Exploration of molecular interactions in cholesterol superlattices: effect of multibody interactions

Experimental evidences have indicated that cholesterol may adapt highly regular lateral distributions (i.e., superlattices) in a phospholipid bilayer. We investigated the formations of superlattices at cholesterol mole fraction of 0.154, 0.25, 0.40, and 0.5 using Monte Carlo simulation. We found that in general, conventional pairwise-additive interactions cannot produce superlattices. Instead, a multibody (nonpairwise) interaction is required. Cholesterol superlattice formation reveals that although the overall interaction between cholesterol and phospholipids is favorable, it contains two large opposing components: an interaction favoring cholesterol-phospholipid mixing and an unfavorable acyl chain multibody interaction that increases nonlinearly with the number of cholesterol contacts. The magnitudes of interactions are in the order of kT. The physical origins of these interactions can be explained by our umbrella model. They most likely come from the requirement for polar phospholipid headgroups to cover the nonpolar cholesterol to avoid the exposure of cholesterol to water and from the sharp decreasing of acyl chain conformation entropy due to cholesterol contact. This study together with our previous work demonstrate that the driving force of cholesterol-phospholipid mixing is a hydrophobic interaction, and multibody interactions dominate others over a wide range of cholesterol concentration.     

On the mechanism of cholesterol interaction with apolipoproteins A-I and E.

It is shown that cholesterol may interact with some substances containing the guanidine group (guanidine itself, arginine, metformin and dodecylguanidine bromide) and with arginine-rich proteins--apoproteins A-I and E. In the latter case the interaction produces the formation of cholesterol-apoprotein complexes. Analysis of such complexes has shown that one apo A-I molecule binds 17-22 and one apo E molecule binds 30-35 sterol molecules, which approximately corresponds to the amount of arginine residues in these proteins. Formation of cholesterol-apoprotein complexes has been suggested to occur due to: (1) formation of hydrogen bond and/or ion-dipole interaction between cholesterol hydroxyl and guanidine groups of the apoprotein arginine residues and (2) hydrophobic interaction of the cholesterol aliphatic chain with nonpolar side chains of the amino acids occupying the third position from arginine in the protein molecule.     

Binding of cholesterol by apolipoproteins A-I and E]

It was shown that cholesterol can interact with some guanidine group-containing compounds (guanidine proper, arginine, metformine and dodecylguanidine bromide) as well as with the arginine-rich proteins--apoproteins A-1 and E. In the latter case this interaction results in the formation of cholesterol-apoprotein complexes. Analysis of such complexes revealed that one apo-A-1 molecule binds 17-22, whereas one apo-E molecule--30-35 sterol molecules, which approximately correspondence to the amount of arginine residues in these proteins. The formation of cholesterol-apoprotein complexes seems to be due to: (1) formation of hydrogen bonds and ion-dipole interactions between the hydroxyl groups of cholesterol and the guanidine groups of the apoprotein arginine residues and, presumably, the carboxylic groups of aspartic or glutamic acids, eventually resulting in the production of chelate complexes; (2) hydrophobic interaction of the cholesterol aliphatic chain with the nonpolar side chains of the amino acids occupying the third position from arginine in the protein molecule.     

Probes for studying cholesterol binding and cell biology

Cholesterol is a multifunctional lipid in eukaryotic cells. It regulates the physical state of the phospholipid bilayer, is crucially involved in the formation of membrane microdomains, affects the activity of many membrane proteins, and is the precursor for steroid hormones and bile acids. Thus, cholesterol plays a profound role in the physiology and pathophysiology of eukaryotic cells. The cholesterol molecule has achieved evolutionary perfection to fulfill its different functions in membrane organization. Here, we review basic approaches to explore the interaction of cholesterol with proteins, with a particular focus on the high diversity of fluorescent and photoreactive cholesterol probes available today.     

