Report from the President the Biological Stain Commission: Its Goals, Its Past and Its Present Status

This is a brief overview of the goals, evolution, and present status of the Biological Stain Commission. The main function of the Commission is the testing and certification of dye batches intended for biological applications. The testing is supported by charges made for batch testing and by the sale of certification labels affixed to individual dye containers. Submission of dyes for testing is voluntary, depending on the cooperation of the companies who sell them and the consumers who buy them. The supportive role of the University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry—both past and present—is not well known and should be. Increasingly federal regulations affect the production, availability, and cost of dyes. Commission income from the sale of labels has decreased in recent years. Continuation of its work requires changes that will produce more income. Much dye is now sold in solutions instead of dry powders. The value of using Stain Commission certified dyes whenever possible is illustrated by the case of basic fuchsin. Years ago this dye was a mixture. Most basic fuchsin now marketed consists mainly of either pararosanilin (Colour Index No. 42500) or rosanilin (C.I. No. 42510). The Biological Stain Commission discovered that some certified batches of both pararosanilin and rosanilin sold as “basic fuchsin” had incorrect C.I. numbers on the labels. Sometimes that caused failure of the aldehyde fuchsin stain. Unless made with pararosanilin, aldehyde fuchsin does not stain pancreatic islet B-cells, elastic fibers, and hepatitis B surface antigen in unoxidized sections. Mislabelling by packagers may interfere with other applications of pararosanilin and rosanilin. The Commission acted to publicize and correct this problem. Biological Stain Commission publications help educate microscopists and histotechnologists about dyes and their best use. Stain Commission representatives from member scientific societies provide valuable input about changes in the availability and quality of such dyes as hematoxylin and others; they also provide useful feedback to their societies about dye problems. Each new generation of biologists and histotechnologists should be taught the importance of using only Stain Commission certified stains when available. They should be taught also to notify the Stain Commission whenever they experience problems with any certified dye.     

Aldehyde Pararosanilin (True Aldehyde Fuchsin) Stains Purified Insulin, Oxidized or Not, Following Adequate Fixation with Either Formalin or Bouin'S Fluid

Gomori reported that aldehyde fuchsin stained the granules of pancreatic islet beta cells selectively and without need of permanganate pretreatment. Others adopted permanganate oxidation because it makes staining faster though much less selective. All aldehyde fuchsins are not equivalent, being made from “basic fuchsin” whose composition may vary from pure pararosanilin to one of its methylated homologs, rosanilin or a mixture. Mowry et al. have shown that only aldehyde fuchsin made from pararosanilin stained unoxidized pancreatic beta cells (PBC). Aldehyde fuchsins made from methylated homologs of pararosanilin stain PBC cells only after oxidation, which induces basophilia of other cells as well; these are less selective for PBC.

Is the staining of PBC by aldehyde fuchsins due to insulin? Others have been unable to stain pure insulin with aldehyde fuchsins except in polyacrylamide gels and only after oxidation with permanganate. They have concluded that insulin contributed to the staining of oxidized but not of unoxidized PBC. This view denies any inherent validity of the more selective staining of unoxidized PBC cells as an indication of their insulin content.

We describe here indisputable staining of unoxidized pure insulins by aldehyde fuchsin made with pararosanilin. Dried spots of insulin dissolved in the stain unless fixed beforehand. Spots of dried insulin solution made on various support media and fixed in warm formalin vapor were colored strongly by the stain. Insulin soaked Gelfoam® sponges were dried, fixed in formalin vapor and processed into paraffin. In unoxidized paraffin sections, presumed insulin inside gel spaces was stained strongly by aldehyde pararosanilin. Finally, the renal tubules of unoxidized paraffin sections of kidneys from insulin-injected mice fixed in either Bouin's fluid or formalin were loaded with material stained deeply by aldehyde pararosanilin. This material was absent in renal tubules of mice receiving no insulin. The material in the spaces of insulin-soaked gels and in the renal tubules of insulin-injected mice was proven to be insulin by specific immunostaining of duplicate sections. The same material was also stained by aldehyde pararosanilin used after permanganate. So, this dye stains oxidized or unoxidized insulin if fixed adequately.     

