Ubiquitin-activating enzyme UBA1 is required for cellular response to DNA damage

The cellular DNA damage response (DDR) machinery that maintains genomic integrity and prevents severe pathologies, including cancer, is orchestrated by signaling through protein modifications. Protein ubiquitylation regulates repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), toxic lesions caused by various metabolic as well as environmental insults such as ionizing radiation (IR). Whereas several components of the DSB-evoked ubiquitylation cascade have been identified, including RNF168 and BRCA1 ubiquitin ligases, whose genetic defects predispose to a syndrome mimicking ataxia-telangiectasia and cancer, respectively, the identity of the apical E1 enzyme involved in DDR has not been established. Here, we identify ubiquitin-activating enzyme UBA1 as the E1 enzyme required for responses to IR and replication stress in human cells. We show that siRNA-mediated knockdown of UBA1, but not of another UBA family member UBA6, impaired formation of both ubiquitin conjugates at the sites of DNA damage and IR-induced foci (IRIF) by the downstream components of the DSB response pathway, 53BP1 and BRCA1. Furthermore, chemical inhibition of UBA1 prevented IRIF formation and severely impaired DSB repair and formation of 53BP1 bodies in G₁, a marker of response to replication stress. In contrast, the upstream steps of DSB response, such as phosphorylation of histone H2AX and recruitment of MDC1, remained unaffected by UBA1 depletion. Overall, our data establish UBA1 as the apical enzyme critical for ubiquitylation-dependent signaling of both DSBs and replication stress in human cells, with implications for maintenance of genomic integrity, disease pathogenesis and cancer treatment.     

A novel protein modification pathway related to the ubiquitin system.

Ubiquitin conjugation is known to target protein substrates primarily to degradation by the proteasome or via the endocytic route. Here we describe a novel protein modification pathway in yeast which mediates the conjugation of RUB1, a ubiquitin-like protein displaying 53% amino acid identity to ubiquitin. We show that RUB1 conjugation requires at least three proteins in vivo. ULA1 and UBA3 are related to the N- and C-terminal domains of the E1 ubiquitin-activating enzyme, respectively, and together fulfil E1-like functions for RUB1 activation. RUB1 conjugation also requires UBC12, a protein related to E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes, which functions analogously to E2 enzymes in RUB1-protein conjugate formation. Conjugation of RUB1 is not essential for normal cell growth and appears to be selective for a small set of substrates. Remarkably, CDC53/cullin, a common subunit of the multifunctional SCF ubiquitin ligase, was found to be a major substrate for RUB1 conjugation. This suggests that the RUB1 conjugation pathway is functionally affiliated to the ubiquitin-proteasome system and may play a regulatory role.     

A novel ubiquitination factor, E4, is involved in multiubiquitin chain assembly

Proteins modified by multiubiquitin chains are the preferred substrates of the proteasome. Ubiquitination involves a ubiquitin-activating enzyme, E1, a ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme, E2, and often a substrate-specific ubiquitin-protein ligase, E3. Here we show that efficient multiubiquitination needed for proteasomal targeting of a model substrate requires an additional conjugation factor, named E4. This protein, previously known as UFD2 in yeast, binds to the ubiquitin moieties of preformed conjugates and catalyzes ubiquitin chain assembly in conjunction with E1, E2, and E3. Intriguingly, E4 defines a novel protein family that includes two human members and the regulatory protein NOSA from Dictyostelium required for fruiting body development. In yeast, E4 activity is linked to cell survival under stress conditions, indicating that eukaryotes utilize E4-dependent proteolysis pathways for multiple cellular functions.     

Multiple forms of ubiquitin-activating enzyme E1 from wheat. Identification of an essential cysteine by in vitro mutagenesis.

Ubiquitin-activating enzyme, E1, directs the ATP-dependent formation of a thiol ester linkage between itself and ubiquitin. The energy in this bond is ultimately used to attach ubiquitin to various intracellular proteins. We previously reported the isolation of multiple E1s from wheat and the characterization of a cDNA encoding this protein (UBA1). We now report the derived amino acid sequence of two additional members of this gene family (UBA2 and UBA3). Whereas the amino acid sequence of UBA2 is nearly identical to UBA1, the sequence of UBA3 is significantly different. Nevertheless, the protein encoded by UBA3 catalyzes the ATP-dependent activation of ubiquitin in vitro. Comparison of derived amino acid sequences of genes encoding E1 from plant, yeast, and animal tissues revealed 5 conserved cysteine residues, with one potentially involved in thiol ester bond formation. To identify this essential residue, codons corresponding to each of the 5 cysteines in UBA1 were individually altered using site-directed mutagenesis. The mutagenized enzymes were expressed in Escherichia coli and assayed for their ability to activate ubiquitin. Only substitution of the cysteine at position 626 abolishes E1 activity, suggesting that this residue forms the thiol ester linkage with ubiquitin.     