Regulation of cholesterol efflux from macrophages

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The lipid efflux pathway is important for both HDL formation and the reverse cholesterol transport pathway. This review is focused on recent findings on the mechanism of lipid efflux and its regulation, particularly in macrophages. RECENT FINDINGS: Significant progress has been made on understanding the sequence of events that accompany the interaction of apolipoproteins A-I with cell surface ATP-binding cassette transporter A1 and its subsequent lipidation. Continued research on the regulation of ATP-binding cassette transporter A1 and ATP-binding cassette transporter G1 expression and traffic has also generated new paradigms for the control of lipid efflux from macrophages and its contribution to reverse cholesterol transport. In addition, the mobilization of cholesteryl esters from lipid droplets represents a new step in the control of cholesterol efflux. SUMMARY: The synergy between lipid transporters is a work in progress, but its importance in reverse cholesterol transport is clear. The regulation of efflux implies both the regulation of relevant transporters and the cellular trafficking of cholesterol.     

Incorporation of cholesterol into serum high density lipoprotein apoprotein and recombinants

The uptake of cholesterol (CHL) by serum high density lipoprotein (HDL) delipidated apoproteins and phospholipid-apoprotein recombinants has been studied with two methods; by incubation with Celite-dispersed cholesterol or with cholesterol crystals. The apoproteins bind very small amounts of cholesterol with a maximum of about 6 micrograms/mg apoprotein. Recombinants with dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) or egg phosphatidylcholine (EPC) as phospholipid component gave similar values for cholesterol uptake. The initial rate for uptake from Celite-cholesterol by recombinants was high (0.1 mol cholesterol/mol phospholipid/h) and somewhat higher than that for phospholipid vesicles. The maximal uptake was by gel filtration shown to depend on the size of the complexes with values about 0.95 mol cholesterol per phospholipid for vesicular complexes, 0.75 for discoidal complexes and between 0.5 and 0.2 for small 'protein-rich' complexes. During the incubation of recombinants with cholesterol there was considerable decomposition of discoidal complexes and formation of larger ones. The results show that phospholipid-apoprotein complexes are efficient acceptors for cholesterol but also that about 25% of the phospholipid in the discoidal complexes is excluded from interaction with cholesterol by interaction with apoprotein.     

Aspirin inhibits formation of cholesterol rafts in fluid lipid membranes

Aspirin and other non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs have a high affinity for phospholipid membranes, altering their structure and biophysical properties. Aspirin has been shown to partition into the lipid head groups, thereby increasing membrane fluidity. Cholesterol is another well known mediator of membrane fluidity, in turn increasing membrane stiffness. As well, cholesterol is believed to distribute unevenly within lipid membranes leading to the formation of lipid rafts or plaques. In many studies, aspirin has increased positive outcomes for patients with high cholesterol. We are interested if these effects may be, at least partially, the result of a non-specific interaction between aspirin and cholesterol in lipid membranes.We have studied the effect of aspirin on the organization of 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) membranes containing cholesterol. Through Langmuir–Blodgett experiments we show that aspirin increases the area per lipid and decreases compressibility at 32.5 mol% cholesterol, leading to a significant increase of fluidity of the membranes. Differential scanning calorimetry provides evidence for the formation of meta-stable structures in the presence of aspirin. The molecular organization of lipids, cholesterol and aspirin was studied using neutron diffraction. While the formation of rafts has been reported in binary DPPC/cholesterol membranes, aspirin was found to locally disrupt membrane organization and lead to the frustration of raft formation. Our results suggest that aspirin is able to directly oppose the formation of cholesterol structures through non-specific interactions with lipid membranes.     

Interactions of band 3-protein from human erythrocyte membranes with cholesterol and cholesterol analogues

The interaction between cholesterol and band 3-protein from human erythrocyte membranes was studied by incorporating the solubilized protein into monolayers of cholesterol and related sterols at the air-water interface and measuring the changes in surface pressure which accompanied protein incorporation. The following results were obtained: 1) Band 3-protein shows a very strong interaction with cholesterol monolayers. Both apolar and polar bonds contribute to this interaction. 2) Steroids with a structure slightly different from that of cholesterol (especially with respect to the polar group and the side chain) in most cases show a reduced affinity for band 3-protein. Thus, the protein-sterol interaction is highly specific. It is assumed that the protein-cholesterol interaction can be subidivided into two parts: an unspecific one which results from contributions from several sterol molecules, and a specific one which is due to the high affinity binding of the protein and cholesterol. The structural element responsible for the high affinity interaction is assumed to be a sterol-binding niche on the surface of band 3-protein. The sterol is thought to be held in the niche by a hydrogen bond at its polar head and a variety of hydrophobic bonds along its ring system and side chain.     