Aldehyde pararosanilin (true aldehyde fuchsin) stains purified insulin, oxidized or not, following adequate fixation with either formalin or Bouin's fluid

Gomori reported that aldehyde fuchsin stained the granules of pancreatic islet beta cells selectively and without need of permanganate pretreatment. Others adopted permanganate oxidation because it makes staining faster though much less selective. All aldehyde fuchsins are not equivalent, being made from "basic fuchsin" whose composition may vary from pure pararosanilin to one of its methylated homologs, rosanilin or a mixture. Mowry et al. have shown that only aldehyde fuchsin made from pararosanilin stained unoxidized pancreatic beta cells (PBC). Aldehyde fuchsins made from methylated homologs of pararosanilin stain PBC cells only after oxidation, which induces basophilia of other cells as well; these are less selective for PBC. Is the staining of PBC by aldehyde fuchsins due to insulin? Others have been unable to stain pure insulin with aldehyde fuchsins except in polyacrylamide gels and only after oxidation with permanganate. They have concluded that insulin contributed to the staining of oxidized but not of unoxidized PBC. This view denies any inherent validity of the more selective staining of unoxidized PBC cells as an indication of their insulin content. We describe here indisputable staining of unoxidized pure insulins by aldehyde fuchsin made with pararosanilin. Dried spots of insulin dissolved in the stain unless fixed beforehand. Spots of dried insulin solution made on various support media and fixed in warm formalin vapor were colored strongly by the stain. Insulin soaked Gelfoam sponges were dried, fixed in formalin vapor and processed into paraffin. In unoxidized paraffin sections, presumed insulin inside gel spaces was stained strongly by aldehyde pararosanilin. Finally, the renal tubules of unoxidized paraffin sections of kidneys from insulin-injected mice fixed in either Bouin's fluid or formalin were loaded with material stained deeply by aldehyde pararosanilin. This material was absent in renal tubules of mice receiving no insulin. The material in the spaces of insulin-soaked gels and in the renal tubules of insulin-injected mice was proven to be insulin by specific immunostaining of duplicate sections. The same material was also stained by aldehyde pararosanilin used after permanganate. So, this dye stains oxidized or unoxidized insulin if fixed adequately.     

Aldehyde fuchsin staining, direct or after oxidation: problems and remedies, with special reference to human pancreatic B cells, pituitaries, and elastic fibers.

Successful production of aldehyde fuchsin (AF) having the unique properties described by Gomori depends on each of many critical variables. AF made from basic fuchsins which contain mainly rosanilin (C.I. 42510) do not stain properly-fixed pancreatic B cells, pituitary basophils, or elastic fibers in unoxidized sections. AF made from basic fuchsins containing mainly pararosanilin (C.I. 42500) stains these entities strongly. Substances stained by AF without oxidation fall into two classes: 1) nonacidic peptides and proteins, most of which contain half-cystines, and 2) polyanions, particularly when sulfated. Group 2 substances stain rapidly, Group 1 substances stain slowly. Many modifications of aldehyde fuchsin have been described. Modified aldehyde fuchsins (MAFs) differ in the kind of aldehyde and in the amount of aldehyde and hydrochloric acid used in their formulation; they differ also in the temperature and duration of the ripening necessary before they can be used. If microsections are first oxidized by acid permanganate or other oxidant, MAF staining of pancreatic B cells, pituitary basophils and other substances containing cystines is speeded and intensified. Most modified methods prescribe oxidation, but the author's does not. The chemical basis, final result and potential side-reactions of oxidation methods (OXMAF) differ from those of direct methods (DIMAF) such as the author's. DIMAF staining is slower but inherently simpler and less destructive. The time required for optimal staining with DIMAF depends on the potency of the stain, which in turn depends on how the stain was made and its age. Detection of DIMAF--reactive peptides and proteins may be hampered by the strong staining of polyanions. This can be remedied if the polyanions are first stained with Alcian blue (AB) or other durable basic dye of contrasting color resistant to acid ethanol. Experiences with the AB-DIMAF staining of pancreatic B cells, pituitaries and elastic fibers in formalin-fixed human tissues are detailed. Proper control of the variables which affect MAF will insure useful and reliable results either directly or after oxidation. Authors and editors are urged to be more careful hereafter to distinguish the results of DIMAF from those of OXMAF methods. Published reports should always specify the parameters that affect the properties of MAF. In OXMAF methods the steps intervening between oxidation and staining should be spelled out. Such care should help dispel the confusion and uncertainty which cloud the use and reputation of aldehyde fuchsin at present. This unique dye deserves wider and wiser use.     

