Initial binding of the broad spectrum antiviral nucleoside ribavirin to the hepatitis C virus RNA polymerase

Ribavirin is a broad spectrum antiviral nucleoside that displays activity against a variety of RNA and DNA viruses. Ribavirin is currently used in combination with interferon-alpha for the treatment of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection and was recently shown to be directly incorporated by the HCV RNA polymerase into RNA products. This capacity ultimately leads to increased mutation rates and drastically reduces the viral fitness. As a first step toward elucidating the nature of the specific interaction between ribavirin and the HCV polymerase, we have utilized fluorescence spectroscopy to monitor precisely the binding of ribavirin triphosphate (RTP) to the viral polymerase. This spectroscopic approach allowed us to clearly separate the RTP binding activity from the concomitant catalytic steps. We report here the first detailed study of the binding kinetics and thermodynamic parameters involved in the interaction between RTP and an RNA polymerase. We demonstrate that RTP binds to the same active site as nucleotides. Furthermore, we provide evidence that the HCV polymerase cannot only bind to RTP but also to nonphosphorylated ribavirin, albeit with less affinity. By using various combinations of template-primers, we also demonstrate that base pairing is not involved in the initial binding of RTP to the HCV polymerase. Based on the results of circular dichroism and denaturation studies, we show that the RNA polymerase undergoes subtle conformational changes upon the binding of RTP, although the interaction does not significantly modify the stability of the protein. Finally, although metal ions are required for catalytic activity, they are not required for the initial binding of RTP to the polymerase. Such quantitative analyses are of primary importance for the rational design of new ribavirin analogues of potential therapeutic value and provide crucial insights on the interaction between RTP and the HCV RNA polymerase.     

Investigating the role of metal ions in the catalytic mechanism of the yeast RNA triphosphatase

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNA triphosphatase (Cet1) requires the presence of metal ion cofactors to catalyze its phosphohydrolase activity, the first step in the formation of the 5'-terminal cap structure of mRNAs. We have used endogenous tryptophan fluorescence studies to elucidate both the nature and the role(s) of the metal ions in the Cet1-mediated phosphohydrolase reaction. The association of Mg2+, Mn2+, and Co2+ ions with the enzyme resulted in a decrease in the intensity of the tryptophan emission spectrum. This decrease was then used to determine the apparent dissociation constants for these ions. Subsequent dual ligand titration experiments demonstrated that the metal ions bind to a common site, for which they compete. The kinetics of real-time metal ion binding to the Cet1 protein were also investigated, and the effects on RNA and nucleotide binding were evaluated. To provide additional insight into the relationship between Cet1 structure and metal ion binding, we correlated the effect of ion binding on protein structure using both circular dichroism and guanidium hydrochloride-induced denaturation as structural indicators. Our data indicate that binding of RNA, nucleotides, and metal ion cofactors does not lead to significant structural modifications of the Cet1 architecture. This suggests a model in which Cet1 possesses a preformed active site, and where major domain rearrangements are not required to form an active catalytic site. Finally, denaturation studies demonstrate that the metal ion cofactors can act by stabilizing the ground state binding of the phosphohydrolase substrate.     

Metal ion catalysis of RNA cleavage by the influenza virus endonuclease

The influenza virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase protein complex contains an associated RNA endonuclease activity, which cleaves host mRNA precursors in the cell nucleus at defined positions 9-15 nucleotides downstream of the cap structure. This reaction provides capped oligoribonucleotides, which function as primers for the initiation of viral mRNA synthesis. The endonuclease reaction is dependent on the presence of divalent metal ions. We have used a number of divalent and trivalent metal ions alone and in combination to probe the mechanism of RNA cleavage by the influenza virus endonuclease. Virus-specific cleavage was observed with various metal ions, and maximum cleavage activity was obtained with 100 microM Mn2+ or 100 microM Co2+. This activity was about 2-fold higher than that observed with Mg2+ at the optimal concentration of 1 mM. Activity dependence on metal ion concentration was cooperative with Hill coefficients close to or larger than 2. Synergistic activation of cleavage activity was observed with combinations of different metal ions at varying concentrations. These results support a two-metal ion mechanism of RNA cleavage for the influenza virus cap-dependent endonuclease. The findings are also consistent with a structural model of the polymerase, in which the specific endonuclease active site is spatially separated from the nucleotidyl transferase active site of the polymerase module.     