The interaction of cholesterol absorption and cholesterol synthesis in man

The total miscible pool of cholesterol in the body is determined largely by the interaction of cholesterol absorption and synthesis. In the present study we have examined the net effects of this interplay in one normal and five hypercholesteremic subjects when various amounts of cholesterol were made available for absorption. Feeding large amounts of cholesterol to the normocholesteremic patient caused an expansion of body pools by as much as 20 g before the amount of cholesterol re-excreted as fecal neutral steroids each day came into balance with the cholesterol absorbed from the diet. There was no detectable decrease in total body synthesis of cholesterol nor any increase in conversion of cholesterol into bile acids. However, feedback control of cholesterol synthesis was demonstrable when large quantities of plant sterols were fed: in the hypercholesteremic patients thus studied, the absorption of both endogenous and exogenous cholesterol was then greatly reduced, and a compensatory increase in synthesis occurred. Thus, the plant sterol experiments, but not the cholesterol feeding experiment, demonstrated that feedback control by dietary cholesterol does occur in man. That feedback control by dietary cholesterol is relatively unimportant in man seems to be due to the fact that in the metabolic "steady state" the absorption mechanism is essentially saturated by the large amounts of endogenous cholesterol available for reabsorption. These findings demonstrate that there are important differences between man and various laboratory animals in regard to the interaction of absorption and synthesis as factors controlling the size of tissue pools of cholesterol.     

Biophysical studies of cholesterol effects on chromatin

Changes in chromatin structure regulate gene expression and genome maintenance. Molecules that bind to the nucleosome, the complex of DNA and histone proteins, are key modulators of chromatin structure. Previous work indicated that cholesterol, a ubiquitous cellular lipid, may bind to chromatin in vivo, suggesting a potential function for lipids in modulating chromatin architecture. However, the molecular mechanisms of cholesterol's action on chromatin structure have remained unclear. Here, we explored the biophysical impact of cholesterol on nucleosome and chromatin fibers reconstituted in vitro and characterized in silico the cholesterol binding to the nucleosome. Our findings support that cholesterol assists 10 and 30 nm chromatin formation and induces folding of long chromatin fibers as a result of direct interaction of the cholesterol to six nucleosomal binding sites.     

Formation of lipid raft nanodomains in homogeneous ternary lipid mixture of POPC/DPSM/cholesterol: Theoretical insights

Lipid rafts, in biological membranes, are cholesterol-rich nanodomains that regulate many protein activities and cellular processes. Understanding the formation of the lipid-raft nanodomains helps us elucidate many complex interactions in the cell. In this study, the formation of lipid-raft nanodomains in a ternary palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine/stearoyl-sphingomyelin/cholesterol (POPC/DPSM/Chol) lipid mixture, the most realistic surrogate model for biological membranes, has been successfully observed for the first time in-silico using microsecond timescale molecular dynamics simulations. The model reveals the formation of cholesterol-induced nanodomains with raft-like characteristics and their underlying mechanism: the cholesterol molecules segregate themselves into cholesterol nanodomains and then enrich the cholesterol-rich domain with sphingomyelin molecules to form a lipid raft thanks to the weak bonding of cholesterol with sphingomyelin. Besides, it is found that the increase in cholesterol concentration enhances the biophysical properties (e.g., bilayer thickness, area per lipid headgroup, and order parameter) of the lipid raft nanodomains. Such findings suggest that the POPC/DPSM/Chol bilayer is a suitable model to fundamentally extend the nanodomain evolution to investigate their lifetime and kinetics as well as to study protein-lipid interaction, protein-protein interaction, and selection of therapeutic molecules in the presence of lipid rafts.     

