Single molecule studies of antibody-antigen interaction strength versus intra-molecular antigen stability

We investigated molecular recognition of antibodies to membrane-antigens and extraction of the antigens out of membranes at the single molecule level. Using dynamic force microscopy imaging and enzyme immunoassay, binding of anti-sendai antibodies to sendai-epitopes genetically fused into bacteriorhodopsin molecules from purple membranes were detected under physiological conditions. The antibody/antigen interaction strength of 70-170 pN at loading rates of 2-50 nN/second yielded a barrier width of x = 0.12 nm and a kinetic off-rate (corresponding to the barrier height) of k(off) = 6s(-1), respectively. Bacteriorhodopsin unfolding revealed a characteristic intra-molecular force pattern, in which wild-type and sendai-bacteriorhodopsin molecules were clearly distinguishable in their length distributions, originating from the additional 13 amino acid residues epitope in sendai purple membranes. The inter-molecular antibody/antigen unbinding force was significantly lower than the force required to mechanically extract the binding epitope-containing helix pair out of the membrane and unfold it (126 pN compared to 204 pN at the same loading rate), meeting the expectation that inter-molecular unbinding forces are weaker than intra-molecular unfolding forces responsible for stabilizing native conformations of proteins.     

Mechanical unbinding of abeta peptides from amyloid fibrils

Using the experimental structures of Abeta amyloid fibrils and all-atom molecular dynamics, we study the force-induced unbinding of Abeta peptides from the fibril. We show that the mechanical dissociation of Abeta peptides is highly anisotropic and proceeds via different pathways when force is applied in parallel or perpendicular direction with respect to the fibril axis. The threshold forces associated with lateral unbinding of Abeta peptides exceed those observed during the mechanical dissociation along the fibril axis. In addition, Abeta fibrils are found to be brittle in the lateral direction of unbinding and soft along the fibril axis. Lateral mechanical unbinding and the unbinding along the fibril axis load different types of fibril interactions. Lateral unbinding is primarily determined by the cooperative rupture of fibril backbone hydrogen bonds. The unbinding along the fibril axis largely depends on the interpeptide Lys-Asp electrostatic contacts and the hydrophobic interactions formed by the Abeta C terminal. Due to universality of the amyloid beta structure, the anisotropic mechanical dissociation observed for Abeta fibrils is likely to be applicable to other amyloid assemblies. The estimates of equilibrium forces required to dissociate Abeta peptide from the amyloid fibril suggest that these supramolecular structures are mechanically stronger than most protein domains.     

Evaluation of temperature effect on the interaction between β-lactoglobulin and anti-β-lactoglobulin antibody by atomic force microscopy

Molecular recognition such as antigen-antibody interaction is characterized by the parameters of kinetics and the energy landscape. Examinations of molecules involved in the interaction at different temperatures using atomic force microscopy (AFM) can provide information on not only the effects of temperature on the unbinding force between a molecule of interest and a complementary molecule but also the parameters of kinetics and the energy landscape for dissociation of the molecular complex. We investigated the effect of temperature on the dissociation process of the complex of β-lactoglobulin and anti-bovine β-lactoglobulin IgG polyclonal antibody using AFM. Measurements of the unbinding forces between β-lactoglobulin and the antibody were performed at 25, 35, and 45 °C. The following results were obtained in our present study: (i) The unbinding forces decreased as temperature increased, suggesting that the binding force between β-lactoglobulin and the antibody includes the force originating from temperature-dependent interactions (e.g., hydrogen bonding). (ii) At each temperature, the unbinding force exhibited two linear regimes in the force spectra, indicating that the dissociation process of the β-lactoglobulin-antibody complex passes at least two energy barriers from the bound state to the dissociated state. (iii) The dissociation rates at zero force and the position of energy barriers increased as temperature increased. (iv) The heights of the two energy barriers in the reaction coordinates were 49.7 k(B)T and 14.5 k(B)T. (v) The values of roughness of the barriers were ca. 6.1 k(B)T and 3.2 k(B)T. Overall, the present study using AFM revealed more information about the β-lactoglobulin-antibody interaction than studies using conventional bulk measurement such as surface plasmon resonance.     

