin-FISH method, to allow the cell cycle status of each cell to be determined as it was scored. A strict scoring criterion was adopted so that each metaphase had to contain 46 centromeres and each dicentric/centric ring had to have an acentric present. In addition to scoring the painted material, unstable aberrations in the whole genome were also recorded. The yield of complete dicentrics decreased by more than a factor of 2 in going from M1 to M2. The decrease was greater at the lower dose. Two-way translocations appeared stable, but one-way translocations decreased. This suggests that if translocation yields are to be used for biological dosimetry purposes, then the two-way type should be used.     

Micronuclei and other nuclear anomalies in buccal smears: methods development.

Laboratory work aimed at improving the epidemiologic utility of an innovative genotoxicity assay is described. The exfoliated cell micronucleus assay involves microscopic analysis of epithelial smears to determine the prevalence of micronucleation, an indicator of structural or numerical chromosome aberrations. While the assay holds promise for the study of epithelial carcinogens, it is hampered by the fact that exfoliated cells are moribund and undergo degenerative phenomena that can produce extranuclear objects difficult to distinguish from classical micronuclei. Modifications in the protocol were assessed in sample buccal smears from several study populations: radiotherapy patients, nonusers of tobacco, and snuff users. Refinements in micronucleus scoring criteria and the inclusion of other nuclear anomalies in the scoring system are proposed. We demonstrate that our criteria are successful in detecting excess micronucleation in positive controls. We also provide evidence that other nuclear anomalies are at least as common as micronucleation and that therefore there is the potential for extensive misclassification. Reliability was assessed in duplicate readings.     

Micronuclei and other nuclear anomalies in buccal smears: methods development

Laboratory work aimed at improving the epidemiologic utility of an innovative genotoxicity assay is described. The exfoliated cell micronucleus assay involves microscopic analysis of epithelial smears to determine the prevalence of micronucleation, an indicator of structural or numerical chromosome aberrations. While the assay holds promise for the study of epithelial carcinogens, it is hampered by the fact that exfoliated cells are moribund and undergo degenerative phenomena that can produce extranuclear objects difficult to distinguish from classical micronuclei. Modifications in the protocol were assessed in sample buccal smears from several study populations: radiotherapy patients, nonusers of tobacco, and snuff users. Refinements in micronucleus scoring criteria and the inclusion of other nuclear anomalies in the scoring system are proposed. We demonstrate that our criteria are successful in detecting excess micronucleation in positive controls. We also provide evidence that other nuclear anomalies are at least as common as micronucleation and that therefore there is the potential for extensive misclassification. Reliability was assessed in duplicate readings.     

A novel source of highly specific chromosome painting probes for human karyotype analysis derived from primate homologues

We have established a series of highly specific painting probes for human acrocentric chromosomes. These chromosomes are involved in the formation of the nucleolar organizer region (NOR) and show DNA sequence homologies within their pericentric heterochromatin. To date, these chromosomes have shown considerable cross hybridization in chromosome painting experiments. Our probe set has been established from primate homologues that are not involved in the NOR in that particular species or from species in which highly repetitive sequences have undergone rapid sequence divergence. The new painting probes should be of particular value for automated microscopy, for which highly specific signals are required as they are recorded at low magnification, e.g. when scoring chromosome 21 domains in interphase nuclei. Received: 22 May 1997 / Accepted: 16 June 1997     

Fluorescence in situ hybridization and spectral imaging analysis of human oocytes and first polar bodies.

We investigated the frequencies of abnormalities involving either chromosome 1, 16, 18, or 21 in failed-fertilized human oocytes. Although abnormalities involving chromosome 16 showed an age-dependent increase, results for the other chromosomes did not show statistically significant differences among the three age groups, <35 years, 35-39 years, and >39 years. The scoring of four chromosomes is likely to underestimate the true rate of aneuploid cells. Therefore, for a pilot study investigating a more-comprehensive analysis of oocytes and their corresponding first polar bodies, we developed a novel eight-probe chromosome enumeration scheme using fluorescence in situ hybridization and spectral imaging analysis.     

The Use of Simulated Annealing in Chromosome Reconstruction Experiments Based on Binary Scoring

We present a method of combinatorial optimization, simulated annealing, to order clones in a library with respect to their position along a chromosome. This ordering method relies on scoring each clone for the presence or absence of specific target sequences, thereby assigning a digital signature to each clone. Specifically, we consider the hybridization of oligonucleotide probes to a clone to constitute the signature. In that the degree of clonal overlap is reflected in the similarity of their signatures, it is possible to construct maps based on the minimization of the differences in signatures across a reconstructed chromosome. Our simulations show that with as few as 30 probes and a clonal density of 4.5 genome equivalents, it is possible to assemble a small eukaryotic chromosome into 33 contiguous blocks of clones (contigs). With higher clonal densities and more probes, this number can be reduced to less than 5 contigs per chromosome.     

