Enhanced Methane Production from Anaerobic Digestion of Disintegrated and Deproteinized Excess Sludge

To improve biogas yield and methane content in anaerobic digestion of excess sludge from the wastewater treatment plant, the sludge was disintegrated by using various methods (sonication, alkaline and thermal treatments). Since disintegrated sludge contains a high concentration of soluble proteins, the resulting metabolite, ammonia, may inhibit methane generation. Therefore, the effects of protein removal from disintegrated sludge on methane production were also studied. As a result, an obvious enhancement of biogas generation was observed by digesting disintegrated sludge (biogas yield increased from 15 to 36 ml/g COD_added·day for the raw excess sludge and the sonicated sludge, respectively). The quality of biogas was also improved by removing proteins from the disintegrated sludge. About 50% (w/w) of soluble proteins were removed from the suspension of disintegrated sludge by salting out using 35 g MgCl₂·6H₂O/l and also by isoelectric point precipitation at pH 3.3. For deproteinized sludge, methane production increased by 19%, and its yield increased from 145 ml/g COD_removed to 325 ml/g COD_removed. Therefore, the yield and quality of biogas produced from digestion of excess sludge can be enhanced by disintegrating the sludge and subsequent protein removal. Revisions requested 14 November 2005; Revisions received 13 January 2006     

Optimal production of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) in activated sludge fed by volatile fatty acids (VFAs) generated from alkaline excess sludge fermentation

To reduce the production cost of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) and disposal amount of excess sludge simultaneously, the feasibility of using fermentative volatile fatty acids (VFAs) as carbon sources to synthesize PHA by activated sludge was examined. At pH 11.0, 60 degrees C and fermentative time of 7d, the VFAs yield was 258.65 mgTOC/gVSS. To restrain cell growth during PHA production, the released phosphorus and residual ammonium in the fermentative VFAs was recovered by the formation of struvite precipitation. Acetic acid was the predominant composition of the fermentative VFAs. PHA accumulation in excess sludge occurred feeding by fermentative VFAs with aerobic dynamic feeding process. The maximum PHA content accounted for 56.5% of the dry cell. It can be concluded from this study that the VFAs generated from excess sludge fermentation were a suitable carbon source for PHA production by activated sludge.     

Anaerobic biodegradation of a petrochemical waste-water using biomass support particles

During the anaerobic biodegradation of effluent from a dimethyl terephthalate (DMT) manufacturing plant, reduction in chemical oxygen demand (COD) degradation and biogas formation was observed after the waste-water concentration exceeded 25% of added feed COD. This condition reverted back to normal after 25–30 days when the DMT waste-water concentration in the feed was brought down to a non-toxic level. However, the above effects were observed only after the concentration of DMT waste-water reached more than 75% of added feed COD when biomass support particles (BSP) were augmented to the system. In the BSP system, a biomass concentration of up to 7000 mg/l was retained and the sludge retention time increased to > 200 days compared to 2200 mg/l and 8–10 days, respectively, in the system without BSP (control). Formaldehyde in the waste-water was found to be responsible for the observed toxicity. The BSP system was found to resist formaldehyde toxicity of up to 375 mg/l as against 125 mg/l in the control system. Moreover, the BSP system recovered from the toxicity much faster (15 days) than the control (25–30 days). The advantages of the BSP system in anaerobic treatment of DMT waste-water are discussed. Correspondence to: C. Ramakrishna     

Norovirus‐binding proteins recovered from activated sludge micro‐organisms with an affinity to a noroviral capsid peptide

Aims: Transmission routes of noroviruses, leading aetiological agents of acute gastroenteritis, are rarely verified when outbreaks occur. Because the destination of norovirus particles being firmly captured by micro‐organisms could be totally different from that of those particles moving freely, micro‐organisms with natural affinity ligands such as virus‐binding proteins would affect the fate of viruses in environment, if such microbial affinity ligands exist. The aim of this study is to identify norovirus‐binding proteins (NoVBPs) that are presumably working as natural ligands for norovirus particles in water environments. Methods and Results: NoVBPs were recovered from activated sludge micro‐organisms by an affinity chromatography technique in which a capsid peptide of norovirus genogroup II (GII) was immobilized. The recovered NoVBPs bind to norovirus‐like particles (NoVLPs) of norovirus GII, and this adsorption was stronger than that to NoVLPs of norovirus genogroup I. The profile of two‐dimensional electrophoresis of NoVBPs showed that the recovered NoVBPs included at least seven spots of protein. The determination of N‐terminal amino acid sequences of these NoVBPs revealed that hydrophobic interactions could contribute to the adsorption between NoVBPs and norovirus particles. Conclusions: NoVBPs conferring a high affinity to norovirus GII were successfully isolated from activated sludge micro‐organisms. Significance and Impact of the Study: NoVBPs could be natural viral ligands and play an important role in the NoV transmission.     

