Are presenilins intramembrane-cleaving proteases? Implications for the molecular mechanism of Alzheimer's disease.

The amyloid-beta protein (Abeta) is strongly implicated in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease. The final step in the production of Abeta from the amyloid precursor protein (APP) is proteolysis by the unidentified gamma-secretases. This cleavage event is unusual in that it apparently occurs within the transmembrane region of the substrate. Studies with substrate-based inhibitors together with molecular modeling and mutagenesis of the gamma-secretase cleavage site of APP suggest that gamma-secretases are aspartyl proteases that catalyze a novel intramembranous proteolysis. This proteolysis requires the presenilins, proteins with eight transmembrane domains that are mutated in most cases of autosomal dominant familial Alzheimer's disease. Two conserved transmembrane aspartates in presenilins are essential for gamma-secretase activity, suggesting that presenilins themselves are gamma-secretases. Moreover, presenilins also mediate the apparently intramembranous cleavage of the Notch receptor, an event critical for Notch signaling and embryonic development. Thus, if presenilins are gamma-secretases, then they are also likely the proteases that cleave Notch within its transmembrane domain. Another protease, S2P, involved in the processing of the sterol regulatory element binding protein, is also a multipass integral membrane protein which cleaves within or very close to the transmembrane region of its substrate. Thus, presenilins and S2P appear to be members of a new type of polytopic protease with an intramembranous active site.     

Presenilin 1 mutations activate gamma 42-secretase but reciprocally inhibit epsilon-secretase cleavage of amyloid precursor protein (APP) and S3-cleavage of notch

The presenilin 1 (PS1) and presenilin 2 (PS2) proteins are necessary for proteolytic cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) within its transmembrane domain. One of these cleavage events (termed gamma-secretase) generates the C-terminal end of the Abeta-peptide by proteolysis near residue 710 or 712 of APP(770). Another event (termed gamma-like or epsilon-secretase cleavage) cleaves near residue 721 at approximately 2-5 residues inside the cytoplasmic membrane boundary to generate a series of stable, C-terminal APP fragments. This latter cleavage is analogous to S3-cleavage of Notch. We report here that specific mutations in the N terminus, loop, or C terminus of PS1 all increase the production of Abeta(42) but cause inhibition of both epsilon-secretase cleavage of APP and S3-cleavage of Notch. These data support the hypothesis that epsilon-cleavage of APP and S3-cleavage of Notch are similar events. They also argue that, although both the gamma-site and the epsilon-site cleavage of APP are presenilin-dependent, they are likely to be independent catalytic events.     

The role of presenilin-1 in the gamma-secretase cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein of Alzheimer's disease

Presenilin-1 (PS1) is required for the release of the intracellular domain of Notch from the plasma membrane as well as for the cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) at the gamma-secretase cleavage site. It remains to be demonstrated whether PS1 acts by facilitating the activity of the protease concerned or is the protease itself. PS1 could have a gamma-secretase activity by itself or could traffic APP and Notch to the appropriate cellular compartment for processing. Human APP 695 and PS1 were coexpressed in Sf9 insect cells, in which endogenous gamma-secretase activity is not detected. In baculovirus-infected Sf9 cells, PS1 undergoes endoproteolysis and interacts with APP. However, PS1 does not cleave APP in Sf9 cells. In CHO cells, endocytosis of APP is required for Abeta secretion. Deletion of the cytoplasmic sequence of APP (APPDeltaC) inhibits both APP endocytosis and Abeta production. When APPDeltaC and PS1 are coexpressed in CHO cells, Abeta is secreted without endocytosis of APP. Taken together, these results conclusively show that, although PS1 does not cleave APP in Sf9 cells, PS1 allows the secretion of Abeta without endocytosis of APP by CHO cells.     

