DNA length-dependent cooperative interactions in the binding of Ku to DNA

Despite its central role in the nonhomologous DNA end joining process, we still have an incomplete picture of the interaction between Ku and DNA. Here we describe both kinetic (surface plasmon resonance or SPR) and equilibrium (electrophoretic mobility shift assay or EMSA) studies of Ku binding to linear double-stranded DNA. Ku interaction with 1-site DNA is noncooperative, as expected. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays indicate cooperativity in the binding of Ku molecules to DNA long enough for two Ku molecules to bind (2-site DNA). For the kinetic studies, we use surface plasmon resonance in which one end of the DNA molecules is linked to a surface while the other end is free to interact with Ku. We find that one Ku molecule dissociates from 1-site DNA with simple Langmuir (i.e., independent) kinetics. However, two Ku molecules associate and dissociate from 2-site DNA with a time course that cannot be described as a simple Langmuir interaction. On 3- and 4-site DNA, EMSA and SPR studies do not reveal any cooperativity, suggesting that the middle Ku does not exhibit cooperative interaction with the two Ku molecules bound at the DNA ends. These results indicate that Ku molecules can demonstrate cooperative interaction, and this is influenced by their positions along the DNA.     

Cooperative Assembly of a Protein-DNA Filament for Nonhomologous End Joining

Nonhomologous end joining repairs DNA double-strand breaks created by ionizing radiation and V(D)J recombination. Ku, XRCC4/Ligase IV (XL), and XLF have a remarkable mismatched end (MEnd) ligase activity, particularly for ends with mismatched 3′ overhangs, but the mechanism has remained obscure. Here, we showed XL required Ku to bind DNA, whereas XLF required both Ku and XL to bind DNA. We detected cooperative assembly of one or two Ku molecules and up to five molecules each of XL and XLF into a Ku-XL-XLF-DNA (MEnd ligase-DNA) complex. XLF mutations that disrupted its interactions with XRCC4 or DNA also disrupted complex assembly and end joining. Together with published co-crystal structures of truncated XRCC4 and XLF proteins, our data with full-length Ku, XL, and XLF bound to DNA indicate assembly of a filament containing Ku plus alternating XL and XLF molecules. By contrast, in the absence of XLF, we detected cooperative assembly of up to six molecules each of Ku and XL into a Ku-XL-DNA complex, consistent with a filament containing alternating Ku and XL molecules. Despite a lower molecular mass, MEnd ligase-DNA had a lower electrophoretic mobility than Ku-XL-DNA. The anomalous difference in mobility and difference in XL to Ku molar ratio suggests that MEnd ligase-DNA has a distinct structure that successfully aligns mismatched DNA ends for ligation.     

One ring to bring them all—The role of Ku in mammalian non-homologous end joining

The repair of DNA double strand breaks is essential for cell survival and several conserved pathways have evolved to ensure their rapid and efficient repair. The non-homologous end joining pathway is initiated when Ku binds to the DNA break site. Ku is an abundant nuclear heterodimer of Ku70 and Ku80 with a toroidal structure that allows the protein to slide over the broken DNA end and bind with high affinity. Once locked into placed, Ku acts as a tool-belt to recruit multiple interacting proteins, forming one or more non-homologous end joining complexes that act in a regulated manner to ensure efficient repair of DNA ends. Here we review the structure and functions of Ku and the proteins with which it interacts during non-homologous end joining.     

C-terminal region of bacterial Ku controls DNA bridging,DNA threading and recruitment of DNA ligase D for double strand breaks repair