Effect of sludge age on performance of an activated sludge unit treating 2,4 dichlorophenol-containing synthetic wastewater

Wastewaters containing chlorophenol compounds are difficult to treat by biological means because of toxic effects of chlorophenols on microorganisms. Synthetic wastewater containing 2,4 dichlorophenol (DCP) was biologically treated in an activated sludge unit at different sludge ages varying between 5 and 30 days while the feed COD, DCP contents and hydraulic residence time (HRT) were constant. Effects of sludge age on COD, DCP and toxicity removals were investigated. Increases in sludge age caused significant increases in biomass concentration in the aeration tank, which resulted in increases in percent COD, DCP and toxicity removals. COD removal increased from 58 to 90%, while DCP and toxicity removals increased from 15 to 100% and from 38 to 100%, respectively, when the sludge age was raised from 5 to 30 days. Resazurin method based on dehydrogenase activity was used for assessment of the feed and effluent wastewater toxicity. Sludge volume index (SVI) decreased with increasing sludge age indicating improved settling characteristics of the sludge at high sludge ages. Operation at a sludge age of 25 days resulted in more than 90% COD and nearly 100% DCP and toxicity removal with an SVI value of 108 ml g⁻¹ under the experimental conditions tested.     

A study of the structures of the YaYa and YaYc glutathione S-transferases from rat liver cytosol. Evidence that the Ya monomer is responsible for lithocholate-binding activity.

The two dimeric lithocholic acid-binding proteins previously identified as ligandin (YaYa) and glutathione S-transferase B (YaYc) were isolated from rat liver cytosol. These proteins have molecular weights of 44000 and 47000 respectively. The recovery of these two proteins from liver was not affected by the addition of the proteinase inhibitor Trasylol. No spontaneous interconversion between these two proteins was observed on storage. YaYa and YaYc proteins yielded peptides of identical molecular weight after limited digestion with Staphylococcus aureus V8 proteinase. Analytical and preparative tryptic-digest peptide 'maps' showed that all the soluble peptides obtained from YaYa protein were also recovered from YaYc protein. Approximately six extra soluble peptides, which were not recovered from YaYa protein, were obtained from the tryptic digest of YaYc protein. Subdigests of the insoluble tryptic-digest 'cores' also resulted in the recovery of identical peptides from both proteins. Evidence is presented that the Ya subunit possessed by both proteins is identical; glutathione S transferase B is a hybrid of ligandin and glutathione S-transferase AA. The Ya monomer is responsible for lithocholate binding.     

A noncleavable signal for mitochondrial import of 3-oxoacyl-CoA thiolase

Rat 3-oxoacyl-CoA thiolase, an enzyme of the fatty acid beta-oxidation cycle, is located in the mitochondrial matrix. Unlike most mitochondrial matrix proteins, the thiolase is synthesized with no transient presequence and possesses information for mitochondrial targeting and import in the mature protein of 397 amino acid residues. cDNA sequences encoding various portions of the thiolase were fused in frame to the cDNA encoding the mature portion of rat ornithine transcarbamylase (lacking its own presequence). The fusion genes were transfected into COS cells, and subcellular localization of the fusion proteins was analyzed by cell fractionation with digitonin. When the mature portion of ornithine transcarbamylase was expressed, it was recovered in the soluble fraction. On the other hand, the fusion proteins containing the NH2-terminal 392, 161, or 61 amino acid residues of the thiolase were recovered in the particulate fraction, whereas the fusion protein containing the COOH-terminal 331 residues (residues 62-392) was recovered in the soluble fraction. Enzyme immunocytochemical and immunoelectron microscopic analyses using an anti-ornithine transcarbamylase antibody showed mitochondrial localization of the fusion proteins containing the NH2-terminal portions of the thiolase. These results indicate that the NH2-terminal 61 amino acids of rat 3-oxoacyl-CoA thiolase function as a noncleavable signal for mitochondrial targeting and import of this enzyme protein. Pulse-chase experiments showed that the ornithine transcarbamylase precursor and the thiolase traveled from the cytosol to the mitochondria with half-lives of less than 5 min, whereas the three fusion proteins traveled with half-lives of 10-15 min. Interestingly, in the cells expressing the fusion proteins, the mitochondria showed abnormal shapes and were filled with immunogold-positive crystalloid structures.     

