Sterility and Hypermutability in the P-M System of Hybrid Dysgenesis in DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER

Inbred wild strains of Drosophila melanogaster derived from the central and eastern United States were used to make dysgenic hybrids in the P-M system. These strains possessed P elements and the P cytotype, the condition that represses P element transposition. Their hybrids were studied for the mutability of the P element insertion mutation, snw, and for the incidence of gonadal dysgenesis (GD) sterility. All the strains tested were able to induce hybrid dysgenesis by one or both of these assays; however, high levels of dysgenesis were rare. Sets of X chromosomes and autosomes from the inbred wild strains were more effective at inducing GD sterility than were sets of Y chromosomes and autosomes. In two separate analyses, GD sterility was positively correlated with snw mutability, suggesting a linear relationship. However, one strain appeared to induce too much GD sterility for its level of snw destabilization, indicating an uncoupling of these two manifestations of hybrid dysgenesis.     

A high level of hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila: High thermosensitivity, dependence on DNA repair, and incomplete cytotype regulation

Summary An unusually high level of P-M hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster is characteristic of hybrid offspring originating from both, A (M × ) and B (P × M) crosses of a subline of the Harwich P strain, termed H ^s . The novel properties induced by mobility of P elements carried by H ^s paternal chromosomes include: very high (over 95%) gonadal dysgenesis (GD) in both sexes at the low restrictive temperature of 21°C, and highly premature sterility when males are reared at 18°C and aged at 21°C. Although all three major chromosomes of the H ^s subline contributed to this atypical pattern of gonadal dysgenesis, chromosome 3 had the largest effect. Gonadal dysgenesis showed a temperature- and sex-dependent repression pattern by the defective P elements of Muller-5 Birmingham chromosomes; at 21°C there was virtually no repression of male sterility, but most effective repression of GD in females. At 29°C repression was effective in males, but declined in females. The high thermosensitive sterility, low fecundity, and premature aging of the male germ line were greatly exacerbated when males derived from either A or B crosses were deficient either in excision repair (mei-9 mutation) or in post-replication repair (mei-41 mutation). These findings demonstrate that both DNA repair pathways are essential for the repair of lesions induced by P element transposition and support the hypothesis that P element-induced chromosome breaks are responsible for the virtual abolition of the germ line. The relatively high premature sterility of cross B DNA repair-deficient males, reared at 18°C and aged at 21°C, indicates that there is incomplete cytotype regulation in H ^s subline hybrids.     

Chromosomal Effects on Mutability in the P-M System of Hybrid Dysgenesis in DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER

Two manifestations of hybrid dysgenesis were studied in flies with chromosomes derived from two different P strains. In one set of experiments, the occurrence of recessive X-linked lethal mutations in the germ cells of dysgenic males was monitored. In the other, the behavior of an X-linked P-element insertion mutation, snw, was studied in dysgenic males and also in dysgenic females. The chromosomes of one P strain were more proficient at causing dysgenesis in both sets of experiments. However, there was variation among the chromosomes of each strain in regard to the ability to induce lethals or to destabilize snw. The X chromosome, especially when it came from the stronger P strain, had a pronounced effect on both measures of dysgenesis, but in combination with the major autosomes, these effects were reduced. For the stronger P strain, the autosomes by themselves contributed significantly to the production of X-linked lethals and also had large effects on the behavior of snw, but they did not act additively on these two characters. For this strain, the effects of the autosomes on the X-linked lethal mutation rate suggest that only 1/100 P element transpositions causes a recessive lethal mutation. For the weaker P strain, the autosomes had only slight effects on the behavior of snw and appeared to have negligible effects on the X-linked lethal mutation rate. Combinations of chromosomes from either the strong or the weak P strain affected both aspects of dysgenesis in a nonadditive fashion, suggesting that the P elements on these chromosomes competed with each other for transposase, the P-encoded function that triggers P element activity. Age and sex also influenced the ability of chromosomes and combinations of chromosomes to cause dysgenesis.     

