Dose-rate effects of gamma-ray-induced mutations in cultured mammalian cells

The dose-rate dependency of three radiobiological parameters, cell killing and mutations resistant to 6-thioguanine (6-TG^r) and to methotrexate (MTX^r), were studied in populations of mouse L5178Y cells exposed to gamma-rays. when the dose rate was reduced from 50 rad/min to 0.8 rad/min, the shape of the dose—response curves changed from sigmoidal to exponential for cell killing, from upward concave to linear in 6-TG^r mutations and remained linear in MTX^r mutations. A linear quadratic model appears capable of explaining the cell killing and 6-TG^r mutations but not the MTX^r mutations.The declining patterns of induced mutation frequencies of 6-TG^r and MTX^r with decreasing dose rate seem to be similar. The addition of DMSO resulted in protection of cells from cell killing, 6-TG^r and MTX^r mutations with acute exposure, but had little effect with chronic exposure. The reduction of mutation frequency of the 6-TG^r marker with chronic exposure was eliminated by holding cells in ice-cold condition during irradiation. These results suggest that there may be two components of induced mutation. One results primarily from repairable damage induced by the indirect action of radiation and shows a clear dose-rate dependency. The other is mainly from non-repairable damage by the direct action of radiation and is only slightly dose rate-dependent. Under chronic exposure conditions, the latter may predominate.     

Life shortening in BALB/c mice following brief, protracted, or fractionated exposures to neutrons

The effects of acute, protracted, or fractionated exposures to fission neutrons on survival times of female BALB/c mice were examined and compared. Mice were given single, brief exposures or exposures given in equal fractions at either 1- or 30-day intervals to doses of 0, 2.5, 5, 10, 20, 50, and 200 rad at the Health Physics Research Reactor (HPRR) or protracted exposures at rates ranging from 0.1 to 10 rad/day using a moderated 252Cf source to doses of 0, 2.5, 5, 10, 20, and 40 rad. The 252Cf source was moderated to have a similar spectron to that of the HPRR facility. After single or fractionated exposures the extent of life shortening increased rapidly over the 0-50 rad range and then began the plateau. No simple model adequately described the dose response over this entire dose range. Over the 0-50 rad dose range for exposures at the HPRR and over the 0-40 rad dose range for protracted exposures the dose response could be adequately described by either a linear model or a square root of the dose regression model except when the dose was fractionated using a 30-day interval. In this instance a linear model provided an adequate fit while a square root of the dose model could be rejected. No increase in effectiveness after fractionation or protraction was observed for neutron-induced life shortening at doses below 50 rad, while at 50 and 200 rad an increase in effectiveness was observed in this and in previous studies. These data were interpreted to suggest that in the dose range below 20-40 rad the dose-effect curve for life shortening may be linear and begins to flatten at higher doses rather than continuously bending at low doses.     

Mutation induction by different dose rates of gamma rays in radiation-sensitive mutants of mouse leukemia cells

Induction of cell killing and mutation to 6-thioguanine resistance was examined in a radiation-sensitive mutant strain LX830 of mouse leukemia cells following gamma irradiation at dose rates of 30 Gy/h (acute), 20 cGy/h (low dose rate), and 6.2 mGy/h (very low dose rate). LX830 cells were hypersensitive to killing by acute gamma rays. A slight but significant increase was observed in cell survival with decreasing dose rate down to 6.2 mGy/h, where the survival leveled off above certain total doses. The cells were also hypersensitive to mutation induction compared to the wild type. The mutation frequency increased linearly with increasing dose for all dose rates. No significant difference was observed in the frequency of induced mutations versus total dose at the three different dose rates so that the mutation frequency in LX830 cells at 6.2 mGy/h was not significantly different from that for moderate or acute irradiation.     