A synergistic effect between cholesterol and tryptophan-flanked transmembrane helices modulates membrane curvature

The aim of this study was to gain insight into the structural consequences of hydrophobic mismatch for membrane proteins in lipid bilayers that contain cholesterol. For this purpose, tryptophan-flanked peptides, designed to mimic transmembrane segments of membrane proteins, were incorporated in model membranes of unsaturated phosphatidylcholine bilayers of varying thickness and containing varying amounts of cholesterol. Analysis of the lipid organization by (31)P NMR and cryo-TEM demonstrated the formation of an isotropic phase, most likely representing a cubic phase, which occurred exclusively in mixtures containing lipids with relatively long acyl chains. Formation of this phase was inhibited by incorporation of lysophosphatidylcholine. These results indicate that the isotropic phase is formed as a consequence of negative hydrophobic mismatch and that its formation is related to a negative membrane curvature. When either peptide or cholesterol was omitted from the mixture, isotropic-phase formation did not occur, not even when the concentrations of these compounds were significantly increased. This suggests that formation of the isotropic phase is the result of a synergistic effect between the peptides and cholesterol. Interestingly, isotropic-phase formation was not observed when the tryptophans in the peptide were replaced by either lysines or histidines. We propose a model for the mechanism of this synergistic effect, in which its dependence on the flanking residues is explained by preferential interactions between cholesterol and tryptophan residues.     

Interaction of the polyene antibiotics with lipid bilayer vesicles containing cholesterol

The interaction of the polyene antibiotics, amphotericin B, nystatin and filipin with cholesterol-containing single bilayer lipid vesicles has been characterized using gel permeation chromatography and proton magnetic resonance. All three antibiotics bind to vesicles at low concentrations without causing a large amount of vesicle destruction. The strength of binding as determined by gel permeation studies is greater for filipin and amphotericin than for nystatin. Nystatin and amphotericin B at these low concentrations induce a rapid loss of internal vesicle contents consistent with pore formation. Filipin induces no leakage beyond that expected from partial vesicle destruction or general detergent action.At antibiotic levels above 1 : 1 antibiotic : cholesterol ratios the NMR results show all three antibiotics to cause extensive vesicle destruction. The onset of this behavior, which appears to be independent of the total antibiotic concentration, indicates a well defined antibiotic : cholesterol interaction stoichiometry. Despite the fact that cholesterol is required for antibiotic activity, the NMR spectra prior to vesicle destruction show no changes indicative of an antibiotic-induced reversal of cholesterol restriction of phosphatidylcholine mobility. The contrast with polyene antibiotic behavior in more extended bilayers is discussed.     

Competitive binding of cholesterol and ergosterol to the polyene antibiotic nystatin. A fluorescence study

Competition studies between cholesterol and ergosterol were carried out to gain insight into the binding interactions between nystatin and these sterols. Lipid vesicles were prepared with mixtures of palmitoyloleoylphosphocholine/ergosterol/cholesterol, and both sterol molar ratio and total content were varied. The inhibitory effect of cholesterol toward the ergosterol ability to induce the formation of long-lived fluorescent antibiotic species was used to detect nystatin-cholesterol interactions. It was found that the key factor controlling nystatin photophysical properties in the ternary lipid mixtures was their ergosterol/cholesterol molar ratio and not their overall sterol content. Moreover, permeabilization studies showed that nystatin was able to form pores in all the mixed vesicles, but the initial rate of pore formation was also dependent on the ergosterol/cholesterol molar ratio. Our data show that ergosterol is displaced by competing cholesterol, indirectly confirming cholesterol's ability to coassemble with nystatin. The distinct spectroscopic properties emphasize the different molecular architecture adopted by nystatin-cholesterol and -ergosterol complexes, and therefore are relevant to understanding the interaction of the antibiotic with membranes.     

