Design of compound libraries based on natural product scaffolds and protein structure similarity clustering (PSSC)

Recent advances in structural biology, bioinformatics and combinatorial chemistry have significantly impacted the discovery of small molecules that modulate protein functions. Natural products which have evolved to bind to proteins may serve as biologically validated starting points for the design of focused libraries that might provide protein ligands with enhanced quality and probability. The combined application of natural product derived scaffolds with a new approach that clusters proteins according to structural similarity of their ligand sensing cores provides a new principle for the design and synthesis of such libraries. This article discusses recent advances in the synthesis of natural product inspired compound collections and the application of protein structure similarity clustering for the development of such libraries.     

γ-Pyrone natural products—A privileged compound class provided by nature

In “Biology Oriented Synthesis” (BIOS), the inherent biological relevance of natural products is employed for the design and synthesis of compound libraries. Towards this end, library generation in BIOS is focused on compound classes from biologically relevant space such as the natural product space or also the drug space and only scaffolds of these areas of proven relevance are employed for synthesis of small focused libraries with limited diversity. We here present a short overview of γ-pyrone natural products, highlighting their biological properties and their potential applicability in a BIOS of a compound library.     

Polymer supported synthesis of a natural product-inspired oxepane library

Natural product inspired compound collections are prevalidated due to the evolutionary selection of the natural product scaffolds. Their synthesis requires the development of novel strategies amenable to formats suitable for library build-up. We describe a method for the synthesis of an oxepane library inspired by the core structure of oxepane natural products endowed with multiple bioactivities. Core aspects of the strategy are the establishment of a one-pot method employing different immobilized scavengers, the employment of an enyne ring closing reaction and diversification by means of different transformations, for example, cycloadditions and cross-metathesis reactions. In total, a collection of 115 oxepanes was obtained in 5–6-step reaction sequences.     

Combinatorial carbohydrate chemistry

The application of combinatorial chemistry to the synthesis of carbohydrate-based compound collections has received increased attention in recent years. New strategies for the solution-phase synthesis of oligosaccharide libraries have been reported, and the use of monosaccharides as scaffolds in the generation of combinatorial libraries has been described. Novel approaches to the assembly of carbohydrate-based antibiotics, such as aminoglycoside analogs and vancomycin derivatives, have also been disclosed.     

Distribution of Molecular Scaffolds and R-Groups Isolated from Large Compound Databases

We describe an approach to isolate molecular scaffolds and R-groups from known chemical compounds in order to generate scaffold and R-group databases from two large compound collections, Optiverse^TM and Maybridge^TM. The distributions of molecular scaffolds and R-groups in the parent databases were analysed and compared. We find that a limited number of scaffolds and R-groups account for the majority of database compounds and that most of the scaffolds occur only once or twice in the compound databases. Diversity analysis suggests that the compound and scaffold databases have similar molecular diversity. Implications for library design are discussed.Electronic Supplementary Material available.     

Natural products and combinatorial chemistry: back to the future

The introduction of high-throughput synthesis and combinatorial chemistry has precipitated a global decline in the screening of natural products by the pharmaceutical industry. Some companies terminated their natural products program, despite the unproven success of the new technologies. This was a premature decision, as natural products have a long history of providing important medicinal agents. Furthermore, they occupy a complementary region of chemical space compared with the typical synthetic compound library. For these reasons, the interest in natural products has been rekindled. Various approaches have evolved that combine the power of natural products and organic chemistry, ranging from the combinatorial total synthesis of analogues to the exploration of natural product scaffolds and the design of completely unnatural molecules that resemble natural products in their molecular characteristics.     

PATTERNS OF STEM VASCULATURE IN PHILODENDRON

A survey of 480 collections of stem material of Philodendron has established five patterns of vascular organization. Species representing each of these patterns were analyzed by cinematographic methods to allow a three-dimensional interpretation of the course of vascular bundles over extended distances. Pattern 1 has mainly collateral organization, but with some bipolar bundles. Pattern 2 has a majority of central bundles aggregated into compound (multipolar) bundles; Pattern 3 differs in that almost all bundles of the central cylinder are multipolar. Patterns 4 and 5 include compound vascular bundles in which the individual strands are not very discrete so that in Pattern 5, which is the most common in the genus, the bundles might be described as amphivasal. In Section Pteromischum, which has monopodial construction, the majority of species exhibit Pattern 2 which is exclusive to this group. Other correlations with subgeneric groupings are emphasized.     