Dose-rate effects of ethyl methanesulfonate on survival and mutation induction in cultured Chinese hamster cells

The dose-rate effects of ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) on the survival and induction of mutations in Chinese hamster Don cells were investigated. The most effective time of exposure to EMS for reducing the surviving fraction of cells was 4 h, shorter and longer exposure times being less effective. The threshold or minimal concentration of EMS giving a surviving fraction of 0.5 was 0.05 mg/ml. The minimal effective time of exposure to EMS for cell death was 1 h. Corrected survival curves showed that longer exposure times at lower dose rates of EMS had less cytotoxic effect than shorter exposure times at higher dose rates.After exposure of Don cells to various doses of EMS for various times, the frequencies of mutations resistant to 6-thioguanine (6TG) were measured. An exposure time of 4 h produced a lower mutation frequency than shorter or longer exposure times that resulted in the same surviving fraction of cells. An exposure time of 20 h produced the highest induced mutation frequency.This system using cultured Chinese hamster cells should be useful as a sensitive procedure for detecting the mutagenic actions of chemicals.     

Chromosome aberration yields in human lymphocytes induced by fractionated doses of x-radiation.

Unstimulated (G0) human peripheral blood lymphocytes were exposed at 37 degrees C to doses of 200 or 500 rad of X-rays delivered in two equal fractions. The dose fractions were separated by intervals of up to 7 h in the 200 rad study and up to 48 h for 500 rad. In both studies the mean levels of dicentrics and total unstable aberrations began to decline when fractions were delivered with intervals of greater than 2 h. With 200 rad the yield had decreased to an additive baseline (i.e. equal to only twice the yield of a single 100-rad fraction) by an interval of 4 h. Following 500 rad the yield declined until 8 h and then remained 20% above the additive baseline even when 48 h separated the fractions. Possible explanations for this discrepancy are discussed. In a second experiment PHA stimulated lymphocyte cultures were exposed to 2 doses of 125 rad of X-rays up to 7 h apart in an attempt to demonstrate the late peak in aberration yields originally reported by Lane [5]. Control cultures received unsplit doses of 250 rad at the time of the corresponding second 125-rad fraction. No evidence of a late peak in dicentric yield was observed. The yield remained approximately the same irrespective of the time interval between fractions but these split dose yields were significantly different from the accompanying unsplit controls.     

The induction by X-rays of chromosome aberrations in male Guinea-pigs and golden hamsters. IV. Dose response for spermatogonia treated with fractionated doses.

The effect of dose fractionation on the induction of translocations by 400 and 600 rad X-rays in spermatogonia of guinea-pigs and hamsters was investigated cytologically. Three types of fractionation were used, dividing the dose into (a) two equal fractions 24 h apart, (b) two equal fractions 8 weeks apart, and (c) eight or twelve equal fractions of 50 rad, at intervals of one week. The two species responded similarly throughout, but gave lower translocation yields than the mouse. The effects of the first and third types of fractionation were similar to those described previously in the mouse, and suggested that a first radiation dose modifies the spermatogonial population so that its sensitivity to a dose 24 h later is altered, and that repeated radiation doses result in development of resistance to translocation induction. After 8-week fractionation the results suggested that in guinea-pigs and hamsters the spermatogonial population had not returned to normal by 8 weeks after the first dose, whereas in the mouse normal sensitivity had returned by this time. The results, reported previously, of single doses of X-rays suggest that the spermatogonial population consists of fractionated doses in the mouse suggest that the sensitive and resistant types represent different phases of the same cell type rather than two distinct types of cell. In the guinea-pig and hamster this question remains open.     

Split-dose exposure to N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine in BALB/3T3 C1 a31-1-1 cells: evidence of DNA repair by alkaline elution without changes in cell survival, mutation and transformation rates

Dose fractionation of a direct-acting chemical carcinogen, the alkylating agent N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), was studied for its concurrent effects on survival, DNA damage and repair, ouabain resistance (Ouar) mutations and neoplastic transformation, in the mouse embryo cell line BALB/3T3 C1A31-1-1. MNNG doses of 0.5, 1 and 2 micrograms/ml were added to the cells either as a single exposure or in two equal fractions separated by 1, 3 or 5 h intervals. No significant difference in cytotoxicity was found when single and split-dose treatments were compared. No recovery from sublethal damage was therefore found in this cell line by split-dose administration of MNNG, although such an effect was found when the same cell line was treated with single and split doses of X-rays. Repair of DNA damage as measured by alkaline elution was studied up to 24 h after a single MNNG exposure (0.5 micrograms/ml). DNA repair was rapid during the first 5 h after treatment and slow thereafter. DNA damage detected after split doses of MNNG at 1 and 5 h intervals was significantly lower than after a corresponding single dose. With both single and split doses, rejoining of single-strand breaks (ssb) was nearly complete after 24 h of repair time. Ouar mutation and neoplastic transformation frequencies were determined for single and split doses of MNNG with the second treatment being given during (1 h) or after (5 h) the period of rapid DNA repair. No significant differences in either effect were detected for dose splitting at any tested dose.     