Influence of calcium, cholesterol, and unsaturation on lecithin monolayers

Surface pressures and potentials of mixed monolayers of dicetyl phosphate-cholesterol, dipalmitoyl lecithin-cholesterol, egg lecithin-cholesterol, and phosphatidic acid-cholesterol were measured. The surface potential is shown to be a more reliable parameter for the study of interactions in monolayers than the surface pressure. Monolayers of dicetyl phosphate-cholesterol follow the additivity rule for area/molecule whereas lecithin-cholesterol monolayers deviate from it. The reverse is true for the additivity rule with regard to surface potential/molecule. Thus, the surface potential indicates that there is no interaction (or complex formation) between lecithin and cholesterol, but that there is ion-dipole interaction between dicetyl phosphate and cholesterol, as well as between phosphatidic acid and cholesterol. The apparent condensation of mixed monolayers of lecithin when cholesterol is added is explained by a consideration of molecular cavities or vacancies caused by thermal motion of the fatty acyl chains, the size of these cavities being influenced by the length and degree of saturation (especially the proportion of monounsaturation) of the fatty acyl chains and the extent of compression of the monolayer. The cholesterol molecules occupy these cavities and therefore cause no proportional increase in area/molecule in the mixed monolayers. Monolayers are liquefied by the presence of cholesterol as well as of unsaturated fatty acyl chains; in contrast, Ca(++)tends to solidify lecithin monolayers. The available evidence suggests that cholesterol can both impart fluidity to the monolayer and occupy the molecular cavities caused by the fatty acyl chains.     

Comparative conformational analysis of cholesterol and ergosterol by molecular mechanics

A comparative conformational analysis of cholesterol and ergosterol has been carried out using molecular mechanics methods. These studies are aimed at giving a better understanding of the molecular nature of the interaction of these sterols with polyene macrolide antibiotics. Structures of cholesterol and ergosterol determined by X-ray methods have been used as initial geometries of these molecules for force field calculations. The calculation of steric energy has also been made for conformations which do not appear in the crystal. The latter conformers have different conformations of the side chain as well as different conformations of rings A and D. The rotational barriers around bonds C17–C20 and C20–C22 have also been calculated. The results obtained on differences and similarities in the conformations of cholesterol and ergosterol allow us to postulate a mechanism for differential interaction with the antibiotics. The relatively rigid side chain of ergosterol (stretched molecule) in comparison with the flexible side chain of cholesterol (bent molecule), allows better intermolecular contact of the first sterol molecule with a polyene macrolide and in consequence facilitates complex formation involving Van der Waal's forces.     

Apolipoproteins, membrane cholesterol domains, and the regulation of cholesterol efflux.

Published data related to both cell membrane biology and apolipoprotein structure are reviewed and used to formulate a new model describing the mechanisms of cholesterol efflux from cell plasma membrane to high density lipoprotein (HDL) particles. The central premise of this model is the existence of heterogenous domains of cholesterol within plasma membranes. We propose that cholesterol efflux from cell membranes is influenced by three factors: 1) the distribution of cholesterol between cholesterol-rich and cholesterol-poor membrane domains, 2) the diffusion of cholesterol molecules through the extracellular unstirred water layer, and 3) the transient interaction of segments of the amphipathic helix of the HDL apolipoprotein with cholesterol-poor membrane domains resulting in enhanced cholesterol efflux.     

Interaction of the Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) with cholesterol,some cholesterol esters,and cholesterol derivatives: a TEM study

The Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) 63-kDa monomer has been shown to interact in aqueous suspension with cholesterol microcystals to produce a ring/pore-like heptameric oligomer approximately 8 nm in outer diameter. Transmission electron microscopy data were produced from cholesterol samples adsorbed to carbon support films, spread across the holes of holey carbon films, and negatively stained with ammonium molybdate. The VCC oligomers initially attach to the edge of the stacked cholesterol bilayers and with increasing time cover the two planar surfaces. VCC oligomers are also released into solution, with some tendency to cluster, possibly via the hydrophobic membrane-spanning domain. At the air/water interface, the VCC oligomers are likely to be selectively oriented with the hydrophobic domain facing the air. Despite some molecular disorder/plasticity within the oligomers, multivariate statistical analysis and rotational self-correlation using IMAGIC-5 strongly suggest the presence of sevenfold rotational symmetry. To correlate the electron microscopy data with on-going biochemical and permeability studies using liposomes of varying lipid composition, the direct interaction of VCC with several cholesterol derivatives and other steroids has been examined. 19-Hydroxycholesterol and 7 beta-hydroxycholesterol both induce VCC oligomerization. beta-Estradiol, which does not possess an aliphatic side chain, also efficiently induces VCC oligomer formation, as does cholesteryl acetate. Cholesteryl stearate and oleate and the C22 (2-trifluoroacetyl)naphthyloxy analogue of cholesterol fail to induce VCC oligomerization, but binding of the monomer to the surface of these steroids does occur. Stigmasterol has little tendency to induce oligomer formation, and oligomers are largely confined to the edge of the bilayers; ergosterol has even less oligomerization ability. Attempts to solubilize and stabilize the VCC oligomers from cholesterol suspensions have been pursued using the neutral surfactant octylglucoside. Although individual solubilized oligomers have been defined which exhibit a characteristic cytolysin channel conformation in the side-on orientation, a tendency remains for the oligomers to cluster via their hydrophobic domains.     