Blockade of gamma-secretase activity within the hippocampus enhances long-term memory

The gamma-secretase complex, a membrane-bound aspartyl protease, hydrolyzes the transmembrane domains of several integral membrane proteins including the key signaling molecules amyloid precursor protein (APP), Notch, deleted in colorectal cancer (DCC), and N- and E-cadherins. The proteolysis processing of these proteins is critical for generation of signaling molecules that may participate in neuronal communication and plasticity. Using a potent gamma-secretase inhibitor, L-685,458, we examined if blockade of its activity in the hippocampus can influence contextual and spatial memory in rats. Surprisingly, we observed that post-training blockade of gamma-secretase activity leads to enhanced long-term memory in two hippocampus-dependent tasks. This suggests that a signaling molecule(s) generated by gamma-secretase activity may have a negative influence on long-term memory formation.     

Spatial segregation of gamma-secretase and substrates in distinct membrane domains

Gamma-secretase facilitates the regulated intramembrane proteolysis of select type I membrane proteins that play diverse physiological roles in multiple cell types and tissue. In this study, we used biochemical approaches to examine the distribution of amyloid precursor protein (APP) and several additional gamma-secretase substrates in membrane microdomains. We report that APP C-terminal fragments (CTFs) and gamma-secretase reside in Lubrol WX detergent-insoluble membranes (DIM) of cultured cells and adult mouse brain. APP CTFs that accumulate in cells lacking gamma-secretase activity preferentially associate with DIM. Cholesterol depletion and magnetic immunoisolation studies indicate recruitment of APP CTFs into cholesterol- and sphingolipid-rich lipid rafts, and co-residence of APP CTFs, PS1, and syntaxin 6 in DIM patches derived from the trans-Golgi network. Photoaffinity cross-linking studies provided evidence for the preponderance of active gamma-secretase in lipid rafts of cultured cells and adult brain. Remarkably, unlike the case of APP, CTFs derived from Notch1, Jagged2, deleted in colorectal cancer (DCC), and N-cadherin remain largely detergent-soluble, indicative of their spatial segregation in non-raft domains. In embryonic brain, the majority of PS1 and nicastrin is present in Lubrol WX-soluble membranes, wherein the CTFs derived from APP, Notch1, DCC, and N-cadherin also reside. We suggest that gamma-secretase residence in non-raft membranes facilitates proteolysis of diverse substrates during embryonic development but that the translocation of gamma-secretase to lipid rafts in adults ensures processing of certain substrates, including APP CTFs, while limiting processing of other potential substrates.     

Characterization of the reconstituted gamma-secretase complex from Sf9 cells co-expressing presenilin 1, nicastrin [correction of nacastrin], aph-1a, and pen-2

Gamma-secretase catalyzes the proteolytic processing of a number of integral membrane proteins, including amyloid precursor protein (APP) and Notch. The native gamma-secretase is a heterogeneous population of large membrane protein complexes containing presenilin 1 (PS1) or presenilin 2 (PS2), aph-1a or aph-1b, nicastrin, and pen-2. Here we report the reconstitution of a gamma-secretase complex in Sf9 cells by co-infection with baculoviruses carrying the PS1, nicastrin, pen-2, and aph-1a genes. The reconstituted enzyme processes C99 and the Notch-like substrate N160 and displays the characteristic features of gamma-secretase in terms of sensitivity to a gamma-secretase inhibitor, upregulation of Abeta42 production by a familial Alzheimer's disease (FAD) mutation in the APP gene, and downregulation of Notch processing by PS1 FAD mutations. However, the ratio of Abeta42:Abeta40 production by the reconstituted gamma-secretase is significantly higher than that of the native enzyme from 293 cells. Unlike in mammalian cells where PS1 FAD mutations cause an increase in Abeta42 production, PS1 FAD missense mutations in the reconstitution system alter the cleavage sites in the C99 substrate without changing the Abeta42:Abeta40 ratio. In addition, PS1DeltaE9 is a loss-of-function mutation in both C99 and N160 processing. Reconstitution of gamma-secretase provides a homogeneous system for studying the individual gamma-secretase complexes and their roles in Abeta production, Notch processing and AD pathogenesis. These studies may provide important insight into the development of a new generation of selective gamma-secretase inhibitors with an improved side effect profile.     