Cytogenetic effects of fractionated or unfractionated X-ray exposures to mouse spermatogonia

The induction of chromosomal aberrations in mouse spermatogonia was studied, after single (50 and 100 rad) and fractionated doses (50 + 50 rad spaced 24 h apart), a short time after irradiation, by analysis of mitotic stages. From 17 to 21 h after the second fraction of the dose, the recorded frequencies of chromosomal deletions and exchanges were fully additive when compared with single “control” doses. Thus there was no suggestion of any sensitization effect of the first exposure. Possible reasons for this are discussed.     

The effect of dose rate on the frequency of specific-locus mutations induced in mouse spermatogonia is restricted to larger lesions; a retrospective analysis of historical data

A series of 19 large-scale germ-cell mutagenesis experiments conducted several decades ago led to the conclusion that low-LET radiation delivered to mouse spermatogonia at dose rates of 0.8 R/min and below induced only about one-third as many specific-locus mutations as did single, acute exposures at 24 R/min and above. A two-hit origin of the mutations was deemed unlikely in view of the then prevailing evidence for the small size of genetic lesions in spermatogonia. Instead, the dose-rate effect was hypothesized to be the result of a repair system that exists in spermatogonia, but not in more mature male reproductive cells. More recent genetic and molecular studies on the marker genes have identified the phenotypes associated with specific states of the mutant chromosomes, and it is now possible retrospectively to classify individual past mutations as "large lesions" or "other lesions". The mutation-frequency difference between high and low dose rates is restricted to the large lesion mutations, for which the dose-curve slopes differ by a factor exceeding 3.4. For other lesion mutations, there is essentially no difference between the slopes for protracted and acute irradiations; induced other lesions frequencies per unit dose remain similar for dose rates ranging over more than 7 orders of magnitude. For large lesions, these values rise sharply at dose rates >0.8 R/min, though they remain similar within the whole range of protracted doses, failing to provide evidence for a threshold dose rate. The downward bend at high doses that had been noted for X-ray-induced specific-locus mutations as a whole and ascribed to a positive correlation between spermatogonial death and mutation load is now found to be restricted to large lesion mutations. There is a marked difference between the mutation spectra (distributions among the seven loci) for large lesions and other lesions. Within each class, however, the spectra are similar for acute and protracted irradiation.     

Induction of lethal mutations in female mice by 9 generations of gamma-irradiation during foetal development.

Female CBA mice were chronically gamma-irradiated in utero during either of two periods, the 10th to 14th days or the 14th to 18th days of gestation. The doses administered were 34 rad/generation in the earlier group and 160 rad/generation in the latter with dose rates of 0.3 rad/h and 1.7 rad/h, respectively. The doses were given through 9 generations. The effect of the irradiation was expressed as an increased frequency in the rate of recessive lethal equivalents by just above 4%. This corresponds to a mutation rate of 1.5 X 10(-4) mutation/rad/genome in the animals irradiated during the 10th to 14th gestational days and 0.3 X 10(-4) mutation/rad/genome in the 14th to 18th day group. As in earlier investigations, neither dominant mutations nor dominance effects of induced recessive lethal equivalents were found.     

X-ray-induced translocations in spermatoginia II. Fractionation responses in mice

The dose-response curve for reciprocal translocations induced by X-rays in spermatognial stem cells, and observed in primary spermatocytes of mice, is “hymp-shaped”, with a maximum yield at about 600 R. To test the hypothesis that the decrease in yield with increasing dose above 600 R is a consequence of the different sensitivities of cells in different stages of the cell cycle to both cell killing and chromosome aberration induction, several fractionation experiments were carried out.A total dose of 2800 R was given in repeated doses of 400 R, separated by 8-week intervals. The yield of translocations is that expected for additivity; for example, the yield at 1600 R is approximately equal to that for four separate 400-R doses.When the total dose (500 R) which gives a translocation yield on the ascending part of the dose-response curve is given as two equal fractions separated by intervals of 30, 90, or 150 min, the translocation yield decreases with increasing interval. However, when a total dose (1000 R) which would give a translocation yield on the descending part of the dose-response curve is given in two equal fractions separated by intervals of from 30 min to 6 weeks, the response is different; the translocation yield increases with intervals up to 18 h, then decreases with intervals up to 4 weeks, and finally increases again to a yield equal to additivity with an interval of 6 weeks. These changes in translocation yield with changes in interval between the two doses are explained in terms of the differential sensitivity of cells to killing and aberration induction in the different phases of the cell cycle, and by assuming that the cells surviving the first dose and repopulating the testis different cycle characteristics from normal cells.     