Design, synthesis and preliminary biological evaluation of a focused combinatorial library of stereodiverse carbohydrate-scaffold-based peptidomimetics

A focused combinatorial library of 126 mimetics of the RGD sequence based on sugar scaffolds have been rationally constructed using molecular modeling, with a particular emphasis on the stereodiversity of the library. A liquid phase, mix and divide synthesis was used, active compounds being identified by using orthogonal libraries and recursive deconvolution strategies.     

A novel complexity-to-diversity strategy for the diversity-oriented synthesis of structurally diverse and complex macrocycles from quinine

Recent years have witnessed a global decline in the productivity and advancement of the pharmaceutical industry. A major contributing factor to this is the downturn in drug discovery successes. This can be attributed to the lack of structural (particularly scaffold) diversity and structural complexity exhibited by current small molecule screening collections.Macrocycles have been shown to exhibit a diverse range of biological properties, with over 100 natural product-derived examples currently marketed as FDA-approved drugs. Despite this, synthetic macrocycles are widely considered to be a poorly explored structural class within drug discovery, which can be attributed to their synthetic intractability.Herein we describe a novel complexity-to-diversity strategy for the diversity-oriented synthesis of novel, structurally complex and diverse macrocyclic scaffolds from natural product starting materials. This approach exploits the inherent structural (including functional) and stereochemical complexity of natural products in order to rapidly generate diversity and complexity. Readily-accessible natural product-derived intermediates serve as structural templates which can be divergently functionalized with different building blocks to generate a diverse range of acyclic precursors. Subsequent macrocyclisation then furnishes compounds that are each based around a distinct molecular scaffold. Thus, high levels of library scaffold diversity can be rapidly achieved. In this proof-of-concept study, the natural product quinine was used as the foundation for library synthesis, and six novel structurally diverse, highly complex and functionalized macrocycles were generated.     

A biomimetic approach to some specifically functionalized cyclic terpenoids

The paper relates on the current advancements in the synthesis of complex cyclic terpenoids by superacidic induced cyclization of open chain precursors. It is shown that functional groups disposal in the initial substrate strongly influences the reaction outcome. Possible variations of the investigated compound structures include particularly alpha-functionalization and alpha,omega-bifunctionalization. This approach allowed a selective initiation of cyclization sequence from an internal double bond or suspending the ring closure cascade to partially cyclized compounds. The reported synthetic schemes are attempts to mimic the biogenetical processes postulated in the living systems.     

Design of Array-Type Compound Libraries that Combine Information from Natural Products and Synthetic Molecules

A new approach to the design of compound libraries, named MetaFocus (Metabolite-Focused library), is presented that exploits information encoded in natural molecules and combines naturally occurring and synthetic compounds. An important goal of the MF approach is the identification of synthetic compounds that mimic properties of natural molecules that are difficult to obtain in sufficient quantities or to synthesize. Compounds in MetaFocus (MF) arrays are focused on natural molecules with attractive therapeutic effects. Similarity search and diversity design techniques are employed to generate compound arrays that start from a selected natural molecule, add similar molecules, either from natural or synthetic sources, and diversify scaffolds derived from these molecules. Since the identification of similar molecules from natural and synthetic sources plays a significant role in our library design efforts, the performance of fingerprint-type search tools was systematically assessed in a newly assembled test database consisting of 16 biological activity classes. MF arrays are organized as an easily expandable and searchable data structure and serve as a knowledge base for drug discovery applications. Here we introduce the design principles and organization of MF arrays and present example applications.     