An investigation of aldehyde fuchsin staining of unoxidized insulin

Aldehyde fuchsin is a standard stain for the secretion granules of pancreatic B cells. The participation of either insulin or proinsulin in aldehyde fuchsin staining is in dispute. There is some evidence that permanganate oxidized insulin is stained by aldehyde fuchsin. Aldehyde fuchsin staining of unoxidized insulin has not been investigated adequately despite excellent staining results with tissue sections. Unoxidized insulin and proinsulin suspended by electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gels were fixed with Bouin's fluid and placed in aldehyde fuchsin for one hour. Because the unoxidized proteins were not stained by aldehyde fuchsin, it was concluded that neither insulin or proinsulin are responsible for the intense aldehyde fuchsin staining of unoxidized pancreatic B cell granules in tissue sections. A series of controlled experiments was undertaken to test the effects of fixatives, oxidation and destaining procedures on aldehyde fuchsin staining of insulin, proinsulin and other proteins immobilized in polyacrylamide gels. It was demonstrated that only oxidized proteins were stained by aldehyde fuchsin and that cystine content of the proteins had no apparent relation to aldehyde fuchsin staining. It was concluded that neither insulin nor proinsulin is likely to be responsible for the intense aldehyde fuchsin staining of unoxidized pancreatic B cell granules in tissue sections.     

Effects of fuchsin variants in aldehyde fuchsin staining

Aldehyde fuchsin stains pancreatic B cell granules, hypophyseal basophils, goblet cell mucins, gastric chief cells, hyaline cartilage, and elastica. Neither the chemical structure of aldehyde fuchsin nor its staining mechanism is known. This study was undertaken to clarify the role of the fuchsin component of aldehyde fuchsin in its staining reaction. The major findings of this investigation include: 1) single N-methylation of the fuchsin molecule abolishes staining of unoxidized pancreatic B cells, although it does not prevent reaction of fuchsin with paraldehyde; 2) aldehyde fuchsin is probably a Schiff base condensation product of pararosaniline and acetaldehyde; 3) a Schiff base structure alone cannot account for aldehyde fuchsin staining of unoxidized pancreatic B cells; 4) a fully potent aldehyde fuchsin is possibly a Tris-Schiff base derivative of pararosaniline.     

The role of paraldehyde in the rapid preparation of aldehyde fuchsin

Preparation of aldehyde fuchsin normally requires ripening for 3 to 5 days. By using a 5-fold excess of paraldehyde a fully potent aldehyde fuchsin can be prepared in 24 hr at room temperature. Aldehyde fuchsin prepared by both normal and accelerated ripening afforded comparable results, including selective staining of unoxidized pancreatic B cells. Dried aldehyde fuchsin prepared form pararosaniline and reconstituted in acid alcohol has spectrophotometric properties different form the ripened strain. Reconstituted aldehyde fuchsin stains unoxidized B cells adequately only if staining time is extended. Excess paraldehyde added to reconstituted aldehyde fuchsin retards decomposition but does not produce a normal stain by spectrophotometric standards. Warming of aldehyde fuchsin solutions to accelerate ripening has been shown to produce deleterious effects and should be avoided.     

Staining properties of aldehyde fuchsin analogs.

This investigation was designed to clarify the role of the aldehyde component of aldehyde fuchsin in its staining reactions. Several aldehyde fuchsin analogs were prepared by using different aldehydes. The staining quality of these analogs and pararosaniline-HCl was compared with that of aldehyde fuchsin prepared with paraldehyde in the usual way. The major findings of this investigation include: 1) Aldehyde fuchsin staining of nonoxidized pancreatic B cells requires a stain prepared with either paraldehyde or acetaldehyde. 2) An aldehyde moiety is required for aldehyde fuchsin staining of strong tissue anions. 3) Staining of elastic tissue with aldehyde fuchsin analogs resembles staining of strong tissue anions more than staining of nonoxidized pancreatic B cells. Possible reaction mechanisms of aldehyde fuchsin with tissue substrates are discussed.     

Purity of commercial non-certified European samples of Pyronin Y

Summary The purity of six European non-certified samples of Pyronin Y was compared with that of two American samples certified by the Biological Stain Commission. The methods used were spectrophotometry and a Methyl Green-Pyronin staining test (both as applied by the Biological Stain Commission), thin layer chromatography, mass spectrometry, determination of pH, and content of some electrolytes. It was found that none of the European batches of Pyronin Y passed the complete test as prescribed by the Biological Stain Commission. Their dye content was uniformly low (between 5 and 19%). Furthermore, thin layer chromatography and mass spectrometry revealed that two of the dye samples contained no Pyronin Y or only traces.It is concluded that assessment of an unknown sample of a dye labelled Pyronin Y should be initiated with thin layer chromatography. The pH and content of electrolytes in an aqueous solution of the dye should also be determined in order to obtain reproducible staining results. Finally, the value of the work performed by the Biological Stain Commission is underlined, although more sophisticated methods are necessary for testing the purity of dyestuffs.     