Multifraction radiation response of mouse lung

The response of mouse lung to repeated doses of 60Co gamma-rays of as low as 115 cGy per fraction was measured using death from pneumonitis between 80 and 120 days after irradiation as the endpoint. A fractionation interval of 3 h was maintained for most regimens but in the longer experiments some 12 h intervals were introduced for logistic reasons. The longest overall duration (for a 43 fraction regimen) was 8 days. The total doses required to produce 50 per cent mortality increased continuously as dose/fraction was decreased, even from 160 to 115 cGy per fraction. Of clinical relevance, the steepness of the isoeffect curve over the dose range 115-500 cGy indicates that the lung shows greater sparing from dose fractionation than is characteristic of more rapidly-responding normal tissues, resembling, in this respect, other more slowly-responding tissues such as spinal cord. The plot of the reciprocal of the LD50 values as a function of dose per fraction was non-linear, suggesting that a linear quadratic dose response model may not be appropriate or that repair of cellular injury in lung is not complete in 3 h, or both.     

Effects of dose rate and dose fractionation of irradiation on pulmonary alveolar macrophage colony-forming cells

We have studied the effects of dose rate and dose fractionation on murine pulmonary alveolar macrophage colony-forming cells (AL-CFC). The dose-response curve of AL-CFC to ionizing irradiation has a Dq of about 100 rad, reflecting the cells' ability to repair sublethal damage. For comparison, we investigated the effect of dose schedule on the committed bone marrow stem cells for both granulocytes and monocytes (GM-CFC) since their dose-response curve has a very small shoulder. We compared the results of dose rates of 3 and 10 rad/min to those obtained with a dose rate of 85 rad/min. We determined survival after giving 100, 300, and 500 rad either in vivo or in vitro. A significant dose rate effect was observed. To study the effect of dose fractionation, a total of 600 rad was given either as a single fraction, three fractions of 200 rad on 3 consecutive days, or six fractions of 100 rad in 3 days. The most dramatic effect was seen in the group that received six 100-rad fractions. No reduction in the number of AL-CFC was seen in this group. In sharp contrast, only a minimal dose schedule effect was observed with GM-CFC.     

Relative biological efficiency for the induction of various gene mutations in normal and enriched with 10B Tradescantia cells by neutrons from 252Cf source

The effectiveness of neutrons from a Californium-252 source in the induction of various abnormalities in the Tradescantia clone 4430 stamen hair cells (Trad-SH assay) were studied. A special attention was paid to check whether any enhancement in effects is visible in the cells enriched with boron ions. Inflorescences, normal or pretreated with chemicals containing boron, were irradiated in the air with neutrons from a 252Cf source at KAERI, Taejon, Korea. To estimate the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of the beam under the study, numbers of Tradescantia inflorescence without chemical pretreatment were irradiated with various doses of X-rays. The ranges of radiation doses used for neutrons were 0-1.0Gy and for X-rays 0-0.5Gy. Following the culturing according to standard procedures screening of gene and lethal mutations in somatic cells of stamen hairs was done in the extended period, between days 7 and 19 after exposures. Maximal RBE values for the induction of pink, colorless and lethal mutations were evaluated from comparison of the slopes in linear parts of the dose response curves obtained after irradiation with X-rays and californium source. The RBE(max) value or the induction of gene mutation was estimated as 7.2 comparing the value 5.6 in the studies reported earlier. The comparison of dose-response curves and its alteration, due to changes in the cells and plants environment during and after irradiation, explains the observed differences. Inflorescence pretreated with borax responded to neutrons differently depending on the biological end points. Although, for the induction of pink mutations no significant difference was observed, though, in the case of cell lethality, pretreated with boron ion plants have shoved a statistically significant increase of the RBE value from 5.5 to 34.7, and in the case of colorless mutations from 1.6 to 5.6.     