On molecular recognition of an uranyl chelate by monoclonal antibodies

The energy landscape of the uranyl (UO2) chelate dissociated from a monoclonal antibody U08S was investigated using dynamic force spectroscopy (DFS). The uranyl ion (UO2(2+)) is chelated with the ligand dicarboxy-phenanthroline (DCP). The monoclonal antibody U08S was raised against UO2-DCP and does not cross-react with DCP alone. The results of plotting the most probable force against the logarithm of the loading rate show two distinguished values of slopes of multiple fitting lines, as observed in our previous study on that system with monoclonal antibody U04S (Odorico et al., 2007a. Biophys. J. 93: 645-654.). It indicates an unbinding process undergoing at least two activation states. We have generated the histogram of unbinding events with respect to the composite stiffness of the complex between the protein and the uranyl compound. Combining the model of Bell and Evans with that of Williams, we have estimated the number of parallel bonds involved in the unbinding process and determined the value of stiffness for individual bonds. We propose that the uranyl compound binds to the two antibodies U04S and U0c at structurally equivalent locations and forms the interaction with similar coordination modes. In addition, the unbinding process goes through two steps; the first weakens the bonding of the central metal with AspL50 of the antibody and the second breaks other non-bonded interactions of the compound with the antibody.     

Energy landscape of chelated uranyl: antibody interactions by dynamic force spectroscopy

We used dynamic force spectroscopy (DFS) to explore the energy landscape of interactions between a chelated uranyl compound and a monoclonal antibody raised against the uranyl-dicarboxy-phenanthroline complex. We estimated the potential energy barrier widths and the relevant thermodynamic rate constants along the dissociation coordinate. Using atomic force microscopy, four different experimental setups with or without the uranyl ion in the chelate ligand, we have distinguished specific and nonspecific binding in the binding affinity of the uranyl compound to the antibody. The force loading rates for our system were measured from 15 to 26,400 pN/s. The results showed two regimes in the plot of the most probable unbinding force versus the logarithm of the loading rate, revealing the presence of two (at least) activation barriers. Analyses of DFS suggest parallel multivalent binding present in either regime. We have also built a molecular model for the variable fragment of the antibody and used computational graphics to dock the chelated uranyl ion into the binding pocket. The structural analysis led us to hypothesize that the two regimes originate from two interaction modes: the first one corresponds to an energy barrier with a very narrow width of 0.5 +/- 0.2 A, inferring dissociation of the uranyl ion from its first coordination shell (Asp residue); the second one with a broader energy barrier width (3.9 +/- 0.3 A) infers the entire chelate compound dissociated from the antibody. Our study highlights the sensitivity of DFS experiments to dissect protein-metal compound interactions.     

Force-based analysis of multidimensional energy landscapes: application of dynamic force spectroscopy and steered molecular dynamics simulations to an antibody fragment-peptide complex

Multidimensional energy landscapes are an intrinsic property of proteins and define their dynamic behavior as well as their response to external stimuli. In order to explore the energy landscape and its implications on the dynamic function of proteins dynamic force spectroscopy and steered molecular dynamics (SMD) simulations have proved to be important tools. In this study, these techniques have been employed to analyze the influence of the direction of the probing forces on the complex of an antibody fragment with its peptide antigen. Using an atomic force microscope, experiments were performed where the attachment points of the 12 amino acid long peptide antigen were varied. These measurements yielded clearly distinguishable basal dissociation rates and potential widths, proving that the direction of the applied force determines the unbinding pathway. Complementary atomistic SMD simulations were performed, which also show that the unbinding pathways of the system are dependent on the pulling direction. However, the main barrier to be crossed was independent of the pulling direction and is represented by a backbone hydrogen bond between Gly^H-H40 of the antibody fragment and Glu^Oε-6_peptide of the peptide. For each pulling direction, the observed barriers can be correlated with the rupture of specific interactions, which stabilize the bound complex. Furthermore, although the SMD simulations were performed at loading rates exceeding the experimental rates by orders of magnitude due to computational limitations, a detailed comparison of the barriers that were overcome in the SMD simulations with the data obtained from the atomic force microscope unbinding experiments show excellent agreement.     