An approach to including protein quality when assessing the net contribution of livestock to human food supply

The production of protein from animal sources is often criticized because of the low efficiency of converting plant protein from feeds into protein in the animal products. However, this critique does not consider the fact that large portions of the plant-based proteins fed to animals may be human-inedible and that the quality of animal proteins is usually superior as compared with plant proteins. The aim of the present study was therefore to assess changes in protein quality in the course of the transformation of potentially human-edible plant proteins into animal products via livestock production; data from 30 Austrian dairy farms were used as a case study. A second aim was to develop an approach for combining these changes with quantitative aspects (e.g. with the human-edible feed conversion efficiency (heFCE), defined as kilogram protein in the animal product divided by kilogram potentially human-edible protein in the feeds). Protein quality of potentially human-edible inputs and outputs was assessed using the protein digestibility-corrected amino acid score and the digestible indispensable amino acid score, two methods proposed by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations to describe the nutritional value of proteins for humans. Depending on the method used, protein scores were between 1.40 and 1.87 times higher for the animal products than for the potentially human-edible plant protein input on a barn-gate level (=protein quality ratio (PQR)). Combining the PQR of 1.87 with the heFCE for the same farms resulted in heFCE×PQR of 2.15. Thus, considering both quantity and quality, the value of the proteins in the animal products for human consumption (in this case in milk and beef) is 2.15 times higher than that of proteins in the potentially human-edible plant protein inputs. The results of this study emphasize the necessity of including protein quality changes resulting from the transformation of plant proteins to animal proteins when evaluating the net contribution of livestock to the human food supply. Furthermore, these differences in protein quality might also need to be considered when choosing a functional unit for the assessment of environmental impacts of the production of different proteins.     

Calmodulin binding to the intestinal brush-border membrane: comparison to other calcium-binding proteins

The intestinal brush-border membrane contains a high concentration of calmodulin bound to a 105,000 dalton (105 kDa) protein. Binding of radioiodinated calmodulin to this protein does not require calcium but is inhibited by trifluoperazine and excess unlabelled calmodulin. Recent evidence suggests that the 105 kDa protein in conjunction with calmodulin may be involved in the regulation of calcium transport across the brush-border membrane. In this report, we evaluated the binding of the 105 kDa protein to other radioiodinated calcium-binding proteins including the vitamin D-dependent intestinal calcium-binding protein. We observed that troponin C and S100 beta protein both bound strongly to the 105 kDa protein. The binding of S100 beta was inhibited by EGTA, but was little affected by trifluoperazine and excess unlabelled S100 beta, whereas that of troponin C was inhibited by trifluoperazine and excess unlabelled troponin C, but was little affected by EGTA. Both troponin C and S100 beta bound to a large number of proteins to which calmodulin did not bind. The vitamin D-dependent calcium-binding protein (calbindin) from chick intestine and rat kidney also bound to the 105 kDa protein, albeit more weakly than troponin C, S100 beta and calmodulin. The binding of the calbindins was increased by EGTA and was little affected by trifluoperazine and excess unlabelled calbindin. Parvalbumin, rat osteocalcin, and alpha-lactalbumin showed little binding to any brush-border membrane protein. Our results indicate that the 105 kDa calmodulin-binding protein of the intestinal brush border can bind to a variety of calcium-binding proteins all of which contain homologous regions thought to be the calcium-binding sites. Only the binding of troponin C resembles the binding of calmodulin, however, in being inhibited by trifluoperazine and excess unlabelled ligand. The functional significance of these observations in terms of regulating calcium transport across the brush-border membrane remains to be established.     

Protein purification using a soluble affinity matrix: purification of estrogen receptor with estradiol-polylysine conjugate.