Repression of P Element-Mediated Hybrid Dysgenesis in Drosophila Melanogaster

Inbred lines derived from a strain called Sexi were analyzed for their abilities to repress P element-mediated gonadal dysgenesis. One line had high repression ability, four had intermediate ability and two had very low ability. The four intermediate lines also exhibited considerable within-line variation for this trait; furthermore, in at least two cases, this variation could not be attributed to recurring P element movement. Repression of gonadal dysgenesis in the hybrid offspring of all seven lines was due primarily to a maternal effect; there was no evidence for repression arising de novo in the hybrids themselves. In one of the lines, repression ability was inherited maternally, indicating the involvement of cytoplasmic factors. In three other lines, repression ability appeared to be determined by partially dominant or additive chromosomal factors; however, there was also evidence for a maternal effect that reduced the expression of these factors in at least two of the lines. In another line, repression ability seemed to be due to recessive chromosomal factors. All seven lines possessed numerous copies of a particular P element, called KP, which has been hypothesized to produce a polypeptide repressor of gonadal dysgenesis. This hypothesis, however, does not explain why the inbred Sexi lines varied so much in their repression abilities. It is suggested that some of this variation may be due to differences in the chromosomal position of the KP elements, or that other nonautonomous P elements are involved in the repression of hybrid dysgenesis in these lines.     

The synergistic effect of X-rays and deficiencies in DNA repair in P-M hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.

X-rays and deficiencies in DNA repair had a synergistic effect on genetic damage associated with P-element mobility in Drosophila melanogaster. These interactions, using sterility and fecundity as endpoints, were tested in dysgenic males deficient in either excision or post-replication DNA repair. Three sublines of the Harwich P strain were used for the construction of hybrid males. These sublines differ in P-induction ability based on gonadal dysgenesis sterility (GD) and snw mutability tests, in P-element insertion site pattern, and in the types of defective P-elements, such as KP elements, they possess. A lower degree of gonadal dysgenesis was correlated with the presence of KP elements. GD sterility and snw mutability were not always correlated. Dysgenic hybrids originating from the standard reference subline, Harwich(white), were much more sensitive to the post-replication repair than the excision repair defect. In contrast, sterility of hybrids derived from the weak subline was least affected by, and that of hybrids of the strongest subline was most affected by either DNA repair deficiency. The exacerbation by X-rays of the effects of DNA repair deficiencies on genetic damage indicates that both repair mechanisms are required for processing DNA lesions induced by the combined effect of P activity and ionizing radiation.     

Cytotype Regulation of P Transposable Elements in Drosophila melanogaster: Repressor Polypeptides or piRNAs?

The telomeric P elements TP5 and TP6 are associated with the P cytotype, a maternally inherited condition that represses P-element-induced hybrid dysgenesis in the Drosophila germ line. To see if cytotype repression by TP5 and TP6 might be mediated by the polypeptides they could encode, hobo transgenes carrying these elements were tested for expression of mRNA in the female germ line and for repression of hybrid dysgenesis. The TP5 and TP6 transgenes expressed more germ-line mRNA than the native telomeric P elements, but they were decidedly inferior to the native elements in their ability to repress hybrid dysgenesis. These paradoxical results are inconsistent with the repressor polypeptide model of cytotype. An alternative model based on the destruction of P transposase mRNA by Piwi-interacting (pi) RNAs was supported by finding reduced P mRNA levels in flies that carried the native telomeric P elements, which are inserted in a known major piRNA locus.     

Quantitative Effects of P Elements on Hybrid Dysgenesis in Drosophila Melanogaster

Genetic analyses involving chromosomes from seven inbred lines derived from a single M' strain were used to study the quantitative relationships between the incidence and severity of P-M hybrid dysgenesis and the number of genomic P elements. In four separate analyses, the mutability of snw, a P element-insertion mutation of the X-linked singed locus, was found to be inversely related to the number of autosomal P elements. Since snw mutability is caused by the action of the P transposase, this finding supports the hypothesis that genomic P elements titrate the transposase present within a cell. Other analyses demonstrated that autosomal transmission ratios were distorted by P element action. In these analyses, the amount of distortion against an autosome increased more or less linearly with the number of P elements carried by the autosome. Additional analyses showed that the magnitude of this distortion was reduced when a second P element-containing autosome was present in the genome. This reduction could adequately be explained by transposase titration; there was no evidence that it was due to repressor molecules binding to P elements and inhibiting their movement. The influence of genomic P elements on the incidence of gonadal dysgenesis was also investigated. Although no simple relationship between the number of P elements and the incidence of the trait could be discerned, it was clear that even a small number of elements could increase the incidence markedly. The failure to find a quantitative relationship between P element number and the incidence of gonadal dysgenesis probably reflects the complex etiology of this trait.     