Crystal Structure of the Human Ubiquitin-activating Enzyme 5 (UBA5) Bound to ATP: MECHANISTIC INSIGHTS INTO A MINIMALISTIC E1 ENZYME*

E1 ubiquitin-activating enzymes (UBAs) are large multidomain proteins that catalyze formation of a thioester bond between the terminal carboxylate of a ubiquitin or ubiquitin-like modifier (UBL) and a conserved cysteine in an E2 protein, producing reactive ubiquityl units for subsequent ligation to substrate lysines. Two important E1 reaction intermediates have been identified: a ubiquityl-adenylate phosphoester and a ubiquityl-enzyme thioester. However, the mechanism of thioester bond formation and its subsequent transfer to an E2 enzyme remains poorly understood. We have determined the crystal structure of the human UFM1 (ubiquitin-fold modifier 1) E1-activating enzyme UBA5, bound to ATP, revealing a structure that shares similarities with both large canonical E1 enzymes and smaller ancestral E1-like enzymes. In contrast to other E1 active site cysteines, which are in a variably sized domain that is separate and flexible relative to the adenylation domain, the catalytic cysteine of UBA5 (Cys²⁵⁰) is part of the adenylation domain in an α-helical motif. The novel position of the UBA5 catalytic cysteine and conformational changes associated with ATP binding provides insight into the possible mechanisms through which the ubiquityl-enzyme thioester is formed. These studies reveal structural features that further our understanding of the UBA5 enzyme reaction mechanism and provide insight into the evolution of ubiquitin activation.     

Ubiquitin-mediated degradation of histone H3 does not require the substrate-binding ubiquitin protein ligase, E3, or attachment of polyubiquitin chains

Radioiodinated histone H3 was incubated with ubiquitin, the ubiquitin-activating enzyme E1, and one of three ubiquitin carrier proteins, reticulocyte E2(20K) or E2(32K) or the yeast RAD6 product. Although the resulting ubiquitin-histone conjugates were synthesized in the absence of the substrate-binding protein E3, they were nevertheless degraded by purified rabbit reticulocyte 26 S protease. In contrast, unmodified histone H3 remained intact upon challenge with the 26 S ubiquitin/ATP-dependent enzyme. Conjugates produced by the RAD6 protein were better proteolytic substrates than those formed by reticulocyte E2 unless ubiquitin molecules with altered lysines were used for conjugate synthesis. Substitution of methylated ubiquitin or ubiquitin molecules in which lysine 48 was converted to arginine by site-directed mutation produced histone conjugates that were degraded at slow but measurable rates. Since methylated ubiquitin molecules are incapable of forming branched polyubiquitin chains, these results demonstrate that neither ubiquitin "trees" nor the substrate binding factor E3 is absolutely required for ubiquitin-dependent degradation of histone H3 in vitro.     

大鼠睾丸特异表达基因Ube1的分离鉴定及生物学特征

本研究采用抑制性消减杂交(suppression subtracfive hybridization, SSH)和cDNA快速扩增(rapid amplification of cDNA ends, RACE)技术从大鼠A型精原细胞和粗线期精母细胞中成功克隆出大鼠泛素激活酶(ubiquitin-activating enzyme)基因Ube1 (GenBank登录号EF690356).该基因序列全长3433 bp,其中开放阅读框有3171 bp,编码一个含1057个氨基酸的蛋白质.Blast比对显示,Ube1与小鼠泛素激活酶基因Ubely1的同源性为93%,与人泛素激活酶基因UBE1的同源性为82%.Ube1基因编码的蛋白质含泛素激活酶信号位点和泛素激活酶活化位点,这些位点也存在于人类和小鼠的泛素激活酶1中.RT-PCR分析显示,Ube1在睾丸中大量表达,而在心、肝、脾、肺、肾、肌肉、脑、卵巢中没有表达.荧光定量PCR分析不同生精细胞中Ube1的表达,显示Ube1在A型精原细胞中大量表达,在粗线期精母细胞、圆形精子细胞和支持细胞中微弱表达.以上结果提示,Ube1是大鼠睾丸特异表达基因,可能通过参与泛素/蛋白酶体途径来影响精子发生.     