Change of the unbinding mechanism upon a mutation: a molecular dynamics study of an antibody-hapten complex

We study forced unbinding of fluorescein from the wild type (WT) and a mutant [H(H58)A] of the single-chain variable-fragment (scFv) anti-fluorescein antibody FITC-E2 by molecular dynamics simulations using various pulling techniques. A large number of long simulations were needed to obtain statistically meaningful results as both the wild type and the H(H58)A mutant unbinding occurs through multiple pathways, often with metastable intermediates. For the wild type, the rate-limiting step in the unbinding process corresponds to the breaking of the non-native interactions characteristic of a specific intermediate. The H(H58)A mutation disfavors the occurrence of this intermediate. Two events where the hapten partially unbinds in the absence of pulling force are observed in extensive equilibrium simulations of the wild type, and their analysis indicates that forced unbinding and spontaneous unbinding proceed along similar pathways. The different unbinding mechanisms observed in the simulations suggest a possible reason for the difference in the experimental off-rate between the two antibodies. We predict mutations that are expected to modulate the occurrence of the unbinding intermediate. For two such new mutants [H(H58)A and S(H52)A], our predictions are validated in silico by additional simulations. The accompanying paper in this issue by Honegger et al. reports the X-ray structure of FITC-E2 with a derivative of fluorescein, which was used as the starting conformation for the work presented here.     

Chip-based protein-protein interaction studied by atomic force microscopy

In this article, a technique for accurate direct measurement of protein‐to‐protein interactions before and after the introduction of a drug candidate is developed using atomic force microscopy (AFM). The method is applied to known immunosuppressant drug candidate Echinacea purpurea derived cynarin. T‐cell/CD28 is on‐chip immobilized and B‐cell/CD80 is immobilized on an AFM tip. The difference in unbinding force between these two proteins before and after the introduction of cynarin is measured. The method is described in detail including determination of the loading rates, maximum probability of bindings, and average unbinding forces. At an AFM loading rate of 1.44 × 10⁴ pN/s, binding events were largely reduced from 61 ± 5% to 47 ± 6% after cynarin introduction. Similarly, maximum probability of bindings reduced from 70% to 35% with a blocking effect of about 35% for a fixed contact time of 0.5 s or greater. Furthermore, average unbinding forces were reduced from 61.4 to 38.9 pN with a blocking effect of ～37% as compared with ～9% by SPR. AFM, which can provide accurate quantitative measures, is shown to be a good method for drug screening. The method could be applied to a wider variety of drug candidates with advances in bio‐chip technology and a more comprehensive AFM database of protein‐to‐protein interactions. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2012; 109: 2460–2467. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Force spectroscopy of the fibrin(ogen)-fibrinogen interaction

Fibrin aggregation is of vital importance in many physiological and pathological processes, such as blood coagulation, wound healing, and thrombosis. In the present study, we investigated the forces involved in the initial steps of the fibrinogen fibrin aggregation by force spectroscopy using the atomic force microscope. Our data confirm the existence of strong specific interactions between fibrin and fibrin(ogen), with unbinding forces ranging from 290 to 375 pN and a logarithmic dependence on the loading rate between 0.8 and 23 nN/s.     