Non-homologous end joining is a ligation process repairing DNA double strand breaks in eukaryotes and many prokaryotes. The ring structured eukaryotic Ku binds DNA ends and recruits other factors which can access DNA ends through the threading of Ku inward the DNA, making this protein a key ingredient for the scaffolding of the NHEJ machinery. However, this threading ability seems unevenly conserved among bacterial Ku. As bacterial Ku differ mainly by their C-terminus, we evaluate the role of this region in the loading and the threading abilities of Bacillus subtilis Ku and the stimulation of the DNA ligase LigD. We identify two distinct sub-regions: a ubiquitous minimal C-terminal region and a frequent basic C-terminal extension. We show that truncation of one or both of these sub-regions in Bacillus subtilis Ku impairs the stimulation of the LigD end joining activity in vitro. We further demonstrate that the minimal C-terminus is required for the Ku-LigD interaction, whereas the basic extension controls the threading and DNA bridging abilities of Ku. We propose that the Ku basic C-terminal extension increases the concentration of Ku near DNA ends, favoring the recruitment of LigD at the break, thanks to the minimal C-terminal sub-region.     

Studies on the mode of Ku interaction with DNA.

The Ku heterodimer plays a central role in non-homologous end-joining. The binding of recombinant Ku to DNA has been investigated by dynamic light scattering, double-filter binding, fluorescence spectroscopy, and band shift assays. The hydrodynamic radius of Ku in solution is 5.2 nm and does not change when a 25-bp double-strand DNA (dsDNA) fragment (D25) is added, indicating that only one Ku molecule binds to a 25-bp fragment. The dissociation constant (k(d)) for the binding to D25 is 3.8 +/- 0.9 nm. If both ends of the substrate are closed with hairpin loops, Ku is still able to bind with little change in the k(d). The k(d) is not affected by ATP, Mg(2+), or ionic strength. However, the addition of bovine serum albumin decreases the k(d) by 2-fold. DNA substrates of 50 bp can bind two Ku molecules, whereas three molecules are bound to a 75-bp substrate. Data analysis with the Hill equation yields a value of the Hill coefficient (n) close to 1, and the k(d) values for the binding of Ku to both ends of these substrates are the same. Thus, we demonstrate that there is no cooperative interaction among the Ku heterodimers binding longer substrates.     

Human Ku70/80 protein blocks exonuclease 1-mediated DNA resection in the presence of human Mre11 or Mre11/Rad50 protein complex

DNA double strand breaks (DSB) are repaired by nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) or homologous recombination (HR). Recent genetic data in yeast shows that the choice between these two pathways for the repair of DSBs is via competition between the NHEJ protein, Ku, and the HR protein, Mre11/Rad50/Xrs2 (MRX) complex. To study the interrelationship between human Ku and Mre11 or Mre11/Rad50 (MR), we established an in vitro DNA end resection system using a forked model dsDNA substrate and purified human Ku70/80, Mre11, Mre11/Rad50, and exonuclease 1 (Exo1). Our study shows that the addition of Ku70/80 blocks Exo1-mediated DNA end resection of the forked dsDNA substrate. Although human Mre11 and MR bind to the forked double strand DNA, they could not compete with Ku for DNA ends or actively mediate the displacement of Ku from the DNA end either physically or via its exonuclease or endonuclease activity. Our in vitro studies show that Ku can block DNA resection and suggest that Ku must be actively displaced for DNA end processing to occur and is more complicated than the competition model established in yeast.     

Direct transfer of Ku between DNA molecules with nonhomologous ends.

The Ku protein is an essential protein for DNA double-strand-break repair by the pathway of nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ). A previous study showed that Ku bound to one DNA molecule could transfer directly to another DNA molecule without being released into the solution first. Direct transfer requires the two DNA molecules having homologous cohesive ends with a minimum of four complementary bases. Results of this study reveal that direct transfer activity of Ku is regulated by NaCl and MgCl2. Increasing either one of the two cations can decrease the required amount of the other. However, the DNA end-binding activity of Ku is not affected by changing the concentration of the cations, indicating that the two activities are regulated independently. Most importantly, the results also show that Ku can transfer directly from one DNA molecule to another one with nonhomologous ends under the condition of 200 mM NaCl and 5mM MgCl2. The ability of direct transfer between DNAs with nonhomologous ends suggests that Ku can align or juxtapose two DNA ends during NHEJ.     

Protein-protein and protein-DNA interaction regions within the DNA end-binding protein Ku70-Ku86.