Reconstitution of gamma-secretase activity

gamma-Secretase is a membrane protein complex with an unusual aspartyl protease activity that catalyses the regulated intramembranous cleavage of the beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP) to release the Alzheimer's disease (AD)-associated amyloid beta-peptide (Abeta) and the APP intracellular domain (AICD). Here we show the reconstitution of gamma-secretase activity in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which lacks endogenous gamma-secretase activity. Reconstituted gamma-secretase activity depends on the presence of four complex components including presenilin (PS), nicastrin (Nct), APH-1 (refs 3-6) and PEN-2 (refs 4, 7), is associated with endoproteolysis of PS, and produces Abeta and AICD in vitro. Thus, the biological activity of gamma-secretase is reconstituted by the co-expression of human PS, Nct, APH-1 and PEN-2 in yeast.     

Functional domains in presenilin 1: the Tyr-288 residue controls gamma-secretase activity and endoproteolysis

Processing of the Alzheimer amyloid precursor protein (APP) into the amyloid beta-protein and the APP intracellular domain is a proteolysis event mediated by the gamma-secretase complex where presenilin (PS) proteins are key constituents. PS is subjected to an endoproteolytic cleavage, generating a stable heterodimer composed of an N-terminal and a C-terminal fragment. Here we aimed at further understanding the role of PS in endoproteolysis, in proteolytic processing of APP and Notch, and in assembly of the gamma-secretase complex. By using a truncation protocol and alanine scanning, we identified Tyr-288 in the PS1 N-terminal fragment as critical for PS-dependent intramembrane proteolysis. Further mutagenesis of the 288 site identified mutants differentially affecting endoproteolysis and gamma-secretase activity. The Y288F mutant was endoproteolyzed to the same extent as wild type PS but increased the amyloid beta-protein 42/40 ratio by approximately 75%. In contrast, the Y288N mutant was also endoproteolytically processed but was inactive in reconstituting gamma-secretase in PS null cells. The Y288D mutant was deficient in both endoproteolysis and gamma-secretase activity. All three mutant PS1 molecules were incorporated into gamma-secretase complexes and stabilized Pen-2 in PS null cells. Thus, mutations at Tyr-288 do not affect gamma-secretase complex assembly but can differentially control endoproteolysis and gamma-secretase activity.     

Characterization of a presenilin-mediated amyloid precursor protein carboxyl-terminal fragment gamma. Evidence for distinct mechanisms involved in gamma -secretase processing of the APP and Notch1 transmembrane domains

A variety of investigations have led to the conclusion that presenilins (PS) play a critical role in intramembranous, gamma-secretase proteolysis of selected type I membrane proteins, including Notch1 and amyloid precursor protein (APP). We now show that the generation of the S3/Notch intracellular domain and APP-carboxyl-terminal fragment gamma (CTFgamma) derivatives are dependent on PS expression and inhibited by a highly selective and potent gamma-secretase inhibitor. Unexpectedly, the APP-CTFgamma derivative is generated by processing between Leu-645 and Val-646 (of APP(695)), several amino acids carboxyl-terminal to the scissile bonds for production of amyloid beta protein peptides. Although the relationship of APP-CTFgamma to the production of amyloid beta protein peptides is not known, we conclude that in contrast to the highly selective PS-dependent processing of Notch, the PS-dependent gamma-secretase processing of APP is largely nonselective and occurs at multiple sites within the APP transmembrane domain.     