Somatic Effects of P Element Activity in Drosophila melanogaster: Pupal Lethality

Nonautonomous P elements normally excise and transpose only when a source of transposase is supplied, and only in the germline. The germline specificity depends on one of the introns of the transposase gene which is not spliced in somatic cells. To study the effects of somatic P activity, a modified P element (delta 2-3) lacking this intron was used as a source of transposase. Nonautonomous P elements from a strain called Birmingham, when mobilized in somatic cells by delta 2-3, were found to cause lethality, although neither component was lethal by itself. The three major Birmingham chromosomes acted approximately independently in producing the lethal effect. This lethality showed a strong dependence on temperature. Although temperature sensitivity was limited to larval stages, the actual deaths occurred at the pupal stage. Survivors, which could be recovered by decreasing the temperature or by reducing the proportion of the Birmingham genome present, often showed multiple developmental anomalies and reduced longevity reminiscent of the effects of cell death from radiation damage. Although the genetic damage occurred in dividing imaginal disc cells, the phenotypic manifestations--death and abnormalities--are not observed until later. The survivors also showed gonadal dysgenic (GD) sterility, a well-known characteristic of P-M hybrid dysgenesis. To explain these findings, we suggest that pupal lethality and GD sterility are both caused by massive chromosome breakage in larval cells, resulting from excision and transposition of genomic P elements acting as substrate for the transposase.     

Genetic and molecular analysis of repression in the P-M system of hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.

Twelve inbred lines derived from an M' strain of Drosophila melanogaster were used to study the repression of P-element-mediated hybrid dysgenesis. Initial assessments indicated that the lines differed in the ability to repress gonadal dysgenesis, and that this ability was highly correlated with the ability to repress snw hypermutability. Later assessments indicated that most of the lines with low or intermediate repression potential evolved to a state of higher repression potential; however, Southern analyses failed to reveal significant changes in the array of genomic P elements that could account for this evolution. In addition, none of the lines possessed the incomplete P element known as KP, which has been proposed to explain repression in some D. melanogaster strains. One of the lines maintained intermediate repression potential throughout the period of study (52 generations), indicating that the intermediate condition was not intrinsically unstable. Genetic analyses demonstrated that in some of the lines, repression potential was influenced by factors that were inherited maternally through at least two generations; however, these factors were not as influential as those in a classic P cytotype strain. Additional tests with a dysgenesis-inducing X chromosome called T-5 indicated that repression itself was mediated by a combination of maternal effects and paternally inherited factors that were expressed after fertilization. These tests also suggested that in some circumstances, the P transposase, or its message, might be transmitted through the maternal cytoplasm.     

Mobilization of hobo elements residing within the decapentaplegic gene complex: suggestion of a new hybrid dysgenesis system in Drosophila melanogaster

We present results demonstrating that the hobo family of transposable elements can promote high rates of chromosomal instability. Using strains with a hobo element inserted within the decapentaplegic gene complex (DPP-C), we have recovered numerous DPP-C mutations involving chromosomal rearrangements and deletions with one endpoint in the vicinity of the pre-existing hobo element. This hypermutability occurred in the germ lines of hybrid progeny from crosses involving strains containing hobo elements to strains lacking them. In some crosses, the offspring had rudimentary gonads, reminiscent of GD sterility. The germline hypermutability and infertility are similar to those produced by P-element-mediated hybrid dysgenesis. Given the many genetic and molecular similarities of the P and hobo systems, we propose that a system analogous to P-M hybrid dysgenesis has been activated in the hobo+ X hobo- crosses.     

DYNAMICS OF P-M HYBRID DYSGENESIS IN P-TRANSFORMED LINES OF DROSOPHILA SIMULANS

An autonomous P element from Drosophila melanogaster was introduced by microinjection into the germ line of its sibling species, Drosophila simulans. The invasion kinetics of P elements was studied in seven independent lines over 60 generations, using gel blotting, in situ hybridization, and dysgenic crosses. Some of the main phenotypic and molecular characteristics of P-M hybrid dysgenesis were observed, i.e., gonadal dysgenesis (GD sterility), chromosome rearrangements, and the occurrence of degenerate P elements. At least four lines reached a steady state with complete or nearly complete P-element regulation but with a moderate number of P elements (10–24 per haploid genome) and P activity (10–35% GD sterility). This failure to obtain strong P strains in D. simulans could be due to experimental conditions, a host-dependent component of P transposition, or more severe selection against the deleterious effects of this transposon.     