The UBA domain of conjugating enzyme Ubc1/Ube2K facilitates assembly of K48/K63‐branched ubiquitin chains

The assembly of a specific polymeric ubiquitin chain on a target protein is a key event in the regulation of numerous cellular processes. Yet, the mechanisms that govern the selective synthesis of particular polyubiquitin signals remain enigmatic. The homologous ubiquitin‐conjugating (E2) enzymes Ubc1 (budding yeast) and Ube2K (mammals) exclusively generate polyubiquitin linked through lysine 48 (K48). Uniquely among E2 enzymes, Ubc1 and Ube2K harbor a ubiquitin‐binding UBA domain with unknown function. We found that this UBA domain preferentially interacts with ubiquitin chains linked through lysine 63 (K63). Based on structural modeling, in vitro ubiquitination experiments, and NMR studies, we propose that the UBA domain aligns Ubc1 with K63‐linked polyubiquitin and facilitates the selective assembly of K48/K63‐branched ubiquitin conjugates. Genetic and proteomics experiments link the activity of the UBA domain, and hence the formation of this unusual ubiquitin chain topology, to the maintenance of cellular proteostasis.     

E1 ubiquitin-activating enzyme UBA-1 plays multiple roles throughout C. elegans development

Poly-ubiquitination of target proteins typically marks them for destruction via the proteasome and provides an essential mechanism for the dynamic control of protein levels. The E1 ubiquitin-activating enzyme lies at the apex of the ubiquitination cascade, and its activity is necessary for all subsequent steps in the reaction. We have isolated a temperature-sensitive mutation in the Caenorhabditis elegans uba-1 gene, which encodes the sole E1 enzyme in this organism. Manipulation of UBA-1 activity at different developmental stages reveals a variety of functions for ubiquitination, including novel roles in sperm fertility, control of body size, and sex-specific development. Levels of ubiquitin conjugates are substantially reduced in the mutant, consistent with reduced E1 activity. The uba-1 mutation causes delays in meiotic progression in the early embryo, a process that is known to be regulated by ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis. The uba-1 mutation also demonstrates synthetic lethal interactions with alleles of the anaphase-promoting complex, an E3 ubiquitin ligase. The uba-1 mutation provides a sensitized genetic background for identifying new in vivo functions for downstream components of the ubiquitin enzyme cascade, and it is one of the first conditional mutations reported for the essential E1 enzyme in a metazoan animal model.     

The HIP2~Ubiquitin Conjugate Forms a Non-Compact Monomeric Thioester during Di-Ubiquitin Synthesis

Polyubiquitination is a post-translational event used to control the degradation of damaged or unwanted proteins by modifying the target protein with a chain of ubiquitin molecules. One potential mechanism for the assembly of polyubiquitin chains involves the dimerization of an E2 conjugating enzyme allowing conjugated ubiquitin molecules to be put into close proximity to assist reactivity. HIP2 (UBE2K) and Ubc1 (yeast homolog of UBE2K) are unique E2 conjugating enzymes that each contain a C-terminal UBA domain attached to their catalytic domains, and they have basal E3-independent polyubiquitination activity. Although the isolated enzymes are monomeric, polyubiquitin formation activity assays show that both can act as ubiquitin donors or ubiquitin acceptors when in the activated thioester conjugate suggesting dimerization of the E2-ubiquitin conjugates. Stable disulfide complexes, analytical ultracentrifugation and small angle x-ray scattering were used to show that the HIP2-Ub and Ubc1-Ub thioester complexes remain predominantly monomeric in solution. Models of the HIP2-Ub complex derived from SAXS data show the complex is not compact but instead forms an open or backbent conformation similar to UbcH5b~Ub or Ubc13~Ub where the UBA domain and covalently attached ubiquitin reside on opposite ends of the catalytic domain. Activity assays showed that full length HIP2 exhibited a five-fold increase in the formation rate of di-ubiquitin compared to a HIP2 lacking the UBA domain. This difference was not observed for Ubc1 and may be attributed to the closer proximity of the UBA domain in HIP2 to the catalytic core than for Ubc1.     