Nicastrin functions as a gamma-secretase-substrate receptor

gamma-secretase catalyzes the intramembrane cleavage of amyloid precursor protein (APP) and Notch after their extracellular domains are shed by site-specific proteolysis. Nicastrin is an essential glycoprotein component of the gamma-secretase complex but has no known function. We now show that the ectodomain of nicastrin binds the new amino terminus that is generated upon proteolysis of the extracellular APP and Notch domains, thereby recruiting the APP and Notch substrates into the gamma-secretase complex. Chemical- or antibody-mediated blocking of the free amino terminus, addition of purified nicastrin ectodomain, or mutations in the ectodomain markedly reduce the binding and cleavage of substrate by gamma-secretase. These results indicate that nicastrin is a receptor for the amino-terminal stubs that are generated by ectodomain shedding of type I transmembrane proteins. Our data are consistent with a model where nicastrin presents these substrates to gamma-secretase and thereby facilitates their cleavage via intramembrane proteolysis.     

Proteomic profiling of gamma-secretase substrates and mapping of substrate requirements

The presenilin/gamma-secretase complex, an unusual intramembrane aspartyl protease, plays an essential role in cellular signaling and membrane protein turnover. Its ability to liberate numerous intracellular signaling proteins from the membrane and also mediate the secretion of amyloid-beta protein (Abeta) has made modulation of gamma-secretase activity a therapeutic goal for cancer and Alzheimer disease. Although the proteolysis of the prototypical substrates Notch and beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP) has been intensely studied, the full spectrum of substrates and the determinants that make a transmembrane protein a substrate remain unclear. Using an unbiased approach to substrate identification, we surveyed the proteome of a human cell line for targets of gamma-secretase and found a relatively small population of new substrates, all of which are type I transmembrane proteins but have diverse biological roles. By comparing these substrates to type I proteins not regulated by gamma-secretase, we determined that besides a short ectodomain, gamma-secretase requires permissive transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains to bind and cleave its substrates. In addition, we provide evidence for at least two mechanisms that can target a substrate for gamma cleavage: one in which a substrate with a short ectodomain is directly cleaved independent of sheddase association, and a second where a substrate requires ectodomain shedding to instruct subsequent gamma-secretase processing. These findings expand our understanding of the mechanisms of substrate selection as well as the diverse cellular processes to which gamma-secretase contributes.     

Analysis of transmembrane domain mutants is consistent with sequential cleavage of Notch by gamma-secretase

gamma-Secretase is a lipid-embedded, intramembrane-cleaving aspartyl protease that cleaves its substrates twice within their transmembrane domains (TMD): once near the cytosolic leaflet (at S3/epsilon) and again in the middle of the TMD (at S4/gamma). To address whether this unusual process occurs in two independent or interdependent steps, we investigated how mutations at the S3/epsilon site in Notch1-based substrates impact proteolysis. We demonstrate that such mutations greatly inhibit not only gamma-secretase-mediated cleavage at S3 but also at S4, independent of their impact on NICD stability. These results, together with our previous observations, suggest that hydrolysis at the center of the Notch transmembrane domain (S4/gamma) is dependent on the S3/epsilon cleavage. Notch (and perhaps all gamma-secretase substrates) may be cleaved by sequential proteolysis starting at S3.     

Intramembrane proteolysis of GXGD-type aspartyl proteases is slowed by a familial Alzheimer disease-like mutation