Amplification of Kp Elements Associated with the Repression of Hybrid Dysgenesis in Drosophila Melanogaster

Mobile P elements in Drosophila melanogaster cause hybrid dysgenesis if their mobility is not repressed. One type of repression, termed P cytotype, is a complex interaction between chromosomes carrying P elements and cytoplasm and is transmitted through the cytoplasm only of females. Another type of repression is found in worldwide M' strains that contain approximately 30 copies per individual of one particular P element deletion-derivative termed the KP element. This repression is transmitted equally through both sexes. In the present study we show that biparentally transmitted repression increases in magnitude together with a rapid increase in KP copy-number in genotypes starting with one or a few KP elements and no other deletion-derivatives. Such correlated increases in repression and KP number per genome occur only in the presence of complete P elements, supporting the interpretation that they are probably a consequence of the selective advantage enjoyed by flies carrying the highest numbers of KP elements. Analysis of Q strains also reveals the presence of qualitative differences in the way the repression of dysgenesis is transmitted. In general, Q strains not containing KP elements have the P cytotype mode of repression, whereas Q strains with KP elements transmit repression through both sexes. This difference among Q strains further supports the existence of at least two types of repression of P-induced hybrid dysgenesis in natural populations of D. melanogaster.     

Evolution of Hybrid Dysgenesis Potential following P Element Contamination in Drosophila Melanogaster

P elements were introduced into M strain genomes by chromosomal contamination (transposition) from P strain chromosomes under conditions of P-M hybrid dysgenesis. A number of independently maintained contaminated lines were subsequently monitored for their ability to induce gonadal (GD) sterility in the progeny of reference crosses, over a period of 60 generations, in two experiments. The efficiency of chromosomal contamination was high; all tested lines acquired P elements following the association of M and P chromosomes in the same genome for a single generation. All the contaminated lines also sustained an initial unstable phase, marked by high frequencies of transposition and sterility within lines, in the absence of P element regulation. Subsequently, each of the lines rapidly evolved to one of three relatively stable strain types whose phenotypic and molecular properties correspond rather closely to those of the P, Q and M' strains that have previously been characterized. The numbers and structures of P elements and the presence or absence of P element regulation during the early generations appeared to be critical factors determining the subsequent course of evolution. On the basis of GD sterility frequencies, both the mean level of P activity, and the average capacity for P element regulation, were reduced in lines raised at 25 degrees, relative to those raised at 20 degrees, during the early generations. This latter result is consistent with the expectation that natural selection will tend to modify the manifestation of dysgenic traits, such as high temperature sterility, which cause a reduction of fitness. However, overall, stochastic factors appeared to predominate in determining the course of evolution of individual lines.     

Hybrid Dysgenesis in DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER: Nature and Inheritance of P Element Regulation

The genetic determination of the control of resistance or susceptibility to germ line changes mediated by P elements was studied in two strains and in derivatives of crosses between them. One strain, characterized as true M, completely lacked P elements. The second strain, pseudo-M (M'), carried a number of P elements, but these did not have the potential to induce the gonadal sterility that is associated with P-M hybrid dysgenesis. Individuals from the true M strain were invariably unable to suppress P factor activity (i.e., all daughters of outcrosses of M females and P males were sterile). In contrast, individuals from the M' strain showed variable degrees of suppression that were manifested in a wide range of gonadal sterility frequencies in standard tests. This continuous distribution pattern was reproducible for more than 25 generations.--The results of the genetic analysis indicate that a strain with a variable degree of suppression of gonadal dysgenesis is not necessarily in a transient state between the extreme conditions of P and M cytotype. A large variance in the ability to suppress gonadal dysgenesis with a mean value intermediate between the extremes of P and M cytotype may be a relatively stable strain characteristic. No reciprocal cross effect was observed in the suppression of sterility of F1 females from M X M' matings. Thus, the existence of M' strains indicates a Mendelian component in P element regulation and suggests that cytotype, which has an extrachromosomal aspect, may be only one of perhaps several mechanisms involved in regulation. Analysis of the effects of individual chromosomes from the M' strain showed that each chromosome contributed to the reduction of gonadal dysgenesis in the progeny of test matings. The results are consistent with a one-component titration model for P element regulation.     

Adaptation to P element transposon invasion in Drosophila melanogaster

Transposons evolve rapidly and can mobilize and trigger genetic instability. Piwi-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) silence these genome pathogens, but it is unclear how the piRNA pathway adapts to invasion of new transposons. In Drosophila, piRNAs are encoded by heterochromatic clusters and maternally deposited in the embryo. Paternally inherited P element transposons thus escape silencing and trigger a hybrid sterility syndrome termed P-M hybrid dysgenesis. We show that P-M hybrid dysgenesis activates both P elements and resident transposons and disrupts the piRNA biogenesis machinery. As dysgenic hybrids age, however, fertility is restored, P elements are silenced, and P element piRNAs are produced de novo. In addition, the piRNA biogenesis machinery assembles, and resident elements are silenced. Significantly, resident transposons insert into piRNA clusters, and these new insertions are transmitted to progeny, produce novel piRNAs, and are associated with reduced transposition. P element invasion thus triggers heritable changes in genome structure that appear to enhance transposon silencing.     