The relationship between male infertility and increased levels of sperm disomy

Sperm chromosome abnormalities cut across a number of areas relevant to ICC XV. The association between increased levels of sperm aneuploidy (usually disomy) and male infertility has implications for the sessions on reproduction, sex chromosomes, aneuploidy and meiosis and was, to the best of our knowledge, first reported in 1995. Since then most studies have reported similar increases of varying degrees but, despite this, a small number of laboratories have presented results that demonstrate no significant association. The purpose of this article is to review the state of the art in this area and to speculate as to reasons for the differences in reports from different laboratories. The findings are broken down by chromosome with studies of the sex chromosomes being broken down further to indicate meiotic stages of origin. We conclude that comparisons are difficult to make since many studies do not clearly define patient and control groups. Nevertheless, despite these and other differences (such as scoring criteria, technical differences, demographics, etc.), the consensus in the literature is that a strong correlation exists between sperm aneuploidy and male infertility. The nature of that relationship will be further defined when andrological criteria are more closely taken into account and protocols for preparation and scoring are standardised.     

The in vitro micronucleus technique

The study of DNA damage at the chromosome level is an essential part of genetic toxicology because chromosomal mutation is an important event in carcinogenesis. The micronucleus assays have emerged as one of the preferred methods for assessing chromosome damage because they enable both chromosome loss and chromosome breakage to be measured reliably. Because micronuclei can only be expressed in cells that complete nuclear division a special method was developed that identifies such cells by their binucleate appearance when blocked from performing cytokinesis by cytochalasin-B (Cyt-B), a microfilament-assembly inhibitor. The cytokinesis-block micronucleus (CBMN) assay allows better precision because the data obtained are not confounded by altered cell division kinetics caused by cytotoxicity of agents tested or sub-optimal cell culture conditions. The method is now applied to various cell types for population monitoring of genetic damage, screening of chemicals for genotoxic potential and for specific purposes such as the prediction of the radiosensitivity of tumours and the inter-individual variation in radiosensitivity. In its current basic form the CBMN assay can provide, using simple morphological criteria, the following measures of genotoxicity and cytotoxicity: chromosome breakage, chromosome loss, chromosome rearrangement (nucleoplasmic bridges), cell division inhibition, necrosis and apoptosis. The cytosine-arabinoside modification of the CBMN assay allows for measurement of excision repairable lesions. The use of molecular probes enables chromosome loss to be distinguished from chromosome breakage and importantly non-disjunction in non-micronucleated binucleated cells can be efficiently measured. The in vitro CBMN technique, therefore, provides multiple and complementary measures of genotoxicity and cytotoxicity which can be achieved with relative ease within one system. The basic principles and methods (including detailed scoring criteria for all the genotoxicity and cytotoxicity end-points) of the CBMN assay are described and areas for future development identified.     

Frequency of aneuploidy related to age in porcine oocytes

It is generally accepted that mammalian oocytes are frequently suffering from chromosome segregation errors during meiosis I, which have severe consequences, including pregnancy loss, developmental disorders and mental retardation. In a search for physiologically more relevant model than rodent oocytes to study this phenomenon, we have employed comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), combined with whole genome amplification (WGA), to study the frequency of aneuploidy in porcine oocytes, including rare cells obtained from aged animals. Using this method, we were able to analyze segregation pattern of each individual chromosome during meiosis I. In contrast to the previous reports where conventional methods, such as chromosome spreads or FISH, were used to estimate frequency of aneuploidy, our results presented here show, that the frequency of this phenomenon was overestimated in porcine oocytes. Surprisingly, despite the results from human and mouse showing an increase in the frequency of aneuploidy with advanced maternal age, our results obtained by the most accurate method currently available for scoring the aneuploidy in oocytes indicated no increase in the frequency of aneuploidy even in oocytes from animals, whose age was close to the life expectancy of the breed.     

Quantitative traits for the tail suspension test: automation, optimization, and BXD RI mapping

Immobility in the tail suspension test (TST) is considered a model of despair in a stressful situation, and acute treatment with antidepressants reduces immobility. Inbred strains of mouse exhibit widely differing baseline levels of immobility in the TST and several quantitative trait loci (QTLs) have been nominated. The labor of manual scoring and various scoring criteria make obtaining robust data and comparisons across different laboratories problematic. Several studies have validated strain gauge and video analysis methods by comparison with manual scoring. We set out to find objective criteria for automated scoring parameters that maximize the biological information obtained, using a video tracking system on tapes of tail suspension tests of 24 lines of the BXD recombinant inbred panel and the progenitor strains C57BL/6J and DBA/2J. The maximum genetic effect size is captured using the highest time resolution and a low mobility threshold. Dissecting the trait further by comparing genetic association of multiple measures reveals good evidence for loci involved in immobility on chromosomes 4 and 15. These are best seen when using a high threshold for immobility, despite the overall better heritability at the lower threshold. A second trial of the test has greater duration of immobility and a completely different genetic profile. Frequency of mobility is also an independent phenotype, with a distal chromosome 1 locus. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi: ) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Mussel micronucleus cytome assay