More than 150 familial Alzheimer disease (FAD)-associated missense mutations in presenilins (PS1 and PS2), the catalytic subunit of the gamma-secretase complex, cause aberrant amyloid beta-peptide (Abeta) production, by increasing the relative production of the highly amyloidogenic 42-amino acid variant. The molecular mechanism behind this pathological activity is unclear, and different possibilities ranging from a gain of function to a loss of function have been discussed. gamma-Secretase, signal peptide peptidase (SPP) and SPP-like proteases (SPPLs) belong to the same family of GXGD-type intramembrane cleaving aspartyl proteases and share several functional similarities. We have introduced the FAD-associated PS1 G384A mutation, which occurs within the highly conserved GXGD motif of PS1 right next to the catalytically critical aspartate residue, into the corresponding GXGD motif of the signal peptide peptidase-like 2b (SPPL2b). Compared with wild-type SPPL2b, mutant SPPL2b slowed intramembrane proteolysis of tumor necrosis factor alpha and caused a relative increase of longer intracellular cleavage products. Because the N termini of the secreted counterparts remain unchanged, the mutation selectively affects the liberation of the intracellular processing products. In vitro experiments demonstrate that the apparent accumulation of longer intracellular cleavage products is the result of slowed sequential intramembrane cleavage. The longer cleavage products are still converted to shorter peptides, however only after prolonged incubation time. This suggests that FAD-associated PS mutation may also result in reduced intramembrane cleavage of beta-amyloid precursor protein (betaAPP). Indeed, in vitro experiments demonstrate slowed intramembrane proteolysis by gamma-secretase containing PS1 with the G384A mutation. As compared with wild-type PS1, the mutation selectively slowed Abeta40 production, whereas Abeta42 generation remained unaffected. Thus, the PS1 G384A mutation causes a selective loss of function by slowing the processing pathway leading to the benign Abeta40.     

A sensitive and quantitative assay for measuring cleavage of presenilin substrates.

The presenilin (PS) proteins are components of the gamma-secretase activity, which is central in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease. Here we present a novel cell-based reporter gene assay for the quantification of PS-controlled gamma-secretase cleavage of the Alzheimer amyloid precursor protein (APP). We show that this assay offers several advantages, including increased sensitivity and specificity, improved quantification of cleavage, and simultaneous detection of all gamma-secretase cleavages in APP. Furthermore, the APP assay can be used in parallel with a similar assay that records gamma-secretase cleavage of a Notch receptor. The use of these assays to analyze the effects of two known gamma-secretase inhibitors and postulated PS active site mutants on APP and Notch processing demonstrated that inhibitors and mutants that differently affect Notch and APP cleavage can be identified rapidly. The possibility in using these assays for high throughput screening of candidate gamma-secretase inhibitors for APP and Notch in parallel opens up new vistas to systematically search for novel inhibitors that selectively block APP cleavage while not affecting Notch signaling.     

Direct and potent regulation of gamma-secretase by its lipid microenvironment

gamma-Secretase is an unusual and ubiquitous aspartyl protease with an intramembrane catalytic site that cleaves many type-I integral membrane proteins, most notably APP and Notch. Several reports suggest that cleavage of APP to produce the Abeta peptide is regulated in part by lipids. As gamma-secretase is a multipass protein complex with 19 transmembrane domains, it is likely that the local lipid composition of the membrane can regulate gamma-activity. To determine the direct contribution of the lipid microenvironment to gamma-secretase activity, we purified the human protease from overexpressing mammalian cells, reconstituted it in vesicles of varying lipid composition, and examined the effects of individual phospholipids, sphingolipids, cholesterol, and complex lipid mixtures on substrate cleavage. A conventional gamma-activity assay was modified to include a detergent-removal step to facilitate proteoliposome formation, and this increased baseline activity over 2-fold. Proteoliposomes containing sphingolipids significantly increased gamma-secretase activity over a phosphatidylcholine-only baseline, whereas the addition of phosphatidylinositol significantly decreased activity. Addition of soluble cholesterol in the presence of phospholipids and sphingolipids robustly increased the cleavage of APP- and Notch-like substrates in a dose-dependent manner. Reconstitution of gamma-secretase in complex lipid mixtures revealed that a lipid raft-like composition supported the highest level of activity compared with other membrane compositions. Taken together, these results demonstrate that membrane lipid composition is a direct and potent modulator of gamma-secretase and that cholesterol, in particular, plays a major regulatory role.     