Models and assumptions underlying genetic risk assessment

Various methods employed for estimating the genetic risks of radiation are reviewed. With the doubling-dose method, genetic damage is expressed as an increase in cases of known genetic disease. The actual doubling dose is based on figures obtained with the mouse. There have been no recent data on induced mutation frequencies. Recent results suggest that the prevalence figure for multifactorial disease may be at least one order of magnitude higher than before. Various assumptions underlying the doubling-dose concept are discussed in the light of recent findings on: (1) spontaneous mutations resulting from insertion elements, and (2) the comparability between spontaneous and induced mutations. The so-called direct method makes use of figures for induction of dominant mutations affecting the skeleton and the lens of the eye in the mouse, and of translocation induction in monkeys. Induction rates are converted to overall rates of induced dominant effects in man by applying certain assumptions. The proportionality between dose and effect is the basis for all genetic risk assessments. The possible significance of data on human lymphocytes indicating a threshold below 4 rad and the induction of repair enzymes by low radiation doses is discussed. The parallelogram approach is based on the principle that estimates can be obtained on the amount of genetic damage that cannot always be assessed directly. Thus mutations in mouse germ cells can be predicted by using mutation frequencies in cultured mammalian cells and O6-ethylguanine adducts. Measurement of haemoglobin mutations in human and mouse erythrocytes, and of HPRT-deficient mutations in lymphocytes of man and mouse should make more precise estimates of mutation frequencies in human germ cells possible. The development of a database on mutations in somatic cells of the mouse, their induction frequencies and molecular nature are considered an important priority. Used in combination with mouse germ-cell mutation frequencies, they should enable more precise risk estimates on the basis of mutations in somatic cells of man.     

Equivalence of pulsed-dose-rate to low-dose-rate irradiation in tumor and normal cell lines

To determine whether different fractionation schemes could simulate low-dose-rate irradiation, ovarian cells of the carcinoma cell lines A2780s (radiosensitive) and A2780cp (radioresistant) and AG1522 normal human fibroblasts were irradiated in vitro using different fraction sizes and intervals between fractions with an overall average dose rate of 0.53 Gy/h. For the resistant cell line, the three fractionation schemes, 0.53 Gy given every hour, 1.1 Gy every 2 h, and 1.6 Gy every 3 h, were equivalent to low dose rate (0.53 Gy/h). Two larger fraction sizes, 2.1 Gy every 4 h and 3.2 Gy every 6 h, resulted in lower survival than that after low-dose-rate irradiation for the resistant cell line, suggesting incomplete repair of radiation damage due to the larger fraction sizes. The survival for the sensitive cell line was lower at small doses, but then it increased until it was equivalent to that after low-dose-rate irradiation for some fractionation schemes. The sensitive cell line showed equivalence only with the 1.6-Gy fraction every 3 h, although 0.53 Gy every 1 h and 1.1 Gy every 2 h showed equivalence at lower doses. This cell line also showed an adaptive response. The normal cell line showed a sensitization to the pulsed-dose-rate schemes compared to low-dose-rate irradiation. These data indicate that the response to pulsed-dose-rate irradiation is dependent on the cell line and that compared to the response to low-dose-rate irradiation, it shows some equivalence with the resistant carcinoma cell line, an adaptive response with the parental carcinoma cell line, and sensitization with the normal cells. Therefore, further evaluation is required before implementing pulsed-dose-rate irradiation in the clinic.     

Lack of Chemically Induced Mutation in Repair-Deficient Mutants of Yeast

Two genes, rad6 and rad9, that confer radiation sensitivity in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae also greatly reduce the frequency of chemically-induced reversions of a tester mutant cyc1-131, which is a chain initiation mutant in the structural gene determining iso-1-cytochrome c. Mutations induced by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), diethyl sulfate (DES), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), dimethyl sulfate (DMS), nitroquinoline oxide (NQO), nitrosoguanidine (NTG), nitrogen mustard (HN2), beta-propiolactone, and tritiated uridine, as well as mutations induced by ultraviolet light (UV) and ionizing radiation were greatly diminished in strains homozygous for either the rad6 or rad9 gene. Nitrous acid and nitrosoimidazolidone (NIL), on the other hand, were highly mutagenic in these repair-deficient mutants, and at low doses, these mutagens acted with about the same efficiency as in the normal RAD strain. At high doses of either nitrous acid or NIL, however, reversion frequencies were significantly reduced in the two rad mutants compared to normal strains. Although both rad mutants are immutable to about the same extent, the rad9 strains tend to be less sensitive to the lethal effect of chemical mutagens than rad6 strains. It is concluded that yeast requires a functional repair system for mutation induction by chemical agents.     