DNA ends are generated during double-strand-break repair and recombination. A p70-p86 heterodimer, Ku, accounts for the DNA end binding activity in eukaryotic cell extracts. When one or both subunits of Ku are missing, mammalian cells are deficient in double-strand-break repair and in specialized recombination, such as V(D)J recombination. Little is known of which regions of Ku70 and Ku86 bind to each other to form the heterodimeric complex or of which regions are important for DNA end binding. We have done genetic and biochemical studies to examine the domains within the two subunits important for protein assembly and for DNA end binding. We found that the C-terminal 20-kDa region of Ku70 and the C-terminal 32-kDa region of Ku86 are important for subunit-subunit interaction. For DNA binding, full-length individual subunits are inactive, indicating that heterodimer assembly precedes DNA binding. DNA end binding activity by the heterodimer requires the C-terminal 40-kDa region of Ku70 and the C-terminal 45-kDa region of Ku86. Leucine zipper-like motifs in both subunits that have been suggested as the Ku70-Ku86 interaction domains do not appear to be the sites of such interaction because these are dispensable for both assembly and DNA end binding. On the basis of these studies, we have organized Ku70 into nine sequence regions conserved between Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Drosophila melanogaster, mice, and humans; only the C-terminal three regions are essential for assembly (amino acids [aa] 439 to 609), and the C-terminal four regions appear to be essential for DNA end binding (aa 254 to 609). Within the minimal active fragment of Ku86 necessary for subunit interaction (aa 449 to 732) and DNA binding (aa 334 to 732), a proline-rich region is the only defined motif.     

Productive and Nonproductive Complexes of Ku and DNA-Dependent Protein Kinase at DNA Termini

DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) is the only eukaryotic protein kinase known to be specifically activated by double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) termini, accounting for its importance in repair of dsDNA breaks and its role in physiologic processes involving dsDNA breaks, such as V(D)J recombination. In this study we conducted kinase and binding analyses using DNA-PK on DNA termini of various lengths in the presence and absence of Ku. We confirmed our previous observations that DNA-PK can bind DNA termini in the absence of Ku, and we determined rate constants for binding. However, in the presence of Ku, DNA-PK can assume either a productive or a nonproductive configuration, depending on the length of the DNA terminus. For dsDNA greater than 26 bp, the productive mode is achieved and Ku increases the affinity of the DNA-PK for the Ku:DNA complex. The change in affinity is achieved by increases in both the kinetic association rate and reduction in the kinetic dissociation rate. For dsDNA smaller than 26 bp, the nonproductive mode, in which DNA-PK is bound to Ku:DNA but is inactive as a kinase, is assumed. Both the productive and nonproductive configurations are likely to be of physiologic importance, depending on the distance of the dsDNA break site to other protein complexes, such as nucleosomes.     

Ku stimulation of DNA ligase IV-dependent ligation requires inward movement along the DNA molecule

The DNA ligase IV.XRCC4 complex (LX) functions in DNA non-homologous-end joining, the main pathway for double-strand break repair in mammalian cells. We show that, in contrast to ligation by T4 ligase, the efficiency of LX ligation of double-stranded (ds) ends is critically dependent upon the length of the DNA substrate. The effect is specific for ds ligation, and LX/DNA binding is not influenced by the substrate length. Ku stimulates LX ligation at concentrations resulting in 1-2 Ku molecules bound per substrate, whereas multiply Ku-bound DNA molecules inhibit ds ligation. The combined footprint of DNA with Ku and LX bound is the sum of each individual footprint suggesting that the two complexes are located in tandem at the DNA end. Inhibition of Ku translocation by the presence of cis-platinum adducts on the DNA substrate severely inhibits ligation by LX. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer analysis using fluorophore-labeled Ku and DNA molecules showed that, as expected, Ku makes close contact with the DNA end and that addition of LX can disrupt this close contact. Finally, we show that recruitment of LX by Ku is impaired in an adenylation-defective mutant providing further evidence that LX interacts directly with the DNA end, possibly via the 5'-phosphate as shown for prokaryotic ligases. Taken together, our results suggest that, when LX binds to a Ku-bound DNA molecule, it causes inward translocation of Ku and that freedom to move inward on the DNA is essential to Ku stimulation of LX activity.     