Development and Validation of a Novel Leishmania donovani Screening Cascade for High-Throughput Screening Using a Novel Axenic Assay with High Predictivity of Leishmanicidal Intracellular Activity

Visceral leishmaniasis is an important parasitic disease of the developing world with a limited arsenal of drugs available for treatment. The existing drugs have significant deficiencies so there is an urgent need for new and improved drugs. In the human host, Leishmania are obligate intracellular parasites which poses particular challenges in terms of drug discovery. To achieve sufficient throughput and robustness, free-living parasites are often used in primary screening assays as a surrogate for the more complex intracellular assays. We and others have found that such axenic assays have a high false positive rate relative to the intracellular assays, and that this limits their usefulness as a primary platform for screening of large compound collections. While many different reasons could lie behind the poor translation from axenic parasite to intracellular parasite, we show here that a key factor is the identification of growth slowing and cytostatic compounds by axenic assays in addition to the more desirable cytocidal compounds. We present a screening cascade based on a novel cytocidal-only axenic amastigote assay, developed by increasing starting density of cells and lowering the limit of detection, and show that it has a much improved translation to the intracellular assay. We propose that this assay is an improved primary platform in a new Leishmania screening cascade designed for the screening of large compound collections. This cascade was employed to screen a diversity-oriented-synthesis library, and yielded two novel antileishmanial chemotypes. The approach we have taken may have broad relevance to anti-infective and anti-parasitic drug discovery.     

Combinatorial synthesis of natural products

Combinatorial syntheses allow production of compound libraries in an expeditious and organized manner immediately applicable for high-throughput screening. Natural products possess a pedigree to justify quality and appreciation in drug discovery and development. Currently, we are seeing a rapid increase in application of natural products in combinatorial chemistry and vice versa. The therapeutic areas of infectious disease and oncology still dominate but many new areas are emerging. Several complex natural products have now been synthesised by solid-phase methods and have created the foundation for preparation of combinatorial libraries. In other examples, natural products or intermediates have served as building blocks or scaffolds in the synthesis of complex natural products, bioactive analogues or designed hybrid molecules. Finally, structural motifs from the biologically active parent molecule have been identified and have served for design of natural product mimicry, which facilitates the creation of combinatorial libraries.     

Synthesis and evaluation of the performance of a small molecule library based on diverse tropane-related scaffolds

A unified synthetic approach was developed that enabled the synthesis of diverse tropane-related scaffolds. The key intermediates that were exploited were cycloadducts formed by reaction between 3-hydroxy-pyridinium salts and vinyl sulfones or sulfonamides. The diverse tropane-related scaffolds were formed by addition of substituents to, cyclisation reactions of, and fusion of additional ring(s) to the key bicyclic intermediates. A set of 53 screening compounds was designed, synthesised and evaluated in order to determine the biological relevance of the scaffolds accessible using the synthetic approach. Two inhibitors of Hedgehog signalling, and four compounds with weak activity against the parasite P. falciparum, were discovered. Three of the active compounds may be considered to be indotropane or pyrrotropane pseudo natural products in which a tropane is fused with a fragment from another natural product class. It was concluded that the unified synthetic approach had yielded diverse scaffolds suitable for the design of performance-diverse screening libraries.     

From consensus sequence peptide to high affinity ligand, a "library scan" strategy

A wide variety of proteins have been shown to recognize and bind to specific amino acid sequences on other proteins. These sequences can be readily identified using combinatorial peptide libraries. However, peptides containing these preferred sequences ("consensus sequence peptides") typically display only modest affinities for the consensus sequence-binding site on the intact protein. In this report, we describe a parallel synthesis strategy that transforms consensus sequence peptides into high affinity ligands. The work described herein has focused on the Lck SH2 domain, which binds the consensus peptide acetyl-Tyr(P)-Glu-Glu-Ile-amide with a K(D) of 1.3 micrometer. We employed a strategy that creates a series of spatially focused libraries that challenge specific subsites on the target protein with a diverse array of functionality. The final lead compound identified in this study displayed a 3300-fold higher affinity for the Lck SH2 domain than the starting consensus sequence peptide.     