Affinity-matured recombinant antibody fragments analyzed by single-molecule force spectroscopy

For many applications, antibodies need to be engineered toward maximum affinity. Strategies are in demand to especially optimize this process toward slower dissociation rates, which correlate with the (un)binding forces. Using single-molecule force spectroscopy, we have characterized three variants of a recombinant antibody single-chain Fv fragment. These variants were taken from different steps of an affinity maturation process. Therefore, they are closely related and differ from each other by a few mutations only. The dissociation rates determined with the atomic force microscope differ by one order of magnitude and agree well with the values obtained from surface plasmon resonance measurements. However, the effective potential width of the binding complexes, which was derived from the dynamic force spectroscopy measurements, was found to be the same for the different mutants. The large potential width of 0.9 nm indicates that both the binding pocket and the peptide deform significantly during the unbinding process.     

Dissociation of Abeta(16-22) amyloid fibrils probed by molecular dynamics

The mechanisms of deposition and dissociation are implicated in the assembly of amyloid fibrils. To investigate the kinetics of unbinding of Abeta(16-22) monomers from preformed fibrils, we use molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and the structures for Abeta(16-22) amyloid fibrils. Consistent with experimental studies, the dissociation of Abeta(16-22) peptides involves two main stages, locked and docked, after which peptides unbind. The lifetime of the locked state, in which a peptide retains fibril-like structure and interactions, extends up to 0.5 micros under normal physiological conditions. Upon cooperative rupture of all fibril-like hydrogen bonds (HBs) with the fibril, a peptide enters a docked state. This state is populated by disordered random coil conformations and its lifetime ranges from approximately 10 to 200 ns. The docked state is stabilized by hydrophobic side chain interactions, while the contribution from HBs is small. Our simulations also suggest that the peptides located on fibril edges may form stable beta-strand conformations distinct from the fibril "bulk". We propose that such edge peptides can act as fibril caps, which impede fibril elongation. Our results indicate that the interactions between unbinding peptides constitute the molecular basis for cooperativity of peptide dissociation. The kinetics of fibril growth is reconstructed from unbinding assuming the reversibility of deposition/dissociation pathways. The relation of in silica dissociation kinetics to experimental observations is discussed.     

Synthetic peptide vaccine development: measurement of polyclonal antibody affinity and cross-reactivity using a new peptide capture and release system for surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy

A method has been developed for measurement of antibody affinity and cross-reactivity by surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy using the EK-coil heterodimeric coiled-coil peptide capture system. This system allows for reversible capture of synthetic peptide ligands on a biosensor chip surface, with the advantage that multiple antibody-antigen interactions can be analyzed using a single biosensor chip. This method has proven useful in the development of a synthetic peptide anti-Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) vaccine. Synthetic peptide ligands corresponding to the receptor binding domains of pilin from four strains of PA were conjugated to the E-coil strand of the heterodimeric coiled-coil domain and individually captured on the biosensor chip through dimerization with the immobilized K-coil strand. Polyclonal rabbit IgG raised against pilin epitopes was injected over the sensor chip surface for kinetic analysis of the antigen-antibody interaction. The kinetic rate constants, k(on) and k(off), and equilibrium association and dissociation constants, KA and KD, were calculated. Antibody affinities ranged from 1.14 x 10(-9) to 1.60 x 10(-5) M. The results suggest that the carrier protein and adjuvant used during immunization make a dramatic difference in antibody affinity and cross-reactivity. Antibodies raised against the PA strain K pilin epitope conjugated to keyhole limpet haemocyanin using Freund's adjuvant system were more broadly cross-reactive than antibodies raised against the same epitope conjugated to tetanus toxoid using Adjuvax adjuvant. The method described here is useful for detailed characterization of the interaction of polyclonal antibodies with a panel of synthetic peptide ligands with the objective of obtaining high affinity and cross-reactive antibodies in vaccine development.     

Method for estimating the single molecular affinity

Affinity constants (k(d), k(a), and K(D)) can be determined by methods that apply immobilized ligands such as immunoassays and label-free biosensor technologies. This article outlines a new surface plasmon resonance (SPR) array imaging method that yields affinity constants that can be considered as the best estimate of the affinity constant for single biomolecular interactions. Calculated rate (k(d) and k(a)) and dissociation equilibrium (K(D)) constants for various ligand densities and analyte concentrations are extrapolated to the K(D) at the zero response level (K(D)(R0)). By applying this method to an LGR5-exo-Fc-RSPO1-FH interaction couple, the K(D)(R0) was determined as 3.1 nM.     

