Diversifying selection at the Bacillus quorum-sensing locus and determinants of modification specificity during synthesis of the ComX pheromone

The competence quorum-sensing system of Bacillus subtilis consists of two-component regulatory proteins, ComP (histidine kinase) and the response regulator, ComA, an extracellular pheromone (ComX), and a protein that is needed for the proteolytic cleavage and modification of pre-ComX (ComQ). ComQ and pre-ComX are both necessary and sufficient for the production of active pheromone, which is released as an isoprenylated peptide. Laboratory strain 168 and a number of natural isolates of bacilli differ in the primary sequences of their pheromones as well as in the masses of their isoprenyl adducts. We have shown that ComX, ComQ, and the membrane-localized sensor domain of ComP are highly polymorphic in natural isolates of bacilli all closely related to the laboratory strain of B. subtilis. In this study, we used two statistical tests (the ratio of synonymous and nonsynonymous substitution rates and the Tajima D test) to demonstrate that these polymorphic sequences evolved by diversifying selection rather than by neutral drift. We show that the choice of isoprenyl derivative is determined by the C-terminal (mature) sequence of pre-ComX rather than by the ComQ protein. The implications of these findings for the evolution of the quorum-sensing system and for the protein-protein interactions involved in determining specificity are discussed.     

Characterization of comQ and comX, Two Genes Required for Production of ComX Pheromone in Bacillus subtilis

Many microbes use secreted peptide-signaling molecules to stimulate changes in gene expression in response to high population density, a process called quorum sensing. ComX pheromone is a modified 10-amino-acid peptide used by Bacillus subtilis to modulate changes in gene expression in response to crowding. comQ and comX are required for production of ComX pheromone. We found that accumulation of ComX pheromone in culture supernatant paralleled cell growth, indicating that there was no autoinduction of production of ComX pheromone. We overexpressed comQ and comX separately and together and found that overexpression of comX alone was sufficient to cause an increase in production of ComX pheromone and early induction of a quorum-responsive promoter. These results indicate that the extracellular concentration of ComX pheromone plays a major role in determining the timing of the quorum response and that expression of comX is limiting for production of ComX pheromone. We made alanine substitutions in the residues that comprise the peptide backbone of ComX pheromone. Analysis of these mutants highlighted the importance of the modification for ComX pheromone function and identified three residues (T50, G54, and D55) that are unlikely to interact with proteins involved in production of or response to ComX pheromone. We have also identified and mutated a putative isoprenoid binding domain of ComQ. Mutations in this domain eliminated production of ComX pheromone, consistent with the hypothesis that ComQ is involved in modifying ComX pheromone and that the modification is likely to be an isoprenoid.     

Specificity and genetic polymorphism of the Bacillus competence quorum-sensing system

A quorum-sensing mechanism involving the pheromone ComX and the ComP-ComA two-component system controls natural competence in Bacillus subtilis. ComX is expressed as a cytoplasmic inactive precursor that is released into the extracellular medium as a cleaved, modified decapeptide. This process requires the product of comQ. In the presence of ComX, the membrane-localized ComP histidine kinase activates the response regulator ComA. We compared the sequences of the quorum-sensing genes from four closely related bacilli, and we report extensive genetic polymorphism extending through comQ, comX, and the 5′ two-thirds of comP. This part of ComP encodes the membrane-localized and linker domains of the sensor protein. We also determined the sequences of the comX genes of four additional wild-type bacilli and tested the in vivo activities of all eight pheromones on isogenic strains containing four different ComP receptor proteins. A striking pattern of specificity was discovered, providing strong evidence that the pheromone contacts ComP directly. Furthermore, we show that coexpression of comQ and comX in Escherichia coli leads to the production of active pheromone in the medium, demonstrating that comQ is the only dedicated protein required for the processing, modification, and release of active competence pheromone. Some of the implications of these findings for the evolution and the mechanism of the quorum-sensing system are discussed.     

Towards structural determination of the ComX pheromone: synthetic studies on peptides containing geranyltryptophan

Bacteria produce and respond to signal molecules depending on their cell density. This process is called "quorum sensing". The ComX pheromone, controlled by quorum sensing, activates natural genetic competence in Bacillus subtilis. ComX is an oligopeptide with a posttranslational modification. It has been suggested that ComX pheromone is modified with an isoprenoid at its tryptophan residue, but the complete chemical structure is unknown. We first determined the molecular formula of ComX(RO-E-2), a competence factor for B. subtilis strain RO-E-2. Then we synthesized putative pheromones with 1-, 2-, 4-, 5-, 6-, or 7-geranyl substituted tryptophan residues. The regio- and stereo-selective synthesis of the geranyl tryptophans was successful, and we prepared the six peptides with modified tryptophan residues. These peptides had the same molecular formula and showed similar hydrophobicity to the natural ComX(RO-E-2) in LC-MS analysis. But, none of them showed the same retention time as the natural pheromone and none exhibited its biological activity. These results suggest that the isoprenoid modification pattern of the tryptophan residue is more complex than postulated.     