DNA assembly techniques for next-generation combinatorial biosynthesis of natural products

Natural product scaffolds remain important leads for pharmaceutical development. However, transforming a natural product into a drug entity often requires derivatization to enhance the compound’s therapeutic properties. A powerful method by which to perform this derivatization is combinatorial biosynthesis, the manipulation of the genes in the corresponding pathway to divert synthesis towards novel derivatives. While these manipulations have traditionally been carried out via restriction digestion/ligation-based cloning, the shortcomings of such techniques limit their throughput and thus the scope of corresponding combinatorial biosynthesis experiments. In the burgeoning field of synthetic biology, the demand for facile DNA assembly techniques has promoted the development of a host of novel DNA assembly strategies. Here we describe the advantages of these recently developed tools for rapid, efficient synthesis of large DNA constructs. We also discuss their potential to facilitate the simultaneous assembly of complete libraries of natural product biosynthetic pathways, ushering in the next generation of combinatorial biosynthesis.     

Extending the applicability of carboxyfluorescein in solid-phase synthesis

Optimized coupling protocols are presented for the efficient and automated generation of carboxyfluorescein-labeled peptides. Side products, generated when applying earlier protocols for the in situ activation of carboxyfluorescein, were eliminated by a simple procedure, yielding highly pure fluorescent peptides and minimizing postsynthesis workup. For the cost-efficient labeling of large compound collections, coupling protocols were developed reducing the amount of coupling reagent and fluorophore. To enable further chemical derivatization of carboxyfluorescein-labeled peptides in solid-phase synthesis, the on-resin introduction of the trityl group was devised as a protecting group strategy for carboxyfluorescein. This protecting group strategy was exploited for the synthesis of peptides labeled with two different fluorescent dyes, essential tools for bioanalytical applications based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). Tritylation and optimized labeling conditions led to the development of a fluorescein-preloaded resin for the automated synthesis of fluorescein-labeled compound collections with uniform labeling yields.     

Polyene substrates with unusual methylation patterns to probe the active sites of three catalytic antibodies

The synthesis of two tetraenes that differ in their methylation pattern from the natural substrate in lanosterol biosynthesis, 2,3-oxidosqualene, and their examination with three catalytic antibodies is described. The design of these novel, linear terpenoid structures was governed by initial results obtained from the characterization of the three catalytic antibodies. These were generated by immunization with a steroidal hapten that mimics multicyclization without the necessity for anti-Markovnikov additions or ring expansions. Such a reaction cascade would represent a more 'primitive' version compared to the oxidosqualene cyclization observed in lanosterol, cycloartenol and beta-amyrin biosynthesis and would not require a tail-to-tail connection of the third and fourth isoprene unit as seen in squalene. The first tetraene design (A) only contains trisubstituted double bonds and hence its synthesis starts from farnesol and tris-norgeraniol. The second tetraene design (B) is considered the more precise match to the inducing hapten that generated the antibody collections by exhibiting one disubstituted double bond and its synthesis utilizes a tris-norgeraniol derivative and a symmetrical bis-allylic alcohol as key building blocks. Chromatographic comparison studies lead to the conclusion that the currently studied antibodies also produce monocyclic products from the two substrates as has been formerly observed with a squalene-derived substrate. In contrast, 2,3-oxidosqualene is not accepted by these catalysts supporting the notion that the current substrates are fully bound by recognition of both terminal functional groups.     

A facile synthesis of the GalNAcbeta1-->4Gal target sequence of respiratory pathogens

The carbohydrate sequence, GalNAcβ1→4Gal, is the target for the adhesion of several respiratory pathogens. The sequence was prepared in an optimized synthesis in forms that allow conjugation to scaffolds or surfaces.     

Optimising inhibitors of trypanothione reductase using solid-phase chemistry

A series of inhibitors of the enzyme trypanothione reductase has been identified using directed solid-phase chemistry. The compounds were based on a series of polyamine scaffolds and used the natural product kukoamine A as the lead structure. A compound with a Ki of 76 nM was identified, although somewhat surprisingly the compound appeared to be noncompetitive in nature.