Force history dependence of receptor-ligand dissociation

Receptor-ligand bonds that mediate cell adhesion are often subjected to forces that regulate their dissociation via modulating off-rates. Off-rates control how long receptor-ligand bonds last and how much force they withstand. One should therefore be able to determine off-rates from either bond lifetime or unbinding force measurements. However, substantial discrepancies exist between the force dependence of off-rates derived from the two types of measurements even for the same interactions, e.g., selectins dissociating from their ligands, which mediate the tethering and rolling of leukocytes on vascular surfaces during inflammation and immune surveillance. We used atomic force microscopy to measure survival times of P-selectin dissociating from P-selectin glycoprotein ligand 1 or from an antibody in both bond lifetime and unbinding force experiments. By a new method of data analysis, we showed that the discrepancies resulted from the assumption that off-rates were functions of force only. The off-rates derived from forced dissociation data depended not only on force but also on the history of force application. This finding provides a new paradigm for understanding how force regulates receptor-ligand interactions.     

Development of a surface plasmon resonance biosensor for the identification of Campylobacter jejuni

The purpose of this study was to develop a biosensor based on surface plasmon resonance (SPR) for the rapid identification of C. jejuni in broiler samples. We examined the specificity and sensitivity of commercial antibodies against C. jejuni with six Campylobacter strains and six non-Campylobacter bacterial strains. Antigen-antibody interactions were studied using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and a commercially available SPR biosensor platform (Spreeta). Campylobacter cells killed with 0.5% formalin had significant lower antibody reactivity when compared to live cells, or cells inactivated with 0.5% thimerosal or heat (70 degrees C for 3 min) using ELISA. The SPR biosensor showed a good sensitivity with commercial antibodies against C. jejuni at 10(3) CFU/ml and a low cross reactivity with Salmonella serotype typhimurium. The sensitivity of the SPR was similar when testing spiked broiler meat samples. However, research is still needed to reduce the high background observed when sampling meat products.     

Atomic force microscope-based single-molecule force spectroscopy of RNA unfolding

Single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) using the atomic force microscope (AFM) has emerged as an important tool for probing biomolecular interaction and exploring the forces, dynamics, and energy landscapes that underlie function and specificity of molecular interaction. These studies require attaching biomolecules on solid supports and AFM tips to measure unbinding forces between individual binding partners. Herein we describe efficient and robust protocols for probing RNA interaction by AFM and show their value on two well-known RNA regulators, the Rev-responsive element (RRE) from the HIV-1 genome and an adenine-sensing riboswitch. The results show the great potential of AFM–SMFS in the investigation of RNA molecular interactions, which will contribute to the development of bionanodevices sensing single RNA molecules.     

Kinetic analysis of the mass transport limited interaction between the tyrosine kinase lck SH2 domain and a phosphorylated peptide studied by a new cuvette-based surface plasmon resonance instrument

We explored the use of a newly developed cuvette-based surface plasmon resonance (SPR) instrument (IBIS) to study peptide-protein interactions. We studied the interaction between the SH2 domain of lck and a phosphotyrosine peptide EPQY*EEIPIYL which was immobilized on a sensor chip. No indications for mass transport limitation (MTL) were observed when standard kinetic approaches were used. However, addition of competing peptide during dissociation revealed a high extent of rebinding. A dissociation rate constant (k(d)) of 0.6+/-0.1 s(-1) was obtained in the presence of large amounts of peptide. A simple bimolecular binding model, applying second-order kinetics for the cuvette system, could not adequately describe the data. Fits were improved upon including a step in the model which describes diffusion of the SH2 domain from the bulk to the sensor, especially for a surface with high binding capacity. From experiments in glycerol-containing buffers, it appeared that the diffusion rate decreased with higher viscosity. It is demonstrated that MTL during association and dissociation can be described by the same diffusion rate. A binding constant (K(D)) of 5.9+/-0.8 nM was obtained from the SPR equilibrium signals by fitting to a Langmuir binding isotherm, with correction for loss of free analyte due to binding. An association rate constant k(a) of 1.1(+/-0.2)x10(8) M(-1) x s(-1) was obtained from k(d)/K(D). The values for k(a) and k(d) obtained in this way were 2-3 orders larger than that from standard kinetic analysis, ignoring MTL. We conclude that in a cuvette the extent of MTL is comparable to that in a flow system.     