A new strategy for protein purification using a soluble affinity matrix is described. The method was used for purification of estrogen receptor. Cytosols from rat uteri and human fibroid uterine tissue, after fractionation by ammonium sulfate, were treated with estradiol-polylysine conjugate. The highly basic affinity complex was separated from other proteins by DEAE-Sephacel chromatography. After dissociation of the eluted complex with excess estradiol, the receptor was recovered by CM-Sephadex chromatography. A 2000-fold purification of the rat uterine estrogen receptor was obtained with an activity recovery of 35%.     

Purification and characterization of a serine protease secreted by Brevibacillus sp. KH3 for reducing waste activated sludge and biofilm formation

A novel protease secreted by Brevibacillus sp. KH3 isolated from excess sludge at 50 °C and used as a sludge-lysing strain was investigated in this study. Sludge reduction was minimized by protease inhibitors and a 40-kDa protease, which significantly contributed to this sludge-reducing activity, was purified as the target protein. The final purified protease demonstrated 92-fold higher specific activity than the initial crude extracts. The sludge-reducing efficiency deteriorated relative to decreased protease activity triggered by EDTA; thus, the purified protease was a causative agent in reducing excess sludge. The 40-kDa protease was a serine metalloprotease and showed the highest activity at 50 °C and pH 8.0, and the activity was enhanced in the presence of calcium ions, indicating that the purified protease contained calcium ion. Furthermore, this 40-kDa protease inhibited biofilm formation in excess sludge. These results imply that sludge reduction is because of reduction of biofilm formation in excess sludge.     

Interaction of the Bacillus sphaericus mosquito larvicidal proteins

Genes for 51.4- and 41.9-kDa insecticidal proteins of Bacillus sphaericus were separately cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. Both proteins were required for toxicity. Approximately equal numbers of cells containing the 51.4- and 41.9-kDa proteins produced the greatest toxicity; excess 41.9-kDa protein did not affect toxicity, whereas excess 51.4-kDa protein reduced activity. Larvae were killed when 41.9-kDa protein was fed up to 24 h after the 51.4-kDa protein, but not when the order of feeding was reversed. Radiolabelled toxins bound in approximately equal amounts to the gastric caecum and posterior midgut of Culex quinquefasciatus larvae. Radiolabelled 51.4-kDa protein was rapidly degraded by ca. 12-13 kDa in the larval gut, while 41.9-kDa protein was degraded by 1-2 kDa. Nonreduced toxin extracted from B. sphaericus produced a band on SDS-PAGE of ca. 68-74 kDa that contained both 51.4- and 41.9-kDa proteins based on sequence analysis, and a band of ca. 51 kDa that contained primarily 41.9-kDa protein. Escherichia coli containing 51.4-kDa protein enhanced toxicity of the latter eluted SDS-PAGE band. These proteins may associate very strongly, and trace amounts of 51.4-kDa protein in preparations of 41.9-kDa protein from B. sphaericus may be responsible for the previously reported toxicity of the latter.     

Proteomic analysis of the rat liver

Rat is a useful, widely used animal model for biological and toxicity studies. We analyzed total and cytosolic rat liver proteins by applying proteomics technologies. The proteins were separated by two-dimensional electrophoresis employing broad and narrow range immobilized pH gradient strips, followed by MALDI-MS analysis of the tryptic digests. Two hundred and seventy-three different gene products were identified, of which approximately 60% were enzymes with a broad spectrum of catalytic activities. Most of the identified proteins were detected in other rat protein samples as well, which were analyzed in our laboratory. Fifteen gene products were detected for the first time. These were represented by one spot each, whereas most of the frequently detected proteins were represented by multiple spots. In average, approximately five to 10 spots corresponded to one gene product. The database includes a large number of proteins known to be involved in toxicology-relevant pathways and may be useful in toxicity prediction studies.     