Cloning of ubiquitin activating enzyme from wheat and expression of a functional protein in Escherichia coli

The initial step in the conjugation of ubiquitin to substrate proteins involves the activation of ubiquitin by ubiquitin activating enzyme, E1. Previously, we purified and characterized multiple species of E1 from wheat germ. We now describe the isolation and characterization of a cDNA clone encoding E1 from wheat. This clone (UBA1) was isolated from a cDNA expression library with anti-wheat E1 antibodies. It contained an open reading frame coding for 1051 amino acids and directed the synthesis of a protein that comigrated with a wheat germ E1 of 117 kDa. UBA1 was confirmed as encoding E1 by (i) comparison of the peptide map of the protein product of UBA1 synthesized in Escherichia coli with that of purified E1 from wheat, and (ii) amino acid sequence identity of peptides generated from purified E1 with regions of the derived amino acid sequence of UBA1. The isolation of two additional cDNAs closely related to UBA1 indicated that E1 was encoded by a small gene family in wheat. Nonetheless, a single poly(A+) mRNA size class of 4 kilobases hybridized with UBA1. When expressed in E. coli, the product of UBA1 catalyzed the formation of a thiol ester linkage between ubiquitin and an ubiquitin carrier protein. The ability of E. coli containing UBA1 to synthesize an active protein will allow us to identify domains important for E1 function using in vitro mutagenesis.     

A conditional yeast E1 mutant blocks the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway and reveals a role for ubiquitin conjugates in targeting Rad23 to the proteasome

E1 ubiquitin activating enzyme catalyzes the initial step in all ubiquitin-dependent processes. We report the isolation of uba1-204, a temperature-sensitive allele of the essential Saccharomyces cerevisiae E1 gene, UBA1. Uba1-204 cells exhibit dramatic inhibition of the ubiquitin-proteasome system, resulting in rapid depletion of cellular ubiquitin conjugates and stabilization of multiple substrates. We have employed the tight phenotype of this mutant to investigate the role ubiquitin conjugates play in the dynamic interaction of the UbL/UBA adaptor proteins Rad23 and Dsk2 with the proteasome. Although proteasomes purified from mutant cells are intact and proteolytically active, they are depleted of ubiquitin conjugates, Rad23, and Dsk2. Binding of Rad23 to these proteasomes in vitro is enhanced by addition of either free or substrate-linked ubiquitin chains. Moreover, association of Rad23 with proteasomes in mutant and wild-type cells is improved upon stabilizing ubiquitin conjugates with proteasome inhibitor. We propose that recognition of polyubiquitin chains by Rad23 promotes its shuttling to the proteasome in vivo.     

Molecular characterization of the thermosensitive E1 ubiquitin-activating enzyme cell mutant A31N-ts20. Requirements upon different levels of E1 for the ubiquitination/degradation of the various protein substrates in vivo.

According to our current knowledge, protein ubiquitination involves three steps: activation of ubiquitin through formation of an energy-rich bond with an E1 ubiquitin-activating enzyme; and transfer of activated ubiquitin onto E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes, which, in turn, alone, or in combination with E3 ubiquitin-protein ligase enzymes, transfer ubiquitin onto target proteins. A31N-ts20 cells are mouse embryo fibroblasts, thermosensitive for E1. We show here that: (a) the enzymatic activity of the enzyme is heat-inactivatable in vitro; and (b) a major mechanism responsible for E1 inactivation in vivo consists of accelerated destruction. Surprisingly, a >90% reduction in E1 abundance little alters the formation of the bulk of protein-ubiquitin conjugates when A31N-ts20 cells are grown at the nonpermissive temperature, indicating that cautious interpretation of results is required when studying ubiquitination of specific substrates using this cell line. Surprisingly, our data also indicate that, in vivo, ubiquitination of the various protein substrates in A31N-ts20 cells requires different amounts of E1, indicating that this mutant cell line can be used for unveiling the existence of differences in the intimate mechanisms responsible for the ubiquitination of the various cell proteins in vivo, and for providing criteria of reliability when developing in vitro ubiquitination assays for specific proteins.     