Intramembrane proteolysis by gamma-secretase

Gamma-secretase mediates the final proteolytic cleavage, which liberates amyloid beta-peptide (Abeta), the major component of senile plaques in the brains of Alzheimer disease patients. Therefore, gamma-secretase is a prime target for Abeta-lowering therapeutic strategies. gamma-Secretase is a protein complex composed of four different subunits, presenilin (PS), APH-1, nicastrin, and PEN-2, which are most likely present in a 1:1:1:1 stoichiometry. PS harbors the catalytically active site, which is critically required for the aspartyl protease activity of gamma-secretase. Moreover, numerous familial Alzheimer disease-associated mutations within the PSs increase the production of the aggregation-prone and neurotoxic 42-amino acid Abeta. Nicastrin may serve as a substrate receptor, although this has recently been challenged. PEN-2 is required to stabilize PS within the gamma-secretase complex. No particular function has so far been assigned to APH-1. The four components are sufficient and required for gamma-secretase activity. At least six different gamma-secretase complexes exist that are composed of different variants of PS and APH-1. All gamma-secretase complexes can exert pathological Abeta production. Assembly of the gamma-secretase complex occurs within the endoplasmic reticulum, and only fully assembled and functional gamma-secretase complexes are transported to the plasma membrane. Structural analysis by electron microscopy and chemical cross-linking reveals a water-containing cavity, which allows intramembrane proteolysis. Specific and highly sensitive gamma-secretase inhibitors have been developed; however, they interfere with the physiological function of gamma-secretase in Notch signaling and thus cause rather significant side effects in human trials. Modulators of gamma-secretase, which selectively affect the production of the pathological 42-amino acid Abeta, do not inhibit Notch signaling.     

Mammalian APH-1 interacts with presenilin and nicastrin and is required for intramembrane proteolysis of amyloid-beta precursor protein and Notch

Presenilin and nicastrin are essential components of the gamma-secretase complex that is required for the intramembrane proteolysis of an increasing number of membrane proteins including the amyloid-beta precursor protein (APP) and Notch. By using co-immunoprecipitation and nickel affinity pull-down approaches, we now show that mammalian APH-1 (mAPH-1), a conserved multipass membrane protein, physically associates with nicastrin and the heterodimers of the presenilin amino- and carboxyl-terminal fragments in human cell lines and in rat brain. Similar to the loss of presenilin or nicastrin, the inactivation of endogenous mAPH-1 using small interfering RNAs results in the decrease of presenilin levels, accumulation of gamma-secretase substrates (APP carboxyl-terminal fragments), and reduction of gamma-secretase products (amyloid-beta peptides and the intracellular domains of APP and Notch). These data indicate that mAPH-1 is probably a functional component of the gamma-secretase complex required for the intramembrane proteolysis of APP and Notch.     

Presenilin clinical mutations can affect gamma-secretase activity by different mechanisms

Mutations in human presenilin (PS) genes cause aggressive forms of familial Alzheimer's disease. Presenilins are polytopic proteins that harbour the catalytic site of the gamma-secretase complex and cleave many type I transmembrane proteins including beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP), Notch and syndecan 3. Contradictory results have been published concerning whether PS mutations cause 'abnormal' gain or (partial) loss of function of gamma-secretase. To avoid the possibility that wild-type PS confounds the interpretation of the results, we used presenilin-deficient cells to analyse the effects of different clinical mutations on APP, Notch, syndecan 3 and N-cadherin substrate processing, and on gamma-secretase complex formation. A loss in APP and Notch substrate processing at epsilon and S3 cleavage sites was observed with all presenilin mutants, whereas APP processing at the gamma site was affected in variable ways. PS1-Delta9 and PS1-L166P mutations caused a reduction in beta-amyloid peptide Abeta40 production whereas PS1-G384A mutant significantly increased Abeta42. Interestingly PS2, a close homologue of PS1, appeared to be a less efficient producer of Abeta than PS1. Finally, subtle differences in gamma-secretase complex assembly were observed. Overall, our results indicate that the different mutations in PS affect gamma-secretase structure or function in multiple ways.