Construction of a cloning system for the mass production of a virus-binding protein specific for poliovirus type 1

In our previous study, virus-binding proteins (VBPs) demonstrating the ability to strongly bind poliovirus type 1 (PV1) were recovered from a bacterial culture derived from activated sludge. The isolated VBPs would be useful as viral adsorbents for water and wastewater treatments. The VBP gene of activated sludge bacteria was isolated, and the cloning system of the VBP was established. The isolation of the VBP gene from DNA libraries for activated sludge bacteria was achieved with the colony hybridization technique. The sequence of the VBP gene consisted of 807 nucleotides encoding 268 amino acids. Fifteen amino acid sequences were retrieved from 2,137,877 sequences by a homology search using the BLAST server at the National Center for Biotechnology Information. The protein encoded in the isolated genome was considered to be a newly discovered protein from activated sludge culture, because any sequences in protein databases were not perfectly matched with the sequence of the VBP. It was confirmed that Escherichia coli BL21 transformed by pRSET carrying the isolated VBP gene could extensively produce the VBP clones. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) revealed that the VBP clone exhibited the binding ability with intact particles of PV1. The equilibrium binding constant between PV1 and VBP in the ELISA well was estimated to be 2.1 x 10(7) (M(-1)), which also indicated that the VBP clones have a high affinity with the PV1 particle. The VBP cloning system developed in this study would make it possible to produce a mass volume of VBPs and to utilize them as a new material of the specific adsorbent in several technologies, including virus removal, concentration, and detection.     

Algal single cell protein from wastewater treatment and renovation process

A Source of high-quality protein for animal feed, based upon algae recovered in the process of upgrading waste oxidation pond effluents and promising to be particularly economical, is being developed at the Technion. Unlike other types of single cell protein(SCP), the algal protein does not have to return the full production cost but only that of concentration and final processing. The balance is shared by the value of waste disposal and the reclaimed water. Whereas such systems as activated sludge require considerable mechanical energy to supply the oxygen needed for aerobically degrading organics in wastewater, oxidation ponds utilize solar energy for that purpose. The sludge obtained when their effluents are clarified consists largely of algae, bacteria, fungi, and zooplankton in relative proportions varying with operating conditions, and contains 40–60%(dry basis) high-quality protein. The high rate oxidation pond (a particularly intensive type of pond) produces on the average 34 g/m²7sol;day solids, or over 100 tons/ha (hectare) annually. Two clarification routes have been found promising: centrifugation and alum flocculation followed by frothflotation. The latter route is less expensive in terms of both fixed and operating cost, and gives clarified effluent of higher quality, which can be seasonally stored with minimal eutrophication because the aluminum removes most of the phosphate from the effluent. A good product has been obtained by drum-drying the concentrate, and preliminary feeding tests have indicated that it can replace at least 1/4 of the soymeal in broiler rations and 2/3 of the fishmeal in carp feed. No ill effect of the aluminum in the product recovered by alum flocculation has been found so far a process for removing and recycling the aluminum has been developed nonetheless, in case ill effects do show up in further tests. The combined value of the benefits derived from a system centered around the high-rate oxidation pond with clarification by flocculation–flotation, in terms of waste treatment by alternative means, potable water saved, and soymeal replaced, significantly exceeds estimated cost.     

Virus-binding proteins recovered from bacterial culture derived from activated sludge by affinity chromatography assay using a viral capsid peptide

The contamination of water environments by pathogenic viruses has raised concerns about outbreaks of viral infectious diseases in our society. Because conventional water and wastewater treatment systems are not effective enough to inactivate or remove pathogenic viruses, a new technology for virus removal needs to be developed. In this study, the virus-binding proteins (VBPs) in a bacterial culture derived from activated sludge were successfully recovered. The recovery of VBPs was achieved by applying extracted crude proteins from a bacterial culture to an affinity column in which a custom-made peptide of capsid protein from the poliovirus type 1 (PV1) Mahoney strain (H(2)N-DNPASTTNKDKL-COOH) was immobilized as a ligand. VBPs exhibited the ability to adsorb infectious particles of PV1 Sabin 1 as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The evaluation of surface charges of VBPs with ion-exchange chromatography found that a majority of VBP molecules had a net negative charge under the conditions of affinity chromatography. On the other hand, a calculated isoelectric point implied that the viral peptide in the affinity column was also charged negatively. As a result, the adsorption of the VBPs to the viral peptide in the affinity column occurred with a strong attractive force that was able to overcome the electrostatic repulsive force. Two-dimensional electrophoresis revealed that the isolated VBPs include a number of proteins, and their molecular masses were widely distributed but smaller than 100 kDa. Amino acid sequences of N termini of five VBPs were determined. Homology searches for the N termini against all protein sequences in the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) database showed that the isolated VBPs in this study were newly discovered proteins. These VBPs that originated with bacteria in activated sludge might be stable, because they are existing in the environment of wastewater treatments. Therefore, a virus removal technology utilizing VBPs as viral adsorbents can be developed, since it is possible to replicate VBPs by protein cloning techniques.     