Specificity and Sensitivity of Insulin Staining by Aldehyde Fuchsin, Pseudoisocyanin and Toluidine Blue

Aldehyde fuchsin, pseudoisocyanin and toluidine blue, histochemical dyes reported to be specific for insulin-containing granules of the pancreatic beta cell, were applied to insulin fixed in polyacrylamide gel by disc electrophoresis. Two major and four minor bands were resolved as demonstrated by staining with amidoschwarz; only the two major bands, were stained by aldehyde fuchsin. The addition of serum did not affect this reaction. Serum or insulin components gave no metachromatic reactions to the other stains. Under the conditions applied, aldehyde fuchsin is the only one of these dyes specific for insulin in this, system, but this stain is not sufficiently sensitive to detect normal serum levels of the hormone.     

Methods for the Standardization of Biological Stains: Part IV

In this paper are given methods for determining the suitability of certain dyes of the triphenylmethane group for certification by the Commission on Standardization of Biological Stains. These methods have been developed by the Commission, in cooperation with the Color and Farm Waste Division, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, U. S. Department of Agriculture. The dyes for which the methods are given in the present paper are: Malachite green, brilliant green, light green SF yellowish, fast green FCF, basic fuchsin (rosanilin and pararosanilin), acid fuchsia, methyl violet, crystal violet, gentian violet, methyl green and anilin blue. For each of these dyes, methods are discussed under the following headings: (1) identification or qualitative examination; (2) quantitative analysis; and (3) biological tests.     

A Modification of the Technic of Handling Chick Embryos

In this paper are given methods for determining the suitability of certain dyes of the triphenylmethane group for certification by the Commission on Standardization of Biological Stains. These methods have been developed by the Commission, in cooperation with the Color and Farm Waste Division, Bureau of Chemistry and Soils, U. S. Department of Agriculture. The dyes for which the methods are given in the present paper are: Malachite green, brilliant green, light green SF yellowish, fast green FCF, basic fuchsin (rosanilin and pararosanilin), acid fuchsia, methyl violet, crystal violet, gentian violet, methyl green and anilin blue. For each of these dyes, methods are discussed under the following headings: (1) identification or qualitative examination; (2) quantitative analysis; and (3) biological tests.     

Current applications of orcein in histochemistry. A brief review with some new observations concerning influence of dye batch variation and aging of dye solutions on staining

Current uses of orcein to demonstrate elastic fibers and, following permanganate oxidation (Shikata's modification), hepatitis B surface antigen, copper associated protein, and sulfated mucins, are reviewed. Variations in staining performance with batch of dye and age of dye solution is also discussed. Additional experimental findings support the view that the orcein stain for elastic tissue and Shikata's modification produces consistent, high quality results as long as appropriate controls and suitable dye batches, e.g., Biological Stain Commission certified dyes, are used.     

Current applications of orcein in histochemistry. A brief review with some new observations concerning influence of dye batch variation and aging of dye solutions on staining

Current uses of orcein to demonstrate elastic fibers and, following permanganate oxidation (Shikata's modification), hepatitis B surface antigen, copper associated protein, and sulfated mucins, are reviewed. Variations in staining performance with batch of dye and age of dye solution is also discussed. Additional experimental findings support the view that the orcein stain for elastic tissue and Shikata's modification produces consistent, high quality results as long as appropriate controls and suitable dye batches, e.g., Biological Stain Commission certified dyes, are used.     

Staining Problems with Eosin Y: A Note from the Biological Stain Commission

In 1980, eosin Y was the certified dye with which technologists encountered most problems. The specific problem most frequently brought to the attention of the Biological Stain Commission was that solutions of eosin Y formed a precipitate and failed to stain cytoplasm red when used as a counterstain to hematoxylin.     

A method for determining identity and relative purity of carmine, carminic acid and aminocarminic acid

Carmine is one of the few dyes currently certified by the Biological Stain Commission that is not assayed for dye content. Existing assay methods are complex and do not differentiate the three cochineal derivatives carmine, carminic acid and aminocarminic acid. The latter dye is relatively new to the food trade as an acid-stable red colorant and may eventually enter the biological stains market. The assay proposed here is a two-step procedure using quantitative spectrophotometric analysis at high pH (12.5-12.6) followed by a qualitative scan of a low pH (1.90-2.10) solution. Carmine is distinct at high pH, and the remaining dyes are easily distinguished at low pH. Four instances of mislabeling are documented from 18 commercial products, but the mislabeled dyes were not certified dyes. Samples from nearly all lots of carmine certified by the Biological Stain Commission from 1920 to 2004 proved to be carmine, but they varied widely in dye content. Batches from 1920 through the 1940s were significantly richer in dye content. Variability has been extreme since 2000, and most of the poorest lots have been submitted since 1990.     