High cholesterol absorption efficiency and rapid biliary secretion of chylomicron remnant cholesterol enhance cholelithogenesis in gallstone-susceptible mice

The study of chylomicron pathway through which it exerts its metabolic effects on biliary cholesterol secretion is crucial for understanding how high dietary cholesterol influences cholelithogenesis. We explored a relationship between cholesterol absorption efficiency and gallstone prevalence in 15 strains of inbred male mice and the metabolic fate of chylomicron and chylomicron remnant cholesterol in gallstone-susceptible C57L and gallstone-resistant AKR mice. Our results show a positive and significant (P<0.0001, r=0.87) correlation between percent cholesterol absorption and gallstone prevalence rates. Compared with AKR mice, C57L mice displayed significantly greater absorption of cholesterol from the small intestine, more rapid plasma clearance of chylomicrons and chylomicron remnants, higher activities of lipoprotein lipase and hepatic lipase, greater hepatic uptake of chylomicron remnants, and faster secretion of chylomicron remnant cholesterol from plasma into bile. All of these increased susceptibility to cholesterol gallstone formation in C57L mice. We conclude that genetic variations in cholesterol absorption efficiency are associated with cholesterol gallstone formation in inbred mice and cholesterol absorbed from the intestine provides an important source for biliary hypersecretion. Differential metabolism of the chylomicron remnant cholesterol between C57L and AKR mice clearly plays a crucial role in the formation of lithogenic bile and gallstones.     

A microscopic interaction model of maximum solubility of cholesterol in lipid bilayers

We recently reported the equilibrium maximum solubility of cholesterol in a lipid bilayer, chi*chol, to be 0.66 in four different phosphatidylcholines, and 0.51 in a phosphatidylethanolamine (Huang, J.,J.T. Buboltz, and G. W. Feigenson. 1999. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. in press). Here we present a model of cholesterol-phospholipid mixing that explains these observed values of chi*chol. Monte Carlo simulations show that pairwise-additivity of nearest-neighbor interactions is inadequate to describe all the chi*chol values. Instead, if cholesterol multibody interactions are assigned highly unfavorable energy, then jumps occur in cholesterol chemical potential that lead to its precipitation from the bilayer. Cholesterol precipitation is most likely to occur near three discrete values of cholesterol mole fraction, 0.50, 0.57, and 0.67, which correspond to cholesterol/phospholipid mole ratios of 1/1, 4/3, and 2/1, respectively. At these solubility limits, where cholesterol chemical potential jumps, the cholesterol-phospholipid bilayer mixture forms highly regular lipid distributions in order to minimize cholesterol-cholesterol contacts. This treatment shows that dramatic structural and thermodynamic changes can occur at particular cholesterol mole fractions without any stoichiometric complex formation. The physical origin of the unfavorable cholesterol multibody interaction is explained by an "umbrella model": in a bilayer, nonpolar cholesterol relies on polar phospholipid headgroup coverage to avoid the unfavorable free energy of cholesterol contact with water. Thus, at high cholesterol mole fraction, this unfavorable free energy, not any favorable cholesterol-phospholipid interaction, dominates the mixing behavior. This physical origin also explains the "cholesterol condensing effect" and the increase in acyl chain order parameter in cholesterol-phospholipid mixtures.