Characterization of the metal ion binding properties of the hepatitis C virus RNA polymerase

The hepatitis C virus nonstructural 5B protein (NS5B) protein has been shown to require either magnesium or manganese for its RNA-dependent RNA polymerase activity. As a first step toward elucidating the nature and the role(s) of the metal ions in the reaction chemistry, we have utilized endogenous tryptophan fluorescence to quantitate the interactions of magnesium and manganese ions with this protein. The association of either Mg(2+) or Mn(2+) ions with the enzyme resulted in a decrease in the intensity of the tryptophan emission spectrum. This decrease was used to determine the apparent dissociation constants for both ions. The apparent K(d) values for the binding of Mg(2+) and Mn(2+) ions to the free enzyme were 3.1 and 0.3 mm, respectively. Dual ligand titration experiments demonstrated that both ions bind to a single common site, for which they compete. The kinetics of real time metal ion binding to the NS5B protein were also investigated. Based on the results of our fluorescence and near-UV circular dichroism experiments, we show that NS5B undergoes conformational changes upon the binding of metal ions. However, this process does not significantly stimulate the binding to the RNA or NTP substrates. We envisage that the ion-induced conformational change is a prerequisite for catalytic activity by both correctly positioning the side chains of the residues located in the active site of the enzyme and also contributing to the stabilization of the intermediate transition state.     

Energetics of RNA binding by the West Nile virus RNA triphosphatase

The West Nile virus (WNV) RNA genome harbors the characteristic methylated cap structure present at the 5' end of eukaryotic mRNAs. In the present study, we report a detailed study of the binding energetics and thermodynamic parameters involved in the interaction between RNA and the WNV RNA triphosphatase, an enzyme involved in the synthesis of the RNA cap structure. Fluorescence spectroscopy assays revealed that the initial interaction between RNA and the enzyme is characterized by a high enthalpy of association and that the minimal RNA binding site of NS3 is 13 nucleotides. In order to provide insight into the relationship between the enzyme structure and RNA binding, we also correlated the effect of RNA binding on protein structure using both circular dichroism and denaturation studies as structural indicators. Our data indicate that the protein undergoes structural modifications upon RNA binding, although the interaction does not significantly modify the stability of the protein.     

Structural roles of monovalent cations in the HDV ribozyme

The hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme catalyzes viral RNA self-cleavage through general acid-base chemistry in which an active-site cytidine and at least one metal ion are involved. Monovalent metal ions support slow catalysis and were proposed to substitute for structural, but not catalytic, divalent metal ions in the RNA. To investigate the role of monovalent cations in ribozyme structure and function, we determined the crystal structure of the precursor HDV ribozyme in the presence of thallium ions (Tl(+)). Two Tl(+) ions can occupy a previously observed divalent metal ion hexahydrate-binding site located near the scissile phosphate, but are easily competed away by cobalt hexammine, a magnesium hexahydrate mimic and potent reaction inhibitor. Intriguingly, a third Tl(+) ion forms direct inner-sphere contacts with the ribose 2'-OH nucleophile and the pro-S(p) scissile phosphate oxygen. We discuss possible structural and catalytic implications of monovalent cation binding for the HDV ribozyme mechanism.     