Structure-activity relationship studies on quorum sensing ComX(RO-E-2) pheromone

The ComX pheromone is a posttranslationally modified oligopeptide that stimulates natural genetic competence in Bacillus subtilis. Various ComX(RO-E-2) analogs were synthesized and their biological activities were studied to investigate structure-activity relationships. These results showed that the minimal active unit was the tripeptide, [3-5]ComX(RO-E-2), and all residues except the modified tryptophan residue were replaceable by alanine without total loss of activity.     

Identification of ComW as a new component in the regulation of genetic transformation in Streptococcus pneumoniae

Regulation of competence for genetic transformation in Streptococcus pneumoniae depends on a quorum-sensing system, genes involved in DNA uptake and recombination and a link between these two gene sets. The alternative sigma factor ComX provides this link. ComE, the response regulator of the quorum-sensing system, is required for expression of ComX and other early genes. However, an unknown ComE-dependent regulator is also required for competence when comX is expressed under control of the raffinose-responsive promoter of the aga operon. The gene comW (SP0018) is required for a high level of competence and is regulated by the quorum-sensing system, but its function is unknown. To explore its role further, comW was cloned into the multicopy plasmid pMSP3535, under the control of a nisin-inducible promoter (P(N)), and transformed into pneumococcal strains containing a raffinose-inducible comX gene (P(R)::comX). Further introduction of a comE deletion blocked the endogenous CSP signal transduction pathway. In the resulting strain, competence was independent of CSP but depended on treatment with both nisin and raffinose, showing that coexpression of comW and comX complemented the comE deficiency. ComX protein accumulation and expression of a late competence gene in the above strain support the conclusion that ComW is a new positive factor involved in competence regulation.     

Chemical structure of posttranslational modification with a farnesyl group on tryptophan

Bacillus subtilis and related bacilli produce a posttranslationally modified oligopeptide, the ComX pheromone, that stimulates natural genetic competence controlled by quorum sensing. The ComX(RO-C-2) pheromone from strain RO-C-2 must be modified with a farnesyl group on the Trp residue, but the precise structure is not known. Here we report the precise nature of posttranslational farnesylation of ComX(RO-C-2) pheromone on the Trp residue, resulting in the formation of a tricyclic structure. The ComX(168) pheromone, produced by the standard laboratory strain used in the study of B. subtilis, is also posttranslationally farnesylated according to phylogenetic resemblance.     

Structure of the Bacillus subtilis quorum-sensing peptide pheromone ComX

The ComX pheromone is an extracellular signaling molecule that stimulates natural competence in response to crowding in the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis. The pheromone is formed by isoprenylation of an inactive precursor peptide, but its precise structure is not known. Here we report the structure of the ComX pheromone, showing that addition of a geranyl group to a tryptophan residue results in the formation of an unusual ring structure.     

Acid labile ComX pheromone from Bacillus mojavensis RO-H-1

Bacillus mojavensis strain RO-H-1 produces a posttranslationally modified hexapeptide, the ComX(RO-H-1) pheromone, that stimulates natural genetic competence controlled by quorum sensing. LC/ESI-MS analysis of partially purification of the ComX(RO-H-1) pheromone suggested a precise modification in its tryptophan residue. The corresponding ComX(RO-H-1) pheromone prepared by solid-phase synthesis was identical to the natural pheromone, and showed significant biological activity. These results indicated that the posttranslational modification of the ComX(RO-H-1) pheromone was geranylation on the tryptophan residue, resulting in the formation of a tricyclic structure. The ComX(RO-H-1) pheromone was immediately dehydrated by acid because of its extreme acid lability.     

Post-translational isoprenylation of tryptophan

Bacillus subtilis and related bacilli produce a post-translationally modified oligopeptide, ComX pheromone, that stimulates natural genetic competence controlled by quorum sensing. The ComX pheromones are formed by geranylation or farnesylation on a tryptophan residue at the 3 position of its indole ring. This results in the formation of a tricyclic structure including, a newly formed five-membered ring, similar to proline. Isoprenylation of ComX to form ComX pheromones is essential for pheromonal activity, and is functionally more crucial than its amino acid sequence. The ComX pheromone is the first example of isoprenoidal modifiations of tryptophan residues in living organisms and post-translational isoprenylation of any amino acid in prokaryotes. Because the presence of geranylated compounds is unusual in primary and secondary metabolites outside the plant kingdom, post-translational geranylation in bacilli is unprecedented in nature.     