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) as a tool for antibody conjugate analysis

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) analysis was used to assess the immunoreactivity of anti-biotin (4) and anti-fluorescein (5) monoclonal antibody after conjugation with the N-hydroxysuccinimide ester of acridinium-9-carboxamide 1. Only minor changes in the apparent equilibrium dissociation constants of the antibody conjugates for their ligands resulted from the conjugation process. However, comparison of the initial binding rate of the conjugates with their ligands with those of the unmodified antibodies over a range of concentrations showed that the antibody conjugates were partially inactivated. The anti-fluorescein conjugates retained at least 90% of their immunoreactivity over the range of modification tested, while anti-biotin conjugates showed a progressive loss of reactivity with increased substitution by the label.     

Probing Interactions within the synaptic DNA-SfiI complex by AFM force spectroscopy

SfiI belongs to a family of restriction enzymes that function as tetramers, binding two recognition regions for the DNA cleavage reaction. The SfiI protein is an attractive and convenient model for studying synaptic complexes between DNA and proteins capable of site-specific binding. The enzymatic action of SfiI has been very well characterized. However, the properties of the complex before the cleavage reaction are not clear. We used single-molecule force spectroscopy to analyze the strength of interactions within the SfiI-DNA complex. In these experiments, the stability of the synaptic complex formed by the enzyme and two DNA duplexes was probed in a series of approach-retraction cycles. In order to do this, one duplex was tethered to the surface and the other was tethered to the probe. The complex was formed by the protein present in the solution. An alternative setup, in which the protein was anchored to the surface, allowed us to probe the stability of the complex formed with only one duplex in the approach-retraction experiments, with the duplex immobilized at the probe tip. Both types of complexes are characterized by similar rupture forces. The stability of the complex was determined by measuring the dependence of rupture forces on force loading rates (dynamic force spectroscopy) and the results suggest that the dissociation reaction of the SfiI-DNA complex has a single energy barrier along the dissociation path. Dynamic force spectroscopy was instrumental in revealing the role of the 5 bp spacer region within the palindromic recognition site on DNA-SfiI in the stability of the complex. The data show that, although the change of non-specific sequence does not alter the position of the activation barrier, it changes values of the off rates significantly.     

Molecular recognition force spectroscopy study of the dynamic interaction between aptamer GBI‐10 and extracellular matrix protein tenascin‐C on human glioblastoma cell

Molecular recognition force spectroscopy (MR‐FS) was applied to investigate the dynamic interaction between aptamer GBI‐10 and tenascin‐C (TN‐C) on human glioblastoma cell surface at single‐molecule level. The unbinding force between aptamer GBI‐10 and TN‐C was 39 pN at the loading rate of 0.3 nN sec^?1. A series of kinetic parameters concerning interaction process such as the unbinding force f_u, the association rate constant k_on, dissociation rate constant at zero force k_off, and dissociation constant K_D for aptamer GBI‐10/TN‐C complexes were acquired. In addition, the interaction of aptamer GBI‐10 with TN‐C depended on the presence of Mg²⁺. This work demonstrates that MR‐FS can be used as an attractive tool for exploring the interaction forces and dynamic process of aptamer and ligand at the single‐molecule level. As a future perspective, MR‐FS may be used as a potential diagnostic and therapeutic tool by combining with other techniques. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.