Mechanistic characterization of the HDV genomic ribozyme: a mutant of the C41 motif provides insight into the positioning and thermodynamic linkage of metal ions and protons

Binding of two Mg2+ and two H+ ions influences the self-cleavage activity of the genomic HDV ribozyme. The positioning of these four ligands and their thermodynamic linkage are not fully resolved. Protonated C41 engages in a base triple, whereas protonated C75 has been implicated as an acid-base catalyst in bond cleavage. Prior studies led to the identification of one structural inner-sphere ion and one catalytic outer-sphere ion. In the present study, the contributions of the C41 base triple to the metal ion- and pH-dependence of the reaction are examined. Experiments were conducted on a CG to UA double mutant (DM), which changes the base triple to one involving an unprotonated C41. Below pH 6, the DM has a steeper dependence on pH than the wild-type (WT), consistent with a single protonation misfolding the core; this conclusion is also supported by thermal denaturation studies. Between pH 6 and 8, the WT and DM display nearly identical catalytic metal ion and H+ binding profiles. In contrast, over the same pH range, the WT and DM have distinct structural ion binding profiles; for the WT, binding is favored at lower pH, whereas the DM shows no pH dependence. These data localize the structural ion to the vicinity of the C41 motif. An overall model is presented that accommodates binding affinity, coupling, and positioning of the two metal ions and the two protons within the ribozyme. The data suggest that a protonated base triple allows the WT ribozyme to maintain appreciable activity at acidic pH, which could play an important role in the life cycle of the virus.     

Distinct roles of the active-site Mg2+ ligands, Asp882 and Asp705, of DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) during the prechemistry conformational transitions

DNA polymerases catalyze the incorporation of deoxynucleoside triphosphates into a growing DNA chain using a pair of Mg(2+) ions, coordinated at the active site by two invariant aspartates, whose removal by mutation typically reduces the polymerase activity to barely detectable levels. Using two stopped-flow fluorescence assays that we developed previously, we have investigated the role of the carboxylate ligands, Asp(705) and Asp(882), of DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) in the early prechemistry steps that prepare the active site for catalysis. We find that neither carboxylate is required for an early conformational transition, reported by a 2-aminopurine probe, that takes place in the open ternary complex after binding of the complementary dNTP. However, the subsequent fingers-closing step requires Asp(882); this step converts the open ternary complex into the closed conformation, creating the active-site geometry required for catalysis. Crystal structures indicate that the Asp(882) position changes very little during fingers-closing; this side chain may therefore serve as an anchor point to receive the dNTP-associated metal ion as the nucleotide is delivered into the active site. The Asp(705) carboxylate is not required until after the fingers-closing step, and we suggest that its role is to facilitate the entry of the second Mg(2+) into the active site. The two early prechemistry steps that we have studied take place normally at very low Mg(2+) concentrations, although higher concentrations are needed for covalent nucleotide addition, consistent with the second metal ion entering the ternary complex after fingers-closing.     

The 1.3 A resolution structure of the RNA tridecamer r(GCGUUUGAAACGC): metal ion binding correlates with base unstacking and groove contraction

Metal ions play a key role in RNA folding and activity. Elucidating the rules that govern the binding of metal ions is therefore an essential step for better understanding the RNA functions. High-resolution data are a prerequisite for a detailed structural analysis of ion binding on RNA and, in particular, the observation of monovalent cations. Here, the high-resolution crystal structures of the tridecamer duplex r(GCGUUUGAAACGC) crystallized under different conditions provides new structural insights on ion binding on GAAA/UUU sequences that exhibit both unusual structural and functional properties in RNA. The present study extends the repertory of RNA ion binding sites in showing that the two first bases of UUU triplets constitute a specific site for sodium ions. A striking asymmetric pattern of metal ion binding in the two equivalent halves of the palindromic sequence demonstrates that sequence and its environment act together to bind metal ions. A highly ionophilic half that binds six metal ions allows, for the first time, the observation of a disodium cluster in RNA. The comparison of the equivalent halves of the duplex provides experimental evidences that ion binding correlates with structural alterations and groove contraction.     