EL5, a rice N-acetylchitooligosaccharide elicitor-responsive RING-H2 finger protein,is a ubiquitin ligase which functions in vitro in co-operation with an elicitor-responsive ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme,OsUBC5b

EL5, a rice gene responsive to N-acetylchitooligosaccharide elicitor, encodes a RING-H2 finger protein with structural features common to the plant-specific ATL family. We show that the fusion protein of EL5 with maltose binding protein (MBP) was polyubiquitinated by incubation with ubiquitin, ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1), and the Ubc4/5 subfamily of the ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2). EL5 possesses the activity to catalyse the transfer of ubiquitin to the MBP moiety, and the RING-H2 finger motif of EL5 is necessary for this activity. Thus, we concluded that EL5 represents a ubiquitin ligase (E3). We also show that two rice E2s (OsUBC5a, OsUBC5b) of the Ubc4/5 subfamily function as E2 which catalyses EL5-mediated ubiquitination, and OsUBC5b was induced by elicitor, as well as EL5. These results strongly suggest that EL5 and OsUBC5b have roles in plant defense response through the turnover of protein(s) via the ubiquitin/proteasome system.     

The E2-25K ubiquitin-associated (UBA) domain aids in polyubiquitin chain synthesis and linkage specificity

E2-25K is an ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme with the ability to synthesize Lys48-linked polyubiquitin chains. E2-25K and its homologs represent the only known E2 enzymes which contain a C-terminal ubiquitin-associated (UBA) domain as well as the conserved catalytic ubiquitin-conjugating (UBC) domain. As an additional non-covalent binding surface for ubiquitin, the UBA domain must provide some functional specialization. We mapped the protein–protein interface involved in the E2-25K UBA/ubiquitin complex by solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and subsequently modeled the structure of the complex. Domain–domain interactions between the E2-25K catalytic UBC domain and the UBA domain do not induce significant structural changes in the UBA domain or alter the affinity of the UBA domain for ubiquitin. We determined that one of the roles of the C-terminal UBA domain, in the context of E2-25K, is to increase processivity in Lys48-linked polyubiquitin chain synthesis, possibly through increased binding to the ubiquitinated substrate. Additionally, we see evidence that the UBA domain directs specificity in polyubiquitin chain linkage.     

Ubiquitylation as a quality control system for intracellular proteins

Quality control of intracellular proteins is essential for cellular homeostasis. Molecular chaperones recognize and contribute to the refolding of misfolded or unfolded proteins, whereas the ubiquitin-proteasome system mediates the degradation of such abnormal proteins. Ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3s) determine the substrate specificity for ubiquitylation and have been classified into HECT and RING-finger families. More recently, however, U-box proteins, which contain a domain (the U box) of about 70 amino acids that is conserved from yeast to humans, have been identified as a new type of E3. The prototype U-box protein, yeast Ufd2, was identified as a ubiquitin chain assembly factor (E4) that cooperates with a ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1), a ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (E2), and an E3 to catalyze the formation of a ubiquitin chain on artificial substrates. Yeast Ufd2 is functionally implicated in cell survival under stressful conditions. This review addresses recent progress in characterization of the role of E3 enzymes, especially that of U-box proteins, in quality control of intracellular proteins.     

Glucose-induced autophagy of peroxisomes in Pichia pastoris requires a unique E1-like protein

Cytosolic and peroxisomal enzymes necessary for methanol assimilation are synthesized when Pichia pastoris is grown in methanol. Upon adaptation from methanol to a glucose environment, these enzymes are rapidly and selectively sequestered and degraded within the yeast vacuole. Sequestration begins when the vacuole changes shape and surrounds the peroxisomes. The opposing membranes then fuse, engulfing the peroxisome. In this study, we have characterized a mutant cell line (glucose-induced selective autophagy), gsa7, which is defective in glucose-induced selective autophagy of peroxisomes, and have identified the GSA7 gene. Upon glucose adaptation, gsa7 cells were unable to degrade peroxisomal alcohol oxidase. We observed that the peroxisomes were surrounded by the vacuole, but complete uptake into the vacuole did not occur. Therefore, we propose that GSA7 is not required for initiation of autophagy but is required for bringing the opposing vacuolar membranes together for homotypic fusion, thereby completing peroxisome sequestration. By sequencing the genomic DNA fragment that complemented the gsa7 phenotype, we have found that GSA7 encodes a protein of 71 kDa (Gsa7p) with limited sequence homology to a family of ubiquitin-activating enzymes, E1. The knockout mutant gsa7Delta had an identical phenotype to gsa7, and both mutants were rescued by an epitope-tagged Gsa7p (Gsa7-hemagglutinin [HA]). In addition, a GSA7 homolog, APG7, a protein required for autophagy in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, was capable of rescuing gsa7. We have sequenced the human homolog of GSA7 and have shown many regions of identity between the yeast and human proteins. Two of these regions align to the putative ATP-binding domain and catalytic site of the family of ubiquitin activating enzymes, E1 (UBA1, UBA2, and UBA3). When either of these sites was mutated, the resulting mutants [Gsa7(DeltaATP)-HA and Gsa7(C518S)-HA] were unable to rescue gsa7 cells. We provide evidence to suggest that Gsa7-HA formed a thio-ester linkage with a 25-30 kDa protein. This conjugate was not observed in cells expressing Gsa7(DeltaATP)-HA or in cells expressing Gsa7(C518S)-HA. Our results suggest that this unique E1-like enzyme is required for homotypic membrane fusion, a late event in the sequestration of peroxisomes by the vacuole.     