Loading of the nonhomologous end joining factor, Ku, on protein-occluded DNA ends

The nonhomologous end joining pathway for DNA double strand break repair requires Ku to bind DNA ends and subsequently recruit other nonhomologous end joining factors, including the DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit and the XRCC4-Ligase IV complex, to the break site. Ku loads at a break by threading the DNA ends through a circular channel in its structure. This binding mechanism explains both the high specificity of Ku for ends and its ability to translocate along DNA once loaded. However, DNA in cells is typically coated with other proteins (e.g. histones), which might be expected to block the ability of Ku to load in this manner. Here we address how the nature of a protein obstruction dictates how Ku interacts with a DNA end. Ku is unable to access the ends within an important intermediate in V(D)J recombination (a complex of RAG proteins bound to cleaved recombination targeting signals), but Ku readily displaces the linker histone, H1, from DNA. Ku also retains physiological affinity for nucleosome-associated ends. Loading onto nucleosome-associated ends still occurs by threading the end through its channel, but rather than displacing the nucleosome, Ku peels as much as 50 bp of DNA away from the histone octamer surface. We suggest a model where Ku utilizes an unusual characteristic of its three-dimensional structure to recognize certain protein-occluded ends without the extensive remodeling of chromatin structure required by other DNA repair pathways.     

The absence of the dna-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit in mice results in anaphase bridges and in increased telomeric fusions with normal telomere length and G-strand overhang

The major pathway in mammalian cells for repairing DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) is via nonhomologous end joining. Five components function in this pathway, of which three (Ku70, Ku80, and the DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit [DNA-PKcs]) constitute a complex termed DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK). Mammalian Ku proteins bind to DSB and recruit DNA-PKcs to the break. Interestingly, besides their role in DSB repair, Ku proteins bind to chromosome ends, or telomeres, protecting them from end-to-end fusions. Here we show that DNA-PKcs(-/-) cells display an increased frequency of spontaneous telomeric fusions and anaphase bridges. However, DNA-PKcs deficiency does not result in significant changes in telomere length or in deregulation of the G-strand overhang at the telomeres. Although less severe, this phenotype is reminiscent of the one recently described for Ku86-defective cells. Here we show that, besides DNA repair, a role for DNA-PKcs is to protect telomeres, which in turn are essential for chromosomal stability.     

Analysis of the mechanism of interaction of simian Ku protein with DNA.

Ku protein is a relatively abundant DNA-binding protein which was first detected as the autoantigen in a patient with scleroderma-polymyositis overlap syndrome (hence the name 'Ku'). It is a heterodimer of two polypeptide chains of molecular weights 85,000 and 72,000, and it characteristically binds, in vitro, to the ends of DNA fragments, and translocates to form regular multimeric complexes, with one protein bound per 30 bp of DNA. We have studied the mechanism of interaction of Ku protein with DNA in vitro, using protein extracted from cultured monkey cells. We find that the precise structure of the DNA ends is not important for binding, as Ku protein can bind to hairpin loops and to mononucleosomes. Bound protein also does not require DNA ends for continued binding, since complexes formed with linear DNAs can be circularized by DNA ligase. Dissociation of the complex also appears to require DNA ends, since ligase closed circular complexes were found to be extremely stable even in the presence of 2 M NaCl. We also found that Ku molecules slide along DNA, with no preferential binding to specific sequences. Thus, Ku protein behaves like a bead threaded on a DNA string, a binding mechanism which allows us to make a new hypothesis concerning the function of this protein in the nucleus.     

Double-strand break repair by Ku70 requires heterodimerization with Ku80 and DNA binding functions.