Muscle contraction: viscous-like frictional forces and the impulsive model

The thermal denaturation of yeast enolase 1 was studied by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) under conditions of subunit association/dissociation, enzymatic activity or substrate binding without turnover and substrate analogue binding. Subunit association stabilizes the enzyme, that is, the enzyme dissociates before denaturing. The conformational change produced by conformational metal ion binding increases thermal stability by reducing subunit dissociation. 'Substrate' or analogue binding additionally stabilizes the enzyme, irrespective of whether turnover is occurring, perhaps in part by the same mechanism. More strongly bound metal ions also stabilize the enzyme more, which we interpret as consistent with metal ion loss before denaturation, though possibly the denaturation pathway is different in the absence of metal ion. We suggest that some of the stabilization by 'substrate' and analogue binding is owing to the closure of moveable polypeptide loops about the active site, producing a more 'closed' and hence thermostable conformation.     

Role of divalent metal cations in ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by the hepatitis C virus NS3 helicase: magnesium provides a bridge for ATP to fuel unwinding

This study investigates the role of magnesium ions in coupling ATP hydrolysis to the nucleic acid unwinding catalyzed by the NS3 protein encoded by the hepatitis C virus (HCV). Analyses of steady-state ATP hydrolysis rates at various RNA and magnesium concentrations were used to determine values for the 15 dissociation constants describing the formation of a productive enzyme-metal-ATP-RNA complex and the four rate constants describing hydrolysis of ATP by the possible enzyme-ATP complexes. These values coupled with direct binding studies, specificity studies and analyses of site-directed mutants reveal only one ATP binding site on HCV helicase centered on the catalytic base Glu291. An adjacent residue, Asp290, binds a magnesium ion that forms a bridge to ATP, reorienting the nucleotide in the active site. RNA stimulates hydrolysis while decreasing the affinity of the enzyme for ATP, magnesium, and MgATP. The binding scheme described here explains the unusual regulation of the enzyme by ATP that has been reported previously. Binding of either free magnesium or free ATP to HCV helicase competes with MgATP, the true fuel for helicase movements, and leads to slower hydrolysis and nucleic acid unwinding.     

Insight into the role of a unique SSEHA motif in the activity and stability of Helicobacter pylori arginase

Arginase is a binuclear Mn(2+) -metalloenzyme of urea cycle that hydrolyzes arginine to ornithine and urea. Unlike other arginases, the Helicobacter pylori enzyme is selective for Co(2+) and has all conserved motifs except (88) SSEHA(92) (instead of GGDHS). To examine the role of this motif in the activity and stability, steady-state kinetics, mutational analysis, thermal denaturation, and homology modeling were carried out. With a series of single and double mutants, we show that mutations of Ser88 and Ala92 to its analogous residues in other arginases individually enhance the catalytic activity. This is supported by the modeling studies, where the motif plays a role in alteration at the active site structure compared to other arginases. Mutational analysis further shows that both Glu90 and His91 are important for the activity, as their mutations lead to significant decrease in the catalytic efficiency but they appear to act in two different ways; Glu90 has a more catalytic role as its mutant displays binding of the two metal ions per monomer of the protein, but His91 plays a critical role in retaining the metal ion at the active site as its mutation exhibits a loss of one metal ion. Thermal denaturation studies demonstrated that Ser88 and His91 both play crucial roles in the stability of the protein as their mutants showed a decrease in the T(m) by ～10-11°. Unlike wild type, the metal ions have larger role in providing the stability to the mutant proteins. Thus, our data demonstrate that the motif not only plays an important role in the activity but also critical in the stability of the protein.     