A method for determining identity and relative purity of carmine, carminic acid and aminocarminic acid.

Carmine is one of the few dyes currently certified by the Biological Stain Commission that is not assayed for dye content. Existing assay methods are complex and do not differentiate the three cochineal derivatives carmine, carminic acid and aminocarminic acid. The latter dye is relatively new to the food trade as an acid-stable red colorant and may eventually enter the biological stains market. The assay proposed here is a two-step procedure using quantitative spectrophotometric analysis at high pH (12.5-12.6) followed by a qualitative scan of a low pH (1.90-2.10) solution. Carmine is distinct at high pH, and the remaining dyes are easily distinguished at low pH. Four instances of mislabeling are documented from 18 commercial products, but the mislabeled dyes were not certified dyes. Samples from nearly all lots of carmine certified by the Biological Stain Commission from 1920 to 2004 proved to be carmine, but they varied widely in dye content. Batches from 1920 through the 1940s were significantly richer in dye content. Variability has been extreme since 2000, and most of the poorest lots have been submitted since 1990.     

A method for determining identity and relative purity of carmine,carminic acid and aminocarminic acid

Carmine is one of the few dyes currently certified by the Biological Stain Commission that is not assayed for dye content. Existing assay methods are complex and do not differentiate the three cochineal derivatives carmine, carminic acid and aminocarminic acid. The latter dye is relatively new to the food trade as an acid-stable red colorant and may eventually enter the biological stains market. The assay proposed here is a two-step procedure using quantitative spectrophotometric analysis at high pH (12.5–12.6) followed by a qualitative scan of a low pH (1.90–2.10) solution. Carmine is distinct at high pH, and the remaining dyes are easily distinguished at low pH. Four instances of mislabeling are documented from 18 commercial products, but the mislabeled dyes were not certified dyes. Samples from nearly all lots of carmine certified by the Biological Stain Commission from 1920 to 2004 proved to be carmine, but they varied widely in dye content. Batches from 1920 through the 1940s were significantly richer in dye content. Variability has been extreme since 2000, and most of the poorest lots have been submitted since 1990.     

The demonstration of two acid groups in juxtaglomerular granules with basic triphenyl methane dyes,aldehyde-fuchsin and schiff's reagent

Summary Oxidation and bromination of mouse kidney JG cell-granules result in the production of cysteic acid from cystine; cysteic acid is capable of taking up rapidly and selectively certain basic triphenyl methane dyes including aldehyde fuchsin at lower pH levels.After treatment with periodic acid, bromine and hydrochloric acid, the JG granules or the nuclear chromatin also take up the basic triphenyl methane dyes (including aldehyde fuchsin) which contain amino groups, probable as a result of the production of aldehyde groups. Basic triphenyl methane lacking amino groups does not react with aldehydes.Some substance present in JG granules could be stained by aldehyde fuchsin after prior oxidation; HCl methyl violet 2B was taken up both with or without prior oxidation. Only strong methylation completely abolished these affinities which were restored after demethylation. These reactions are attributed to cystine.The staining of JG granules with dilute aldehyde fuchsin and dilute methyl violet 2B is not affected by oxidation, bromination, aldehyde blocking and hydrolysis; these reactions are abolished by mild methylation, but restored by subsequent saponification. These staining properties are due to the presence of carboxylic acid in JG granules.The positive PAS reaction of JG granules is due to the presence of 1.2-glycol in the same granules.     

The Biological Stain Commission's Quality Control Laboratory operations and improved traceability of certified stains

Abstract

The Biological Stain Commission (BSC) is a quality control laboratory that certifies biological dyes for staining cells and tissues. Originally, a single lot of a certified dye was sold to histologists. Today, companies frequently change their lot numbers as part of regulatory efforts. When a certified dye undergoes a lot number change, the BSC must re-certify this dye to verify that it is identical to the one certified earlier. The BSC has improved how these lot changes are monitored using a redesigned BSC certification label. Certification labels always have been issued by the BSC and are attached to every bottle of “BSC certified dye” that is sold. The new BSC certification label has added security features and currently bears both the BSC certification number and the manufacturer batch lot number. The result is improved security and traceability of certified dyes.