Heterodimers of the 70 and 80 kDa Ku autoantigens (Ku70 and Ku80) activate the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK). Mutations in any of the three subunits of this protein kinase (Ku70, Ku80 and DNA-PKcs) lead to sensitivity to ionizing radiation (IR) and to DNA double-strand breaks, and V(D)J recombination product formation defects. Here we show that the IR repair, DNA end binding and DNA-PK defects in Ku70-/- embryonic stem cells can be counteracted by introducing epitope-tagged wild-type Ku70 cDNA. Truncations and chimeras of Ku70 were used to identify the regions necessary for DNA end binding and IR repair. Site-specific mutational analysis revealed a core region of Ku70 responsible for DNA end binding and heterodimerization. The propensity for Ku70 to associate with Ku80 and to bind DNA correlates with the ability to activate DNA-PK, although two mutants showed that the roles of Ku70 in DNA-PK activation and IR repair are separate. Mutation of DNA-PK autophosphorylation sites and other structural motifs in Ku70 showed that these sites are not necessary for IR repair in vivo. These studies reveal Ku70 features required for double-strand break repair.     

Analysis of DNA-dependent protein kinase-mediated DNA end joining by two-photon fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy

Nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) is the primary mechanism by which mammalian cells repair DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Proteins known to play a role in NHEJ include the DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs), the Ku 70/Ku 80 heterodimer (Ku), XRCC4, and DNA ligase IV. One of the main roles of the DNA-PKcs-Ku complex is to bring the ends of the DSB together in a process termed synapsis, prior to end joining. Synapsis results in the autophosphorylation of DNA-PKcs, which is required to make the DNA ends available for ligation. Here, we describe a novel assay using two-photon fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy that allows for the analysis of DNA synapsis and end joining in solution using purified proteins. We demonstrate that although autophosphorylation-defective DNA-PKcs does not support DNA ligase-mediated DNA end joining, like wild-type (WT) DNA-PKcs, it is capable of Ku-dependent DNA synapsis in solution. Moreover, we show that, in the presence of Ku, both WT DNA-PKcs and autophosphorylation-defective DNA-PKcs promote the formation of multiple, large multi-DNA complexes in solution, suggesting that, rather than align two opposing DNA ends, multiple DNA-PK molecules may serve to bring multiple DNA ends into the NHEJ complex.     

Destroying the ring: Freeing DNA from Ku with ubiquitin

The Ku heterodimer, consisting of the proteins Ku70 and Ku80, is the central component of the non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) pathway of double strand break (DSB) repair. Ku is able to recognize and bind a DSB by virtue of its ring-like structure. Both pre-repair and topologically trapped post-repair Ku heterodimers are thought to be inhibitory to multiple cellular processes. Thus, a regulated mechanism for the removal of Ku from chromatin was predicted to exist. Recent evidence shows that Ku80 is removed from DNA through a ubiquitin-mediated process. Similar processes have been shown to be involved in the regulated dissociation of a host of other proteins from chromatin, and this appears to be a general and conserved mechanism for the regulation of chromatin-associated factors. A potential mechanism for this pathway is discussed.     

Binding of inositol hexakisphosphate (IP6) to Ku but not to DNA-PKcs

The nonhomologous DNA end joining (NHEJ) pathway is responsible for repairing a major fraction of double strand DNA breaks in somatic cells of all multicellular eukaryotes. As an indispensable protein in the NHEJ pathway, Ku has been hypothesized to be the first protein to bind at the DNA ends generated at a double strand break being repaired by this pathway. When bound to a DNA end, Ku improves the affinity of another DNA end-binding protein, DNA-PK(cs), to that end. The Ku.DNA-PK(cs) complex is often termed the DNA-PK holoenzyme. It was recently shown that myo-inositol hexakisphosphate (IP(6)) stimulates the joining of complementary DNA ends in a cell free system. Moreover, the binding data suggested that IP(6) bound to DNA-PK(cs) (not to Ku). Here we clearly show that, in fact, IP(6) associates not with DNA-PK(cs), but rather with Ku. Furthermore, the binding of DNA ends and IP(6) to Ku are independent of each other. The possible relationship between inositol phosphate metabolism and DNA repair is discussed in light of these findings.     