Mutational analysis of the guanylyltransferase component of Mammalian mRNA capping enzyme

RNA guanylyltransferase is an essential enzyme that catalyzes the second of three steps in the synthesis of the 5'-cap structure of eukaryotic mRNA. Here we conducted a mutational analysis of the guanylyltransferase domain of the mouse capping enzyme Mce1. We introduced 50 different mutations at 22 individual amino acids and assessed their effects on Mce1 function in vivo in yeast. We identified 16 amino acids as being essential for Mce1 activity (Arg299, Arg315, Asp343, Glu345, Tyr362, Asp363, Arg380, Asp438, Gly439, Lys458, Lys460, Asp468, Arg530, Asp532, Lys533, and Asn537) and clarified structure-activity relationships by testing the effects of conservative substitutions. The new mutational data for Mce1, together with prior mutational studies of Saccharomyces cerevisiae guanylyltransferase and the crystal structures of Chlorella virus and Candida albicans guanylyltransferases, provide a coherent picture of the functional groups that comprise and stabilize the active site. Our results extend and consolidate the hypothesis of a shared structural basis for catalysis by RNA capping enzymes, DNA ligases, and RNA ligases, which comprise a superfamily of covalent nucleotidyl transferases defined by a constellation of conserved motifs. Analysis of the effects of motif VI mutations on Mce1 guanylyltransferase activity in vitro highlights essential roles for Arg530, Asp532, Lys533, and Asn537 in GTP binding and nucleotidyl transfer.     

Characterization of the inhibition of hepatitis C virus RNA replication by nonnucleosides

The RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is necessary for the replication of viral RNA and thus represents an attractive target for drug development. Several structural classes of nonnucleoside inhibitors (NNIs) of HCV RNA polymerase have been described, including a promising series of benzothiadiazine compounds that efficiently block replication of HCV subgenomic replicons in tissue culture. In this work we report the selection of replicons resistant to inhibition by the benzothiadiazine class of NNIs. Four different single mutations were identified in separate clones, and all four map to the RNA polymerase gene, validating the polymerase as the antiviral target of inhibition. The mutations (M414T, C451R, G558R, and H95R) render the HCV replicons resistant to inhibition by benzothiadiazines, though the mutant replicons remain sensitive to inhibition by other nucleoside and NNIs of the HCV RNA polymerase. Additionally, cross-resistance studies and synergistic inhibition of the enzyme by combinations of a benzimidazole and a benzothiadiazine indicate the existence of nonoverlapping binding sites for these two structural classes of inhibitors.     

Evaluation of uranyl photocleavage as a probe to monitor ion binding and flexibility in RNAs

In order to evaluate uranyl photocleavage as a tool to identify and characterize structural and dynamic properties in RNA, we compared uranyl cleavage sites in five RNA molecules with known X-ray structures, namely the hammerhead and hepatitis delta virus ribozymes, the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron, as well as tRNA(Phe) and tRNA(Asp) from yeast. Uranyl photocleavage was observed at specific positions in all molecules investigated. In order to characterize the sites, photocleavage was performed in the absence and in increasing amounts of MgCl(2). Uranyl photocleavage correlates well with sites of low calculated accessibility, suggesting that uranyl ions bind in tight RNA pockets formed by close approach of phosphate groups. RNA foldings require ion binding, usually magnesium ions. Thus, upon the adoption of the native structure, uranyl ions can no longer bind well except in flexible and open to the solvent regions that can undergo induced-fit without disrupting the native fold. Uranyl photocleavage was compared to N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea and lead-induced cleavages in the context of the three-dimensional X-ray structures. Overall, the regions protected from ENU attack are sites of uranyl cleavage, indicating sites of low accessibility which can form ion binding sites. On the contrary, lead cleavages occur at flexible and accessible sites and correlate with the unspecific cleavages prevalent in dynamic and open regions. Applied in a magnesium-dependent manner, and only in combination with other backbone probing agents such as N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea, lead and Fenton cleavage, uranyl probing has the potential to reveal high-affinity metal ion environments, as well as regions involved in conformational transitions.     