NUB1-mediated targeting of the ubiquitin precursor UbC1 for its C-terminal hydrolysis.

NEDD8 is a ubiquitin-like protein that controls vital biological events through its conjugation to target proteins. Previously, we identified a negative regulator of the NEDD8 conjugation system, NEDD8 ultimate buster-1 (NUB1), that recruits NEDD8 and its conjugates to the proteasome for degradation. Recently, we performed yeast two-hybrid screening with NUB1 as bait and isolated a ubiquitin precursor UbC1 that is composed of nine tandem repeats of a ubiquitin unit through alpha-peptide bonds. Interestingly, NUB1 interacted with UbC1 through its UBA domain. Further study revealed that the UBA domain interacted with alpha-peptide bond-linked polyubiquitin, but not with isopeptide bond-linked polyubiquitin, indicating that the UBA domain of NUB1 is a specific acceptor for the linear ubiquitin precursor. A functional study revealed that an unidentified protein that was immunoprecipitated with NUB1 served as a ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase for UbC1. Thus, NUB1 seems to form a protein complex with the unidentified ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase and recruit UbC1 to this complex. This might allow the ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase to hydrolyze UbC1, in order to generate ubiquitin monomers. Northern blot analysis showed that the mRNAs of both NUB1 and UbC1 were enriched in the testis. Furthermore, in situ hybridization showed that both mRNAs were strongly expressed in seminiferous tubules of the testis. These results may imply that the UbC1 hydrolysis mediated by NUB1 is involved in cellular functions in the seminiferous tubules such as spermatogenesis.     

The protein substrate binding site of the ubiquitin-protein ligase system

In order to gain insight into the mechanisms that determine the selectivity of the ubiquitin proteolytic pathway, the protein substrate binding site of the ubiquitin-protein ligase system was identified and examined. Previous studies had shown that the ligase system consists of three components: a ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1), ubiquitin-carrier protein (E2), and a third enzyme, E3, the mode of action of which has not been defined. E3 from rabbit reticulocytes was further purified by a combination of affinity chromatography, hydrophobic chromatography, and gel filtration procedures. A 180-kDa protein was identified as the subunit of E3. Two independent methods indicate that E3 has the protein binding site of the ubiquitin ligase system. These are the chemical cross-linking of 125I-labeled proteins to the E3 subunit and the functional conversion of enzyme-bound labeled proteins to ubiquitin conjugates in pulse-chase experiments. The trapping of E3-bound protein for labeled product formation was allowed by the slow dissociation of E3 X protein complex. The specificity of binding of different proteins to E3, examined by both methods, showed a direct correlation with their susceptibility to degradation by the ubiquitin system. Proteins with free alpha-NH2 groups, which are good substrates, bind better to E3 than corresponding proteins with blocked NH2 termini, which are not substrates. Oxidation of methionine residues to sulfoxide derivatives greatly increases the susceptibility of some proteins to ligation with ubiquitin, with a corresponding increase in their binding to E3. However, a protein derivative which was subjected to both amino group modification and oxidation binds strongly to the enzyme, even though it cannot be ligated to ubiquitin. It thus seems that the substrate binding site of E3 participates in determining the specificity of proteins that enter the ubiquitin pathway of protein degradation.