Hybrid Dysgenesis in Drosophila Simulans Lines Transformed with Autonomous P Elements

The molecular and phenotypic analysis of several previously described P element-transformed lines of Drosophila simulans was extended in order to determine whether they had the potential to produce a syndrome of P-M hybrid dysgenesis analogous to the one in Drosophila melanogaster. The transformed line with the highest number of P elements at the beginning of the analysis, DsP pi-5C, developed strong P activity potential and P element regulation, properties characteristic of D. melanogaster P strains. The subsequent analysis of sublines derived from 34 single pair matings of DsP pi-5C revealed that they were heterogeneous with respect to both their P element complements and P activity potentials, but similar with respect to their regulatory capabilities. The subline with the highest P activity, DsP pi-5C-27, was subsequently used as a reference P strain in the genetic analysis of the D. simulans transformants. In these experiments, the reciprocal cross effect was observed with respect to both gonadal sterility and male recombination. As in D. melanogaster, the induction of gonadal sterility in D. simulans was shown to be temperature-dependent. Molecular analysis of DsP pi-5C-27 revealed that it has approximately 30 P elements per genome, at least some of which are defective. The number of potentially complete P elements in its genome is similar to the number in the D. melanogaster P strain, Harwich-77. Overall our analysis indicates that P-transformed lines of D. simulans are capable of expressing the major features of P-M hybrid dysgenesis previously demonstrated in D. melanogaster and that P elements appear to behave in a similar way in the two sibling species.     

P-Element repression in Drosophila melanogaster by a naturally occurring defective telomeric P copy

In Drosophila melanogaster, hybrid dysgenesis occurs in progeny from crosses between females lacking P elements and males carrying P elements scattered throughout the genome. We have genetically isolated a naturally occurring P insertion at cytological location 1A, from a Tunisian population. The Nasr'Allah-P(1A) element [NA-P(1A)] has a deletion of the first 871 bp including the P promoter. It is flanked at the 3' end by telomeric associated sequences and at the 5' end by a HeT-A element sequence. The NA-P(1A) element strongly represses dysgenic sterility and P transposition. However, when testing P-promoter repression, NA-P(1A) was unable to repress a germinally expressed P-lacZ construct bearing no 5'-homology with it. Conversely, a second P-lacZ construct, in which the fusion with lacZ takes place in exon 3 of P, was successfully repressed by NA-P(1A). This suggests that NA-P(1A) repression involves a homology-dependent component.     

Rapid spread of transposable p elements in experimental populations of Drosophila melanogaster

The invasion of P elements in natural populations of Drosophila melanogaster was modeled by establishing laboratory populations with 1%, 5% and 10% P genomes and monitoring the populations for 20 generations. In one experiment, the ability of flies to either induce or suppress gonadal sterility in different generations was correlated with the amount of P element DNA. In a second experiment, the percentage of genomes that contained P elements, and the distribution of P elements among individual flies was monitored. The ability to induce gonadal dysgenesis increased rapidly each generation. However, the increase in P cytotype lagged behind by five to ten generations. The total amount of P element DNA and the frequency of flies containing P elements increased each generation. The number of P elements within individual genomes decreased initially, but then increased. Finally, the distribution of P elements within the genomes of individuals from later generations varied considerably, and this pattern differed from the parental P strain. These results suggest that the interaction between the assortment and recombination of chromosomal segments, and multiplicative transposition could result in the rapid spread of P elements in natural populations.     

Evolutionary flux of P element regulation in a Drosophila melanogaster hybrid dysgenesis cline.

Clines of P-induced hybrid dysgenesis provide a means for monitoring the evolution of transposition repression over space and time. We have studied the molecular and phenotypic profiles of flies taken from a 2900 km cline along the eastern coast of Australia, which had previously been characterized over 10 years ago as having P populations in the north, Q populations at central sites and M' populations in the south. We have found that Q and M' populations of flies have increased their range within the cline at the expense of P lines. Q populations were found to be in the north of the cline and M' populations in the south. Some of the northern Q lines transmit repression through both sexes and type I deletion elements have been isolated from them. We suggest that these elements are responsible for Q type repression. The results support our model that populations made up of Q individuals with strong biparentally transmitted repression form an evolutionarily stable strategy for the repression of hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.