RNA sequences and structures required for the recruitment and activity of the dengue virus polymerase

Dengue virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase specifically binds to the viral genome by interacting with a promoter element known as stem-loop A (SLA). Although a great deal has been learned in recent years about the function of this promoter in dengue virus-infected cells, the molecular details that explain how the SLA interacts with the polymerase to promote viral RNA synthesis remain poorly understood. Using RNA binding and polymerase activity assays, we defined two elements of the SLA that are involved in polymerase interaction and RNA synthesis. Mutations at the top of the SLA resulted in RNAs that retained the ability to bind the polymerase but impaired promoter-dependent RNA synthesis. These results indicate that protein binding to the SLA is not sufficient to induce polymerase activity and that specific nucleotides of the SLA are necessary to render an active polymerase-promoter complex for RNA synthesis. We also report that protein binding to the viral RNA induces conformational changes downstream of the promoter element. Furthermore, we found that structured RNA elements at the 3' end of the template repress dengue virus polymerase activity in the context of a fully active SLA promoter. Using assays to evaluate initiation of RNA synthesis at the viral 3'-UTR, we found that the RNA-RNA interaction mediated by 5'-3'-hybridization was able to release the silencing effect of the 3'-stem-loop structure. We propose that the long range RNA-RNA interactions in the viral genome play multiple roles during RNA synthesis. Together, we provide new molecular details about the promoter-dependent dengue virus RNA polymerase activity.     

Cation binding and thermostability of FTHFS monovalent cation binding sites and thermostability of N10-formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase from Moorella thermoacetica

Formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase (FTHFS) from the thermophilic homoacetogen, Moorella thermoacetica, has an optimum temperature for activity of 55-60 degrees C and requires monovalent cations for both optimal activity and stabilization of tetrameric structure at higher temperatures. The crystal structures of complexes of FTHFS with cesium and potassium ions were examined and monovalent cation binding positions identified. Unexpectedly, NH(4)(+) and K(+), both of which are strongly activating ions, bind at a different site than a moderately activating ion, Cs(+), does. Neither binding site is located in the active site. The sites are 7 A apart, but in each of them, the side chain of Glu 98, which is conserved in all known bacterial FTHFS sequences, participates in metal ion binding. Other ligands in the Cs(+) binding site are four oxygen atoms of main chain carbonyls and water molecules. The K(+) and NH(4)(+) binding site includes the carboxylate of Asp132 in addition to Glu98. Mutant FTHFS's (E98Q, E98D, and E98S) were obtained and analyzed using differential scanning calorimetry to examine the effect of these mutations on the thermostability of the enzyme with and without added K(+) ions. The addition of 0.2 M K(+) ions to the wild-type enzyme resulted in a 10 degrees C increase in the thermal denaturation temperature. No significant increase was observed in E98D or E98S. The lack of a significant effect of monovalent cations on the stability of E98D and E98S indicates that this alteration of the binding site eliminates cation binding. The thermal denaturation temperature of E98Q was 3 degrees C higher than that of the wild-type enzyme in the absence of the cation, indicating that the removal of the unbalanced, buried charge of Glu98 stabilizes the enzyme. These results confirm that Glu98 is a crucial residue in the interaction of monovalent cations with FTHFS.     

A single metal ion plays structural and chemical roles in an aminoacyl-transferase ribozyme.

Catalytically active RNA molecules rely on metal ions for structural and/or catalytic functions. Our in vitro selected aminoacyl-transferase ribozyme is no exception, as it employs a single fully hydrated Mg2+ ion for catalysis [Suga, H., et al. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 10118-10125]. Here we report the essential catalytic residues of the ribozyme and their spatial arrangement in the relation to the metal binding site. Evidence obtained using a combination of Pb2+ and Tb3+ hydrolytic cleavage assays on wild type and mutant ribozymes revealed a cooperative metal binding site that consists of the tandem G:U wobble pairs in P1 and consecutive G:U and U:A pairs in P3. The formation of this concerted Mg2+ binding site positions the P1 and P3 helices in a parallel manner, placing the L3 tetraloop in close proximity to the internal guide sequence (IGS, substrate binding site), which is adjacent to P1. Certain monovalent metal ions inhibit catalysis at low concentrations but support catalysis at high concentrations. These analyses imply that the Mg2+ ion plays both structural and chemical roles and that it brings about the significant rate acceleration in aminoacyl-transfer in concert with the L3-IGS long-range interaction.