Symmetric signalling within asymmetric dimers of the Staphylococcus aureus receptor histidine kinase AgrC

Virulence in Staphylococcus aureus is largely under control of the accessory gene regulator ( agr ) quorum-sensing system. The AgrC receptor histidine kinase detects its autoinducing peptide (AIP) ligand and generates an intracellular signal resulting in secretion of virulence factors. Although agr is a well-studied quorum-sensing system, little is known about the mechanism of AgrC activation. By co-immunoprecipitation analysis and intermolecular complementation of receptor mutants, we showed that AgrC forms ligand-independent dimers that undergo trans- autophosphorylation upon interaction with AIP. Remarkably, addition of specific AIPs to AgrC mutant dimers with only one functional sensor domain caused symmetric activation of either kinase domain despite the sensor asymmetry. Furthermore, mutant dimers involving one constitutive protomer demonstrated ligand-independent activity, irrespective of which protomer was kinase deficient. These results demonstrate that signalling through either individual AgrC protomer causes symmetric activation of both kinase domains. We suggest that such signalling across the dimer interface may be an important mechanism for dimeric quorum-sensing receptors to rapidly elicit a response upon signal detection.     

The geranyl-modified tryptophan residue is crucial for ComXRO-E-2 pheromone biological activity

The ComX pheromone is an isoprenoidal oligopeptide containing a modified tryptophan residue, which stimulates natural genetic competence in gram-positive bacteria, Bacillus. We have reported the structure of the ComX_RO-E-2 pheromone, which is produced by the RO-E-2 strain of Bacillus subtilis. ComX_RO-E-2 analogs with substituted amino acids and isoprenoid modified tryptophan residues (e.g., prenyl, geranyl, and farnesyl), were synthesized and examined for biological activity. These results indicate that Phe-Trp^∗(Ger)-NH₂ is the minimum pharmacophore of the ComX_RO-E-2 pheromone. Furthermore, the length of the isoprenoid moiety (i.e., modification style), and the presence of double bonds, are crucial for biological activity. The modification style of the ComX pheromone is more important than the peptide sequence with respect to biological activity.     

Towards Structural Determination of the ComX Pheromone: Synthetic Studies on Peptides Containing Geranyltryptophan

Bacteria produce and respond to signal molecules depending on their cell density. This process is called “quorum sensing”. The ComX pheromone, controlled by quorum sensing, activates natural genetic competence in Bacillus subtilis. ComX is an oligopeptide with a posttranslational modification. It has been suggested that ComX pheromone is modified with an isoprenoid at its tryptophan residue, but the complete chemical structure is unknown. We first determined the molecular formula of ComX_RO-E-2, a competence factor for B. subtilis strain RO-E-2. Then we synthesized putative pheromones with 1-, 2-, 4-, 5-, 6-, or 7-geranyl substituted tryptophan residues. The regio- and stereo-selective synthesis of the geranyl tryptophans was successful, and we prepared the six peptides with modified tryptophan residues. These peptides had the same molecular formula and showed similar hydrophobicity to the natural ComX_RO-E-2 in LC–MS analysis. But, none of them showed the same retention time as the natural pheromone and none exhibited its biological activity. These results suggest that the isoprenoid modification pattern of the tryptophan residue is more complex than postulated.     

Lack of the Consensus Sequence Necessary for Tryptophan Prenylation in the ComX Pheromone Precursor

ComX, an oligopeptide pheromone that stimulates the natural genetic competence controlled by quorum sensing in Bacillus subtilis and related bacilli, contains a prenyl-modified tryptophan residue. Since ComX is the only protein known to contain prenylated tryptophan, the universality of this unique posttranslational modification has yet to be determined. Recently, we developed a cell-free assay system in which the tryptophan residue in the ComX(RO-E-2) pheromone precursor derived from B. subtilis strain RO-E-2 can be geranylated by the ComQ(RO-E-2) enzyme. We report here our attempt to identify the consensus sequence surrounding the geranylated tryptophan residue by using the cell-free system with various ComX(RO-E-2) pheromone precursor analogs. We found that [47-58]ComX(RO-E-2), corresponding to the C-terminal 12-residue peptide of the pheromone precursor, contained a short sequence essential for geranylation. We also found that the length of the sequence between the tryptophan residue and the C-terminus was important for geranylation, and that some [47-58]ComX(RO-E-2) pheromone precursor amino acids were involved in the geranylation reaction. However, we could not identify a consensus sequence surrounding the geranylated tryptophan. Our evidence suggests that, like Rab which lacks a consensus sequence yet is geranylgeranyl-modified on a cysteine residue, the ComX pheromone and its precursor also lack a consensus sequence.