Computational studies on full-length Ku70 with DNA duplexes: base interactions and a helical path

The Ku70/80 heterodimer is among the first responding proteins to recognize and bind the DNA double strand breaks (DSBs). Once Ku is loaded at the DSB, it works as a scaffold to recruit other repair factors in non-homologous end joining thereby facilitates the following repair processes. In this work, we characterized the detailed interactions and binding free energies between a Ku70 subunit and several DNA duplexes, by using some well-established computational methods. The results reveal that the structure of the protein may suffer certain contractions without the company of Ku80, and may experience large conformational changes in the presence of different DNA duplexes. Notably, we observe the closest interactions between Ku70 and DNA can be easily strengthened to form H-bonds with the bases in the minor groove, which is unexpected. However, this finding is supported by the presence of a similar bond between Ku80 and DNA in the published crystal structure (PDB code 1JEY). We suggest that these interactions are responsible for the observed pausing sites when Ku translocates along DNA and the subtle difference in binding with AT- and GC-rich DNA ends. Additionally, simulations indicate the inner surface of the ring encircling the DNA is not flat, but contains a delicate clamp like structure, which is ideal to grip the two strands of DNA in the minor groove and confine the movement of the duplex in a unique helical path.     

The embryonic lethality in DNA ligase IV-deficient mice is rescued by deletion of Ku: implications for unifying the heterogeneous phenotypes of NHEJ mutants

There are two general pathways by which multicellular eukaryotes repair double-strand DNA breaks (DSB): homologous recombination (HR) and nonhomologous DNA end joining (NHEJ). All mammalian mutants in the NHEJ pathway demonstrate a lack of B and T lymphocytes and ionizing radiation sensitivity. Among these NHEJ mutants, the DNA-PK(cs) and Artemis mutants are the least severe, having no obvious phenotype other than the general defects described above. Ku mutants have an intermediate severity with accelerated senescence. The XRCC4 and DNA ligase IV mutants are the most severe, resulting in embryonic lethality. Here we show that the lethality of DNA ligase IV-deficiency in the mouse can be rescued when Ku86 is also absent. To explain the fact that simultaneous gene mutations in the NHEJ pathway can lead to viability when a single mutant is not viable, we propose a nuclease/ligase model. In this model, disrupted NHEJ is more severe if the Artemis:DNA-PK(cs) nuclease is present in the absence of a ligase, and Ku mutants are of intermediate severity, because the nuclease is less efficient. This model is also consistent with the order of severity in organismal phenotypes; consistent with chromosomal breakage observations reported here; and consistent with the NHEJ mutation identified in radiation sensitive human SCID patients.     

Overexpression of Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase is lethal for mice lacking double-strand break repair

The non-homologous DNA end joining (NHEJ) pathway is a major double-strand DNA break repair pathway in cells of multicellular eukaryotes. Ku is a heterodimeric protein consisting of Ku70 and Ku86, and it is thought to be the first component to bind to a broken double-strand DNA end. Mice lacking Ku86 show features of premature aging, live about 6-12 months, and show a characteristic loss of neurons in the central nervous system during development. Cells from mice lacking Ku have increased numbers of chromosome breaks, a significant fraction of which are caused by oxidative metabolism. Overexpression of the cytoplasmic Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD1) from a transgene is known to increase the number of chromosome breaks in primary cells (presumably by increasing reactive oxygen species). Here we show that SOD1 overexpression in a Ku86-/- mouse results in embryonic lethality. This striking effect is, however, subject to a strain-specific modifier. Genome-wide marker analysis is most consistent with the modifier being on mouse chromosome 13. Analysis of 10 markers on chromosome 13 suggests that the modifier is within the same region as a modifier of the murine amyotropic lateral sclerosis (ALS) phenotype when it is caused by overexpression of a mutant form of SOD1. Based on these results, we propose a model in which oxidative metabolism causes chromosome breaks, leading to neuronal death; and this neuronal death may account for that seen in NHEJ mutant animals and in mammals with SOD1-mediated ALS.