The micronucleus (MN) assay is one of the most widely used genotoxicity biomarkers in aquatic organisms, providing an efficient measure of chromosomal DNA damage occurring as a result of either chromosome breakage or chromosome mis-segregation during mitosis. The MN assay is today applied in laboratory and field studies using hemocytes and gill cells from bivalves, mainly from the genera Mytilus. These represent 'sentinel' organisms because of their ability to survive under polluted conditions and to accumulate both organic and inorganic pollutants. Because the mussel MN assay also includes scoring of different cell types, including necrotic and apoptotic cells and other nuclear anomalies, it is in effect an MN cytome assay. The mussel MN cytome (MUMNcyt) assay protocol we describe here reports the recommended experimental design, sample size, cell preparation, cell fixation and staining methods. The protocol also includes criteria and photomicrographs for identifying different cell types and scoring criteria for micronuclei (MNi) and nuclear buds. The complete procedure requires approximately 10 h for each experimental point/sampling station (ten animals).     

Technologies for large-scale physical mapping of human chromosomes

Developing and characterization ordered clone collection from human chromosome specific DNA libraries is proceeding as part of a larger effort to construct a physical map of the entire human genome. The robotics and automation section at Los Alamos has been focussed on developing the hardware and software tools required to support this objective. These tools are typically integrated systems that combine an intuitive user interface, a database, as well as the relevant hardware technologies. To date, we have developed a system to automatically grid clones onto nylon filters in high density arrays. We have also developed a hybridization autoradiograph software scoring tool that combines image analysis, databasing, and a user interface.     

Cytological and molecular evidence of deletion of ribosomal RNA genes in chromosome 6 of barley (Hordeum vulgare).

The barley chromosomal mutant T-35, in which only one pair of satellite chromosomes is apparent, was analyzed using a range of cytological and molecular techniques. Using conventional Feulgen staining, Giemsa and silver banding, in situ hybridization, and Southern blot analysis, unequivocal cytological and molecular evidence was obtained that T-35 is a homozygous deletion of rRNA genes residing in the nucleolus organizer region (NOR) of chromosome 6. According to the criteria of arm ratio and Giemsa-banding pattern of this chromosome, the deletion involved the whole NOR, one of the breakpoints being localized in the short arm proximally to the NOR-associated heterochromatic band, the other probably in the satellite of the chromosome. As a result of this deletion, an increased activity of the rRNA genes (as indicated by the size of the silver bands) on the other NOR-bearing chromosome (chromosome 7) was observed. The possible reasons for this phenomenon are discussed.     

Nondisjunction of chromosome 21: comparisons of cytogenetic and molecular studies of the meiotic stage and parent of origin.

In the present report, we summarize studies aimed at examining the reliability of chromosome heteromorphisms in analyses of chromosome 21 nondisjunction. We used two cytogenetic approaches--fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) to repetitive sequences on 21p and traditional Q-banding--to distinguish chromosome 21 homologues and then compared the results of these studies with those obtained by DNA markers. Using a conservative scoring system for Q-banding and FISH heteromorphisms, we were able to specify the parental origin of trisomy in 10% of cases; in contrast, DNA marker studies were informative for parental origin in almost all cases. The results of the molecular and cytogenetic studies of parental origin concurred in all cases in which assignments were made independently using both techniques. However, in 4 of 13 cases in which the molecular studies contributed to the interpretation of the cytogenetic findings, the two results did not agree with respect to the meiotic stage of nondisjunction. A relatively high frequency of crossing-over on either the short arm or proximal long arm of chromosome 21 could explain these results and may be a mechanism leading to nondisjunction.     

Association between G2-phase block and repair of radiation-induced chromosome fragments in human lymphocytes.

We have studied the induction of chromosomal aberrations in human lymphocytes exposed in G0 to X rays or carbon ions. Aberrations were analyzed in G0, G1, G2 or M phase. Analysis during the interphase was performed by chemically induced premature chromosome condensation, which allows scoring of aberrations in G1, G2 and M phase; fusion-induced premature chromosome condensation was used to analyze the damage in G0 cells after incubation for repair; M-phase cells were obtained by conventional Colcemid block. Aberrations were scored by Giemsa staining or fluorescence in situ hybridization (chromosomes 2 and 4). Similar yields of fragments were observed in G1 and G2 phase, but lower yields were scored in metaphase. The frequency of chromosomal exchanges was similar in G0 (after repair), G2 and M phase for cells exposed to X rays, while a lower frequency of exchanges was observed in M phase when lymphocytes were irradiated with high-LET carbon ions. The results suggest that radiation-induced G2-phase block is associated with unrejoined chromosome fragments induced by radiation exposure during G0.