Comparison of protein fermentation characteristics in rumen fluid determined with the gas production technique and the nylon bag technique

In this study, a modified version of the gas production technique was used to determine protein fermentation characteristics in rumen fluid of 19 feedstuffs. Performing the incubations in a N-free environment, and with an excess of rapidly fermentable carbohydrates, made N the limiting factor to microbial growth, and so gas production profiles reflected the availability of N from the feed samples. Results showed that fermentation of protein in rumen fluid can be determined with this modified gas production technique, and that there were distinct differences in protein fermentation between the feed samples. Availability of protein for fermentation was highest in wheat, potato pieces and lupin, and lowest in Rumiraap, a formaldehyde treated rapeseed meal, palm kernel expeller and brewery grains. The protein degradation characteristics of the 19 feed ingredients were also determined with the in situ nylon bag technique. With the obtained results, the amount of rumen escape protein (REP) was calculated for each feedstuff. The results showed that the rate of degradation ranged from 0.010/h for Rumiraap to 0.151/h for wheat. The amount of REP ranged from 197 g/kg CP for lupin to 840 g/kg CP for Rumiraap. Comparing the gas production results with the results obtained with the nylon bag technique showed that there was a good relationship between the gas production after 12–25 h of incubation and the calculated amount of REP (r² = 0.83–0.85). The results show that the adapted gas production technique, being depleted of N and using an excess of rapidly fermentable carbohydrates, is suitable to recognize differences in N availability between feed samples and can be used as an alternative to the nylon bag technique and other in vitro techniques.     

Isolation and partial characterization of the low-molecular-mass zinc/cadmium-binding protein from the testes of the patas monkey (Erythrocebus patas). Distinction from metallothionein.

The mammalian testes are generally quite susceptible to cadmium. A deficiency of metallothionein (MT), a metal-binding protein linked to Cd tolerance, has been observed in rat testes and may explain the sensitivity in rats. Little is known about the metal-binding proteins in primate testes. Thus this study examined the nature of these proteins in a non-human primate species, the patas monkey (Erythrocebus patas). In all cases proteins isolated from testes were compared with authentic MT isolated from the liver of a zinc-treated monkey. A low-molecular-mass Zn/Cd-binding protein was seen in testicular and hepatic cytosol after gel filtration. Neither protein had substantial amounts of associated copper. These proteins could be partially purified from both sources by heat treatment and acetone precipitation. When such extracts were further separated by reverse-phase h.p.l.c., four hepatic forms were isolated, all of which proved to be authentic MT by amino acid analysis. However, only two testicular forms were separated by h.p.l.c., both of which had amino acid compositions quite unlike that of MT, having a much lower cysteine content and amino acids which are absent from MT (leucine and phenylalanine). The testicular protein appeared to be uninducible by Zn treatment. These results suggest that the low-molecular-mass Cd/Zn-binding proteins in the patas testes are not MTs and further support the hypothesis that a MT deficiency may be an important determinate of the marked testicular sensitivity to Cd toxicity.     

Conversion and toxicity characteristics of formaldehyde in acetoclastic methanogenic sludge

An unadapted mixed methanogenic sludge transformed formaldehyde into methanol and formate. The methanol to formate ratio obtained was 1:1. Formaldehyde conversion proceeded without any lag phase, suggesting the constitutive character of the formaldehyde conversion enzymes involved. Because the rate of formaldehyde conversion declined at increased formaldehyde additions, we hypothesized that some enzymes and/or cofactors might become denatured as a result of the excess of formaldehyde. Furthermore, formaldehyde was found to be toxic to acetoclastic methanogenesis in a dual character. Formaldehyde toxicity was partly reversible because once the formaldehyde concentration was extremely low or virtually removed from the system, the methane production rate was partially recovered. Because the degree of this recovery was not complete, we conclude that formaldehyde toxicity was partly irreversible as well. The irreversible toxicity likely can be attributed to biomass formaldehyde-related decay. Independent of the mode of formaldehyde addition (i.e., slug or continuous), the irreversible toxicity was dependent on the total amount of formaldehyde added to the system. This finding suggests that to treat formaldehyde-containing waste streams, a balance between formaldehyde-related decay and biomass growth should be attained.