Serial analysis of chromosomal aberrations and proliferation kinetics of mouse spermatogonia after single or fractionated X-ray exposures

Dose-fractionation studies on translocation induction in stem-cell spermatogonia of mice, as measured by spermatocyte analysis many cell generations after irradiation, revealed that a small conditioning dose of X-rays sensitizes the stem cells to the induction of translocations by a second dose 24 h later (Van Buul and Léonard, 1974, 1980). To find out whether such sensitization effects also occur at other spermatogonial stages, a comparison was made of the effects of single (50, 100 and 150 rad) and fractionated (100 + 50 rad, with 24 h in between) doses of X-rays on the induction of chromosomal aberrations in spermatogonia by analysing spermatogonial metaphases shortly after irradiation at multiple sampling times (0–48 h; every 4 h). In addition, the kinetics of spermatogonial proliferation was studied by using, in vivo, a BrdU chromosome-labelling procedure. The recorded frequencies of chromosomal aberrations did not indicate any sensitization effect of dose fractionation. It is concluded that the sensitization effects, as observed for chromosomal aberrations in male premeiotic germ cells, are characteristic for the stem-cell spermatogonia and do not occur in the more differentiated spermatogonia.     

Search for mutations altering protein charge and/or function in children of atomic bomb survivors: final report.

A sample of (1) children whose parents had been proximally exposed (i.e., less than 2,000 m from the hypocenter) at the time of the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and (2) a suitable comparison group have been examined for the occurrence of mutations altering the electrophoretic mobility or activity of a series of 30 proteins. The examination of the equivalent of 667,404 locus products in the children of proximally exposed persons yielded three mutations altering electrophoretic mobility; the corresponding figure for the comparison group was three mutations in 466,881 tests. The examination of a subset of 60,529 locus products for loss of enzyme activity in the children of proximally exposed persons yielded one mutation; no mutations were encountered in 61,741 determinations on the children of the comparison group. When these two series are compared, the mutation rate observed in the children of proximally exposed persons is thus 0.60 x 10(-5)/locus/generation, with 95% confidence intervals between 0.2 and 1.5 x 10(-5), and that in the comparison children is 0.64 x 10(-5)/locus/generation, with 95% intervals between 0.1 and 1.9 x 10(-5). The average conjoint gonad doses for the proximally exposed parents are estimated to be 0.437 Gy of gamma radiation and 0.002 Gy of neutron radiation. If a relative biological effectiveness of 20 is assigned to the neutron radiation, the combined total gonad dose for the parents becomes 0.477 Sv. (Organ absorbed doses are expressed in gray [1 Gy = 100 rad]; where dose is a mixture of gamma and neutron radiation, it is necessary because of the differing relative biological effectiveness of gamma and neutron radiation to express the combined gamma-neutron gonad exposures in sieverts [1 Sv = 100 rem]).     

Specific locus mutation rates after repeated small radiation doses to mouse oocytes

When female mice were given a dose of 20 × 10 rad X-rays, the specific locus mutation rate among offspring conceived up to 7 weeks after the end of treatment was 1/39887 or 0.18·10⁻⁷/rad/locus, whereas when the same total dose of 200 rad was given in a single exposure the mutation rate was 9/34813 or 1.85·10¹⁰⁻⁷/rad/locus. The lower mutation rate after the 20 × 10 rad dose was obtained whether the total of 200 rad was given over a period of 5 days or 4 weeks, and if only young conceived in the first 20 days, rather than 7 weeks, were considered. It is suggested that each 10 rad fraction had the same small effect, and hence that these results confirm and extend Russell's previous finding that the dose-response relationship for specific locus mutations in females is curved.